MODULE VIII Column
MODULE VIII Column
Course Description : This course is concerned with the design, applications and code
specifications used in structural reinforced concrete members subjected to flexure
(beams, girders, joists, lintels, girts, etc.), tension and compression members
(columns), combined stressed members (beams-columns), beam column connections
using the Elastic Limit Method, also known as the Alternate Stress Design (ASD) or
Working Stress Design (WSD) and the Plastic Limit Method (PLM) or the Ultimate
Strength Design (USD). Applications and specifications as applied to buildings,
bridges, and other reinforced concrete structures are also given emphasis. A thorough
knowledge and proficiency in Structural Theory is imperative.
Total Learning Time: 4 Units (3 hours lecture, 3 hours computational laboratory per week)
Pre-requisites : Theory I and Theory II
Overview:
A reinforced concrete column is a structural member designed to carry compressive
loads, composed of concrete with an embedded steel frame to provide reinforcement. For
design purposes, the columns are separated into two categories: short columns and slender
columns. he strength of short columns is controlled by the strength of the material and the
geometry of the cross section. Reinforcing rebar is placed axially in the column to provide
additional axial stiffness. Accounting for the additional stiffness of the steel, the nominal
loading capacity Pn for the column in terms of the maximum compressive stress of the
concrete fc', the yield stress of the steel fy, the gross cross section area of the column Ag, and
the total cross section area of the steel rebar Ast.
Learning Outcomes:
After completing this module, the students should be able to:
1. Identify the different 3 types of columns in terms of loads, and in terms of
reinforcements and ties.
2. Analyze and design axially loaded columns, columns with small
eccentricity and columns with large eccentricity.
3. Analyze and design columns using the interaction diagrams.
Indicative Content: Axially loaded columns and columns with small eccentricity, Columns
with large eccentricity, Column interaction diagrams
2. Columns in a frame that is not braced against sidesway. The effect of slenderness
maybe neglected when:
a) KLu/r < (34 – 12) M1/M2 --- can be consider short column
b) KLu/r > (34 – 12) M1/M2 ----- it is a long column.
Slenderness effect should be considered.
r = 0.30 times the overall dimension in the direction stability for rectangular
compression members (tied column)
r = 0.25 times the diameter of circular compression members (spiral column)
Design Equations:
a. For tied column: ϕ= 0.70
Pu = .80ϕAg [0.85fc’ (1 – ρg) + ρgfy]
For column with small eccentricity, e < 0.10h for tied column
Spacing of lateral ties:
1. 48 times diameter of lateral ties
2. 16 times diameter of main bars
3. Least column dimension
Note: Use whichever is lesser.
Example: Given:
PDL = 1,000 kN PLL = 1,350 kN MDL = 20 kN-m
MLL = 30 kN-m fc’ = 30MPa fy = 400MPa
ρg = 0.03
Design a short column using:
a) Square tied column
b) Circular spiral column
c) Square section with spiral reinforcement
Figure: 450mm
450mm
8 - # 10 bars
40mm
8 # 9 bars
Dc = 370mm d = 450mm
40mm
Spiral pitch
Ag = 157,780.80mm2 h2 = 157,780.80mm2
h = 397.2163 ----------------- h = 400mm
Check for eccentricity ----- actual e = 0.10 (400) = 40mm > e allowable (21mm) -- ok
As = 0.03 (400)2 = 4800mm2
Using # 10 bars ------ As = 319mm2
Number of bars = 4800/319 = 5.86 ---- say 6 pieces
S = 4As/Dcρs ------------------- Dc = 400 – 2 (40) = 320mm
ρs = 0.45 [ 4502/3202 - 1]30/400 = 0.033
S = 4 (78.54)/320(0.033) = 29.75mm say 28mm
Figure:
6 # 9 bars with
10mmϕ spiral @ 28mm o.c.
400mm
400mm
Cb = ___600d___
(fy + 600)
ab = β1 Cb
Determine the value of eb using the equation appropriate to the directions of force
load. Thus: Pn + T = Cs + Cc
Note:
a) if e < eb ----- primary compression failure, fs’ = fy, fs may or may not yield.
Compression failure – This occurs when there is a large axial load, acting at a small
eccentricity. Failure occurs by crushing of the concrete on the compression side with strain
0.003, whereas the yield strain on the steel on the tension side is less than the yield strain, that
is Єs < Єsy, therefore, fs = fy.
b) if e > eb ----- primary tension failure, fs = fy, fs’ may or may yield
Tension failure – This occurs when the axial load is small and the eccentricity is
large causing the tension steel bars to yield before actual crushing of concrete. At the point
of failure, the strain in the tension side Єs > Єsy, whereas the strain in concrete reaches
0.003, therefore fs = fy.
