Author's Accepted Manuscript: Seminars in Pediatric Neurology
Author's Accepted Manuscript: Seminars in Pediatric Neurology
Katherine Mackenzie
www.elsevier.com/locate/bios
PII: S1071-9091(17)30153-5
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spen.2017.12.004
Reference: YSPEN698
To appear in: Seminars in Pediatric Neurology
Cite this article as: Katherine Mackenzie, Stereotypic Movement Disorders,
Seminars in Pediatric Neurology,doi:10.1016/j.spen.2017.12.004
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for
publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version
of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and
review of the resulting galley proof before it is published in its final citable
form. Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered
which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the
journal pertain.
Stereotypic Movement Disorders
Katherine Mackenzie, MD
Katherine Mackenzie, MD, Division of Child Neurology, 750 Welch Road Suite 317,
Abstract
pathophysiology and management. Stereotypies are fixed and chronic movements. Stereotypies
begin before 3 years of age and continue into adulthood. Primary motor stereotypies occur in
additional diagnosis such as Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) or other neurologic disorders.
pathways. No genetic markers have been identified despite a clear genetic predisposition.
Behavioral therapy is the principle treatment. Future studies will focus on identifying genetic
markers, and on better understanding the functional and structural neurobiology of these
movements.
Introduction
Stereotypies are described as repetitive and purposeless movements that occur in a specific
pattern and are distractible.1 These movements tend to occur more at times of increased stress,
physiologic stereotypies or common behaviors) occur commonly in both children and adults.
These include leg shaking, hair twirling, and nail biting. Complex motor stereotypies are more
complex movements such as hand flapping, finger/arm wiggling, mouth opening, orofacial
movements, and body rocking.1 Alterations in breathing patterns or vocalizations may also
accompany the movements. Both types of stereotypies, simple and complex, are also divided
into two categories as either primary or secondary, depending on the presence of an additional
Children with stereotypies often report that these movements are a pleasant experience, and
may feel frustrated when parents and teachers interrupt them.4 One child described her
movements as follows, “it just feels right…sometimes I hold my hands by my side to stop the
movements but it doesn’t feel nice”.5 One theory is that the movements are a way of physically
expressing or dealing with excitement, or can be a way of coping with boredom (i.e. in both
under- and overstimulating environments).6 Older children and adults may learn to suppress
movements, or attempt to mask stereotypies with other purposeful movements, when in front of
others. A subset of children with stereotypies report episodes of intense imagery during their
movements, such as imagining that they are part of a video game or cartoon. 5 Self-injurious
behaviors are generally also considered to be complex motor stereotypies on a more severe
Primary simple motor stereotypies are reported to occur in roughly 20-70% of typically
roughly 3-4%.5, 8, 9, 10, 11 However, in children with developmental disabilities, the prevalence of
stereotypies is reported to be high at 61%, and is even higher in children with ASD at 88%.12
Complex motor stereotypies typically begin before 3 years of age, with peak onset around 12
months, and persist throughout adolescence and adulthood. 2,13 One study found that 80% of
children with stereotypies developed their movements before 24 months of age, with only 8%
Stereotypies also appear to be persistent throughout life. The largest longitudinal study of
children/adolescents with primary complex motor stereotypies (ages between 9-20 years old)
found that 98% of participants continued to have stereotypies but roughly 80% reported that
they were improved/more manageable with older age.13 An earlier 2008 study by this group
reported that of the 98 children surveyed, only 6% experienced resolution of their stereotypy.
Resolution was more likely if the child’s primary stereotypy was head nodding (38% of head
nodding resolved).2
disorder and with normal intelligence. The term “Secondary Stereotypies” refers to stereotyped
movements that occur in the setting of an additional diagnosis such as ASD, intellectual
disability delay, sensory delays, or genetic disorders such as Rett syndrome, Lesch-Nyhan,
Cornelia de Lange, Angelman syndrome, and Fragile X syndrome.14,15 There is also a known
association of adult onset disorders and stereotypies, including Frontotemporal Dementia and
Children with sensory deficits such as blindness have a high incidence of stereotypies. Part of
is based on this observation. For example, one study reported an incidence of stereotypy in
blind children of roughly 70%, and included the following in order of frequency: body rocking
(30%), repetitive handling of objects (31%), hand and finger movements (28%), and eye
pressing and eye poking (31%). They also noticed an increase in stereotypies with decreased
environmental stimulation and increased restriction.18 Another study found that 100% of the 85
blind children surveyed performed stereotyped movements (eye poking, body rocking, etc.) that
increased during times of “monotony, arousal, demand, and during feeding or eating”. 19
There are 3 main care-giver based rating scale questionnaires that can be helpful in evaluating
stereotypies in children that are based on care-giver reporting: 1) Motor Stereotypy Severity
Scale/SSS (see Table 2 for description20) broken down into three components: SSS Motor
and a Linear Analog Scale 21,22 2) Repetitive Behavior Scale (see Table 3 for description23,24)
with six subscales to assess for stereotyped behavior, self-injurious behavior, compulsive
behavior, ritualistic behavior, sameness behavior, and restricted behavior 23,24,,25,26 and 3)
