CH 03 - 12e 2006 (F)
CH 03 - 12e 2006 (F)
Questions, Short Exercises, Exercises, Problems, and Cases: Answers and Solutions
3.1 See the text or the glossary at the end of the book.
3.2 Net income equals cash inflows minus cash outflows from operating, investing, and
non-owner (that is, debt servicing) financing activities. If the period were long
enough, then sales of goods and services (revenue under the accrual basis) and cash
receipts from customers (revenue under the cash basis) would both occur in the same
long-enough time period. Revenues would therefore not differ between the cash and
accrual basis. Likewise, costs incurred to generated revenues (expenses under the
accrual basis) and cash expenditures for goods and services consumed (expenses under
the cash basis) would both occur in the same period. Expenses would also not differ
between the cash and accrual basis. With the same amounts of revenues and expenses,
net income on an accrual basis would equal net income on a cash basis.
3.3 The amount of revenue recognized equals the amount of cash the firm expects to
collect from customers. The firm does not necessarily recognize the revenue,
however, at the time it receives the cash. It typically recognizes revenue at the time of
sale even though it has not yet collected cash from customers. Likewise, the amount
of expense recognized equals the cash disbursement made for equipment, materials,
labor, and so forth. However, the firm recognizes the expense when it consumes the
services of these factor inputs, not when it makes the cash expenditure.
3.4 Revenues measure the inflow of net assets from operating activities and expenses
measure the outflow of net assets consumed in the process of generating revenues.
Thus, recognizing revenues and expenses always involves a simultaneous entry in an
asset and/or liability account. Likewise, adjusting entries almost always involve an
entry in at least one income statement and one balance sheet account.
3.5 Cost is the economic sacrifice made to acquire goods or services. When the good or
service acquired has measurable future benefits to a firm, the cost is an unexpired cost,
or an asset. When the firm consumes the good or service, the cost is an expired cost,
or expense.
3-1 Solutions
3.6 Accrual accounting attempts to relate inputs with outputs to obtain a measure of the
economic value added by a firm’s operating activities. Accrual accounting recognizes
expenses in the same period as related revenues. Costs not closely related to particular
revenues become expenses in the period when the firm consumes the services of assets
in operations. Thus, expenses either match with particular revenues or with a
particular accounting period.
3.7 Current accounting practice takes the viewpoint of shareholders by reporting the
amount of net income available to shareholders after subtracting from revenues all
expenses incurred in generating the revenue by claimants (for example, employees,
lenders, governments) other than shareholders. Critics point out that funds provided
by shareholders have a cost just as much as funds provided by lenders and accounting
should subtract this cost as well in measuring net income.
3.8 Contra accounts provide disaggregated information concerning the net amount of an
asset, liability, or shareholders' equity item. For example, the account, Property, Plant
and Equipment net of Accumulated Depreciation, does not indicate separately the
acquisition cost of fixed assets and the portion of that acquisition cost written off as
depreciation since acquisition. If the firm used a contra account, it would have such
information. The alternative to using contra accounts is to debit or credit directly the
principal account involved (for example, Property, Plant and Equipment). This
alternative procedure, however, does not permit computation of disaggregated
information about the net balance in the account. Note that the use of contra accounts
does not affect the total of assets, liabilities, shareholders' equity, revenues, or
expenses, but only the balances in various accounts that comprise the totals for these
items.
Solutions 3-2
3.11 (Ann Taylor Stores; analyzing changes in inventory and accounts payable.)
(Amounts in Millions)
3.15 (Radio Shack; computing income tax expenses and income taxes paid.)
(Amounts in Millions)
3-3 Solutions
3.16 (Journal entry for prepaid rent.)
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+300 +300 IncSt RE
The required balance in the Prepaid Rent account on December 31, Year 12, is $1,500,
which equals one-twelfth of the $18,000 payment for the period February 1, Year 12,
through January 31, Year 13. The Prepaid Rent account had a balance of $1,200 on
January 1, Year 12, and the firm made no entry affecting this account during Year 12.
Thus, the entry above increases the balance from $1,200 to $1,500. The entry made
on February 1, Year 12, decreased retained earnings (rent expense) by $18,000. Rent
expense for Year 12 should be $17,700 [= $1,200 + (11/12 X $18,000)]. The entry
above reduces the expenses (that is, increases retained earnings) from $18,000 to
$17,700.
Entry Made:
Equipment Expense.................................................................. 20,000
Cash...................................................................................... 20,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–20,000 –20,000 IncSt RE
Correct Entries:
Equipment ....................................................................20,000
Cash...................................................................................... 20,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–20,000
+20,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–4,000 –4,000 IncSt RE
Solutions 3-4
3.17 continued.
Correcting Entry:
Equipment ....................................................................20,000
Depreciation Expense............................................................... 4,000
Equipment Expense.............................................................. 20,000
Accumulated Depreciation................................................... 4,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+20,000 –4,000 IncSt RE
–4,000 +20,000 IncSt RE
b. -- $ 2,160 --
c. $39,200 -- --
d. -- $ 59,400 --
e. -- $ 9,000 $ 9,000
f. -- $ 9,000 $ 9,000
a. No. (One might argue that receipt of the order and completion of manufacturing
are sufficient to justify recognition of revenue. However, the purchaser may
reject the T-shirts when received. Furthermore, the concert may not take place
and the purchaser would fail to pay for the T-shirts. Thus, sufficient uncertainties
remain to justify delaying revenue recognition until at least the time of delivery.)
c. No (the baseball games will not take place until next year).
3-5 Solutions
3.20 (Sun Microsystems; expense recognition.)
b. $ 4,560 -- --
c. -- $ 5,800 $ 6,300
e. -- -- --
f. -- -- $ 4,500
g. $ 6,600 -- --
b. $200 (= $12,000/60).
c. $2,000 (= $24,000/12).
e. $1,200 (the repair does not extend the life beyond that originally expected).
f. None (the firm will include the deposit in the acquisition cost of the land).
Solutions 3-6
3.22 continued.
l. Assets increase for the amount of the cash or goods received from
supplier.
3.23 (Corner Grocery Stores; journal entries for notes receivable and notes payable.)
a. Year 12
Dec. 1
Cash..................................................................................... 100,000
Notes Payable................................................................. 100,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+100,000 +100,000
Dec. 31
Interest Expense ($100,000 X .06 X 30/360)...................... 500
Interest Payable.............................................................. 500
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+500 –500 IncSt RE
3-7 Solutions
3.23 a. continued.
