Shear and Diagonal Tension in Beams: Lec. Hasanain M. Al-Musawi Reinforced Concrete Design I
Shear and Diagonal Tension in Beams: Lec. Hasanain M. Al-Musawi Reinforced Concrete Design I
3.1 Introduction
Chapter one dealt with the flexural behavior and flexural strength of beams.
Beams must also have an adequate safety margin against other types of
failure, some of which may be more dangerous than flexural failure.
Shear failure of reinforced concrete. More properly called diagonal
tension failure is one example. Shear failure is difficult to predict accurately.
In spite of many decades of experimental research, it is not yet fully
understood.
• Relatively small bars are used, generally No.10 to 16. Simple U-shaped bars
similar to figure below are most common. Although multiple- leg stirrups
such as shown in figure below are sometimes are necessary.
• Stirrups are formed to fit around the main longitudinal bars at the bottom
and hooked or bend around longitudinal bars at the top of the member to
improve anchorage and provide support during construction.
• Bent up bar are no longer widely used because of the added cost of the
labor needed to bend the bars.
d. Combinations of above.
• Welded wire reinforcement is also used for shear reinforcement,
practically for small, lightly loaded member with thin webs and for
certain types of precast beams.
• Typically, web reinforcement is provided in the form of vertical
stirrups, spaced at varying intervals along the axis of the beam
depending on requirements as shown in figure below:
For concrete beams reinforced for flexure only, shear force required to initiates
diagonal cracks in web-shear cracks region or to propagate cracks in flexure-
shear region can be estimated from relation below:
Vc = 0.17𝝀√𝒇𝒄` bwd
Where:
𝜆 is the lightweight modifications factor is used to account for the lower tensile-
compressive strength that taken from ACI Table 19.2.4.2 below:
• Typically, the designer will not know the blends of aggregate necessary to
achieve the target design strength and density required for a project. In most
cases, local concrete and aggregate supplies have standard lightweight
concrete mixtures and can provide the volumetric fractions of lightweight and
normal weight aggregates necessary to achieve the target values. These
volumetric fractions can be used to determine the value of 𝜆 or in the absence
of such data, it is permissible to use the lower-bound value of 𝜆 (0.75) for
the type of lightweight concrete specified.
Vs = force per each stirrups × No. of stirrups through the inclined crack
𝑃
Vs = (𝐴𝑣 × 𝑓𝑦 )𝑓𝑜𝑟𝑐𝑒 𝑝𝑒𝑟 𝑒𝑎𝑐ℎ 𝑠𝑡𝑖𝑟𝑢𝑝𝑠 × (𝑆 )
𝑁𝑜.𝑜𝑓 𝑠𝑡𝑖𝑟𝑟𝑢𝑝𝑠 𝑡ℎ𝑟𝑜𝑢𝑔ℎ 𝑡ℎ𝑒 𝑖𝑛𝑐𝑙𝑖𝑛𝑒𝑑 𝑐𝑟𝑎𝑐𝑘
Where:
𝜋
Av = area of shear reinforcement = × ∅2𝑠𝑡𝑖𝑟𝑟𝑢𝑝𝑠 × No. of Legs
4
• For stirrups such as those in figure below, A v is 4 times the area of the bar
used
• For members with a circular section ACI Code provided that the area used
to calculate Vc be product of the diameter of the effective depth. The latter
may be taken as 0.8 times the diameter of the member
o Closed Stirrups
6. Calculate Smaximum
If ∅Vs ≤ ∅0.33√𝑓𝑐 ` bwd then:
𝑑
2
600
3𝐴𝑣 𝑓𝑦𝑡
Smax = 𝑀𝑖𝑛𝑖𝑚𝑢𝑚
𝑏𝑤
16𝐴𝑣 𝑓𝑦𝑡
{ √𝑓𝑐 ` 𝑏𝑤
5.5 m
Solution:
1. Calculate shear force at critical section
Wu = 1.2WD + 1.6WL = 1.2 × 40 + 1.6 × 34 = 104.8 kN/m
wu × ℓ 104.8 × 5.5
R reaction at support = = = 288.2 kN
2 2
Wu = 104.8 kN/m
𝑤𝑢 ℓ 104.8×5.5 5.5 m
R= =
2 2
= 288.2 kN
S.F.D
- 288.2 kN
• As all the limitations of ACI Code article 9.4.3.2 are satisfied, then sections
located less than a distance “d” from face of support shall be permitted to be
designed for Vu computed at distance “d”.
