Let's Get Started: Unit 3
Let's Get Started: Unit 3
LECTURE 12 : M - estimation
Hi there,
Following are my notes for the lecture. These are my handwritten detailed notes. I felt that Prof. R
taught a lot more in the videos than he wrote in the slides. I tried to make them without any
mistakes and cover most of the video material.
I however DO NOT TAKE any responsibilty if you fail your exams following my notes. So please
check the actual lecture slides and videos if you suspect something is wrong.
The notes DO NOT CONTAIN solutions to any homework problems.Only the problems and
exercises solved in the videos are included in these notes.
-Ilrr,
is 1 caru ask
tdea non: $to1y parornetevll.tat tvtteresh nne
luesfiot
tjke uvhal's lhe wwaft , varriartce., med,i6[, asT,luantle , Frobakrti{g
o1 X hetr,g gr.eatey*hayu o , ,Bkrare ne/A, qq-fl,r morv-ten*, etc.
NoU" +hat a\L ltne queshons, -fLke, vlelil, vox tytedhn . qqth monrevttelc.
crrw a\so be {ouna . a! rn}e hore *ne a:x-cict dis+rilcukon fe* #14}
sur daf& arrcl v ue url osltmaff- hem wi"ttr, P5 . L, uulmle
iwt
^e.rr';ro;\RA
)'t-a,st*attot v..le arc agproacrrrnl bamz problern' d*l*-h
LZ^Z
8o rare horne ot/Jd porome[ez d interesk ,t Ne sog .rt e )'[ ie { A *he set-
to urft1'q1n orv porarmeter -t boto-,aga ' I^le moke
g(X, 1) : A vandorr, functiorr, te o ravrdcrln, vanjable. (raecnr.tae i( a Junctt*
a a$ X ) ovtd. ttot€ thakil,s a yondorrrvcruob\e
finc*tma {. 1 noFvecfor
Nith .Hl,ir. p .toss {unckrn hrs cALc,rrlat e q,$ exgec\attbra atrud cqll tt Qt1)
oY,,1ieyLq(t =d
is ,ure l,tayre o.partamfu, 4 iv,,tertst .r1.Wu *Cu !g
/So rarhat vrre are dowrg
Sag,tvr6 4^Bl ,in ordL +o t i" true gavawe-)cer lust r'tirum'tae
^d .d
qlrt,l"= E [ ((x,1)] -t^i* is tnot *t,'e wre.thod'
(ne wrel{,tod {s ,lot' *he Paramekr o'+
t*t::t : {u-"*t'n'
1, -t* is mruinirn'rsed
*i$"c{t-n
(X, ti Alcl^ 'that 1We ex pectaUrru +
O
E xavrnples
j*t do asimple exornpte ',^" ha\^e 61 simgte rnandorvrvariobleX
Lek $tvSu
y\re harne a ovre d'rrnets't-lctL prameker 1 e 1n
hlhjcl^'A
E =B ond
otro-S*^b be & ' flence E=Jut=$'7
or.,t *lr,tr 'tunch"n
AovnBvwQ. g6mcs up {o us arrl, sa5r, fl**y
((*rt) = ().-r1) Y:ceK& tcts
-tl^rs tuwc.h"iz e>tf.cba#'sw
+\d ast<g \we, \^)l44t 1v,u,nl,,ruses
\ree ul|Lat '^"t^^*'sesu E [X-'1)"1
1
w uoVs do ib
lzullose )Me
PA{ *
X 'is fC*l i (*'e could h'aw'loket'r' thc pmf )
Qttl = E [(*-t:"]
q (t =
JE ,*-t)" {t*r
d,c
t E^t) = ? [ t.-1rz
t
jcxt dx 1vr. tr,.le qra-ltorr is rnvr| rt. so ta.re
o1 Q\Jn cah- {ake- *lte ctev[vatr,re inside
G8(rl) = t (r.-
^P'frxr dx = Arr(-tt-r){rr.l ax = ,J (1-x) ft*l d'x
a1 a1
-Lt J
E JEE
'lu.rg tg ,1*"t 1, o at {= f
dx : o
J,,i-x)ftxr
Y
,tofi*,,a* -Jrc$">dx =o
ttr-]s ie I *{nrs is E[x]
{tug ts O o*,
4-- t*
E [ *-{l -o = r[xl -{ :+ {= rlxl
8, t?.e J.rr,"ch,on a({ E [t*-l )'] ts vnirurr*sed. ah t = E[X]
Lz.\
Noaf rue rno\ne oru *o ll, e vuex-t eXample
Here E =Bd ie X tS a d d.twrerrs,iana[ randorvlrector r-[e a c'stl.tmvr.
