Walmart-Case-Study-LATEST-1 Revised
Walmart-Case-Study-LATEST-1 Revised
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
By
Belleza, Ed Mark
Cordero, Angelika May
Gaila, Jackilyn
Gregorio, Diane
Lumugdang, Chzebelle Deniel
3BSA3
July 2021
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PAGE
TITLE PAGE
TABLE OF CONTENTS i
Chapter
1 INTRODUCTION
Background of the Study 1
Review of Related Literature and Studies 3
Theoretical Framework 12
Conceptual Framework 14
Statement of the Problem 16
Significance of the Study 18
Scope and Limitations 17
Definition of Terms 19
2 METHODOLOGY
Research Design 20
Population and Sampling 20
Source of Data 21
Data Analysis 22
QUESTIONNAIRE 24
REFERENCES 35
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
successfully passed the CPA board exam based on the official releases of the PRC,
ranges from a low of 14% to a high of 42% for the May and October year 2014 to
2019.
In New Era University, the CPALE passing rate has not been consistent
through the years – with results surpassing the national passing rate down to
something falling below it. Based on the results of the May and October year 2014-
2019 CPA licensure exam, the average passing rate of the New Era University is
38.09% for the first-time takers. This invariably attests to the unusual level of
performance of accounting graduates who will take the CPA board examination in
the future. With this, it is a central idea to determine the factors that contribute to
the future.
1
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
internal and external factors. Specifically, in the CPA board exam, factors such as
exam structure were discussed. The current research, on the other hand, targets to
add other factors to be studied, such as peer influence and taking multiple formal
reviews apart from the aforementioned factors: study habits, undergraduate studies
performance, school, and home, for these factors, was found out by the researchers
matter of course a research-based study must be done in order to assert that the
2
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
Inventory Management
stores and ecommerce sellers satisfy customers, reduce costs, and increase profits.
Retail inventory management is the process of ensuring you carry merchandise that
shoppers want, with neither too little nor too much on hand. By managing inventory,
retailers meet customer demand without running out of stock or carrying excess
supply. In practice, effective retail inventory management results in lower costs and a
methods give retailers more information with which to run their businesses,
including: product locations, quantities of each product type, which stock sells well
and which does not, by location and sales channel, profit margin by style, model,
product line or item, Ideal amount of inventory to have in back stock and storage,
how many products to reorder and how often, when to discontinue a product, how
Inventory management is vital for retailers because the practice helps them
increase profits. They are more likely to have enough inventory to capture every
possible sale while avoiding overstock and minimizing expenses. From a strategic
Costs, when you know how much stock you have and how much you need, you can
pinpoint inventory levels more accurately, thereby reducing storage and carrying
costs for excess merchandise. Other savings include shipping, logistics, depreciation,
and the opportunity cost that comes from not having an alternative product that might
sales, retailers want to avoid running out of inventory. Retailers can use inventory
management tools to determine how much stock is “just right” to have on hand,
neither too much nor too little. Improves Profit Margins, with lower inventory costs
and enough supply to fill every order, retailers improve profitability. Prevents
costly inefficiency that happens when products expire or become obsolete. Reduces
Satisfaction, when customers get the products, they want faster with fewer mistakes
assets of many organizations. Too much and too low inventories bring down the level
merchandising organization, the goal should always be the same, that is, to ensure the
inventory is ready and at the same time inventory is at a low level (Kungu, 2019).
Stock and Lambert (2011) assert that inventory serves five purposes in the
firm. Thus, inventory provides protection from uncertainties in demand and order
cycle, enables the firm to achieve economies of scale, balances supply and demand,
still needs intentions so the conventional and simple methods of managing the
inventories are lacking in best systems, which is also lagging them in sharing of
theory; an empirical evaluation of the same is not done so far in the context of SMEs,
business for many business owners. In a retail store, merchandise stocks contribute to
profits only when they are sold, and money is received at the cash register. These
are unable to tolerate the types of losses that result from inadequate inventory
management. Inventories are unreliable, inefficient, and costly unless they are
controlled.
The relevance of these literatures to this study is that they suggest that though
and disadvantages.
