Training Material
Training Material
Prepared for
STEDIN
July 2019
Rotterdam
Publisher:
DIgSILENT GmbH
Heinrich-Hertz-Straße 9
72810 Gomaringen / Germany
Tel.: +49 (0) 7072-9168-0
Fax: +49 (0) 7072-9168-88
Contents
3 Network enhancement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43
5 Connection of grids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 66
6 Network Planning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68
7 Load Scaling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 87
7.1 Feeders . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 88
Training material ii
7.4 Exercise: Quasi-Dynamic-Simulation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 90
Notes:
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
1 Training material
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
DIgSILENT PowerFactory
PowerFactory Software
Training material 2
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
Software Structure
Basic Concepts
3 Training material
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
Data Manager
Training material 4
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
Project Structure
- Results
- General Settings
Database Structure
Global Library:
Library Only administrator is allowed
to make changes
User 1
User 2
User 3
Project
Local Library:
Library User 3 is allowed to
make changes
5 Training material
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
Project
General Definitions
Equipment Types Type A “Manufacture´s Datasheet”
…
Topology and
Grid Element 1 Element 2 Operational Data
…
• Located typically inside the project • Only the Administrator can create new
• The User can edit and create new types types and/or change the existing ones
Training material 6
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
The PowerFactory Network Model contains two folders called Network Data and Diagrams
which contains all electrical and graphical information.
- controller models
- Topology (Variations)
7 Training material
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
Project Overview
Project Overview
• Study Cases
• Operation Scenarios
• Grids
Training material 8
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
Drawing Area
Substations
9 Training material
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
• Clear presentation
• Customisable colouring
• Representation of:
- Circuit-breakers
- Disconnectors
- Tie breakers
Training material 10
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
Drawing Tools
• Typical approach: Insert busbars and the connect branch elements (lines, transformers)
11 Training material
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
Terminals
Training material 12
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
Navigation Window
13 Training material
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
Search Function
Drawing Toolbar
Training material 14
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
“Freeze” Mode:
• Freeze the graphic to enter and change data, e.g. Switches statuses or changing loads (P, Q)
Graphic Mode:
• Re-connect elements
15 Training material
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
Drawing Toolbar
Result layer
Heatmap
Drawing format
Insert page
Introduction to the Database Structure 29
Symbol Toolbar
Training material 16
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
Symbol Toolbar
Short-circuit Command
Advanced Features
17 Training material
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
• All changes are internally recorded with a time stamp in the project history.
• Undo includes all data changes (e.g. done inside the Data Manager)
• The project history resp. the time stamp is cleared upon project deactivation.
- Graphical changes
- …
Output Window
Training material 18
1.1 Introduction in PowerFactory
Output Window
Errors finish the calculations and have to be fixed (e.g. load flow does not converge!).
Warnings are issued to draw the user's attention to critical issues, but do not
terminate the calculations (e.g. reactive power limits of generators exceeded!).
Info informs the user about the calculation steps carried out in PowerFactory.
Events are output for certain simulations in which certain simulation events are
defined at certain times (e.g. failure event).
Other displays that may be of interest to the user (e.g.: result reports)
19 Training material
1.2 Creation of a first project and entering of network data
In this first exercise you will be introduced to the basic concepts of PowerFactory. A 110 kV grid
will be built from scratch.
• Create a new project with the name “PF Seminar”. To create a project, select the option
File → New→ Project. . . from the main menu.
• A grid is automatically created in the new project and a dialog will pop up. Name the grid
“110 kV grid”.
• Also a new diagram will be automatically created; rename it “Single Line Diagram HV”. To
rename the diagram, right click on the diagram tab and select → Rename page
• Change the drawing format from landscape to portrait using the icon Drawing Format. . .
from the graphic tool bar.
• You may maximise the graphic window by clicking on the icon Maximise Graphic Window
. By clicking this icon again you will get back to the original mode.
We will use a background picture as reference to help us draw the network. To include a
background picture:
• A warning window will be opened indicating that the selected file is not located in the
“External Data Directory”. In this case we can ignore the message.
Here is some guidance about creating network elements in the single line diagram:
• Select the elements from the Drawing Toolbox.
• Place the selected element in the network diagram by clicking with the left mouse button.
• If you want to enter the same element more than once, just click again in a empty space
of the network diagram.
• If you want to select a different element, right click on the mouse or press the Esc key.
• To move the element, click on it and by keeping the mouse button pressed and move the
object to the new position. Releasing the mouse sets the new location.
• If you want to resize a busbar or a terminal, select the element once and drag one of the
black boxes to the left or to the right.
• When inserting branch elements (eg. lines, transformers, loads, etc.) it is possible to
connect them directly to the desired node when inserting them into the diagram.
• Double clicking on any element will open its dialog. Here you may input the different
parameters.
Training material 20
1.2 Creation of a first project and entering of network data
Hint: Always start with node positioning. Then it will be easier to connect Branch Ele-
ments.
When editing the network, also use the Zoom-function and the Undo-functionality.
Enter the network elements of the 110 kV grid as given in figure 1.1 as follows:
• Use the element Busbar ( ) to represent the 380 kV busbar. Change the voltage level
accordingly.
• Use the short terminal element ( ) to represent the busbars between the generators and
the transformers. The voltage level here is 10 kV.
• Use the elements Single Busbar System ( ) and Double Busbar System ( ) to repre-
sent the 110 kV substations. Make sure the voltage level is set to 110 kV.
• Change the names of the single and double busbar objects according to figure 1.1. To
access the substation name open the edit dialog of the busbar and then click on the blue
arrow ( ) next to the Substation parameter.
• Connect the busbars with the line elements ( ) and change the names according to
figure 1.1.
