LP1 Uts
LP1 Uts
UNIT 1:
THE SELF FROM VARIOUS PERSPECTIVES
1.1. Introduction
This chapter explores key concepts, issues, and concerns regarding the self
and identity to arrive at a better understanding of one’s self. It strives to meet
this goal by looking at a variety of explanations from different disciplinal
perspectives such as philosophy, sociology and psychology concepts of self.
WHO AM I?
SELF
WHAT AM I?
PHILOSOPHICAL
PERSPECTIVE PSYCHOLOGICAL
PERSPECTIVE
SOCIOLOGICAL
PERSPECTIVE
A search for answers to the nature of the self and the qualities that define it can be
traced back to great philosophers during the ancient times. Over time, various
disciplines offered their own explanations. Each views in the figure above offers
understanding and insights into the nature of the self, and each can be helpful to
1 | Understanding the Self 2
young people to develop answers to the difficult but essential questions: “Who am
I”? and “What am I?”.
A. Socrates
B. Plato
These three elements of our selves are in a dynamic relationship with one
another, sometimes in conflict. When in conflict occurs, Plato believes it is
the responsibility of the Reason to sort things out and exert control,
restoring a harmonious relationship among the three elements of our
selves.
Having described his vision of the soul/self, Plato goes on to elaborate his
ideas about soul. In his theory of forms, he introduces the concepts of the
two worlds: the world of forms (non-physical ideas) and the world of sense
(reality). While the world of forms is real and permanent, the world of sense
is temporary and only a replica of the ideal world. Plato claims that the
1 | Understanding the Self 4
sensible world is dependent on the ideal world where the concept of the
soul belongs. Since the soul is regarded as something permanent, man
should give more importance to it than the physical body which resides in
world of sense.
Example:
– College life- to illustrate Plato’s psyche. College students want to hang out with their friends, spend time
on computer games, eat the favourite food, and do thrilling activities that will excite the whole gang. These
satisfy the appetitive element of the psyche. However, when professors throw challenging projects and
assignments that would require tremendous amount of time and effort, the spirited psyche kicks in to face the
challenges head on. All these are going on because the mind or the nous is orchestrating these pursuits
according to the quality of the nous a person has. In other words, in order to have a good life, one must develop
the nous and fill it with the understanding of the limits of the self, and the correct ethical standards.
C. ARISTOTLE
• The vegetative soul includes the physical body that can grow.
• Sentient soul includes sensual desires, feelings and emotions.
• Rational soul is what makes man human. It includes the intellect
that allows man to know and understand things.
Aristotle suggests that the rational nature of the self is to lead a good,
flourishing, and fulfilling life (self-actualization). The pursuit of happiness
is a search for a good life that includes doing virtuous actions.
1 | Understanding the Self 5
D. St. Augustine
E. Rene Descartes
F. John Locke
A British philosopher and politician. In
contrary to the primary reason as proposed
by Descartes, he suggested another way of
looking at the self. His proposition is that
the self is comparable to an empty space
where every day experiences contribute to
the pile of knowledge that is put forth on
that empty space. Experience, therefore, is
an important requirement in order to have
sense data which, through the process of
Figure 5: John Locke
reflection and analysis, eventually becomes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Locke
sense perception.
These sense data are further categorized by Locke according to primary
qualities such as numbers, solidity, figure, motion, among others, and
secondary qualities such as color, odor, temperature and all other elements
that are distinguishable by the subjective individual. Sense perception
becomes possible when all these qualities are put together in the faculty of
the mind.
It must be noted here that the validity of sense perception is very subjective.
Perception is changing from one individual to another. For example, when
one reads a text message: “Congratulations! You won 1M pesos in an online
lottery.” From an unknown number, one text receiver may hastily reply in
excitement and elation while the other text receiver may just totally ignore
1 | Understanding the Self 7
G. David Hume
Scottish philosopher and historian, put
forward his sceptical take on the ideas
forming the identity of the self. To Hume, the
self is “that to which our several impressions
and ideas are supposed to have a reference. If
any impression gives rise to the idea of self,
that impression must continue invariably the
same through the whole course of our lives,
since self is supposed to exist after that
manner. He claimed that there cannot be a
persisting idea of the self. While Hume Figure 6: David Hume
agreed that all ideas are derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_H
ume
impressions, problematically, it follows that
the idea of the self is also derived from
impressions.