Behavior Problems Inventory/BPI (see Table 4 for description27,28) with three subscales for
DSM-V criteria is the finding that the movement “interferes with social, academic, or other
activities and may result in self-injury”. As such, it is important for clinicians to discuss with
parents and patients whether these movements are causing interference in daily activities. In
addition, evaluation for other neurologic/psychiatric comorbidities (Table 6), that can be
associated with stereotypies, is an important part of the evaluation process. Many of these
comorbidities are also understood to involve dysfunction of the fronto-striatal circuits in the
brain. One large study identified comorbidities in roughly 90% of children surveyed based on
(63%), tics (22%), OCD (35%), and anxiety (73%).13 Another study of children with the
diagnosis of primary complex motor stereotypy found that 1/3 had symptoms of Developmental
Coordination Disorder, defined as learning and execution of coordinated motor skills below
expected level for age.3,29 The parents of these children also reported more symptoms of
Differential Diagnosis:
A frequent question from referring physicians to pediatric neurology clinics is whether these
movements could represent a seizure or a motor tic. Through a careful history, review of home
videos, and observation in the clinical setting, these diagnoses can generally be distinguished
Parents and teachers often raise concerns that stereotypies could be seizures. The semiology
of the movements typically points towards the appropriate diagnosis. Distinguishing features of
boredom. Conversely, seizures are not typically triggered by a change in emotions, attention, or
cognitive tasks. The ability to redirect a child or interrupt the movements is also a key
may also be helpful in that stereotypies can happen many times a day, whereas most seizures
are less frequent and tend to occur in discreet episodes with a relatively clear on and off timing.
Motor tics are frequently confused with stereotypes. Motor tics involve a preceding undesired
sensation that is relieved once the movement is completed. This phenomenon is not described
experience for children when performed. It is not uncommon for a child with stereotypies to
Tics also tend to involve discreet muscle groups in a specific repetitive pattern (blink and then
head nod to the right, blink and then head nod to the right), whereas stereotypies can be more
variable from movement to movement (hand rotational movements change to arm flapping with
body rocking). Additional clues to help distinguish between these two types of movements
include age of onset. Tics tend to present in children older than 3 years of age, whereas the
average age of presentation for stereotypies almost always begin before 3 years of age. Tics
often change over time, whereas stereotypies tend to be the same throughout a person’s
lifetime. Both tics and stereotypies are suppressible, at least temporarily, but tics are usually
internally suppressed whereas stereotypies are externally suppressed (i.e. by the parent or
teacher). Both movements improve with specific behavioral therapy but are only indicated if the
movements are impairing the child. Medications can be helpful in modulating tics, whereas
medication trial results have been disappointing in reducing stereotypies. Primary differences
overstimulation given that they are a side effect from dopaminergic drugs such as
regions also play a role in modulating and suppressing stereotypies.33 Y-aminobutyric acid
(GABA) also appears to play a role. A recent imaging study also showed a correlation of
decreased striatal and anterior cingulate cortex GABA levels with increased complex motor
stereotypies in children.34
MRCPS seen in the prefrontal cortex prior to voluntary movements were absent prior to
stereotypies.35
Structural brain imaging studies have reported various differences in the brains of people with
stereotypies as well. For example, one study of adult males reported decreased frontal white
matter and caudate nuclei volume in participants with stereotypies.36 Another study reported
smaller sized putamen.37 There are also some case reports of focal lesions resulting in
stereotypies. One woman with a unilateral lentiform nucleus stroke developed parkinsonism and
stereotypies that improved with pimozide.38 Another study reported stereotypies and autistic
stereotypies. Reports of a positive family history have ranged between 17-39 %, the majority of
whom are first-degree relatives.2, 13, 40, 41 To date, no specific genes have been identified in
stereotypies but current research is focused on specific genes with known links to Autism
Management
The majority of stereotypies does not cause significant physical or emotional distress, and often
do not require intervention. For stereotypies that are bothersome, habit reversal therapy can be
successful in reducing their severity and frequency.43 In the classroom or home setting,
response interruption and redirection when performed regularly and consistently can also be
For children with secondary stereotypies and self-injurious behavior, pharmacotherapy may be
demonstrated efficacy in reducing stereotypy for children with Autism. 46,47,48 However, there are
longitudinal study of children with primary complex motor stereotypy reviewed medications
prescribed for other comorbidities such as ADHD or OCD, and found that no difference in
stereotypy severity was reported by patients while taking medications that included
Motor stereotypies are relatively common in childhood and can occur with or without additional
stereotypies tend to present in early childhood and often do not change over a person’s lifetime.
yet been identified despite a known increased incidence of stereotypies among family members
with these movements. Most primary stereotypies do not require treatment, but habit reversal
training can be effective for children who desire help in reducing their movements. However, for
children with secondary stereotypies (i.e. other neurodevelopmental disorders) and self-injurious
Table 1.
