A Term Paper ON: Change Management
A Term Paper ON: Change Management
ON
(CHANGE MANAGEMENT)
MANPREET SINGH
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Content
Acknowledgement
1 Introduction To The Topic
2 Introduction To The Company
3 Changes at Tata Motors
4 Need for the Change
5 Relevance for the Change
6 Change in Workforce & culture
7 Role of Leadership in Change Management
8 Barriers to Change
9 Planning The Change at Tata Motors
10 Employee Motivation to Accept the Change
11 Evaluating The Change Process at Tata Motors
12 Conclusion & Strategies To manage Change Process
13 Suggestions
14 References
INTRODUCTION
TO
CHANGE MANAGEMENT
· Strategic changes
· Technological changes
· Structural changes
· Changing the attitudes and behaviors of personnel
There are many models in understanding the transitioning of individuals through the
phases of change management and strengthening organizational development initiative in
both government and corporate sectors. They are
1. ADKAR Model
2. Unfreeze-Change-Refreeze
3. Kübler-Ross
4. Formula for Change
5. PCI (People Centered Implementation)
Some of the Potential issues concerning the successful Change deployment process:
The House (Of Quality) Needs Foundations
Underestimating the need for a support structure can be a big mistake in the process of
deploying Lean or Six Sigma. It is important to first assess the gap between your current
state and the future, desired state. This activity produces a list of things that need to
change and, in addition, those that need to be positively reinforced. In the change process,
this is not an either/or proposition. Both need to be done. As an example, if one has the
fortune of having an army of talented Black Belts but a broken Champion support
system, the program can fail in a heartbeat. Again, if both are present and yet, executive
support is absent, then that can lead to disastrous results for a program as well.
The role of a consultant is potentially huge in this case. The superior knowledge base can
be helpful in foreseeing roadblocks and addressing them at the very outset.
One common trait of all change initiatives is that they go through a series of necessary
steps that have their own lead times. Failing to recognize this fact often leads to skipping
essential activities that only create an illusion of speed and never produces desired
results.
Doing the same old thing and expecting different results is the definition of insanity. As
much as new tools and a new roadmap empowers people to do things differently,
systemic constraints -- be it organizational structure or reward system -- if not addressed
adequately can seriously damage the credibility of the effort and make cynics out of
employees.
Actions to confront big roadblocks early in the deployment phase can do the magic of
boosting morale and providing momentum to overcome psychological hurdles throughout
the organization.
Show Me The Money
In all fairness to the shareholders, every initiative should aim at producing measurable
economic benefit to a business. Care should be taken to ensure that there is correlation
between the metrics used to monitor improvement efforts and the bottom line. This may
warrant adjustments to the accounting procedures2 to enable the identification of reform
opportunities, drive the right activities and calculate project benefits consistently. In
many cases, gains are realized only after a series of project segments (like a step
function). It is important in such cases to make sure that cost accounting doesn't
disincentives the very activities that culminate into a breakthrough.
Leaders Wanted
More often than not, management is incentivised to minimize risk and preserve the
status quo. Change on the other hand requires creation of a new state of business,
which naturally requires leadership. A paralyzed decision making process (often the
biggest impediment to change) is a symptom of having too many managers and not
enough leaders3. Great leaders transform cultures and stimulate breakthroughs. It is vital
to have a good number of them on one's side as champions of the renewal process.
Strategic changes
Technological Changes
Structural Changes
Behavioural Changes
INTRODUCTION
TO
TATA MOTORS
Tata Motors Limited is India's largest automobile company, with consolidated
revenues of Rs.70,938.85 crores (USD 14 billion) in 2008-09. It is the leader in
commercial vehicles in each segment, and among the top three in passenger vehicles with
winning products in the compact, midsize car and utility vehicle segments. The company
is the world's fourth largest truck manufacturer, and the world's second largest bus
manufacturer.
The company's 24,000 employees are guided by the vision to be "best in the manner in
which we operate, best in the products we deliver, and best in our value system and
ethics."
Established in 1945, Tata Motors' presence indeed cuts across the length and breadth of
India. Over 5.9 million Tata vehicles ply on Indian roads, since the first rolled out in
1954. The company's manufacturing base in India is spread across Jamshedpur
(Jharkhand), Pune (Maharashtra), Lucknow (Uttar Pradesh), Pantnagar (Uttarakhand) and
Dharwad (Karnataka). Following a strategic alliance with Fiat in 2005, it has set up an
industrial joint venture with Fiat Group Automobiles at Ranjangaon (Maharashtra) to
produce both Fiat and Tata cars and Fiat powertrains. The company is establishing a new
plant at Sanand (Gujarat). The company's dealership, sales, services and spare parts
network comprises over 3500 touch points; Tata Motors also distributes and markets Fiat
branded cars in India. Tata Motors, the first company from India's engineering sector to
be listed in the New York Stock Exchange (September 2004), has also emerged as an
international automobile company. Through subsidiaries and associate companies, Tata
Motors has operations in the UK, South Korea, Thailand and Spain. Among them is
Jaguar Land Rover, a business comprising the two iconic British brands that was acquired
in 2008.
