Chapter 4: Design Considerations
Chapter 4: Design Considerations
Table of Contents
Chapter 4: Design Considerations .................................................................................. 1
4-1 Introduction ........................................................................................................ 3
4-2 Deflection and Camber ...................................................................................... 3
4-2.01 Maximum Allowable Deflection................................................................. 3
4-2.02 Actual Deflection ...................................................................................... 3
4-2.03 Negative Deflection .................................................................................. 4
4-2.04 Camber .................................................................................................... 5
4-2.05 Horizontal Deflection ................................................................................ 8
4-3 Beam Continuity ................................................................................................. 8
4-4 Cap Beam Center Loading Strips....................................................................... 9
4-4.01 Introduction............................................................................................... 9
4-4.02 Design Criteria........................................................................................ 10
4-5 Construction Sequence .................................................................................... 10
4-5.01 Introduction............................................................................................. 10
4-5.02 Transverse Construction Joint ................................................................ 11
4-6 T-Beam Bridges ............................................................................................... 11
4-7 Friction ............................................................................................................. 12
4-7.01 Introduction............................................................................................. 12
4-8 Prestressing Forces ......................................................................................... 12
4-9 Long-Term Superstructure Deflection .............................................................. 13
4-10 Falsework at Deck Overhangs ...................................................................... 13
4-10.01 Introduction............................................................................................. 13
4-10.02 Stem and Soffit Pour .............................................................................. 14
4-10.03 Deck Pour .............................................................................................. 15
4-11 Concrete Deck on Steel Girders ................................................................... 15
4-11.01 New Steel Girder Bridges ....................................................................... 15
CHAPTER 4, DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS FEBRUARY 2021
4-1 Introduction
This chapter covers design considerations which must be addressed during design and
review of shop drawings. Subsequent chapters cover specific design methods and
procedures.
Shop drawings must not be authorized if the applicable design considerations have not
been addressed properly in the design.
𝐋
𝐦𝐚𝐱 ≤ (4-2.01-1)
𝟐𝟒𝟎
Consideration must be given to such factors as the sequence of construction and the
depth of the superstructure when two or more concrete pours are involved.
The specifications do not include a limiting value for live load deflection, as they are of a
transient nature. However, when a bridge deck finishing machine is supported at the
outer edge of a cantilevered deck overhang, particular care must be taken to prevent
excessive deflection of the deck overhang support system. Unless special precautions
are taken, the concentrated load, due to the weight of the finishing machine, may cause
the deck overhang to deflect appreciably with respect to the remainder of the deck
surface. This will decrease bridge deck thickness and reduce reinforcing steel cover,
both of which are detrimental to the completed structure.
The applicable specification is the general requirement that falsework must be designed
and constructed to produce, in the finished structure, the lines and grades shown on the
plans. See Standard Specifications, Section 48-2.01A, Temporary Structures –
Falsework – Summary. To ensure compliance with this general requirement, add the
“deflection due to the weight of a deck finishing machine” to the “deflection due to the
weight of the concrete”. The sum of these two deflections should not be too large as to
adversely affect the character of the finished work. This will require engineering
judgment. In summary, the important point is that the weight of the finishing machine be
considered, and the total deflection limited to a realistic value.
When falsework stringers are considerably longer than the actual falsework span, the
stringer cantilever extending beyond the point of support will deflect upward as the main
span is loaded. The design must include provisions to accommodate this upward
deflection. The usual method is to use a sleeper (filler strip) on the main span only,
which allows free movement of the stringer cantilever. The sleeper should end at the
center line of the falsework top cap and should not extend into the cantilever section of
the stringer. The sleeper must be thick enough to offset the theoretical uplift on the
cantilever, see Figure 4-1, Sleeper on the Falsework Stringer.
Sometimes the contractor may use the steel beam cantilever beyond the support, with
wood beams wedged tight between its flanges, to close the gap at abutment and bent
faces. This may be acceptable for a closure distance up to 4 feet. This detail, when
applied to longer distances, can cause depression in the wet soffit concrete due to
stringer tail movement when concrete is placed in the main span. This should be
discouraged.
4-2.04 Camber
The term “camber” is used to describe an adjustment to the profile of a load supporting
beam or stringer so the completed structure will have the lines and grades shown on the
plans. In theory, the camber adjustment consists of the sum of the following factors:
• Anticipated total deflection of the falsework beam (stringer) under its own weight
and the actual load imposed
• Difference between the falsework beam profile and profile grade, also called
vertical curve compensation
• Difference between the falsework beam profile and ultimate superstructure
deflection curve (bridge camber)
• Difference between the falsework beam profile and any permanent or residual
camber to remain in the structure for its useful service life
When falsework beams are relatively short, the theoretical adjustment due to vertical
curve compensation, bridge camber, and desired permanent or residual camber will be
small and may be neglected. As falsework spans increase, these factors become
increasingly significant and must be considered along with beam deflection.