Vud at critical section: 104.8 kN/m
∑ 𝑓𝑦 = 0 Vud
288.2 –104.8 × 0.5 – Vud = 0
Vud = 288.2 –104.8× 0.5 = 235.8 kN
R = 288.2 kN
2. Find ∅Vc = ∅0.17√𝐟𝐜 ` bwd
Vc = 0.75 ×0.17√30 × 300 × 500 × 10-3
Vc = 104.75 kN
3. When Vu > ∅Vc Go to step 4
Vu = 235.8 kN > Vc = 104.75 kN
4. When Vud > ∅Vc calculate ∅Vs
Vu = ∅Vc + ∅Vs
∅Vs = 235.8 – 104.75 = 131.05 kN
∅Vs ? ∅0.66√fc ` bwd
131.05 kN < 406.6 kN
∴ Section dimensions are O.K
5. Calculate So
∅Av fyt d 0.75 × 78.5 × 2 × 300 × 500
So = = = 134.7 mm ≈ 130 mm
∅Vs 131.05 × 103
6. Calculate Smaximum
∅Vs ? ∅0.33√fc ` bwd
131.05 kN < 203.3 kN then :
d 500
= = 𝟐𝟓𝟎 𝐦𝐦
2 2
600 mm
3Av fyt 3 × 78.5 × 2 × 300
Smax = Minimum = = 474 mm
bw 300
16Av fyt 16 × 78.5 × 2 × 300
= = 461 mm
{ √fc` bw √30 × 300
∴ Smax = 250 mm
7. ∵ So < Smaximum O.K then use S = 130 mm ∎
Lec. Hasanain M. Al-Musawi Reinforced Concrete Design I Page 17
Chapter Three: Shear in Beams 3rd stage
5.37
• Required number of stirrups = ( + 1) ≈ 43
0.13
2∅10mm
Nominal bars to
support the stirrups
∅10mm@130mm
• In practice the structural designers may use the same spacing along beam span.
This spacing should be computed based on maximum shear force. However
the shear force can be divided to three distinguish regions shown in figure
below:
Vud
∅Vc
∅vc
Region 1 2
d Region 2
Region 3
Shear reinforcement required Min. Shear Shear reinforcement
reinforcement not required
For Region 1
Shear reinforcement will be used as shown in example 1.
For Region 2
Min. Shear reinforcement will be provided from the least of following:
d
2
600
3Av fyt
Smax = Minimum
bw
16Av fyt
{ √fc` bw
For Region 3
∅vc
No shear reinforcement is required as long as > Vud
2
∅Vc = 104.75
∅vc
= 52.4
2
Region 1
Region 2
Region 3
0.5m 1.26 m 0.49 m 0.5 m
2.75 m
Note: drawing is not to scale
For Region 1
Shear reinforcement will be 130 mm
For Region 2
Min. Shear reinforcement will be provided from the least of following:
d 500
= = 𝟐𝟓𝟎 𝐦𝐦
2 2
600 mm
3Av fyt 3 × 78.5 × 2 × 300
Smax = Minimum = = 474 mm
bw 300
16Av fyt 16 × 78.5 × 2 × 300
= = 461 mm
{ √fc` bw √30 × 300
∴ S for region 2 will be 250 mm
For Region 3
∅vc
No shear reinforcement is required as long as > Vud
2
1.695 0.49
• Required number of stirrups = [( + 1) + ( )] × 2 = 36
0.13 0.13
❖ Which one of these two methods do you think more economic?