• Add the transformers ( ), generators ( ), loads ( ) and the external grid ( ) to the
network and change the names accordingly.
21 Training material
1.2 Creation of a first project and entering of network data
• After the network data has been entered, make the background layer invisible again.
Training material 22
1.2 Creation of a first project and entering of network data
So far we have entered all the network elements, however some elements (eg. lines, transform-
ers, generators) are not completely defined without a type. First we will import a predefined
library:
• Deactivate the project before importing a file. Deactivation can be done via File → Deac-
tivate Project.
• Import the Library folder Types.pfd
• You can find the import option in the main menu bar: File → Import→ Data (*.pfd,*.dz,*.dzs).
Select the corresponding file.
• Press the black arrow button ( ) close to the New Path parameter to select the path to
which you want to import the objects. Select the folder Library → Equipment Types Library
within your project.
• Activate the project. There are several ways activate a project:
– Via the main menu bar: File → Activate Project. . . .
– Furthermore the last 5 activated projects are listed in the File menu on the main
menu bar. The last activated project is the first one in this list. By selecting an
inactive project this project will be activated.
– Via the Data Manager. Right click on the project and select Activate from the context
menu.
• Open the Data Manager and locate the folder Equipment Type Library within your project.
• Click on the left side of the Data Manager and then click on the New Object icon ( ).
• Select the corresponding type from the list.
• Create one line type (TypLne), one 2-windings transformer type (TypTr2), one synchronous
machine type (TypSym) and one busbar type (TypBar ) by using the data sheets given in
tables 1.1, 1.3, 1.4 and 1.2.
• Any parameters which are not provided should be left at their default values. You might
have to change between the different pages on the element dialog to find the parameters.
23 Training material
1.2 Creation of a first project and entering of network data
Busbar (TypBar)
Name SS 110 kV
Nominal Voltage 110 kV
Short-Circuit Peak Current 30 kA
Rated Short-Circuit Thermal Current 16 kA 1 s
Training material 24
1.2 Creation of a first project and entering of network data
Cable (TypLne)
Name N2XS(FL)2Y 1x300RM
Nominal Cross Section [𝑚𝑚2 ] 300
Rated Voltage [𝑘𝑉 ] 110
Rated Current [𝐴] 594
Max. Operational Temperature [∘ 𝐶] 90
Positive Sequence AC Resistance @90∘ 𝐶 [𝑂ℎ𝑚/𝑘𝑚] 0.078053
Positive Sequence AC Resistance @20∘ 𝐶 [𝑂ℎ𝑚/𝑘𝑚] 0.0613
Positive Sequence Reactance [𝑂ℎ𝑚/𝑘𝑚] 0.144
Zero Sequence Resistance [𝑂ℎ𝑚/𝑘𝑚] 0.2451
Zero Sequence Reactance [𝑂ℎ𝑚/𝑘𝑚] 0.578053
Capacitance [𝜇𝐹/𝑘𝑚] 0.15
Earth-Fault Current [𝐴/𝑘𝑚] 9.002249
Rated Short-Time (1s) Current [𝑘𝐴] 42.9
Max. End Temperature [∘ 𝐶] 240
Laying Ground
Generator (TypSym)
Name 46 MVA Gen
Rated Power 46.306 MVA
Rated Voltage 10.5 kV
Power Factor 0.8
Connection D
Rotor Resistance 0.0732 p.u.
Stator Resistance 0.0132 p.u.
Reactances [p.u]
xd 2.01
xd” sat 0.15
xd’ 0.27
xd” 0.175
xq 1.03
xq” 0.41
x2 0.29
Time Constants [s]
d-axis Transient 1.04
d-axis Subtransient 0.04
q-axis Subtransient 0.04
Rotor Type Salient Pole
Inertia Time Constant [s] 2.2 (rated to Sgn)
25 Training material
1.2 Creation of a first project and entering of network data
Now we will define the network elements parameters, which includes assigning the correspond-
ing type.
• Use the information provided in tables 1.5 to 1.9 to assign the types and define elements
parameters. Any parameters which are not provided should be left at their default values.
• You might have to change between the different pages on the element dialog to find the
parameters.
Training material 26
1.2 Creation of a first project and entering of network data
In this exercise we will use the command Network Data Assessment to check if all the data was
correctly inserted and see if there are any problems with the network topology:
• Press the Network Data Assessment ( ) to open the edit dialog of the command.
• Select Verification → Input parameters.
• Execute the command and check for messages in the output window.
• Execute the command again with the option Verification → Topology.
• Fix the errors if there are any.
27 Training material
2 Load Flow Analysis
• Options of Calculation
• Presentation of Results
Exercise: Load Flow Calculation
• Load Flow Calculation on the basis of an existing network
Notes:
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
Training material 28
2.1 Load Flow Analysis with PowerFactory
29 Training material
2.1 Load Flow Analysis with PowerFactory
General Procedure
Calculation Methods
AC load flow
DC load flow
• Losses neglected
Training material 30
2.1 Load Flow Analysis with PowerFactory
• Basic options
– Balanced / unbalanced load flow
– AC or DC load flow method
– Automatic adjustment of taps and shunts
– Consider/ neglect active and reactive power
limits
– Consider/ neglect voltage dependency of loads
and feeder load scaling
• Calculation settings
- Iteration control (number of iterations,
calculation accuracy etc.)
– Information messages
– Warning messages
– Error messages
• Evaluate importance of warnings (e.g. Exceeding Mvar limit range might not be acceptable)
31 Training material
2.1 Load Flow Analysis with PowerFactory
“Isolated Areas”
• A network area is isolated, if no galvanic connection exist to the slack bus bar.
• If this isolated area is not connected to a generator, then it is ‘isolated and not supplied’.