Year 13
March 1
Note Payable....................................................................... 100,000
Interest Payable................................................................... 500
Interest Expense.................................................................. 1,000
Cash................................................................................ 101,500
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–101,500 –100,000 –1,000 IncSt RE
–500
b. Year 12
Dec. 1
Notes Receivable................................................................. 100,000
Cash................................................................................ 100,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+100,000
–100,000
Dec. 31
Interest Receivable.............................................................. 500
Interest Revenue............................................................. 500
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+500 +500 IncSt RE
Year 13
March 1
Cash..................................................................................... 101,500
Note Receivable.............................................................. 100,000
Interest Receivable......................................................... 500
Interest Revenue............................................................. 1,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+101,500 +1,000 IncSt RE
–100,000
–500
Solutions 3-8
3.24 (Dollar General; journal entries for inventories.) (Amounts in Millions)
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+4,368 +4,368
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–4,376 –4,376 IncSt RE
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–4,349 –4,349
September 1, Year 12
Prepaid Insurance....................................................................... 3,600
Cash........................................................................................ 3,600
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+3,600
–3,600
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–1,200 –1,200 IncSt RE
3-9 Solutions
3.25 continued.
September 1, Year 13
Prepaid Insurance....................................................................... 4,800
Cash........................................................................................ 4,800
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+4,800
–4,800
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–4,000 –4,000 IncSt RE
Shareholders'
Assets Liabilities Equity
a. U/S $ 6,000 NO U/S $ 6,000
b. NO U/S $ 1,200 O/S $ 1,200
c. U/S $ 4,600 NO U/S $ 4,600
d. O/S $ 250 NO O/S $ 250
e. NO U/S $ 1,500 O/S $ 1,500
f. NO O/S $ 11,600 U/S $ 11,600
Note: The actual and correct entries appear below to show the effect and amount of
the errors, but are not required.
a. Actual Entry:
Cash..................................................................................... 1,400
Sales Revenue................................................................. 1,400
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+1,400 +1,400 IncSt RE
Solutions 3-10
3.27 a. continued.
Correct Entry:
Cash..................................................................................... 1,400
Advance from Customer................................................ 1,400
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+1,400 +1,400
b. Actual Entry:
Cost of Goods Sold............................................................. 5,000
Cash................................................................................ 5,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–5,000 –5,000 IncSt RE
Correct Entries:
Machine............................................................................... 5,000
Cash................................................................................ 5,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+5,000
–5,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–500 –500 IncSt RE
c. Actual Entry:
None for accrued interest.
3-11 Solutions
3.27 c. continued.
Correct Entry:
Interest Receivable ($2,000 X .12 X 60/360)...................... 40
Interest Revenue............................................................. 40
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+40 +40 IncSt RE
e. Actual Entry:
None for declared dividend.
Correct Entry:
Retained Earnings............................................................... 1,500
Dividend Payable........................................................... 1,500
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+1,500 –1,500 Dividend
f. Actual Entries:
Machinery........................................................................... 50,000
Accounts Payable........................................................... 50,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+50,000 +50,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–49,000 –50,000 +1,000 IncSt RE
Solutions 3-12
3.27 f. continued.
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–4,000 –4,000 IncSt RE
Correct Entries:
Machinery........................................................................... 50,000
Accounts Payable........................................................... 50,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+50,000 +50,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–49,000 –50,000
–1,000
Machinery........................................................................... 4,000
Cash................................................................................ 4,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+4,000
–4,000
3-13 Solutions
3.28 (Ailawadi Corporation; cash versus accrual basis of accounting.)
a. and b.
a. b.
Accrual Cash
Basis Basis
Sales Revenue................................................................. $ 69,500a $ 61,200b
Less Expenses:
Cost of Merchandise Sold.......................................... $ 43,200c --
Payments on Merchandise Purchased........................ -- $ 44,800
Depreciation Expense................................................ 1,000d --
Payments on Equipment Purchased........................... -- 36,000
Utilities Expense........................................................ 1,010e 750
Salaries Expense........................................................ 4,760f 3,500
Rent Expense............................................................. 3,000 6,000
Insurance Expense..................................................... 100 1,200
Interest Expense......................................................... 200g --
Total Expenses....................................................... $ (53,270) $ (92,250)
Net Income (Loss).......................................................... $ 16,230 $ (31,050)
Solutions 3-14
3.29 (McKindly Consultants, Inc.; cash versus accrual basis of accounting.)
a. and b.
a. b.
Accrual Cash
Basis Basis
Consulting Revenue........................................................ $ 135,000 $ 109,000
Less Expenses:
Rental Expense........................................................... $ 7,500 $ 7,500
Depreciation Expense................................................ 2,000a --
Payments on Equipment Purchased........................... -- 24,000
Utilities Expense........................................................ 4,040b 3,460
Salaries Expense........................................................ 109,800c 98,500
Supplies Expense....................................................... 3,630d 2,790
Interest Expense......................................................... 2,000e --
Total Expenses....................................................... $ 128,970 $ 136,250
Net Income (Loss).......................................................... $ 6,030 $ (27,250)
3.30 (Hansen Retail Store; preparing income statement and balance sheet using accrual
basis.)
3-15 Solutions
3.30 continued.
Assets
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+6,000
–6,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+50 –50 IncSt RE
Solutions 3-16
3.31 continued.
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+18,000 +18,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–3,000 +3,000 IncSt RE
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+40,000
–40,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–2,250 –2,250 IncSt RE
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+24,000
–24,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–3,500 –3,500 IncSt RE
3-17 Solutions
3.31 continued.
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+12,000
–12,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–4,000 –4,000 IncSt RE
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+7,000 +7,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–5,000 –5,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–5,500 –5,500 IncSt RE
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+48,000 +48,000
Solutions 3-18
3.32 a. continued.
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–12,000 +12,000 IncSt RE
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+10,000
–10,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+50 +50 IncSt RE
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+6,600
–6,600
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–3,250 –3,250 IncSt RE
3-19 Solutions
3.32 c. continued.
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+6,100 –500 IncSt RE
–6,600
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–2,750 –2,750 IncSt RE
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–14,900 –14,900 IncSt RE
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–200 –200 IncSt RE
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+200,000
–200,000
Solutions 3-20
3.32 e. continued.
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–9,000 –9,000 IncSt RE
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–12,000 –12,000 IncSt RE
(2) No adjusting entry required because the full amount paid is an expense for
Year 3.
a. T-accounts.
√ 50,000 √ 450,000
3-21 Solutions
3.33 a. continued.
300,000 √ 800,000 √
Selling and
Cost of Goods Sold (SE) Administrative Expense (SE)
(3) 1,200,000 1,200,000 (12) (6) 625,000 625,000 (12)
Solutions 3-22
3.33 a. continued.
b. MOULTON CORPORATION
Income Statement
For Year 13
3-23 Solutions
3.33 a. continued.
Transactions spreadsheet.
Balance Sheet Accounts Transactions, By Number and Description
Balance: Acquire Sell Recog. Collect Pay Pay S&A Repay Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Balance:
Beginning Inventory Inventory COGS Accts. Accts. Expenses Note Int. on Insur. Depre. Inc. Tax End of
of Period on on Rec. Pay. Payable Bank Expired Exp. Period
Account Account Loan
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
ASSETS
Current Assets:
Cash 343,000 1,400,000 -950,000 -625,000 -82,400 85,600
Accounts Receivable 2,000,000 -1,400,000 600,000
Inventory 275,000 1,100,000 -1,200,000 175,000
Prepaid Insurance 12,000 -12,000 0
Total Current Assets 630,000 860,600
Noncurrent Assets:
Land 50,000 50,000
Building 450,000 450,000
Equipment 80,000 80,000
Accumulated
Depreciation -34,000 (34,000)
Total Noncurrent Assets 580,000 546,000
Total Assets 1,210,000 1,406,600
Imbalance, if Any - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Income Statement Sales COGS S&A Exp. Int. Exp. Int. Insur. Depre. Inc Tax
Accounts Rev. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp.
