Analysis of Magnitude and Rate-Of-Rise of VFTO in 550 KV GIS Using EMTP-RV
Analysis of Magnitude and Rate-Of-Rise of VFTO in 550 KV GIS Using EMTP-RV
Abstract – Very Fast Transients (VFT) originate mainly from disconnector switching operations in
Gas Insulated Substations (GIS). In order to determine the rate-of-rise of Very Fast Transient
Overvoltage (VFTO) in a 550 kV GIS, simulations are carried out using EMTP-RV. Each component
of the GIS is modeled by distributed line model and lumped model based on equivalent circuits. The
various switching conditions according to closing point-on-wave and trapped charge are simulated, and
the results are analyzed. Also, the analysis of travelling wave using a lattice diagram is conducted to
verify the simulation results.
Keywords: DS, EMTP-RV, Lattice diagram, Rate-of-rise, Travelling wave, Very fast transient
overvoltage
1. Introduction using a lattice diagram. Finally, all the cases of the rate-of-
rise of VFTO according to the simulation conditions are
In GIS, VFTOs are generated during the switching discussed.
operation of a Disconnect Switch (DS) or a circuit breaker.
During the switching operation, a number of pre-strikes or
re-strikes occur because of the slow speed of the moving 2. Rate-of-Rise of VFTO
contact of DS. These strikes generate VFTO with very high
frequency oscillations [1-8]. Even though their magnitudes The rate-of-rise of VFTO can be defined as the
are lower than Basic Insulation Level (BIL) of the system, magnitude of voltage per microsecond, i.e. in kV/µs. In this
they contribute to the aging on the insulation of the system paper, firstly, previous methods to calculate the rate-of-rise
due to their frequent occurrences. Also, VFTO can of voltage are discussed.
influence on the insulation of other GIS equipment such as Fig. 1 shows the methods to calculate the rate-of-rise of
transformers [9-13]. Hence, it is necessary to estimate the voltage [14].
magnitudes and the rate-of-rise of VFTO generated during
switching operations for insulation coordination of GIS
components.
This paper proposes a new method to calculate the rate
of rise of VFTO and analyzes the magnitude and rate-of-
rise of VFTO at transformer terminals in a 550 kV GIS
using EMTP-RV. Firstly, the calculation methods of rate-
of-rise are discussed. Secondly, the modelling of each
component in GIS is presented. Each component is
modelled by distributed line models and lumped line
models based on the equivalent circuits recommended by Fig. 1. Methods to calculate rate-of-rise of voltage
IEEE. Thirdly, the simulations with various switching
In Fig. 1, the rate-of-rise can be calculated as follows:
conditions are performed. The waveform and rate-of-rise of
VFTO for each case are presented. The simulation results (1) A: the slope at t=0
of rate-of-rise are verified by analysis of travelling wave (2) B: the average value of method A and method C
† Corresponding Author : College of Information and Communication (3) C: the slope from t=0 to the first peak voltage
Engineering, Sungkyunkwan University, Korea ([email protected])
* College of Information and Communication Engineering, Sung-
kyunkwan University, Korea ({hunchul0119, bihyn}@ hanmail.net)
This paper proposes the new method to calculate the
** Power & Industrial Systems PG, Hyosung Corporation, Changwon- rate-of-rise defined in (1). The proposed method uses the
city, 641-050, Korea ({gozip, dslee07}@hyosung.com). second-order difference based on the moving window
*** Dept. of Electrical Engineering., Yeungnam University, Korea
technique, which is used in transient analysis and
([email protected])
Received: August 8, 2011; Accepted: May 17, 2012 protection algorithm of power system. In this paper, a ∆t
11
Analysis of Magnitude and Rate-of-rise of VFTO in 550 kV GIS using EMTP-RV
12
Hun-Chul Seo, Won-Hyeok Jang, Chul-Hwan Kim, Young-Hwan Chung, Dong-Su Lee and Sang-Bong Rhee
open close
Circuit Breaker
state state
open close
Disconnect Switch
state state
4. Simulation
13
Analysis of Magnitude and Rate-of-rise of VFTO in 550 kV GIS using EMTP-RV
4.3 Discussion
(a) Method A
14
Hun-Chul Seo, Won-Hyeok Jang, Chul-Hwan Kim, Young-Hwan Chung, Dong-Su Lee and Sang-Bong Rhee
occurred when the first surge waveform arrives at the Table 4. Comparison of Simulation Results in Descending
transformer terminal. Order of Rate-of-rise
Surge
Rate-of- Branches on surge propagation time
Operating
Case rise propagation route and from DS to
feeder
(kV/µs) resistance transformer
terminal (µs)
3 400.575 226
11 397.382 T/L 240
10 401.623 240
9 389.031 301
6 376.81 TR 363
5 378.091 363
Fig. 8. Rate-of-rise calculated by proposed method
2 300.67 T/L 255
Table 3. Rate-of-rise calculated by each method
Method A Method C Proposed Method
(kV/µs) (kV/µs) (kV/µs) 4 275.384 TR 363
case 1 448.314 3.222 444.24
case 2 305.3 1.786 300.67 8 247.156 363
case 3 422.87 2.639 400.575 TR
case 4 281.102 1.702 275.384 7 186.934 363
case 5 387.057 1.191 378.091
case 6 387.52 1.195 376.81
case 7 191.542 1.149 186.934
case 8 252.255 1.009 247.156
case 9 409.691 1.493 389.031
case 10 407.79 2.649 401.623
case 11 410.628 2.649 397.382
15
Analysis of Magnitude and Rate-of-rise of VFTO in 550 kV GIS using EMTP-RV
the latter cases is that the former cases have shorter surge
propagation times from the DS to the transformer terminal
than the latter cases. Shorter propagation time is derived
from the shorter propagation length and the resistances per
unit length on the propagation routes are the same.