2. Results in form of Tabular Data (export results to Microsoft Office tools, windows clipboard)
Training material 32
2.1 Load Flow Analysis with PowerFactory
33 Training material
2.1 Load Flow Analysis with PowerFactory
• External Grid
- Definition of the voltage
- Definitions of the angle
-> Voltage is constant for all operational points
• AC voltage source:
- Definition of the voltage
- Definitions of the angle
Additionally:
- Definition of Impedance (positive, negative and zero sequence
-> Voltage deviation due to Load Flow will be taken into calculation
• Synchronous Machine
Training material 34
2.2 Load Flow Calculation
• To import a project select from the main menu File → Import→ Data (*.pfd;*.dz;*.dzs). . .
and then select the file to import. To activate it, right click on it and select Activate.
• Deactivate all options other than AC load flow, balanced, positive sequence.
• Execute the Load Flow Calculation command.
• Check the messages in the output window to verify if there are any warnings or error
messages (error messages will be shown in red colour) and correct the mistakes if there
are any listed.
• Once mistakes are corrected repeat the load flow calculation.
• Notice that the colouring mode changes automatically to Voltages/Loading after a load
flow calculation. Move and/or resize the colour legend if necessary.
• Add the Direction Arrows layer to the grid and configure it to show the direction of the
active power flow. (use the Layers button and jump to Element details, where the
setting Power Flow direction arrows has to be set.
• Evaluate the results shown in the result boxes.
• Add the legend for the results to the single line diagram.
– Press the Show Legend Block button to show the results box legend.
– Double click the legend with the data cursor to change the view.
– Use the graphics cursor to move/resize the legend.
• Fill out Table 2.1 with the calculation results.
35 Training material
2.3 Evaluation of results
• Choose the Current, Power Factor result box format for the edge elements (lines, trans-
formers, generators, etc.) and evaluate the results.
• Select the Branch Flow result box format for edge elements again and observe the changes
in the listed variables.
• Change the exponent for the current from kA to A.
Hint: The exponent can be changed on the Basic Data page on the study case edit dialog.
To open the study case edit dialog, right click on the active study case and select Edit
or select from the main menu Edit → Project Data→ Study Case.
• Display the voltage deviation for the nodes (busbars) within the result boxes:
– Right click on the result box of the busbar and select → Edit Format for Nodes.
– Append a new row and add the voltage deviation (m:du) to the result box.
• Create an additional result box for the transformer T-1 and add the variables active and
reactive power losses to the textbox.
– Right-click on the transformer and select Create Additional Result Box. This will
create a default textbox in the single line diagram.
• Open the Network Model Manager ( ) in order to display all busbars relevant for calcu-
lation ( ).
• Go to the Flexible Data page and sort the list according to the voltages in p.u. To sort the
list click on the corresponding column title.
• Filter the data to get only the busbars with a voltage below 1.00 p.u. Use the select icon
to define the column filter.
• Show only two decimal places in column u, Magnitude p.u.. To do so right-click on the
column title and select Edit Number Format.
• Fill out Table 2.3 with the results. Report only one busbar per substation.
Training material 36
2.3 Evaluation of results
• Open the Network Model Manager ( ) in order to display all the grids ( ).
• Define the flexible data page for the grid and select the following variables:
– Generation, Active Power (c:GenP)
– General Load, Active Power (c:LoadP)
– Losses (c:LossP)
– Line Losses (c:LossPlne)
• Fill out Table 2.4 with the results.
• Create an ASCII report for the Total System Summary and observe the results in the
output window. ASCII reports can be created by pressing the (Output Calculation
Analysis) button on the main menu.
• Clear the output window. Click on the Clear All ( ) in the output window.
• Create a new ASCII report for the Complete System Report → All.
37 Training material
2.3 Evaluation of results
Training material 38
2.4 Load Flow Calculation with Voltage Control
As you may have realised, the voltage on some busbars in the 110 kV grid is relatively low,
especially at substation “SS3”. To support the voltage in the grid, we will firstly use a station
control. We will then consider the reactive power limits and capability curves of the generators.
Finally we will adjust the transformer taps to find the best operation point of the tap changer.
A station control is a reactive power controller for one or more generators which will keep the
voltage at a specific busbar at the given set-point.
• Define a station controller for the generators “Gen1” and “Gen2”. The station control
should control the voltage of busbar “S1” of the substation “SS1”.
• To define a new station controller, select the two generators and the busbar and right-click
the selection. Then select Define → Station Control. . . .
• This will open a predefined station control dialog, which already has the generators and
the busbar entered at the corresponding positions.
• On the Load Flow page, set the voltage setpoint to 1.01 p.u.
• On the Distribution tab, change the reactive power distribution to be shared equally Ac-
cording to Nom. Power. Use the Info-button to print the control strategy in the output
window.
• Execute the load flow calculation. Has the new voltage setpoint of “SS1” been reached?
Are there any overloaded elements? 2
• Use the Network Model Manager ( ) to get the recently created Station Control ( ).
• Put the station controller out of service and execute a load flow calculation.
• We will now use the Comparison of results tool to compare the results with and without
station control, follow these steps:
– Click on the Comparing of results on/off button ( ), a message indicating that the
results where saved as Case A will pop-up.
– Put the station control in service and execute the load flow calculation command
again.
– The results are now deviations in percent (%) relative to Case A.
– Click on the button Edit Comparing of results ( ) and change the Compare Mode
to Case_B-Case_A. What is the difference on the generators? 3
– Press again the Comparing of results on/off button ( ) to disable the function.
2 The voltage is reached but the two generators are overloaded at 102.8 %
3 27.2 %
39 Training material
2.4 Load Flow Calculation with Voltage Control
• Set the reactive power limits of the generators Gen1 and Gen2 to -12 MVAr / +30 MVAr.