Solutions 3-24
3.33 continued.
c. MOULTON CORPORATION
Comparative Balance Sheet
a. T-accounts.
3-25 Solutions
Solutions 3-26
3.34 a. continued.
3-27 Solutions
3.34 a. continued.
Patent
Insurance Expense (SE) Amortization Expense (SE)
(12) 1,000 1,000 (16) (13) 400 400 (16)
Solutions 3-28
3.34 a. continued.
Transactions spreadsheet.
Balance Sheet Transactions, By Number and Description
Accounts
Balance: Purchase Acquire Sell Recog. Paid Paid Collects Pay Pay Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Balance:
Begin- Equip. Merchan. Mer. For COGS Compen. Utilities Accts. Accts. Accts. Unpaid Unpaid Depre. Rent Insur. Patent Int. Exp. Inc. Tax End of
ning of with Loan On Acct. Cash & To Emp. Rec. Pay. Pay. Comp. Util. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp. Amort. Exp. Period
Period on Acct. With W/O Exp.
Discount Discount
1 2 3a 3b 4 5 6 7a 7b 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
ASSETS
Current Assets:
Cash 247,200 62,900 -32,400 -2,700 84,600 -205,800 -29,000 124,800
Accounts Receivable 194,600 -84,600 110,000
Merchandise
Inventories 188,800 217,900 -162,400 -4,200 240,100
Prepaid Rent 60,000 -30,000 30,000
Prepaid Insurance 12,000 -1,000 11,000
Total Current Assets 508,000 515,900
Noncurrent Assets:
Equipment 90,000 90,000
Accumulated
Depreciation -1,500 (1,500)
Patent 24,000 -400 23,600
Total Noncurrent
Assets 24,000 112,100
Total Assets 532,000 628,000
Imbalance, if Any - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
-
Income Statement Sales COGS Comp. Utility Comp. Utility Depre. Rent Insur. Amort. Int. Income
Accounts Rev. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp. Tax Exp.
3-29 Solutions
3.34 continued.
Solutions 3-30
3.34 continued.
a. T-accounts.
3-31 Solutions
Solutions 3-32
3.35 a. continued.
√ 280,000 √ 97,750
3-33 Solutions
3.35 a. continued.
53,000 √ 450,000 √
Selling and
Administrative Expense (SE) Rent Expense (SE)
(5) 235,000 235,000 (14) (8) 1,400 1,400 (14)
Solutions 3-34
3.35 a. continued.
Transactions spreadsheet.
Balance Sheet Accounts Transactions, By Number and Description
Balance: Pays Acquire Sell Mer. Recog. Pays Collect Pays Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Balance:
Begin- Insur. Mer. Inv. Inv. On COGS S&A Cash from Sup. For Rent Depre. Patent Insur. Int. Exp. Inc. Tax End of
ning of Premium On Acct. Acct. Exp. Cust. Pur. On Exp. Exp. Amort. Exp. Exp. Period
Period Acct.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
ASSETS
Current Assets:
Cash 47,150 -2,400 -235,000 1,206,000 -710,000 305,750
Marketable Securities 95,000 95,000
Accounts Receivable 1,495,500 -1,206,000 289,500
Receivable from Supplier 1,455 -1,455 -
Merchandise Inventories 70,945 1,050,000 -950,000 170,945
Prepaid Rent 1,400 -1,400 -
Prepaid Insurance 2,400 -100 2,300
Total Current Assets 215,950 863,495
Noncurrent Assets:
Land 80,000 80,000
Building 280,000 280,000
Equipment 97,750 97,750
Accumulated Depreciation -2,500 (2,500)
Patent 28,000 -450 27,550
Total Noncurrent Assets 485,750 482,800
Total Assets 701,700 1,346,295
Imbalance, if Any - - - - - - - - -
- - - - -
Income Statement Sales COGS S&A Rent Depre Amort. Insur. Int. Exp. Inc. Tax
Accounts Rev. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp.
3-35 Solutions
3.35 continued.
b. PATTERSON CORPORATION
Income Statement
For the Month of February, Year 13
Solutions 3-36
3.35 continued.
c. PATTERSON CORPORATION
Comparative Balance Sheet
3-37 Solutions
3.36 (Zealock Bookstore; analysis of transactions and preparation of income statement and
balance sheet.)
a. T-accounts.
900 1,320
Solutions 3-38
3.36 a. continued.
25,000 1,980
3-39 Solutions
3.36 a. continued.
Transactions spreadsheet.
Balance Sheet Transactions, By Number and Description
Accounts
Balance: Issue Obtain Pay Rent Acquire Acquire Make Pur. Sell Recog. Return Collect Pay Pay Sup. Receive Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Balance:
Begin- Common Bank in Book- Compu- Deposit Books Books COGS Unsold Cash Compen- For Pur. Adv. Int. Exp. Rent Depre. Depre. On Inc. Tax End of
ning of Stock for Loan Advance shelves ters for with on Acct. for Cash Books from sation to On Acct. From Exp. On Comp. Exp. Period
Period Cash for Cash Cash Supplier and on Credit Emp. Cust. Book-
Acct. Sales shelves
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8a 8b 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
ASSETS
Current Assets:
Cash 25,000 30,000 -20,000 -4,000 -10,000 -8,000 24,600 142,400 -16,700 -139,800 850 24,350
Accounts Receivable 148,200 -142,400 5,800
Merchandise
Inventories 160,000 -140,000 -14,600 5,400
Prepaid Rent 20,000 -10,000 10,000
Deposit with Suppliers 8,000 8,000
Total Current Assets - 53,550
Noncurrent Assets:
Equipment 4,000 10,000 14,000
Accumulated
Depreciation -400 -1,500 (1,900)
Total Noncurrent
Assets - 12,100
Total Assets - 65,650
Imbalance, if Any - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Income Statement Sales COGS - Comp. Int. Rent Depre. Depre. Inc. Tax
Accounts Rev. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp.
Solutions 3-40
3.36 continued.
b. ZEALOCK BOOKSTORE
Income Statement
For the Six Months Ending December 31, Year 10
c. ZEALOCK BOOKSTORE
Balance Sheet
December 31, Year 10
Assets
Current Assets:
Cash........................................................................................ $ 24,350
Accounts Receivable.............................................................. 5,800
Merchandise Inventories........................................................ 5,400
Prepaid Rent........................................................................... 10,000
Deposit with Suppliers........................................................... 8,000
Total Current Assets.......................................................... $ 53,550
Equipment.............................................................................. $ 14,000
Less Accumulated Depreciation............................................ (1,900)
Equipment (Net).................................................................... $ 12,100
Total Assets....................................................................... $ 65,650
3-41 Solutions
3.36 c. continued.