More than any other single factor, the satisfactory appearance of a completed structure
will depend on the accuracy of the camber used in the falsework construction. Good
judgment will be required, particularly in determining the amount of camber to be used
to compensate for anticipated dead load falsework deflection, take up, and settlement.
In general, the deck weight of a conventionally reinforced box girder bridge should be
omitted when calculating camber, since additional stringer deflection as the deck is
placed usually is insignificant. In the case of cast-in-place prestressed construction,
falsework span length may be an important consideration. In such structures, judgment
will be required as to the relative stiffness of the girder stems, and whether they will
resist additional deflection and by how much, as the deck is placed. Experience has
shown that including 10-20% of the deck weight for deflection is a reasonable estimate
for typical prestressed box girder bridges.
The engineer furnishes the amount of camber to use in constructing falsework; see
Standard Specifications, Section 48-2.03C, Falsework – Erection.
To warrant proper design and installation, camber strips must conform to the following
criteria:
• 900 psi maximum allowable compressive stress for perpendicular-to-grain
loading
• 1.5-inch minimum width
• 1/8-inch maximum crushing
• Must be centered along the longitudinal centerline of the falsework beam
• Structure cross slope, allowable wood crushing, and joist deflection must be
considered when determining the height of the camber strip.
• The minimum height of the camber strip must be such that the joists will not
come into contact with any part of the falsework beam under any loading
condition.
• Must not extend onto the unloaded portion of a trailing beam cantilever
• If the amount of camber is large, as in the case where a parabolic curved bridge
soffit is supported by a long falsework beam, the camber strips should be braced
or built up with wide material to avoid lateral instability. The use of laterally
unsupported tall, narrow camber strips is not permitted.
• A sleeper is required when the stringer does not follow bridge cross slope and
camber strip does not include allowance for cross slope, see Figure 4-2, Camber
Strip and Sleeper Requirements.
Because camber strips are an incidental part of the system, their installation seldom
receives more than cursory attention. Casual treatment of camber strip installation can
result in an unforeseen and undesirable loading of the falsework beam. For example, a
camber strip placed at a distance away from the centerline of a steel beam may induce
torsional stresses that were not considered in the design. Undesirable torsional stresses
may be induced in beams supporting falsework for structures having steep cross
slopes, even if the camber strip is properly placed along the beam centerline.
Horizontal deflection will be a consideration when the horizontal design load is resisted
by bending in a falsework member. This situation occurs when falsework is supported
by pile bents. For pile bents, it is necessary to combine bending and vertical load
stresses to obtain the actual stress.
The procedure for evaluating the adequacy of falsework pile bents is discussed in
Section 8-6, Pile Foundations.
Horizontal deflection may be an issue with falsework where the stringers are loaded on
the bottom flange and not directly over the web. Loading stringers this way may cause
the top flange to move horizontally. See Figure 4-3, Bottom Flange Loading.
For example, the simple span condition will be assumed when calculating positive
bending moments in joists, stringers, and similar continuous members; however, full
continuity will be assumed when calculating negative bending moments in these same
members. Assume full continuity when calculating the beam reaction on interior
supports under continuous falsework members but assume the simple span condition
when calculating the reaction at the end support.
In a framed bent, continuity must be considered in any case where stringer loads are
applied within the cap span rather than directly over the supporting post to ensure that
allowable post loads are not exceeded.
Continuous caps are often supported by two or more towers in a heavy-duty shoring
system. If leg loads are unequal, the resulting differential leg shortening will cause a
redistribution of beam reactions and a corresponding change in the magnitude and
location of maximum cap bending stress.
When beams are continuous over two or more spans, beam uplift can occur in adjacent
unloaded spans when concrete is placed in one span. Refer to discussion in Section
4-2.01A, Negative Deflection.
The engineer will be expected to recognize these and other cases where the effect of
beam continuity must be investigated to prevent the overstressing of any falsework
member or instability in the system.
The allowable compressive stress for perpendicular-to-grain loading for center loading
strips is:
• 900 psi for single strip or shim up to 6 inches thick.
• Comply with National Design Specifications (NDS) for multiple strips or shims
with a combined thickness up to 6 inches thick.
