Notes On Reading in The Philippine History (Compilation)
Notes On Reading in The Philippine History (Compilation)
History might be written on the papyrus, walls, temples, coliseums, o It includes looking at the personal data providers apparent
sphinx, obelisks and other monumental relics of the past. Ancient or possible motives.
scribes and writers wrote the most critical event in their time for o It indicates the accuracy, trustworthiness and integrity of
memoriam, but their written text eventually become the reference to the materials to which historical data will be based
understand the following events. 2. External Criticism
History lets you travel through a world of books, documents, artifacts, o It applies experimental science to certify the authenticity of
digital media and images to places. Studying History is excellent at the material that holds the data in which historical
developing attributes for life and a range of skills for employment, information will be based.
and it provides you with curiosity and creativity to understand the o It entails such physical and technical tests as the dating of
world. paper when a document is written.
History is being written based on the actual evidence, manuscripts o It involves knowledge of when certain things existed, or it
and written documents which provide sources of historical supports the claim whether it is possible or impossible to
information. exist.
2 CATEGORIES OF HISTORICAL DATA o It evaluates the authenticity and genuineness of data.
Primary Source
TWO CLASSIFICATIONS OF DATA
It provides direct or firsthand evidence about an event, Primary data
object, person, or work of art. o Means original data that has been collected especially for
It contains first hand knowledge about historical events , the purpose in mind, this type of data is generally afresh
figures and people and collected for the first time. It is useful for current
It provides compelling and direct evidence of human studies as well for future studies.
activity. Primary Research Methods and techniques
These are the things that were created or in use during the Primary Research
period which is being studied. Quantitative – based on numbers. (Quantitative)Survey Experiments
These sources are actual records that have survived from Mechanical Observation Simulation
the past. Qualitative – more detail. (Qualitative) Focus Groups Individual
Examples of Primary Sources: Depth Interviews Human Observation Case Studies
Autobiography, Memoirs, Eyewitness Accounts, Diary, Fossils, Quantitative Research Categories Sampling Methods:
Relics, Letters, Photographs, Speeches, Videos, Legal documents, Random Sample - Equal chance of anyone being picked.
Ornaments, Clothing, Tools. Stratified or Segment Random Sampling – Samples on the basis of a
I TELL YOU SOMETHING, I AM THE PRIMARY SOURCE . representative strata or segment.
Secondary Sources Quota Sampling – By segment, not randomly selected.
It is something that was made by someone or by a group of Advantages of primary data
people who participated in the historical era which is being o Targeted issues are addressed Data interpretation is better
studied. Efficient spending for information Decency of data
These are usually created by historians and scholastic Proprietary issues Addressed specific research issues
writers based on their interpretation of the primary sources. Greater control
These are sources of historical data which are created later Disadvantages of primary data
or after the historical event which is being studied and o High cost, time consuming, inaccurate feed-back, a greater
provided by the people who were not present in that event. number of resources is required
It describes, discuss, interpret, comment upon, analyze, Secondary data
evaluate, summarize, and process primary sources. o Secondary data is data that has been collected for another
Examples of Secondary Sources purpose, it involves less cost, time and effort. Secondary
Biography, Encyclopedia, Textbooks, Thesis, Dissertation, data is data that is being reused.
Interviews, News reports, Movies, News Articles, Scholarly Journals, Internal Sources – Marketing Applications, Sales Record, Marketing
Transcriptions, Almanacs, Dictionaries. Activity, Cost Information, Distributor Reports, Costumer Feedback.
SOMEONE ELSE WHAT I TOLD YOU, YOU ARE THE SECONDARY External Sources – Financial Applications, Journals, Books,
SOURCE. Magazines, Newspaper, Libraries, The Internet
Two Ways to Examine the Historical Sources for the Scholastic Advantages of secondary data
Writers and Historians to Validate the Authenticity of the Sources that o Ease of access, Low cost to acquire, Clarification of
They Collected:
research question, may answer research questions
1.Internal Criticism
Disadvantages of secondary data
o It looks within the data itself to try to determine the truth-
Quality of research, not specific to researchers needs, incomplete
facts and the reasonable interpretation information, not timely
Lesson 2: site of the first
o Stating by the footnote to Francisco Colin’s Labor
Evangelica that Magellan did not go to Butuan but form
Limasawa to Cebu.
Mass in the Philippines o Francisco Albo
o Pilot of Magellan’s flagship does not mention the first mass
ANTONIO PIGAFETTA
but he writes that they erected a cross on a mountain
o Around 1491 when he was born at Vicenza, republic of which overlooked three islands the west and the
Venice or was know now as Italy and died at the aged of southwest.