5
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
In one study its findings showed the challenges facing the manual system of
inventory management system are as follows; the manual system requires everyday
counting of items in the inventory, human errors are very prevalent during counting
and recording and in case of disaster like fire or flood or poor communication, all the
manual inventory records will be damaged and irretrievable. Based on the findings
this paper highlights the possible solutions to the above problems; a computerized
inventory management system to order and update the stocks was designed and goods
the possibility of human error. The person may forget to record a transaction or only
the wrong count of items. This decision on additional orders need not increase
product, meaning business could run out a single item criticality in the wrong time.
Profitability Ratio
and after deducting all expenses incurred during a given period. Khaled Al-Jafari and
Samman (2015) mentioned it is considered one of the most important goals that
cease.
operational efficiency; however, Gaur et al. (2005) suggested the use of a new
turnover ratios of companies. They observed that gross margin, capital intensity, and
6
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
sales surprise were the factors influencing the firms’ inventory turnover ratios in the
retail industry. In subsequent work, Gaur and Kesavan (2015) found that company
size and sales growth rate also affected inventory turnover ratios of retail companies.
company's performance and inventory management. The study used inventory days
as a dependent variable and gross profit and net profit as an independent variable.
According to the analysis result, the researcher identified inventory management and
gross profit had a positive relationship, net profit had a negative relationship and
inventory management significantly affected gross profit margin and net profit
margin.
manufacturing industry because it can tell how fast the products are moving out of the
factory. Higher inventory turnover indicates less cash being tied up in slow-moving
products that are not being sold. In addition, inventory turnover measures are
signal of how efficiently products are moving along the manufacturing supply chain.
Determining the speed of sales can be a useful benchmark for evaluating firms’
competitiveness. Moreover, his works also considered gross margin, capital intensity,
firm size, debt cost, and demand uncertainty as control variables for inventory supply
of profitability that shows the percentage of revenue that exceeds the cost of goods
sold (COGS). The gross profit margin reflects how successful a company's executive
7
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
producing their products and services. In short, the higher the number, the more
The gross profit margin is calculated by taking total revenue minus the COGS
and dividing the difference by total revenue. The gross margin result is typically
multiplied by 100 to show the figure as a percentage. The COGS is the amount it
If a company's gross profit margin wildly fluctuates, this may signal poor
management practices and/or inferior products. On the other hand, such fluctuations
may be justified in cases where a company makes sweeping operational changes to its
business model, in which case temporary volatility should be no cause for alarm.
comparative study of SAIL & TATA Steel). The main purpose of a business unit is to
make profit. The profitability analysis is done to throw light on the current operating
performance and efficiency of business firms. It should be duly noted that net income
figure alone is not very helpful in determining the efficiency and performance of the
business firm unless it is related to some other figures such as sales, cost of goods
sold, operating expenses, capital invested etc. Thus, the profitability ratios are
calculated to enlighten the end result and comparison of business firms which is the
It is evident from the gross profit ratio of Tata Steel showed a decreasing trend
and so is the case with SAIL, which shows inefficiency of the management, however
on the basis of the average it can be concluded that Tata Steel performed better as the
decrease is less than the decrease in the gross profit ratio of SAIL. Therefore, it is
suggested that management of both the companies should increase the gross profit
8
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
ratio by controlling cost of goods sold and by increasing sales and try maintaining the
Inventory Method
FIFO Method
FIFO assumes that any sale of an item is from the oldest batch on hand and is
relevant when the prices you bought it at fluctuate when you have large numbers of
nearly identical items, specific identification may not be worth the effort. First In,
This method will give you a very accurate representation of your inventory,
which can be beneficial if you buy batches of the same item at varying prices,” stated
(Abir, 2021). “It will often mirror reality as older units of a stock-keeping unit (that
scannable barcode) tend to be sold before the newer ones in ideal circumstances.
“The downside is that it takes more effort to track different costs within the same
stock-keeping unit for different batches of purchases. For example, if you sell a
particular shirt with one universal product code (UPC) that was bought in three
batches, it’s harder to track a different cost for each batch than one cost for the entire
UPC.
