Explainer: What Are The Pandora Papers?
Explainer: What Are The Pandora Papers?
Leaked files from 14 offshore service providers tie more than 330 public
officials, including 35 world leaders, to offshore fortunes.
The millions of leaked confidential files linked more than 330 politicians to hidden fortunes worth
billions of dollars [Reuters]
1
The leaked records come from 14 offshore services firms from around
the world – from Vietnam to Belize to Seychelles.
The team also verified the information from the 2.94-terabyte haul by
cross-referencing it to public records from dozens of countries.
The ICIJ found that the documents were linked to more than 330
politicians and public officials, including 35 current and former
national leaders, in more than 91 countries and territories.
2
Are offshore companies illegal?
Setting up offshores companies to do business is not in itself illegal,
the ICIJ stressed, as some people might have legitimate reasons to
keep their finances secret.
3
But such entities have often proven to be attractive as they can
facilitate tax evasion and money laundering.
The Papers also listed Kenya’s President Uhuru Kenyatta and his
mother as beneficiaries of a secretive foundation in Panama.
4
Offshore system
Besides unveiling the financial dealing of hundreds of world leaders
and celebrities, the investigation put the spotlight on the offshore
system itself, with the US emerging as a big player in the offshore
world.
South Dakota, the files show, emerged as the US state with the largest
number of trusts – a financial mechanism used often to avoid or
greatly reduce taxation.
The Pandora Papers are the latest in a series of mass ICIJ leaks of
financial documents, from LuxLeaks in 2014, to the 2016 Panama
Papers, which triggered the resignation of the prime minister of
Iceland and paved the way for the leader of Pakistan to be ousted.
They were followed by the Paradise Papers in 2017 and FinCen files in
2020.
5
Pandora Papers: Russia dismisses leaks
implicating Putin
Revelations accusing the Russian president, who is not directly named but
linked via associates, are ‘unsubstantiated’, says Kremlin.
Putin is not directly named in the Pandora Papers, but he is linked via associates to secret assets in
Monaco [File: Sputnik/Ramil Sitdikov/Kremlin via Reuters]
1
The files were leaked to the International Consortium of Investigative
Journalists (ICIJ) and published on Sunday.
“We didn’t see anything on hidden wealth within Putin’s inner circle,”
Peskov said, adding it was not clear “how this information can be
trusted”.
The leaks reveal that the $4m Monaco property was purchased
through an offshore company towards the end of 2003 for the woman
– a native of Putin’s hometown Saint Petersburg – who was previously
reported to have had a relationship with Putin.
2
The purchase of the property went ahead shortly after Krivonogikh
gave birth, the leaks showed.
The Pandora leaks also revealed that the head of a state-run television
network, Konstantin Ernst – who oversaw the opening and closing
ceremonies of the 2014 Winter Olympics – was gifted a stake in a
billion-dollar Moscow property deal.
3
Two former Hong Kong leaders named in
Pandora Papers leak
CY Leung accused of failing to disclose sale of company shares while
Tung Chee-hwa allegedly set up offshore companies to skirt taxes.
Former Hong Kong chief executives CY Leung, left, and Tung Chee-hwa, centre, toast with current
leader Carrie Lam during the 23rd anniversary of Hong Kong's handover from Britain to China last
year [File: Anthony Wallace/AFP]
Two former leaders of Hong Kong have been named in the Pandora
Papers leak, the most extensive global data drop detailing secretive
financial dealings by the world’s wealthiest people that aim to conceal
their assets.
Leung Chun-ying, or CY Leung, reportedly did not declare his income
from the sale of shares of a Japanese company while still serving as the
4
Chinese territory’s chief executive. Tung Chee-hwa, a billionaire,
allegedly set up offshore companies after he retired from office.
CY Leung was Hong Kong’s leader between 2012 and 2017, while Tung
was the city’s first chief executive after Hong Kong’s handover to
China in 1997. He remained in charge until 2005.
Aside from CY Leung and Tung, some 35 current and former world
leaders, including the Russian President Vladimir Putin and King
Abdullah II of Jordan, were also named.
