Assessing The Life Satisfaction of Elderly Living in Old Age Homes in The City of Ahmedabad-28-43
Assessing The Life Satisfaction of Elderly Living in Old Age Homes in The City of Ahmedabad-28-43
ABSTRACT
The present study was planned to find out the quality of life and the
coping strategies of the inmates of old age homes in the city of
Ahmedabad. 50 inmates (Male=33, Female=17) from five old age
Homes, were selected through the random sampling method. The
elderly subjects were interviewed individually to find out the
reasons for coming to live in old age homes and to know their views
about the living conditions and their coping strategy in the new
environment. The findings of this study revealed that the majority
of the elderly people did not get respect, love and affection from
their family members and were highly dissatisfied with the
behaviour their children. They were considered as a burden by the
family members. The respondents were of the view that in old age
when health deteriorates and person is unable to work his self
respect is badly hurt.
people living in institutions were higher than the mean scores on these
parameters of the elderly living with their children. As an interpre-
tation of these findings it may be said that elderly people who
demonstrate a tendency towards external locus of control have higher
level of satisfaction and vice-versa. This is mainly due to the fact that
elderly people who are externally focused and who have developed
trust in their health care provider actually demonstrate higher levels of
satisfaction than those who rely on themselves or depend on old age
homes. As a result the second group may experience more guilt or
feeling of hopelessness when faced with poor treatment.
In summary, review of studies on life satisfaction among old age
people have shown that emotional states like anxiety, depression and
guilt were more and social and emotional support were very less
among the elderly living in institutions.
Methodology
Sample
The elderly people living in old aged homes of Ahmadabad
constituted the population of the research. Gujarat has a total of 57 old
aged homes out of which 10 are in Ahmedabad. After listing the
number of old age homes in Ahmedabad, the researchers randomly
selected 50 inmates (Male=33, Female=17) from five old age homes.
60 per cent elderly were living in ‘pay and stay’ type old age homes.
Their children were paying their expenses.
Method
A semi-structured interview schedule was used to find out the
views of respondents. These respondents were interviewed individ-
ually. The researcher took utmost care to make it as convenient as
possible for the respondents. In addition, the researchers were able to
explain or rephrase the questions if the respondents were unable to
158 Indian Journal of Gerontology
The table also brought out that nearly 42 per cent of respondents were
having 6–9 members in their family, which indicates that majority of
them were from joint families. It was also seen that the majority (42%)
of respondents had worked in the public sector. As regards marital
status, 62 per cent of were married and 24 per cent, widowed. A very
negligible number of the respondents were unmarried. Similarly, it
was also observed that very few numbers of respondents were getting
more than Rs 3 lakhs salary per annual. Table 2 presents the distri-
bution of socio-economic status of the respondents.
Table 2
Socio-Economic Status of the Respondents
followed by ‘Family Feud’ (22%) and ‘Lack of Peace and health condi-
tions at home (18%). A very striking fact that emerged was that a
noticeable percentage (8%) of the respondents did not disclose the
reasons for their staying in these homes. This suggests the charitable
nature of such persons who, despite being cheated or ill-treated by
their younger relatives, were reluctant to speak ‘ill’ about them.
Maybe they were also reluctant to disclose embarrassing family secrets
to unknown.
Table 3
Reasons for Staying in Old Age Homes
Social and Emotional Support for the Elderly at Old Age Homes
An individual’s social support system comprises multiple
networks and various relations that include family, relatives, friends
and neighbours. The ageing experience of older people is largely influ-
enced by the degree they are embedded in social support networks.
162 Indian Journal of Gerontology
From the above Table, it can be seen that children of 48 per cent of the
respondents visit the old age homes on a monthly basis. A very
noticeable fact that emerged is that children of 22 per cent of respon-
dents do not visit them at all. A similar trend of ‘neglect’ was noticed
from close relatives – in nearly 60 per cent cases, no one was visiting
the inmates.
Table 5
Visits to Parents at Old Age Homes
fulfilled. It was also noted, some old age homes had fixed visiting
hours. However, in majority of the old age homes, there were no time
restrictions and relatives could come to visit anytime. Thus, restricted
visiting hours could not be cited as a reason for the children/close
relatives not ‘looking up’ the inmates more frequently.
Cont’d…
It can be seen from the Table that, even on this parameter, there is
an overall tendency to accept things as they are, since the largest
number in the two age brackets 61 to 65 and 66 to 70, and overall, gave
‘Neutral’ response regarding their satisfaction levels. However, the
largest number of respondents in the above 70 years age bracket gave a
categorical ‘Not satisfied’ response on this issue. It is also noteworthy
Life Satisfaction of Elderly Living in Old Age Homes 165
that for all the age brackets, and overall, the ‘Not satisfied’ response
were more than the ‘Satisfied’ response. Even though most inmates
were not satisfied with the conditions in the old age homes, they are
forced to stay there, obviously for want of a better alternative. This
finding is in tune with that of Litwin and Shiovitz (2006) which
indicates that many of the elderly prefer to stay in old age homes,
despite their low level of satisfaction. This is mainly due to that fact
that many of them had stressful family relations and lack of family
care which forces them to seek ‘refuge’ in old age homes. Further, life
satisfaction is affected by their role in their family, their
socio-economic and health conditions, and the frequency of meeting
they have with their children living far away (Kim, 1996). Similarly,
studies conducted by Ko, (1995) and Meng, (1986) reveals that religious
activities also play an important role for life satisfaction of the elderly
people. Religious activities helps in finding new meaning to life and
gaining a positive attitude towards death and the loss associated with
old age.
