Bioethanol Production Notes
Bioethanol Production Notes
LECTURE-14
(BIOETHANOL)
INTRODUCTION
Bioethanol is the ethyl alcohol or ethanol obtained from bioresources (biomass) by
hydrolysis or sugar fermentation processes.
It is a principle fuel used as a petrol substitute for road transport vehicles.
Although ethyl alcohol or ethanol can also be produced by the chemical process of
reacting ethylene with steam, but cannot be said bioethanol because of the lack of
renewable source of raw material and the nature of production route.
Sugar fermentation is the process widely used.
The main sources of sugar required to produce ethanol come from fuel or energy crops.
These crops include corn, maize and wheat crops, waste straw, willow and popular
trees, sawdust, reed canary grass, cord grasses, Jerusalem artichoke, myscanthus and
sorghum plants.
There is also ongoing research and development into the use of municipal solid wastes
to produce ethanol fuel.
Ethanol or ethyl alcohol (C2H5OH) is a clear colourless liquid, it is biodegradable, low
in toxicity and causes little environmental pollution if spilt.
Ethanol burns to produce carbon dioxide and water.
Ethanol is a high octane fuel and has replaced lead as an octane enhancer in petrol.
By blending ethanol with gasoline we can also oxygenate the fuel mixture so it burns
more completely and reduces polluting emissions.
Ethanol fuel blends are widely used in the United States.
The most common blend is 10% ethanol and 90% petrol (E10).
Vehicle engines require no modifications to run on E10 and vehicle warranties are
unaffected too.
Only flexible fuel vehicles can run on up to 85% ethanol and 15% petrol blends (E85).
Figure-3: Global biofuel production by fuel type (thousand barrel per day)
3
Figure-5: Prediction of world bioethanol production (a) and consumption (b) by 2024.
Note: According to the International Renewable Energy Agency, the advanced biofuels
(based on 2nd, 3rd and 4th generation feedstocks) market is expected to grow to reach 124
billion litres per year by 2030.
4
Based on the source of raw materials, bioethanol may be classified into two groups:
First generation (1G) bioethanol, second generation (2G) bioethanol and the third
generation (3G) bioethanol
i. First Generation (1G) Bioethanols
o The first generation bioethanols refer to the ethanols that have been derived
from the food-based feedstocks, such as starch, sugar, etc
o These are alcohols produced by the use of enzymes and micro organisms
through the process of fermentation of starches and sugar.
o These are the most common type of alcohols.
o Sugar crops such as sugar cane, sugar beet and sweet sorghum mostly consist
of glucose, fructose, and sucrose as their major components are used.
5
o Autotrophic algae harness sunlight and fix atmospheric CO2 into carbohydrates
such as starch and cellulose via photosynthesis.
o On the other hand, heterotrophic algae species can utilize small organic carbon
compounds that are turned into lipids, protein, and oils.
o Conversely, macroalgae are large multicellular marine algae obtained from
natural and cultivated resources.
o Harvested macroalgae (red, brown and green) are mainly used to produce
hydrocolloids that constitute 10-40% of their biomass.
o Macroalgae has a low concentration of lipids and primarily contains 35-74%
carbohydrates and 5-35% proteins.
o Conversely, most of the microalgae such as Botryococcus braunii, Chlorella
sp., Nannochloris sp., Nitzschia sp., Schizochytrium sp. have at least 20-50%
oil content.
o Several studies have reported the production of bioethanol from both micro
and macro-algal biomass.
o Starch and cellulose are extracted from algae biomass using mechanical shear
or by enzyme hydrolysis, after which they are utilized for bioethanol
production.
o Enzymatic hydrolysis of cellulose from algae is simpler than from plant
biomass due to negligible or no presence of lignin in algae.
o Various species of algae were reported to contain different starch and biomass
content after oil extraction.
o Ethanol production from algal starch is similar to conversion processes of
starch or sugars to ethanol (plant source).
o The conversion technologies of algal and plant based cellulosic biomass to
ethanol are similar.