hxth d vandorvt vartalc\es 0.6 its elemenla
Tt tg atso tr,.^ .tfrdb ,1 € ).,1 and It= Rd 4e hhte paYotvne\cv a!,
iwtevvsL is "6tso oL rrech* (dx t)
Some ovle curr\eg 1o trs oncl eaysrT girneyotr *ha func*ton
z=. r Z-t
\z eEd
L
4
llztr| = z?nfi+zt* ' ,i
!6* 0.s \Ne lrtnov,c {"r cur probte'nr, X (vec\'or) e Rd
-r1 (v€cto/) € Frd
Lzts deno(c
(r) ?tlase dona[ crrutuga
t
X ,r{r
X {r as E [xtt)1
x (2) t
^)
6
a arrd so ow.
.ocl
lytesz Arc
a lu.St
(d)
Vaxiab\es tn &
X 1d upuntttt yton {hevehar,
been no latk { f [X,.!,1
12. 5
3o by the de{r6
"l LEuct"ideaw nsrrn,
p(x,{) = ll x-1ll )L = (>(rrltz:ag xd)T
,^t",tn -
2-
,t = (.r1r
1o)t
3(x,1)
P[X,4
-thtas a yarn-dorn vaxiable noL a lneel'raa
,.t )'
*his is o. {un"tcon "& -1 = (1r t\zt\, " -
a Qt,t) jt
arli L
a. E [(X(ir-
a.tj 4 )'] -28 t X
rjl
errch c,ornpcmeraf C VQtrl) ts zero at t= t*
t2"6
8 hrrnu \^)e f.*tty ha,,ne our ans1^1ef
Q
(.,t) E I e(x, 1) 1 = E I I x-,,tll'^] is,r,,,ui,u,vrised. at
(r)
E fxctll X
t+= E I xtz>1
^v?n.te
X x(z)
x ta)
L Elx("1)l
L?-t
t pdf
{hat q(t) -- f [f x-r1tl is {o be f *r.r.d
vniniywuizes
x be {,*t
"J oo
Gen
q'(51 = E,gl
t w,,^lt be i\ a.s i+ is u iw lea+ure exeycise "
#,.TI &
-(t- x) cc i$ rc< o
Q,t .> ig ca[ed, t?ue' cdzcL ]u'n"c*toa' d"X 'tf >L), o
12. 7
r
tl
.l t+ qt') 'ts tr^^t**! c,cr,r*inr.rou.l orl [a, bl
d,t
Qt1)
JJ =\ 6tt) ara,d difle-rerthable qlL (a, b) arn d :te ta, b)
tu
tl ) - 8(*)
el D'l'Y iti a iw 'tec-tuha ?-v't><sge
-@
1*
12" s
E [-t-,(x,
a fl.fe
1)l
Ot{gt/$€J{, dS
=Q(1)
ffi
ttt,* dd"A oll -these. caLc-,ilaHfl9, vn arno- *o reaUss 'll4a+ 'this ^rr',r'-ld'to1 *y
1:+owcle
sorl^e 'tnstghls 'ilnerrittcattS v*r,at goool u it i{
{. aorr+ knor: P
becoWe olt ea\orlo{torrs truc did {or Wr€-c"rw, rynediana
the l,es cara,
orrlg be conrp,trted knouring 4te dtstrib-r.rhorn IP. Bu* 't{taL lr 41rue v^aittu
\z,rolDtem
4 cto not knoul JP. -fvrolf n:\ 1. am doinn e-thrr,r-d*i6v1,s.
,{ko iI you nol-tce vxevle.r *ravvr +J,* bqr'n-irp
-t{ruf !.et\uvz haw we
j*r og es.[r^a-[tovrr . fe. r^re l',ave r.n,ni jorrned"[ *n1 o*):"w p.lors
. ltorn
*Vtes.^Pl€, dcba X,rXerXl----K* v\>z lrr'aw'
v{etL llr*\ i.s absrrt +o cwouge, , L i+
,"ntL 'truvotve our o\d recepre
{o--^.
