New Paradigms in High Rise Design
New Paradigms in High Rise Design
org/papers
Subject: Architectural/Design
Antony Wood1)
1)
Lecturer in Architecture, School of the Built Environment, University of Nottingham
Abstract
Tall Buildings are perhaps the most keenly debated building typology currently in existence. Opinion on their
contribution to the urban agenda is usually clearly divided; strongly for, or strongly against. Since September 11th
and the World Trade Centre towers’ collapse, the suitability of Tall Buildings in our future cities has become even
more of a key issue. This is especially true of London, a city which has only embraced tall buildings in relatively
recent times, and only in limited number. Although there have been strong moves in parts of the world to create
tall buildings rooted to the specifics of ‘place’, London has tended to cling to the import of the
commercially-driven, rectangular, air-conditioned ‘box’ model typical of most North America cities. This paper
presents alternative options for tall building design. It takes, as its vehicle, theoretical design research projects
developed at the University of Nottingham. Based on the Heron Tower project currently being developed in the
City of London, and working together with Kohn Pederson Fox architects, the paper outlines the differing design
approaches developed, and charts similarities in these approaches. By relating this to recent tall buildings
internationally, the paper concludes by suggesting new paradigms for high rise design.
2. Cultural Symbolism: Tall Buildings which are 9. Internalism. Tall Buildings which are inspired by a
inspired by an element of the indigenous culture of the concept / organising principle for the internal spaces of
location, which is unfortunately often taken quite the building, which dictates the design and external
literally (and thus with limited success) in the expression etc. This approach often includes elements
translation. Towers with Corinthian capitals and such as atria, skygardens etc. One of the best built
Islamic domes proliferate around the world, but examples is Norman Foster’s 1997 Commerzbank,
perhaps more successful examples include the Chinese Frankfurt (Zukowsky 2000).
pagoda-inspired 1998 Jin Mao Tower, Shanghai by
SOM Architects (Dupre 1998, pp116-117). 10. Materialism. Tall Buildings which are concerned
predominantly with an expression of materials and,
3. Abstract Symbolism. Towers which take an often, skin – which may or may not be linked into the
element of the culture as inspiration, but incorporate environmentalist / sustainable debate. A good example
this in a subtle, ‘abstract’ way. This often leads to a is the intelligent-skin façade and motor-driven
deeper, more refined approach e.g. the Islamic skin of windows of Ingenhoven Overdik and Partners’ 2003
BEP Architects’ 1984 Menara Dayabumi, Kuala Uptown Munchen Building, Germany (Abel 2003
Lumpur. pp79-82).