Designed with a family in mind, it has a roomy passenger compartment with generous leg
space and head room. It can comfortably seat four persons. Its mono-volume design will
set a new benchmark among small cars. Its safety performance exceeds regulatory
requirements in India. Its tailpipe emission performance too exceeds regulatory
requirements. In terms of overall pollutants, it has a lower pollution level than two-
wheelers being manufactured in India today. The lean design strategy has helped
minimise weight, which helps maximise performance per unit of energy consumed and
delivers high fuel efficiency. The high fuel efficiency also ensures that the car has low
carbon dioxide emissions, thereby providing the twin benefits of an affordable
transportation solution with a low carbon footprint. In May 2009, Tata Motors introduced
ushered in a new era in the Indian automobile industry, in keeping with its pioneering
tradition, by unveiling its new range of world standard trucks called Prima. In their
power, speed, carrying capacity, operating economy and trims, they will introduce new
benchmarks in India and match the best in the world in performance at a lower life-cycle
cost. Tata Motors is equally focussed on environment-friendly technologies in emissions
and alternative fuels. . It has developed electric and hybrid vehicles both for personal and
public transportation. It has also been implementing several environment-friendly
technologies in manufacturing processes, significantly enhancing resource
conservation.
Phase 1:
The key objectives were to move to a system of market pricing and to reduce their break-
even point, both of which called for major reductions in costs—variable costs, fixed
costs, and interest costs. They used many approaches to cost reduction, including bench-
marking our rivals. For example, they took apart vehicles to see what they could do to
modify the products and to lower costs. They went in for e-sourcing, and today they are
the largest company doing e-sourcing in India and one of the leading ones in the
automobile industry worldwide. In two and a half years, they reduced the break-even
from nearly two-thirds of capacity utilization to around onethird, which meant that even
if the market shrank by close to 60 percent, they would still be in the black. The whole
organization really got together to ensure that the bleeding stopped. One of the major
drivers of success at Tata Motors Ltd. (TML) was its ability to fully exploit information
technology to drive business goals and reduce cost. The company was an early adopter of
CAD and CAM systems.
Phase 2:
The concentration in phase one was indeed on cost reduction, but while this was
going on they thought about taking action in areas that would have an impact during the
other phases. For phase two, the concentration was on improving product quality and
upgrading product features so as to make the products more competitive. They also
started work on new products that would be required by the market after three to five
years and strengthened the position in the marketplace by setting up a new salesplanning
process, tightening credit norms, improving the liquidity and profitability of the dealers,
reorienting toward customer satisfaction, and extending the reach of the distribution
network. For phase three, the concentration was on starting work on international markets
by identifying key markets and segments and developing a comprehensive plan to
improve our competitive position so as to get a respectable market share. They also
started looking at opportunities for inorganic growth.
Phase 3:
In phase the concentration was on starting work on international markets by
identifying key markets and segments and developing a comprehensive plan to
improve Tata Motor’s competitive position so as to get a respectable market share. They
also started looking at opportunities for inorganic growth. International diversification
was such a key part of the transformation strategy. It was all part of first, reducing the
impact of domestic cyclicity – cyclicity is present across the world but in different phases
in different places - and, second, seeking new geographies for growth in the face of the
limitations of the domestic market, especially in commercial vehicles, where we enjoy a
very high market share of over 60 percent. Tata Motors wanted to leverage the market-
leading products internationally.
TATA NANO
SWEEPING CHANGE
Tata Nano, the new model introduced by Tata motors, hailed as "the people's car", is an
amazingly cheap car. With a price tag of US$ 2500, Tata Nano is indeed an affordable
middle class family car. Tata Nano is a dream comes true for an average Indian. His /her
ideas about owning and driving a car will become a reality soon. An analysis of the new
car seems necessary as it is bringing mobility to the masses in an efficient and economic
manner.
Ownership cost
It is quite obvious that Tata Nano is cheap to manufacture, but the question is, does
owning and operating a Nano over a period of time yield significant savings and benefits?
While the low-price tag of Nano looks attractive, it is important to look at certain other
factors like the running cost of the car in the long run. Potential buyers need to consider
the rising price of petrol. Petrol prices have breached the US$ 100 mark with no sign of
abating as global demand skyrocketed. The influx of thousands of Tata Nano on Indian
roads would elevate the demand for petrol and this might bring a new dimension to the
continuous hike of petrol price in India, which still depends on the Middle East for oil.
Petrol prices may reach a point where owners of Tata Nano could no longer afford to buy
petrol to run it. If that is the case, Tata Nano owners may leave their cars behind and
resort to riding two-wheelers. In such a scenario, Tata Nano's value proposition may no
longer make an economic sense. The low cost of ownership model championed by Tata
may not remain successful at times of surging energy prices. The would-be owners of
Tata Nano have to consider the cost of replacement parts and service maintenance for the
car during the period of ownership. Tata Nano is built from scratch and most of the
component parts are new and do not share platform with other models in the Tata family.