39-40 around 1531. James Robertson
o He studied astronomy; geography and cartography. o Agreed with Pastells in a footnote that “Mazua” was
o An Italian scholar and explorer from the republic of Venice. actually Limasawa
o He travelled with the Portuguese explorer Ferdinand o In the authentic account of Pigafetta, the port was not in
Magellan and his crew on their first voyage around the Butuan but an island named Mazua (Masawa).
world. Father Bernard
o He was one of the 18 men who returned to Spain in 1522. o studied all the Pigafetta’s maps, which place in Mazau off
the southern tip of the larger island of Leyte., a check with
o The first Catholic Mass in the Philippines was held on
the modern maps will show that this jibes with Limasawa
March 31, 1521 (Eastern Sunday) and not Masao or Butuan.
o Father Pedro de Valderrama. EVIDENCE FOR LIMASAWA
o Located at the southern Leyte. 1. The evidence of albo’s log-book
o A popularly known as the birthplace of the church in the 2. The evidence of pigafetta pigafetta’s testimony regarding the route
Philippines. 3. The evidence of pigafetta’s map
o Holy first mass marked the birth of roman Catholicism in 4. the two native kings
the Philippines. 5. The seven days at “mazaua”
6. An argument from omission
PLANTING OF THE CROSS
7. Summary of the evidence of albo and pigafetta.
o In the afternoon, Magellan instructed his comrades to plant
8. Confirmatory evidence from the legazpi expedition.
a large cross on the top of a hill overlooking the sea.
CONTROVERSIES BETWEEN LIMASAWA AND MASAO/BUTUAN Proclamation of the National Shrine
o The legislative fiat declared the site in Magallanes,
MASAO/BUTUAN Limasawa Island in the Province of Leyte, where the first
1872 Mass in the Philippines was held is hereby declared a
o A monument to commemorate the site of first mass on the national shrine to commemorate the birth of Christianity in
Philippines was erected in Butuan. the Philippines. Magallanes is east of the island of
1953 Limasawa.
o The people in Butuan asked the Philippine Historical
Committee to rehabilitate the monument or place a marker
Lesson 3: Jose Rizal’s
on the site.
o On the basis of this objection the monument was re
Retraction
erected but the marble slab stating it was the site of first
Retraction
mass was removed.
o Zaide identified Masao in Butuan as the location of the first
Retraction is a statement of saying that something you said
mass. The basis Zaide’s claim is the diary of Antonio or wrote at an earlier time is not true or correct. For more
Pigafetta, chronicle of Magellan’s voyage. understanding it simply withdrawal or taking back
EVIDENCE FOR MASAO promises, statement, opinion, etc.
o The name of the place, The route from Homonhon, The
latitude position, The geographical features, The bonfire, HE DID OR HE DID NOT?
The balanghai, House, Abundance of gold, A developed
settlement A question that was raised up following Jose Rizal’s
LIMASAWA execution on December 30,1896 at Bagong Bayan. From
Jaime de Veyra the accounts of priest and Spanish newspaper, he
o Stated that the first mass was celebrated in Limawasa not retracted but for those who opposed, there was a secret
letter hidden inside Jose Rizal’s shoes denying the
in Butuan.
retraction and a claim that friars published a fake copy of
Historian Pablo Pastells
retraction. Regardless of whether he retracted or not, the
love for his country is admirable and worthy of emulation.
Arguments Favoring the Retraction FASCIST newspapers at that time. Morato maintained the
o According to rumor favoring that Jose Rizal’s retraction, the Rizal never retracted although friars managed to publish a
Spanish friars who visited him before he get executed fake copy of his retraction (Pasigui & Cebalu, 2006).
convinced him to make retraction, for the approval of Josephine Bracken Failed to Produce Marriage Contract
marrying Josephine Bracken because according to some o After Jose Rizal’s death in 1896 Josephine Bracken sued
information he wanted to marry Josephine Bracken when the Rizal Family in order to produce the so-called “Jose’s
he was on Dapitan. On the other hand, he did retraction for Last Will and Testamend” and even wrote Ferdinand
the reason that he died as Catholic. Blumentritt asking help to claim some properties entitled to
Father Balaguer’s Text her being thw window of Rizal. When Basa received the
o The second is form Father Balaguer’s text dated January demand from Josephine and her lawyers, he only asked
1897. Josephine’s proof marriage with Jose Rizal, a marriage
Father Manuel Garcia’s Text certificate issued by church authorities in Manila or even a
o The third is alleged “original” text discovered by Father certification from the British Consul in Manila. Josephine
Manuel Garcia on May 18, 1935 was not able to produce the document and so she failed to
Letters of Josephine Bracken claim some properties of Rizal. (If there is no marriage then
o According to De Viana (2013), in the Jose Rizal National there could be no retraction that took place before Rizal. (If
Centennial Commission published Rizal’s letters to his there no marriage then there could be no retraction that
friends and relatives. Included among these letters was took place before Rizal was executed, as retraction is a
one made by Josephine Bracken in 1897 which was a brief condition before the frias will solomenize Jose and
If Bracken, in her diary claimed that Rizal married her Josephine’s wedding
hours before Rizal’s execution and the fact that she o For the reason of Baron Fernandez, this man stated that he
even used “Rizal” as username. Then, there could be has a proof stating that before Rizal faced death, Rizal told
a retraction. It is a condition of the priest before to his sister Narcisa to look on his shoebox, because he
solemnizing the marriage of Rizal and Bracken that had a letter that could be a proof of Rizal’s denial to his
the former (Rizal) retracted first. retraction. The second witness is Manoling Morato, a friend
07:00 - 07:03 a.m. Sounds of gun. Rizal turns halfway of Baron Fernandez, he said that the friar forged the
around, falls down backwards and lies on the ground retraction letter and published in the Clerico-Fascist
Newspaper. Both Manoling Morato and Baron Fernandez
facing the sun. Silence. Shouts of vivas for Spain .