Examples of Stereotypies
Leg shaking
Thumb sucking
Nail biting
Teeth clenching/grinding
Hand/arm waving
Finger wiggling
Mouth opening
Orofacial movements
Table 2.
Motor Stereotypy Severity Scale/SSS. 20
Number 0 None
1 Single stereotypy
2 2-5 discrete stereotypies
3 >5 discrete stereotypies
Frequency 0 Never
1 Rarely Not daily
2 Occasionally Daily, but infrequent
3 Frequent Daily, multiple times per day
4 Very Frequent Virtually every hour
5 Always Few if any, stereotypy-free intervals
Intensity 0 Absent
1 Minimal Minimally forceful compared to voluntary actions and not visible
2 Mild Not more forceful than comparable voluntary actions and not usually noticed
3 Moderate More forceful than comparable voluntary actions and call attention to
individual
4 Marked More forceful than comparable voluntary actions, exaggerated, and call
attention
5 Severe Extremely forceful and exaggerated, call attention, may cause physical
injury
Global 0 None
Impairment 10 Minimal Associated with subtle difficulties in self-esteem, family, school, or social
acceptance
Rating 20 Mild Associated with minor problems in self-esteem, family, school, or social
acceptance
30 Moderate Associated with clear problems in self-esteem, family, school, or social
acceptance
40 Marked Associated with major difficulties in self-esteem, family, school, or social
acceptance
50 Severe Associated with extreme difficulties in self-esteem, family, and severely
restricted life
because of social stigma and school avoidance
Table 3.
Repetitive Behavior Scale – Revised Subscales (43 item questionnaire for parents). 23, 24
Stereotyped Behavior
Self-injurious Behavior
Compulsive Behavior
Ritualistic Behavior
Sameness Behavior
Restricted Behavior
Table 4.
Behavior Problems Inventory 27, 28
SELF INJURIOUS BEHAVIOR
1. Self-biting (so hard that a tooth print can be seen for some time; bloodshot or breaking of skin may occur)
2. Hitting head with hand or other body part (e.g., face slapping, knee against forehead) or with/against objects (e.g., slamming
against a wall, knocking head with a toy)
3. Hitting body (except for the head) with own hand or with any other body part (e.g., kicking self, slapping arms or thighs), or
with/against objects (e.g., hitting legs with a stick, boxing the wall)
4. Self-scratching (so hard that reddening of the skin becomes visible; breaking of the skin may also occur)
5. Vomiting and rumination (deliberate regurgitation of swallowed food with rumination)
6. Self-pinching (so hard that reddening of the skin becomes visible; breaking of the skin may occur)
7. Pica: Mouthing or swallowing of objects which should not be mouthed or swallowed for health or hygiene reasons (non-food items
such as feces, grass, paper, garbage, hair)
8. Inserting objects in body openings (in nose, ears, or anus, etc.)
9. Pulling finger or toe nails
10. Inserting fingers in body openings (e.g., eye poking, finger in anus)
11. Air swallowing resulting in extended abdomen
12. Hair pulling (tearing out patches of hair)
13. Extreme drinking (e.g., more than 3 liters per day)
14. Teeth grinding (evidence of ground teeth)
15. Other: ……………………………………………….
STEREOTYPED BEHAVIOR
16. Rocking back and forth
17. Sniffing objects
18. Spinning own body
19. Waving or shaking arms
20. Rolling head
21. Whirling, turning around on spot
22. Engaging in repetitive body movements
23. Pacing
24. Twirling things
25. Having repetitive hand movements
26. Yelling and screaming
27. Sniffing own body
28. Bouncing around
29. Spinning objects
30 Having bursts of running around
31. Engaging in complex hand and finger movements
32. Manipulating objects repeatedly
33. Exhibiting sustained finger movements
34. Rubbing self
35. Gazing at hands or objects
36. Maintaining bizarre body postures
37. Clapping hands
38. Grimacing
39. Waving hands
40. Other ....................................................................
AGGRESSIVE/DESTRUCTIVE BEHAVIOR
41. Hitting others
42. Kicking others
43. Pushing others
44. Biting others
45. Grabbing and pulling others
46. Scratching others
47. Pinching others
48. Spitting on others
49. Being verbally abusive with others
50. Destroying things (e.g., rips clothes, throws chairs, smashes tables)
51. Being mean or cruel (e.g., grabbing toys or food from others, bullying others)
52. Other: ….............................................
Parents are asked to quantify Frequency (0=Never, 1=Monthly, 2= Weekly, Daily=3, Hourly=4)
and Severity (Mild=1, Moderate=2, Severe=3)
A. Repetitive, seemingly driven, and apparently purposeless motor behavior (e.g., hand
shaking or waving, body rocking, head banging, self-biting, hitting own body).
B. The repetitive motor behavior interferes with social, academic, or other activities and
obsessive-compulsive disorder).
Table 6.
ADHD
Anxiety
OCD
Tics
Learning Disorders
Table 7.
Tics Stereotypy
Enjoyable No Yes
and Redirection
Dopamine Antagonists
Monoamine Depleters
References