The reactive power limits are fixed on the Operational Limits tab on page Load Flow of the
synchronous machine dialog.
4
• Execute a load flow calculation. Are there any warnings listed in the output window?
• Open the Load Flow Calculation command and enable the option Consider Reactive
Power Limits.
• Execute a new load flow. Are there any changes in the results? Can the voltage setpoint
of the station control be reached? 5 If not, why not? 6
Reactive power limits of generators are actually dependent on the operating point. By con-
sidering the generator capability curve the reactive power limits can be entered precisely in
PowerFactory.
• Create a new capability curve, which is dependent on the active power of the machine.
Use the values given in table 2.7.
• To define a capability curve locate the folder Mvar Limit Curves within the Operational
Library. Click on the right side of the Data Manager and press the icon New ( ). The
Capability Curves (IntQlim) should be selected.
• The Input Mode is defined on the Configuration page. Take care to use the limits in p.u.
instead of in MVA.
4 Maximum Reactive Power Limit exceeded (Q = 36.98 Mvar > Qmax = 30.00 Mvar )
5 S1: Voltage set point cannot be kept (v = 0.9935 p.u., vset = 1.0100 p.u.)
6 The generators reach their limits
7 S1: Voltage set point cannot be kept (v = 0.9984 p.u., vset = 1.0100 p.u.)
Training material 40
2.4 Load Flow Calculation with Voltage Control
The voltage can be controlled by changing the tap position of a transformer. Verify that the
Station Controller is still in service.
• Adjust the automatic tap changing for the transformer T-1 as following:
– Controlled Node: LV
– Tap control: discrete
– Control mode: V
– Upper voltage bound 1.03 p.u.
– Voltage setpoint: 1.02 p.u.
– Lower voltage bound: 1.01 p.u.
• Execute the load flow calculation with the additional option Automatic Tap Adjust of Trans-
formers enabled.
8
• Are they any warning messages or elements loaded over 100 %?
• Display the transformer tap positions on the network graphic (use layers and activate
the corresponding setting within the Element Detail page).
8 No
41 Training material
3 Network enhancement
• Entering element-data
Level: Basic.
Notes:
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
Training material 42
3.1 Use of Templates
Enhancement of Networks
Use of Templates
Templates
43 Training material
3.1 Use of Templates
Templates Library
Training material 44
3.2 Enhancement of a medium voltage grid
Within this exercise, firstly you will become familiar with the 20 kV grid. Afterwards a new line
will be entered and loads and a wind farm will be connected along this line.
• Import and activate the project “BA Enhancement START” (File → Import→ Data (*.pfd;*.dz;*.dzs))
• First look at the Project Overview window: how many networks are considered in this
calculation?
• What date does the Study Case have?
• Note that you can change settings using the Project Overview window. Change the date
of the Study Case to the current day.
• Add the components of the 20 kV grid as shown in figure 3.1. Add a new line with a length
of 10 km between SS1 (20 kV) and SS3 (20 kV). The loads can be connected by selecting
the load element and directly clicking on the line. A new window will appear, where you
can enter the position of connection.
• Add switches to the left and right side of the new terminals. To add switches, right-click on
the line very close to the terminal, select Create Switch.
• Enter the load data and the line types according to figure 3.1.
• Open the circuit breaker on the right side of load L2.
Now we will connect a small wind park as shown in figure 3.2, which consists of a wind-turbine
and a step-up transformer.
45 Training material
3.2 Enhancement of a medium voltage grid
• Use single busbar system ( ) to represent the medium voltage connection of the wind
park:
– Substation Name: Wind MV
– Nominal Voltage: 20 kV
– Type: T-SS-20
• Use a short busbar ( ) for the low voltage side of the wind farm:
– Name: Wind LV
– Nominal Voltage: 0.69 kV
Training material 46
3.3 Optional Exercise: Templates
– Name: WT
– Plant Category: Wind
– Subcategory: Onshore
– Number of parallel units: 1
– Nominal Apparent Power: 5 MVA
– Power Factor: 0.9
– Local controller: Const.Q
– Dispatch: P = 4.5 MW, Power Factor = 1.0
– Sub transient short circuit current: 5 kA
– R/X” ratio: 0.1
• Execute a load flow calculation. Check if there are overloaded (> 100 %) elements.
It is often the case that a combination of generator, busbar and transformer should be used more
than once to represent a plant. In this exercise we will learn how to create a plant template to
as a solution to this requirement.
• Select the wind park created in exercise 3.2.2 (generator, transformer and low voltage
busbar).
• Right-click on the selection and select Define template
Now we will connect the newly created template to the substation Wind MV :
PowerFactory already offers some predefined substations. However it is also possible to create
customised substations, which might contain a different number of switch bays or an additional
busbar. In this exercise we will create a new substation template for a single busbar system with
two tie breakers and two bays per busbar.
• Insert a Single Busbar System with Tie Breaker ( ) system on a free area in your single
line diagram.
47 Training material
3.3 Optional Exercise: Templates
• Open the detailed view of the newly created substation ( → Show Detailed Graphic of
Substation).
• Delete two bays in every busbar and resize the busbars accordingly.
• Copy one section of the substation (e.g. BB2) and the connected elements (including tie
breaker) and paste it connecting it to the busbar BB2.
• Rename the substation to “SS Two Bays Two Tie Breakers”, short name “2B2TB”.
Hint: To access the substation name open the edit dialog of one of the busbars of the
substation and then click on the blue arrow ( ) next to the Substation parameter
• Go back to the single line diagram, select the original substation, right click on it and select
→ Update Representation.
• To hide the name of the new busbar, right click on the label and select Shift to Layer →
Invisible Objects.