Current Liabilities:
Accounts Payable................................................................... $ 5,600
Note Payable.......................................................................... 30,000
Advances from Customers..................................................... 850
Interest Payable...................................................................... 900
Income Tax Payable............................................................... 1,320
Total Current Liabilities.................................................... $ 38,670
Shareholders' Equity:
Common Stock...................................................................... $ 25,000
Retained Earnings.................................................................. 1,980
Total Shareholders' Equity................................................ $ 26,980
Total Liabilities and Shareholders' Equity........................ $ 65,650
d. Net income was positive, which is unusual for a new business in its first year.
The profit margin, however, is only 1.1 percent (= $1,980/$172,800). This small
margin does not leave much room for unexpected events. Current Assets exceed
Current Liabilities by a comfortable margin. The firm sells its inventory quickly
and collects its accounts receivable soon after sale. It must also pay its suppliers
quickly.
a. T-accounts.
Solutions 3-42
3.37 a. continued.
3-43 Solutions
3.37 a. continued.
Solutions 3-44
3.37 a. continued.
Transactions spreadsheet.
Balance Sheet Transactions, By Number and Description
Accounts
Balance: Pay Yr. Repay Obtain Rec. Pay Pur. Sells Recog. Return Collect Pay Pay Sup. Dec. Rec. Int. Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Balance:
Begin- 10 Inc. Bank Bank Refund Annual Books Books COGS Unsold Cash Emp. and Exp. Rent Depre. Depre. Inc. Tax End of
ning of Tax Loan Loan of Sec. Rent on Acct. for Cash Books from Compen. Pay Exp. On On Exp. Period
Period with Int. Dep. and on Credit Div. Book- Comp.
Acct. Sales shelves
1 2 3 4 5 6 7a 7b 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
ASSETS
Current Assets:
Cash 24,350 -1,320 -31,800 75,000 8,000 -20,000 24,900 320,600 -29,400 -281,100 -4,000 85,230
Accounts Receivable 5,800 327,950 -320,600 13,150
Merchandise Inventories 5,400 310,000 -286,400 -22,700 6,300
Prepaid Rent 10,000 20,000 -20,000 10,000
Deposit with Suppliers 8,000 -8,000
-
Total Current Assets 53,550 114,680
Noncurrent Assets:
Equipment 14,000 14,000
Accumulated
Depreciation -1,900 -800 -3,000 (5,700
)
Total Noncurrent Assets 12,100 8,300
Total Assets 65,650 122,980
Imbalance, if Any - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
- -
Income Statement Int. Exp. Sales COGS Comp. Int. Exp. Rent Depre. Depre. Inc. Tax
Accounts Rev. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp.
3-45 Solutions
3.37 continued.
b. ZEALOCK BOOKSTORE
Comparative Income Statement
For Year 10 and Year 11
Year 10 Year 11
Sales Revenue......................................................... $ 172,800 $ 353,700
Less Expenses:
Cost of Goods Sold............................................ $ 140,000 $ 286,400
Compensation Expense...................................... 16,700 29,400
Interest Expense................................................. 900 3,900
Rent Expense...................................................... 10,000 20,000
Depreciation Expense......................................... 1,900 3,800
Income Tax Expense.......................................... 1,320 4,080
Total Expenses............................................... $ 170,820 $ 347,580
Net Income.............................................................. $ 1,980 $ 6,120
c. ZEALOCK BOOKSTORE
Comparative Balance Sheet
December 31, Year 10 and Year 11
Year 10 Year 11
Assets
Current Assets:
Cash.................................................................... $ 24,350 $ 85,230
Accounts Receivable.......................................... 5,800 13,150
Merchandise Inventories.................................... 5,400 6,300
Prepaid Rent....................................................... 10,000 10,000
Deposit with Suppliers....................................... 8,000 --
Total Current Assets...................................... $ 53,550 $ 114,680
Noncurrent Assets:
Equipment.......................................................... $ 14,000 $ 14,000
Less Accumulated Depreciation......................... (1,900) (5,700)
Equipment (Net)................................................. $ 12,100 $ 8,300
Total Assets.................................................... $ 65,650 $ 122,980
Solutions 3-46
3.37 c. continued.
3-47 Solutions
3.37 d. continued.
SCHEDULE 1
Financial Ratios for Zealock Bookstore
Year 10 Year 11
Sales................................................................................ 100.0% 100.0%
Cost of Goods Sold........................................................ (81.0) (81.0)
Compensation Expense.................................................. (9.7) (8.3)
Interest Expense............................................................. (.5) (1.1)
Rent Expense.................................................................. (5.8) (5.7)
Depreciation Expense..................................................... (1.1) (1.1)
Income Tax Expense...................................................... (.8) (1.1)
Net Income..................................................................... 1.1% 1.7%
3.38 (Prima Company; working backwards to balance sheet at beginning of the period.)
A T-account method for deriving the solution appears below and on the following
page. The end-of-year balance appears at the bottom of the T-account. The derived
starting balance appears at the top. “p” indicates plug; “c” closing entry.
Solutions 3-48
3.38 continued.
Accounts Payable
(for Merchandise) Interest Payable
26,000 (p) 300 (p)
(3) 128,000 127,000 (9) (6) 1,200 1,200 (15)
25,000 Bal. 300 Bal.
Interest Expense
(15) 1,200 1,200 (16c)
3-49 Solutions
3.38 continued.
Transactions spreadsheet.
Balance Sheet Transactions, By Number and Description
Accounts
Balance: Recog. Acct. Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Recog. Record Balance:
Begin- Sales Rec. Pur. Of COGS Cash Depre. Tax Exp. Tax Paid Prepay. Oper. Int. Exp. Int. Paid Div. Dec. Mkt. End of
ning of Rev. Collected Merchn. Pay. To Exp. Made Exp. and Paid Sec. Pur. Period
Period Supp.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
ASSETS
Current Assets:
Cash 11,700 47,000 150,000 -128,000 -7,500 -49,000 -1,200 -5,000 -8,000 10,000
Marketable Securities 12,000 8,000 20,000
Accounts Receivable 22,000 153,000 -150,000 25,000
Merchandise Inventory 33,000 127,000 -130,000 30,000
Prepayments for
Miscellaneous Ser. 1,700 49,000 -47,700 3,000
Total Current Assets 80,400 88,000
Noncurrent Assets:
Land, Building, & Equip. 40,000 40,000
Accumulated (16,000
Depreciation -12,000 -4,000 )
Total Noncurrent
Assets 28,000 24,000
Total Assets 108,400 112,000
Imbalance, if Any - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Income Statement Sales COGS Depre. Tax Exp. Ot. Op. Int. Exp.
Accounts Rev. Exp. Exp.
Solutions 3-50
3.38 continued.