K"$tu*-
\t
{*V.l,o{r'rn-,
h- A""Y^X* i
tz. q
> )"Snrdtort
we hlrtl cted rne Nre wv ts*trv"ator -i^ o"s 'tl^-e minirniser
4
Q" t1l ',= tZ f(x;,{)
4[ tf^. co-Lc.u\aUoa, h]e &Ld b** ffw .T.'{h"is*tv
t,uttl tlsr- nesulli
\
taut r^)€ trge +he roorcl eltpivicaL' as La\cuhtto'rn done rn sa,vrpte
.Eke , e*?*ical rned*an, e*?tical
QxL
evr,r,pirucal vneon luardite
I l) Consistanay
ep,mew\bzr {or
hle dicl -lhe cose + MLE . \'oe had" KL ( &*, Ft)
lho.l had c^. rzr,tntmuvrrr, at = 9* . VOe "?t li"d *he $rrvnu\ato $vd
'^$h^+
O
+
A P
n+ oo f
12. {c
It) No'rnal,ity,(syrngtottc
NorD r.u.steo.d, + hecalLin3 urhab nle dicl {r, the cose ol Uue , ,^4) dont we iusY
rrepeat,{o sse rnrhat l,uoggavtS
- > t^e 1:iyst step tnvotved {he. exg.msitr, ol g/txf ,{l axound ^t+ Jitt
csnvinievrce rnr rrtl\ use qlt{t = g/(xiri1:'r"* +^" raytcrr e,xpangisn hos
-{o do Nttt^, Y.V. 8i
"o*l"t^q
eit{) = glrt*) + (,t-{:g/r1*r+
-l
Tcrtce su mnaa+ttrn bolth sides t ott.g that 4hese toYvrtg tEltoreo\
97,'" .In"
(* teit{r r I gi 11*11
;:}'n ('' Vuxrri{fl)
+) [ (,'rr1*11)
"Ji [0,
(d)
JA( ,t Vqr(
A
^t n4o
E t ?;" t't*' I
Or ivtothev t^lords
.tfr, (t -
1n)
(d)
lnl a I 0, va,r l?{
EtgirL+)Jz
tq*l] i
-l a .)
Ir,. 1I
r--+ f,6 fis ts rchat Pr{ B. tatked otcoub 2 h}e see +he vq}dahce {ern,t, t}ua[ L .,
some function ρ : E × M → R, where M is the set of all possible values of the unknown
true parameter μ⃗ .
∗
2 2
∂ ρ ∂ ρ
⎡⎛ ⃗
(X1 , μ) … ⃗ ⎞⎤
(X1 , μ)
∂μ1 ∂μ1 ∂μ1 ∂μd
⎢⎜ ⎟⎥
⎢⎜ ⎟⎥
J = E [Hρ] = E ⎢⎜ ⎟⎥ (d × d)
⎢⎜ ⋮ ⋱ ⋮ ⎟⎥
⎢⎜ ⎟⎥
2 2
∂ ρ ∂ ρ
⎣⎝ ⃗
(X1 , μ) … ⃗ ⎠⎦
(X1 , μ)
∂μd ∂μ1 ∂μd ∂μd
∂ρ
⎡⎛ ⃗ ⎞⎤
(X1 , μ)
∂μ1
⎢⎜ ⎟⎥
⃗ ]
K = Cov [∇ρ (X1 , μ) = Cov ⎢ ⎜ ⎟⎥ (d × d) .
⎢⎜ ⋮ ⎟⎥
⎢⎜ ⎟⎥
∂ρ
⎣⎝ ⃗ ⎠⎦
(X1 , μ)
∂μd
2
∂ ρ
J (μ) = E[ (X1 , μ)]
2
∂μ
∂ρ
K (μ) = Var [ (X1 , μ)]
∂μ
12. r2
&vtsis*ency
,t^
A P
t4->6 t )k
r'rcn naaf]Y
{s5^np*o*ta -L
Jvt (
t t +
)
rd)
w+ q)
i(., rtt) K(t) (,{ )
ttne pa,ronnetev to
ro5ts "1 t
t. Gotu. : Sotve some eluot{ton +o $"d
'- f^voke some lnel*oti[+hat boundg I
,-, tuouna/c,o'rserva.*tvg
iw the vcrrionce berrru'
B. {Futg.irr' i Sdrstih'tte t
iI^' lLace 4{
72"LV
F Robus+ sLattsHoe I
S uppose we hovg some observotton' =.) !W* a stanclard elorr*iar.r"
Couchg Eosln\"rt*
d
lo
ll-.