Therefore, shorter propagation time indicates that the route
has smaller resistance and vice versa. As the resistance on
the route is smaller, the damping of surge also becomes
smaller, and consequently, the rate-of-rise becomes higher.
Fig. 12 illustrates the relation between the rate-of-rise and
the propagation time. This result satisfies regardless of
closing point-on-wave.
Fig. 10. Relation between rate-of-rise and number of
branches on route in case of the closing point-on-
wave from 0° to 180°
(2V1 + 1) Z 2 − Z1
V= (4)
Z 2 + Z1
16
Hun-Chul Seo, Won-Hyeok Jang, Chul-Hwan Kim, Young-Hwan Chung, Dong-Su Lee and Sang-Bong Rhee
is inversely proportional with the magnitude of the first section. The surge toward the measurement point cannot go
waveform of the surge voltage when the closing point is into the section of the trapped charge as shown in Fig. 16
between 0° and 180°. and Fig. 17. It means that the first surge waveform
For closing point of between 180° and 360°, on the other measured after closing a DS does not influence on the
hand, the rate-of-rise is proportional with the magnitude of trapped charge. Therefore, the trapped charge does not
the first waveform of the surge voltage as shown in Fig. 14. influence on the rate-of-rise calculated by proposed method.
This is because the first peak of the surge voltage is bigger
than –0.87pu for all cases, which mean that the slope of the
initial surge voltage is positive.
17
Analysis of Magnitude and Rate-of-rise of VFTO in 550 kV GIS using EMTP-RV
18
Hun-Chul Seo, Won-Hyeok Jang, Chul-Hwan Kim, Young-Hwan Chung, Dong-Su Lee and Sang-Bong Rhee
and Systems, Vol. 10, No. 10, pp. 3593-3602, October Chul-Hwan Kim In 1990 he joined
1982. Cheju National University, Cheju, Korea,
[14] Dean E. Perry, Richard C. Raupach, C. A. EDWARD, as a full-time Lecturer. He has been a
“A Switching Surge Transient Recording Device”, visiting academic at the university of
IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, Vol. BATH, UK, in 1996, 1998, and 1999.
PAS-87, No. 4, pp. 1073-1078, April, 1968. Since March 1992, he has been a pro-
[15] Hun-Chul Seo, Won-Hyeok Jang, Chul-Hwan Kim, fessor in the School of Electrical and
Toshihisa Funabashi, Tomonobu Senju, “Analysis of Computer Engineering, Sungkyunkwan
rate-of-rise of VFTO according to Switching Conditions University, Korea. His research interests include power
in GIS”, International conference on Power System system protection, artificial intelligence application for
Transients 2011. protection and control, the modelling/protection of underground
[16] Hun-Chul Seo, Chul-Hwan Kim, “The analysis of cable and EMTP software. He received his B.S and M.S
power quality effects from the transformer inrush degrees in Electrical Engineering from Sungkyunkwan
current: A case study of the Jeju power system, University, Korea, 1982 and 1984, respectively. He
Korea”, IEEE Power and Energy Society General received a Ph.D in Electrical Engineering from Sungkyun-
Meeting - Conversion and Delivery of Electrical kwan University in 1990. Currently, he is a director of
Energy in the 21st Century, 2008. Center for Power IT(CPIT) in Sungkyunkwan University.
[17] DCG-EMTP(Development coordination group of
EMTP) Version EMTP-RV, Electromagnetic Transients Young-Hwan Chung He received his
Program. [Online]. Avaliable : http://www.emtp.com. B.S and M.S degrees in School of
[18] Allan Greenwood, “Electrical Transients in Power Electrical Engineering from Pusan
Systems”, John Wiley & Sons 1991. National University, Korea, in 1998
[19] Van der Sluis, “Transients in Power System”, John and 2000. At present, he has been the
Wiley & Sons 2001. manager for reliability engineering
team since 2006. His research interest
includes power system transients and
reliability of high voltage equipments
Hun-Chul Seo He received his B.S
and M.S degrees in School of
Electrical and Computer Engineering Dong-Su Lee He received his B.S and
from Sungkyunkwan University, Korea, M.S degrees in School of Electrical
2004 and 2006. He worked for Korea Engineering from Hong-ik University,
Electrical Engineering & Science Korea, in 2004 and 2006. At present,
Institute, Seoul, Korea, as a researcher he has been the senior researcher for
in power system division from 2006 to reliability engineering team since 2007.
2009. At present, he is working on his Ph. D thesis. His His research interest includes power
research interests include power system transients, system transients and reliability of high
protection and stability. voltage equipments.
19