LIFO Method
LIFO, as the name suggests, is basically the opposite of FIFO. It treats the last
items bought as the first ones sold. Here is what (Abir, 2021) has to say about this
method. “LIFO is when you attribute specific costs to individual items or batches of
items based on their actual cost, and you reduce your cost as you sell items with the
last items added being removed from inventory first. This method only makes sense
when it actually mirrors reality where the newest items are sold first, and older items
9
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
can sit there for a long time.” It is not a particularly common method, he explains,
Lastly, if the prices of the products you buy hardly change then you can use an
even easier method called Weighted Average Costing. With the weighted average
method, you use a pool of cost for all units of a particular stock keeping unit. Any
purchase is added to the pool of cost, and the pool of cost is divided by all units you
have on hand. “The benefit is that it’s much easier to track than specific costing
because you don’t need to know exactly which batch a sold unit was part of, which is
especially helpful when you have many identical units,” says (Abir, 2021). It may
also give you a more accurate costing method than the retail method—which does not
This is when you assign a specific cost to each item in your store. Abir says
this method makes the most sense for retailers that have a lot of different items,
especially if they were bought from various sources. “A good example would be an
antique dealer,” says Abir. Specific identification methods depend on the size of your
retail business, according to the Corporate Finance Institute (CFI). For the specific
identification method to suit your retail business, you need to be able to identify the
location, cost, and sale amount of every stock-keeping unit (SKU) confidently and
accurately in your inventory. The bigger your business and its inventory, the harder
that becomes. The CFI suggests specific identification is better suited to small
businesses because it can give them a more accurate profit and loss statement, with
10
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
reliable numbers on income and losses and normal spoilage of inventory (due to
The retail method provides the ending inventory balance for a store by
measuring the cost of inventory relative to the price of the goods. In essence, it
determines how much expense to recognize this period versus the next period. The
retail method assumes that all your inventory has a consistent markup, explains (Abir
Syed, 2021) CPA of UpCounting. “So, you take the total value of what you have for
sale, reduce it by its markup, and use that number as your cost.” The benefit of this
method, explains Abir, is that it is extremely easy to calculate and can work when
you have weak inventory cost tracking. “The main con is that it’s generally not very
accurate, especially if you have prices that fluctuate at different times of the year
(which most retailers do), and if you have products with different markups.”
11
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
Theoretical Framework
This study adopts to the EOQ Model. EOQ is the purchase order quantity for
replenishment that minimizes total inventory costs. The purchase order is triggered
when the inventory level hits the reorder point. The following illustrates the EOQ
Model.
The current study was anchored to the Attribution theory by Bernard Weiner
dimension known as the locus of causality from internal and external (Marc, 2016).
If the behavior is attributed to an internal locus of causality, a person assumes that the
outcome resulted from personal factors or something within us. It is all about being
aware that you are a person who controls your motivation and outcome which in
turn, what drives success. In the context of this assessment, it may denote that
12
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
factors such as their academic performance in college and study habits, as well as the
times they underwent formal review which manifests their effort, passion, and
perseverance they have from their undergraduate studies until their review for the said
examination.
The other locus of causality from Walberg’s Attribution Theory is the external
locus. In this principle, it is assumed that a person attributes the outcomes to factors
outside of himself, or due to situational factors. In this context: peer influences, the
school, home environment, enrollment in a review center are the outer factors that the
One of the most widely used models is the EOQ model in determining the
optimal inventory level under operational management. This mathematical model was
developed by F.W Haris year 1913 but still R.H. Wilson is given credit for his early
in-depth analysis of the model. the model is also known as the Wilson EOQ model.
According to this model, some costs (ordering cost) decline with inventory holdings,
while others (holding cost) rise and that the total inventory-associated cost curve has
a minimum point. This is the point where total inventory costs are minimized. Since
inventory costs directly impacts the profitability of the company, the EOQ Model
businesses.
13
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
Conceptual Framework
< Inventory
Management Practice
Ordering
< PROFITABILITY
Storing
Receiving
Selling
Effective
inventory
management
practices
independent variables are variables that predict the amount of variation in the
14
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
dependent variable. Thus, the value of the dependent variable depends on any change
in the independent variable. This study’s independent variable was represented by the
Efficiency.
vein. Therefore, this framework was very important as it clearly revealed the effect
manufacturing firms. This will help inform policies and practices of the
levels.