5
DTZ Japan Ltd. ICIJ collaborated with Hong Kong’s Stand News in
the investigation.
The report also said that even after he took office as Hong Kong’s chief
executive on July 1, 2012, Leung continued to serve as director of three
offshore companies and only quit his posts in August that same year.
Leung never publicly acknowledged his role and duties in the three
companies, according to the report.
Leung furious
Leung characterised the Stand News report as misleading and warned
against fanning the “flames of irresponsible journalism” in a series of
posts on social media.
6
different procedures in contracts, and in some instances, resignations
did not take effect immediately.
Leung reacted angrily to the Pandora Papers leak and warned against fanning the ‘flames of
irresponsible journalism’ following the expose of his business transactions [File: Anthony
Wallace/AFP]
7
The report said that Leung was paid the sum to stop him from taking a
position with DTZ’s competitor. The complaint against him was
dropped in 2018, with the justice department citing insufficient
evidence.
The Stand News report also said that both CY Leung and Tung were
clients of Trident Trust, an international company that manages trusts
and funds. The paper alleged both men used intermediaries to register
offshore accounts and shell companies around the world for
themselves and family members to shelter them from taxes.
8
Pandora Papers: Ukraine leader seeks to
justify offshore accounts
Files obtained by ICIJ claim Volodymyr Zelenskyy and his partners
established a network of offshore companies in 2012.
An adviser to Zelenskyy's chief of staff said the president created the offshore companies to 'protect'
income from then pro-Russian President Viktor Yanukovych [File: Ukrainian Presidential Press Office
via AP]
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy’s office has sought to justify
his use of offshore companies as protecting him against pro-Russian
forces, following leaked revelations in the Pandora Papers.
9
A former comedian, Zelenskyy was elected president in 2019 on
promises to fight corruption and reduce the influence of oligarchs in
the ex-Soviet country.
The Pandora Papers are based on documents leaked to the ICIJ and
exposed the offshore dealings of kings, presidents and prime
ministers, including Jordan’s King Abdullah II, Czech Prime Minister
Andrej Babis and Kenyan President Uhuru Kenyatta.
The report also found that Zelenskyy, just before he was elected,
transferred his stake in one of the offshore companies to his top aide
Serhiy Shefir – the target of a shooting attack last month.
10
“Journalists have de facto confirmed the president’s absolute respect
for the standards of anti-corruption legislation,” Mykhailo Podoliak
told the AFP news agency.
“He and his accomplices took funds offshore without paying any taxes
to the Ukrainian budget,” Iryna Gerashchenko, a lawmaker from
Poroshenko’s faction, wrote on Facebook.
The Pandora Papers are the latest in a series of mass ICIJ leaks of
financial documents, from LuxLeaks in 2014, to the 2016 Panama
Papers, which triggered the resignation of the prime minister of
11
Iceland and paved the way for the forced resignation of the leader of
Pakistan.
They were followed by the Paradise Papers in 2017 and FinCen files in
2020.
12
Who has been named in the Pandora Papers?
Some of those named after secret files were leaked to a consortium of
journalists that revealed offshore deals.
A massive global investigation has exposed the ties between world leaders, celebrities and sport
stars to the hidden world of offshore wealth collectively worth trillions of dollars [Reuters]
A massive global investigation has exposed the ties between world
leaders to the hidden world of offshore wealth collectively worth
trillions of dollars.
Dubbed the Pandora Papers, the landmark probe, published on
Sunday, was conducted by the International Consortium of
Investigative Journalists (ICIJ) – an ensemble of 600 journalists from
150 media outlets in 117 countries.
13
Digging into more than 11.9 million documents leaked from 14
offshore financial services firms, the ICIJ found that 35 heads of state
and government and more than 300 politicians have set up offshore
structures and trusts in tax havens from the British Virgin Islands,
Seychelles, to Hong Kong and Belize.
Jordan
Jordan’s King Abdullah II amassed about $100m worth of property in
the United States and United Kingdom through secret companies.
They were purchased between 2003 and 2017 via firms registered in
tax havens and include properties in Malibu, southern California, and
Washington and London.