o Algae can grow on non-arable lands and do not change land usage.
o Further, CO2 produced in industrial flue gases can be used to produce algal
biomass.
o Another main advantage of algal biomass is that it does not require fresh water
for cultivation.
o Waste water from industrial and domestic sewage can also be used for the
cultivation of algal biomass.
o The major obstacle for the commercialization of algal biofuels is process
economics.
o Harvesting corresponds to 20-30% of total cultivation costs.
o Cultivation of microalgae through open ponds is economical but has inherent
disadvantages such as low productivity, water loss, low CO2 utilization, and
high affinity to be contaminated by other algal strains.
o The disadvantages of open ponds led to development of closed
photobioreactors, which facilitate higher productivity, less contamination, and
less water loss.
o However, photobioreactors suffered from CO2, O2 and pH gradients, wall
growth, fouling, hydrodynamic stress, and high scale up costs.
8
Figure-9: Different systems for algal cultivation A) Open ponds B) Tubular PBRs C)
Flat PBRs D) Biofilm based PBRs E) Fermentor cultivation F) algal biomass
cultivation using waste water. (PBRs: Photo Bioreactor Systems)
developmental stage and for the time being only their tetraploid and octaploid forms
are known; we also now know that similar cell types (isotypes) reproduce easily.
Willow (salix)
This is a member of the Angiosperm family and is consequently characterized by a
hard wood.
In this species, a fraction of the xylose units is acetylated.
Some of the OH groups of the xylose carbons C2 and C3 are replaced by O-acetyl
groups.
With pretreatment, these groups release acetic acid that, in high enough
concentrations, inhibits the yeasts involved in the fermentation process, according to
some studies.
It was recently demonstrated that, by pretreating willow with sulfuric acid before
the enzymatic hydrolysis process, and then simultaneously performing
saccharification and fermentation, they succeeded in obtaining a global ethanol yield
of 79%.
Cereals
These must be ground to obtain starch, from which bioethanol is subsequently obtained.
The cereals containing fewer proteins and more carbohydrates are preferable for
distilling purposes because they have a higher bioethanol conversion rate. This means
that the nitrogen content in the cereals can be adapted to facilitate starch accumulation
instead of proteins synthesis, thereby improving both the energy yield and the quality of
the fermentation process. The principal cereals are:
o Wheat
It grows mainly in temperate regions.
The wheat treatment process is much the same as for the other cereals and it is
best to use high-gravity fermentation to obtain the best performance in the
fermentation process.
Figure-22: Wheat
o Barley
The most suitable is the so-called Winter variety, which is often underestimated
as a foodstuff, despite the fact that it can tolerate drought and is highly adaptable.
Figure-23: Barley.
o Corn stover
This is what remains on the ground after maize has been harvested.
This raw material is abundantly available and demands no further investment in
biomass, although not all of the corn stover can be removed - 30% of it must be
left on the ground to prevent erosion (by facilitating water infiltration and
reducing evaporation), and as the main source of soil organic carbon (SOC) in
order to preserve the soil’s productivity.
Corn stover contains polymeric hemicellulose and cellulose, but their
biodegradability by glycosidase is strongly inhibited by a small quantity (12-
15%) of lignin.
Agricultural wastes, such as cereal straw, wheat straw, corn cob, rice husk and
bagasse from processing sugar cane have also been examined as potential sources of
lignocellulosic biomass.
Other research has focused on forest based woody wastes and forest biomass bark,
sawdust, softwood trimmings (pine) and hardwood chips (oak), or on waste from
parks and gardens (leaves , grasses, branches.
Industrial wastes, such as brewer’s spent grains and spent grains from distilleries,
and municipal solid wastes such as food waste, kraft paper and paper sludge
containing cellulose have also been considered.
Because of its high organic load, the whey obtained as a byproduct of the cheese
industry is toxic to the environment and requires treatment before removal as waste.
The use of whey as a substrate for the production of biomediated ethanol can reduce
the costs associated with the treatment of effluent in dairies.