• If desired, rearrange/resize the substation.
• To apply this as an user-defined substation, right click on the substation and select Define
substation template.
• You may use the new template, if you click the icon General Busbar System on
the Drawing Toolbox. Place the new substation in your network and check whether the
requested number of busbars, breakers and bays is correct.
Training material 48
4 Short Circuit Calculation
49 Training material
4.1 Presentation: Short-Circuit Calculation in PowerFactory
in
DIgSILENT PowerFactory
Training material 50
4.1 Presentation: Short-Circuit Calculation in PowerFactory
Backward-Infeed at fault
location (incl. Security
Factor)
Superposition as result
approximation
51 Training material
4.1 Presentation: Short-Circuit Calculation in PowerFactory
Superposition Method
Backward-Infeed at fault
location
Superposition as result
Training material 52
4.1 Presentation: Short-Circuit Calculation in PowerFactory
Field of application
IEC
Dimensioning of switchgears Max. currents
Cable sizing Max. thermal loading
Dimensioning of switches Ib for max. currents
Protection concept Min currents
Complete method
Protection concept Precise calculation, if Load Model is
exact
Multiple faults Supported
53 Training material
4.1 Presentation: Short-Circuit Calculation in PowerFactory
Current
Upper Amplitude ib
iDC ib
2 2Ib
2 2Ib
Lower Amplitude
Current
Upper Amplitude
DC-Component iDC
Time
Lower Amplitude
Training material 54
4.1 Presentation: Short-Circuit Calculation in PowerFactory
Nominal Voltage Calc. max. S/C Current Calc. min S/C Current
cmax cmin
Medium Voltage
1.10 1.00
1 kV < Un 35 kV
1.10 1.00
High Voltage
If Un not defined: If Un not defined:
35 kV < Un
cmaxUn Um cminUn 0.9Um
1PE
ZE
1 U1 ~ ZN1 ZT1 Z L1
2 ZN2 ZT2 Z L2
0 Z N0 ZT0 ZL0
C L/2 C L /2
3 ZE
55 Training material
4.1 Presentation: Short-Circuit Calculation in PowerFactory
Star-Point Compensation
1 U1 ~ Z N1 ZT1 Z L1
2 Z N2 ZT2 Z L2
02 3LE CL 1
Training material 56
4.1 Presentation: Short-Circuit Calculation in PowerFactory
iq(ind) [p.u.]
K
U
K
iq(kap) [p.u.]
57 Training material
4.2 Short Circuit Calculation in a medium voltage grid
In this part of the exercise, you will learn how to use the Short Circuit Calculation both near
and far from the generator, as well as the influence of switching operations on the Short Circuit
Analysis of a 20 kV medium voltage grid. Furthermore, you will consider the influence of a wind
turbine on the resulting short circuit current and how it affects the dimensioning of a busbar.
Finally, you will get to know how ground fault compensation can be implemented.
Open the circuit breaker again at the line “L SS1-SS3_b” next to load “L-2” so that the original
network topology is obtained.
Now switch to the “Single Line Diagram HV”. Activate the grid “110 kV grid” again.
• Calculate a max 3-phase Short Circuit at busbar “S1” of the substation SS1 in the “110 kV
grid”.
• Analyse the influence of the break time on the breaking current Ib. For this purpose add
Ib to the results shown in the result boxes. Use Comparison of Results for the analysis.
• Analyse the influence on the fault clearing time on Ith. Add Ith to the results shown in the
result box.
• Switch over again to the 20 kV grid. Calculate a 3-phase Short Circuit on line “SS1-SS2-
1”. The fault location should be at 70 per cent of the line (counted from the external grid).
• Analyse the influence of the fault location on the short-circuit currents.
Training material 58
4.2 Short Circuit Calculation in a medium voltage grid
In this exercise, different treatments of the transformer star point will be analysed.
Single-Phase short-circuits are especially problematic in medium voltage grids. Thus we will
continue the Short Circuit training in the 20 kV-grid.
• Change the LV star point of the two 110/20 kV transformers at substation “SS1” and “SS3”
to be “not connected”.
• Execute a single phase to ground short circuit at “SS1”. Use the IEC 60909 method.
• Note the resulting values in table 4.2.
Earthfault Compensation
• Execute the short circuit calculation at “SS1” and “SS3”, considering the isolated star
point of both transformers. What is the value of the imaginary part of the zero sequence
impedance at both locations?
• Enter the internal grounding impedance of each transformer in a way, that the network is
compensated. Therefore, use the zero sequence impedance (R0, X0) at the short circuit
busbar.
59 Training material
4.3 Additional Exercise: Complete Method and Calculation of Multiple Faults
• Now calculate the single-phase Short Circuit with the Complete Method. Is the single-
phase ground fault still compensated?
• Compare the results with those of the IEC method. Why does the connection technology
of the loads not matter in the IEC Short Circuit Calculation?
• Calculate a simultaneous single phase to ground fault at the 20 kV-lines “SS1-SS2-1” (fault
in phase A) and “SS1-SS2-2” (fault in phase B) by applying the option Multiple Faults for
the Short-Circuit method complete.
• For this mark both lines and select the right-mouse-option Calculate → Multiple Faults. . . .
After that double click on each one of the listed Short Circuit events and select the fault
type.
Training material 60
4.3 Additional Exercise: Complete Method and Calculation of Multiple Faults
• Afterwards press Close. The Short Circuit Dialog appears. Note that the complete method
and the option Multiple Faults is selected automatically. Press Execute.
• Observe the current distribution after the calculation. Change the variable choice if nec-
essary, to see the results of several phases.
