Women'S Empowerment Through Ngos Intervention: A Socio-Economic Assessment of Rural Area in Rangpur
Women'S Empowerment Through Ngos Intervention: A Socio-Economic Assessment of Rural Area in Rangpur
BACKGROUND
During 1990, micro-credit programs of non-government Organizations (NGOs) emerged as the mainstream
catalyst in the development interventions to address poverty reductions and women empowerment within multi-
dimensional socio-economic program, particularly in developing or least developed countries
(Newaz,2003;Sicher,1999;Wright 19999;Rhaman,1999).Though micro-credit loan of NGOs have positive
impact on women‟s empowerment, but document related to micro-finance literature proves that some
controversial issues also related with that initiatives (Li, Gan, and Hu, 2011). Micro-finance program is a form
of business though it is small which most often involve with self-employment in the informal sector, women
make up a large and growing segment of business in informal sector within investment, savings and building up
entrepreneurship (Armnedariz de Afhion and Morduch, 2005). During in 1990s, some NGOs got international
recognition and donor support in Bangladesh and rapidly grown –up. Microcredit has been evolved over the
years and does provide not only credit to the poor, also spans a myriad of other services, including saving,
insurance, remittances and non-financial services such as financial literacy training and skill development
training program; microcredit are referred to as micro-finance, In generally women‟s are more reliable to NGOs,
that‟s why maximum portion of loan distributed to women (Duvendack, Palmer-Jones, Copestake, Hooper,
Lokeand Rao,2011). Given the women constraints to credit and for the goal of gender equity, women are the
main target of micro-finance institutions and have obviously become the main beneficiaries. NGOs and its
microcredit program has been regarded as one of the crucial tools for poverty reductions and women
empowerment, also NGOs become a learning curve for women (Al-Amin andChowqdhury,2008 ).
Studies relating to micro-credit and women empowerment, some claim that micro-credit help women increase
their income earning abilities, lead to a greater power to overcome cultural asymmetries, others contend that
small loans allocated to women are usually controlled by their spouse, which results in more severe
subordination of women and leaves them more vulnerable to the patriarchy system within the household and/or
at society level(Islam, Tauhidul and Islam, Emdadul, 2012). The traditional patriarchal cultures of the society
sign that married women are always ready to fulfill the demand of their male counterparts, that‟s why women
wish but they could not utilize their money in their own way. Women‟s participation in NGOs program within
taking loans helps to increase women empowerment. By proper utilization of NGOs loan, women can play a
greater role in household decision making, having greater access to financial and economic resources, having
greater social network,greater bargaining power with their husbands ad greater freedom of mobility, also they
can play role in community decisions (Pitt, Khandaker and Cartwright,2003).But some critics found that, for
existing patriarchal social structure, women don‟t have enough control over their own resources and they can‟t
utilize their loan in their own way. Some scholars argued that NGO loan does not usually increase bargaining
capacity for such women borrower who surrender nearly 40 percent of control over their decisions related to
savings and investment, and 90 percent of their return realizations from their investments and savings, onto their
husbands, traditional socio-cultural norms have also a significant impact on that issue (Goetz and Gupta,1996).
Objectives
The overall objective of the study is to examine the impact of NGOs on women Empowerment in rural settings.
The specific ones are-
1) To examine the women‟s control over loans, savings and income generating activities of the study population
and also either the women can utilize their taken loan from NGOs or not,
2) To review the impact of NGOs loan in family decision making, either they can take their decision
independently or influenced by other male members.
3) To assess the role of NGOs in concerning women about political participation, voting behavior, and also
community decision making, also to examine the existing attitude of society about women through NGOs.
LITERATURE REVIEW
Women Empowerment refers to the creation of an environment for women where they can make decisions of
their own for their personal benefits as well as for the society. That‟s why, the empowerment approach comes
from women‟s groups who seek to empower themselves through greater self-reliance and economic sufficiency,
which is important catalyst in that context. They do not seek integration into mainstream development, in which
they have no choice in defining the society they want .Women seek to influence their own change, the right to
determine their own choice in life. They also seek to gain control of and access to resources. This approach
differs from the equity approach in origin and strategies. The empowerment approach seeks to meet both
strategic and practical needs (Union Padokkhep,1995: 77). The empowerment of women would result in overall
development of society both at micro and macro level. Active participation of women in economic activities and
decisions, would contribute towards overall economic development. But they faces Challenges, because of the
inherent superiority complex among the males, they often doesn‟t allow their female counter-part to rise as high
as them(Erickson andDitomassi,2003).
