RED (Hylocereus Costaricensis) WITH DIFFERENT METHODS Dragon Fruit Pectin Render and Characteristics
RED (Hylocereus Costaricensis) WITH DIFFERENT METHODS Dragon Fruit Pectin Render and Characteristics
https://ejournal.unib.ac.id/index.php/agroindustri
pISSN: 20885369 eISSN: 26139952
DOI :10.31186/j.agroind.11.2.120-132
ABSTRACT
This study aims to determine the effect of the method and time of extraction on the yield and
characteristics of pectin Pectin extracted from red dragon fruit peel according to the SNI pectin (01-
2238-1991) and the International Pectin Producers Association (IPPA) 2003. The experimentals
design was a Completely Randomized Design with 2 factors. The first factor was the extraction
method used, namely (M1 = conventional method, M2 = ultrasonic method). The second factor was
extraction time (W1 = 15 minutes, W2 = 30 minutes, W3 = 60 minutes, and W4 = 90 minutes. The
experiment was carried out with three replications. The results showed that the extraction method had
a significant effect on yield , equivalent weight (BE), galacturonic acid content, degree of esterification,
water content and ash content, but had no significant effect on methoxyl content. Extraction time
significantly affected the yield, BE, methoxyl content, galacturonic acid content, degree of esterification,
water content and ash content. While the interaction of the two treatments significantly affected the
yield, equivalent weight, and water content. The highest yield was 13.57% obtained from the ultrasonic
method for 60 minutes. BE pectin produced either by conventional method or ultrasonic method with
extraction time of 30 and 60 minutes has met the standards of IPPA (2003) and SNI pectin (01-2238-1991).
ABSTRACT
This study aims to determine the effect of the method and extraction time on the yield and
characteristics of red dragon fruit peel pectin according to SNI pectin (01-2238-1991) and the
International Pectin Producers Association (IPPA) 2003. The experimental design was a Completely
Randomized Design with 2 factors. . The first factor is the extraction method, namely (M1 =
conventional method, M2 = ultrasonic method). The second factor was the extraction time (W1=15
minutes, W2=30 minutes, W3=60 minutes, and W4=90 minutes). The experiment was carried out with
three replications. The results showed that the extraction method had a significant effect on yield,
equivalent weight (BE), galacturonic acid content, degree of esterification, moisture content and ash
content, but had no significant effect on methoxyl content. Extraction time has a significant effect on
yield, BE, methoxyl content, galacturonic acid content, degree of esterification, moisture content and ash content.
While the interaction of the two treatments had a significant effect on the yield, weight
equivalent, and water content. The highest yield was 13.57% obtained from the ultrasonic method
for 60 minutes. BE pectin produced either by conventional method or ultrasonic method with
extraction time of 30 and 60 minutes has met the standards of IPPA (2003) and SNI pectin
(01-2238-1991).
Adhiksana et al. (2017) to extract pectin from First, the extraction time (W1=15 minutes,
banana peels. Damanik and Pandia (2019) W2= 30 minutes, W3= 60 minutes, and W4=90
used this method to extract orange peel pectin. minutes) was the second factor. Each
experiment was repeated three times.
The ultrasonic method is an extraction
method using ultrasonic waves,with
acoustic waves namely
above
frequencies Research Stages
16-20 kHz. The non-destructive and non- Sample preparation
invasive nature of the ultrasonic method means Samples were obtained from juice
that this method can be used in various traders around the city of Bengkulu. The
applications. Kuldiloke (2002) states that the samples were washed and then sorted.
extraction process can be accelerated by the The clean samples were cut into small pieces
ultrasonic method. with a size of 1 cm x 1 cm and dried in an oven
for 48 hours at a temperature of 48 0C and
The cell wall of the material is broken down by then crushed to 80 mesh size (Tang, 2011).
ultrasonic vibrations so that the contents in it
can come out easily.
The use of ultrasonic methods in the Pectin Extraction
extraction of pectin from red dragon fruit peel 50 g of the mashed sample was put into
has not been reported. So that the properties an Erlenmeyer and added 100 ml of distilled
of the pectin produced are not yet known. The water and 300 ml of 0.05 N oxalic acid solvent.
purpose of this study was to determine the Pectin was extracted by conventional methods
effect of the method and extraction time on the and ultrasonic methods.
yield and characteristics
peel pectinofaccording
red dragon fruit
to SNI
pectin (01-2238-1991) and the International In the conventional method, Erlenmeyer
Pectin Producers Association (IPPA) 2003. containing a mixture of dragon fruit peel,
distilled water and oxalic acid was heated at
60 0C for 15, 30, 60, and 90 minutes to treatment)
(according
and then filtered. The filtrate obtained was
RESEARCH METHODS mixed with 96% ethanol (1:1), after which it
was precipitated for 24 hours, so that sour
Materials and tools pectin was obtained. The acid pectin was
The main ingredients used are dragon washed with 96% ethanol to separate the
fruit peel, hydrochloric acid (HCl) pa, aquades, monosaccharides and disaccharides.