As a result, it is difficult to assess the vehicle's reliability, durability and parts' longevity.
These factors along with unavailability of the model have made it difficult to estimate the
cost of ownership of Tata Nano and the frequency of service trips. The overall cost of
parts and services of Tata Nano is likely to be at the range of similarly sized car like
Maruti 800. The perception of frequent parts breakdown and shorter service interval due
to sub-standard parts and inferior materials on budget cars may not hold true for Tata
Nano. Tata Nano's component parts are developed and manufactured by reputable
component manufacturers like Bosch, Rico Auto, Lumax Group, Rane Group, Asahi
Glass etc. Moreover, the cost of parts and services is likely to decline as more Tata Nano
cars are driven on the road.
Nano overseas
The rise in petrol prices makes consumers around the world to look for a low cost car.
Tata seems to capture this trend and is looking forward to introduce Tata Nano beyond
Indian shores. One of the countries where Tata Nano is likely to make inroads is
Thailand, dubbed as the 'Detroit of Asia', due to its extensive vehicle manufacturing
activities in ASEAN region.
Thailand has introduced the 'Eco-Car' project, a framework laid by the government to
build green cars that are fuel efficient and cost effective. Vehicle manufacturers all over
the world are invited to submit plans for the Eco-car investment project in Thailand.
Various incentives have been provided for manufacturers of green cars in Thailand,
including exemption from corporate tax for up to eight years and duty exemption for
imported machinery. However, the investment should yield an output of 100,000 units by
the fifth year of production. Such initiative bodes well for Tata Nano. Tata is one of the
seven manufacturers that have submitted applications for the Eco-Car project and its
application has already been approved. Tata might use this plan to export to other
ASEAN countries through the ASEAN free trade area agreement (AFTA).
Unfreezing
Old ideals and processes must be tossed aside so that new ones may be learned. Often,
getting rid of the old processes is just as difficult as learning new ones due to the power
of habits. Just as a teacher erases the old lessons off the chalkboard before beginning a
new lesson, so must a leader help to clear out the old practices before beginning the new.
During this part of the process you need to provide just a little bit of coaching as they are
unlearning not learning and a lot of cheerleading (emotional support) to break the old
habits.
Changing
The steps to the new ideals are learned by practicing:
Wh a t I h e a r , I f o r g e t .
Wh a t I s e e , I r ememb e r .
Wh a t I d o , I u n d e r s t a n d .
Although there will be confusion, overload and despair, there will also be hope,
discovery, and excitement. This period requires a lot of coaching as they are learning and
just a little bit of cheerleading due to the affect of Arousal Overloading.
Refreezing
The new processes are now intellectually and emotionally accepted. What has been
learned is now actually being practiced on the job. Just a little bit of coaching is required
and a lot of cheerleading is used to set up the next change process. . remember it is c o n t
i n u o u s process improvement!
BARRIERS TO CHANGE
The three greatest barriers to organizational change are most often the following.
1. Inadequate Culture-shift Planning. Most companies are good at planning
changes in reporting structure, work area placement, job responsibilities, and
administrative structure. Organizational charts are commonly revised again and again.
Timelines are established, benchmarks are set, transition teams are appointed, etc. Failure
to foresee and plan for resultant cultural change, however, is also common. When the
planning team is too narrowly defined or too focused on objective analysis and critical
thinking, it becomes too easy to lose sight of the fact that the planned change will affect
people. Even at work, people make many decisions on the basis of feelings and intuition.
When the feelings of employees are overlooked, the result is often deep resentment
because some unrecognized taboo or tradition has not been duly respected.
CONCLUSION
Tata Nano achieves what most people deemed impossible through originality and
ingenuity. It is a no frills car that serves the needs of the general public and India's
deplorable road conditions and notorious traffic. In this sense, the production and launch
of Tata Nano can be called a revolution - not only to the consumers but also to industry
players. Other players are contemplating on their own versions of low cost alternatives as
a result of the overwhelming response from the Indian public and all over the world
during the pre-launching ceremony. Moreover, their skepticism is met with a surprise
upon seeing the model in action. The next step forward for Tata is to address the possible
concerns with regard to ownership in order for customers to grasp the value proposition
that Tata is trying to propagate. This includes dispelling all perceptions of shortcomings
normally associated with a low-cost car through vigorous testing on real roads using real
users. The basic rule of customer service still applies. Tata Nano should meet the
consumer's expectations by providing a reliable
and modestly safe vehicle to drive. The car, with its immense recognition gained even
before its launch, is expected to fulfil the dreams of common people.
SUGGESTIONS
1. Feedback: This involves the awareness of oneself, others, group
processes and organizational dynamics. Awareness leads to change if the
feedback is not too threatening.