Certain research studies of the manifestations of women‟s empowerment revealed six general categories, NGOs
can nurture that variable to promote empowerment of women within sustainable development:1. Ability to earn
a living, 2. Increased decision making-making power in the household; 3.Participation in non-family solidarity
groups, 4.Mobility and visibility in the community, 5. Ability to act effetely in the public sphere, 6.Sense of
security and vision of future. It also refers to the equitable representation of women in decision making
structures, both formal and informal, and their voice in the formulation of policies affecting their societies and
lives (Mahtab, 2012: 246).Women empowerment also focuses on empowering to knowledge about and
understanding of the conditions and causes of subordination within social structure; together with this is added
educational attainment which is without doubt the most fundamental perquisite for empowering women in all
sphere of society; Economic Empowerment is the ability to earn and control economic resources; Political
Empowerment is the ability to analyze one‟s world and to recognize and mobilize for social change, NGO have
scope to flourish that three variables to ensure sustainable development of that community(Batliwala, 1994).
“NGO as a formal non-profit, non-partisan private body which comes into being as a result of personal
initiative of an individual or a group of individual to voluntary undertake development works at the grassroots
within microcredit program, they emphasis on giving loan to women in greater rate, as they are comparatively
more reliable, that flourish a women into greater decision making and bargaining power with male members in
family and society” (Rahman, Motiar and Alam,Shafiqul,2006).According to Streeten (1997), (1) NGOs are
good at reaching and mobilizing the poor and remote communities; (2) they help poor people to gain control of
their lives, and they work with and strengthen local institutions;(3) they carry out projects at lower costs and
more efficiently than the government agencies and (4) they promote sustainable development. NGOs have an
important role to play in supporting women, men and households, and expected that they can meet the welfare.
She accounted some role and functions for NGOs, such as counseling and support service, awareness raising
and advocacy, legal aid and microfinance (Streeten, Paul, 1997).
„Women‟s empowerment‟ has been described as „women‟s power‟ which is being able to make contributions at
all levels as society and having this contribution recognized and valued in community .Power in the context of
women therefore, means participating in decision-making in all sphere of life not just areas of society which are
accepted as women‟s place, creating from a women‟s perspective, within inclusion of women in decision
making process. NGOs can empower women through capacity building, develop community capacities such as
ability, skill and knowledge of mobilizing resources, planning and evaluating community initiation and solving
problems to gain the mastery over their lives (Griffin, 1989). Empowerment is thought to occur when an
organization like NGOs sincerely engages people and progressively responds to this engagement with mutual
interest and intention to promote growth, empowerment develops over time as employees gain greater control
over their lives and increasingly take part in decisions which affect them and self-growth get fostered (Erickson,
2003). Hashemiet. Al.(1996) find that membership in NGO (as like Grameen Bank and BRAC) have a
significant positive effect on empowerment even controlling for women‟s independent contributions to
household income. They find that even in cases where members attached to credit program do not contribute
independently because their husbands‟ misappropriation of their loan. NGOs mobilize the communities to be
self-reliant. It assists the communities to discover their own potentials and rely on their own resources (Nikkhah,
Hedayat and Redzuan, Marof, 2010). Though some academician examined that maximum portion of taken loan
by women used by male members of family, and women have less influence in controlling resources, as gender
equality has not yet been ensured. But most of the critics argue that the said program run by NGOs for women
in Bangladesh expanded, in part, due to the financial viability of agencies providing small credit loan to women.
Male dominance over women still exists in rural areas because of existing patriarchal and traditional form of
social structure, that‟s why, women borrower have not yet establish their full control over their own resources.
Also, Women borrowers have a little or no control over their loan money to invest in productive sources,as they
wish, maximum time, they have to fill up husbands purposes. Even sometimes, women have no idea about
where and how their husbands are investing their money received by them (Islam, Tauhidul and Emdadul, 2012:
134).
But the situation also slightly changing ,Women are now being aware by different consciousness building
program run by NGOs, being self-motivated to get loan, it is found that women borrowers to have invested their
loan money in income-generating activities like rearing livestock, tailoring and so on. And it is also observed
that in some cases, husband‟s dominations as well as cooperation in investing their money in against a project.
At present, a positive sign has been seen that women get self-motivated for joining micro-credit program and
also, they are now participating in different training program run by NGO‟s and get aware about socio-political
affairs.
Table: Summary of the women empowerment indicators through NGOs proposed by different researchers and
organizations
Researcher/Organization and Year of research NGO and Women Empowerment
Friedman (1992); Mayoux (2001);Fayyaz (2002); Malhotra Economic decision making and also involved in
et al. (2002); Mason and Smith (2003); Kumar and household decision making,
Sreedhara (2004); Acharya and Bennet (1983); Schuler
and Hashemi (1994); Mason and Smith (2003); Bangladesh
Demographic and Health Survey (BDHS) (2004);
Gender Empowerment Measure (GEM); Friedmann (1992); Political decision making, Political campaigning
Hashemi et al. (1996); Malhotra et al. (2002); Fayyaz and protests/ political participation and decision
(2002); Moghadam and Senftova (2005), Gender making
Empowerment Measure (GEM).
Friedmann (1992); Hashemi(1996); Amin (1998); Malhotra Physical freedom of movement, Ability to
et al.(2002); Mason and Smith (2003);Malhotra and Schuler interact in the public sphere/Participation in non-
(2005); Towfiqua et al.(2007); Schuler and Hashemi family group, social mobility.
(1994) .