Lec. Hasanain M. Al-Musawi Reinforced Concrete Design I Page 20
Chapter Three: Shear in Beams 3rd stage
Wu = 65.5 kN/m
9.15
6. Calculate Smaximum
∅Vs ? ∅0.33√fc ` bwd
∵ 168.38 kN < 190.14 kN then:
d 508
= = 𝟐𝟓𝟒 𝐦𝐦
2 2
600 mm
3Av fyt 3 × 113 × 2 × 275
Smax = Minimum = = 565 mm
bw 330
16Av fyt 16 × 113 × 2 × 275
= = 657.5 mm
{ √fc` bw √21 × 330
∴ Smax = 254 mm
7. ∵ So < Smaximum O.K then use S = 140 mm ∎
Solution:
Pu = 200 kN Pu = 50 kN
250 kN
50 kN
S.F.D
For part AB A B C
1. Calculate shear force at critical section
Vud = 250 kN
2. Find ∅Vc
∅Vc = ∅0.17√𝑓𝑐 ` bwd = 0.75×0.17× √30 ×400×600×10-3 = 167.6 kN
3. Vud > ∅Vc Go to step 4.
250 > 167.7
4. When Vud > ∅Vc calculate ∅Vs
Vu = ∅Vc + ∅Vs
∅Vs = Vu − ∅Vc = 250 – 167.7 = 82.4 kN
∅Vs ? ∅0.66√fc ` bwd then beam dimensions are O.K
82.4 kN < 650.69 kN
5. Calculate So
∅Av fyt d 0.75 × 2 × 78.5 × 300 × 600
So = = = 257.2 mm ≈ 250 mm
∅Vs 82.4 × 103
Lec. Hasanain M. Al-Musawi Reinforced Concrete Design I Page 24
Chapter Three: Shear in Beams 3rd stage
6. Calculate Smaximum
∵ ∅Vs < ∅0.33√fc ` bwd then:
d 600
= = 𝟑𝟎𝟎 mm
2 2
600 mm
3Av fyt
Smax = Minimum =
3 × 78.5 × 2 × 300
= 353.4 mm
bw 400
16Av fyt 16 × 78.5 × 2 × 300
= = 344.1 mm
{ √fc` bw √30 × 400
∴ Smax = 300 mm
7. Use S = 250 mm for part AB ∎
For part BC
Vud = 50 kN
∅Vc
Vud ?
2
∵ 50 < 83.8
∴ Shear Reinforcement is not required for part BC ∎
13@250mm
13@250mm
PL = 80 kN, PD = 60 kN PL = 80 kN, PD = 60 kN
WD = 4.68 kN/m
5. Calculate So
∅Av fyt d 0.75 × 2 × 78.5 × 300 × 550
So = = = 202 mm ≈ 200 mm
∅Vs 96.6 × 103
Lec. Hasanain M. Al-Musawi Reinforced Concrete Design I Page 26
Chapter Three: Shear in Beams 3rd stage
6. Calculate Smaximum
∅Vs ≤ ∅0.33√fc ` bwd then:
96.6 kN < 223.6 kN
d 550
= = 275 mm
2 2
600 mm
3Av fyt
Smax = Minimum =
3 × 78.5 × 2 × 300
= 474 mm
bw 300
16Av fyt 16 × 78.5 × 2 × 300
= = 462 mm
{ √fc` bw √30 × 300
∴ Smax = 275 mm
7. Use S = 200 mm ∎
4.3
• Required number for stirrups = ( + 1) = 23
0.2
Solution:
a. Design for shear in Region 1
1. Calculate shear force at critical section
WD self-weight = 0.35 × 0.6 × 24 = 5 kN/m
WD total = 5 + 36 = 41 kN/m
Wu = 1.2WD + 1.6WL = 1.2 × 41 + 1.6 × 30 = 97.2 kN/m
Vud = 179.3 kN (Find it as a homework)
2. Find ∅Vc
∅Vc = ∅0.17√fc ` bwd = 0.75 × 0.17× √21 × 350 × 530 × 10-3 = 108 kN
3. Vud > ∅Vc
179.3 > 97.2 Go to step 4.