61 Training material
4.4 Additional Exercise: Short Circuit Calculation in an Industrial network
Import the project “industrial grid.pfd” and activate the project. The example project contains
motors, loads, diesel generators, a battery and includes several voltage levels.
Please have a look at the position of the switches in the network in figure 4.1.
• Close the switch for the external grid and for the low voltage side of the transformer “T1”
as shown in figure 4.2.
• Calculate the max. 3 phase Short Circuit for all Busbars and Junction Nodes according
to IEC 60909. Are there any overloaded elements? Note the automatic change of the
colouring mode.
Training material 62
4.4 Additional Exercise: Short Circuit Calculation in an Industrial network
• Define a table for busbars with the use of flexible data having the following results:
– Initial short circuit current (Ikss)
– Initial short circuit power (Skss)
– Peak current (ip)
– Break current(Ib) or (Ia)
– Thermal equivalent short circuit current (Ith)
• Sort the table according to the highest initial short circuit power. At which busbar do you
observe the highest short- circuit power? Please fill out Table 4.3.
• Analyse the influence of the motor on the short-circuit current. Which motor has the largest
contribution to the fault? Please add the result to Table 4.3.
Up till now the 11 kV busbars have not been connected. Close the circuit breaker at the busbar
“Power Station” between “L1” and “R1” (as shown Figure 4.3)
• Recalculate the 3 phase max. Short Circuit for all busbars. Is this configuration allowed?
Add the results to Table 4.3 below.
63 Training material
4.4 Additional Exercise: Short Circuit Calculation in an Industrial network
By entering a type for a circuit-breaker, the user is able to detect overloading of the circuit-
breaker element during a fault. Please set up the configuration shown in Figure 4.4. The
external infeed should be switched off, the battery and the “Generator 1” should be set to out
of service. Ensure that the circuit-breaker between “L1” and “R1” of the busbar “Power Station”
remains closed.
• Add a new circuit-breaker type to the motor “CWP 2”. The circuit-breaker type should have
the following default data:
– Rated Current = 1 kA
– Peak Short-Circuit Current = 50 kA
– Rated Breaking Current = 50 kA
• Are the threshold values respected for this circuit-breaker element? Activate the option
“verification” in the tab “verification” in the Short Circuit command and set the limit to 90
per cent.
• Change the type if the limits are not respected.
Training material 64
5 Connection of grids
Notes:
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
65 Training material
5.1 Exercise: Network Connection
The project “BA NETCON START” contains a 110 kV- and a 20 kV-grid, shown in the diagrams
“Single Line Diagram HV” and “Single Line Diagram MV” respectively. The two grids are not
connected, but if you look in a Data Manager you can see that the 20 kV-grid contains three
110kV busbars. The busbars “SS1 110kV” and “SS3 110kV” are currently just connected to
external grids, but could in fact correspond to “SS1/S1” and “SS3/S1” in the 110 kV grid, and be
represented on both graphics. Mark these in graphic on the “Single Line Diagram MV”. You will
now use two different methods for achieving the connection just described.
5.1.1 Connection via pasting the same element into a second grid
• Delete the external network “Ext-SS1” and the busbar “SS1 110 kV” in the 20 kV grid.
• Navigate to the 110 kV grid and copy the busbar “SS1/S1”. Paste the copied into the 20 kV
grid ONLY graphically; to do so, return to the 20 kV grid and select the right click option
Paste Graphic Only. By selecting Paste Graphic Only a graphical representation of the
element will be added to the 20 kV grid; the electrical element will remain on the 110 kV
grid.
• Connect the transformer “T SS 1” to the busbar. Validate the results by performing a Load
Flow Calculation. The voltage at the busbar “SS1/S1” should be equal at both grids. Right
click on the busbar “SS1/S1” and select Mark in other diagram to jump from one grid to
the other.
Training material 66
6 Network Planning
Purpose: Become acquainted with helpful tools for grid expansion and operational
planing.
• Variations
• Expansion Stages
• Operation Scenarios
• Study Cases
• Data Management
Exercise: Planning by use of Variations, Operation Scenarios and
Study Cases
• Set up a Variation for Network Planning
• Usage of several expansion stages
Notes:
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
...............................................................................................
67 Training material
6.1 Presentation: Network Planning and Operation: Organising the Project Data
Relevant Terminology
1. Grids
2. Variations
1
3. Expansion Stages 2 6
3
4. Operation Scenarios
5. Study Cases
6. Study Time
7. Project overview
Training material 68
6.1 Presentation: Network Planning and Operation: Organising the Project Data
1. Grids
2. Variations
• Application:
- Representing the phased expansion of
the network in relation to time
• Definition:
- Variations are defined in terms of
Expansion Stages
69 Training material
6.1 Presentation: Network Planning and Operation: Organising the Project Data
3. Expansion Stages
Base
Stage Variation I
Expansion
Stage 1
Variation II
Expansion
Stage 1
Expansion
Stage 2
Network Planning and Operation 6
Training material 70
6.1 Presentation: Network Planning and Operation: Organising the Project Data
Base Stage
Variation II
4. Operation Scenarios
71 Training material
6.1 Presentation: Network Planning and Operation: Organising the Project Data
Several Variations can be active simultaneously Only one Scenario active at any time
Training material 72
6.1 Presentation: Network Planning and Operation: Organising the Project Data
Operation
Scenario A Exp. Exp. Exp.
Stage I.1 Stage I.2 Stage I.3
Operation
Scenario B
Time
5. Study Cases
The Study Case specifies which grids, operation scenarios, variations and calculation options
to use for a study.