IFAD(International Fund for Agriculture Development), Social empowerment, raising
Friedmann (1992); Mayoux (2001); Fayyaz (2002); Kumar consciousness/Knowledge/ right, Self
and Sreedhara (2004); Chen (1997) ; Confidence, Self Esteem
Women‟s Microfinance Initiative (WMI); Mayoux (2001); Economic security/ involvement in major
Sridevi (2005); Hashemi et al. (1996). decisions, Control over income Power over
economic resources, income generating activities
Source: Prepared by author.
Explaining NGOs’ Role and Women Empowerment: Theoretical Framework
The concept of Power has undergone fundamental transformation over time. The Marxist notion of power exist
in matter that mostly dominant social classes in society experiments its power over the subordinate, women is
considerate as the part of that subordinate classes and other oppressed classes until they are over thrown to some
social conflict and raises the self-consciousness among women about their oppression and deprivation, they try
to raise their voice as unique class to be a part of mainstream economy, and new hegemonic division come out.
The conventional concept of power, as exercised by someone over those below, that someone want to be
hegemonic class over women, as empowerment is a gradual process, that‟s why women community will be
going on that constructive and gradual process and be empowered, it was critically confronted by the
poststructuralist movement in the 1980s. It was Michael Foucault, a French historian, who introduced the power
as disseminate and dispersed across social spaces, and produced and can be observed at several angles rather
than existing in a singular upright dimension. The contest between Marxists and Poststructuralists, as well as
Postmodernists fumes on. Marxist emphasizes that some social classes practice their authority by involving the
state in order to the own interests of capital growth. Poststructuralists feminist however, focused upon the
Focauldian redefined this power concept to challenge this notion that power can be practiced over some entity
(Ho-Won J, 2000: 80-85). In the post-second world war era there were levels of political that what might be
called forms of liberalism that could be linked to extensive social changes and forms of feminist study and its
analysis. In the first period of social liberalism or social democracy there was the rise of second wave
feminism‟, this wave was distinguishing the earlier political forms of feminist demonstration, focused on liberal
identity of women in the society.In the period from the 1960s and into the 1970s this movement was particularly
important because it emphasizes a critique of the workings of liberal social democracy which not only in regards
of education but also with respect to women and the family. The second period can be considered as one of a
reaction to a more liberal and social democratic era and is often called the period of economic liberalism, that
period emphasis on economic and entrepreneurial freedom of women, considered as human resource. NGOs as
non-formal organization engaged with women to provide capital to women. Here ideas of gender entered the
glossary of social and policy examination. The third period of neo-liberalism is that of conversion of political
and social relationships and the conduct in which feminists and others have to understand these changes, which
provide a critique of educational partnerships. When economic sufficiency ensured to women then NGO would
offer some training program to concern women about their rights and control over own resources and decision
making power will be enhanced, women will be politically aware and be concerned about gender equality
(Pettman J, 2004: 672).
In the literature of women empowerment various approaches have been developed by the different scholars.
Among them the welfare, equity, anti-poverty, efficiency and empowerment approaches are prominent ones.
The welfare approaches widely followed during the period 1950-70 aims at beginning women into development
as better mother mothers which is considered their most important role in development. Some reproductive role,
relating particularly to food aid, malnutrition and family planning, women have seen as passive beneficiaries of
development by NGOs with focus on their reproductive role. The equity approach and anti-poverty are the two
phases of a single approach popularly known as the women in Development (WID) approach. Equity approach
tries to gain equity for women in the development process as active participants while the anti-poverty approach
strives for ensuring the increase of poor women‟s productivity where women‟s poverty seen as problem of
underdevelopment, not of subordination. To gain equity for women in the development process, NGO try to
present women as active participants in development. In Equity approach, NGOs are trying to ensure political
and economic autonomy for women by reducing inequality with men comparing subordinate position of women
in terms of socio-economic relationship with men.NGOs support poor and marginal women to ensure their
productivity. Efficiency and Empowerment approach is predominant Women in Development (WID) approach
that recognizes women‟s economic contribution to development, in this approaches, women‟s economic
participation seen as associated with equity and efficiency. To prepare women in three roles like women seen
entirely in terms of delivery capacity, ability to extend working day and increasing control over resources. The
main motto of Empowerment approach is to empower women through greater self-reliance; women‟s
subordination seen not only as problem of men but also of colonial and neo-colonial oppression , grassroots
organization like NGO united that women community to confront oppression and play role to make self-reliant
women who are largely unsupported by government and agencies. By that procedure, women participation in
household decision making indicates household empowerment, participation of women in economic decision
making indicates economic empowerment, and physical freedom of movement indicates social empowerment
(Coroline, M, 2000: 56-57).
NGOs and Women Empowerment can be viewed as a continuum of several interrelated and mutually
reinforcing components:
Awareness building about women situation, discrimination and rights and opportunities as a step
towards gender equality.
Capacity building and skills development of women, and engagement of women in income generating
program especially the ability to plan, make decisions, organize, manage and carry out activities ,to
deal with people and institutions in the world around them;
Participation and greater control and having decision making power in home, community and society;
Action to bring about greater equality between men and women, also having access to information and
resources.
