Scribd
Upload
64 views

Solutions To Homework 2

1. The document provides solutions to 5 problems regarding continuity of functions between metric spaces. It shows that the composition of continuous functions is continuous, defines and proves properties of discrete and rational metrics, and shows a function from a convergent sequence to a limit point is continuous if and only if the sequence converges.

Uploaded by

tomizzed
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
64 views

Solutions To Homework 2

1. The document provides solutions to 5 problems regarding continuity of functions between metric spaces. It shows that the composition of continuous functions is continuous, defines and proves properties of discrete and rational metrics, and shows a function from a convergent sequence to a limit point is continuous if and only if the sequence converges.

Uploaded by

tomizzed
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 4

Solutions to Homework 2

1. Let X, Y , and Z be metric spaces, with metrics dX , dY , and dZ . Let


f : X → Y be continuous at a point p ∈ X, and let g : Y → Z be
continuous at f (p). Show that g ◦ f is continuous at p.
Solution: Let  > 0 be given. Because g is continuous at f (p), there
is an η > 0 such that dY (f (p), r) < η implies dZ (g(f (p)), g(r)) <  for
all r ∈ Y , and in particular for all r of the form g(q) for some q ∈ X.
Because f is continuous at p, there is a δ > 0 such that dX (p, q) < δ
implies dY (f (p), f (q)) < η for all q ∈ X. Thus dX (p, q) < δ implies
dZ (g(f (p)), g(f (q))) <  for all q ∈ X.
2. Let X be any set, and let dX be the discrete metric
(
0 if p = q, or
dX (p, q) =
1 if p 6= q.
(a) Show that this is a metric.
Solution: Clearly d is symmetric, d(p, p) = 0, and d(p, q) > 0 if
p 6= q. It remains to check the triangle inequality:
d(p, r) ≤ d(p, q) + d(q, r)
for all p, q, r ∈ X. We could analyze a series of cases (p = q = r,
or p = q 6= r, etc.) and see that the triangle inequality holds
in each case. Or we could ask, how could the triangle inequality
fail, knowing that all distances appearing in it are either 0 or 1?
Only if the left-hand side is 1 and the right-hand side is 0. But
if the right-hand side is 0 then d(p, q) = d(q, r) = 0, so p = q and
q = r, so p = r, so the left-hand side is 0, not 1.
(b) Let (Y, dY ) be another metric space (not necessarily discrete).
Show that every map f : X → Y is continuous.
Solution: Let p ∈ X and  > 0 be given, and let δ = 12 . If
dX (p, q) < δ = 12 then dX (p, q) = 0, so p = q, so dY (f (p), f (q)) =
0 < .

1
4. Let X = Q with the usual metric inherited from R. Show that the set

A = {x ∈ Q : x2 < 1}

is open but not closed, but that the set

B = {x ∈ Q : x2 < 2}
√
is both open and closed. (You can use the fact that 2 is irrational
without proving it.)
Solution: Notice that we can also describe A as

A = {x ∈ Q : |x| < 1}.

To see that A is open, let a ∈ A, and take  = 1 − |a| > 0; then for all
x ∈ Q, if |x − a| <  then

|x| ≤ |x − a| + |a| <  + |a| = 1,

so x ∈ A. To see that A is not closed, consider the sequence xn = 1− n1 ,


which stays in A but converges to 1 which is not in A.

We can also describe B as

B = {x ∈ Q : x2 ≤ 2},

because there is no x ∈ Q with x2 = 2. Thus we can describe it either


as √
B = {x ∈ Q : |x| < 2},
or as √
B = {x ∈ Q : |x| ≤ 2}.
√
To see that B is open, let a ∈ A, take  = 2−|a|, and argue as before.
To see √
that B is closed, let xn be a sequence of rational numbers with
|xn | ≤ 2, converging to a limit `. We have
√
|`| ≤ |` − xn | + |xn | ≤ |` − xn | + 2

√ is an n such that√|` − xn | < , so the


for all n. For every  > 0 there
√ side is less that 2 + : that is, |`| < 2 +  for all  > 0,
right-hand
so |`| ≤ 2.

3
√
Alternatively, we could show that Q \ B, which
√ is {x ∈ Q : |x| > 2},
is open. Let x ∈ Q \ B, and let  = |x| − 2. Then for all y ∈ Q we
have
|x| ≤ |x − y| + |y|,
so
|y| ≥ |x| − |x − y|,
so if |x − y| <  then
√ √
|y| > |x| − (|x| − 2. 2) =
√ √
Or you might prefer to consider two cases, x > 2 and x < − 2.

5. Optional: Let
W = {1, 12 , 13 , 14 , . . . , 0}
with the usual metric inherited from R. Let X be another metric
space. Given a sequence p1 , p2 , . . . ∈ X and a point ` ∈ X, show that
the function f : W → X defined by
(
f ( n1 ) = pn ,
f (0) = `

is continuous if and only if pn → `.


Solution: First suppose that f is continuous. The sequence n1 con-
verges to 0 in W , so by Homework 1, Problem 3 we see that the
sequence f ( n1 ) = pn converges to f (0) = `.
Conversely, suppose that pn → `. We want to show that f is contin-
uous at every w ∈ W . There are two cases: either w = n1 , or w = 0.
Let  > 0 be given.
If w = n1 , let δ = n1 − n+1
1 1
= n(n+1) . If w0 ∈ W satisfies d(w, w0 ) < δ,
then w0 = w, so d(f (w), f (w0 )) = 0 < .
If w = 0, choose N such that d(pn , `) <  for all n > N , and let
δ = 1/N . If w0 ∈ W satisfies d(w, w0 ) < δ = 1/N , then either
w0 = 0, so d(f (w), f (w0 )) = 0 < , or w0 = 1/n for some n > N ,
so d(f (w), f (w0 )) = d(`, pn ) < .

You might also like