Problem 1. Given an eccentrically loaded column shown, fc’ = 20.70MPa, fy = 276MPa and
As = As’ = 4 # 9. Determine the safe ultimate load and moment:
a. at balance condition
b. e = 300mm
c. e = 150mm
Figure:
510mm Pn
8 # 9 bars 510mm
65mm 65mm
Solution:
a) at balance condition: d = 510 – 65 = 445mm
Cb = __600d__ = __600 (445)__ = 304.79mm
fy + 600 276 + 600
ab = β1Cb = 0.85 (304.79) = 259.07mm
fs’ = (ab - β1d’) (600) = [259.07 – 0.85 (65)]600 = 472.04 MPa > 276Mpa
ab 259.07
Therefore: fs’ = fy.
∑Fv = 0 ------------------- Pn + T = Cc + Cs
Pnb + Asfs = 0.85fc’ab b + As’fs’ --- at balance condition fs = fy
Pnb + Asfy = 0.85fc’ab b + As’fy ---- As = As’
Pnb = 0.85fc’ab b
Pnb= 0.85 (20.70) (259.07) (510) ÷ 1000 = 2,324.75kN
Pub = ϕ Pnb = 0.70 (2324.75) = 1,627.325kN
Mub = Pub.eb
∑MAs = 0
Pnb (e’b) = Cc (d – a/2) + Cs (d – d’)
Pnb (e’b) = 0.85 fc’ ab b (d – ab/2) + As’ fy (d – d’)
(1000) (2324.75) e’b = 2,324.75 (1000) (445 – 259.07/2) + (2580) (276) (445 – 65)
e’b = 434.92mm
e’b = eb + (d – d’)/2 ---------- eb = e’b – (d – d’)/2
eb = 434.92 – (445 – 65)/2
eb = 239.92mm
Mub = Pub.eb
Mub = 1627.33 (0.23992m)
Mub = 390.43 kN-m
If numerical values of Pn and Mn are determined for a particular column for each of
the failure modes discussed in the preceding section and if these are plotted as a diagram, the
result is called a column interaction diagram.
Interaction diagrams are obviously useful for studying the strengths of columns with
varying proportions of loads and moments. Any combination of loading that fails inside the
curve is satisfactory, whereas any combination falling outside the curve represents failure.
In the interaction diagrams it would be necessary to have a diagram for each different
column cross section, for each different set of concrete and steel grades, and for each
different bar arrangement. The result would be an astronomical number of diagrams. The
number can be tremendously reduced, however, the diagrams are plotted with ordinates of
ɸPn/Ag (instead of Pn) and with abscissas of ɸPne/Agh (instead of Mn). Thus each interaction
diagram can be used for cross sections with widely varying dimensions. The ACI has
prepared interaction curves in this manner for different cross section and bar arrangement
situations for different grades of steel and concrete.
Example:
1. Using the interaction curves, determine the value of Pn for the short tied column.
fc’ = 3,000 psi and fy = 60,000 psi for eccentricity;
a) ex = 18 inches
b) ex = 8 inches
2.50in
3#9 (3in2)
x 19” 24in.
3#9 (3in2)
2.50in
therefore, interpolate between the values obtained from the interaction diagram
Solution: b) ex = 8 inches
therefore, interpolate between the values obtained from the interaction diagram
A. SLENDERNESS EFFECTS
The slenderness of columns is based on their geometry and on their lateral bracing. As
their slenderness increases, their bending stresses increase and thus buckling may occur.
Reinforced concrete columns generally have small slenderness ratios. As a result, they can
usually be designed as short columns without strength reductions due to slenderness.
B. UNSUPPORTED LENGTHS
The length used for calculating the slenderness ratio of a column Lu is its unsupported
length. This length is considered to be equal to the clear distance between slabs, beams, or
other members that provide lateral supports to the column.
D. RADII OF GYRATION
The radius of gyration of a round column is equal to 0.25 times its diameter and 0.289
times the dimension of a rectangular column in the direction being considered. The ACI
Code permits the approximate value 0.30 to be used in place of 0.289 and this is done herein.
E. COMMENTS ON SLENDERNESS
Moments at the ends of a column are referred to as M1b, M2b and M2s by the code.