Having a range of options from which to make choices, assertiveness, education and health is also the
cornerstone of empowerment (Karl, Marlee: 1995).
By reviewing above theories and literature, the study develops following framework to explain the role of NGOs
in women empowerment in greater Rangpur region. NGOs play three vital roles such as microcredit or loan,
training and skill building program and consciousness raising program. These types of activities play a great role
in women empowerment.
important. NGOs are BRAC, ASA, CARE, Caritas, Thengamara Mahila Sabuj Sangha(TMSS)(Bangladesh
Population Census-2000).In that geophysical context, we have selected four villages in Pairaband Union, names
of these selected villages are Khuddomuradpur,Devipur,Joyrampuranwar and Pokeya Keshobpur. Total area of
Pairaband union is 6826 square (acre), population-26957 (Male-13810 and Female 13147), literacy rate is
40.73. Several NGOs are working in that area (Source: Banglapaedia).
loan more than one lac in agriculture and forestry while 2.4 percent have ranging from seventy five thousand to
one lac taka.
Livestock and fisheries: Among women, 87 respondents expend their taken loan in livestock and fisheries
whose mean and SD are 4.6885E4 and 59874.52 respectively ranging from 3000 to 3.00E5. 48.3 percent spend
their loan less than twenty five thousands while 18.4 percent spend from twenty five thousand to fifty thousand
and 14.9 percent have from fifty thousand to seventy five thousands. Around 18.4 percent women have total
expenditure of loan more than one lac in livestock and fisheries in.
Processing and manufacturing: Among the respondents, 37 respondents expend their taken loan in processing
and manufacturing whose current mean and SD are 4.0784E4 and 48315.59respectively ranging from 5000 to
2.00E5. 56.8 percent expend their loan less than twenty five thousands while 15.4 percent expend in processing
and manufacture from twenty five thousand to fifty thousand and 21.6 percent have from fifty thousand to
seventy five thousands. Around 16.2 percent women have total expenditure of loan more than one lac in
livestock and fisheries
Shop keeping: Among the women, 68 respondents expend from their taken loan in shop-keeping whose current
mean and SD are 4.4956E4 and 52076.99 respectively ranging from 1000 to 2.00E5. 47.1 percent have spent
their loan less than twenty five thousands while 19.1 percent have expend from twenty five thousand to fifty
thousand and 16.2 per cent have from fifty thousand to seventy five thousands. Around 17.6 percent women
have total expenditure of loan more than one lac in livestock and fisheries.
Case Study 01:ShantaMariyom was married off at the age of 15 years. As early age, she was not matured enough to realize
about family life. After two years, husband divorced her and she came back to her father’s family. But she was not happy with
this family due to the manner of her brother’s wife. Sometimes, she tried to commit suicide but failed due to her pretty
baby.One day, she decided that she should come out in order to search a job and she went to Dhaka. Shanta said, “I searched
but failed and realized that employment is not easy for a woman.” Again, Shanta came back in her family and she decided to
be an entrepreneur. Shanta took some land as leased from local land lord and she started to cultivate potatoes by borrowing
some loans from a local NGO. Now, she is an independent woman and working as an elected representative of a local NGO.
Now-a-days, her husband wants to back her. However, Shanta said that, “When I was child my family gave marriage and I
didn’t realize my family, I couldn’t participate in family work and so they did not value me. Now I am self-sufficient and I have
an individual place,family members respect me and I have social values.
House Building:Among the women, 148 respondents expend from their taken loan in house building whose
mean and SD are 7.3685E4 and 1.07163E5 respectively ranging from 1500 to 5.00E5. 41.2 percent have spent
loan less than twenty five thousands while 14.2 percent have spent loan from twenty five thousand to fifty
thousand and 12.2 percent have from fifty thousand to seventy five thousands. Around 31.1 percent women
have total expenditure of loan more than one lac in livestock and fisheries. The expenditure of 1.4 percent
women in house building is seventy five thousand taka to one lac.
Small entrepreneurship and trade: Among the women, 28 respondents expend from their taken loan in small
entrepreneurship and trade whose mean and SD are 6.2607E4 and 72031.04 respectively ranging from 5000 to
2.00E5. 50 percent have spent their loan less than twenty five thousands while 10.7 percent expend from twenty
five thousand to fifty thousand and 7.1 per cent have from fifty thousand to seventy five thousands. Around
32.1 percent women have total expenditure of loan more than one lac in small entrepreneurship and trade.
Own business purpose: Among the women, 66 respondents expend from their taken loan in own business
purpose whose current mean and SD are 7.0742E4 and 67094.67 respectively ranging from 1500 to 3.00E5.
25.8 percent have expend their loan less than twenty five thousands while 21.2 percent have spent loan
between twenty five thousand and fifty thousand and 18.2 per cent have from fifty thousand to seventy five
thousands. Around 31.8 percent women have total expenditure of loan more than one lac in own business
purpose. The expenditure range of 3.0 percentage women in house building is seventy five thousand taka to one
lac.