To prevent overstressing of concrete and reinforcing steel in the girder stems of T-beam
girder bridges, the Standard Specifications, Section 48-2.02B(1) General limit the length
of falsework spans to:
𝐋 = 𝟖. 𝟓𝐓 + 𝟏𝟒 (4-6-1)
Occasionally contractors request to use a longer falsework span than allowed by the
specifications. It is acceptable to exceed the specified span length provided the criteria
in Section 5-8, Longer T-Beam Falsework Spans, are satisfied.
4-7 Friction
4-7.01 Introduction
Friction used as a means of resisting opposing horizontal forces is a very intangible
factor. The use of friction for this purpose should be considered with caution. The
coefficient of friction should be assumed as not being greater than 0.30 maximum for all
contact surfaces. The only exception to this friction factor is for concrete anchor blocks,
see Section 5-5.13A, Cable Anchored to Concrete Blocks.
In general, friction may be considered as resisting the tendency of one member to slide
over or across another member, provided frictional resistance is actually developed
under the loading condition being investigated.
Do not consider frictional resistance in any case where the dead load is not applied
uniformly through all stages of construction, or where continuity would reduce the load
acting on a support under a non-uniform loading condition.
The Standard Specifications, Section 48-2.02B(2), Design Criteria – Loads, require that
the falsework must support any increase or readjustment of loads caused by
prestressing forces.
load transfer must be added to the dead load calculated in the usual manner to obtain
the total dead load for the falsework design at the hinge support.
If the dead load hinge reaction (the load applied to the cantilever span by the supported
span) is not shown on the contract plans, it may be obtained from the designer.
Long term superstructure deflection will begin as soon as the structure is stressed. As
deflection occurs, a portion of the dead load initially transferred to the falsework at the
hinge will be carried back to the falsework near the center of the span. The amount of
dead load carried back is a function of time and is not easy to predict. However, this
should not present a problem in most cases because the load carried back cannot
exceed the load originally resisted by the falsework.
If falsework is removed in stages, field engineers should be aware that part of the
redistributed load will be carried back with time, and that components of the falsework
system remaining in place near the center of the span will be subjected to a gradually
increasing load as superstructure deflection takes place. Dead load carried back may
be an important consideration when evaluating the adequacy of a given falsework
removal sequence. See also Section 9-5.03, Stage Construction, for removal sequence
considerations.
The load applied to the exterior and adjacent interior falsework beams, during the deck
pour, should be investigated in all cases where the depth of a box girder structure,
having sloped exterior girders, exceeds 5 feet. When the applied loads result in
differential beam deflection of sufficient magnitude to cause the exterior girder support
system to become dysfunctional, the falsework design must include means to resist
girder rotation. The method by which this is accomplished must be shown on the shop
drawings, such as tiebacks to the base of the adjacent interior girder.
Horizontal loads applied to the girder flanges by the falsework will produce a torsional
moment in the girder. To prevent possible overstressing of the permanent diaphragm
connections, the falsework design must include temporary struts and/or ties to resist the
full torsional moment and to prevent appreciable relative vertical movement between the
edge of deck form and the adjacent steel girder.
Figure 4-6, Steel Girder Falsework, shows conventional falsework for the interior deck
forms, however, it is common to use stay in place steel deck forms for the interior deck.
The top flange of the steel girders must be surveyed after the girders are erected, but
before any load is placed on them. This step is necessary to verify that the theoretical
girder dead load camber shown on the bridge contract plans was achieved. Any
deviation in the camber must be accounted for by adjusting the thickness of the fillet
between the top of the girder flange and the bottom of the deck.
Referring to Figure 4-7, Steel Girder Widening Falsework, the falsework on the new
girder adjacent to the existing must be constructed independently of the existing bridge.
Typically, it is constructed using overhang brackets to support the portion of the deck
hanging over the new girder next to the closure pour.
Referring to Figure 4-8, Incorrect Steel Girder Widening Falsework, the portion of the
new deck, hanging over the new girder towards the closure pour, must not be supported
by the existing girder. The existing girder is in its final position, but the new girder will
deflect downward during the deck pour. The deflection can be up to several inches
depending upon the span length and girder stiffness.
If this portion of the deck is supported on the existing girder, the deck form between the
new and existing girder will continue to move as the deck pour proceeds along the new
girder and the new girder continues to deflect. This will also result in the following:
• Point A: The slope on the new deck will change
• Point B: Rebar in the concrete placed earlier in the pour will keep moving
resulting in debonding, e.g. when the pour is at mid-span, the forms and rebar at
1/4-span are still moving due to the girder deflection.
