0% found this document useful (0 votes)

236 views56 pages

Dennis Kucinich Lawsuit Against The Plain Dealer

Dennis Kucinich lawsuit against The Plain Dealer

Uploaded by

WKYC.com

We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.

Available Formats

Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

0% found this document useful (0 votes)

236 views56 pages

Dennis Kucinich Lawsuit Against The Plain Dealer

Dennis Kucinich lawsuit against The Plain Dealer

Uploaded by

WKYC.com

We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.

Available Formats

Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

You are on page 1/ 56

IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS

CUYAHOGA COUNTY, OHIO

DENNIS JOHN KUCINICH ) CASE NO.:

c/o Counsel )
Minc LLC ) JUDGE:
200 Park Avenue, Suite 200 )
Orange Village, Ohio 44122 )
) COMPLAINT
Plaintiff, )
) JURY DEMAND ENDORSED
v. ) HEREON
)
PLAIN DEALER PUBLISHING CO., )
dba THE PLAIN DEALER )
4800 Tiedeman Rd. )
Brooklyn, Ohio 44144 )
)
and )
)
ADVANCE LOCAL MEDIA, LLC )
1 World Trade Center, 39th Floor )
New York, New York, 10007 )
)
and )
)
ADVANCE OHIO, LLC )
1801 Superior Ave. #100 )
Cleveland, OH 44114 )
)
and )
)
CHRIS QUINN )
4800 Tiedeman Rd. )
Brooklyn, Ohio 44144 )
)
and )
)
JOHN CANIGLIA )
4800 Tiedeman Rd. )
Brooklyn, Ohio 44144 )
)
and )
)
)
)
SETH RICHARDSON )
4800 Tiedeman Rd. )
Brooklyn, Ohio 44144 )
)
Defendants. )

Plaintiff, Dennis Kucinich, by and through counsel, for his Complaint against Defendants,
Plain Dealer Publishing Co., dba The Plain Dealer, Advance Local Media, LLC, Advance Ohio,
LLC, Chris Quinn, John Caniglia, and Seth Richardson (hereinafter the “Defendants”) states as
follows:

PARTIES, JURISDICTION, AND VENUE

1. Plaintiff Dennis Kucinich (“Plaintiff”) is a resident of Cuyahoga County and was a
resident of Cuyahoga County at all times relevant to the instant dispute.

2. Defendant, Plain Dealer Publishing Co., dba The Plain Dealer, is a corporation
organized under the laws of the state of Ohio.

3. Defendant Advance Local Media, LLC is a foreign limited liability company

organized under the laws of the State of New York and, upon information and belief, is the owner
of the Internet domain name, Cleveland.com.

4. Defendant Advance Ohio, LLC is a limited liability company organized under the
laws of the State of Ohio. Upon information and belief, Defendant Advance Ohio, LLC is a wholly
owned subsidiary of Advance Local Media, LLC.

5. Defendant Chris Quinn is the Editor of Cleveland.com and Vice President of

Content at Advance Ohio, and upon information and belief, is a resident of Cuyahoga County.

6. Defendant John Caniglia is a general assignment reporter at Cleveland.com and,

upon information and belief, is a resident of Cuyahoga County.

7. Defendant Seth Richardson is a political reporter at Cleveland.com and the

Cleveland Plain Dealer, and upon information and belief, is a resident of Cuyahoga County.

8. At all times mentioned herein, Defendants Quinn, Caniglia, and Richardson were
acting within the course and scope of their employment for Defendants Plain Dealer, Advance
Local Media LLC, and Advance Ohio LLC.

9. At all times mentioned herein, Defendants acted knowingly, maliciously, and

intentionally, pursuant to an agreed upon plan and purpose to request, procure, solicit, and to aid
and abet the publication of false and defamatory accusations against Plaintiff.

2
10. This Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter and parties of this action as it is
where the actions and injuries complained of herein have primarily occurred.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
11. Plaintiff Dennis Kucinich is a former presidential candidate, a 16-year member of
the United States Congress, Ohio State Senator, Mayor of the City of Cleveland, Clerk of the
Cleveland Municipal Court, and member of the Cleveland City Council. He is also a television
news analyst and author 1. He has spent over one-half of a century developing his good name,
reputation, and brand to become known both nationally and internationally, as a highly respected
and devoted public servant who served his city, state, and nation honorably.

12. Central to Plaintiff’s reputation and legacy is the time he served as Mayor of
Cleveland from 1977 to 1979, for which he is known for courageously putting his career on the
line to save the city’s municipal power system, The Cleveland Municipal Light System (which is
now Cleveland Public Power), from a takeover by the utility monopoly The Cleveland Electric
Illuminating Company (whose successor is now FirstEnergy Corp.).

13. Plaintiff’s valiant efforts opposing the sale of The Cleveland Municipal Light
System have been recognized multiple times over the years by the Cleveland City Council, which
on October 21, 1996, awarded Plaintiff special recognition by recommending that all or part of
Cleveland Public Power should be named after Plaintiff, and again on December 14, 1998, by
passing a resolution which stated in part,
“….Today the City of Cleveland has one of the fastest growing municipal
electric systems in America. Currently, Cleveland Public Power is
expanding to provide low-cost electricity to more and more people,
providing power for city facilities and streetlights, thereby helping to keep
taxes low and encouraging economic development. None of this would have
been possible had Mayor Kucinich not refused to sell the city’s electric
system on December 15, 1978: now, therefore, be it resolved that Cleveland
City Council hereby extends its deep appreciation to Dennis J. Kucinich,
for having the courage and foresight to refuse to sell the City’s municipal
electric system, which has saved the people of Cleveland over $300 million
since that time.”
14. In February of 2021, Plaintiff was actively exploring the possibility of running
again for mayor of Cleveland. For purposes of this political exploration, his political campaign
accepted lawful and appropriate financial contributions from Plaintiff’s political backers,
including a longtime friend of his for over 30 years, Tony George (“Mr. George”), who also
donated to three other Mayoral candidates.

1
Plaintiff’s most recent book, The Division of Light and Power, published in June of 2021, is his 684-page
documented story of his fight to save public power in Cleveland.

3
15. Defendants learned about Mr. George’s contributions from public campaign
disclosures required by Ohio Law. Defendants did not want Plaintiff to run for or become the
Mayor of Cleveland again. So, Defendants tried to stop Plaintiff from successfully running by
targeting and defaming Plaintiff’s reputation. Primarily by tying and associating Plaintiff to
FirstEnergy Corp. (“FirstEnergy”), which was at the time, and still is, embroiled in the largest
alleged racketeering and bribery scandal in Ohio’s history.

16. Significantly, Defendants’ intentions and dislike of Plaintiff are not a secret. In the
course of events, Defendants published articles “passionate[ly]” advocating to the public that
“[w]hatever you do, don’t vote for Dennis Kucinich.” They baselessly claimed that Plaintiff was
“remarkabl[y] ignorant of municipal finance” and engaged in “constant violence-mongering.”
Defendants also published a column with a headline that stated that the most “narrow and clear
path” to successfully stop Plaintiff “from returning as Cleveland’s Mayor … require[d]
targeting his reputation.” See Exhibits 1 and 2, attached. This evidence is only the tip of the
iceberg.

17. On February 5, 2021, in furtherance of this plan, Defendants drafted, edited,

published, and then broadcast on the homepage of Cleveland.com a story, which began: “Dennis
Kucinich, who made his name saving Cleveland Public Power’s predecessor, is exploring another
run for Cleveland mayor with the financial backing of CPP’s adversary, the scandal-immersed
FirstEnergy.”

18. That same day, Defendants also stated in a live podcast broadcast from their website
called “This Week in CLE,” that according to “campaign finance records…. Kucinich took a
significant amount of money from FirstEnergy….”. Defendants mocked Plaintiff on the podcast
while reporting that Plaintiff also said, ‘No one buys my friendship.” They laughed while stating
how “overwhelming[ly]” ironic it was that other candidates could now use Plaintiff’s “ties to
First Energy as a reason not to vote for him” when his “most famous moment was standing
up to the precursors of these two utilities to protect CPP.”

19. To be clear, any allegation that Plaintiff took money from FirstEnergy or consorted
with FirstEnergy was completely erroneous. Defendants made these accusations intentionally and
with knowledge of their falsity. Defendant Caniglia interviewed Plaintiff prior to publishing his
allegations. He could have easily asked Plaintiff a determinative question to confirm the truth or
falsity of the allegation. However, upon information and belief, Defendant Caniglia intentionally
and recklessly failed to ask Plaintiff about his story’s false and defamatory hook, i.e., whether the
Plaintiff or his campaign did in fact receive financial backing for his mayoral campaign from First
Energy.

20. Shortly after the publication of the article, Plaintiff brought the falsity of these
statements to Defendants’ attention. In response, Defendants authored and published updates to
their publications.

4
21. For example, on and around February 8, 2021, Defendants unpublished their
podcast episode recording from appearing on Cleveland.com and replaced it with a version which
removed the accusation and added a new twenty-second audio retraction that stated:

“Quick editor’s note, the original version of this podcast episode incorrectly said
that Dennis Kucinich took a significant amount of money from FirstEnergy.
Neither Kucinich nor his campaign received money from FirstEnergy. The
incorrect statement has been edited out of the episode.” 2

22. Defendants also revised and updated the language of their article, attached as
Exhibit 3, to include the following Editor’s note from Defendant Chris Quinn, which stated that:

“…[T]he original version of this story incorrectly stated Dennis Kucinich is

exploring a run for Mayor with the financial backing of FirstEnergy Corp.
Kucinich’s campaign received no money from FirstEnergy Corp.”

23. However, even with these updates, Defendants’ podcast and article still states and
purposely gives the false and defamatory impression that Plaintiff consorts with FirstEnergy. It
also intentionally puts Plaintiff in a false light that he somehow consorts with FirstEnergy Corp.
or is associated with its alleged bribery scandal, which makes him a corrupt politician.

24. On September 3, 2021, Defendants again authored, edited, and published a story,
both on Cleveland.com and in the Plain Dealer, regarding Plaintiff receiving an additional
campaign contribution from Mr. George. The article falsely claimed that Mr. George was directly
“connected to the ongoing [FirstEnergy] scandal.” See Exhibit 4, attached. The stated inference
being that Plaintiff is associated with Mr. George, who Defendants try to tie to the bribery scandal,
putting him in a false light as consorting with FirstEnergy and being associated with its bribery
scandal. Defendants made these inferences intentionally and with actual malice.

25. The statements contained in the February 5, 2021 and September 3, 2021 articles,
as well as the statements made on the February 5, 2021 podcast, will hereinafter be referred to as
the “False Statements”.

26. Upon good faith, information and belief, thousands of individuals and numerous
media outlets and websites picked up on all of the articles and reports posted on Cleveland.com
mentioned above and they republished and repeated their allegations against Plaintiff, thus
exposing millions of people to Defendants’ falsehoods and erroneous narrative.

2
This week in CLE – Feb. 5, 2021 Why Donald Trump – not Gov. Mike DeWine – should get
credit for Ohio nursing home vaccinations, https://www.listennotes.com/podcasts/today-in-
ohio/this-week-in-the-cle-feb-5-g6TC_ER5W7d/.
5
27. As a natural and foreseeable consequence of Defendants’ action, Plaintiff having
been portrayed by Defendants exactly the opposite as his history and career has demonstrated, has
suffered, and continues to suffer severe mental and emotional distress in that Cleveland.com
attacked the central life accomplishment of Plaintiff’s career, his extraordinary advocacy of public
power. Plaintiff’s good will, credibility as a public power advocate and author, and his commercial
value and brand have been substantially harmed as a result.