Education: Among the women, 74 respondents expend from their taken loan in education whose mean and SD
are 2.4635E4 and 35889.04 respectively ranging from 1000 to 2.00E5.74.3 percent have expend their loan less
than twenty five thousands while 10.8 percent have spent loan from twenty five thousand to fifty thousand and
2.7 per cent have from fifty thousand to seventy five thousand. Around 12.2 percent women have total
expenditure of loan more than one lac in education.
Daughters’ marriage purpose: Among the women, 49 respondents expend from their taken loan in daughters‟
marriage purpose whose mean and SD are 1.0913E5 and 3.53474E5 respectively ranging from 2000 to 2.50E6.
32.7 percent have spent their loan less than twenty five thousands while 12.2 percent have from twenty five
thousand and fifty thousand and 24.5 per cent have from fifty thousand to seventy five thousands. Around 28.6
percent women have total expenditure of loan more than one lac in daughters‟ marriage purpose. The
expenditure range of 2.0 percentage women in daughters‟ marriage purpose is seventy five thousand taka to one
lac.
Income of women
Selling Vegetables:Table 1.3 also describes the yearly income of women. Among the women, 88 respondents
yearly earned by selling vegetables such as potato, spinach etc. whose mean and SD are 1.9745E4 and 37730.76
respectively ranging from 300 to 3.00E5.77.3 percent have yearly income less than twenty five thousands while
11.4 percent have income from twenty five thousand to fifty thousand and 8.0 per cent have from fifty thousand
to seventy five thousands. The income of 2.3 percent women from selling vegetables is more than one lac. The
income range in selling vegetables of 1.1 percentage women is seventy five thousand taka to one lac.
Other agriculture related activities (rice, wheat etc.): Table 1.3 shows that yearly income of 73 women from
other agriculture related activities such as rice, wheat etc. whose mean and SD are 1.9745E4 and 20824.66
respectively ranging from 2000 to1.20E5. 65.8 percent have yearly earned less than twenty five thousands while
24.7percent have earned between twenty five thousand and fifty thousand and 8.2 per cent have from fifty
thousand to seventy five thousands. Around 1.4 percent women have earned money more than one lac from
other agriculture related activities (rice, wheat etc.).
Livestock (Cow and Goat): Among the women, 83 respondents yearly income from selling livestock (Cow
and Goat) whose mean and SD are 2.9118E4 and 26511.59 respectively ranging from 3000 to 2.00E5. 54.2
percent have yearly income less than twenty five thousands while 24.1 percent have earned between twenty
five thousand and fifty thousand and 19.3 per cent have from fifty thousand to seventy five thousands. Total
income of 1.2 percent women from livestock (Cow and Goat) is more than one lac. The income range from
livestock (Cow and Goat) of 1.2 percentage women is seventy five thousand taka to one lac.
Table 1.3: Information about loan, expenditure of loan and income of women
Information about loan, expenditure of loan and income of women
100000≤
<25000
100000
25000-
50000-
75000-
50000
75000
N Mean SD Rang
% % % % %
Amount of loan
Current amount of loan 270 63.8 19.9 11.1 0.7 4.4 2.6778E4 29504.64 1500-3.00E5
Total amount of loan 282 20.9 13.1 17.0 6.7 42.2 1.5454E5 2.39874E5 2500-1.50E6
Expenditure of loan
Agriculture and forestry 211 41.7 16.1 19.4 2.4 20.4 5.2488E4 1.10627E5 1000-1.50E6
Livestock and fisheries 87 48.3 18.4 14.9 - 18.4 4.6885E4 59874.52 3000-3.00E5
Processing and manufacturing 37 56.8 5.4 21.6 - 16.2 4.0784E4 48315.59 5000-2.00E5
Shop keeping 68 47.1 19.1 16.2 17.6 4.4956E4 52076.99 1000-2.00E5
House building 148 41.2 14.2 12.2 1.4 31.1 7.3685E4 1.07163E5 1500-5.00E5
Small entrepreneurship/trade 28 50.0 10.7 7.1 32.1 6.2607E4 72031.04 5000-2.00E5
Own Business purpose 66 25.8 21.2 18.2 3.0 31.8 7.0742E4 67094.67 1500-3.00E5
Education 74 74.3 10.8 2.7 12.2 2.4635E4 35889.04 1000-2.00E5
Daughters marriage purpose 49 32.7 12.2 24.5 2.0 28.6 1.0913E5 3.53474E5 2000-2.50E6
Income of women
Selling Vegetables 88 77.3 11.4 8.0 1.1 2.3 1.9745E4 37730.76 300-3.00E5
Other agriculture related 73 65.8 24.7 8.2 1.4 1.9562E4 20824.66 2000-1.20E5
activities (rice, wheat etc.)