• Point C: The concrete may debond from the steel girder.
• Point D: The outer screw jack will deflect down the same amount as the inner
screw jack, but the joist will move less at the outer screw jack, causing the joist to
only be supported at the inner screw jack and the post on the existing girder and
hence the joist will be over loaded.
The top of the steel girders must be surveyed after the girders are erected, but before
any load is placed on them. This step is necessary to verify that the theoretical girder
dead load camber shown on the bridge contract plans was achieved. Any deviation in
the camber must be accounted for by adjusting the thickness of the fillet between the
top of the girder flange and the bottom of the deck.
railroad track is less than the height of the falsework and forms. See Figure 4-9,
Falsework Adjacent to Roadways or Railroads.
The minimum width and height of each opening to be provided through the falsework will
be shown on the structure plans or in the special provisions.
The width of a vehicular opening is the distance between the temporary railings. The
clear distance between falsework posts will be considerably greater than the width
shown in the special provisions.
For a vehicular opening, no portion of the falsework may encroach into the clearance
zone shown in Figure 4-10, Clearance to Railing Members and Barriers.
The clearance is measured from the portion of the railing or barrier closest to the
falsework, e.g. for temporary railing (Type K) it is measured from the toe.
Corbels are considered part of the footing or foundation. However, if corbels are used
as build up, they are considered as other members.
For K-rail anchor details see Standard Plans, T3B, Temporary Railing (Type K).
Deflection of the falsework stringers under the dead load of the concrete will reduce the
theoretical clearance, and this must be considered in the design.
Figure 4-11, Points of Minimum Vertical Clearance, shows that the point of minimum final
vertical clearance of the bridge may not be the same as the point of minimum temporary
vertical clearance for the falsework during construction.
When pipe frame or tubular steel components are used in falsework over or adjacent to a
roadway or railroad, either as individual posts or as legs in a tower bent, the specified
minimum section modulus for steel posts will apply to the post or tower leg, but not to the
screw jack extension.
Many contractors prefer to adjust falsework to grade by wedging or jacking at the bottom
of a falsework bent, rather than at the top. In such designs, two or more posts will be
supported by a bottom cap, which will be supported by wedges or wedges over sand
jacks set on the falsework footings.
Each post must be mechanically connected to the bottom cap to withstand a force of at
least 2000 lb. The design force does not accumulate along the bottom cap, so the
connection between the bottom cap and the falsework foundation is only required to
resist 2000 lbs total, regardless of the number of posts supported. A single point of
restraint will not provide adequate resistance in the transverse direction when the 2000
lb force is applied perpendicular to the beam, unless the connection is capable of
resisting moment as well as shear. The most practical solution is to restrain the bottom
cap at both ends, and both connections must be designed to resist (transfer) 2000 lbs.
As an alternative means of providing lateral restraint, the 2000 lb force may be carried
from the bottom cap directly to the ground in the manner shown in Figure 4-12,
Application of 2000 Pound Load.
If cap systems are used as discussed in Section 6-8, Cap Systems, all the caps in the
cap system must be restrained for the 2000 lb load as discussed above for the single
bottom cap.
Each falsework post must be mechanically connected to the top cap, and the connection
must be designed to resist and comply with the following:
• 1000 lb force applied at the top of the post will be:
o Applied at the top of each post regardless of its size, spacing, or loading;
however, it will be assumed as acting on only one post at a time.
o Applied in any direction.
• Lateral restraint must be effective in any horizontal direction.
• For a bent in a highway median or in between railroad tracks, the restraint must
be effective in all directions.
• For falsework with bents parallel or at an angle to roadways or railroads, this
requirement applies to all posts within the limits shown in Section 4-12.01,
Introduction, but not less than two posts.
Details showing the connection between stringer and cap, cap and post, and post and
footing, must be shown on the shop drawings. All components must be designed so that
the specified maximum allowable stresses in bending, shear, and bearing are not
exceeded. The load duration factor, CD, for impact loading may be used to determine
the allowable value of nails and bolts used in the connection:
4-12.05D Bracing
The Standard Specifications, Section 48-2.02B(4), Falsework – Design Criteria –
Special Locations, require bolted connections when timber members are used to brace
falsework bents over or adjacent to roadways and railroads:
• For falsework with bents parallel or at an angle to roadways or railroads, this
requirement applies to all bracing within the limits shown in Section 4-12.01,
Introduction, but not less than one cross brace between two posts.
