Paper Fix
Paper Fix
INTRODUCTION
The development of learning media such as books, actually using books will
make students easy to understand and develop. There are many book publishers
who publish books varying lessons that make the development of learning media.
But there are some books that do not show the quality of the contents of the book
according to the standards set. Based on it, the teacher must analyze and choose
the books accurately. The teacher must know whether the books that he/she chose
were good or not. After analyzing the textbook the teacher need to know how its
far the book can give the good effect in learning process, help the teacher and the
students to understand the materials, and also as an assessment whether the
textbooks are appropriate or not.
Here, the writer in a bit explains there are some components that must contain
that’s book. At least there are some sources that can be as the references in
assessment of the book. Based on it, the writer try to explain about three
references standard to be a book qualified. There are the references from Greene
and Pety, Jeremy Harmer, BSNP, and Readibility. To know whether the book has
good quality or not, the author analyzes the theory as agreed and calculate the
accurate of the book with the level or grade of students. The book that analyzed is
from KEMENDIKBUD publisher by Siti Wachida, Asep Gunawan, and Yuli
1
Rulani Khatimah. With have a titled When English A Bell. ( English for Junior
High School VIII).
2
CHAPTER II
LITERATURE OF REVIEW
1. Definition of Textbook
Buckingham in Tarigan (1986:11) states that textbook is a book
which usually used by teachers as a tool to support teaching and learning
processes in schools and university. Based on some opinions from the
experts about textbook, Tarigan (1986:13) concluded textbook is a book in
a specific subject areas which the standard book, compiled by experts in
the field for instructional purposes and objectives, which equipped with a
mean of teaching appropriate and easily understood by the users in schools
and universities that can support the teaching and learning program. So,
we can conclude that textbook is a media in learning process containing a
specific subject areas that used by the teacher.
2. Textbook Design
a. Greene and Pety
Greene and Petty (1971:545-8) in Tarigan (1986:20-21) explain the
criteria of good textbook. There are:
1) The textbook must be interested and attractive toward the learners. So,
they will be interested in using textbook for study.
2) The textbook must be able to motivate the learners to use.
3) The content of textbook must be illustrative. So, attractive for the
learners.
4) The textbook should consider the linguistic aspect. So, it will be
suitable with the learner’s ability.
5) The content of textbook must be related to the other branch of science.
6) The textbook must stimulate the personal activity of the learners.
7) The content of textbook must be clear in written to avoid the learners
will be confused in using textbook
3
8) The book must have clear point of view because it will be a point of
view for the learners in using textbooks
9) Textbooks must be able provide the balance and emphasize the values
to the learners
10) Textbooks must be able to respect the differences individual of each
learners.
b. Jeremy Harmer
Jeremy Harmer in his book How to Teach English new ed. explains the
criteria of good textbook. There are:
4
(b) the teacher? Does the design of
the book make it easy to follow?
5
promote the skills (e.g. writing-for-
writing, not writing-for-learning)?
Are there possibilities for both study
and activation in the skills areas? Are
the skills activities likely to engage
students?
6
activities for fast and slow learners?
7
8) Moral value varieties, the good textbook does not give
negative moral value.
b) Language Expedience
1) Simplicity, to the point
2) Communicative
3) Dialogic and interactive, the good text book can motivate
students, the language that used can increase students reading
interest, make students to learn more and more about material.
The good textbook also can guide the students to build the
criticism mind, the students looking for the answer in every
question that they think by finding in other textbook or other
sources.
4) Conformity with the learner cognitive development
5) Conformity with KBBI
6) Conformity with terminology, symbol, and icon.
c) Expediency presentation
1) Presentation technique
i. The system presentation consistence in every chapter,
system presentation consistence in every chapter should
have introduction/opening, content, and
conclusion/closing.
ii. Chronological Concept, should be begin from the easy
level until difficult level.
2) Supporting presentation
i. The explanation about what the thing that the students
should get after learning its chapter. So, they will get
the learning motivation.
ii. The textbook contains the examples in every topics
iii. Key words in the beginning of each chapter.
iv. The exercises in every last chapter
v. Preface
8
vi. Glossaries
vii. Index
viii. References
ix. Appendix
d) Graphitization
1) Book size format, font 12-14 pts, Times New Roman font
(depend on other font)
2) Cover design, cover design should be simple and illustrative.
Either from font, color, or illustration.
3) Content design, should easy to read and support the materials.
This point can be seen from font style, font color, paragraph,
illustration, and figure or picture illustration.