15
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
1.1. Ordering
1.2. Receiving
1.3. Storing
1.4. Sales
2. How may the profitability of the hardware businesses be measured in terms of:
16
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
businesses. This was done to have an understanding about the hardware businesses
within the area of Batasan Hills, Quezon City. A short questionnaire that consists of
distribute. The respondents that will partake in the survey will only be
17
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
evaluation of the inventory management they use. This will enable them to stress out
the effectiveness of their current inventory method. The findings will make them
enhance the factors that contribute to achieving the proper management of inventories
b. Other Hardware Entities – For the hardware entities/owners who would like
c. Future Investors – This study will provide relevant information to the future
better facilitate the management of inventories that will help the hardware owners
tax obligations in all businesses must account for the value of their trading stock at the
end of each income year (closing stock) and at the start of the next income year
(opening stock). Plus, the corporate tax of any business is directly related to inventory
18
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
management. The First In, First Out (FIFO) method increases corporate tax liability.
In contrast, the Last In, First Out (LIFO) method decreases corporate tax liability.
other business subjects to be able to deliver to their students the most recent inventory
f. Future Researchers – This study will be an effective tool and reference for
the future researchers who would intend to make further relevant study particularly on
Definition of terms
Cost efficient. The act of saving money without wasting time and money. It is
Inventory. Products which are available for sale. It is an asset that is intended to be
Inventory costs. It is the total costs associated with ordering and holding of
inventory.
the entire flow of goods from purchasing right through to sale, ensuring that you
always have the right quantities of the right item in the right location at the right time.
well.
19
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
Chapter 2
METHOD
Research Design
quantitative and data, which enabled the researcher to have an in-depth examination
of the proposed study. It was also intended to provide answers to the research
question. The design was chosen since it was deemed to be the most effective to
significantly contribute of to the depth and specificity of the study. Given that the aim
Quezon City to be their respondents. The total amount of the population will be
20
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
Source of Data
The researchers will prepare a letter of request signed by their thesis adviser
City to obtain the total number of hardware stores located at batasan, Quezon city.
After that, the researchers will be able to gather information from the management of
disseminated.
The result of the data gathering will be tallied and tabulated according to the
frequency of items checked by the researchers. The results will be interpreted by the
statistician using statistical tools. The result will help the researchers to arrive at the
21
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
Data Analysis
With the data collected being numerical scores, which can be analyzed,
statistics were employed to organize, analyze, interpret, and summarize the data
collected. To carry this task out, the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS)
version 22.0 was employed. This software is useful in the handling of complex data
manipulations and analyses. It is fairly fast and easy to use. It allows the use of
percentages, graphs, charts, means and a score of other useful interpretations from a
simple pull-down menu. It was then decided that it would be the best to use in this
survey.
1. Spearman rank-order
exists between two variables measured on at least an ordinal scale will be used in this
study. It is denoted by the symbol rs (or the Greek letter ρ, pronounced rho). The test
is used for either ordinal variables or for continuous data that has failed the
22
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
2. Cross Tabulation
multiple variables. Also known as contingency tables or cross tabs, cross tabulation
Cross tabulations are used to examine relationships within data that may not
be readily apparent. Cross tabulation is especially useful for studying market research
or survey responses. Cross tabulation of categorical data can be done with through
is a statistical technique that uses several explanatory variables to predict the outcome
of a response variable. The goal of multiple linear regression (MLR) is to model the
(dependent) variable.
23
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
QUESTIONNAIRE
We, the researchers from New Era University, as part of our studies, are
questions would be a great contribution to this paper. Please be assured that the
By beginning the survey, you acknowledge that you have read this information
and agree to participate in this research, with the knowledge that you are free to
appreciated. Thank you for taking time to assist us in our educational endeavors.
Age: ____________________________________________________
1-5 years
24
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
6-10 years
Above 10 years
1-20
21-50
51-100
Instructions: For each statement, please check whether you Strongly Agree, Agree,
3. To what extent do you agree with the following statements about how your business
Ordering
i. We rely on common
quantity of inventory
(stock) to order
ii. We use an equation to
of inventory (stock)
periodically
25
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
discounts
v. We order inventory
customer
vi. We receive our inventory
(stock) automatically
order
vii. We order only when we
level, we automatically
place an order
ix. When we place an order,
Yes
No
26
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
Instructions: For each statement, please check whether you Strongly Agree, Agree,
5. To what extent do you agree with the following statements about storage of stock in
your business?
Strongly Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly
Agree Disagree
i. Warehouse We insure
in the
ii. We own our warehouse
6. Do you plan in advance before ordering inventory (stock) for the warehouse in your
business?