NaCl pa,, NaOH pa, 96% ethanol, oxalic acid
pa, PP indicator pa. The equipment used is a Then dried in an oven at 40 0C for 24 hours.
Philips HR2221/00 grinder, Memmert UN110 Furthermore, the yield of pectin was calculated
oven, knife, analytical balance Sartorius and characterized based on the International
Pectin Producers Association and SNI Pectin
ED224S, calico cloth, measuring cup, Thermo
Scientific FB1410M-33 furnace, dropper, (01-2238-1991).
beaker, biuret, universal indicator, crucible , In the ultrasonic method, the extraction
process is carried out in an ultrasonic device.
thermometer, Erlenmeyer, separating funnel,
80 mesh ABM filter, Delta D150 H ultrasonic Erlemeyer containing sample mix
powder and oxalic acid are fed into the ultrasonic
cleaner , Jepo Tech TM-17SB hotplate, volume
apparatus. Extraction done
pipette, volumetric flask, suction ball, aluminum
cup. at 60 °C for 15, 30, 60, and 90 minutes. The
Research design next process is the same as extraction with
In this study used conventional methods.
2-factor complete randomized design. The
extraction method (M1 = conventional method,
M2 = ultrasonic method) is a factor
Observation Parameter
yield 176 = weight of lowest pectic acid equivalent
Equivalent Weight
(SNI 01-2238-1991)
A total of 0.5 g of pectin was added with 2
ml of 95% ethanol and then dissolved in 2.5%
Ash content
NaCl.
Pectin as much as 0.25 grams was put
The results of the mixing are dripped with 5
into a porcelain dish that had been weighed and
drops of phenolphthalein indicator and then
the constant weight was known and closed and
titrated using 0.1 N NaOH until the color changes,
weighed, then put into a kiln at 6000 C for 45
the titration volume is recorded (SNI
minutes. The ash obtained was put into a
01-2238-1991). The equivalent weight is
desiccator, after being cooled and then weighed
determined using the formula:
again to determine the constant weight (SNI
mg sample 01-2238-
=
ml NaOH x N NaOH
1991).
Methoxyl Level
(%) =
25 ml of 0.2N NaOH was added to the
solution resulting from the determination of BE, initial weight (g) final weight (g)
stirred until homogeneous 100%
final weight (g)
then cover and for 30 minutes.
Then 0.2 N . HCl solution was added Water content
as much as 25 ml and 5 drops of phenolp hthalein.
The water content is determined by
Then it was titrated with 0.1N NaOH until a pink
dried pectin for 8 hours in an oven at 400 C. The
color (SNI
formula for calculating the moisture content is as
01-2238-1991). Methoxyl content is calculated
follows:
using the formula:
(%) =
(%) =
mg NaOH x 31 x N NaOH
initial weight (g)ÿ ()
sample weight (mg) x 100 %
initial weight (g)
The yield referred to here is the entire compared to research by Nazaruddin et al.
extract extracted with 0.05 N oxalic acid. The (2011) (15-20.1%) and Yati et al. (2017) (15%).
yield obtained is about 1.39% - The yield obtained in this study is higher than
the results of Jamillah's (2011) research, which
13.57%, as shown in Figure 2. is 10.8%.
The highest yield obtained by the conventional According to Aziz (2018) the yield is influenced
method is 13.25% and the ultrasonic method by factors including the type of solvent, solvent
is 13.57 %. concentration, extraction time and the type of
The yield obtained is smaller material extracted.
16.00%
13.57%e
14.00% 13.25%e
12.00% 10.58%d
yield 10.00%
8.00% 6.18%c
5.66%c 5.73%C
6.00%
3.66%B
4.00%
1.46%a
2.00%
0.00%
15 minutes 30 minutes 60 minutes 90 minutes
Extraction time
Conventional ultrasonic
Figure 2. Average yield (%) of pectin from red dragon fruit peel
The yield obtained was higher with the showed that the yield produced by the
addition of extraction time. ultrasonic method was higher.