4) Paper quality, paper quality should from sturdy and qualified
paper.
5) Printing quality, the best printing quality are clean, sharpness,
and contrast.
6) Banding quality, the best banding quality use sturdy banding,
so the banding will long lasting, hard to folded or ripped.
d. Readability of Text
1) The formulation of text readability accounting
Readability is an attempt to match the reading level of written
material to the "reading with understanding" level of the reader. To locate
the readability level of any document in MS Word, click on tools and then
on spelling and grammar check. The Flesch Kincaid level will be supplied
after the spell check has been completed (unless you have this option
turned off in which case click on tools, click on options, click on spelling
and grammar and then tick the box that says show readability statistics).
In this occasion, the writer analyzes the text in the first semester of SMP
grade VIII.
9
2) Flesch reading ease
School
Score Notes
Level
70.0– 7th
Fairly easy to read.
80.0 grade
8th &
60.0– Plain English. Easily understood by 13- to 15-
9th
70.0 year-old students.
grade
10th to
50.0–
12th Fairly difficult to read.
60.0
grade
30.0–
College Difficult to read.
50.0
10
0.0– college Very difficult to read. Best understood by
30.0 graduate university graduates.
3) Syllabus
The relationship between textbook and syllabus are close, because
when the author makes a textbook the author has to match the
materials with the syllabus, and the materials for each level is
different. (The syllabus of SMP grade VIII is available in the
appendix).
11
1. Book Details
Telp. : 021-87906446
Prize : Rp 24.900,00
Email : [email protected]
2. Cover
12
From the cover of the book provided has a form of creativity of the author
in designing available in a presentation. From the selection of colors, the form of
writing that becomes the theme, to the part that becomes the icon in the book. In
this book there are orange, green and a little bit of color. The orange color
becomes the basic color of this book, which is considered capable of "stimulating"
emotions, meaning making students' attraction when looking at the cover of this
book gives a strong impression on the learner so that their joy and optimism
emerge to learn. There is also a green color that lies horizontally on the cover that
gives its own impression, which symbolizes the balance and harmony of students
to have a sense of interacting and able to create a peaceful classroom atmosphere
when studying. After the base color on the cover there is a basic image that is not
too prominent on the cover, including images: lights, anchors, pencils, clocks,
microscope and others.
The image characterizes that students have high creativity. And a little
blue that is the color of the veil worn by one of the student icons symbolizes the
intelligence and confidence that a student has. Also listed is the symbol of
Tutwuri Handayani which is a symbol that this book was published by the
Ministry of Culture and the Republic of Indonesia. Tut Wuri Handayani said this
is a slogan created by Ki Hajar Dewantara. In the upper right corner there is a
symbol of the curriculum 13 in the form of a circle, and in a circle ad is a picture
of a book and a sketch of a person which means that unites the standard of
education in Indonesia. Pictures of books and sketches of people in the middle of
a circle represent someone who is studying. The writing of curriculum 13 at the
bottom of the circle explains that the book uses standard curriculum guidelines 13.
The 13 curriculum itself is designed to meet the learning model from the 21st
century. Under the logo of curriculum 13 it is written that this book was revised in
2017.
13
The title of the book is deliberately placed in the middle of the section of
the book so that it becomes the focus of the target when students will read the
book. The book has a title printed on the cover of English "When English Ring A
Bell". English writing shows that the book is a guide for English subjects.
Furthermore, the words "When English Ring A Bell" have meaning At the bottom
of the cover there are pictures of eight students, which surround the sketch of the
earth. Eight icons explained that this book was published for eighth grade high
school junior students. Six icons identify students and two icons as instructors.
Green sketches of the earth mean that this book is published in various continents
to educate the children of the nation who will later create the prosperity of the
earth itself. Then the last logo in the bottom corner of the cover stated that this
book was created not only for national schools but also for the specific secondary
school for grade 8.
14
such as greeting birthday, graduate, or asking about what you want
to do.
g. This book is clear and easy for students to understand. material,
examples and forms of activity are also in accordance with what is
available. However, this book does not classify or explain the skills
learned.
h. Based on what we observe this book, the explanation of the
material is too short and refers more to the activity of students,
there is no grammar material, and there is no material that refers to
skill listening and reading.
i. Of course values for students. for example, such dialogues listed in
the book can be applied in daily life. So, this book has a balance
between the material provided and its application.
j. The book is designed specifically for VIII grade junior high school
and the material is according to the abilities possessed by VIII
grade.