Crude glycerol, which is generated during the transesterification of animal fats and
vegetable oils, is a significant byproduct of the biodiesel industry.
The fermentation of crude glycerol obtained from waste enables this surplus to be
reduced.
Fermentation of glycerol is performed by conversion to phosphoenol pyruvate (PEP)
or pyruvate, leading to increased content of reducing equivalents and higher
bioethanol yield than the fermentation of glucose and xylose from biomass.
Lignocellulosic bioethanol generates lower levels of greenhouse gases than first
generation bioethanol and causes less air pollution.
However, the production of lignocellulosic bioethanol requires feedstock preparation
prior to fermentation and the finding/developing of ethanol producers able to
ferment sugars from cellulose and hemicellulose breakdown as evident from the
Figure-8.
Various types of biomass which may be used for production of second generation
(2G) bioethanol have been summarized by Figure-19.
Another pilot plant facility of Japan producing 20, 000 lit per annum bioethanol
from municipal solid waste has been demonstrated in Figure-30.
Figur-30: LanzaTech and Sekisui (Japan) advance conversion of municipal solid waste
to ethanol (2017).
20
Figure-31: Common flow diagram for bioethanol production for 1 st and 2nd generation
feedstocks.
22
Yeast
C6H12O6 → C2H5OH + CO2
o Different types of fermentation processes were developed over time, such as:
batch process, fed-batch process, and continuous process.
o Fed-batch process is commonly used in 70%–75% of the ethanol distilleries, the
feeding time normally lasts for 4–6 hours, and fermentation is finished within
6–10 hours.
o In the batch process, the fermentation vat is loaded with a carbon source (must or
sugarcane juice) prior the addition of yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae).
o The yeast suspension (with 30% of yeast cell, on a wet basis) represents
25%–30% of the total volume of fermentation, which is performed in tanks of
300–3000 m3.
o This method is not used in industrial ethanol plants, since it can lead to low
productivity of ethanol due to the presence of contaminants once the process
takes place under aerobic conditions, being used only on a laboratory scale, in
small distilleries, or in yeast propagation.
25
o In the fed-batch process, yeast is added to the fermentation vat and the juice is
added continuously during the fermentation process until the maximum volume
of the vat is reached.
o This process is performed in serial fermentation vats, where the must is added
with constant feed flow rate or intermittently.
o After the vat reaches its maximum volume, the fermentation continues until the
total reduction of the sugar is complete, and the product is collected followed by a
cleaning and sterilization process of the fermenter for the next batch.
o This fermentation method has some advantages, such as maintenance of the
maximum concentration of viable cells, prolongation of cell lifetime, and less
inhibition of yeast by the high substrate concentration.
o The fed-batch system is widely used in Brazilian industry, being employed in
approximately 75% of the mills, due to a higher ethanol yield at the end of
fermentation and being less subject to contamination.
Bioethanol has much lower energy content than gasoline (about two-third of the energy
27
UTILIZATION OF BIOETHANOL
29
India has around 330 distilleries, which can produce over 4.8 billion liters of rectified
spirits (alcohol) per year. Of this total, about 166 distilleries have the capacity to distill 2.6
billion liters of ethanol (denatured and undenatured) to be used in fuel, industrial
chemicals, and beverages. Final C & B Heavy molasses, sugarcane juice, food grains unfit
for human consumption, and any other potential domestic raw material sources available
in the country may be used for making fuel-grade ethanol.
Consumption
India’s total ethanol consumption in 2019 was forecasted to rise 22 percent to a
record 3.8 billion liters.
In 2018, a record of 3.1 billion liters was consumed.
The consumption will outgrow ethanol production for the fifth consecutive year,
more so due to the burgeoning demand of fuel ethanol for blending with gasoline.
As a result, supply to industrial and potable sectors will be limited by drop in
demand on price sensitivities (illustrated in Figure-35).
The ethanol consumption growth (14 % annual, 5-year average, 2015-2019) is rather
strong compared to production growth (8% annual, 5-year average).