28. As a direct result of Defendants’ False Statements to the public, Plaintiff has and
continues to suffer actual harm and special damages to his reputation. Including, but not limited
to, diminution in value to his brand and good will, decreases in expected book sales, and damage
and negative financial effects to personal and professional relationships of long-time friends, allies,
backers, and supporters, like David Kelley and Tristan Rader, and from Ohio environmental
groups and/or their leaders. Longtime supporters of Plaintiff’s campaigns and political career read
the allegations in the article and the allegations negatively affected their opinion of Plaintiff, both
personally and as a political candidate.

29. Plaintiff is informed and believes and alleges thereon that unless enjoined and
restrained, the Defendants will continue to post, publish, distribute, disseminate and exploit such
fictitious narratives and demands that the Defendants cease and desist. Such infringement and
violation of Plaintiff’s rights will continue to cause Plaintiff severe emotional distress and damage,
for which there is no adequate remedy at law, as the false narrative continues to circulate. Such
conduct and activity by the Defendants will continue to cause Plaintiff to suffer irreparable harm
for which there is no adequate remedy at law.
COUNT ONE
Libel Per Se and Libel Per Quod

30. Plaintiff incorporates the allegations and averments previously set forth as if fully
restated herein.

31. On or about February 5, 2021, Defendants published an article to Cleveland.com

titled, “Dennis Kucinich fuels possible run for Cleveland mayor with money from longtime
FirstEnergy supporter Tony George.”

32. In the original version of the article, Defendants falsely and maliciously asserted:
“Dennis Kucinich, who made his name saving Cleveland Public Power’s predecessor, is exploring
another run for Cleveland mayor with the financial backing of CPP’s adversary, the scandal-
immersed FirstEnergy.”

33. The original version of the article was subsequently revised to read: “Dennis
Kucinich, who made his name saving Cleveland Public Power’s predecessor, is exploring another
run for Cleveland mayor with the financial backing of a businessman closely aligned with CPP’s
adversary, the scandal-immersed FirstEnergy Corp.”

6
34. At the time of the article’s publication, and to this day, neither Plaintiff, nor
Plaintiff’s campaign, have ever received any mayoral campaign contributions from FirstEnergy.
Plaintiff has never been connected to, in any way, the House Bill 6 scandal.

35. At the time of the original publication, the Defendants knew these statements were
false, or demonstrated reckless disregard for the truth, as Defendants were well aware of Plaintiff’s
history with FirstEnergy and that Plaintiff had built his reputation and career around his actions
which were averse to FirstEnergy and its predecessor The Cleveland Electric Illuminating
Company. Neither Plaintiff, nor his campaign, had received any campaign contributions from
FirstEnergy, despite the Defendants’ false assertion otherwise.

36. Defendants’ conduct in publishing the false statements in the articles and podcast
was far below acceptable journalistic and newspaper industry standards and Defendants committed
these actions intentionally and with malice.

37. As a direct and proximate result Defendants’ libel, Plaintiff has suffered special
damages, including several instances where long-time supporters of Plaintiff and his political
campaigns had their view of Plaintiff negatively affected, and chose not to further support Plaintiff
and his campaign.

38. As a direct and proximate result of Defendants’ libel, Plaintiff has suffered and
sustained damages, including but not limited to expenses incurred, significant reputational harm,
emotional distress, mental anguish, special damages, and a decrease in the commercial value of
Plaintiff’s reputation.

COUNT TWO
Slander and Slander Per Se

39. Plaintiff incorporates the allegations and averments previously set forth as if fully
restated herein.

40. On or about February 5, 2021, Defendants published an episode of the “This Week
in the CLE” podcast on Cleveland.com in which Defendants doubled-down on the written
defamation against Plaintiff by stating that campaign finance records required to be filed with the
Cuyahoga County Board of Elections were released which showed that the Plaintiff had taken “a
significant amount of money from FirstEnergy….”

41. Defendants intentionally and maliciously made these false statements on the
podcast in an effort to lend credibility to the written version of the story.

42. The campaign finance records referenced by the Defendants do not show that
Plaintiff or his campaign had taken “a significant amount of money from FirstEnergy. . ..” Neither
Plaintiff nor his mayoral campaign had taken any campaign contributions at all from FirstEnergy.

7
43. The segment of the podcast containing the spoken defamatory statements remained
active on Cleveland.com and available to the public for several days before it was ultimately
deleted by Defendants with the following explanation: “The original version of this podcast
episode incorrectly said that Dennis Kucinich took a significant amount of money from
FirstEnergy. Neither Kucinich nor his mayoral campaign received money from FirstEnergy. The
incorrect statement has been edited out of the episode.”

44. At the time of the publication of the podcast, the Defendants knew these statements
were false, or demonstrated reckless disregard for the truth, as Defendants were well aware of
Plaintiff’s history with FirstEnergy and that Plaintiff had built his reputation and career around his
actions which were averse to FirstEnergy. Neither Plaintiff, nor his campaign, have received any
campaign contributions from FirstEnergy, despite the Defendants’ false assertion otherwise.

45. Defendants’ conduct in publishing the false statements in the articles and podcast
was far below acceptable journalistic and newspaper industry standards and Defendants committed
these actions intentionally and with malicious intent.

46. As a direct and proximate result of the Defendants’ libel, Plaintiff has suffered
special damages, including several instances where long-time supporters of Plaintiff and his
political campaigns had their view of Plaintiff negatively affected, and chose not to further support
Plaintiff and his campaign.

47. As a direct and proximate result of the Defendants’ slander, Plaintiff has suffered
and sustained damages, including but not limited to expenses incurred, significant reputational
harm, emotional distress, mental anguish, special damages, and a decrease in the commercial value
of Plaintiff’s reputation.
COUNT THREE
Libel and Slander by Implication

48. Plaintiff incorporates the allegations and averments previously set forth as if fully
restated herein.

49. The False Statements authored and published by Defendants constitute defamation
by implication as they intentionally make the inference that Plaintiff had material ties to, and
political financial backing from, FirstEnergy, a corporation who Plaintiff built his career and
reputation on fighting.

50. The False Statements authored and published by Defendants further constitute
defamation by implication as they intentionally mislead readers, and voters in Cuyahoga County,
to believe that Plaintiff consorted with FirstEnergy and their misdeeds, and is therefore a corrupt
politician, and was involved in the largest bribery scandal in Ohio history.

8
51. The False Statements were read, and listened to, by visitors to the Cleveland.com
website, readers of the Plain Dealer, and numerous residents and registered voters of the City of
Cleveland and Cuyahoga County.

52. Plaintiff is informed and believes, and upon that basis, asserts that the False
Statements were written and published with malice in that those publications were made with
knowledge of the false impression they would create, or with reckless disregard as to the same.

53. Defendants conduct in publishing the False Statements was far below acceptable
journalistic and newspaper industry standards and Defendants committed these actions
intentionally and with malicious intent.

54. As a direct and proximate result Defendants’ libel, Plaintiff has suffered special
damages, including several instances where long-time supporters of Plaintiff and his political
campaigns had their view of Plaintiff negatively affected, and chose not to further support Plaintiff
and his campaign.

55. As a direct and proximate result of Defendants’ slander, Plaintiff has suffered and
sustained damages, including but not limited to expenses incurred, significant reputational harm,
emotional distress, mental anguish, special damages, and a decrease in the commercial value of
Plaintiff’s reputation.
COUNT FOUR
False Light

56. Plaintiff incorporates the allegations and averments previously set forth as if fully
restated herein

57. In addition to the other statements authored and published by Defendants, on

September 3, 2021, Defendants published another article in the Plain Dealer and to Cleveland.com
which insinuated that Plaintiff had taken money from entities directly connected to the House Bill
6 scandal. The Richardson article was published within eight (8) days before the primary election
on the mayoral race.

58. Defendants published the False Statements intentionally and maliciously to place
Plaintiff in a false light, as Mr. George, cited in the article has never been connected to the House
Bill 6 scandal, and had donated to several other candidates in the mayoral race. In the referenced
articles and podcast, Defendants did not attempt to connect any other mayoral candidate who
received political contributions from Tony George to the House Bill 6 scandal.

59. The Defendants intentionally gave publicity to the False Statements by publishing
them in written form on Cleveland.com and the Plain Dealer and by further promoting and
advancing the defamatory statements in a podcast published on Cleveland.com.

9
60. All of Defendants’ False Statements placed Plaintiff in a false light, i.e., that he
and/or his campaign ever sought to receive or did, in fact, receive political campaign funds from
FirstEnergy and/or in connection with the House Bill 6 scandal.

61. The implication created by Defendants’ articles is that Plaintiff consorted with
FirstEnergy and their misdeeds, is therefore a corrupt politician, and was involved in the largest
bribery scandal in Ohio history.

62. Defendants had knowledge, or acted in reckless disregard, as to the false light in
which Plaintiff would be placed by the defamatory statements contained in the article and podcast.

63. Defendants’ conduct in publishing the false statements in the articles and podcast
was far below acceptable journalistic and newspaper industry standards and Defendants committed
these actions intentionally and with malicious intent.

64. As a direct and proximate result of Defendants’ actions, Plaintiff has suffered and
sustained damages, including but not limited to expenses incurred, significant reputational harm,
emotional distress, mental anguish, special damages, and a decrease in the commercial value of
Plaintiff’s reputation.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff Dennis Kucinich demands judgment against Defendants, jointly
and severally, as follows:

(a) Actual and/or compensatory damages, and punitive damages where available, in an
amount exceeding $25,000.00 with the exact about to be proven at trial;

(b) Costs of this action, reasonable attorney fees, and pre- and post-litigation interest
at the maximum rate provided by law;

(c) Issuance by this Court of an Order decreeing that the Statements are false,
defamatory, and place Defendant in a false light;

(d) For any and all other relief to which the Court determines Plaintiffs are entitled.

Respectfully submitted,

/s/ Aaron M. Minc .

Aaron M. Minc (0086718)
Andrew C. Stebbins (0086387)
Michael Pelagalli (0093995)
Minc LLC
200 Park Avenue, Suite 200
Orange Village, Ohio 44122
Phone: (216) 373-7706

10
Fax: (440) 792-5327
Email: [email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]

11
JURY DEMAND

Plaintiff Dennis Kucinich hereby demands a trial by jury pursuant to Civil Rule 38.

/s/ Aaron M. Minc .

Aaron M. Minc (0086718)
Andrew C. Stebbins (0086387)
Attorney for Plaintiff

12
A Page Vault
Document
Document title:
title: We
We endorse
endorse Justin
Justin Bibb
Bibb for
for mayor
mayor of
of Cleveland:
Cleveland: Editorial
Editorial board,
board, cleveland.com
cleveland.com and
and
The
The Plain
Plain Dealer
Dealer -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com

Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/we-endorse-justin-bibb-for-mayor-of-
https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/we-endorse-justin-bibb-for-mayor-of-
cleveland-editorial-board.html
cleveland-editorial-board.html

Page
Page loaded
loaded at
at (UTC):
(UTC): Tue,
Tue, 16
16 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 18:08:42
18:08:42 GMT
GMT

Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Tue,
Tue, 16
16 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 18:16:30
18:16:30 GMT
GMT

Capture
Capture tool:
tool: v7.13.2
v7.13.2

Collection
Collection server
server IP:
IP: 34.230.137.168
34.230.137.168

Browser
Browser engine:
engine: Chrome/77.0.3865.120
Chrome/77.0.3865.120

Operating
Operating system:
system: Microsoft
Microsoft Windows
Windows NT
NT 10.0.17763.0
10.0.17763.0 (10.0.17763.0)
(10.0.17763.0)

PDF
PDF length:
length: 12
12

Capture
Capture ID:
ID: e42c5513-9699-4c68-9611-1d9550a39db8
e42¢5513-9699-4¢c68-9611-1d9550a39db8

User:
User: drl-mhughes
drl-mhughes

Exhibit 1

PDF REFERENCE
PDF REFERENCE #:
#: kVi i hYsCnEj uL5LTar eKpg
kViihYsCnEjuL5LTareKpg
— le] Set weather VV (C} cClevela d.com
NORTH
AD) Account V

\ATVSRV 0TH g (=TTo MRSS Col g (=I o TUN or=| (== 10 To 1 U) SO yo To TU (oR /o IR A D1 RST o Sw 1 o LSM (oo
EE) YA

THOUGHT IT WAS CONE?