Agree
Criteria of
Possible questions for and
the Good The Reasons
course book analysis Disagre
Book
e
15
guide, audio, etc)
available?
Apart from a
workbook, what other
extras are offered with
the course? Are there The textbook doesn’t offer
Internet sites with extra material relates to
extra material the course. It provides
(exercises, texts, etc), only a variety of exercises
Add-ons and
or with ‘meeting no packaged in the form of
extras
places’ for users? game and picture. No
What else does the quotations or moral value
publisher offer to is found within the
support the course? textbook.
What value should we
place on the extras that
are available?
16
language that the
students will
understand. So it can be
understand? Can the
said that the students can
course book be used
use the course book
by students working
whether by the guide from
on their own, or is a
the teacher or working on
teacher necessary to
their own.
show them how to use
it?
17
pronunciation, etc) include four English skills.
that we would expect? The topics in the book are
Do we and our also arranged based on the
students like the level of difficulty. For
sequencing of further information, please
language and topics, see the syllabus analysis.
etc? Does the course
book build in a feeling
of progress?
18
students will be more
trained and improved.
19
book unprejudiced in
the way it deals with
different customs, surrounding environment.
ethnicities, races and
sexes?
learners?
20
5. Analyzing Textbook based on BSNP
Struktur text
a. Menyebutkan tujuan dari (a)
undangan pribadi dan (b) ucapan
selamat (greeting card).
b. Menyebutkan informasi rinci dari
(a) undangan pribadi dan (b)
ucapan selamat (greeting card).
Unsur kebahasaan
(1) Kata dan tata bahasa yang
lazim digunakan dalam
undangan dan ucapan selamat
dari sumber-sumber otentik.
(2) Penggunaan nominal singular
dan plural secara tepat, dengan
atau tanpa a, the, this, those,
my, their, dsb secara tepat
dalam frasa nominal
(3) Ucapan, tekanan kata, intonasi
(4) Ejaan dan tanda baca
(5) Tulisan tangan
Topik
Berbagai kegiatan, acara, dan hari
penting siswa dan guru, dengan
memberikan keteladanan tentang
perilaku santun, peduli, cinta
damai, dan kerjasama.
Multimedia:
Layout dan dekorasi yang membuat
tampilan teks lebih menarik.
21
Chapter VI. Page 82
(to show the existence of things
and people)
Teks lisan dan tulis untuk
menyatakan dan menanyakan
keberadaan orang, benda, binatang
dalam jumlah yang tidak tertentu
Fungsi sosial
Menjelaskan, membanggakan,
memuji, mengaguni, mengkritik,
dsb.
Struktur teks
There are only a few students left in
school.Where are the others?; How
many chairs are there in this
classroom? A lot.; There is not much
water in the dry season. So we have
to save water.; It’s said that there
very few monkeys in the zoo, and
some are very thin.,dan
semacamnya.
Unsur kebahasaan
(1) Ungkapan dengan There ...
(2) Kosa kata: kata benda, Kata
jumlah yang tidak tertentu:
little, few, some, many, much, a
lot (of).
(3) Kata kerja, dan kata sifat yang
terkait dengan orang, binatang,
benda di kelas, sekolah, rumah,
22
dan sekitarnya
(4) Penggunaan nominal singular
dan plural secara tepat, dengan
atau tanpa a, the, this, those,
my, their, dsb secara tepat
dalam frasa nominal
(5) Ucapan, tekanan kata, intonasi,
(6) Ejaan dan tanda baca
(7) Tulisan tangan.
Topik
Keberadaan orang, binatang, benda,
di kelas, sekolah, rumah, dan
sekitarnya yang memberikan
keteladanan tentang perilaku jujur,
disiplin, percaya diri, dan
bertanggung jawab.
Fungsi sosial
Menghargai alam semesta, memberi
contoh kebiasaan baik/jelek,
membanggakan, dsb.
Struktur teks
The sun shines everyday in
Indonesia, so it is mostly very green.
My father is very healthy because he
wakes up early and excersises
everyday. We have English on
Monday and Wednesday. Do you get
up early? Yes, I help my Mom before
I go to school; I clean the house and
wash the dishes.,dan semacamnya.
Unsur kebahasaan
(1) Kata kerja dalam Simple
Present Tense.
(2) Adverbia: always, often,
sometimes, never, usually, every
...