Both have risen, but in response to different drivers: the rise in fuel prices coupled
with very attractive purchase price of ethanol is driving ethanol consumption;
consecutive year bumper harvests is supporting production growth.
A 6.6% blend rate seemed achievable where all the ethanol produced (from
molasses) in 2019 was blended with gasoline.
Potential blending would be higher yet if imports are permitted and duties lowered.
However, given the demand from the potable and industrial sectors and limitations
on imports, a national blend average of 5.8% in 2019 was expected.
The Indian Sugar Mill Association indicate that the Oil Marketing Companies
(OMCs) could procure upwards of 2.4 billion liters in 2019.
Of the total requirement of 3.3 billion liters established by OMCs for marketing year
2019, total ethanol offered by the suppliers (from 21 states) to the oil marketing
companies for blending with gasoline was 3.13 billion liters.
Of this, some 2.7 billion liters was finalized against which 1.08 billion liters was
supplied as of May 20, 2019.
Since the quantity of ethanol demanded at higher prices may be less, the industrial
uses and the potable sector will need to augment some of its supply from grain-based
distilleries, partly from raw material imports or by directly importing the finished
products.
Production
Production was forecasted at 3 billion liters in 2019, which was 11% rise in the
production as compared to 2018, a record volume.
Molasses supply for fuel use will increase in response to price incentive to divert B-
heavy molasses, in addition to final C-heavy for producing fuel grade ethanol, but at
the cost of diverting excess sugar.
30
The Indian Sugar Mill Association supply estimate of 2.4 billion liters in 2019 was
based on 1.8 billion liters produced from C-Heavy molasses, some 425-430 million
liters from B-Heavy molasses, 165-170 million liters from damaged food grains, and
20 million liters from sugarcane juice.
In 2018, an estimated 2.7 billion liter of ethanol was produced (from molasses).
The total quantity offered for EBP (Ethanol Blended Petrol (EBP) programme was
launched in January, 2003. The programme sought to promote the use of alternative
and environment friendly fuels and to reduce import dependency for energy
requirements) was 1.8 billion liters of which 1.6 billion liters was blended with
gasoline to mark a 4.1% blend rate for 2018.
The differential and remunerative price to ethanol suppliers will substantially
increase availability of ethanol for the EBP Program, reduce dependence on crude
oil, and in turn help proliferate a more environmentally friendly fuel.
For background information on the ethanol program, please see Biofuel Annual
2017 GAIN report IN8085.
Imports
Although domestic production has risen, India remains a net importer of ethanol (for
all end uses).
For the sixth consecutive year the United States is still the single largest ethanol
supplier to India.
In calendar year (CY) 2018, Indian ethanol imports (mostly denatured) were down
14 percent to 633 million liters, valued at $269 million.
Despite costlier imports, (INR depreciated 11 percent against the USD), strong local
demand for industrial consumption drove Indian imports of U.S. ethanol.
31
The U.S. ethanol share in the total import basket was down by 4%, but still held a
dominant share (94 percent).
Generally, industrial and chemical users in India import ethanol to augment their
cumulative demand, particularly when local supply is short.
A recently introduced requirement to obtain an import license to import ethanol (for
non-fuel use) may reduce imports temporarily.
While importers scramble to comply with the new import requirements, a few major
importers will use existing stocks to cover the shortfallin coming months.
Overall import demand remains high: 2019 imports will grow to upwards of 750
million liters (mostly denatured), the highest in a decade, and the United States will
continue to be the largest ethanol supplier to India.
For the record, India imported 718 million liters of ethanol in 2017 worth $280
million, which was the highest volume sourced in the last ten years.
Other small but steady suppliers to India include Pakistan, South Africa, UAE, and
UK. (Figure ).
China, South Korea, and Netherland are intermittent suppliers. Last year (2018),
imports slumped 10 percent to 631 million liters after rising steadily for five years.
Switzerland entered as a new player and supplied almost 4.6% of imports.