4. When Vud > ∅Vc calculate ∅Vs
Vu = ∅Vc + ∅Vs
∅Vs = Vu − ∅Vc = 179.3 – 108 = 71.3 kN
∅Vs ? ∅0.66√fc ` bwd
71.3 kN < 420.7 kN O.K then beam dimensions are O.K
5. Calculate So
∅Av fyt d 0.75 × 2 × 78.5 × 420 × 530
So = = = 367.6 mm ≈ 360 mm
∅Vs 71.3 × 103
6. Calculate Smaximum
∵ ∅Vs < ∅0.33√fc ` bwd then:
d 530
= = 𝟐𝟔𝟓 mm
2 2
600 mm
3Av fyt
Smax = Minimum =
3 × 78.5 × 2 × 420
= 373 mm
bw 530
16Av fyt 16 × 78.5 × 2 × 420
= = 658 mm
{ √fc`bw √21 × 350
∴ Smax = 265 mm
7. ∵ So > Smaximum ∴Use S = Smaximum 265 ∎
Example 6: Calculate the maximum live load that the beam can carry based on
shear consideration only, use fc` = 30 MPa and fy = 300 MPa
Wu
∅10@150mm
6m 4∅20
Solution
∅𝑏𝑎𝑟
dfor one layer = h – cover – ∅stirrups –
2
20
d = 600 – 40 – 10 – = 540 mm
2
Vu = ∅Vs + ∅Vc
∅Vc = ∅0.17√𝑓𝑐 ` bwd = 0.75×0.17× √30 ×400 ×540 × 10-3
∅Vc = 150.8 kN
∅𝐴𝑣 𝑓𝑦𝑡 𝑑 ∅𝐴𝑣 𝑓𝑦𝑡 𝑑 0.75×78.5×2×300×540
So = → ∅ 𝑉𝑠 = = = 127.17 kN
∅𝑉𝑠 𝑠 150×103
Vu = ∅Vn = ∅Vs + ∅Vc = 150.8 + 127.17 = 277.97 kN
∑ fy = 0
R = Vud + Wu × d Wu Vud
𝑤𝑢 ℓ
= Vud + Wu × d
2
𝑤𝑢 ×6
= 277.97 + Wu × 0.54
2
3Wu – 0.54Wu = 277.97 d = 0.54
𝑤𝑢 ℓ
2.46Wu = 277.97 R=
2
277.97
Wu = = 112.9 kN/m
2.46
Wu = 1.2 WD + 1.6WL
112.9 = 1.2 × 0.6 × 0.4 × 24 + 1.6 × WL
WL = 66.24 kN/m ∎
Example 7: for the singly reinforced beam within the frame shown in figure
below, a designer as proposed to use open U stirrups with diameter of 10mm and
within spacing shown below, for beam shear reinforcement:
1. Is the using of open U stirrups justified according to ACI Code
requirements?
2. Based on proposed spacing and beam shear strength, what is the maximum
uniformly factored load Wu that could be applied?
Use fc` = 28 MPa, fy = 420 MPa and ∅𝑠𝑡𝑖𝑟𝑟𝑢𝑝𝑠 = 10 mm
Wu = ?
2m 3m 2m
Region 1 Region 2 Region 1
Spacing 150mm Spacing 250mm Spacing 150mm
7m
Solution:
1. Is the using of open U stirrups justified according to ACI Code
requirements?