PRIMA COMPANY
Balance Sheet
As of January 1, Year 2
Assets
Cash................................................................................ $ 11,700
Marketable Securities..................................................... 12,000
Accounts Receivable...................................................... 22,000
Merchandise Inventory................................................... 33,000
Prepayments................................................................... 1,700
Total Current Assets............................................... $ 80,400
Land, Buildings, and Equipment.................................... $ 40,000
Less Accumulated Depreciation..................................... (12,000) 28,000
Total Assets............................................................. $ 108,400
3.39 (The Secunda Company; working backwards to cash receipts and disbursements.)
A T-account method for deriving the solution appears on the following two pages.
After Entry (6), we have explained all revenue and expense account changes.
Plugging for the unknown amounts determines the remaining, unexplained changes in
balance sheet accounts. A “p” next to the entry number designates these entries. Note
that the revenue and expense accounts are not yet closed to retained earnings, so
dividends account for the decrease in the Retained Earnings account during the year of
$10,000.
3-51 Solutions
3.39 continued.
Solutions 3-52
3.39 continued.
Sales
0 Bal.
100,000 (1)
100,000 Bal.
3-53 Solutions
3.39 continued.
Transactions spreadsheet.
Balance Sheet Transactions, By Number and Description
Accounts
Balance: Recog. Cash Recog. Pur. Of Cash Recog. Int. Paid Recog. Recog. Cash Recog. Recog. Check on Balance:
Begin- Sales on Collect. COGS Mer. On Pay. For Int. Exp. Depre. Of Oper. Paid for Mort. Div. Dec. Ending End of
ning of Acct. From Acct. Merchn. Exp. Exp. Prepay. Paid & Paid Bal. Sheet Period
Period Cus. Amts.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 8 9 10 11 12
ASSETS
Current Assets:
Cash 20,000 85,000 -55,000 -2,000 -26,000 -3,000 -10,000 9,000 9,000
Accounts Receivable 36,000 100,000 -85,000 51,000 51,000
Merchandise Inventory 45,000 -50,000 65,000 60,000 60,000
Prepayments 2,000 -27,000 26,000 1,000 1,000
Total Current Assets 103,000 121,000 121,000
Noncurrent Assets:
Land, Buildings, &
Equip. 40,000 40,000 40,000
Accumulated
Depreciation -16,000 -2,000 -18,000 (18,000)
Total Noncurrent
Assets 24,000 22,000 22,000
Total Assets 127,000 143,000 143,000
Imbalance, if Any - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Income Statement Sales COGS Int. Exp. Ot. Oper. Ot. Oper.
Accounts Rev. Exp. Exp.
Solutions 3-54
3.39 continued.
SECUNDA COMPANY
Cash Receipts and Disbursements Schedule
Receipts:
Collections from Customers................................... $ 85,000
Disbursements:
Suppliers of Merchandise and Other Ser-
vices.................................................................... $ 81,000
Mortgage................................................................. 3,000
Dividends................................................................ 10,000
Interest ................................................................... 2,000
Total Disbursements........................................... 96,000
Decrease in Cash............................................................ $ 11,000
Cash Balance, January 1................................................. 20,000
Cash Balance, December 31........................................... $ 9,000
A T-account method for deriving the solution appears below and on the following two
pages. Transactions (1)—(9) correspond to the numbered cash transactions
information. In Transactions (10)—(25), “p” indicates that the figure was derived by
a “plug” and “c” indicates a closing entry. The final check is that the debit to close
Income Summary in Transaction (25) matches the plug in the Retained Earnings
account.
Accounts and
Cash Notes Receivable
Bal. 40,000 Bal. 36,000
(1) 144,000 114,000 (4) (10p) 149,000 144,000 (1)
(2) 63,000 5,000 (5)
(3) 1,000 500 (6)
57,500 (7)
1,200 (8)
2,000 (9)
Bal. 67,800 Bal. 41,000
3-55 Solutions
3.40 continued.
Building, Machinery,
Prepaid Miscellaneous Services and Equipment
Bal. 4,000 Bal. 47,000
(7) 57,500 56,300 (12p)
Bal. 5,200 Bal. 47,000
Solutions 3-56
3.40 continued.
3-57 Solutions
3.40 continued.
Transactions spreadsheet.
Balance Sheet Transactions, By Number and Description
Accounts
Balance: Collect. Recog. Collect. Recog. Pay. To Pur. Of Recog. Repay. Pay. Of Pay. For Acq. Of Pay. For Recog. Dec. Recog. Check on Balance:
Begin- From Sales Of Int. Rev. Sup. Of Merchn. COGS Of Mort. Int. Misc. Misc. Prop. Prop. Tax and Depre. Ending End of
ning of Credit Rev. Interest Merchn. Ser. Ser. Taxes Exp. Pay. Exp. Bal. Sheet Period
Period Cust. Div. Amts.
1 2 3a 3b 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
ASSETS
Current Assets:
Cash 40,000 144,000 63,000 1,000 -114,000 -5,000 -500 -57,500 -1,200 -2,000 67,800 67,800
Accounts & Notes Rec. 36,000 -144,000 149,000 41,000 41,000
Merchandise Inventory 55,000 121,000 -126,500 49,500 49,500
Interest Receivable 1,000 -1,000 700 700 700
Prepaid Misc. Services 4,000 1,200 5,200 5,200
Total Current Assets 136,000 164,200 164,200
Noncurrent Assets:
Bldg., Mach., &
Equipment 47,000 47,000 47,000
Accumulated
Depreciation -10,000 -2,000 -12,000 (12,000)
Total Noncurrent
Assets 37,000 35,000 35,000
Total Assets 173,000 199,200 199,200
Imbalance, if Any - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
-
Income Statement Sales Int. Rev. COGS Int. Mis. Ser. Prop. Tax Depre.
Accounts Rev. Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp.
Solutions 3-58
3.40 continued.
TERTIA COMPANY
Statement of Income and Retained Earnings
Revenues:
Sales ......................................................................$ 212,000
Interest Revenue...................................................... 700
Total Revenues................................................... $ 212,700
Expenses:
Cost of Goods Sold................................................. $ 126,500
Property Tax Expense............................................. 1,700
Depreciation Expense............................................. 2,000
Interest Expense...................................................... 500
Miscellaneous Expenses......................................... 56,800
Total Expenses................................................... 187,500
Net Income..................................................................... $ 25,200
Less Dividends............................................................... (2,000)
Increase in Retained Earnings........................................ $ 23,200
Retained Earnings, Beginning of Year........................... 76,000
Retained Earnings, End of Year..................................... $ 99,200
3.41 (Portobello Co.; reconstructing the income statement and balance sheet.)
T-accounts to derive the amounts in the income statement and balance sheet appear
below.
3-59 Solutions
3.41 continued.
Accumulated Depreciation—
Computer System (at Cost) Computer System
√ 78,000 26,000 √
13,000 (13)
√ 78,000 39,000 √
Accumulated Depreciation—
Delivery Trucks Delivery Trucks
√ 0 0 √
(9) 60,000 4,500 (12)
√ 60,000 4,500 √
Solutions 3-60
3.41 continued.
Interest Expense
(10) 3,000
(11) 2,000 5,000 (22)
3-61 Solutions
3.41 continued.
Transactions spreadsheet.