WE SHOP THE Sou FOR ALL
OF THE HARD TO FIND ITEMS.

: BY
Diviliie hours S — /
6770 BROOKPARK ROAD Mon-Sat: 10-7pm « Sun: 11-5pm BY ror pimicrions

Opinion

We endorse Justin Bibb for mayor of Cleveland:

Editorial board, cleveland.com and The Plain
Dealer
Published: Aug. 08, 2021. 5:25 a.m.

&» State Farm

DEICER GEIR]
any budget.’

In this pivotal moment for Cleveland. the first mayoral election in 20 years
without an incumbent. Justin Bibb is the candidate with the vision for the
successful city we wish to be: Editorial board. cleveland.com and The Plain
Dealer.

f ¥
By Editorial board, cleveland.com and The Plain Dealer “Individual premiums and budgets wil vary by customer.
Al applicants subject to State Farm underwriting requirements.

Promise. Vision. Hope. Elections for mayor in major cities are

about so much more than choosing leaders. They are those
rare moments when we envision the great communities we Recommended for You
wish to be, when we define ourselves through the people we
mealond ta nn en Madbliv | mémmé Datimade

Promise. Vision. Hope. Elections for mayor in major cities are

about so much more than choosing leaders. They are those
rare moments when we envision the great communities we Recommended for You

wish to be, when we define ourselves through the people we

select to serve. Netflix Latest Rounds
Of Cancellations and
Renewals, See The List
In this pivotal moment for Cleveland, the first mayoral election bonvoyaged.com

in 20 years without an incumbent, we believe the candidate

with the vision for the successful city we wish to be is Justin
Browns
Bibb. disappointment - the
same old, same old
cleveland.com

The Most Iconic

Swimsuit Moments in
Movie History

POLO
Harpers Bazaar

RALPH LAUREN Are Nick Chubb and

Kareem Hunt the
SHOP NOW
Browns’ most
important offensive...
cleveland.com

{S POWERED BY CONCERT FEEDBACK | &¥

Sportscasters Salaries
Finally Released
We feel so strongly about this endorsement that we're taking Gameday News

the rare step of publishing it on the front page of The Plain

Dealer.
Cleveland Guardians
name dispute
We endorse Bibb because of his ideas for fighting crime, with resolved; baseball
more efficient deployment of safety forces and better training club and roller derby...
{ cleveland.com
for them before and after they are hired. We endorse Bibb
because of his collaborative approach to building the Cleveland Promoted Links by Taboola

economy. We endorse Bibb because no candidate has worked

harder to understand the challenges of the city or study
solutions across the country.

Bibb is young and inexperienced, no doubt. He's 34 and never

held elective office. But talk to the leaders of non-profit [>]
ETHOS

agencies in this town, or business leaders, or neighborhood

leaders. They all know him. He's been talking to them for years. S AT&T
More important: He's been listening as they discuss their
challenges. AT&T Unlimited Elite®

With unlimited
Challenges are the heart of this election. Reducing violent high-speed
crime. Recovering from the pandemic. Reimagining a EYEE ELE)
no extra cost
downtown core with fewer workers. Speeding up the
transformation of the schools. Eradicating lead paint and lead Learn more
Offer Detais >
in water pipes. Reducing infant mortality. Cutting into
multigeneration poverty.

And giving people hope. We need hope.

in water pipes. Reducing infant mortality. Cutting into

multigeneration poverty.

And giving people hope. We need hope.

S AT&T

AT&T Unlimited Elite®

With unlimited
high-speed
data and 5G at
P 0 I, 0 pS 3 no extra cost
RALPH LAUREN f Learn more
Offer Detais >

SHOP NOW

{5 POWERED BY CONCERT FEEDBACK | £}

Based on the connections Bibb has made across many sectors

of the community, we think he is in the best position of all the
candidates to attract the powerhouse cabinet needed to guide
the city forward, the kind of cabinet Michael R. White attracted
when he was the underdog candidate Clevelanders elected to
renew their hopes, way back in 1989. We think Bibb would
sweep into office with the same vigor and innovative thinking
that White displayed. It's no surprise that Bibb has had
conversations with White.

Related coverage: Read the opening statements that

Cleveland mayoral candidates submitted during the
endorsement process.

We are passionate about this endorsement, but we are equally

passionate — if not more so -- in what we say next: Whatever
you do, don't vote for Dennis Kucinich. As much as we believe
Bibb offers a grand hope for the future, we believe Kucinich is
not relevant to our future challenges.

Kucinich is the youngest person ever to serve as mayor — 42

years ago — and is campaigning as if it were still the 1970s. He
has repeatedly pandered, seizing on the news of the day to
make reckless promises and grandstand. He has shown a
remarkable level of ignorance of municipal finance and baited
residents with constant violence-mongering.

Most frightening, though, is that Kucinich says he would have

squandered the entirety of the city’s reserves and rainy day
fund last year — more than $70 million — to hire 400 additional
police officers. Mayor Frank Jackson has deftly guided
Cleveland through challenging financial times these last 16
years, leaving the city with the cash it needs to fend off crises.
Kucinich would deplete it in an instant, leaving the city
vulnerable.

Document
Document title:
title: We
We endorse
endorse Justin
Justin Bibb
Bibb for
for mayor
mayor of
of Cleveland:
Cleveland: Editorial
Editorial board,
board, cleveland.com
cleveland.com and
and The
The Plain
Plain Dealer
Dealer -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/we-endorse-justin-bibb-for-mayor-of-cleveland-editorial-board.html
https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/we-endorse-justin-bibb-for-mayor-of-cleveland-editorial-board.html
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Tue,
Tue, 1616 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 18:16:30
18:16:30 GMT
GMT Page
Page 33 of
of 11
11
fund last year — more than $70 million — to hire 400 additional
police officers. Mayor Frank Jackson has deftly guided
Cleveland through challenging financial times these last 16
years, leaving the city with the cash it needs to fend off crises. Advertisement
Kucinich would deplete it in an instant, leaving the city S ater
vulnerable.
AT&T Unlimited Elite®
And hiring 400 additional police officers is not the solution for With unlimited
the city’s violence problem. Nor is that hiring sustainable. high-speed
Public safety is the biggest cost in a city budget that always is
EYEE ELE)
no extra cost
tight. Adding tens of millions in extra costs to that budget is
ridiculous. Learn more
Offer Detais >

Aside from Kucinich, we are heartened by the quality of most of

the candidates vying for mayor. They have rich backgrounds
and offer clearly differing visions and strategies, meaning
voters have genuine choices to make.

If Bibb were not in this race, our endorsement would go to City

Council President Kevin Kelley, who has the greatest knowledge
of how the city works. He has demonstrated visionary thinking
with his work to provide lawyers to impoverished families
facing eviction and to combat the city’s inexcusable infant
mortality rate. A decade ago, Kelley worked to provide free
broadband in his ward, putting him way ahead of the curve on
what is now seen as a vital public service. Kelley is a true public
servant, and he offers plenty of ideas for tackling Cleveland's
challenges. The knock on him is that he has been council
president for eight years, so why didn’t he use that powerful
position to tackle Cleveland's challenges the last eight years?
It's a question that causes doubts about his leadership skills.

[FAN PI ol & I PARI UA gD

SHOP NOW

{S POWERED BY CONCERT FEEDBACK | &¥

State Senator Sandra Williams is another strong candidate.

Early in her career she worked as a parole and probation officer
for juvenile offenders, giving her unique perspective on the
violent crime that has become the top issue in the mayor's
race. Since 2007, she has served in the Ohio Statehouse, as a
representative and senator, immersed in discussions on many
issues affecting the city. Like Bibb and Kelley, she fully
understands the city's challenges and deficiencies. Williams,

violent crime that has become the top issue in the mayor's
race. Since 2007, she has served in the Ohio Statehouse, as a
representative and senator, immersed in discussions on many
Advertisement
issues affecting the city. Like Bibb and Kelley, she fully
understands the city's challenges and deficiencies. Williams, S Arex
however, is that rare candidate for whom we rescinded an ATET Unlimited Elite®
endorsement. In 2014, we endorsed her run for the state TH HT UNLIMITED
Senate but rescinded our recommendation after she misled high-speed |ararss |
the editorial board about the nature and seriousness of data and 5G at Ome |
. i. . . . Lo . no extra cost
campaign filing violations for which she was being investigated. HBOMAX
Integrity matters. We also are troubled by her role as one of the Learn more
oF:
few Democrats to support the corrupt House Bill 6.

We find less to like in City Councilman Basheer Jones, who has

parlayed his popularity as a former deejay to be a top
contender. He's a charismatic communicator who wins people
over with the power of his words. The more he talks, though,
the clearer it becomes that he has not done the work needed to
be mayor. He does not offer many concrete ideas for governing,
and he has not been a force in his first term as a City Council
member. He missed many of the council's meetings, even
though they were virtual, depriving himself of the chance to
learn more about the city he wishes to govern. We're also
concerned by a speech he once made, long available on
YouTube, in which described the role of women as inferior to
men. Jones, unlike Bibb, has not built the relationships needed
to fortify City Hall with the strong cabinet he would need to
help govern.

Former longtime City Councilman Zack Reed has focused his

campaign on public safety, repeating the strategy he used four
years ago to emerge from the field as the general election
challenger to Frank Jackson, who beat Reed handily. Reed has
fully considered ideas about using violence counselors to work
with the community, a strategy that has had success in other
cities. But we don't believe Reed has what it takes to lead. In his
years at the City Council, he was a fire thrower, always ready
with a criticism about city services and functions, but he didn’t
roll up his sleeves to collaborate with his colleagues on
solutions. This city needs a collaborative leader.

Finally, we have West Park attorney Ross DiBello, whose biggest

obstacle is his obscurity, which he helped preserve by being the
only candidate to decline participation in an endorsement
interview with our Editorial Board. We see nothing in DiBello’s
background or his campaign to offer voters confidence that he
would be a competent mayor.

Our choice is Bibb. The energy he would bring to a City Hall in

need of a jolt and the work he has done to strategize for that
jolt are exciting. Bibb is the embodiment of the hope, vision and
promise that this election is about, and we strongly urge voters

Our choice is Bibb. The energy he would bring to a City Hall in

need of a jolt and the work he has done to strategize for that
jolt are exciting. Bibb is the embodiment of the hope, vision and
promise that this election is about, and we strongly urge voters S Aer
to select him. AT&T Unlimited Elite®

With unlimited
high-speed
EYEE ELE)
no extra cost

Learn more
Offer Detais >

NAY PH dl I FRAN UN 1 DRY

SHOP NOW

{5 POWERED BY CONCERT FEEDBACK | &}

Six of the seven candidates contending in the Sept. 14

Cleveland nonpartisan mayoral primary were interviewed by
the editorial board of The Plain Dealer and cleveland.com June
14 as part of its endorsement process.

Listen to that endorsement interview here or via the player

below:

Cleveland Mayoral endorsement - 01:50:15 ™

About our editorials: Editorials express the view of the

Editorial Board of cleveland.com and The Plain Dealer -- the
senior leadership and editorial-writing staff. As is traditional,
editorials are unsigned and intended to be seen as the voice of
the news organization.

Have something to say about this topic?

* Send a letter to the editor, which will be considered for print

publication.

* Email general questions about our editorial board or

comments or corrections on this endorsement editorial to
Elizabeth Sullivan, director of opinion, at
[email protected].

Note to readers: if you purchase something through one of our affiliate links we may earn a
commission.

Around the Web Tabla Feed

=T Nr

AT&T Unlimited Elite® - .

With unlimited wie"

high-speed |warss
EYEE ELE)
no extra cost lo]
HBOMAX

=Ol =o]
268
Learn more
Offer Detais >
Cadillac's Thrilling New Lineup Is Finally Here
2021 Cadillac SUVS | Search Ads | Sponsored

These Cars Are So Loaded It's Here Are The 25 Coolest Gifts
Hard to Believe They're So... of 2021
Luxury SUVs | Search Ads | Sponsored Amazing Deals | Sponsored

No Offense, But These 2 Big Retailers Aren't The

Cheapest Places To Shop
MoneyWise.com
| Sponsored

Fnsurance CoMPANPY « run40,

| © con y
2amny a an, ed
ry
Cwm pa FTE
4x

40000005 156 HHI

ori

Medicare Recipients Are In For The Tequila Market Size Will

A Big Surprise This Week Surpass $14.70B by 2028....
Finance Daily
| Sponsored AsomBroso | Sponsored

a
Document
Document title:
title: We
We endorse
endorse Justin
Justin Bibb
Bibb for
for mayor
mayor of
of Cleveland:
Cleveland: Editorial
Editorial board,
board, cleveland.com
cleveland.com and
and The
The Plain
Plain Dealer
Dealer -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/we-endorse-justin-bibb-for-mayor-of-cleveland-editorial-board.html
https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/we-endorse-justin-bibb-for-mayor-of-cleveland-editorial-board.html
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Tue,
Tue, 1616 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 18:16:30
18:16:30 GMT
GMT Page
Page 77 of
of 11
11
WITUILAIT NTULIYITIIWD AIT 1 rwvi HIT ITYUIA VIAINTL J1£T vvil

A Big Surprise This Week Surpass $14.70B by 2028....

Finance Daily
| Sponsored AsomBroso | Sponsored

=T Nr

AT&T Unlimited Elite®

With unlimited
high-speed
EYEE ELE)
no extra cost

Learn more
Offer Detais >

Bitcoin for beginners: what you need to know before

buying Bitcoin
eToro Crypto Updates | Sponsored

This Tumbler Is Taking The Unsold Caribbean Cruise

United States By Storm Cabins Are Almost Being...
Freedom Discount Club | Sponsored Cruise Deals | sponsored se... |Sponsored

Here Are The 27 Coolest Gifts For 2021

Top Tech Today | Sponsored

Mature Trainer: This Is What Most Beautiful High School

"Ripped" Old Guys Do... Campuses in the U.S.
Power Life | Sponsored FamilyMinded | Sponsored

AIPA” HE
|

S AT&T

AT&T Unlimited Elite®

With unlimited
high-speed
(EYEE ECE
no extra cost
Browns disappointment -the 91-year-old woman found in
Learn more
same old, same old bushes in South Euclid was
cleveland.com beaten to death, medical...
cleveland.com

3 Toxic Foods For Dogs: The At 91, This Is The Car Clint
One Meat You Should Never... Eastwood Drives
www.thecaninecode.com | Sponsored Joy Delivery | Sponsored

New Shaftless Stair Lifts takes Only Hours to Install -

See How Much They Cost
Stair Lifts | Search Ads | Sponsored

New Shaftless Stair Lifts takes Only Hours to Install- See

How Much They Cost
Stair Lifts | Search Ads | Sponsored

New Shaftless Stair Lifts takes Only Hours to Install- See Advertisement
How Much They Cost < ater
Stair Lifts | Search Ads | Sponsored

AT&T Unlimited Elite®

With unlimited —
platform WE Center high-speed ATET5G

7 LEVEE ECE 8 Sore]

no extra cost
HBOMAX

Learn more
= 8
Offer Detais >

Cleveland Guardians name RTA police officer charged

dispute resolved; baseball after video shows he pushed
club and roller derby team w... man with mental illness off...
cleveland.com cleveland.com

/
Buick's Thrilling New Lineup Does Your Cat Throw Up
Is Finally Here Often? - Try This One Trick
2021 Buicks | Search Ads | Sponsored Ultimate Pet Nutrition | Sponsored

Think Testosterone is the Answer? Mike Tyson Says

"Think again”
Mike Tyson's IM-21| Sponsored

|ZT

Always Put a Plastic Bottle on Your Tires when Parked, AT&T Unlimited Elite®
Here's Why With unlimited
Rich Houses | Sponsored high-speed
EYEE ELE)
no extra cost

Learn more
Offer Detais >

Marc R. Kotora viii Macke

Are Nick Chubb and Kareem Solon Councilman Marc

Hunt the Browns’ most Kotora recognized at his final
important offensive players? council meeting
cleveland.com cleveland.com

What Your Dog Shouldn't Be 63 Year-Old Fitness Legend

Eating (Most Dog Owners... Finds "Fountain of...
Ultimate Pet Nutrition | Sponsored Power Life By Tony Horton | Sponsored

7 Discounts Seniors Get Only If They Ask

The Wallet Watcher | Sponsored

Lh AN

Document
Document title:
title: We
We endorse
endorse Justin
Justin Bibb
Bibb for
for mayor
mayor of
of Cleveland:
Cleveland: Editorial
Editorial board,
board, cleveland.com
cleveland.com and
and The
The Plain
Plain Dealer
Dealer -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/we-endorse-justin-bibb-for-mayor-of-cleveland-editorial-board.html
https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/we-endorse-justin-bibb-for-mayor-of-cleveland-editorial-board. html
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Tue,
Tue, 1616 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 18:16:30
18:16:30 GMT
GMT Page
Page 11 of 11
11 of 11
A Page Vault
Document
Document title:
title: Stopping
Stopping Dennis
Dennis Kucinich from returning
Kucinich from returning as
as Cleveland’s
Cleveland’s mayor
mayor will
will require
require targeting
targeting
his
his reputation:
reputation: Brent
Brent Larkin
Larkin -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com

Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/stopping-dennis-kucinich-from-returning-
https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/stopping-dennis-kucinich-from-returning-
as-clevelands-mayor-will-require-targeting-his-reputation-brent-larkin.html
as-clevelands-mayor-will-require-targeting-his-reputation-brent-larkin.html

Page
Page loaded
loaded at
at (UTC):
(UTC): Tue,
Tue, 16
16 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 18:08:42
18:08:42 GMT
GMT

Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Tue,
Tue, 16
16 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 18:22:15
18:22:15 GMT
GMT

Capture
Capture tool:
tool: v7.13.2
v7.13.2

Collection
Collection server
server IP:
IP: 34.230.137.168
34.230.137.168

Browser
Browser engine:
engine: Chrome/77.0.3865.120
Chrome/77.0.3865.120

Operating
Operating system:
system: Microsoft
Microsoft Windows
Windows NT
NT 10.0.17763.0
10.0.17763.0 (10.0.17763.0)
(10.0.17763.0)

PDF
PDF length:
length: 9
9

Capture
Capture ID:
ID: 91a84b27-eda1-4fbb-b1ad-c7225a4ea2da
91a84b27-eda1-4fbb-b1ad-c7225a4ea2da

User:
User: drl-mhughes
drl-mhughes

Exhibit 2

PDF REFERENCE
PDF REFERENCE #:
#: qyj heGowwZ19r JEvygJHXw
qyjheGowwZ19rJEvygJHXw
— le] Set weather VV (CIV ] AD) Account V

\ATVSRV 0TH g (=TTo MRSS Col g (=I o TUN or=| (== 10 To 1 U) SO yo To TU (oR /o IR A D1 RST o Sw 1 o LSM (oo
EE) YA

9x guarle
THOUGHT
IT WAS GONE? A f s oH i 2 1)
WE SHOP THE COUNTRY FOR ALI
OF THE HARD TO FIND ITEMS.

Sn store Sours /

6770 BROOKPARK ROAD Mon - Sat: 10-7pm « Sun: 11-5pm AT

SUBSCRIBER EXCLUSIVE

Stopping Dennis Kucinich from returning as

Cleveland’s mayor will require targeting his
reputation: Brent Larkin
Updated: Aug. 16. 2021. 2:18 p.m. | Published: Aug. 15, 2021, 5:45 a.m.

XELJANZ/Z
(tofacitinib)
Smgtablets

Watch her
story unfold

ug
HEAR FROM A REAL PATIENT »

Available by prescription only

SCROLL FOR IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION AND INDICATION

Serious Infections. XELJANZ (tofacitinib) can lower the
ability of your immune system to fight infections. Do not start
taking XELJANZ if you have any kind of infection unless your
healthcare provider tells you it is okay. Serious Infections
have happened in people taking XELJANZ. These serious
infections include tuberculosis (TB) and infections caused by
bactena, fungi, or viruses that can spread throughout the
body. Some people have died from these infections. Your
healthcare provider should test you for TS before starting and
Dennis Kucinich. a former Cleveland mayor and longtime member of Congress, during treatment with XELJANZ
} i X ~ Before and after starting XELJANZ, tell your doctor if you
seen here in June with his wife, Elizabeth, and supporters announces his have an infection or symptoms ofan infection, including
N * Fi 8 he
candidacy to reclaim Cleveland's top office. Byer swastng, of lls
FULL PRESCRIBING AND GUIDE

f LJ shares

Recommended for You

By Brent Larkin, cleveland.com

M1 EVEL ANDY Nhin Car thnca utha Aa nat unt Nannie LB

Document
Document title:
title: Stopping
Stopping Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich from
from returning
returning as
as Cleveland’s
Cleveland’s mayor
mayor will
will require
require targeting
targeting his
his reputation:
reputation: Brent
Brent Larkin
Larkin -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/stopping-dennis-kucinich-from-returning-as-clevelands-mayor-will-require-targeting-his-reputation-brent-…
https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/stopping-dennis-kucinich-from-returning-as-clevelands-mayor-will-require-targeting-his-reputation-brent-...
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Tue,
Tue, 16
16 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 18:22:15
18:22:15 GMT
GMT Page
Page 11 of
of 8
seen here in June with his wite, Elizabeth, and supporters announces his have an infection or symptoms of an infection, including:
* Fever, sweating, or chills
candidacy to reclaim Cleveland's top office.
FULL PRI AND MEDICATION GUIDE

f 4 163

Recommended for You

By Brent Larkin, cleveland.com

CLEVELAND, Ohio -- For those who do not want Dennis

Meet the CBD of Your
Kucinich to win back the job he had and lost 42 years ago, the Dreams
Charlotte's Web CBD
path to success is both narrow and clear.

They must do to Kucinich in the Cleveland mayoral election

what Shontel Brown and her supporters did to Nina Turner in Browns
disappointment - the
the Aug. 3 special election for Congress. same old, same old
cleveland.com

With early voting about to begin, the task of taking down

Kucinich, the clear frontrunner in every known poll gauging
How Meghan Markle
voter sentiment prior to the Sept. 14 primary, falls largely to Looks Without Makeup
Is Tough To Handle
Council President Kevin Kelley and his supporters. Unless
Life Indigo
Kelley can erode support for Kucinich, it puts at risk his chance
of being one of the top two vote-getters who advance to the
Cleveland Guardians
Nov. 2 runoff election. name dispute
resolved; baseball
Towards that end, there are rumblings of a planned club and roller derby...
cleveland.com
independent expenditure seeking to use mailings and perhaps
television ads aimed at wrecking Kucinich’s reputation. It's
24 Celebrities Who
easy to imagine what those attacks would say: “Kucinich Married Their
almost ruined the city when he was mayor the first time. Don’t Mistresses
High Tally
let him finish the job.”

It is a low-risk strategy, with no guarantee of success. Denying RTA police officer

charged after video
Kucinich a spot in the mayoral runoff election is a more difficult
shows he pushed man
task than defeating him in a runoff election. with mental illness o...
cleveland.com

Promoted Links by Taboola

MATTRESSFIRM

BLACK
UNJUNK YOUR SLEEP AT OUR

FRIDAY

{ VE
Brent Larkin was The Plain Dealer's editorial director from 1991 until his
retirement in 2009. The Plain Dealer
©
SAVE UPTO

XELJANZ®Z LLELIEL Ele fH)

(tofacitinib] + FREE
ADJUSTABLE
Watch her story unfold BASE with qualifying purchase
-
Ww

HEAR FROM A REAL PATIENT »

Available by prescripsion anly

Watch her story unfold _cvertisement

EF MATTRESSEIRM

Ww
HEAR FROM A REAL PATIENT »
Available by prescription anly
SCROLL FOR IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION AND INDICATION UNIUNK YOUR SLEEP ATOUR
Serious Infections. XELJANZ (tofacitinib) can lower the Bl AC Bi
ability of your immune system to fight infections. Do not start
taking XELJANZ if you have any kind of infection unless your LY
healthcare provider tells you itis okay. Serious Infections = x | (1):
have happened in people taking XELJANZ. These serious J A
infections include tuberculosis (TB) and infections caused by

FULL PRESCRIBING INFORMATION INCLUDING BOXED WARNING AND MEDICATION GUIDE

To advance, Kucinich needs about 8,000 votes, maybe less.

That is 85,000 fewer than he received when elected mayor in
1977, an interesting but meaningless morsel that speaks to the
city’s enormous population loss and voter interest that has DQ)
dropped off a cliff. a
SAVE UPTO
Far more relevant is Kucinich’s 2018 candidacy for governor.
Kucinich never had a prayer of winning his Democratic Party
primary race against former Ohio Attorney General Richard rr TTI
Cordray. This year, Kucinich has significant support from + FREE
organized labor. In 2018, he had none, with his two most AB3USTABLE
notable endorsements coming from The Plain Dealer and Our
Revolution, Bernie Sanders’ political organization. Shop Now

Statewide, Cordray annihilated Kucinich, and beat him badly in

Cuyahoga County. But in Cleveland, Kucinich received 15,064
votes to Cordray's 13,643.

Kucinich's base in the city among working class whites was

once borderline impenetrable. Parts of that base still exist, but
it is doubtful they are impenetrable.

It took about $4 million in advertising to convince voters in the

11th Congressional District that Nina Turner's past criticisms of
President Biden and Hillary Clinton made her unworthy of the
Democratic nomination for the congressional seat vacated by
Marcia Fudge. The investment in taking down Kucinich will
likely be only a tiny fraction of the amount spent against Turner.
And it will be made to an electorate that essentially cares about
only one issue — personal safety.

Ideastream, the City Club and the Northeast Ohio Journalism

Solutions Collaborative are performing a commendable public
service by sponsoring two mayoral debates. But it is difficult to
impact an election outcome when the targeted audience is not
paying attention.

As a wise veteran of Cleveland mayoral elections notes this not

a persuasion election, one where voters weigh candidate
qualifications and various issues. It is an election that elevates
the importance of the ground game, of painstakingly
identifying supporters and doing whatever is necessary to get
them to vote.

Document
Document title:
title: Stopping
Stopping Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich from
from returning
returning as
as Cleveland’s
Cleveland’s mayor
mayor will
will require
require targeting
targeting his
his reputation:
reputation: Brent
Brent Larkin
Larkin -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/stopping-dennis-kucinich-from-returning-as-clevelands-mayor-will-require-targeting-his-reputation-brent-…
https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/stopping-dennis-kucinich-from-returning-as-clevelands-mayor-will-require-targeting-his-reputation-brent-...
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Tue,
Tue, 16
16 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 18:22:15
18:22:15 GMT
GMT Page
Page 3
3 of
of 8
A> a wise veleidll Ul vieveldliu 11idyouidl gieClulls ULES Lis Hout

a persuasion election, one where voters weigh candidate

qualifications and various issues. It is an election that elevates
the importance of the ground game, of painstakingly
identifying supporters and doing whatever is necessary to get
MATTRESSFIRM
them to vote.
UNJUNK YOUR SLEEP AT OUR

BLACK
FRIDAY

Jo
The candidate with the best organized campaign is probably D
Justin Bibb, the smart, young, unproven newcomer endorsed SAVEUPTO
by The Plain Dealer and cleveland.com. Bibb has breakout
potential, but comparisons to Mike White's upset win in 1989
are way off base. on select mattresses

+ FREE
Heading into the 1989 mayoral primary election, few gave AB3USTABLE
White a chance. But he was hardly an unknown. White had a
decade-long record in City Council and the Ohio Senate and a Shop Now
loyal political base in Glenville. Bibb has neither.

Kelley, now the recipient of Mayor Frank Jackson's

endorsement, is the safest choice in a year where some argue
safe is not the best option. He is smart, decent, and
knowledgeable, with an inspiring life story. But Kelley's name
recognition is startlingly low for someone in his eighth year of
the second most important office in city government.

As the candidate with the biggest campaign bankroll, Kelley

last week began a month-long television advertising campaign
designed to improve that lagging name recognition.

With primary election day about a month out, the most

important thing to know is no one really knows where this race
is headed. Six candidates have a chance of advancing -- Bibb,
Kelley, Kucinich, State Sen. Sandra Williams, Councilman
Basheer Jones, and former Councilman Zack Reed.

Only Jones is unelectable in a general election. The first term

councilman from the Hough area seems smart and polished,
the field's best communicator. But the widely circulated video
clip of Jones making disparaging comments about women
would lead to a landslide loss.

Of course, 50 years ago “unelectable” was a word most of us

used in describing the mayoral candidacy of County Auditor
Ralph Perk.

Document
Document title:
title: Stopping
Stopping Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich from
from returning
returning as
as Cleveland’s
Cleveland’s mayor
mayor will
will require
require targeting
targeting his
his reputation:
reputation: Brent
Brent Larkin
Larkin -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/stopping-dennis-kucinich-from-returning-as-clevelands-mayor-will-require-targeting-his-reputation-brent-…
https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/stopping-dennis-kucinich-from-returning-as-clevelands-mayor-will-require-targeting-his-reputation-brent-...
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Tue,
Tue, 16
16 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 18:22:15
18:22:15 GMT
GMT Page
Page 4
4 of
of 8
Of course, 50 years ago “unelectable” was a word most of us
used in describing the mayoral candidacy of County Auditor
Ralph Perk.

MATTRESSFIRM

UNJUNK YOUR SLEEP AT OUR

BLACK
FRIDAY

TR
BY
©
SAVE UPTO
Mayor Perk served three terms.

Brent Larkin was The Plain Dealer's editorial director from 1991
on select mattresses

until his retirement in 20009.

To reach Brent Larkin: [email protected]

Editor's note: This column was updated Aug. 16 to correct the

date of the Sept. 14 primary.

Have something to say about this topic?

* Send a letter to the editor, which will be considered for print

publication.

* Email general questions, comments or corrections on this

opinion column to Elizabeth Sullivan, director of opinion, at
[email protected].

Note to readers: if you purchase something through one of our affiliate links we may earn a
commission.

Around the Web Tabla Feed

Cadillac's Thrilling New Lineup Is Finally Here

2021 Cadillac SUVS | Search Ads | Sponsored

ul L | ol
Document
Document title:
title: Stopping
Stopping Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich from
from returning
returning as
as Cleveland’s
Cleveland’s mayor
mayor will
will require
require targeting
targeting his
his reputation:
reputation: Brent
Brent Larkin
Larkin -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/stopping-dennis-kucinich-from-returning-as-clevelands-mayor-will-require-targeting-his-reputation-brent-…
https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/stopping-dennis-kucinich-from-returning-as-clevelands-mayor-will-require-targeting-his-reputation-brent-...
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Tue,
Tue, 16
16 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 18:22:15
18:22:15 GMT
GMT Page
Page 5
5 of
of 8
Cadillac's Thrilling New Lineup Is Finally Here
2021 Cadillac SUVS | Search Ads | Sponsored

- B® A

See The Man Gladys Knight ls This Tumbler Is Taking The

Married To At 76 United States By Storm mm! I
Tele Health Dave | Sponsored Freedom Discount Club | Sponsored .

21,

A PTO

DIL

Buick's Thrilling New Lineup Is Finally Here

2021 Buicks | Search Ads | Sponsored

24 Celebrities Who Married Take A Look At The Car Clint

Their Mistresses Eastwood Drives In Real Life
High Tally
| Sponsored Joy Delivery
| Sponsored

No Offense, But These 2 Big Retailers Aren't The

Cheapest Places To Shop
MoneyWise.com | Sponsored

of |

AEE i

Document
Document title:
title: Stopping
Stopping Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich from
from returning
returning as
as Cleveland’s
Cleveland’s mayor
mayor will
will require
require targeting
targeting his
his reputation:
reputation: Brent
Brent Larkin
Larkin -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/stopping-dennis-kucinich-from-returning-as-clevelands-mayor-will-require-targeting-his-reputation-brent-…
https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/stopping-dennis-kucinich-from-returning-as-clevelands-mayor-will-require-targeting-his-reputation-brent-...
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Tue,
Tue, 16
16 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 18:22:15
18:22:15 GMT
GMT Page
Page 6
6 of
of 8
No Offense, But These 2 Big Retailers Aren't The
Cheapest Places To Shop
MoneyWise.com | Sponsored

rr — ny - MATTRESSFIRM

E
UNJUNK YOUR SLEEP AT OUR

BLACK
FRIDAY

Hollywood Celebs Scooping The US States People Are ;

Up Strange Investment? Fleeing And The Ones They... ETT

The Legacy Report

| Sponsored Forbes | Sponsored J HH

on select mattresses

+ FREE
ADJUSTABLE
[:7.X5 with qualifying purchase

Shop Now

2 Steps To Tell When A Slot is Close To Hitting The

Jackpot
Buzzdaily Winners | Sponsored

If Your Dog Eats Dry Food 20 Everyday Things Kate

(Most Dog Owners Don't Kn... Middleton Is Not Allowed To...
Ultimate Pet Nutrition | Sponsored Post Fun | Sponsored

Ny
2 | A
Wwe 7
vem np £

Browns disappointment -the Which Ohio State football

same old, same old players will go through senior
cleveland.com day activities against Michig...
cleveland.com

Document
Document title:
title: Stopping
Stopping Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich from
from returning
returning as
as Cleveland’s
Cleveland’s mayor
mayor will
will require
require targeting
targeting his
his reputation:
reputation: Brent
Brent Larkin
Larkin -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/stopping-dennis-kucinich-from-returning-as-clevelands-mayor-will-require-targeting-his-reputation-brent-…
https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/stopping-dennis-kucinich-from-returning-as-clevelands-mayor-will-require-targeting-his-reputation-brent-...
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Tue,
Tue, 16
16 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 18:22:15
18:22:15 GMT
GMT Page
Page 7
7 of
of 8
cleveland.com day activities against Michig...
cleveland.com

hy » Ja

Insane Black Friday TV Sales Plastic Surgeon: “Do This To

Happening Now Fill In Wrinkles At Home”...
Tech Sales Finder| Sponsored Beverly Hills MD | Sponsored dnl

21)

A PTO

Bitcoin for beginners: what you need to know before

buying Bitcoin
eToro Crypto Updates | Sponsored

_——_—_ Zul
| Wheat Draw 4
ihe Bread 3

he Crust %
Hand Tossed
Crab Rangoon Pizza 1m.
levard Wheat Hy 4
ubtotal
i at br

Es oh) Sl oi
HARNTAR oes I RAEER ER LE

Wife Goes To Bathroom, Waitress Tells Husband This

World Lifestyle | Sponsored

platform WB Center

Cleveland Guardians name RTA police officer charged

dispute resolved; baseball after video shows he pushed
club and roller derby team w... man with mental illness off...
cleveland.com cleveland.com

Document
Document title:
title: Stopping
Stopping Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich from
from returning
returning as
as Cleveland’s
Cleveland’s mayor
mayor will
will require
require targeting
targeting his
his reputation:
reputation: Brent
Brent Larkin
Larkin -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/stopping-dennis-kucinich-from-returning-as-clevelands-mayor-will-require-targeting-his-reputation-brent-…
https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/2021/08/stopping-dennis-kucinich-from-returning-as-clevelands-mayor-will-require-targeting-his-reputation-brent-...
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Tue,
Tue, 16
16 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 18:22:15
18:22:15 GMT
GMT Page
Page 8
8 of
of 8
A Page Vault
Document
Document title:
title: Dennis
Dennis Kucinich fuels possible
Kucinich fuels possible run for Cleveland
run for Cleveland mayor
mayor with
with money
money from
from longtime
longtime
FirstEnergy
FirstEnergy supporter
supporter Tony
Tony George
George -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com

Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/02/dennis-kucinich-fuels-possible-run-for-
https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/02/dennis-kucinich-fuels-possible-run-for-
cleveland-mayor-with-money-from-longtime-firstenergy-supporter-tony-george.html
cleveland-mayor-with-money-from-longtime-firstenergy-supporter-tony-george.htmi

Page
Page loaded
loaded at
at (UTC):
(UTC): Thu,
Thu, 18
18 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 13:09:47
13:09:47 GMT
GMT

Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Thu,
Thu, 18
18 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 13:10:46
13:10:46 GMT
GMT

Capture
Capture tool:
tool: v7.13.2
v7.13.2

Collection
Collection server
server IP:
IP: 54.157.181.49
54.157.181.49

Browser
Browser engine:
engine: Chrome/77.0.3865.120
Chrome/77.0.3865.120

Operating
Operating system:
system: Microsoft
Microsoft Windows
Windows NT
NT 10.0.17763.0
10.0.17763.0 (10.0.17763.0)
(10.0.17763.0)

PDF
PDF length:
length: 10
10

Capture
Capture ID:
ID: 19c9aa8b-5395-46a6-93c5-1339a42a5893
19c9aa8b-5395-46a6-93¢c5-1339a42a5893

User:
User: drl-mhughes
drl-mhughes

Exhibit 3

PDF REFERENCE
PDF REFERENCE #:
#: 4f yDXASECak87HW.ouNF3
4fyDXA5ECak87HWLouNiF3
(CIN [SVE
glo Kelolag] AD) Account V
COVERING NORTHEAST OHIO

a A. Tal
cailgarlors mS /

OS alore Shur:

6770 BROOKPARK ROAD Mon-Sat: 10-7pm + Sun: 11-5pm FOR DIRECTIONSp-

SUBSCRIBER EXCLUSIVE o~

Dennis Kucinich fuels possible run for Cleveland

mayor with money from longtime FirstEnergy
supporter Tony George
Updated: Feb. 08, 2021.12:25 p.m. | Published: Feb. 05, 2021. 6:00 a.m.

Earn yo
fo} ff IF: \
erioqal

Choose from popular emphasis

areas for a successful career in IP
» Patent Law +»Copyright Law
»Trademark Law Trade Secret Law
Sandra Day O'Connor
Learn more Basu College of Law
sr St Gooreenty

Dennis Kucinich (AP Photo/John Minchillo) AF

f Ww 4
By John Caniglia, cleveland.com

Editor's note: For several hours Friday, the original version of

this story incorrectly stated Dennis Kucinich is exploring a run
for mayor with the financial backing of FirstEnergy Corp. Recommencdad jor You
Kucinich's campaign received no money from FirstEnergy.
This scarf is quickly
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Dennis Kucinich, who made his name becoming a must-have
for every woman
saving Cleveland Public Power's predecessor, is exploring Fashion In USA

another run for Cleveland mayor with the financial backing of a

Document
Document title:
title: Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich fuels
fuels possible
possible run
run for
for Cleveland
Cleveland mayor with money
mayor with money from
from longtime
longtime FirstEnergy
FirstEnergy supporter
supporter Tony
Tony George
George -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/02/dennis-kucinich-fuels-possible-run-for-cleveland-mayor-with-money-from-longtime-firstenergy-supporter-tony-…
https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/02/dennis-kucinich-fuels-possible-run-for-cleveland-mayor-with-money-from-longtime-firstenergy-supporter-tony-...
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Thu,
Thu, 18
18 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 13:10:46
13:10:46 GMT
GMT Page
Page 11 of
of 9
Recommended for You
for mayor with the financial backing of FirstEnergy Corp.

ha
Kucinich's campaign received no money from FirstEnergy.
This scarf is quickly
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Dennis Kucinich, who made his name ! becoming a must-have
for every woman
saving Cleveland Public Power's predecessor, is exploring Fashion In USA
another run for Cleveland mayor with the financial backing of a
businessman closely aligned with CPP’s adversary, the EARLY SINS SEECRE
WOULDNT
ARMOND ROSH
ELECTION
Budish race exit
scandal-immersed FirstEnergy Corp. foreshadowed: Darcy
cartoon
Westlake restaurant owner Tony George and his family cleveland.com

contributed $28,000 in the last days of December as seed

money for Kucinich's possible campaign. Kucinich, who said he Here's The Salaries
has not decided about seeking the office, has received a total Made For Each Military
Rank
of $51,000, according to campaign finance records filed late Post Fun

last month.

Dear Annie: | need to

George, whose family owns the Barley House and the Harry
get out of my comfort
Buffalo, has sided with FirstEnergy for years. He is a close zone and start looking
for anew job
friend of Charles Jones, the Akron utility's former chief cleveland.com

executive officer, and former Ohio House Speaker Larry

Householder, who is at the center of the Statehouse bribery The 15 Most Beautiful
scandal, according to interviews and finance reports. Fox News Anchors,
Ranked
Rest Wow
The fact that Kucinich would accept contributions from a
supporter of FirstEnergy, which is CPP’s chief competitor,
appears at odds with the former mayor. In 1978, Kucinich Big gulp! Bear steps
inside California 7-
fought to save Cleveland Municipal Light, which later became Eleven store
CPP. The city went into default after Kucinich refused to sell the cleveland.com

utility, and he lost the mayor's office a year later.

Promoted Links by Taboola

Kucinich said the campaign contributions from George are

rooted in a longstanding friendship that began when the two 803

men met at a fund-raiser for Bill Clinton, then an aspiring

candidate for the White House. a 2h

“I have friends who may be close to FirstEnergy, but that is

their cross to bear,” Kucinich said. “This is not a nodding — Co
acquaintance. Tony George has been a friend of mine for 30 TR
years. No one buys my friendship, and no one buys my opinion. Earn your Master
And no one has ever bought my vote.” oY fl IE: \T TY (HY ))
in Intellectual
Property Law
(Captain Morgan
Build the foundation -
for a successful career HEIGL
in IP Law :
PSU ese

{S POWERED BY CONCERT FEEDBACK | &}

Earn your Master
oY fl IE: \T TY (HY ))
George said he has given contributions to plenty of candidates, in Intellectual
including others considering a possible mayoral run. They Property Law
include Basheer Jones and Kevin Kelley, members of Cleveland
City Council, and Sandra Williams, the Democratic state Build the foundation a
senator from Cleveland. He also has contributed to former lors Suropeniu career hii
Councilman Zack Reed, whose name has come up as a possible PSU Eze
candidate for the race.

Kucinich, he said, stands out.

“Dennis and | have been friends forever,” George said. “He is

not just a friend. He is a family friend. My family and | have
been very generous to a lot of candidates. | don't have an
agenda, except for good government.”

The contributions from George and his family come amid an

FBI investigation and increased scrutiny for candidates with
ties to FirstEnergy.

In spring 2019, Householder, as speaker, helped craft House Bill

6, a $1.3 billion bailout for two nuclear plants. FirstEnergy had
sought the help when its subsidiary, FirstEnergy Solutions,
owned the plants. The subsidiary went into bankruptcy in 2018,
and the plants are now owned by Energy Harbor.

In exchange for Householders support, the company and its

affiliates funneled more than $60 million to a nonprofit that
Householder and his allies controlled, according to federal
court documents. Householder and four others have been
indicted on federal racketeering charges. The company has not
been charged, though it has severed ties with Jones and other
top executives.

George and his family contributed nearly $120,000 to

Householder from 2016 to 2019, records show.

Kucinich stressed that George has never tried to dissuade him

over the former mayor's support of CPP.

“I' have lived with my advocacy for Public Power for more than a
half century, so political contributions have zero influence on
my work,” Kucinich said. “If the test of my friendship was
agreeing with someone, | would have a smaller circle of
friends.”

agreeing with someone, | would have a smaller circle of

friends.”

Earn your Master

oY fl IE: \T TY (HY ))
in Intellectual
Property Law
Build the foundation
for a successful career
in IP Law
PSU Eze
{S POWERED BY CONCERT FEEDBACK | &}

George said he is not opposed to CPP, though he has fought

often with city leaders.

“I support good energy policy.” he said. “I'm a businessman

who wants affordable rates.”

Kucinich must decide before June 16, the deadline for

candidates to file for the race. The nonpartisan primary is Sept.
14, with the top two finishers squaring off in the Nov. 2 general
election.

Besides the possible candidacies of Kelley, Jones, Reed and

Williams, nonprofit leader Justin Bibb has announced that he
also will seek the mayor's job. Incumbent Frank Jackson has
not said whether he will seek a fifth term.

Kelley has more than $530,000 in campaign contributions for

the possible run. Kucinich has a small fraction of that.

“In every election that | have won, I've been outspent,” said
Kucinich, 74, who served in the Ohio Senate for two years and
in the U.S. Congress for 16. “Once I'm in the race, it will be
easier to raise money. But | haven't made that announcement.”

Besides the George family, Cleveland real estate investor

James Kassouf, who was pardoned in December by former
President Trump involving a 1989 tax case, also served as a
major contributor to Kucinich. He and his family gave $20,000
in the last days of December.

Note to readers: if you purchase something through one of our affiliate links we may earn a
commission.

Sponsor Content

Looking to save on health

insurance next year? Here’s
what to know about ACA
open enrollment
Open enrollment for 2022 is here,
and individuals who purchase health

Looking to save on health

insurance next year? Here’s
what to know about ACA
open enrollment
Open enrollment for 2022 is here, =a | - Earn your Master
and individuals who purchase health , of Laws (10)
plans through ACA marketplaces are . |
now able to in Intellectual XN 7
7)
CVS Health

Around the Web Tabla Feed Build the foundation

: _-— for a successful career
inlIP Law
Apply today £su EERoct vo

Man Who Predicted 2020 Crash 45 Days Early Now Says

"Do This" On Thursday
VisionaryProfit| Sponsored

New Mazda's Finally On Sale No Appointment? No Problem

All Things Auto
| Sponsored = Upgrade to the World's...

The Easy Blog by EasyBreat... | Sponsored

Document
Document title:
title: Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich fuels
fuels possible
possible run
run for
for Cleveland
Cleveland mayor with money
mayor with money from
from longtime
longtime FirstEnergy
FirstEnergy supporter
supporter Tony
Tony George
George -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/02/dennis-kucinich-fuels-possible-run-for-cleveland-mayor-with-money-from-longtime-firstenergy-supporter-tony-…
https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/02/dennis-kucinich-fuels-possible-run-for-cleveland-mayor-with-money-from-longtime-firstenergy-supporter-tony-...
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Thu,
Thu, 18
18 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 13:10:46
13:10:46 GMT
GMT Page
Page 55 of
of 9
Earn your Master
Lo} ff EVEN (HEY)
LANGE UE] Xx
PropertyLaw =

Build the foundation

a : : — for a successful career
New Nissan's Finally On Sale in PLaw Sancta Day O'Connor
All Things Auto | Search Ads | Sponsored
nr

This Only Looks Like A Here Are The 27 Coolest Gifts

Regular Pocketknife - A Deej... For 2021
Deejo | Sponsored Top Tech Today
| Sponsored

Earn an Official Penn State Degree Without Setting Foot

in the Classroom
Penn State World Campus | Sponsored

Top Surgeon: Throw Out Your These Cars Are So Loaded It's
Olive Oil Now (Here's Why) Hard to Believe They're So...
Gundry MD | Sponsored Luxury SUVs | Search Ads | Sponsored

Document
Document title:
title: Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich fuels
fuels possible
possible run
run for
for Cleveland
Cleveland mayor with money
mayor with money from
from longtime
longtime FirstEnergy
FirstEnergy supporter
supporter Tony
Tony George
George -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/02/dennis-kucinich-fuels-possible-run-for-cleveland-mayor-with-money-from-longtime-firstenergy-supporter-tony-…
https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/02/dennis-kucinich-fuels-possible-run-for-cleveland-mayor-with-money-from-longtime-firstenergy-supporter-tony-...
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Thu,
Thu, 18
18 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 13:10:46
13:10:46 GMT
GMT Page
Page 66 of
of 9
Earn your Master
oY fl IE: \T TY (HY ))
Tl GEE

Build the foundation

for a successful career
in IP Law
Apply today PSU
a Zt Sone

Cadillac's Thrilling New Lineup Is Finally Here

2021 Cadillac SUVS | Search Ads | Sponsored

The True Cost of a Financial 2022 Mercedes Finally On Sale

Advisor, Revealed. New Mercedes | sponsored s... | Sponsored

SmartAsset| Sponsored

Budish race exit Dear Annie: | need to get out

foreshadowed: Darcy cartoon of my comfort zone and start
cleveland.com looking for a new job
cleveland.com

People Born Before 1968 Are Las Vegas: Unsold Alaska

In For A Treat This Month Cruise Cabins Are Almost...
Learning Saving | Sponsored Alaska Cruise Deals | spons... | Sponsored

Document
Document title:
title: Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich fuels
fuels possible
possible run
run for
for Cleveland
Cleveland mayor with money
mayor with money from
from longtime
longtime FirstEnergy
FirstEnergy supporter
supporter Tony
Tony George
George -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/02/dennis-kucinich-fuels-possible-run-for-cleveland-mayor-with-money-from-longtime-firstenergy-supporter-tony-…
https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/02/dennis-kucinich-fuels-possible-run-for-cleveland-mayor-with-money-from-longtime-firstenergy-supporter-tony-...
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Thu,
Thu, 18
18 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 13:10:46
13:10:46 GMT
GMT Page
Page 77 of
of 9
Earn your Master
oY fl IE: \T TY (HY ))
Tl GEE

Build the foundation

for a successful career
in IP Law
Apply today PSU
a Zt Sone
We are looking for volunteers in Nevada for a free, no
obligation hearing test
Hearwell | Sponsored

This scarf is quickly becoming a must-have for every

woman
Fashion In USA | Sponsored

‘Ghostbusters: Afterlife’ is a What's trending today:

fun ‘80s-style teen adventure November 18, 2021
that pushes the limits of... cleveland.com
cleveland.com

Why Some Fruits And Surgeon Reveals How To Fill

Vegetables Can Dramatically... In Balding Eyebrows
Health Intelligence | Sponsored Beverly Hills MD | Sponsored

Document
Document title:
title: Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich fuels
fuels possible
possible run
run for
for Cleveland
Cleveland mayor with money
mayor with money from
from longtime
longtime FirstEnergy
FirstEnergy supporter
supporter Tony
Tony George
George -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/02/dennis-kucinich-fuels-possible-run-for-cleveland-mayor-with-money-from-longtime-firstenergy-supporter-tony-…
https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/02/dennis-kucinich-fuels-possible-run-for-cleveland-mayor-with-money-from-longtime-firstenergy-supporter-tony-...
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Thu,
Thu, 18
18 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 13:10:46
13:10:46 GMT
GMT Page
Page 88 of
of 9
Earn your Master
oY fl IE: \T TY (HY ))
LG EE]
Property Law
Build the foundation ye
for a successful career RE IE
in IP Law
Apply today Fe BO cae
Arline
State Unveesty

Here Are 23 of the Coolest Gifts for This 2021

National Penny Gift Guide | Sponsored

Think Testosterone is the Answer? Mike Tyson Says

"Think again”
Mike Tyson's IM-21 | Sponsored

Jury convicts Michigan man of Big gulp! Bear steps inside

killing wife by poisoning California 7-Eleven store
cereal with heroin cleveland.com
cleveland.com

=
Unsold Phones Are Almost Jungle Moc Crafted Cozy
Being Given Away See more

Document
Document title:
title: Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich fuels
fuels possible
possible run
run for
for Cleveland
Cleveland mayor with money
mayor with money from
from longtime
longtime FirstEnergy
FirstEnergy supporter
supporter Tony
Tony George
George -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/02/dennis-kucinich-fuels-possible-run-for-cleveland-mayor-with-money-from-longtime-firstenergy-supporter-tony-…
https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/02/dennis-kucinich-fuels-possible-run-for-cleveland-mayor-with-money-from-longtime-firstenergy-supporter-tony-...
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Thu,
Thu, 18
18 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 13:10:46
13:10:46 GMT
GMT Page
Page 99 of
of 9
A Page Vault
Document
Document title:
title: Donald
Donald Trump
Trump backers
backers bet
bet big
big on
on Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich in
in mayoral
mayoral race
race -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com

Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/09/donald-trump-backers-bet-big-on-dennis-
https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/09/donald-trump-backers-bet-big-on-dennis-
kucinich-in-mayoral-race.html
kucinich-in-mayoral-race.htmi

Page
Page loaded
loaded at
at (UTC):
(UTC): Fri,
Fri, 19
19 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 16:35:04
16:35:04 GMT
GMT

Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Fri,
Fri, 19
19 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 16:39:11
16:39:11 GMT
GMT

Capture
Capture tool:
tool: v7.13.2
v7.13.2

Collection
Collection server
server IP:
IP: 54.157.181.49
54.157.181.49

Browser
Browser engine:
engine: Chrome/77.0.3865.120
Chrome/77.0.3865.120

Operating
Operating system:
system: Microsoft
Microsoft Windows
Windows NT
NT 10.0.17763.0
10.0.17763.0 (10.0.17763.0)
(10.0.17763.0)

PDF
PDF length:
length: 13
13

Capture
Capture ID:
ID: f898f2db-6fe9-4d59-8d28-42b8dcea5cb9
f898f2db-6fe9-4d59-8d28-42b8dceabch9

User:
User: drl-dbuxton
drl-dbuxton

Exhibit 4

PDF REFERENCE
PDF REFERENCE #:
#: AhAW C2sYZuJ7kr 1gzeJ QF
4hAWrC2sYZuJ7kr1gzeJQF
le] Set weather V

Gio) gE | BETTERDECISIONS.

SUBSCRIBER EXCLUSIVE o~

Donald Trump backers bet big on Dennis

Kucinich in mayoral race
Updated: Sep. 03.2021, 4:05 p.m. | Published: Sep. 03,2021. 11:47 am.

SONY

Perfect for
HEWAY
E11 eo] 1 8)
X90J 4K HDR TV

Cleveland City Hall

SI CVANVAVAD (1

f v x2 prrs
By Seth A. Richardson, cleveland.com

CLEVELAND, Ohio — Two Republicans — a convicted and LEARN MORED,

pardoned fraudster and a figure tied to the House Bill 6 bribery PS5™ system sold separately.
©2021 Sony Interactive Entertainment.
scandal — are betting big on Democratic former Mayor Dennis
Kucinich in the race to succeed Mayor Frank Jackson.

According to unaudited financial disclosure forms filed with the Recommended for You
Cuyahoga County Board of Elections on Thursday, James
Kassouf, Tony George and their family members donated
The Contentious Scene
maximum contributions of $5,000 adding up to $65,000 for That Took MASH Off Air
Kucinich from July through August. Kucinich reported more Taco Relish

than $235,000 in contributions, more than four times what he

raised in the 18 months prior. Cleveland Guardians
merchandise is now
on sale: Here's where
get hats, jerseys,...
Invest from anywhere cleveland.com

(YF de R{-\WA do] oI}

Historic Figures Who

Lived Long Enough To
Be Photographed
Past Factory

11)Y,
digitally | financially | personally CHICKEN NUG!
4 Levels of Chicken
AMATEUR HOME COOK
Nuggets: Amateur to

Document
Document title:
title: Donald
Donald Trump
Trump backers
backers bet
bet big
big on
on Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich in
in mayoral
mayoral race
race -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/09/donald-trump-backers-bet-big-on-dennis-kucinich-in-mayoral-race.html
https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/09/donald-trump-backers-bet-big-on-dennis-kucinich-in-mayoral-race.html
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Fri,
Fri, 19
19 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 16:39:11
16:39:11 GMT
GMT Page
Page 11 of
of 12
12
| Historic Figures Who
Lived Long Enough To
| Be Photographed
Past Factory

ally
digitally | financially | personally CHICKEN NUG!
4 Levels of Chicken
AMATEUR HOME COOK Nuggets: Amateur to
or @ Food Scientist
LIN k 2 cleveland.com
Kucinich led the field of seven mayoral candidates, barely
edging out nonprofit executive Justin Bibb, who raised more
Here's The Salaries
than $218,000.
Made For Each Military
) Rank
Because Cleveland campaign limits run by calendar year Post Fun
instead of election cycle, the Georges and Kassoufs have been
able to donate beyond the $5,000 limit. Both families gave
What's trending
Kucinich $48,000 between Dec. 22 and Dec. 31, allowing them today: November 19,
to give another $5,000 each this year. 2021
cleveland.com

All told, the Georges have given Kucinich's campaign $63,000

while the Kassoufs gave $50,000, accounting for $113,000 of
the $324,000 Kucinich has raised — around 35% total.

George has been connected to the ongoing House Bill 6

scandal, in which Akron-based utility company FirstEnergy
admitted to engaging in a $60 million bribery scheme to pass a
ratepayer funded bailout for two formerly owned nuclear
facilities. Republican former Ohio House Speaker Larry
Householder and four others were charged with racketeering ip)
by federal authorities.

Cleveland City Council President Kevin Kelley, who is also

running for mayor, is investigating whether FirstEnergy worked
to undermine municipally owned Cleveland Public Power
through the political group Consumers Against Deceptive Fees.

George was heavily tied to FirstEnergy following an audit

released by the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio that
showed the company gave George's businesses millions of
dollars for various services. George also worked on behalf of
the company to try to secure rights to power aggregation for
TPI Efficiency. When that failed, he launched an unsuccessful
bid to cut the number of council members from 17 to 9.

TPI Efficiency Founder Roger Zona also contributed $5,000 to

Kucinich's campaign.