The highest yield was obtained from
extraction for 60 minutes, both using
ultrasonic and conventional methods. At the Equivalent Weight
extraction time of 90 minutes, there was a The equivalent weight is a measure of
decrease in yield, both in the conventional the presence of free
galacturonic
(unesterified)
the
acid
pectin
groups in
method and the ultrasonic method. Allegedly molecular chain (Arimpi and Pandia, 2019).
this happened because the solvent had The results of this equivalent weight
started to saturate. According to Ketaren measurement will be used as the basis for
and Suastawa (1995), there will be an testing the levels of methoxyl, galacturonic
increase in yield if the extraction time is acid and the degree of esterification. The
longer. Because the contact between the equivalent weight obtained in this study was
solvent and the material becomes longer. in the range of 379,878 mg - 1840,082 mg
This process continues until the solvent (Figure 3). The standard weight of pectin
Adhiksana et al. (2017) extracted
becomes saturated. equivalent according to IPPA (2003) and
pectin by conventional and ultrasonic SNI pectin (01-2238-1991) is 600-800 mg.
methods from banana peels, his research
also Results
2000 1840,082
1800
1600 1452,865
1235,911
1400
1250
1200
Equivalent
Weight
(mg)
1000
800
595,261
600 423.74
422.515 379,878
400
200
0
15 minutes 30 minutes 60 minutes 90 minutes
Extraction time
Conventional ultrasonic
Figure 3. Average equivalent weight (mg) of pectin from red dragon fruit peel
The ANOVA results show that the Likewise with the extraction for 30, 60 and
different methods and time and their 90 minutes.
interactions haveequivalent
a significant
weight
effectobtained.
on the Figure 3 shows the highest equivalent
weight found in the conventional method
The results of the DMRT test at the 5% level with a time of 60 minutes, which is 1840,082
showed that the extraction time gave a mg. This equivalent weight is still high.
significant difference to the equivalent weight Allegedly this is influenced by the nature of
of pectin. The results of the extraction with pectin or errors in the analysis process.
15 minutes of equivalent weight were This equivalent weight is higher when
significantly different with 30,60 and 90 minutes. compared to the results of the study of
Suwoto et al. (2017) which is 379,879 mg.
7.00%
6.25% 6%
6.24% 6.15%
6.00%
Methoxyl
Level
5.00%
4.00%
3.00%
2.00%
1.00%
0.00%
15 minutes 30 minutes 60 minutes 90 minutes
Extraction time
conventional ultrasonic
Figure 4. Average content of methoxyl (%) pectin from red dragon fruit peel
The results of ANOVA with a level of have low equivalent weight and better
5% showed that only the extraction time gelling ability (Aziz et al., 2018). The
had a significant effect on the methoxyl requirements of IPPA (2003) and SNI pectin
content. The DMRT test at 5% level showed (01-2238-1991) for methoxyl content have
that the levels of methoxyl pectin extracted been fulfilled.
for 15 minutes were significantly different
from the levels of methoxyl extracted for 30 Galacturonic Acid Level
and 60 minutes. The methoxyl content of One of the determinants of the quality
the extraction with a time of 30 minutes of pectian is the level of galactoronic acid,
significantly different with the time of 15 and which is an indicator of the purity of pectin
90 minutes. Pectin extracted for 90 minutes against neutral and other organic materials
had a significantly different methoxyl content (Rosalina et al., 2017). The higher the
compared to that extracted for 30 and 60 galacturonic content, the higher the quality
minutes. Methoxyl levels are related to of the pectin. According to IPPA (2003) and
equivalent weight. If the methoxyl content is SNI pectin (01-2238-1991) the minimum
high, the pectin will level of pectin is 35%. Value that
obtained in this study between 48%- galacturonic acid extract for 15 minutes was
65%, as shown in Figure 5. significantly different from the extract for 60
The ANOVA results show that the minutes and 90 minutes. Likewise with the
extraction time has a significant effect extraction for 30 minutes.