Balance Sheet Transactions, By Number and Description
Accounts
Balance: Recog. Pay Yr. 9 Dec. and Rec. Issue Pay Pur. Of Recog. Acquire Recog. Recog. Recog. Cash Record Recog. Cash Recog. Cash Recog. Recog. Balance:
Begin- Insur. Dividend Pay. Yr. Repay. Com- Merch. Merch. COGS Del. Int. Exp. Dep. Dep. Col. Sales Sales on Paid to Unpaid Paid for Unpaid Unpaid End of
ning of Exp. 10 Div. Of Note mon Suppliers On Trucks On Note Exp. On Exp. On From from Acct. Emp. Sal. Exp. Taxes Taxes Consult. Period
Period & Int. Stock for Acct. Pay. Del. Comp. Cust. Cus. Ser. Exp.
Merch. Equip. System Adv.
1 2a 2b 3 4a 4b 4c 4d 5a 5b 5c 6 7a 7b 7c 8a 8b 9a 9b 10
ASSETS
Current Assets:
Cash 18,600 -1,800 -3,000 10,900 -115,000 -3,000 210,000 -85,000 -27,000 4,700
Accounts Receivable 33,000 -208,600 226,600 51,000
Notes Receivable 10,000 -10,000 -
Interest Receivable 600 -600 -
Merchandise Inventory 22,000 11,000 95,000 -88,000 40,000
Prepaid Insurance 4,500 -3,000 1,500
Advances to Employees 4,000 4,000
Prepaid Property Taxes 3,000 3,000
Total Current Assets 88,700 104,200
Noncurrent Assets:
Computer System 78,000 78,000
Delivery Trucks 60,000 60,000
Accum. Depre.:
Comp. Sys. -26,000 -13,000 (39,000)
Accum. Depre.:
Del. Trucks -4,500 (4,500)
Total Noncurrent
Assets 52,000 94,500
Total Assets 140,700 198,700
Imbalance, if Any - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Income Statement Insur. Int. Rev. COGS Int. Exp. Depre. Depre. Sales Sales Sal. Exp. Sal. Exp. Tax Exp. Tax Exp. Consul.
Accounts Exp. Exp. Exp. Rev. Rev. Exp.
Solutions 3-62
3.41 continued.
PORTOBELLO CO.
Income Statement
For the Year Ended December 31, Year 10
Revenues:
Sales................................................................................................... $ 227,200
Interest................................................................................................ 300
Total Revenues.............................................................................. $ 227,500
Expenses:
Cost of Goods Sold............................................................................ $ 88,000
Depreciation....................................................................................... 17,500
Salaries............................................................................................... 75,800
Taxes.................................................................................................. 18,000
Insurance............................................................................................ 3,000
Consulting.......................................................................................... 4,800
Interest................................................................................................ 5,000
Total Expenses............................................................................... $ 212,100
Net Income ........................................................................................ $ 15,400
3-63 Solutions
3.41 continued.
PORTOBELLO CO.
Balance Sheet
December 31, Year 10
Assets
Current Assets:
Cash.................................................................... $ 4,700
Accounts Receivable.......................................... 51,000
Merchandise Inventories.................................... 40,000
Prepaid Insurance............................................... 1,500
Advances to Employees..................................... 4,000
Prepaid Property Taxes...................................... 3,000
Total Current Assets...................................... $ 104,200
Noncurrent Assets:
Computer System—at Cost................................ $ 78,000
Less Accumulated Depreciation......................... (39,000) $ 39,000
Delivery Trucks.................................................. $ 60,000
Less Accumulated Depreciation......................... (4,500) 55,500
Total Noncurrent Assets................................ $ 94,500
Total Assets.................................................... $ 198,700
Current Liabilities:
Accounts Payable............................................... $ 16,000
Interest Payable.................................................. 2,000
Dividend Payable............................................... 3,000
Salaries Payable.................................................. 1,300
Taxes Payable..................................................... 4,000
Consulting Fee Payable...................................... 4,800
Advances from Customers................................. 1,400
Total Current Liabilities................................ $ 32,500
Note Payable....................................................... 60,000
Total Liabilities.............................................. $ 92,500
Shareholders' Equity:
Common Stock................................................... $ 51,000
Retained Earnings............................................... 55,200
Total Shareholders' Equity............................. $ 106,200
Total Liabilities and Shareholders'
Equity............................................................. $ 198,700
Solutions 3-64
3.42 (Computer Needs, Inc.; reconstructing the income statement and balance sheet.)
a. T-accounts.
Inventory Prepayments
√ 46,700 √ 1,500
(E) 172,100 158,100 (F) (G) 300
√ 60,700 √ 1,800
3-65 Solutions
3.42 a. continued.
Selling and
Administrative Expense Depreciation Expense
(G) 19,000 19,000 (M) (K) 3,300 3,300 (M)
Solutions 3-66
3.42 a. continued.
Transactions spreadsheet.
Balance Sheet Transactions, By Number and Description
Accounts
Balance: Cash Col. Recog. Pay. To Recog. Recog. Pay Pay Recog. Pay Prin. Acq. Recog. Balance:
Begin- From Sales on Mer. Merch. COGS Emp. & Income Depre. & Int. on Equip. Inc. Tax End of
ning of Cust. Acct. Sup. Pur. On Prov. Of Taxes Exp. Mort. Exp. Period
Period Acct. S&A
Serv.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
ASSETS
Current Assets:
Cash 15,600 189,000 -164,600 -21,000 -3,388 -4,800 -6,000 4,812
Accounts Receivable 32,100 -151,500 159,700 40,300
Inventories 46,700 172,100 -158,100 60,700
Prepayments 1,500 300 1,800
Total Current Assets 95,900 107,612
Noncurrent Assets:
Prop., Plant, &
Equipment 59,700 6,000 65,700
Accumulated
Depreciation -2,800 -3,300 (6,100)
Total Noncurrent
Assets 56,900 59,600
Total Assets 152,800 167,212
Imbalance, if Any - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Income Statement Sal. Rev. Sal. Rev. COGS S&A Depre. Int. Inc. Tax
Accounts Exp. Exp. Exp. Exp.
3-67 Solutions
3.42 a. continued.
Year 8 Year 9
Amounts Percentages Amounts Percentages
Sales....................................... $ 152,700 100.0% $ 197,200 100.0%
Cost of Goods Sold................ (116,400) (76.2) (158,100) (80.2)
Selling and Administra-
tion Expenses..................... (17,400) (11.4) (19,000) (9.6)
Depreciation........................... (2,800) (1.9) (3,300) (1.7)
Interest.................................... (4,000) (2.6) (4,000) (2.0)
Income Taxes......................... (3,388) (2.2) (3,584) (1.8)
Net Income............................. $ 8,712 5.7% $ 9,216 4.7%
Solutions 3-68
3.42 a. continued.