-1
I
./)
I
12.15
Cauchy distribution
The Cauchy distribution, named after Augustin
Cauchy, is a continuous probability distribution. It is Cauchy
also known, especially among physicists, as the Probability density function
Lorentz distribution (after Hendrik Lorentz),
Cauchy–Lorentz distribution, Lorentz(ian)
function, or Breit–Wigner distribution. The
Cauchy distribution is the distribution of
the x-intercept of a ray issuing from with a
uniformly distributed angle. It is also the distribution
of the ratio of two independent normally distributed
random variables with mean zero.
PDF
Parameters location (real)
scale (real)
Support
PDF
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cauchy_distribution
12.16
The special case when and is called the standard Cauchy distribution with the
probability density function[4][5]
History
Functions with the form of the density function of the Cauchy distribution were studied by
mathematicians in the 17th century, but in a different context and under the title of the witch of
Agnesi. Despite its name, the first explicit analysis of the properties of the Cauchy distribution was
published by the French mathematician Poisson in 1824, with Cauchy only becoming associated with
it during an academic controversy in 1853.[2] As such, the name of the distribution is a case of
Stigler's Law of Eponymy. Poisson noted that if the mean of observations following such a
distribution were taken, the mean error did not converge to any finite number. As such, Laplace's use
of the Central Limit Theorem with such a distribution was inappropriate, as it assumed a finite mean
and variance. Despite this, Poisson did not regard the issue as important, in contrast to Bienaymé,
who was to engage Cauchy in a long dispute over the matter.
Mean
If a probability distribution has a density function , then the mean, if it exists, is given by
We may evaluate this two-sided improper integral by computing the sum of two one-sided improper
integrals. That is,
For the integral to exist (even as an infinite value), at least one of the terms in this sum should be
finite, or both should be infinite and have the same sign. But in the case of the Cauchy distribution,
both the terms in this sum (2) are infinite and have opposite sign. Hence (1) is undefined, and thus so
is the mean.[12]
Note that the Cauchy principal value of the mean of the Cauchy distribution is
is not zero, as can be seen easily by computing the integral. This again shows that the mean (1) cannot
exist.
Various results in probability theory about expected values, such as the strong law of large numbers,
fail to hold for the Cauchy distribution.[12]
Higher moments
The Cauchy distribution does not have finite moments of any order. Some of the higher raw moments
do exist and have a value of infinity, for example the raw second moment:
By re-arranging the formula, one can see that the second moment is essentially the infinite integral of
a constant (here 1). Higher even-powered raw moments will also evaluate to infinity. Odd-powered
raw moments, however, are undefined, which is distinctly different from existing with the value of
infinity. The odd-powered raw moments are undefined because their values are essentially equivalent
to since the two halves of the integral both diverge and have opposite signs. The first raw
moment is the mean, which, being odd, does not exist. (See also the discussion above about this.) This
in turn means that all of the central moments and standardized moments are undefined, since they
are all based on the mean. The variance—which is the second central moment—is likewise non-
existent (despite the fact that the raw second moment exists with the value infinity).
The results for higher moments follow from Hölder's inequality, which implies that higher moments
(or halves of moments) diverge if lower ones do.
3/13
Laplace distribution - Wikipedia
12.18
Laplace distribution
In probability theory and statistics, the Laplace
distribution is a continuous probability distribution Laplace
named after Pierre-Simon Laplace. It is also sometimes Probability density function
called the double exponential distribution, because
it can be thought of as two exponential distributions
(with an additional location parameter) spliced together
back-to-back, although the term is also sometimes used
to refer to the Gumbel distribution. The difference
between two independent identically distributed
exponential random variables is governed by a Laplace
distribution, as is a Brownian motion evaluated at an
exponentially distributed random time. Increments of
Laplace motion or a variance gamma process evaluated
over the time scale also have a Laplace distribution.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laplace_distribution
12. 11
F Hubev/s Logs
Ne wtll inlroduce *tue Huber/s Loss Junctiot lrr.5(x) , fhis is a good subs{iful'e
{or l?el as +}Lis fuvrc{twr con be d*}erenhated and drruble di$ferenhqted"
i^ contrask to l>cl . we wtll xee how the c[evivattw,s ld
2.5 t
,(.