73 Training material
6.1 Presentation: Network Planning and Operation: Organising the Project Data
Study Case Grid A Grid B Var X Var Y Var Z Scen i Scen ii Scen iii
SC0 x x
SC1 x x x
SC2 x x x x x
SC3 x x x x x X
SC4 x x x x x X
Project Data
Project
General Definitions
Equipment Types Type A “Manufacturer’s Datasheet”
…
Topology and
Grid Element 1 Element 2 Operational Data
…
Study Cases
Training material 74
6.1 Presentation: Network Planning and Operation: Organising the Project Data
7. Project Overview
75 Training material
6.1 Presentation: Network Planning and Operation: Organising the Project Data
Data Management
Undo Functionality
• Undo includes all data changing (e.g. done inside the Data Manager)
- Graphical changes
- …
Training material 76
6.1 Presentation: Network Planning and Operation: Organising the Project Data
Information allows:
Project Versions
Project
Latest version
Version 1 Version 2 Version 3 Version 4 created by the user.
Time of Working
V1 V2 V3 V4 with the Project
Status of Project
77 Training material
6.1 Presentation: Network Planning and Operation: Organising the Project Data
Roll-Back Function
Project
Time
V1 V2 V3 V4
Status of Project
• Internally only the data differences between the Base Project and the Derived Project are stored in
the database
Training material 78
6.1 Presentation: Network Planning and Operation: Organising the Project Data
Base Project
Base Project
New Version of
Version 1 Version 2 Version 3 Version 4 the base project
79 Training material
6.1 Presentation: Network Planning and Operation: Organising the Project Data
Base Project
Merge Tool
User 1 Derived Project
Merge Tool
User 2 Derived Project
Merge Tool
User 3 Derived Project
Training material 80
6.2 Exercise: Low voltage network planning
In the next exercise you will be introduced to the network planning and operation tools in
PowerFactory.
• Insert a new grid via Insert → Grid. . . . Name the grid “400 V town grid”.
• A new window will open, select the option Add Grid to active Study Case, this is equivalent
to activate the grid.
• Insert a new variation via Insert → Variation. . . . Name the variation “Low voltage plan-
ning”. Activate the variation.
• A new Expansion Stage will be automatically created, rename it as “First planning step”.
Chose a date in 3 months’ time as the activation time.
• Notice the differences shown in the Project overview window. Check if the study case time
is equal to the time of the active expansion stage.
• Compare the project overview window of your project to the Figure 6.1 below.
• Adjust the title of the “400 V town grid” according to your needs. You could add for example
the project title, study case name, or your company name to the title.
Note: To show the title block, select the corresponding Layer ( ). Once it is shown
double click on it to open the edit dialog
• Copy the busbar “SS2 (20kV)/S1” from the 20 kV grid and paste the busbar only graphi-
cally to the 400 V grid by using the right mouse-option Paste Graphic Only.
• Adapt the width of the busbar if necessary.
81 Training material
6.2 Exercise: Low voltage network planning
• Now, build up the 400 V grid as shown in Figure 6.2. Use the types from the global library
of PowerFactory.
• Perform a Load Flow Calculation and note the results of busbar “Police” in the 400 V grid.
What voltage do you obtain at the node?
The 400 V grid will be enhanced by a new terminal called “Town hall”. The terminal “Town hall”
is 400 m away from the terminal “Police”.
Furthermore the local fire department and the police plan to use the spacious roof area to install
a solar power plant. We will analyse whether retrofitting measures will be necessary to allow
the connection of several hundred kWp PV-power.
• Create a new expansion stage with the name “Second planning step”. The activation date
should be 6 months from today.
Training material 82
6.2 Exercise: Low voltage network planning
• Build the grid as shown in figure 6.3. Note the change of the load at the substation
“Firefighters”. Use the stated types from the global library.
• Are the limits respected for Load Flow Analysis? Are changes to the network topology
required?
• Choose another type for the overloaded lines in order to respect the limits.
It is time now to test how the activation and deactivation of variations and expansion stage work
and their relation to the Study Time:
• Deactivate the variation by using the project overview window. Which changes appear if
the variation is not active?
• Freeze the single line diagram . What changed?
• Why is the 20 kV busbar visible when the variation is deactivated if it was drawn after
inserting the variation?
• Activate the variation “Low voltage planning” again.
• Change the Study Time to 4 months from now. Which expansión stage is activated?
• Now select the expansion stage Second planning step as recording expansion stage.
Observe the message in the pop-up window and the change in the Study Time.
83 Training material
6.2 Exercise: Low voltage network planning
Before defining new operation scenarios, we recommend that our users save the base case
data in an operation scenario.
• Save the actual base case data in an operation scenario. To do so, select File → Save
Operation Scenario as. . .
• Name the newly created scenario “Base Case”.
• Open the edit dialog of some of the elements of the network. All data which is treated
as operational data has a blue background . This is a hint that an operational scenario is
active.
• The new scenario is listed in the project overview window, in the Data Manager the
operational scenarios are located in the folder Operation Scenarios. In case of an active
operation scenario, the name is highlighted in red.
• Create a new operation scenario and name it “high load”. Activate this operation scenario.
• View all loads within the project using the Network Model Manager ( ). Change the
scaling factor for all loads to 1.1.
Hint: The parameter Scaling Factor is located on the Load Flow tab
• Notice the star (*) next to the name of the operational scenario in the project overview
window. This is a hint that operational data has been changed and has not been saved.
• Define the Flexible Data page of the loads to include the Active Power (e:plini) and the
Actual Active Power (e:plini_a). Verify the scaling factor is applied.
• Execute a Load Flow Calculation and check the convergence.
• Deactivate the operational scenario high load and activate the scenario base case. You
will be asked if you want to save the changes in the deactivated scenario. Select Yes.
Comparison of scenarios
The defined changes in the operation scenarios will be compared to each other now.
• Deactivate any operational scenario which is active and clear the output window.