DLA Piper, a London law office representing Abdullah, told the ICIJ
that he had “not at any point misused public monies or made any use
whatsoever of the proceeds of aid or assistance intended for public
use”.
The royal palace said in a statement on Monday that the king’s
ownership of private properties in the UK and the US was not a secret,
adding that privacy and security reasons were behind not disclosing it.
Lebanon
The leaked files also showed that in neighbouring Lebanon, top
political and financial figures have embraced offshore havens.
14
These include Prime Minister Najib Mikati, his predecessor Hassan
Diab, Riad Salameh, the governor of Lebanon’s central bank –
currently under investigation in France for alleged money laundering
– and former minister of state and the chairman of Al-Mawarid Bank
Marwan Kheireddine.
15
The consortium said Kheireddine and Diab did not respond to
requests for comment while Salameh said he declares his assets.
Mikati’s son, Maher, told the ICIJ that owning real estate through
offshore entities offers more “flexibility” when it comes to renting,
inheritance planning, and “potential tax advantages”.
Pakistan
The Pandora Papers show that prominent members of Pakistani Prime
Minister Imran Khan’s government, donors to his party and family
members of the country’s powerful military generals moved millions
of dollars of wealth through offshore companies.
16
Czech Republic
The report said Czech PM Andrej Babis moved $22m through offshore
companies to buy an estate on the French Riviera in 2009 while
keeping his ownership secret.
17
Babis, speaking on Sunday in a TV debate ahead of October 8-9
elections, denied wrongdoing and said “the money left a Czech bank,
was taxed, it was my money, and returned to a Czech bank”.
Azerbaijan
The investigation found Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev and his
family have secretly been involved in British property deals worth
more than 400 million pounds ($542m), according to the BBC.
South Dakota
The Guardian newspaper said the files provided evidence that the US
state of South Dakota rivalled opaque jurisdictions in Europe and the
Caribbean for financial secrecy.
Kenya
Kenya’s President Uhuru Kenyatta and six members of his family have
been linked to 13 offshore companies, according to the documents.
18
The Kenyattas’ offshore investments included a company with stocks
and bonds worth $30m, the BBC reported.
United Kingdom
Tony Blair, the UK prime minister from 1997 to 2007, became the
owner of an $8.8m Victorian building in 2017 by buying a British
Virgin Islands company that held the property, and the building now
hosts the law firm of his wife, Cherie Blair, according to the
investigation.
The two bought the company from the family of Bahrain’s industry
and tourism minister, Zayed bin Rashid al-Zayani.
Buying the company shares instead of the London building saved the
Blairs more than $400,000 in property taxes, the investigation found.
The Blairs and the al-Zayanis both said they did not initially know the
other party was involved in the deal, the probe found. A lawyer for the
al-Zayanis said they complied with UK laws.
Russia
The Washington Post said Russian woman Svetlana Krivonogikh
became the owner of a Monaco apartment via an offshore company
incorporated on the Caribbean island of Tortola in April 2003, just
weeks after she gave birth to a girl.
19
At the time, she was in a secret, years-long relationship with Russian
President Vladimir Putin, the Post said, citing Russian investigative
outlet Proekt.
Ernst told the organisation the deal was not secret and denied
suggestions he was given special treatment.
Ukraine
Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelensky, who has been vocal on
anti-corruption issues, used a network of offshore companies to buy
three upmarket properties in London.
His office said it had been a way of protecting himself against the
“aggressive actions” of the regime of his predecessor, the pro-Russia
president Viktor Yanukovich.
Chile
The leaked documents revealed Chilean President Sebastian Pinera,
one of the country’s wealthiest men, used offshore companies in the
British Virgin Islands for dealings involving the Dominga mining
project, which his family co-owned in part with a friend.
20
protected natural reserve, according to the report. The government –
at that time headed by Pinera – did not do so, despite appeals from
environmentalists, nor did subsequent governments.
When investigators looked into the case a few years later, Pinera said
he had not been involved in managing the companies and had not
even realised the connection with Dominga.
Montenegro
Montenegro’s President Milo Djukanovic and his son in 2012 allegedly
established a trust and hid their wealth in a complicated network of
companies, according to the investigation.