Yes
No
Yes
No
8. Do you compare inventory (stock) ordered to the budgets regularly in your business?
Yes
No
9. Do you update the inventory (stock) budgets regularly in your business?
Yes
No
10. Do you conduct stocktaking in your business?
27
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
Yes
No
11. If Yes, to Question 10, how often does your business conduct stocktaking?
Daily
Weekly
Monthly
Every 6 months
Annually
Yes
No
13. Does your business have dedicated staff that manage the warehouse?
Yes
No
Instructions: For each statement, please check whether you Strongly Agree, Agree,
y Disagree
28
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
Agree
i. Our warehouse staff
accounting records
iii. We have clear
procedures followed by
our warehouse
iv. Access to our
warehouse is restricted
to record inventory
(stock) received
vi. Our staff use computers
to record inventory
(stock) issued
vii. Our staff can determine
inventory (stock)
barcoding system to
monitor movement of
29
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
warehouse
Instructions: For each statement, please check whether you Strongly Agree, Agree,
15. To what extent do you agree with the following statements about how your
Agree Disagree
i. Receiving, issuing,
responsibilities are
properly segregated.
ii. We match the delivery
to a purchase order.
iii. We conduct a quality
or malfunctioning.
iv. We allocate storage
received.
v. We check the contents
of each delivery we
order.
vi. Inventory are removed
30
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
issued
vii. Inventory are removed
issued
viii. We stored inventory
according to material
groups
ix. Material stock level are
monitored effectively
Please use the following scale to answer Question 2.
Instructions: For each statement, please check whether you Strongly Agree, Agree,
2. To what extent do you agree with the following statements about how your business
Agree Disagree
i. We deliver the order
(shipping fee)
ii. We have systems
or processes in place to
accuracy
31
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
delivery
delivery
v. We check the contents of
to dated
32
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
33
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
Adcroft, A. (2011, July 27). The motivations to study and expectations of studying
undergraduate students in business and management. Retrieved from
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0309877x.2011.590581
Cruzada, Deo. (2019, July 27). Behind the boards: CPA topnotchers share exam
preparations, experiences. Retrieved July 6, 2021, from The LaSallian
website:https://thelasallian.com/2019/07/27/behind-the-boards-cpa-
topnotchers-share-exampreparations-experiences/
34
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
Fan, X., & Chen, M. (2001). Parental Involvement and Students' Academic
Achievement: A Meta-
Analysis. Retrieved 6 July 2021,
from
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/226537478_Parental_Involvement_a
nd_Students'_A cademic_Achievement_A_Meta-Analysis
Lightweis, S. (2014). Bridging the Gap between Accounting Students and the
Profession: A Case Study.
Higher Education Studies, 4(5). https://doi.org/10.5539/hes.v4n5p18
Nabi Al-Duwaila, & Abdullah Al-Mutairi. (2020, December 30). Factors Affecting
the Success in Certified Public Accountant Exam in Kuwait. Retrieved April
15, 2021, from ResearchGate website:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/348071903
35
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
Oliva, C., Aclan, G., Quimio, A., Salayo, M., Rodriguez, A., & Manongsong, J.
(2017). Retrieved 6
July 2021, from https://research.lpubatangas.edu.ph/wp-
content/uploads/2017/06/APJARBA2017.3.04.pdf
Seifert, K. & Sutton, R. (2017). Motivation Theories on Learning. Retrieved April 12,
2021, from
Pressbooks.com website:
https://lidtfoundations.pressbooks.com/chapter/student-motivation/
Sugue, Winona (2018). 5 Effective Study Tips From A CPA Licensure Exam
Topnotcher. (2018). Retrieved July 7, 2021, from @edukasyonph website:
https://www.edukasyon.ph/blog/5effective-study-tips-from-a-cpa-board-exam-
topnotcher
Sugahara, S., Hiramatsu, K., & Boland, G. (2009). The factors influencing accounting
school students’ career intention to become a Certified Public Accountant in
Japan | Emerald Insight. (2013). Asian Review of Accounting.
https://doi.org/10.1108\/ara
36
New Era University
College Of Accountancy
No. 9 Central Avenue, New Era Quezon City, Philippines
Yu, D. (2016). How Much Do Study Habits, Skills, and Attitudes Affect Student
Performance in Introductory College Accounting Courses?. Retrieved 6 July
2021, from https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ955535.pdf
37