In as much as we wanted to be persistent, constant and stable with our
knowledge about ourselves, Hume asserted that this is just impossible. As
long as we only derive our knowledge from sense impressions, there will
never be the “self.” This means that for Hume, all we know about ourselves
are just bundles of temporary impressions. Perhaps, this support the
difficulty of answering the question “Who am I?” because what we can
readily answer are impressions such as name, height, color of hair,
affiliations, skills, achievements, and the like. All these are temporary and
non-persisting. In fact, Hume harshly claimed that there IS no self.
H. Immanuel Kant,
A Prussian metaphysicist who synthesized the rationalist view of Descartes
and the empiricist view of Locke and Hume. His new proposition
maintained that the self is always transcendental. In fact, he calls his
philosophy the Transcendental Unity of Appreciation.
1 | Understanding the Self 8
I. Sigmund Freud
A psychologist, lamented the victory and
insisted on the complexity of the self. Freud,
refusing to take the self or subject as technical
terms, regarded the self as the “I” that
ordinarily constitute both the mental and
physical actions. So, we say “I run”, “I eat”, “I
decide”, “I feel the tingling sensation”, or “I
refuse to cheat because it is wrong”.
Admittedly, the question “Who Am I” will not
provide a victorious unified answer but a
complicated diverse feature of moral Figure 8. Sigmund Freud
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sigmu
judgments, inner sensations, bodily nd_Freud
movements and perceptions. He sees the “I” as
1 | Understanding the Self 9
J. Gilbert Ryle
A British philosopher, proposed his positive view in his
“Concept of the Mind”. It started as a stern critique of
Descartes’ dualism of the mind and body. He said that the
”thinking I” will never be found because it is just a “ghost in
the machine”. The mind is never separate from the body. He
proposed that physical actions or behaviours are dispositions
of the self. These dispositions are derived from our inner
private experiences. In other words, we will only be able to
understand the self-based from the external Figure 10. Gilbert Ryle
manifestation- behaviours, expressions, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilber
t_Ryle
language, desires, and the like. The mind,
therefore, is nothing but a disposition of the self.
Ryle, believed that “what truly matters is the behaviour that a person
manifests in his day to day life.
K. Maurice Merleau-Ponty
A French phenomenological philosopher.
He believed the physical body to be an
important part of what makes up the
subjective self. This concept stands in
contradiction to rationalism and empiricism.
This work asserts that self and perception
are encompassed in a physical body. The
physical body is part of self.
His philosophy, the Phenomenology of
Figure 11. Maurice Merleau-
Perception draws heavily from the Ponty
https://literariness.org/2017/05/28/key-
contemporary research Gestalt psychology theories-of-maurice-merleau-ponty/
and neurology. He developed a
phenomenological rhythm that will explain the perception of the self. The
rhythm involves three dimensions. First is the empiricist take on
perception, followed by the idealist-intellectual alternative, and lastly, the
synthesis of both positions.
On the onset, Merleau-Ponty rejected classical empiricism because it
eliminates the indeterminate complexities of experience that may influence
1 | Understanding the Self 11
Assessment:
Based on the discussion above, summarize based on your understanding the
philosophical point of view of the following Philosophers. Lastly, make your
own philosophical definition of the self by anchoring it or by getting the
commonality of the different philosophical views we discussed.
YOU
ST. (what is YOUR
PLATO ARISTOTLE DESCARTES HUME KANT
AUGUSTINE philosophical
view of the Self)
Philosophical
Perspective
Rubrics
3 2 1
All statements are Some statements are Most statements cited
Accuracy accurate and verified. accurate and verified outside information or
opinion
No more than words in Two sentences contain More than 3 sentences
a row are taken directly more than 4 words in a contain more than 4
Paraphrasing from the material row are taken directly words in a row are
given. from the material taken directly from the
given. material given.