f$ t:tl a S
2.0 h 5t,,)
t(rxt-*) i{ rxt> 5
1.5
1.0
0.5
-3 -2 -1 1 2 3
1.0
% it l)tl4 5
0.5
LJs tr.l +5 if x >6
-( 6 I
$
x<-t
-3 -2 -1 1 2 3
-0.5
-1.0
1.0
0.8
0.6
t 'T txl4 6
h"rt*l
0.4 o othevr^nse
0.2
-3 -2 -1 1 2 3
10 delta : 4
delta : 2
8
delta : 1.5
6 modulus of x
delta : 1
4
delta : 0.5
delta : 0.1
2
-4 -2 2 4
This is a comparison graph of |x| with Huber's function. See how the green one most closely resembles |x|
t2.zo
+ L(xr,XlrX3.,..Xn, m) = Jm
t
t
qVL
-E
gL
lx;-nn,l
- n logZ { tx;- rn \
) lr+ Ii keti hood' =
lD jh,t" exprrc,ssitrru rnrr* rY1. . on,d-
ane wext step is
ctaffete,ntto}e
+t,ot b.oo.,*L ol $.te q[getufe vaLueA ' But \dol-ltE nolr
hle co.n,t clo
\,rre har€ Une naethocl .t { - es*e m attcrn
axiu^uvt4, Jf ketlhaod es{imateozr
+ Suppose trrstead d. ealcuLattnl h
;
nle w outd Vrqr,e ' stated {h; problenzr' as Jottot+s
We havt soy)4e dtshd'b ut0on' 9
= rn,
UUhrfo vr,tlytivrrr,tsas E I eXrrn]J
tOl,rerf
L t)Yn) lx-ml * >t e-&
et = ueshan, . -Jl,rl,t tnc,r tt"e $*t
8, t^le kvtotrl +lrue ' cLrl,s hgev fo 'tlnas 1
exarnp\e ol eStrnaHurL .
lxi- vrn,\
3ut {h,ts is j*t -lt^p. mk-utcrtlsr,r *hat needed. fu M,
nrua2irmum ltkelihood Laso . \zwet l|rue )4cstwra+r:l, t* lx-nrl
t
aA hrcll ae {l're Mt E es*irraatov ,[ L (m,1) is
u ?Lx,m)=
mzd,.o,t" enrfric,ai .
h -
ts ttne egh,tato*ts lt'e evwpr-ica\ wtedtoru
t '"rf
Ne a\sokvtov.r ((*rrr^) = lx-ml here
'C^uttslst"^q b-__-__.+
F -.lr
r'tly', YN
n ----) oo
dmL
K (rn1 = Cov[v Q('n)] : Vqx I ('rr)l = V*t I (rn)]
t.,f
Nol,o hle haut. 4h"z Vroblevvt
"r*
trn. {-*r* ,* ug
* e('vra) d lr.
= dm jru* l>e
t '-- -ml r.ntt, ca,LcrLqted. aA
I
dm
a- ctosed frr.ra.red Sotrttr"orr"
and so car(t be -.|*-re duuble
cler[v attle
hle are g{uclc . dr.r, ts rotn e.re, err s L-,t^ c*rrlz
*** ff
,trruto pr\
12"L2
Ao tte harna e(x, m) = lx-rnl ond t,tle cavrit afJferenhate il ,be*us<
*ne funcli61 is naugh*y. C+ hqs a kink . And *he kink 'r,e prccisc-l;r
of tL= rrt rarhevre {:lne Jttncksvt ,t.s raoh eli{Jer+table . we &rc 't}.o*
\^erg flu.rpoEe hre I'r^o.rc, *he *lt;ehr-rrs
lm-x I
L"s hs(.)
we wtll use hg ( rn- x)
,L m a:tts
os it sl"u,{6 {he furucfrcrr {o ?n-
t rn- xt Jire rndtr'va*fcn l.,ere ,i the dsrivah.rne
Gt m = 2L is. hrett defined. . The doubte
h r(^- *l
derivattrae howeuer disesrdtngstrS
is discornttrulous at r,,,s t g and
x.
m a>qs =
nob f = frL ,Eo r,rrc ctWl
,ueed to
* orrg alao rt -+f4 +
5, LeL e(x,nru) .
