Analysis of Black Start of A Microgrid With PV, DG, and BESS
Analysis of Black Start of A Microgrid With PV, DG, and BESS
Abstract: Different combinations of operating scenarios for a Stabilizing the microgrid system by maintaining the voltage
microgrid with distributed energy resources and energy storage and frequency through an efficient control system is the main
system is considered to understand the operation of a microgrid. key factor that distinguishes microgrid from the distributed
An operational strategy analysis of a microgrid system consisting
network. Several papers have discussed various control
of photovoltaics, diesel generator, and battery energy storage
system during a black start in islanded mode is considered in this algorithms to maintain the bus voltage to stabilize the
paper. BESS under study consists of a bidirectional converter and microgrid system [3], [7]-[9].
a battery system. BESS is assumed to be active as a solution
provided in all the scenarios. The various capabilities of BESS in
a microgrid system is also discussed. Microgrid system provides
reliable power supply and hence black start capability for such a
system is essential in keeping intact the advantages of a microgrid.
Performing a black start requires a sequential process to be
followed to avoid fluctuations in bus voltage, frequency, and
protecting the fuses/ contactors from blowing. To black start the
system under study, the DC breaker connecting the battery and the
bidirectional converter needs to be closed. Closing the DC breaker
results in high inrush current from batteries at the DC output of
the bidirectional converter. A DC arrangement is envisaged in the Fig. 1.Renewable-based power generation capacity in
battery energy storage system to avoid arcing due to high inrush India [2]
current.
The blackout of the microgrid will have a huge impact on
the system as renewable energy goes unutilized and it affects
Keywords: Battery Energy Storage System, Black Start, Diesel
Generator, Environmental Impact, Microgrid, Photovoltaic, the loads. Restoring the system helps to reduce the
Reliability, Renewables. interruption time and economic loss [10] [11]. The process of
restoring the electric power or distributed system to operate
I. INTRODUCTION without relying on the external electric power system is
called the black start (BS) of microgrid [12]. Performing
With the progression of the economy, energy demand has
black start helps in restoring the system back online to the
increased considerably. Renewable energy such as wind,
photovoltaics (PV), hydroelectric, biomass, etc. forming normal stable operating condition [13] [14]. It also helps in
Distributed energy resources (DERs) and energy storage maximizing the system reliability and reduces the
systems (ESS) such as batteries, flywheels, pumped hydro, environmental impact. The system must be capable of black
supercapacitor, etc. have seen a widespread distribution [1] start, i.e., the system should have enough startup power
[2]. Fig. 1 shows how renewable energy sources are playing a capacity. Carrying out black start without enough power
crucial role in India at present. Distributed generation has capability leads to fluctuations in bus voltage and frequency
received widespread attention and Microgrid (MG) emerged [13], [15]-[18].
as a result. Different black start restoration sequence for microgrids
The microgrid system consists of low voltage distribution like series and parallel restoration based on the restoration
system with DERs together with an ESS and flexible loads. time and its comparison is discussed in [10], [18]-[20].
This system can be operated by either connected to the grid or Parallel restoration strategy has a complex design and it is
off-grid. Microgrids helps in secure and reliable access to difficult to connect the subsystem to the microgrid as there
power [3] [4]. During a contingency, microgrid disconnects will be high impulse current when the subsystem is
itself from the main grid and operates in an islanded mode connected. But the available method helps in fast restoration
with uninterrupted supply to load using its DERs [5] [6]. of the system [21]-[23]. The serial restoration process has a
simple hardware and software design which takes more time
for restoration [24] [25].
Revised Manuscript Received on March 5, 2020. The general content flow of the document is arranged as
* Correspondence Author
Akhiya Sanal*, R&D Associate Engineer, Power Grids-Grid follows. Section 2 explains the system review where the
Automation, ABB India Limited, Bengaluru, India. Email: microgrid system under study is discussed. Section 3 presents
[email protected] the various operating scenarios of the system. Section 4
Pruthiraj Swain, R&D Engineer, Power Grids-Grid Automation, ABB
India Limited, Bengaluru, India. Email: [email protected]
discusses the black start strategy and section 5 is the
Ashoka Shyamaprasad, Technical Product Manager, Power Grids-Grid conclusion with the main
Automation, ABB India Limited, Bengaluru, India. Email: takeaway points.
[email protected]
Fig. 7. MG application- Standalone operation [27] Fig. 10. MG application- Load/ generation Shifting [27]
F. Smoothing Thus, by installing a BESS in a microgrid will maximize
This operation indicates the management of fluctuations of the system reliability, provides uninterrupted power supply,
renewable energy sources or sudden load changes by reduces the effect on the environment by maximizing the
smoothing the power to a defined rate as shown in Fig. 8. renewable energy penetration, resulting in fuel and
BESS system corrects the output to control the voltage associated cost savings, and hence fuel independence.
fluctuations and power swings on the grid [33].
III. OPERATING SCENARIOS
To analyze the system, different operating scenarios listed
in Table. I. are considered.
Table- I: Various Operating Scenarios
Scenario Grid DG PV BESS
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Fig. 8. MG application- Solar/Wind Smoothing [27] 8
Active Inactive
G. Peak Shaving
A. Scenario 1 – Grid, DG, PV and BESS active
This application helps in managing the peak load using
storage or dispatchable generators. It helps in reducing the
consumption during peak demand by storing the excess
energy as shown in Fig. 9 & thus saving cost during
maximum demand on utility [34] [35].
The grid and the PV system supply the loads. BESS the voltage and frequency reference for the PV inverter. PV
provides reactive power to keep the voltage within the inverter shares the load with the BESS system. If the battery
defined boundaries whenever the voltage falls. Similarly, SoC reaches the minimum SoC set limit (SoCMIN), then the
BESS consumes the reactive energy to control the voltage for output power is maintained at 0kW and PV output is
overvoltage circumstances. When the PV generation is regulated to supply load. Fig. 13 shows the system where the
higher than the demand, the batteries in the BESS system is load is fed only by PV and BESS as discussed in scenario 3.
charged up to a specified maximum State of Charge (SoC)
D. Scenario 4 – PV inactive in islanded mode
limit. Fig. 11 shows the arrangement and the flow of power
from the sources.
B. Scenario 2 – Islanded mode
presumed to be inactive. Grid forms the PV system's voltage H. Scenario 8 – DG and PV inactive in islanded mode
and frequency reference. The grid, PV and BESS can meet This is the worst-case scenario where DG and PV are
the load. The surplus generation is used up to the maximum inactive, and the operation mode of microgrid system is in
specified SoC point for charging the battery system. Fig. 15 islanded mode, as shown in Fig. 18. The BESS system meets
shows the flow of power during scenario 5. the entire load up to SoCMIN. On reaching the minimum set
F. Scenario 6 – DG and PV inactive in grid-connected point of SoC, the system will shut down and blackout occurs.
mode The DC circuit breaker between the battery system and the
BDC system opens to avoid a further reduction in SoC level
Fig. 16 shows the scenario where DG and PV are inactive
due to the feeding of residual loads. During daytime when PV
and the microgrid system is grid connected. The load is met
becomes active, the operating scenario shifts to scenario 3.
from the grid and BESS. BESS system is getting charged
from the surplus power availability from the grid. During the
daytime, the conditions are the same as scenario 5 as PV
becomes active.