Livestock (Cow and Goat) 83 54.2 24.1 19.3 1.2 1.2 2.9118E4 26511.59 3000-2.00E5
Livestock (Cocks and duck) 57 87.7 8.8 3.5 1.0285E4 13758.23 40-60000
Day labor 12 58.3 25.0 8.3 8.3 2.5338E4 34621.82 150-1.08E5
(Field Survey 2017)
Livestock (Cocks and duck): Among the women, 57 respondents yearly income by selling livestock (Cocks
and duck) whose mean and SD are 1.0285E4 and 13758.23 respectively ranging from 40 to 60000. 87.7 percent
women yearly earn money less than twenty five thousands while 8.8 percent earn money between twenty five
thousand and fifty thousand and 3.5 per cent have from fifty thousand to seventy five thousands.
Day labor: Table 1.3 shows that 12 women yearly earn as day laborer whose mean and SD are 2.5338E4 and
34621.82 respectively ranging from 150 to 1.08E5. 58.3 percent have yearly earned less than twenty five
thousands while 25 percent have income level between twenty five thousand and fifty thousand and 8.3 per cent
have earned from fifty thousand to seventy five thousands. Around 8.3 percent women have earned more than
one lac as day laborer. So, all the following statistical analysis shows that NGOs is working like a catalyst in
pursuing all the variables of women empowerment of that study area.
Case Study 03: This is Lipi Akter. At the beginning of my family life, I had to endure a lot of abuse. I would not dare to give an
opinion.I did not have any income at the time. I did not have any work other than cooking. To remove the situation I took loan
from NGO.I brought a sewing machine through the loan money. Since then I started to make little income.I am happy about my
income. From the profit of sewing machine I paid my loan.I am very happy to contribute to the world a little bit. My family has
no problem. My child is now going school and I am able to pay tuition of my child. My husband and his family now does not
torture me.My husband has given priority of me in all family matters now. I can participate in making decision of my family
and have own opinion about my children.
Information about women’s income, expenditure, voting activities and household decision
Women empowerment is related to some indicator and variable like income, investment and capability of
expenditure of women. In that context, some question raised in mind that, either women have independence to
engage herself with income generating activities or not,either women are capable enough to expend her income
independently or not, either women have independence in practicing their voting rights in local election or
influenced by their male counterpart, either male member of family take any opinion from female member or
women don‟t have any influence on house-hold affairs. If that question indicates positive feedback then it will
be significant behind empowerment of women.The table1.6 represent that women were divided into two groups
to give their opinion regarding that inquiry.183 respondents‟ claimed that they have independence to engage
themselves in income generating activities, what represents 64.9 %,they also acknowledge that NGO have
contributed in that context. In opposite, number of 99 respondents (out of 282) shared that they can‟t participate
in income generating activities by their own opinion,82 female respondents‟ acknowledged that they are capable
enough to expend their own money and they can give their own opinion, they are not being influenced by male
members of family, which represents 29.1%.In opposite, number of 200 respondents (Out of 282) claimed that
they have not capability to expend their income independently, which represents 70.9%,their opinion have not
usually been taken by their male counterparts. Number of 218 respondents‟ share that they can practice their
voting rights as they want and they are not being influenced by another family member, what represents 77.3
%,in opposite, only 64 respondents (22.7%) claimed that they are influenced by other family members, they also
add that program of voting behavior run by NGOs raised their consciousness, that also indicates empowerment
of women. In that survey, we found that,270 respondents ,acknowledged that they can give their opinion in
household affairs which represents 97.7 %, but 12 respondents (only 4.3%) claimed that ,they are being
dominated by male counterparts in household management, and their opinion don‟t have any value in household
matters, and they can‟t influence decision making of family. In comparison with two opinions regarding income,
investment, expenditure and voting rights of women, we can say that, there have a positive trends and it have
been changing positive way towards empowerment of women, and NGO have been contributing behind that
changing scenery of women empowerment.
Table 1.6: Information about income, expenditure and voting activities (N-282)
Yes No
Indicator of empowerment
Frequency Percent Frequency Percent
Engagement with income generating activities 183 64.9 99 35.1
Capability of expending income independently 82 29.1 200 70.9
Independence in voting practice in local election 218 77.3 64 22.7
Having opinion in house-hold affairs 270 95.7 12 4.3
(Field Survey 2017)
The following statistical data have been collected from field survey. In table 1.7 presents that who influence the
expenditure of women, where we observe that, some male members‟ like-husband, father, son etc. influence in
expenditure. Among the total respondents,123 respondents‟ acknowledged that their expenditure have been
influenced by her husbands, what represents 61.5%, 50 respondents‟ said their father influenced in their
expenditure that represents 25 %, number of 7 respondents‟ shared that their expenditure influenced by their
son, what represents 3.5 % and at last, 20 respondents‟ shared their expenditure influenced by other male
DOI: 10.9790/0837-2203032542 www.iosrjournals.org 35 | Page
Women’s Empowerment through NGOs Intervention: A Socio-economic Assessment of Rural Area in Rangpur
members of family, what represents 10%. The following table clearly describe that there have acute lack of
intendance in expending money by women‟s own choice and also there have a silent patriarchal structure exists
in that rural areas of Rangpur, where husband played a vital role in that context. But it is positive that,
expenditure of women is in increasing rate that means women are getting engaged in income generating
activities and their income level get higher.