=hg(x-m)
Here are ir,^"texfed trr
^E
t/)e know (m-x) 7- elerivahues wrt vy1,
a
d m- x (-6
T(m) = E t
t'
dnt
hs (m-x )
]=EIrtt--xrns)l
we know E ( r(a)) = t(a) So
Ttrn) = lP(lm-x|4s) : whiah caru he. co\cuta\zd. as f, ru
JJ*, t)
ylr+ E
Jtrm)= Jft,.rc{x
rn- [
m ^nS*
4tne frd$ is, symrnetri")o
( \ * haw,
m-$
= * J firtro- : . rut",*-*, dx
nn+ 6
T(rrt)
o a" 'o
> l((rrt) m+E
j (r-m)
K(m) e- 4x
- \/orc [ #ttm-x) ] 0
m+E
\tv/le mbev m
+hah e dx dx
m-X ; lm-x la L J
0
-d hlr,n-x; =[ t ; x (rn-[ = em L-e-x1m+t
dvn L* -6 o
; x)nt+6 (dI ,;'m"-s;
=- em
uets cqU Y - d \tg1nn-x)
drn L -e-6
valL(y) = E[y"l -Elyla So T(m*1= 1-t6
W* colculate eu,ch L s+e oy srup
m-6
Pot
t @
Elvl = j 6 ftx:dr +
rrc+
(m -cc) f(1)dx
- J 6 ft*l a*
-@
m-6 rn+ 6
Srl ftrrl
14 * vvl
>x
^4r' \ m+6
m+t m+t
m+t
Jtr-xlf
rn-
t)t) = rn j ft*:drc J
zt*t") rt^ttr__3_,FT.{
$
rn- t ,n- t L{"J
=e
rrt
e [v"] rn 5 rn- m+ t
(fi''?
@
e- (rn-x)
-(rm >t) dx + -
( x-m) e dx + (cc-m) I
z- -(:(-m)
e [v'1 = E, e dr *
L J ) .2_
-b 2- rn-E nL 2, rn+5
@ @
obtaira"ed
o @
By \€? rery rig oryous C,olc-uJatteryr
irn' UtaitheMaHcl 1nre hcrc
ry I^?''.t ti ^3 e,o,drr ex?r€si,isvt
s
=t & s"e-
1- ! (z+ tt + t") e E
t
t - a1, (z-+(6 + t")d
4.,
L, !"eI
2-€
t( 5
-1-s) t< 0v* )
E LYtl = C *@ *@n@ Q.
1.5
1.0
0.5
delta
-15 -10 -5 5 10 15
72_.L5
go rnre hone
t
Jn lmt m)
(d)
n+@ it ) Z(t-6e6-a L)
(t- e-t).
thte
know 6 r-s define Such *hat 8>o (ie
pos,"rfi\rre)
a ti* ['*
S-)o L
# * 1S' +
EL a
863
ts! - (s+ t) f n* I +t*{
rt rr 3L
+---.-.
L
1+ z6 n tf,* !S. . +1-z [,* 6 + 6' + 6.3
u *to 3t r! 2,t 31.
t
t2,26
St rtther stt^apfify
f(r-i,-
'"(*; t-il.
2 li- 5 ( a-rJ +
6-ro wr) h).
2-
+ s"(t,-h) s'(L3!- L\*
6 (
lto t) +
\ z\)
*"lL
\21
e- \
AL] + a\ I
g -L
b t3J ?rl\
z-r-
o
( ,")
2*I
{
I
[{, t )
4r.vg,er Huber( Logs : lnJe soid wG $^""1 r+t6 {.* h5trn-x) -= g (m,x)
d"v,tz wilL tate-r put S= o ara,d thsn A ,lartt\ be trngivtcat rnedia.ra, OA
Remember
(rn- x)' lm-x\S g
,
hs ( no- x)
\m-x\ ) 5
rnrherl 6 + O
he(m-X) : o. ,(
( \/n - Xl - z)\ =o
-0 m
0
d o \^re &re g+ac.k,., Bub not re at\Y
'(
^+ We wonter\to minirntge L U,5[m-xi)
i i ht(m-xi)
+ .sv ony 6 > o hle ccrvl s qS the minimtser h)il\ a\sovryrinr"rtue
i5
1e vr,r-tyrivnizing rwUrutrvttztnt
.m A,tt +
YVL
+ B* lln*'s vne*hod
4 vayv1 t vtae I ts
1r**
. Lzl{ Sza r.rfti
L?^"28
-
{\€ i*b tx- m\'
^e 2,
&fl^ rs e
is the $ot exornple ie r,..:hen ?(r, ,fr) = (x- ,n)'
-t4ne hA+ = ftx] :l6,?avL
eslinnatton ll K sannple qv€r
-'lk."
Jru (n Etxl) vv
(d)
1a
,il(o , L)
asy rrtpfoftc Vart ora'ce aE I \"Jhi le *h"e, vf&oll -had vard anes 2
,
8, MLE Chose wwdlan-.