Year 8 Year 9
Amounts Percentages Amounts Percentages
Assets
Cash......................................... $ 15,600 10.2% $ 4,812 2.9%
Accounts Receivable............... 32,100 21.0 40,300 24.1
Inventories............................... 46,700 30.6 60,700 36.3
Prepayments............................ 1,500 1.0 1,800 1.1
Total Current Assets........... $ 95,900 62.8% $ 107,612 64.4%
Property, Plant and
Equipment:
At Cost............................. $ 59,700 39.0% $ 65,700 39.3%
Less Accumulated
Depreciation.................. (2,800) (1.8) (6,100) (3.7)
Net.................................... $ 56,900 37.2% $ 59,600 35.6%
Total Assets......................... $ 152,800 100.0% $ 167,212 100.0%
3-69 Solutions
3.42 continued.
b. Although sales increased between Year 8 and Year 9, net income as a percentage
of sales declined from 5.7% to 4.7%. The decline occurs primarily as a result of
an increase in the cost of goods sold to sales percentage. The increased
percentage might suggest (1) increased competition, which forced Computer
Needs, Inc. to lower its prices, (2) increased cost of merchandise, which
Computer Needs, Inc. could not or chose not to pass on to customers, or (3) a
shift in product mix to lower margin products. The percentage is also affected by
the estimates made for the December 31, Year 9 balances in Accounts
Receivable, Inventories, and Accounts Payable. The following summarizes the
effects of an overstatement (O/S), understatement (U/S), or no effect (NO) of
each of these three accounts, assuming the other two accounts are correctly stated,
on the cost of goods sold to sales percentage.
Solutions 3-70
3.42 b. continued.
Year 8 Year 9
Amounts Percentages Amounts Percentages
Income before Taxes............... $ 12,100 100.0% $ 12,800 100.0%
Income Tax Expense............... (3,388) (28.0) (3,584) (28.0)
Net Income.............................. $ 8,712 72.0% $ 9,216 72.0%
3.43 (The GAP and The Limited; interpreting common-size income statements.)
a. The decreasing cost of goods sold to sales percentages for both firms suggest a
common explanation. One possibility is that the economy was doing well and
both firms were able to increase selling prices and thereby their profit margins.
Another possibility is that the firms were able to purchase merchandise in larger
quantities or pay more quickly to take advantage of discounts. A third possibility
is that the firms implemented more effective inventory control systems, thereby
reducing obsolescence and the need to reduce selling prices to move their
merchandise. Another possibility is that sales grew rapidly and the firms were
able to spread their relatively fixed occupancy costs over a larger sales base.
b. The Limited relies more heavily on in-store promotions, which tend to increase
its cost of goods sold to sales percentages, whereas The GAP relies more on
advertising to stimulate sales, which The GAP includes in selling and
administrative expenses.
c. The increasing selling and administrative expenses to sales percentages for both
firms suggest a common explanation. One possibility is that the specialty
retailing industry became more competitive over this period (from new entrants
and from the Internet) and the firms had to increase marketing expenses to
compete. This explanation, however, is inconsistent with a more attractive
pricing environment suggested in Part a. above. Another possibility is that both
firms experienced increased administrative expenses as they introduced new store
concepts and opened new stores.
d. The explanation in Part b. applies here as well. The GAP includes its promotion
costs in selling and administrative expenses, whereas more of those of The
Limited appear in cost of goods sold.
3-71 Solutions
3.43 continued.
e. The interest expense to sales percentage decreased for The GAP and increased for
The Limited. One possible explanation is The GAP reduced the amount of debt
outstanding or grew it at a slower pace than that of The Limited. Another
possibility is that the market viewed The GAP as increasingly less risky,
permitting it to borrow at lower interest rates. On the other hand, the market
viewed The Limited as more risky and required it to pay a higher interest rate.
These two possibilities are not independent. Perhaps The GAP was able to
borrow at a lower rate because it reduced the amount of debt in its capital
structure. The higher interest rate for The Limited may reflect increased risk
from an increased proportion of debt in its capital structure.
f. Both firms experienced increased net income relative to sales. Both firms should
therefore experience increased income tax expense relative to sales. A more
meaningful way to interpret income taxes is to relate income tax expense to
income before income taxes. The latter is the base on which governments impose
income taxes. Consider the following:
The GAP The Limited
Year 8 Year 9 Year 10 Year 8 Year 9 Year 10
(1) Income before
Income Taxes
(plug)................. 12.4% 14.6% 16.3% 5.8% 6.5% 6.9%
(2) Income Tax
Expense............. (4.2) (5.5) (6.6) (2.0) (2.3) (2.4)
(3) Net Income......... 8.2% 9.1% 9.7% 3.8% 4.2% 4.5%
The income tax expense to income before income taxes percentages for The GAP
continually increased while those of The Limited remained relatively stable. One
possible explanation is that The GAP expanded its operations into other countries
and perhaps experienced higher income tax rates in those countries than it
experiences in the United States.
g. The profit margins of The Limited are just slightly larger than that for Wal-Mart
in Exhibit 3.8. One would expect specialty retailers to differentiate their products
and services more than Wal-Mart and achieve a higher profit margin percentage.
The question is: How much higher? The GAP achieves profit margins similar to
those for Kellogg (branded foods) and Omnicom Group (creative marketing
services). Extensive competition characterizes specialty apparel retailing, which
dampens profit margins. However, new fashions and trends stimulate demand
and permit higher profit margins. One might, therefore, expect an average profit
margin for specialty retailers somewhere between
Solutions 3-72
3.43 g. continued.
that of The Limited and The GAP. The Limited appears to have performed worse
during this period than one might expect and The GAP performed better.
(1) Research and development to create the beverage, which generally involves
developing the formula for the syrup.
Coke primarily engages in the first three activities and its independent bottlers
engage in the last three activities. PepsiCo engages more heavily in all six
activities. The lower cost of goods sold to sales percentage for Coke might
suggest that the market views the first three activities as higher value added than
the last three, permitting Coke to extract a relatively high price from its bottlers
for the syrup sold to them. PepsiCo’s cost of goods sold to sales percentage
reflects both the higher value added of the first three activities and the lower
value added of the last three activities. Another possible explanation is that Coke
dominates its bottlers and can extract a higher price because of the bottlers’
reliance on Coke for most of their purchases.
3-73 Solutions
3.44 continued.
Coke’s tax burden by this measure is less than that of PepsiCo in Year 11 and
Year 12. The income tax is a tax on income before taxes and not on sales. Thus,
this measure more accurately reflects the income tax burden. The larger income
tax expense to sales percentages for Coke results from Coke having higher
income before taxes to sales percentages.
e. The products of Coke and PepsiCo have brand recognition. Consumers willingly
pay a higher price for branded products than non-branded products. One might
argue that little intrinsic difference exists between the products of these two
companies, so that competition between them should lower the profit margins, as
occurs for AK Steel and Wal-Mart. The two companies dominate the
nonalcoholic beverage market however. An unwritten understanding not to
compete too heavily on low prices permits both firms to realize relatively large
profit margins. The greater competition among branded food companies and
advertising companies might explain their lower profits relative to Coke and
PepsiCo. The profit margins of Coke and PepsiCo are lower than Pfizer’s,
because consumers view pharmaceutical products as necessities and insurance
companies bear some of the cost.