The right side of table 1.7 describe the nature of influence of political behavior of women, where we observed a
comparatively positive trend of women empowerment, because, less than 50% respondents acknowledge that
,their political behavior have been influenced by male members of family. Data collected from 64 respondents,
only number of 39 respondents‟ acknowledged that, their political behavior have been influenced by their
husbands, what represents 60.9%. 21 respondents‟ acknowledged that their political behavior influenced by their
father, what represents 32.8 %,political behavior of 2 respondents have been influenced by their son, what
represents only 3.1% and number of 2 respondents said their political behavior influenced by other family
member of family except husband, father and son, what represents 3.1%.
Case Study 04: My name is Tajmin. I have studied at primary school. My husband was working for others land. We haven't
any peace of my family because of lower income of my husband. There always remain quarrel at simple matters. We have
two children. But we couldn't fulfill their desires. After taking loan we have a small grocery shops and we buy a sewing
machine. My husband started working at Grocery shops and i am at home making clothes. After some days, we started to
earn. There brings happiness in our life. Money problem become solved. Then, my husband and my children's are very
happy to me. Now i can send my children's to school. My husband supports me at my every work. He takes my opinion in
doing something new. We have always discuss about any work. Now we are a happy family. "
Findings of the statistical analysis proved that, NGO works a lot to make women conscious about their political
rights by throwing different types of program, and less number of women are influenced by male members that
is also the positive sign of women empowerment, they can take their decisions about political affairs by their
own choice.
Table 1.7: Information on influence on expenditure and political behavior of women
Influence on expenditure Influence on political
of women (N-200) behavior of women (N-64)
Frequency Percent Frequency Percent
Husband 123 61.5 39 60.9
Father 50 25.0 21 32.8
Son 7 3.5 2 3.1
Other male members of the family 20 10.0 2 3.1
Total 200 100.0 64 100.0
(Field Survey 2017)
Giving opinion in household matter
Following table 1.8 shows that husband took opinion from women related to some family affairs, frequency of
respondents and their percentage also presented in that table. 218 respondents said that husbands took their
opinion from wife regarding the matters of using loan taken from NGO, what represents the percentage of
77.3%. 225 respondents acknowledges that their husbands took their own opinion regarding decision of cooking
food today what represents the percentage of 79.8%,215 respondents acknowledges that their husbands took
their own opinion regarding decision on health care what represents the percentage of 76.2%, 209 respondents
acknowledged that their husbands took their own opinion regarding decision on going shopping what represents
the percentage of 74.1%,199 respondents acknowledges that their husbands took their own opinion regarding
decision on giving votes what represents the percentage of 70.6%,164 respondents said that their husbands
took their own opinion regarding decision on supporting political parties what represents the percentage of
58.2%,210 respondents said that their husbands took their own opinion regarding livelihood expenditure what
represents the percentage of 74.5%,210 respondents said that their husbands took their own opinion regarding
buying livestock‟s what represents the percentage of 74.5%,243 respondents‟ said that their husbands took
their own opinion regarding children‟s education what represents the percentage of 86.2% and 201 respondents
said that their husbands took their own opinion regarding buying livestock what represents the percentage of
71.3%.
Case Study 05: I am educated woman but at a time,I was unemployed woman.So, I did not have a respectable place in my
family.They always neglected me and I was broken-heart women and I felt shame but I did not try to do something. One day my
friend suggested to do something and informed me about micro-credit program of NGO. According to her suggestion, one day,I
took some loan and my husband cooperated me to start a hatchery business. By taking training about small business from rural
NGOs, now I am capable enough to run a hatchery .My family and society now show respect me for my self-sufficiency and
some unemployed village women come to know about my story and try to encourage them to be self-independent. However, I
feel so much happy because one day I would search work but now I have recruited some employs in my business. I want to be
thankful to NGO and also to my husband for cooperation.
230 respondents said that their husbands took their own opinion regarding agriculture what represents the
percentage of 81.6%, 206 respondents said that their husbands took their own opinion regarding children‟s
marriage purpose what represents the percentage of 73.0%,213 respondents said that their husbands took their
own opinion regarding construction of house what represents the percentage of 75.5%,218 respondents said
that their husbands took their own opinion regarding other family affairs what represents the percentage of
77.3%. The study finds that the good number of husband within good percentage are taking opinion from wife
regarding different family affairs, that is the positive sign of women empowerment, also NGO was a catalyst
behind that changes. The awareness building program offered by NGOs encouraged women to raise their voice
in household management and they can take part in decision making of family by their own opinion.