As the beam is singly reinforced and it is not subjected to torsion or to reversal
loads, then using U stirrups is justified according to ACI Code∎
For Region 1
Vu = ∅Vs + ∅Vc
∅Vc = ∅0.17√fc ` bwd = 0.75 × 0.17 × √28 × 300 × 536 × 10-3 = 108.5 kN
∅Av fyt d ∅Av fyt d 0.75 × 78.5 × 2 × 420 × 536
So = → ∅ Vs = = = 176.7 kN
∅Vs s 150 × 103
For Region 2
∅Vc = 108.5 kN
∅Av fyt d 0.75 × 78.5 × 2 × 420 × 536
∅ Vs = = = 106 kN
s 250 × 103
Vu = 108.5 + 106 = 214.5 kN
wu × 3
= 214.5
2
Wu = 143 kN/m
Finally
Wu = minimum (96.2, 143) kN/m
∴ Wu = 96.2 kN/m ∎
• The main effect of axial load is to modify the diagonal cracking load of
the member.
• The longitudinal force, which modifies the magnitude and direction of the
principle tensile stresses, may significantly alter the diagonal cracking
load.
• Axial compression will increase the cracking load, while axial tension
will decrease it.
a. Axial Compression
The ACI Code provides that, for members carrying significant axial
compression as well as bending and shear, the contribution of the concrete
taken as:
𝐍𝐮
Vc = 0.17(𝟏 + ) λ √𝒇𝒄` 𝐛𝐰 𝐝
𝟏𝟒𝐀𝐠
Where: Nu is the compression force normal to cross section of beam.
b. Axial Tension
The ACI Code provided the following relation when the members are
subjected to axial tension as well as bending and shear.
𝟎.𝟐𝟗𝐍𝐮
Vc = 0.17(𝟏 + ) λ √𝒇𝒄` 𝐛𝐰 𝐝
𝐀𝐠
• The above equation should not be less than zero, where Nu is Negative for
tension.
Lec. Hasanain M. Al-Musawi Reinforced Concrete Design I Page 33
Chapter Three: Shear in Beams 3rd stage
Example: A beam with dimensions b = 300mm, d = 600 mm, and h = 700 mm,
with fc` = 28 MPa, carries a single concentrated factored load of 440 kN at
midspan. Find the maximum shear strength of the concrete V c at the critical
section for shear a distance d from the support:
1. If no axial forces are present
2. If axial compression of 270 kN acts
3. If axial tension of 270 kN acts
Neglect the self-weight of the beam.
Solution:
1. If no axial forces are present
∅Vc = ∅0.17√fc ` bwd = 0.75 × 0.17 × √28 × 300 × 600 × 10-3 = 121.4 kN
2. If axial compression of 270 kN acts
Nu
Vc = 0.17(1 + ) λ √fc ` bw d
14Ag
Nu = 270 kN, Ag = 300 × 700 = 210,000 mm2
270 × 103
Vc = 0.17(1 + ) × 1 × √28 × 300 × 600 × 10-3 = 176.8 kN
14 × 210,000
3. If axial tension of 270 kN acts
0.29Nu
Vc = 0.17(1 + ) λ √𝑓𝑐 ` bw d
Ag
0.29 × 270 × 103
Vc = 0.17(1 − ) × 1 × √28 × 300 × 600 × 10-3 = 101.5 kN
210,000
Table of Contents
3.1 Introduction ............................................................................... 1
3.2 Type of Web Reinforcement ..................................................... 2
3.5 Shear Strength Provided by Shear Reinforcement Vs ............... 7
3.6 Maximum value for fy and fyt .................................................... 8
3.7 ACI Code Provisions for Shear Design ..................................... 9
3.8 Anchorage of Stirrups ............................................................. 10
3.9 Stirrups Adjacent to the Support ............................................. 12
3.10 Design of Shear Reinforcements ........................................... 13
3.11 Design Procedure for Web Reinforcement............................ 14
Example 1: .................................................................................... 16
Example 2: .................................................................................... 22
Example 3: .................................................................................... 24
Example 4: .................................................................................... 26
Example 5: .................................................................................... 28
Example 6: .................................................................................... 30
Example 7: .................................................................................... 31
3.12 Effect of Axial forces ............................................................ 33