M1b is the value of the smaller factored moment due to the loads that result in no appreciable
sidesway. M2b is the value of the larger factored end moment due to the loads that result in no
appreciable sidesway. It may not be less than P u (0.60 + 0.03h). M2s is the value of the larger
factored end moment due to loads which result in appreciable sidesway but not less than Pu
(0.60 + 0.03h).
If klu/r < 22 for columns in unbraced frames, or less than 34 – 12(M 1b/M2b) for
columns in braced frames, slenderness effects may be neglected. Should klu/r for a particular
column be larger than the applicable ratio then there is a long column.
Mc = δbM2b + δsM2S
Where δb is a moment magnification factor that takes into account the effect of
member curvature in a frame braced against sideway and δs is a moment magnification factor
that takes into account the lateral drift of a column caused by lateral and gravity loading the
frame not being braced against sidesway.
6. EI = _(EcIg/5) + Es Ise_
1 + βd
or more conservatively as
7. EI = __EcIg/2.5__
1 + βd
The Euler buckling load enters into the calculation and equals
Pc = __π2EI__
(kLu)2
δb = ______Cm__________ >1.0
1 – (Pu/ɸPc)
δs = ________1______ >1.0
1 – (ΣPu/ɸΣPc)
The terms ΣPu and ΣPc are the summations for all the columns in the story in question.
For frames not braced against sidesway it is necessary to calculate both δ b and δs. For frames
that are braced against sidesway it is necessary to calculate only δ b while δs is to be taken as
one.
Problem 1: For the column shown, fy = 60,000 psi, fc’ = 3,000 psi, P DL = 60k, PLL = 100k,
MDL = 120ft-k and MLL = 140ft-k. The frame is braced against sidesway, the column is bent
in single curvature about the x-axis, and the moments are equal at each end of the member. Is
the member satisfactory? when:
a. Lu = 10 feet
b. Lu = 20 feet, if not, calculate δ and determine the steel area required.
Figure:
2.5in
4#10
x x 15in 20in
4#10
2.5in
15in
but not less than 254 (0.6 + 0.03 x 20)/12 = 25.40 ft-k.
e = 12(406)/254 = 19.18inches
e/h = 19.18/20 = 0.959
ρg = 10.12/300 = 0.0337
γ = 15/20 = 0.75 ------------- refer to interaction diagram, graph 9.
EI = 16,768,741 k-in2
Pc = _π2EI_ = _(π)2 (16,768,741)_ = 2873k
(klu)2 (12 x 20)2
Pn = 254/0.70 = 362.90k
Mu = (1.40) (120) + (1.70) (140) = 406 ft-k
Mn = 406/0.70 = 580 kips
Mc = δbM2b = (1.14) (580) = 661.20 ft-k
γ = 15/20 = 0.75
e = (12) (661.20)/362.90 = 21.86in
e/h = 21.86/20 = 1.093
_ϕPne_ = 0.847 (1.093) = 0.926 --------- ρg from the interaction curve = 0.048
Agh
1. From the given cross-section of the tied column, determine the maximum
downward load that the column can support, if eccentricity is 200mm, effective steel
covering is 75mm. The column is reinforced with 6 -28mm ϕ bars. fc’ = 21Mpa, and
fy = 415MPa. Use column interaction diagram.
Figure:
600mm Pn
350mm
Figure:
15” h = 20”
b = 12”
3. A short circular column carries a service axial load dead load of 800kN, axial live
load of 400kN and a service dead load and live load moment of 120kN-m and 95kN-m
respectively. Use fc’ = 28MPa and fy = 415MPa. Determine the minimum number of
28mmɸ of steel bars needed.
Figure:
500mm
Figure:
6-25mmϕ
300mm
350mm
Additional Readings: Compression and Bending – Direct Method, Plastic Centroid, Design
and Analysis of Composite Structures Connections: Beam – Column Connection
References:
: Association of Structural Engineers of the Philippines; National Structural Code
of the Philippines (NSCP C101, Vol. 1 Buildings and Other Vertical Structures),
7th Edition, 2016
: McCormac, Jack C.; (2005); Design of Reinforced Concrete; 7th Edition; John
Wiley & Sons, New York, USA
: Nilson, Arthur H. and Winter, George et al.; (2000); Design of Concrete
Structures; 13th Edition; McGraw-Hill, Inc.
: Gambhir,M.L.; (2010); Fundamentals of Reinforced Concrete Design
: Meyer, C., (1997); Design of Concrete Structures
: American Concrete Institute; ACI 318 Building Code Requirements for
Reinforced Concrete; Latest Edition
Prepared by: