Effect of Low and High Intensity Exercise On Circulating Growth Hormone in Men
Effect of Low and High Intensity Exercise On Circulating Growth Hormone in Men
1
Copyright (* 199‘2 by The Endocrine Society Prrnted in U.S.A.
ABSTRACT 0.05; epinephrine was 1,113 & 519 pmol/L us. 496 + 273, P < 0.05; and
We hypothesized that circulating GH would increase only if a norepinephrine was 7.89 & 3.45 nmole/L us. 2.83 * 1.34, P < 0.05). GH
threshold of work intensity [corresponding to the anerobic or lactate did not increase significantly from preexercise baseline during low
threshold (LT)] was exceeded. Ten healthy male volunteers (18-35 yr) intensity exercise (e.g., GH after lo-min low intensity exercise changed
first performed ramp-type progressive cycle-ergometer exercise to de- from baseline values by 1.5 & 2.0 fig/L, NS). Although lactate was
termine the LT and the maximal oxygen uptake. On subsequent morn- elevated after 5-min of high intensity exercise, peak GH was signifi-
ings after an overnight fast, each subject performed bouts of 1, 5, and cantly elevated (mean increase above baseline of 7.7 + 2.4 pg/L, P <
10 min constant work rate exercise of either high intensity (above LT) 0.05) only after 10 min of high intensity exercise (increases in 9 of 10
or low intensity (below LT). A l-h interval separated exercise bouts. subjects). The GH increase occurred despite simultaneous increases in
Gas exchange (breath-by-breath), GH, immunoreactive insulin, glu- both IRI and glucose. A minimum duration of 10 min, high intensity
cose, lactate, pyruvate, and epinephrine and norepinephrine were meas- exercise consistently increased circulating GH in adult males. (J Clin
ured at regular intervals. After the lo-min bouts of high compared with Endocrinol Metab 75: 157-162, 1992)
low intensity exercise, lactate was 7.2 f 3.7 mmol/L us. 1.4 + 1.3, P <
157
158 FELSING ET AL. JCE & M. 1992
Vol75.Nol
TABLE 2. Subject age, weight, height, and exercise gas exchange characteristics
performed progressive ramp-type cycle ergometry to determine the combined dead space of 90 mL. O2 and CO* tensions were determined
VO>max and the LT (see below). The next two sessions consisted of l-, by mass spectrometry from a sample drawn continuously from the
5-, and lo-min of constant work rate exercise on the cycle ergometer. mouthpiece at 1 mL/s. The inspired and expired volumes and gas tension
An hour of rest separated each exercise burst. For one session, the work signals upderwent analog-to-digital conversion, from which oxygen
rate chosen corresponded to 50% of the difference between the subject’s uptake (V02) (standard temperature pressure dry), CO, production
LT and VOzmax (high intensity exercise), whereas for the other session (VCO*) (standard temperature pressure dry), and minute ventilation (v,)
all work rates corresponded to 50% of the subject’s lactate threshold (body temperature pressure saturated) were calculated on-line, breath-
(low intensity). by-breath as previously described (27). The breath-by-breath data were
For a given session, subjects always performed a fixed sequence of then interpolated to l-s time intervals.
exercise duration (l-, 5-, IO-min), but the order of the exercise intensity
(i.e. high intensity day, low intensity day) was randomized. We chose
this protocol because we anticipated that lo-min exercise bouts would Noninvasive determination of LT and vO,max
be the most likely to elicit GH responses and it was performed last to
minimize possible confounding effects of a prior GH pulse on subse- The LT and 7j02max were measured noninvasively from the gas
quent pulses. We chose a l-h interval between exercise bouts. This was exchange data obtained during the progressive exercise. The lactate
a balance between, on the one hand, allowing sufficient time for gas threshold was defined as the V02 at which the ventilatory equivalent
exchange parameters, lactate, and hormones levels to return to baseline, for O2 ($,/$O,) and the end tidal O2 (PetOz),in<reased without an
and, on the other hand, minimizing the possibility of spontaneous GH increase in the ventilatory qquivalent for CO* (VE/VC02) and the end
pulses and too prolonged a fasting period. tidal CO2 (PetCO>) (28). VOzmax was defined as the highest VOZ
The subjects arrived at approximately 0800 h on the morning of a achieved by the subject.
low or high intensity exercise study. We chose the morning to perform
the study because fewer naturally occurring GH pulses are seen during
the morning hours (after about 0800-0900 h). They were instructed to GH, glucose, insulin, lactate, and catecholamines
refrain from any exercise and to remain fasted for at least 12 h before
the study. An antecubital venous catheter was placed for intermittent An in-house RIA was used to measure GH using WHO standard no.
blood sampling. Baseline blood samples were taken at 10 and 5 min 66/217, antisera generated in-house, and hGH from NIDDK for iodi-
before the first (1 min) exercise burst. The subject performed the exercise, nation purposes. The GH intraassay variability is less than lo%, inter-
then samples were taken every 10 min during the rest period. This was assay variability is 12.6%, and the sensitivity is 0.5 pg/L. Insulin was
repeated after the 5- and lo-min bursts. An additional sample was also measured using an in-house RIA using standard from Wellcome
obtained during exercise (at 5 min) during the last (lo-min) exercise equated to first IRP 66/304, antiporcine antibody from ICN and porcine
period. Breath-by-breath gas exchange measurements were made 5 min insulin from Lilly for iodination. The insulin intraassay variability is less
before, during, and 10 min after each exercise period. than lo%, interassay variability is 11.5%, and the sensitivity 7 pmol/L.
Glucose was measured using the Abbott bichromatic analyzer using the
Abbott UV glucose kit. The glucose intraassay variability is 2.1% and
Gas exchange measurements the interassay variability is 2.4%. Lactate was measured spectrophoto-
The subjects breathed through a mouthpiece connected to a low metrically using the Behring Stat-pack rapid lactate test. The lactate
impedance turbine volume transducer and a breathing valve with a intraassay variability is 2.8%, the interassay variability is 3.5%, and the
GH AFTER LOW- AND HIGH-INTENSITY EXERCISE
Results
Gas exchange parameters
The individual subject age, weight, height, and exercise
gas exchange characteristics are shown in Table 2. As ex-
pected, the VOz reached a steady state during the 5- and lo-
min low intensity exercise bouts but not for high intensity
exercise (Fig. 1). V02, of course, increased significantly with Time (min)
exercise duration for both low and high intensity exercise.
With 10 min of exercise, the peak VO, was 4 and 9 times FIG. 3. Mean GH and SE (closed circles) and VO, (lines) after 1, 5,
and 10 min of low (left panel) and high (right panel) intensity exercise.
greater, on average, than baseline for low and high intensity * indicates P < 0.05. Clear vertical bars represent the exercise bouts.
exercise, respectively. GH significantly increased only after 10 min of high intensity exercise.
Lactate and pyruvate (Fig. 2) for peak lactate among the subjects was 57%. Qualitatively
similar results were found for the lactate-to-pyruvate ratios.
As expected, lactate concentrations were increased during
all durations of high intensity exercise. There were no sub-
GH (Fig. 3)
stantial differences between the two baseline lactate values;
however, the lactate levels immediately before the lo-min Spontaneous GH pulses (judged by inordinately elevated
high intensity exercise bout were slightly but significantly preexercise GH with patterns suggesting upward or down-
higher (P < 0.01) than the baseline levels and than those ward slopes) occurred in only one subject. There were no
before the 5-min exercise bouts. The coefficient of variation significant differences between the two baseline GH levels.
GH responsesto exercise were quite variable in magnitude
3.0 7
among the subjects; the ratio of peak pulse to baselineranged
from 0.7 to 14 after low intensity exercise and from 0.5 to
51 after high intensity exercise. After low intensity exercise,
exercise-associatedincreasesin GH for the group as a whole
were not statistically significant. Two of the 10 subjectshad
disproportionately greater GH pulses than the others and
their GH pulses account by and large for the increase in the
mean GH concentration after 5 and 10 min of exercise.After
the lo-min high intensity bout there was a significant GH
pulse in 9 of 10 subjects (mean peak of 7.7 & 2.4 pg/L ZIS.a
mean baselineof 1.7 f 2.4 pg/L, P < 0.05). The smallincrease
in GH after 5-min of high intensity exercise was not statis-
tically significant. The coefficient of variation for the peak
Time (min) GH pulse after 10 min in the high intensity range was 85%.
FIG. 1. VO, during low and high intensity exercise in a representative After the lo-min high intensity exercise bout, the peak GH
subject. Note that VO, did not achieve a steady state during high pulse occurred at a mean of 29 + 12 min after the onset of
intensity (above LT) exercise even though the work rate was constant. exerciseand occurred significantly (P < 0.05) later than those
160 FELSING ET AL. JCE & M. 1992
Voll5.Nol
of lactate (15 min), E (10 min), NE (11 min), and insulin (21 Discussion
min).
The gas exchange and lactate data demonstrate that we
achieved the goal of identifying low- and high-intensity
Glucose and insulin (Fig. 4) exercise in the subjects. The lo-min period of high-intensity
(above the lactate threshold) exerciseconsistently resulted in
After low intensity exercise, glucose increased by 0.39 + bursts of GH secretion in adult males. In contrast, low
0.11 mmol/L (P < 0.05) for 5-min exercise and by 0.28 + intensity exercise, including the lo-min protocols, did not
0.11 mmol/L for lo-min bouts. With high intensity exercise, elicit significant GH responses.Despite rigorous control over
significant increases (P < 0.05) were found after the I-min the work rate, our data, like most previous studies, revealed
(0.28 f 0.06 mmol/L), 5-min (0.39 + 0.11 mmol/L), and lo- great subject-to-subject variability in the peak GH response
min (0.61 + 0.11 mmol/L) protocols. Low intensity exercise achieved (nb., the coefficient of variation among the subjects
had no significant effect on insulin. During high intensity was higher for GH than for lactate and catecholamines).
exercise, insulin increased significantly (P < 0.05) after the Thus, whereas there does appear to be a minimum threshold
1-min (29 -C 7 pmol/L), 5-min (50 + 14 pmol/L), and lo- of exercise duration and intensity necessary for a GH pulse,
min (29 + 7 pmol/L) protocols. exerciseintensity alone cannot entirely predict the amplitude
and duration of the subsequent GH response.
The onset of the GH response to exercise was later and
Catecholamines (Fig. 5) less consistent than the gas exchange, lactate, and other
During low intensity protocols, significant increaseswere hormonal responses.The elevation in GH induced by exer-
found for E after the lo-min exercise bout and for NE after cise lasted far longer than both the lo-min exercise bout
the l- and IO-min bouts. Both E and NE increased with the itself and the other substrate and hormonal responsesstud-
ied. The time required to achieve a GH responsein our study,
high intensity protocols after the 5- and IO-min bouts. The
between 5 and 10 min, was similar to that observed by
magnitude of the increase in catecholamines after low inten-
Sutton and Lazarus (9) who used a 20-min protocol. The
sity was substantially less than that observed after the high
peak GH in their study also occurred at about 30 min after
intensity protocols. The coefficient of variation for peak NE the onset of exercise, i.e. after the exercise bout was com-
among the subjects was 45% and for epinephrine was 49%. pleted. It appears that 10 min of high intensity exercise are
necessary to reliably stimulate pituitary secretion of GH.
2 200- The disappearance of GH from the circulation follows a
2 s first-order exponential decay (29-32), and reported half-
E 150-
.3
.&
2
$6
100 - -5
E
z
cJi!...jii.1
Ji.,&L
* . l
times range from 8.9 min (30) to as high as 27 min (32). A
variety of techniques, including deconvolutional analysis (29,
33), has been used to quantify pituitary GH secretion during
spontaneous pulses. We constructed a simple single com-
c 8
50.5, partment model in which GH is transported from the pitui-
tary to the circulation with first-order kinetics, and follows a
0 40 60 120 160 200
first-order disappearance from the plasma. Iterative nonlin-
0 40 60 120 160 200
Time (min)
ear curve-fitting techniques (34) were used to calculate the
time constants and the amount of GH secreted from the
FIG. 4. Mean glucose and SE (open circles) and mean insulin and SE
(closed circles) after 1, 5, and 10 min of low (left panel) and high (right mean GH levels during and after the IO-min high intensity
panel) intensity exercise. * indicates P < 0.05 for peak over baseline protocol. The following equation was used:
values. Clear vertical bars represent the exercise bouts. Both insulin
and glucose increased consistently after high intensity exercise.
where A represents the GH released consequent to the
‘t 1000 c i
exercise stimulus, 71 corresponds to the disappearance
time constant (equivalent to the half-time divided by 0.69)
for GH from the plasma compartment, r2 corresponds to
the time constant of GH release from the pituitary com-
partment to the plasma, and t is the time in min. (A 5-
min delay was included in the model).
A reasonably good fit was seen when 27 min was used
as the value for the half-time of plasma GH disappearance
(Fig. 6). The analysis predicted a total GH pulse of 0.061
I-min 5-min IO-min I-min 5-min lo-min
mg when using the mean weight of our subjects (78 kg)
FIG. 5. Mean peak values (minus baseline) t SE for NE (left panel) and a GH volume of distribution of 4.4% (35). The model
and E (right panel) after 1, 5, and 10 min of low (hollow bars) and high
(hatched bars) intensity exercise. * indicates P < 0.05 compared to low suggests a t% of the GH release into the plasma of 11 f
intensity exercise. 3 min, and a mean GH secretory rate over four half-lives
GH AFTER LOW- AND HIGH-INTENSITY EXERCISE
obic and aerobic exercise of equal duration and work expenditure determine parameters of aerobic function during exercise. J Appl
on plasma growth hormone 1e;els. Em J Appl Physiol. 52:255-7. Physiol. 50:217-21.
8. Lassarre C. Girard F. Durand I. Ravnaud I. 1974 Kinetics of human 29. Hindmarsh PC, Matthews DR, Brain C, Pringle PJ, Brook CG.
growth hormone during sudmax~mal exercise. J Appl Physiol. 1990 The application of deconvolution analysis to elucidate the
37:826-30. pulsatile nature of growth hormone secretion using a variable half-
9. Sutton J, Lazarus L. 1976 Growth hormone in exercise: comparison life of growth hormone. Clin Endocrinol (Oxf). 32:739-47.
of physiological and pharmacological stimuli. J Appl Physiol. 30. Hindmarsh PC, Matthews DR, Brain CE, et al. 1989 The half-life
41:523-7. of exogenous growth hormone after suppression of endogenous
10. Sutton JR. 1977 Effect of acute hypoxia on the hormonal response growth hormone secretion with somatostatin. Clinical Endocrinol
to exercise. J Appl Physiol. 42:587-92. (Oxf). 30:443-50.
11. VanHelder WI’, Radomski MW, Goode RC, Casey K. 1985 Hor- 31. Cameron DP, Burger HG, Catt KJ, Doig A. 1969 Metabolic clear-
monal and metabolic response to three types of exercise of equal ance rate of radioiodinated human growth hormone in man. J Clin
duration and external work output. Eur J Appl Physiol. 54:337-42. Invest. 48:1600-S.
12. Astrand P-O, Rodahl K. 1977 Textbook of work physiology, 2nd 32. Parker ML, Utiger RD, Daughaday WH. 1962 Studies of human
ed. New York: McGraw-Hill; 389. growth hormone. II. The physiologic disposition and metabolic fate
13. Cooper DM, Barstow TJ, Bergner A, Lee W-NP. 1989 Blood of human growth hormone in man. J Clin Invest. 41:262-S.
glucose turnover during high- and low-intensity exercise. Am J 33. Veldhuis JD, Iranmanesh A, Ho KK, Waters MJ, Johnson ML,
Physiol. 257:405-12. Lizarralde G. 1991 Dual defects in pulsatile growth hormone secre-
14. Cooper DM, Wasserman DH, Vranic M, Wasserman K. 1986 tion and clearance subserve the hyposomatotropism of obesity in
Glucose turnover in response to exercise during high- and low-Fi02 man. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 72:51-9.
breathing in man. Am J Physiol. 251:E209-14. 34. Jennrich R. 1988 Nonlinear regression, In: Dixon WJ, ed. BMDP
15. Wasserman K, Whipp BJ, Koyal SN, Beaver WL. 1973 Anaerobic statistical software manual. Berkeley: University of California Press;
threshold and respiratory gas exchange during exercise. J Appl 857-84.
Physiol. 35:236-43. 35. Albertsson Wikland K, Rosberg S, Libre E, Lundberg LO, Groth
16. Wasserman K, Whipp BJ, Davis JA. 1981 Respiratory physiology T. 1989 Growth hormone secretory rates in children as estimated
of exercise: metabolism, gas exchange, and ventilatory control. In: by deconvolution analysis of 24-h plasma concentration profiles.
Widdicombe JG, ed. Respiratory Physiology III. (Int. Rev. Physiol. Am J Physiol. 257:E809-14.
Ser., vol. 23.) Baltimore: University Park Press. 36. Iranmanesh A, Lizarralde G, Johnson ML, Veldhuis JD. 1991
17 Amirav I, Dowdeswell RJ, Plit M, Panz VR, Joffe VI, Seftel HC. Nature of altered growth hormone secretion in hyperthyroidism. J
1990 Growth hormone response to exercise in asthmatic and normal Clin Endocrinol Metab. 72:108-15.
children. Eur J Pediatr. 149:443-6. 37. Roth J, Glick SM, Yalow RS. 1963 Hypoglycemia: a potent stimulus
18 Seip RL, Weltman A, Goodman D, Rogol AD. 1990 Clinical utility to the secretion of growth hormone. Science. 140:987-S.
of cycle exercise for the physiologic assessment of growth hormone 38. Wasserman DH, Cherrington AD. 1991 Hepatic fuel metabolism
during muscular work: role and regulation, Am J Physiol. 260:E811-
release in children. Am J Dis Child. 144:998-1000.
19 Tarnopolsky LJ, MacDougall JD, Atkinson SA, Tarnopolsky MA, 24.
39. Laso FJ, Gonzalez Buitrago JM, Martin Ruiz C, de Castro S. 1991
Sutton JR. 1990 Gender differences in substrate for endurance
Hormonal regulation of potassium shifts during graded exhausting
exercise. J Appl Physiol. 68:302-S.
exercise. Eur J Appl Physiol. 62:292-6.
20. Bang P, Brandt J, Degerblad M, et al. 1990 Exercise-induced
40. Lavoie JM, Bonneau MC, Roy JY, Brisson GR, Helie R. 1987
changes in insulin-like growth factors and their low molecular
Effects of dietary manipulations on blood glucose and hormonal
weight binding protein in healthy subjects and patients with growth
responses following supramaximal exercise. Eur J Appl Physiol.
hormone deficiency. Eur J Clin Invest. 20:285-92. 56:109-14.
21. Friedmann B, Kindermann W. 1989 Energy metabolism and reg-
41. Yale JF, Leiter LA, Marliss EB. 1989 Metabolic responses to intense
ulatory hormones in women and man during endurance exercise. exercise in lean and obese subjects, J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 68:438-
Eur J Appl Physiol. 59:1-9. 45.
22. Hagberg JM, Seals DR, Yerg JE, et al. 1988 Metabolic responses to 42. Savin W, Davidson D, Haskell WL. 1982 Autonomic contribution
exercise in young and older athletes and sedentary men. J Appl to heart rate recovery from exercise in humans. J Appl Physiol.
Physiol. 65:900-8. 53:1572-5.
23. Greene SA, Torresani T, Prader A. 1987 Growth hormone response Darr K, Basset D, Morgan B, Thomas DP. 1988 Effects of age and
43.
to a standardised exercise test in relation to puberty and stature. training status of heart rate recovery after peak exercise. Am J
Arch Dis Child. 62:53-6. Physiol. 254:H340-3.
24. Bunt JC, Boileau RA, Bahr JM, Nelson RA. 1986 Sex and training 44. Borer KT, Shapiro B, Vinik AI. 1983 A role for somatostatin in the
differences in human growth hormone levels during prolonged control of hamster growth. Brain Res Bull. 11:663-9.
exercise. J Appl Physiol. 61:1796-1801. 45. Barstow TJ, Casaburi R, Storer T. 1989 Training speeds kinetics of
25. Raynaud J, Drouet L, Martineaud J-P, Bordachar J, Coudert J, V02 for work below the lactate threshold. FASEB J. 3:A849.
Durand J. 1981 Time course of plasma growth hormone during 46 DeVol DL, Rotwein I’, Sadow JL, Novakofski J, Bechtel PJ. 1990
exercise in humans at altitude. J Appl Physiol. 50:229-33. Activation of insulin-like growth factor gene expression during
26. Wasserman K, Hansen JE, Sue DY, Whipp BJ. 1987 Principles of work-induced skeletal muscle growth. Am J Physiol. 259:E89-95.
exercise testing and interpretation. Philadelphia: Lea & Febiger. 47 Maiter D, Underwood LE, Maes M, Davenport ML, Ketelslegers
27. Beaver WL, Lamarra N, Wasserman K. 1981 Breath-by-breath JM. 1988 Different effects of intermittent and continuous growth
measurement of true alveolar gas exchange. J Appl Physiol. hormone (GH) administration on serum somatomedin-C/insuIin-
51:1662-75. like growth factor I and liver GH receptors in hypophysectomized
28. Whipp BJ, Davis JA, Torres F, Wasserman K. 1981 A test to rats. Endocrinology 123:1053-9.