The improved profit margin results primarily from decreases in the cost of goods sold
to sales percentage and in the selling and administrative expense to sales percentage.
One possible explanation for these decreased percentages is that either Nokia's market
dominance or the rapid growth in industry sales gave it pricing flexibility and Nokia
was able to price its products favorably relative to its costs. Another possibility is that
the rapid sales growth permitted Nokia to spread fixed manufacturing, selling, and
administrative expenses over a much larger sales base. The decreasing in-
Solutions 3-74
3.45 continued.
terest expense to sales percentage also favorably affected the profit margin. Nokia
may have reduced the amount of debt in its capital structure or replaced debt with a
higher interest rate with debt carrying a lower interest rate. It is also possible that
Nokia grew its debt but at a less rapid pace than the growth in sales, permitting the
interest expense to sales percentage to decline.
Offsetting these favorable effects on the profit margin percentage is a reduction in
the other revenues percentage. We have no information to interpret this change. The
income tax expense to sales percentage increased, the result in part of an increase in
net income before income taxes. The average income tax rate also increased, as the
following analysis shows.
The principal reason for the declining profit margin is an increase in the cost of goods
sold to sales percentage. Increased competition in the fast food segment of the
restaurant industry led McDonalds either to reduce selling prices or not increase
selling prices in line with increases in operating expenses. Offsetting the increasing
cost of goods sold to sales percentage is a decline in income tax expense as a
percentage of income before taxes, as the following analysis shows:
3-75 Solutions
3.47 (Identifying industries using common-size income statement percentages.)
Exhibit 3.29 indicates that two firms have relatively low profit margins, two firms
have medium profit margins, and two firms have relatively large profit margins. Low
barriers to entry, extensive competition, and commodity products characterize firms
with low profit margins. The likely candidates for Firms (1) and (2) are Kelly
Services and Kroger Stores. The office services offered by Kelly Services are clerical
in nature and not particularly unique. Kelly Services serves essentially as an
intermediary between the employee and the customer, offering relatively little value
added. Grocery products are commodities, with little, if any, differentiation between
grocery stores. Firms (1) and (2) differ primarily with respect to depreciation and
interest expense. Grocery stores require retail and warehouse space. Kelly Services
should require relatively little space, since its employees work on the customers'
premises. Thus, Firm (1) is Kroger Stores and Firm (2) is Kelly Services.
Firms with the highest profit margin should operate in industries with high
barriers to entry, relatively little competition, and differentiated products. Electric
utilities have operated until recently as regulated utilities and require extensive
amounts of capital to build capital-intensive plants. Regulation and capital serve as
barriers to entry. Gillette offers brand name products. The brand names serve as an
entry barrier. Customers also perceive its products to be differentiated. Thus, Firm
(5) and Firm (6) are likely to be Commonwealth Edison and Gillette in some order.
Firm (5) has considerably more depreciation and interest expense than Firm (6) and
Firm (6) has considerably more selling and administrative expenses than Firm (5).
Thus, Firm (5) is Commonwealth Edison and Firm (6) is Gillette.
This leaves Hewlett-Packard and Delta Airlines with medium profit margins.
Hewlett-Packard offers products that are somewhat differentiated and with some brand
name appeal. However, competition in the computer industry and rapid technological
change drive down profit margins. Delta Airlines offers a commodity product, but the
need for capital to acquire airplanes serves as a barrier to entry. Thus, these two firms
have some characteristics of firms with relatively low profit margins and some
characteristics of firms with relatively high profit margins. Firm (3) appears to have
considerably more debt in its capital structure than Firm (4). The short product life
cycles in the computer industry tend to drive down their use of debt. The aircraft of
Delta Airlines can serve as collateral for borrowing. Thus, one would expect Delta
Airlines to have a higher amount of borrowing. This clue suggests that Firm (3) is
Delta Airlines and Firm (4) is Hewlett-Packard.
a. The Prepaid Rent account on the year-end balance sheet should represent eight
months of prepayments. The rent per month is $2,000 (= $24,000/12), so the
balance required in the Prepaid Rent account is $16,000 (= 8 X $2,000). Rent
Expense for Year 2 is $8,000 (= 4 X $2,000 = $24,000 – $16,000).
Solutions 3-76
3.48 a. continued.
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+16,000 +16,000 IncSt RE
b. The Prepaid Rent account on the balance sheet for the end of Year 3 should
represent eight months of prepayments. The rent per month is $2,500 (=
$30,000/12), so the required balance in the Prepaid Rent account is $20,000 (= 8
X $2,500). The balance in that account is already $16,000, so the adjusting entry
must increase it by $4,000 (= $20,000 – $16,000).
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+4,000 +4,000 IncSt RE
The Rent Expense account will have a balance at the end of Year 3 before closing
entries of $26,000 (= $30,000 – $4,000). This amount comprises $16,000 (=
$2,000 X 8) for rent from January through August and $10,000 (= $2,500 X 4) for
rent from September through December.
c. The Prepaid Rent account on the balance sheet at the end of Year 4 should
represent two months of prepayments. The rent per month is $3,000 (=
$18,000/6), so the required balance in the Prepaid Rent account is $6,000 (= 2 X
$3,000). The balance in that account is $20,000, so the adjusting entry must
reduce it by $14,000 (= $20,000 – $6,000).
3-77 Solutions
3.48 c. continued.
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–14,000 –14,000 IncSt RE
The Rent Expense account will have a balance at the end of Year 4 before closing
entries of $32,000 (= $18,000 + $14,000). This amount comprises $20,000 (=
$2,500 X 8) for rent from January through August and $12,000 (= $3,000 X 4) for
rent from September through December.
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–1,000 +1,000 IncSt RE
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
–750 –750 IncSt RE
Solutions 3-78
3.48 continued.
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+5,000 –5,000 IncSt RE
Equipment........................................................................... 10,000
Accumulated Depreciation............................................. 2,000
Depreciation Expense..................................................... 8,000
Shareholders'
Assets = Liabilities + Equity (Class.)
+10,000 +8,000 IncSt RE
–2,000
3-79 Solutions
3.49 (Ethical issues in accounting choices.)
Each of these firms received an unqualified opinion from their independent auditor,
suggesting that they applied generally accepted accounting principles properly. Each
firm disclosed sufficient information about their application of accounting principles
for the user to ascertain that UAL applied its accounting principles in more income-
enhancing ways than AMR and Delta. Thus, the remaining question is whether UAL’s
aggressiveness relative to AMR and Delta creates an ethical concern. Using an
average life of 21.1 years, the average life for Delta, results in depreciation expense of
$1,082.3 (= $22,835.5/21.1). The longer depreciable life decreases depreciation by
approximately $112.3 million (= $1,082.3 – $970.0), a 10.4 percent reduction (=
$112.3/$1,082). This reduction appears material, given the importance of
depreciable assets to airlines. The differences in the estimated uncollectible
accounts percentages seem even more material. However, most customers prepay for
their airline tickets, so accounts receivable do not represent a significant proportion of
total assets.
Solutions 3-80