Djukanovic’s office said that he did establish a business trust with his
son in 2012, while not in office. After he became the prime minister
later the same year, Djukanovic transferred all the rights to his son,
the office said. While Djukanovic was one of the owners there had
been no business transactions, they said.
Brazil
The documents showed Brazilian Economy Minister Paulo Guedes had
multimillion dollar investments in an offshore company named
Dreadnoughts International in the British Virgin Islands.
21
In a statement sent through his press office, Paulo Guedes said he
provided all the necessary information to the Public Ethics
Commission when he took office in the government in 2019.
Mexico
Three prominent Mexican business tycoons with a combined fortune
of about $30bn are among those named in the leaked documents,
media involved in the investigation reported.
They are mining magnate German Larrea, Modelo beer heiress Maria
Asuncion Aramburuzabala and Olegario Vazquez Aldir, who heads
Grupo Empresarial Angeles, according to the Spanish daily El Pais.
China
China’s only politician to be named in the Pandora Papers is a female
entrepreneur who the report says set up an offshore firm to trade US
stocks, according to Bloomberg.
22
The company had $2m in assets and was registered with the US
Securities and Exchange Commission, but is currently inactive, ICIJ
said.
Hong Kong
Two former leaders of Hong Kong have been named in the Pandora
Papers leak.
CY Leung was Hong Kong’s leader between 2012 and 2017, while Tung
was the city’s first chief executive after Hong Kong’s handover to
China in 1997. He remained in charge until 2005.
India
The Indian Express, part of the ICIJ consortium, said the Pandora
Papers showed that businessman Anil Ambani and his representatives
owned at least 18 offshore companies in Jersey, the British Virgin
Islands and Cyprus.
23
Set up between 2007 and 2010, seven of these companies had
borrowed and invested at least $1.3bn, the report said.
24
Jordan king exposed over tax havens and
luxury homes
So-called Pandora Papers says King Abdullah II is among dozens of
world leaders secretly holding millions of dollars offshore.
King Abdullah's lawyers were cited as saying all the properties were bought with personal wealth
[Elizabeth Frantz/Reuters]
25
The so-called Pandora Papers probe involving some 600 journalists is
based on the leak of some 11.9 million documents from 14 global
financial services.
“Jordan doesn’t have the kind of money that other Middle Eastern
monarchies, like Saudi Arabia, have to allow a king to flaunt his
wealth,” Annelle Sheline, a Middle East scholar, was quoted as saying.
“If the Jordanian monarch were to display his wealth more publicly, it
wouldn’t only antagonize his people, it would p**s off Western donors
who have given him money.”
26
The royal palace said on Monday that King Abdullah’s properties in
the US and UK were “no secret”, and that privacy and security reasons
were behind not disclosing it.
“This is not unusual nor improper,” said the royal palace statement.
“The cost of these properties and all related expenditures have been
personally funded by His Majesty. None of these expenses have been
funded by the state budget or treasury,” the statement continued.
The Jordanian palace said these properties were used during official
visits and some of these are used during private visits.
King Abdullah’s lawyers were cited saying all the properties were
bought with personal wealth, and it was common practice for
high-profile individuals to buy properties via offshore companies for
privacy and security reasons.
“[Abdullah] has not at any point misused public monies or made any
use whatsoever of the proceeds of aid or assistance intended for public
use.”
27
Some 35 current and former leaders are featured in the documents
analysed by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists
(ICIJ) – facing allegations ranging from corruption to money
laundering and global tax avoidance.
The documents also show Czech Prime Minister Andrej Babis – facing
an election later this week – failed to declare an offshore investment
company used to buy a chateau worth $22m in the south of France.
“The new data leak must be a wake-up call,” said Sven Giegold, a
Green party lawmaker in the European Parliament. “Global tax
evasion fuels global inequality. We need to expand and sharpen the
countermeasures now.”
28
Aliyev and Kenyatta on the list
Among the other revelations from the ICIJ investigation:
The Pandora Papers are the latest in a series of mass ICIJ leaks of
financial documents that started with LuxLeaks in 2014, and was
followed by the Panama Papers, the Paradise Papers and FinCen.
29
30