Kassouf is a real estate owner and parking lot operator who

pleaded guilty to filing a false tax return. As part of the plea
agreement, Kassouf was ordered to serve four months of home
detention and pay a $10,000 fine. Republican President Donald
Trump pardoned him in December.

Both George and Kassouf are heavy Republican donors and

huge backers of Trump. Both held fundraisers for Trump's
presidential campaigns.

The Georges and Kassoufs have given to other candidates as

well, though not nearly to the degree Kucinich has benefitted.
Kassouf gave $5,000 to former Cleveland City Councilman
Zack Reed this reporting period as well as $2,500 last year.
George has spread money to Reed as well as Cleveland City

Document
Document title:
title: Donald
Donald Trump
Trump backers
backers bet
bet big
big on
on Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich in
in mayoral
mayoral race
race -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/09/donald-trump-backers-bet-big-on-dennis-kucinich-in-mayoral-race.html
https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/09/donald-trump-backers-bet-big-on-dennis-kucinich-in-mayoral-race.html
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Fri,
Fri, 19
19 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 16:39:11
16:39:11 GMT
GMT Page
Page 2
2 of
of 12
The Georges and Kassoufs have given to other candidates as
well, though not nearly to the degree Kucinich has benefitted.
Kassouf gave $5,000 to former Cleveland City Councilman
Zack Reed this reporting period as well as $2,500 last year. eee .
George has spread money to Reed as well as Cleveland City (1p)
Councilman Basheer Jones and state Sen. Sandra Williams.

A spokesman for Kucinich did not respond to requests for

comment.

Late fundraising

Bibb raised the second biggest pot of money during the filing
period, not including a vendor refund of $59,000.

Among Bibb’s donors is Ben Newhouse, a member of the

Newhouse family that owns Advance Publications, the parent
company of cleveland.com and The Plain Dealer. Newhouse
gave Bibb $1,000. Newhouse is not a member of the
cleveland.com and Plain Dealer editorial board, which endorsed
Bibb in the primary and is separate from news coverage.

After spending nearly $396,000, Bibb ended the reporting

period with more than $90,000 cash on hand. Kucinich spent
more than $226,000 and ended the period with more than
$45,000.

Kelley, who has raised the most money in the race so far, pulled
in more than $185,000 for the reporting period. He spent by far
the most at about $641,000, ending this reporting period with
more than $80,000 cash on hand.

There was a steep drop-off in fundraising after the top three,

with Williams coming in fourth after pulling in more than
$77,000. Williams spent nearly $135,000, ending the reporting
period with around $37,000 cash on hand.

Reed reported raising nearly $70,000 and spent more than

$82,000, ending the period with more than $22,000 cash on
hand.

After reporting raising the most money in his July 31 filing,

Jones had a steep decline relative to the other candidates.
Jones raised just more than $38,000 in contributions. He
reported another $10,000 in income through a vendor refund.
However, after spending more than $247,000, Jones ended the
reporting period with more than $103,000 cash on hand, the
most of any of the candidates.

Save an average of
2x more with our
(gle [go \Vi[oTe I] (oTol[A

1A
digitally | financially | personally

Attorney Ross DiBello reported raising around $1,800 in

Attorney Ross DiBello reported raising around $1,800 in (1p)

contributions and spent more than $2,200, ending the period
with around $4,200 cash on hand.

Totals

Dennis Kucinich:

Amount from last report - $36,544.24

Amount raised - $235,411

Amount spent - $226,323.30

Cash on hand - $45,631.95

Justin Bibb:

Amount from last report - $208,265.35

Amount raised - $218,664.90 (not including $59,445 vendor

refund)

Amount spent - $395,985.05

Cash on hand - $90,400.20

Kevin Kelley:

Amount from last report - $537,136.16

Amount raised - $185,415 (not including $1,823.70 in-kind

contribution)

Amount spent - $641,974.24

Cash on hand - $80,756.92

Sandra Williams:

Amount from last report - $93,667.87

Amount raised - $77,732.97 (not including $27.92 vendor

refund)

Amount spent - $134,808.84

Cash on hand - $36,619.92

Zack Reed:

Amount from last report - $35,710.12

Amount raised - $69,564.97

Amount spent - $82,332.95

Maximize your
money with our
(gle [go \Vi [oT Ih (oTol[3

.11)Y]
digitally | financially | personally

Cash on hand - $22,402.14

Basheer Jones:

Amount from last report - $302,687.50

Amount raised - $38,145 (not including $10,000 vendor

refund)

Amount spent - $247,535.40

Cash on hand - $103,297.10

Ross DiBello:

Amount from last report - $5,586

Amount raised - $1,816.69 (not including $9.65 vendor refund)

Amount spent - $2,225.99

Cash on hand - $4,186.35

Problems at Cleveland Public Power persist. Here's what the

mayoral candidates want to do about it

Listen to all the interviews with Cleveland mayoral candidates

on special episodes of This Week in the CLE

Homicides are up in Cleveland. Here are what the mayoral

candidates said they would do about it.

Frank Jackson endorses Kevin Kelley for Cleveland mayor

Former Cleveland Mayor Michael R. White returns to public

campaigning after two decades to endorse Justin Bibb

Cleveland City Council approves putting police oversight

reforms, civilian control on November ballot

Cleveland residents soon to get first chance at public comment

before City Council in nearly 100 years

How would Cleveland's mayoral candidates spend the city's

$511 million in American Rescue Plan stimulus?

Note to readers: if you purchase something through one of our affiliate links we may earn a
commission.

Around the Web Tabla Feed

New Episodes of Doctor Who Every Sunday

It's you-know-Whol Jodie Whittaker and Mandip Gill are back for an all- new
season.
AMC+| Sponsored

CHICKEN NUGGETS

4 Levels of Chicken Nuggets: Amateur to Food Scientist

cleveland.com

The Contentious Scene That Took MASH Off Air

Taco Relish | Sponsored

Here's The Salaries Made For Couple Makes A Bet: No

Each Military Rank Eating Out, No Cheat Meals,...
Post Fun | Sponsored HealthyGem | Sponsored

Historic Figures Who Lived Long Enough To Be

Photographed
Past Factory | Sponsored

No Offense, But These 2 Big 7 Mistakes Comfortable

Retailers Aren't The Cheape... Retirees Know to Avoid
MoneyWise.com | Sponsored Hiring the wrong financial advisor
can wreak havoc on your ...
SmartAsset| Sponsored

20 Everyday Things Kate Middleton Is Not Allowed To

Do
Post Fun | Sponsored

Bitcoin for beginners: what The Unfriendliest States In

you need to know before... America, Ranked
eToro Crypto Updates | Sponsored MoneyWise.com | Sponsored

Document
Document title:
title: Donald
Donald Trump
Trump backers
backers bet
bet big
big on
on Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich in
in mayoral
mayoral race
race -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/09/donald-trump-backers-bet-big-on-dennis-kucinich-in-mayoral-race.html
https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/09/donald-trump-backers-bet-big-on-dennis-kucinich-in-mayoral-race.html
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Fri,
Fri, 19
19 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 16:39:11
16:39:11 GMT
GMT Page
Page 7
7 of
of 12
Most Beautiful High School Campuses in the U.S.
FamilyMinded | Sponsored

A Candid Look At The Making Insane Black Friday TV Sales

Of 'The Wizard Of Oz' Happening Now
Factable | Sponsored Tech Sales Finder
| Sponsored

Cleveland Guardians Ohio man armed with pickax

merchandise is now on sale: forces victim to withdraw
Here’s where get hats, jerse... money from ATM, police say
cleveland.com cleveland.com

Wife Goes To Bathroom, "Throw Out Your Protein

Waitress Tells Husband This Powder" - Mike Tyson
The waitress had been closely Mike Tyson's IM-21] Sponsored
watching the husband and wife, ...
World Lifestyle | Sponsored

Document
Document title:
title: Donald
Donald Trump
Trump backers
backers bet
bet big
big on
on Dennis
Dennis Kucinich
Kucinich in
in mayoral
mayoral race
race -- cleveland.com
cleveland.com
Capture
Capture URL:
URL: https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/09/donald-trump-backers-bet-big-on-dennis-kucinich-in-mayoral-race.html
https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/2021/09/donald-trump-backers-bet-big-on-dennis-kucinich-in-mayoral-race.html
Capture
Capture timestamp
timestamp (UTC):
(UTC): Fri,
Fri, 19
19 Nov
Nov 2021
2021 16:39:11
16:39:11 GMT
GMT Page
Page 8
8 of
of 12
Wife Goes To Bathroom, "Throw Out Your Protein
Waitress Tells Husband This Powder" - Mike Tyson
The waitress had been closely Mike Tyson's IM-21 | Sponsored
watching the husband and wife, ...
World Lifestyle | Sponsored Advertisement

Fisherman See Animal Sitting On Iceberg, Then Look

Again
pawtracks | Sponsored

Plastic Surgeon: "Do This Every Day To Lift Sagging

Skin"
Beverly Hills MD | Sponsored

CHEER BUCKEYES,
BEARCATS, BENGALS
AND BROWNS PHANG
PLAYOFF PATHS.

Browns activate RBs Nick VP Harris Ohio pitch: Darcy

Chubb and Demetric Felton off cartoon
COVID-19 reserve in time for... cleveland.com
cleveland.com

Buick's Unbelievable New Mature Trainer: This Is What

Lineup On Sale "Ripped" Old Guys Do...
Luxury SUV Savings
| Sponsored Power Life | Sponsored

Luxury SUV Savings

| Sponsored Power Life | Sponsored

This Secret IRS Loophole May Change Your Life

go.dailystocktraders.com| Sponsored

63 Year-Old Fitness Legend Finds "Fountain of

Agelessness" By Eating These 4 Foods Daily
Power Life By Tony Horton
| Sponsored

House of Representatives Spirit Airlines planning

passes $2 trillion social expansion at Cleveland
spending bill along party lines Hopkins airport
cleveland.com cleveland.com

If Your Cat Bites You, Here's Plastic Surgeon: “Do This To

What It Really Means Fill In Wrinkles At Home”...
Give It Love
| Sponsored Beverly Hills MD | Sponsored

TRICOCI

B == >. — Co BLACK FRIDAY SAVINGS NOW!

PTR %
30" %

rRICOCT
UNBEATABLE
BEAUTY BUYS
Las Vegas: Unsold Alaska Cruise Cabins Are Almost | g
Being Given Away Sl oo |

F
4
Alaska Cruise Deals | sponsored searches
| Sponsored ENDS 11.29

A Young Woman Made A Royal Discovery About Her Life

At The Age of 28
FinanceChatter| Sponsored

What's trending today: Twenty One Pilots to play

November 19, 2021 Cleveland; early ticket access
cleveland.com deadline is Sunday
cleveland.com

I've Seen "Jaws" 7 Times And Couple Turns School Bus Into
| Still Failed This Jaws Quiz a Tiny Home That Outdoes...
BleacherBreaker | Sponsored Comedy
| Sponsored

Man Hears Hissing Sound, Then Sees Grass Lifting

James followed the strange hissing noise around his house. He had never

TRICOCT
heard anything like it. It led him to his backyard—that's when he froze. UNBEATABLE
BEAUTY BUYS
World Lifestyle | Sponsored

Ei BUY NOW |
ENDS 11.29
“Taems As

Take A Look At The Car Clint Eastwood Drives In Real

Life
Joy Delivery | Sponsored

Hospital community work Medina County ranch offers

benefits us all by aiming at the country living in a convenient
root of health needs: Brian... location: House of the Week
cleveland.com cleveland.com

— i 0 .
"My Three Sons" Cast: Then Does Your Cat Throw Up
And Now Often? - Try This One Trick
Past Factory
| Sponsored Ultimate Pet Nutrition
| Sponsored