Exports
Ethanol exports in 2019 are expected to fall more than 20 percent to 100 million
liters (mostly undenatured).
Strong domestic consumption demand (for EBP and industrial use) will limit
exportable supply.
Biofuel or fuel grade exports are restricted when domestic supply is less than
domestic demand.
Some industry sources indicate that a steady demand from African nations and
neighboring countries will keep export sales rolling, albeit in smaller volumes.
In 2018, Nigeria, Ghana, Angola, Cameroon and Nepal were the top five export
destinations.
Ethanol suppliers from the United States, Netherland, France, Hungary, Belgium and
Spain compete directly with Indian exporters’.
India has a strong focus in the area of biofuels and stipulated an ethanol blending
target of 10 per cent by 2022 and 20 per cent by 2030, while biodiesel blending target
has been set at 5 per cent by 2030 when it had announced a new policy on Biofuels in
2018.
Today’s global trend towards increased use of environmentally friendly fuels
(Ethanol) is likely to gather pace. Brazil which is the second-largest ethanol producer
after the United States in the world is home to the world’s largest fleet of cars that use
ethanol. Ethanol is derived from sugarcane as an alternative to fossil fuel-based
petroleum.
India is the second-largest producer of sugar after Brazil in the world and sugar
production during the last few years has remained 24-26 million tons. A surplus sugar
stock with a stronger financial incentive to convert excess sugar to ethanol should help
the oil marketing companies procure upwards of 2.4 billion litres in 2019. This will
help to achieve its highest fuel Ethanol blending in petrol penetration at 5.8 per cent,
compared to last year’s record of 4.1 per cent.
To strengthen the financial condition of sugar mills and cut oil imports, the
Government is emphasising on ethanol production. According to the reports, the Centre
is planning to reduce the expenditure on oil imports by increasing the ethanol
production and blending of ethanol with petrol.
According to a report published in Economic Times, an official from consumer
affairs, food and public distribution ministry said, “Government plans to enhance
ethanol production capacity to 9 billion litres from 3.55 billion litres in two years. The
government has in-principle approved 362 new plants in sugar mills to add capacity of
5.5 billion litres which requires an investment of Rs 18,000 crore.”
This will help in meeting the government’s target of blending 10% ethanol by
2022. This will reduce the country’s import by 2 million tonnes annually reducing bill
by Rs 7,000 crore.
In 2018 in order to assist sugar mills, the Indian government increased the ethanol
price from C heavy molasses from Rs.43.46 per litre to Rs.43.75 per litre, and the cost
of ethanol from B heavy molasses hiked from Rs.52.43 per litre to Rs.54.27 per litre.
Price of ethanol from sugarcane juice/sugar/sugar syrup route was fixed at 59.48 per
litre.
As sugar mills in India have been facing issues with depressing sugar prices,
surplus stocks and piling cane arrears, experts believe the production of Ethanol will
aid sugar mills to improve the financial condition and to clear cane arrears.
33
34
Brazil has ethanol fuel available throughout the country. A typical Petrobras filling station at São
Paulo with dual fuel service, marked A for alcohol (ethanol) and G for gasoline.
Typical Brazilian "flex" models from several carmakers, that run on any blend of ethanol and gasoline,
from E20-E25 gasohol to E100 ethanol fuel..
The Honda CG 150 Titan Mix was launched in the Brazilian market in 2009 and became the
First mass production flex-fuel motorcycle sold in the world.
39
An example of an ethanol powered bus. This is a Scania OmniCity which has been touring the United
Kingdom, which does not use the fuel widely. A larger fleet of similar buses entered service in
Stockholm in 2008.
40
EPA's E15 label required to be displayed in all E15 fuel dispensers in the U.S.
UK government calculation of carbon intensity of corn bioethanol grown in the US and burnt in the UK.
42
Graph of UK figures for the carbon intensity of bioethanol and fossil fuels. This graph assumes that all
bioethanols are burnt in their country of origin and that previously existing cropland is used to grow
the feedstock.