23
(3) Kosa kata: kata benda, kata
kerja, dan kata sifat yang
terkait dengan orang, binatang,
benda di kelas, sekolah, rumah,
dan sekitarnya
(4) Penggunaan nominal singular
dan plural secara tepat, dengan
atau tanpa a, the, this, those,
my, their, dsb secara tepat
dalam frasa nominal
(5) Ucapan, tekanan kata, intonasi,
(6) Ejaan dan tanda baca
(7) Tulisan tangan.
Topik
Tindakan, kejadian, keadaan, di
kelas, sekolah, rumah, dan
sekitarnya yang memberikan
keteladanan tentang perilaku jujur,
disiplin, percaya diri, dan
bertanggung jawab.
Fungsi sosial
Menjelaskan, memberi alasan,
memberi contoh tindakan, dsb..
Struktur teks
What are you doing here? Waiting for
her; Don’t play around. Look!
Everybody is doing their task.; I need
to see the Principal. May I see him
now? No, he’s having a meeting.; Be
quiet, please. The baby is sleeping.
,dan semacamnya.
Unsur kebahasaan
(1) Kata kerja untuk kegiatan dan
tindakan dalam Present
Continous tense.
(2) Kosa kata: kata benda, kata
24
kerja, dan kata sifat yang
terkait dengan orang, binatang,
benda di kelas, sekolah, rumah,
dan sekitarnya
(3) Kata kerja untuk keadaan: be,
have, dalam Present
Continuous Tense.
(4) Adverbia: now
(5) Kata ganti obyek: me, you, him,
her, us, dst.
(6) Penggunaan nominal singular
dan plural secara tepat, dengan
atau tanpa a, the, this, those,
my, their, dsb secara tepat
dalam frasa nominal
(7) Ucapan, tekanan kata, intonasi,
(8) Ejaan dan tanda baca
(9) Tulisan tangan.
Topik
Tindakan, kejadian, keadaan, di
kelas, sekolah, rumah, dan
sekitarnya yang memberikan
keteladanan tentang perilaku jujur,
disiplin, percaya diri, dan
bertanggung jawab.
Fungsi sosial
Menjelaskan, memberikan alasan,
memberi keteladanan, memberikan
klarifikasi
Struktur teks
Why didn’t you go to school
yesterday? Because I got a very bad
flu. Budi was late so he could not get
in and follow the flag ceremony.
Although it is small, our school will
25
win “The Best School of the Year”
trophy because it is very clean. I
walk to school but I’m never
late.,dan semacamnya.
Unsur kebahasaan
(1) Kata yang menyatakan
hubungan sebab akibat: Why?,
because, so
(2) Kata yang menyatakan
hubungan kebalikan: although,
but
(3) Kosa kata: kata benda, kata
kerja, dan kata sifat yang
terkait dengan orang, binatang,
benda di kelas, sekolah, rumah,
dan sekitarnya
(4) Penggunaan nominal singular
dan plural secara tepat, dengan
atau tanpa a, the, this, those,
my, their, dsb secara tepat
dalam frasa nominal
(5) Ucapan, tekanan kata, intonasi,
(6) Ejaan dan tanda baca
(7) Tulisan tangan.
Topik
Tindakan, kejadian, keadaan, di
kelas, sekolah, rumah, dan
sekitarnya yang memberikan
keteladanan tentang perilaku jujur,
disiplin, percaya diri, dan
bertanggung jawab.
Fungsi sosial
Mengidentifikasi, mengenalkan,
memuji, mencela, mengagumi
Struktur teks
Who is taller? Your sister or your
brother?; No one in the class is big as
26
Candra. He is the biggest. He is
bigger than any other student in the
class.; To me, writing is more difficult
than reading. Listening is the most
difficult. Our library have more books
than the community library.,dan
semacamnya.
Unsur kebahasaan
(1) Kosa kata: kata benda dan kata
sifat yang terkait dengan orang,
binatang, benda di kelas,
sekolah, rumah, dan sekitarnya
(2) Perbandingan sifat: as ... as, -er,
-est, more ..., the most ...
(3) Perbandingan jumlah: more,
fewer, less
(4) Penggunaan nominal singular
dan plural secara tepat, dengan
atau tanpa a, the, this, those,
my, their, dsb secara tepat
dalam frasa nominal
(5) Ucapan, tekanan kata, intonasi,
(6) Ejaan dan tanda baca
(7) Tulisan tangan.
Topik
Sifat orang dan benda di kelas,
sekolah, rumah, dan sekitarnya
yang memberikan keteladanan
tentang perilaku jujur, disiplin,
percaya diri, dan bertanggung
jawab.