on galacturonic acid levels. The results of
the DMRT test showed that the levels of acid
70.00% 65%
59.% 62%
58%
60.00% 53%
52% 51%
48%
50.00%
galacturonic
levels
acid
40.00%
30.00%
20.00%
10.00%
0.00%
15 minutes 30 minutes 60 minutes 90 minutes
extraction time
conventional ultrasonic
Figure 5. Average galacturonic acid content (%) pectin from red dragon fruit peel
Esterification Degree
100.00%
90.00% 85.77%
79.21%
80.00% 69.58%
71.08%
66.74% 65.90%
70.00% 58.73%
esterification
Degree
of
60.00% 54.68%
50.00%
40.00%
30.00%
20.00%
10.00%
0.00%
15 minutes 30 minutes 60 minutes 90 minutes
Extraction time
conventional ultrasonic
Figure 6. Average value of esterification degree (%) of pectin from red dragon fruit peel
The ANOVA results showed that the decreased (Roikah et al., 2016). The lowest
interaction between the method and the esterification degree value was obtained from
extraction time did not significantly affect the the ultrasonic method with a time of 60 minutes
value of the degree of esterification of the pectin produced.
with a value of 54.68% and the highest was
The difference in method and the time difference produced by the conventional method with a
have a significant effect on the value of the time of 15 minutes, with a value of 85.77%.
degree of esterification with a level of 5%, so Pectin extracted for 15 and 90 minutes using
that it is continued on the DMRT test at a level of 5%. the conventional method and 15 minutes with
DMRT test results show that the extraction time the ultrasonic method the degree of esterification
provides a significant difference does not meet the IPPA (2003) and SNI pectin
to the value of the degree of esterification standards (01-22).
produced. The degree of esterification of pectin 2238-1991), because the value exceeds 70%.
extracted for 15 minutes was significantly
different from the extraction yield of 30, 60 and Ash Level
90 minutes and the pectin extracted for 30 One of the quality of pectin can be seen
minutes was not significantly different from the from the ash content. If the ash content is low,
extraction yield of 60 minutes. the pectin quality will increase. The ash content
Figure 6 shows that the degree of obtained is 6.15%-8.50%, which can be seen in
esterification obtained decreases with increasing Figure 7. The ash content value has met the
extraction time. IPPA (2003) and SNI pectin standards
Because pectin turns into pectic acid, and (01-2238-1991), which is a maximum of 10%.
methyl ester turns into galcoronic acid, so the
degree of esterification
9.00% 8.50%
8.01%
8.00% 7.17% 7.51%
6.72% 6.72%
7.00%
6.15% 6.34%
6.00%
content
ash
5.00%
4.00%
3.00%
2.00%
1.00%
0.00%
15 minutes 30 minutes 60 minutes 90 minutes
extraction time
conventional ultrasonic
Figure 7. Average ash content (%) of pectin from red dragon fruit peel
The ANOVA results show that between on the ultrasonic method with a time of 15
the method and the extraction time, the minutes, which is 6.15%. According to Fitria
interaction does not have a significant effect (2013) the remaining organic matter and the
on the ash content produced, but the method method used will affect the ash content. If
and the extraction time have a significant the ash content is high, the percentage of
effect. pectin content will decrease (Jariyah et al., 2015).
at the 5% level. The results of the DMRT test The ash content of the ultrasonic method
at the 5% level showed that the pectin which is smaller than the ash content of the
obtained with an extraction time of 15 minutes conventional method indicates that the pectin
was significantly different from the pectin produced by the ultrasonic method is purer
extracted from 30, 60, and 90 minutes. But than the conventional method.
the results of the pectin extract with a time of
60 minutes had no significant effect with 90 minutes.
Figure 7 shows the ash content Water content
produced by the ultrasonic method is lower Figure 8 shows the water content
than the ash content of the conventional obtained. The value is in the range of
method. The highest ash content is found in 2.16-3%, all of which have met the IPPA
the conventional method of extraction time of (2003) standard and SNI pectin (01-2238-1991)
90 minutes, which is 8.50%. The lowest ash which is a maximum of 12%.
content is
3.50%
3%
2.87%
3.00% 2.44%
2.52%
2.40%
2.50% 2.35%
2.16% 2.20%
content
Water 2.00%
1.50%
1.00%
0.50%
0.00%
15 minutes 30 minutes 60 minutes 90 minutes
Extraction Time
conventional ultrasonic
Figure 8. Average water content (%) of pectin from red dragon fruit peel
Rangana, S. (1977). Hanbook of Analysis and Naga (Hylocereus Polyrhizus) and its Use
Quality Control for Fruit Vegetable as a Binder in Toothpaste Preparations.
Products. Second Edition. Journal of Pharmaceutical Media, 14(1),
McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited. 1-16.
New Delhi. 35.