Once it was established that most of the respondents stay in old
age homes since they had no other option, the logical question that
arose what about some of the positives they found in these ‘homes’.
One factor that emerged during personal interaction was that they
have the freedom to do what they want and to live as they wish and are
not bound by restrictions especially on their movements. Two, they
did not have to be dependent on the whims of family members. Three,
they felt they were being properly and adequately looked after and the
staff behaved properly with them. Yet another issue was having the
company of others belonging to a similar age bracket. This afforded
them the opportunity to discuss their problems and share experiences.
Thus, it emerged that the peaceful and positive ambiance at old age
homes was the reason behind their happiness. This arrangement
provides them the much needed comfort, solace stress free
environment, peace of mind and absence of conflicts, mostly with
their children.
implemented for the welfare of the elderly. It can be seen that the
majority of respondents were aware about the pension schemes
available for them, irrespective of whether they had earlier worked in
the private or public sector. Similarly, it could be seen that 54 per cent
of them were aware about various concessions available to them. Also
30 per cent were aware about the aid provided to old age homes. One
of the respondents was also aware of Maintenance of Senior Citizen’s
Act, 2007. According to this Act, it is the obligation of the children or
relative, as the case may be, to maintain a senior citizen, if the
concerned senior citizen is unable to maintain himself from his
earning or his property. This respondent informed that he was aware
of the Senior Citizen’s Act, since his own brother had successfully
used the provisions contained in the Act.
Table 8
Awareness About Government Policies
because as they age, they require physical, mental and emotional care
and support. It is about time people changed their psyche as elderly
not only can take, but also provide/give their enriching lessons and
experience. A few respondents stated that if people start to put
themselves in their position (empathising with them), it would help in
increasing their quality of life because ageing and related problems are
not in anybody’s control. People need to understand that they too will
age as some time later in life.
Thus, the suggestions of respondents indicate that care, support
and understanding can enhance the quality of life or dignity. They also
opined that elderly must put into practise their freedom of speech in
every matter to prove that they are not silent sufferers. It shows that
they had a pessimistic outlook and did not want to suggest ways that
could help in enhancing their quality of life as they felt nothing could
be done to improve it.
Finally the study revealed that the most common reasons for the
respondents staying in old age homes was that they could not look
after themselves or there was no one to take care of them. In fact, this
is, in a way, a forced choice. Another reason was the conflict with
children or with other family members. The most common purpose
reported for preferring institutional living arrangement was to seek
peace of mind here since, familial affection was denied to them by their
children/close relatives. It is saddening to note that the decision of
majority of respondents was not their own, they did not come out of
their own free will. Living in old age homes gave a positive and homily
feeling to majority of respondents of this study. They were happy
because they have made friends and enjoyed being in the company of
co-inmates. On the other hand, the efforts of government are not very
effective, because a significant number of respondents (28%) revealed
that they were not aware of any policy. Pension scheme was the only
scheme that was known to the respondents. Respondents informed
that they never felt the need to be abreast of government policies.
In conclusion, it can be said that with an increase in materialism
in the contemporary society and an inclination towards the western
world, there is a change in traditionally preserved and followed values.
Now an increasing number of children, instead of considering taking
care of their parents as a responsibility, see them as ‘disposable’
168 Indian Journal of Gerontology
References
Anastasia E, Maria K, Grace C. (2003). Subjective quality of life in old
age in Greece: The effect of demographic factors, emotional state
and adaptation to ageing. Eur Psychologist, 8, 178–91.
Barua A, Mangesh R, Harsha Kumar HN, Mathew S (2007). A
cross-sectional study on quality of life in geriatric population,
Indian Journal of Community Medicine, 32(2): 146–147.
Das N.P. and Shah Urvi (2004). A Study of Old Age Homes in the
Care of Elderly in Gujarat. Retrieved from http://
prcbaroda.org/Pages/oldage%20home%20report.htm
Ghosh, AB. (2006). Psychiatry in India: Need to focus on geriatric
psychiatry. Indian Journal of psychiatry, 48: 49–50.
Kim, J.D. (1996). Life Satisfaction of the old and the factors affecting it.
Doctoral Dissertations from Kyungsan University.
Kim, H., et al. (1999). A longitudinal study on social support and life
satisfaction among Japanese elderly. Japanese Journal Public
Health, 46 (7), 532–541.
Ko, S.D. (1995). Study of extracting the factors deciding the quality of the
life of the old. Doctoral Dissertation from Ewha Woman’s
University.
Litwin H, Shiovitz E (2006). Association between activity and
well-being in later life: What really matters? Ageing and society, 26:
255–242.
Life Satisfaction of Elderly Living in Old Age Homes 169