1 | Understanding the Self 12
According to MEAD, the self is not present at birth. It develops only with social
experience in which language, gestures, and objects are used to communicate
meaningfully. Since there is meaning in human actions, a person infers
people’s intention or direction of action, which may lead him or her to
understand the world from others’ point of view- a process that MEAD labels
a role-taking. Then he or she creates his or her own role and anticipates how
others will respond. When he or she performs his or her own particular role,
he or she becomes self-aware. The self continues to change along with his or
her social experience. In other words, no matter how much the world shapes a
person, he or she will always remain creative being, and be able to react to the
world around him or her.
1. Preparatory Stage (0-3 years old) children imitate people around them,
especially family members with whom they have daily interaction. But
they copy behavior without understanding underlying intentions, and
so at this stage, they have no sense of self. During tis stage, children are
just preparing for the role-taking.
1 | Understanding the Self 14
Assessment:
Thinking outside the box. Make a “siday” about how your family,
community, and social media influenced the development of your self-
identity. Siday is a waray version of a poem. Your siday should have
all the elements of the poem with the minimum of 5 stanzas. Please
follow the rubrics as your guide.
Rubric
3 2 1
Meaning and Siday is creative and Siday is creative but appear Siday appears to be
Originality original. to be rushed. thoughtless or rushed.
Vivid, detailed images, and Some use of image, idea, or Difficult to visualize image
Sensory Details intensely felt emotion make emotion. or emotion
the poem come alive.
The siday is complete and The poem is somewhat The poem is not written in
Form
follows its intended form. written in its proper form. its proper form.
is which is also called the thinking self. The I-Self reflects the soul of the
person or the mind which is also called the pure ego.
The Me-Self, on the other hand, is the empirical self which refers to the
person’s personal experiences and is further divided into sub-categories:
the material self, social self, and the spiritual self.
• The material self is attributed to an individual’s physical attributes
and material possessions that contribute to one’s self-image.
• The social self refers to who a person is and how he or she acts in
social situations. James believes that people have different social
selves depending on the context of a social situation.
• The spiritual self refers to the most intimate and important part of
the self that includes the person’s purpose, core values, conscience,
and moral behavior. James believes that the path to understanding
the spiritual self requires introspection.
The Real Self consists of all the ideas, including the awareness of what one
is and what one can do. The Ideal Self is the person’s conception of what
one should be or what one aspires to be which includes one’s goal and
ambitions in life.
In Roger’s view, the closer the ideal self to the real self, the more fulfilled
and happy the individual becomes. When the ideal self is far from the real
self, the person becomes unhappy and dissatisfied.
other family members. To achieve an individual identity, one must create a vision
of the self that is authentic which is anchored on the meaning of his or her goals
for the future sense of having hold of one’s destiny in an effort to reach goals that
are personally meaningful.
Some of the ways adolescents try to establish their identity is through status
symbols such as having “state-of-art” mobile phone, designer bags and clothes,
and other material possessions.
Theory proposes that individuals go through eight psychosocial stages of
development. While Erikson believed that each stage is important, he gives
particular emphasis on the development formation and lays the foundation for
certain strengths and virtues in life such as hope, will, purpose, competence,
fidelity, love, care, and wisdom. Each stage consists of developmental task that
one needs to accomplish to develop successfully. During each stage, an individual
also experiences life crises which could
Assessment:
1. When you were a child, did I feel listened to or was I harshly criticized by your
family? (Explain briefly your answer)
2. Did you get appropriate attention and affection when you did great things or
was neglected? (Explain briefly your answer)
3. Are you always expected to be perfect by your family and relatives? (Explain
briefly your answer)
4. Site the most memorable moment in your childhood (whether pleasant or
unpleasant) which contributed to the person you are right now.
1.3 References
1.4 Acknowledgment
The images, tables, figures and information contained in this module were
taken from the references cited above.
C. M. D. Hamo-ay
1 | Understanding the Self
22
DISCLAIMER:
This module is not for commercial, and this is only for educational purposes. Some
technical terminologies and phrases were not changed, but the author of this module
ensures that all the in-text citations are in the reference section. Even the
C. M. D. Hamo-ay