• Compare the operation scenario high load with the scenario base case. Follow these
steps:
– Right click on the base scenario and select Compare.
– A new window will open.
– Select the operation scenario which you want to compare with (high load) and con-
firm the selection pressing OK.
• The differences between the operation scenarios will be listed in the output window.
Operational data can be applied from one scenario to another. E.g. the high load data could
become the future base case.
• Activate the scenario to which you would like to apply the changes (destination operation
scenario) here: “base case”.
• Mark the operational scenario “high load” and select the right click option Apply.
• The data will be copied automatically and previous values will be overwritten.
• Now compare both scenarios. Are there still differences between the scenarios?
Training material 84
6.3 Study Cases
With the use of study cases, you can manage your calculation cases. A study case contains
all the necessary references to the active grids, variations and operation scenarios. By defining
study cases, you can switch easily between different calculation set-ups which differ by variation
or scenarios.
• Define several study cases, which represent the grid with different active variations, expan-
sion stages and operation scenarios, e.g. “base case”, “base case - low load”, “variation -
low load”.
– For this purpose select Insert → Study Case. . . .
– Add networks, possibly variations and operation scenarios to the Study Case via the
Project Overview Window using the right click option Activate.
– One or more grids can be assigned to one Study Case. During a calculation only
elements of an active grid will be included.
• Analyse whether there are particular combinations which lead to unacceptable operating
conditions.
Changes done in a network within a variation can be consolidated into the base grid. The
variation itself will be removed and the changed will be stored in the base network.
• Please ensure that the variation “Low voltage planning” with its two expansion stages is
active.
• Since the consolidation is irreversible, please export the project now.
• Create a version to save the currently existing project. Call the version “Finished enhance-
ment”.
• Right click in the project overview window on your active study case and select Consolidate
Network Variation. The active variations will be consolidated into the base network by this
command and the variation will be removed.
85 Training material
7 Load Scaling
Training material 86
7.1 Feeders
7.1 Feeders
Medium voltage networks are usually operated in a radial configuration. In these exercises
some typical analyses for medium voltage systems based on the 20 kV network will be carried
out. Voltage profiles which show the dependency of some variable in relation to the distance
from a feeding point and Load Flow calculations for the situation where loads along a feeder are
scaled according to a single value measured at the feeder location are examined.
• Define feeders at the in-feed transformers of the 20kV grid “T SS1” and “T SS3”.
– Define the feeder directly from the connection of the Busbar and Transformer.
– Click the right mouse button on the field between transformer and busbar and choose
Define → Feeder....
– Enter a name for the feeder and try to find a colour for later colouring. Here you can
select as well the type of load scaling.
• Name the feeders “Feeder SS1” respectively “Feeder SS3”. Note that the feeder direction
is into the 20 kV grid.
• Change the colouring mode to Feeder. Change the colours of the feeders to your liking.
• Click with the right-mouse button on this element and select Show → Voltage Profile to
create a voltage profile plot for this feeder definition.
– A voltage profile can only be created if a Load Flow Calculation was previously
performed and a feeder was defined.
• Create a second voltage profile plot for the second feeder definition “Feeder SS3”.
The loads along the feeder “Feeder SS3” are to be scaled according to a total power demand
of 35 MW that has been measured at the feeder.
• Open the Network Model Manager in order to display all relevant loads for the calculation.
• Enable the option “Adjusted by Load Scaling” for the loads “L 6”, “L 7” and “L 14” in the 20
kV grid to adjust these loads automatically. Close the browser again.
• Set the load-scaling mode of the feeder to Active Power and set the measured active
power to 35 MW.
• Calculate a Load Flow with the option Feeder Load Scaling enabled.
87 Training material
7.3 Feeder Load Scaling
Show the adjusted scale factor in the result box of the loads (Variable Set: Signals, variable:
scale).
Note: If required, it is possible to permanently apply the scaled values in place of the original
values in the network model.
• After performing an automatic load scaling, the determined scaling factors can be adopted
permanently in the database, by choosing the button Update Database and selecting
Scaling Factor of Loads.
• Increase the active power scaling of “Feeder SS3” from 35 MW to 50 MW. Are there any
overloads? Are they visible in the voltage profile plot?
Training material 88
7.4 Exercise: Quasi-Dynamic-Simulation
With the help of the command Quasi-Dynamic-Simulation you can perform Load Flow simula-
tions over a whole day, a week or a whole year, etc. This simulation is performed in the low
voltage grid.
Now the network consists of loads and one PV system, where the power infeed is calculated
depending on the altitude of the sun. The loads are defined by the load profiles.
89 Training material
7.4 Exercise: Quasi-Dynamic-Simulation
* In the following window you can select the PV system and choose the variables.
* Choose active and reactive power.
– Option 2
* Select the button Edit Result Variables in the toolbar of the Quasi-Dynamic-
Simulation.
* Choose the Results AC, balanced.
* Create a new object.
* Select Others. . . in the Class Name menu.
* Select in the following dialog Bus Net Elements and choose the element Low-
Voltage Load (ElmLodlv).
* For the element choose active and reactive power as the variable to be recorded.
• Run a simulation for the whole day. Pay attention to the date of the Study Case (12 months
from today). Choose a step size of 1 h.
• Create a diagram by selecting the option Create Subplot in the toolbox. For example add
the loading of the transformer “T SS3”, the voltage at “SS3/S1” or the active power at the
Low-Voltage Load “L Police” to the diagram.
Training material 90
Dear Participant,
Thank you for taking part in our PowerFactory training course. In order to offer
an improved training experience in the future, we are collecting feedback on how
we performed in this course.
The following address will lead you to our survey; it is completely anonymous
and it usually only takes two minutes to complete.
https://survey.digsilent.de/index.php/902019