awareness building initiative in rural area.The rural women‟s access to credit, especially micro-credit has not
only facilated their entry into paid work, but also helped them in undertaking micro-enterprise development
programs, thus increasing their autonomy, enhancing their economic and social status. Another positive impact
of micro-credit is that it is key to poverty reduction in rural area as like rural area of Rangpur. And this study in
Rangpur also analyses that, loan from NGOs have not yet ensured economic and political empowerment of
women in real meaning, and also, women‟s control over resources, bargaining power and decision making
power about household management has not been increased in expected level and sometimes influenced by male
members of family. But the study found that, trend is changing, women are going to be more independent in
utilizing their loan money that is positive sign of women empowerment. Objectives and findings of this study
have consistency.Loan from NGOs is a catalyst that can enhance women empowerment in rural area as like
Rangpur. But the study found that, a patriarchal culture and power-structure domination has been in existence in
rural society since long.In the context of control over loan money, women borrower gets limited power in
decision making where it is using. Husbands or male members are seen to control loan money and their decision
is superior in using money. However, micro-credit program helps to women join income generating activities.
so far as they are contributing to family income women borrowers also get bargaining capacity in family
decision making because they are now aware about their rights and roles, also they are now conscious about
their political rights, though sometimes their political behavior influenced by male members. Progress among
the women can be analyzed by observing the gender relations with their husbands.Though present situation can
not present the real scenery of women empowerment, but in broad sense with the cooperation of NGOs women
empowerment is increasing in slowly, not only in Rangpur but also in whole Bangladesh.
1) As the term of women‟s empowerment consist of 3 ingredients (a) husbands discuss their wives in
household matter (b) physical movement outside the house and in matters of spending money and (c)
decision-making power, that emphasis should be given from two sides-women should be aware of raising
their voice to have their own rights and to establish their control over their resources and income, also NGO
should provide some training and knowledge to men/husband and to make men more concern, what type of
women community should have and the cooperation of men should ensure, because gender relations is
important to empower women in better way.
2) Third world country like Bangladesh, the involvement of general mass in income generating activities is
required at all levels, especially home-based and village based entrepreneur-ship development. It is
evident that the entrepreneurship development program and empowerment are correlated and women
empowerment depends on taking part in different development activities. Women should be engaged in
market- based mainstream economy through building up entrepreneurship.
3) Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) can frequently play a significant role in supporting for changes
in law, policy and establishment rules in favor of empowering women. NGO can also be a catalyst to start
campaign for political awareness and education for women.
4) NGO should give more emphasis on diverting women into political field, if they encourage women to
participate politics and provide more training to make them aware about their political rights, then
leadership quality will be flourished among themselves, that‟s why NGO should Support the rise of women
leaders across all sectors, then they will be capable to lead the society, can do something for ensuring
women empowerment.
5) NGO should provide more training to increase women's access to educational opportunities, especially
those sectors in rural area which is most relevant to a sustainable economy, then women empowerment will
be enhanced.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
[1] Al-Amin,M.,Chowdhury,T.(2008), Women,Poverty and Empowerment: An Investigation into the Dark Side of Microfinance. Asian
Affairs, 30(2),pp-16-29
[2] Amin, R. S., Becker, & Bayes, A. (1998). NGO Promoted Micro-Credit Programs and Women‟s Empowerment: Quantitative and
Qualitative Evidence. The Journal of Developing Areas, 32(1).
[3] Armenda‟riz de Aghion., Morduch,J. (2005).The economics of microfinance. Cambridge: MIT Press.
[4] Bangladesh Population Census-2001, Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics; Cultural survey report of MithapukurUpazila 2007.
[5]Batiwala, S.(1994) women‟s Empowerment in south Asia: concepts and practices, Food and Agricultural Organizations/Asia, South Asia
Bureau of Adult Education, New Delhi, India(FAO/ASPBAE).
[6] Bhuiyan, Mohammad Badruzzaman and Rubab Abdullah. 2007. “Women Empowerment Through Entrepreneurship Development:
Bangladesh Perspective.”Daffodil International University Journal of Business and Economics 2 (2): 136-137.
[7]Creswell, John W. 2003. Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Method Approaches. 3rd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Saga
publication.
[8]Creswell, John W., Plano Clark, and Vicki L. 2007. Designing and conducting mixed methods research. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
publication
[9] Coroline, Mooser (1995), Gender planning and Development: Theory, Practice and Training, ,pp-56-57.
[10] Duvendack,M.,Palmer-Jones,R.,Copestake,J.G.,HooperL,L. Loke& Rao,N.(2011).What is the evidence of the Micro-finance on the
wellbeing of the poor people? London: University Of London.
[11]Erickson, J.I., Hamilton, G.A., Jones, D.E., &Ditomassi, M. (2003). Measuring the impact of collaborative governance: Beyond
empowerment. Journal of Nursing Administration, 33(2), 96-104.
1
Md. Kazi Rezuan Hossain
Lecturer, Department of Political Science, Begum Rokeya University, Rangpur
Email: [email protected]
2
Muhammad Anwar Hossain
Lecturer, Department of Sociology, Begum Rokeya University, Rangpur.
Email: [email protected]
3
Mahmuda Khatun
Former Student of Political Science, Chittagong University, Chittagong.
Email:[email protected].