• This requirement applies to bracing in the longitudinal as well as the transverse
direction.
• The bolt diameter must be at least 5/8-inch.
• Substitution of bolts with coil rods is permitted if the root diameter of the coil rod
is greater than or equal to the required bolt diameter. Also, the substituted coil
rods must provide the capacity required for the connection. The term coil rod
includes threaded coil rods, as well as threaded rods.
• The brace must be bolted at both ends. It is not acceptable practice to use a bolt
at one end of a brace and nails or lag screws at the other end.
• Other fastener types may be used as intermediate fasteners in the center
intersection of a diagonal brace. See Section 6-3.02, Wood Cross Bracing.
All components of the falsework system which contribute to horizontal stability and
resistance to impact, except for bolts in bracing, must be installed at the time each
element of the falsework is erected, see Standard Specifications, Section 48-2.03C,
Falsework – Erection. Therefore, friction cannot be considered as contributing to the
strength of the connection, at either the top or the bottom, because frictional resistance
is not developed until a load is applied.
Bolts in bolted connections need not be installed when the falsework is erected to facilitate
adjusting of the falsework to grade. However, if the contractor elects to use nails in lieu
of bolts as a temporary expedient, the nailed connection must be shown on the shop
drawings, and the connection must be designed to resist the assumed horizontal load
while the connection is in use.
When nails are used as temporary fasteners to facilitate grade adjustment, they should
be replaced by bolts as soon as feasible, and in any case prior to placing concrete.
In the case of towers, the modified design load will be applied to all tower legs if any of
the tower legs are within the limit shown in Section 4-12.01, Introduction.
4-12.06C Bracing
The principal design requirement is that bracing for falsework bents located within 20
feet of the track centerline must be designed to resist the following:
• 5000 lb. or the assumed horizontal load, whichever is greater
• This requirement applies to both transverse and longitudinal bracing
In the specification context, the term “bent” means the overall length of the falsework
bent regardless of the number of posts used. Typically, the 5000 lb. load will govern the
design only in the case of relatively narrow structures where the bent consists of five, or
fewer, falsework posts.
The load duration factor, CD, in the wood connections is determined as follows:
• 1.25 for the assumed horizontal load or 5000 lb. load
• 1.6 for wind load
4-12.06D Timber
For timber members:
• All connections must be bolted
• The bolt diameter must be at least 5/8-inch
• Substitution of bolts with coil rods is permitted if the root diameter of the coil rod
is greater than or equal to the required bolt diameter. Also, the substituted rods
must provide the capacity required for the connection
The railroad will require solid end blocking when timber stringers are used regardless of
the height-to-width ratio of the timber stringers.
The load duration factor, CD, in the wood connections is determined as follows:
• CD = 1.25 for the assumed horizontal load or 5000 lb load
• CD = 1.6 for wind load
4-12.06E Steel
For steel, the allowable compression, tensile, bending, and shear stresses are limited
to:
𝐅𝐛 ≤ 𝟎. 𝟓𝟓𝐅𝐲 (4-12.06E-1)
𝐅𝐯 ≤ 𝟎. 𝟑𝟓𝐅𝐲 (4-12.06E-2)
• All temporary structures and equipment within 25 feet of centerline of track must
be shown on the shop drawings. Similarly, all temporary structures and
equipment, which if they were to fall over would land within 25 feet of centerline
of track, must be shown on the shop drawings.
• All temporary structures and equipment within railroad right-of-way must be
shown on the shop drawings. Similarly, all temporary structures and equipment,
which if they were to fall over would land within railroad right-of-way, must be
shown on the shop drawings.
• Soffit and deck overhang forming details should be included
See also Section 2-4.02B. Review Procedure when Railroad is Involved, for additional
information.
4-13.02 Considerations
Waste slabs are considered a construction method and not falsework as defined by the
Falsework Manual. In order to check the adequacy of the slabs, the structure
representative should require shop drawings as outlined in the Standard Specifications,
Section 5-l.23B(2), Shop Drawings.
4-14.02 Considerations
Sand beds are considered a construction method and not falsework as defined by the
Falsework Manual. In order to check the adequacy of the sand beds, the structure
representative should require shop drawings as outlined in the Standard Specifications,
Section 5-l.23B(2), Shop Drawings.
The sand bed is constructed such that the soffit joists have full bearing on the sand bed.
The plywood is designed to be supported by the joist only. Although sand is placed and
compacted between the joists, this sand is only intended to help distribute the plywood
load evenly but is not intended to support the plywood.