have documents to prove that when Rizal was with
An Eyewitness Account by Rev. Fr. Antonio Rosell
Josephine Bracken and Archbishop of Cebu at that time
o “I heard Fathers Balaguer and Villaclara tell of the
tried to offer the marriage the archbishop neglect and told
conversation of the condemned man with all the details of Rizal that he does not do marriage in excommunicated,
discussion and observations that took place among them. and he offers him to retract. Rizal did not retract instead he
Likewise, I heard them relate the Rizal Spontaneously and Josephine Bracken lived together and even if they
asked his confession to be heard, receiving many times lived together there are no proofs that they are married.
this Sacrament and that after the dawn of the thirtieth he They don’t have any marriage certificate.
took communication and was united in Holy Matrimony with
the young Irish Josefina. There was according to these
fathers a brief but complete retraction written and signed by
Lesson 4: Cavite mutiny
Rizal himself. I do not remember literally the text of this
abjuration and profession of Catholic faith”.
The account both mentioned about the retraction and marriage
between Jose Rizal and Josephine Bracken.
Arguments against Retraction
Statement of Baron Fernandez
o Baron Fernandez a spanish who worked for almost half
century in two secret archives in Madrid and Segovia. He
found a thick sheaf of Rizal’s defense (unofficial defense-
ADCIORES AI DEFENSA) which he had written before his
execution in December 30, 1896.
Manoling Morato “Exposes”
o Manoling Morato, a friend of Baron Fernandez, bought
from Fernandez the alleged documents containing Rizal’s
denial of the said retraction that took place hours before his
execution. Morato said in his “EXPOSE” that the friars
forged the retraction letter and published in the CLERICO-
Lesson 5: Cry of Balintawak or Pugad Lawin
o The cry of balintawak or pugad lawin is the beginning of the o who believed that Bonifacio and his men were in
Philippine Revolution against the spanish empire. Balintawak on August 19.
o This history was re-opened before. All our textbooks, o They left Balintawak for Kangkong on August 21, and
following a resolution from the National Historical on the afternoon of August 22 they proceeded to
Commission, state that the start of the revolution is with a Pugad Lawin.
cry, followed by the tearing of cedulas led by Andres o The next day, August 23, 1896 in the yard of Juan
Bonifacio in Pugad Lawin, Quezon City. Ramos, son of Melchora Aquino better known as
o The history was re-open because of all the debates on “Tandang Sora” the katipuneros listened to Bonifacio’s
dates and places which may seem trivial to the general speech, tore their cedulas and vowed to fight.
public but it is also quiddity of historians. o He cited Dr. Pio Valenzuela as his primary source who
o Re-opening this issue, there are 3 people with different is a close associate of Andres Bonifacio.
standpoint depending on the source, the dates and places
do not seem to match. Gregoria de Jesus Nakpil
o who is a widow of Andres Bonifacio.
3 PEOPLE WITH DIFFERENT STANDPOINT o In 1928, she wrote a short autobiography entitled “Mga tala
Teodoro A. Agoncillo ng aking buhay” where she stated that the cry of
balintawak took place on August 25, 1896 in Pasong
Tamo.
Julio Nakpil.
o Bonifacio’s associate.
o The composer of Katipunan.
o Th second husband of Gregoria de Jesus Nakpil.
o In 1925, he wrote in his handwritten notes on the Philippine
Revolution in the National Library under Teodoro M. Kalaw
that the first cry of balintawak was on August 26, 1896 in
the place called Kangkong adjacent to Pasong Tamo within
the jurisdiction of Balintawak, Caloocan then within the
province of Manila.
There are a lot more conflicting sources but up until this day, when
searching about the Philippine Revolution the results shown is
August 23, 1896 in Pugad Lawin.
MILITARY CAREER
Section 29. Repeal of laws. All acts or parts of acts which are
inconsistent with the provisions of this Act are hereby
repealed.
Section 30. Effectivity. This Act shall take effect upon its
approval.
Approved: September 9, 1955
LAND REFORM AFFECT AGRICULTURE
o The study found that land reform can assist in
creating more employment-intensive farming systems
by: reducing the size of farming units, while
increasing their total numbers; changing the mix and
scale of farm commodities produced; and. Changing
farming systems so that they become more
employment-intensive.
ADDITIONAL ABOUT LAND REFORM ACT 1400
o Land reforms are also considered essential as it
provides social justice to millions of cultivators. The
land policy that charges tenurial relations in favor of
the actual tiller means that the cultivator/small farmer