Struktur text
(gagasan utama dan informasi
rinci)
27
a. Menyebutkan nama orang,
binatang, benda dan nama
bagian-bagiannya yang dipilih
untuk dideskripsikan
b. Menyebutkan sifat orang,
binatang, benda dan bagiannya,
dan
c. Menyebutkan tindakan dari atau
terkait dengan orang, binatang,
benda yang semuanya sesuai
dengan fungsi sosial yang hendak
dicapai.
Unsur kebahasaan
(1) Penyebutan kata benda singular
dengan a dan the, dan plural (-
s).
(2) Kata ganti it, they, she, we, dst.;
our, my, your, their, dst.
(3) Kata sifat tentang orang,
binatang, benda dalam
kehidupan siswa di rumah,
sekolah, dan sekitarnya, dengan
atau tanpa kata keterangan
quite, very.
(4) Frasa nominal seperti dark
brown, cute little cat, beautiful
red flower
(5) Kata kerja untuk menyatakan
keadaan dan tindakan rutin
dalam simple present tense: be,
have, go, play,get, take, dll.
(6) Penggunaan nominal singular
dan plural secara tepat, dengan
atau tanpa a, the, this, those,
my, their, dsb secara tepat
dalam frasa nominal
(7) Ucapan, tekanan kata, intonasi
(8) Ejaan dan tanda baca
(9) Tulisan tangan
Topik
Orang, binatang, benda di sekitar
dan relevan dengan kehidupan
28
siswa, dengan memberikan
keteladanan tentang perilaku jujur,
disiplin, percaya diri, kerjasama,
dan bertanggung jawab.
Fungsi sosial
Melaporkan, menceritakan,
menjelaskan
Struktur teks
What did you do after school
yesterday? My brother and I went
fishing in the river.; Who opened the
box? Yusuf did.; She got an accident.
She was riding on her motorcycle
and hit the lamp post.,dan
semacamnya.
Unsur kebahasaan
(1) Kata kerja dalam Simple Past
Tense, Past Continuous Tense
(2) Kata sambung: when, while,
after, before, dll.
(3) Penggunaan nominal singular
dan plural secara tepat, dengan
atau tanpa a, the, this, those,
my, their, dsb secara tepat
dalam frasa nominal
(4) Ucapan, tekanan kata, intonasi,
(5) Ejaan dan tanda baca
(6) Tulisan tangan.
Topik
Kegiatan dan tindakan yang terjadi
di masa lalu di sekolah, rumah, dan
sekitarnya dan yang relevan dengan
kehidupan siswa sebagai pelajar
dan remaja, dengan memberikan
keteladanan tentang perilaku jujur,
disiplin, percaya diri, dan
bertanggung jawab.
29
Teks recount pendek dan NOTHING
sederhana tentang kegiatan,
kejadian, dan peristiwa
Fungsi sosial
Melaporkan, meneladani,
membanggakan, berbagi
pengalaman, dsb.
Struktur text
(gagasan utama dan informasi
rinci)
a. Memberikan pendahuluan
(orientasi) dengan
menyebutkanorang(-orang) yang
terlibat, tempat, waktu, dsbdari
peristiwa/kejadian/pengalaman
yang akan disampaikan
b. Menguraikan urutan kejadian
secara kronologis, urut dan
runtut.
c. Menutup dengan memberikan
komentar atau penilaian umum
tentang
peristiwa/kejadian/pengalaman
yang telah disampaikan (opsional).
Unsur kebahasaan
(1) Kata kerja dalam Simple Past
tense, Past Continuous Tense
(2) Kosa kata: kata kerja yang
menunjuk tindakan atau
kegiatan
(3) Adverbia penghubung waktu:
first, then, after that, before, at
last, finally, dsb.
(4) Adverbia dan frasa
preposisional penujuk waktu:
yesterday, last month, on
Monday, an hour ago,
immediately, dsb.
(5) Penggunaan nominal singular
dan plural secara tepat, dengan
30
atau tanpa a, the, this, those,
my, their, dsb secara tepat
dalam frasa nominal
(6) Ucapan, tekanan kata, intonasi
(7) Ejaan dan tanda baca
(8) Tulisan tangan
Topik
Peristiwa, kejadian, pengalaman
yang terjadi di sekolah, rumah, dan
sekitarnya dan yang relevan dengan
kehidupan siswa sebagai pelajar
dan remaja, dengan memberikan
keteladanan tentang perilaku jujur,
disiplin, percaya diri, kerjasama,
dan bertanggung jawab.
Teks tulis (a) pesan singkat dan (b) Chapter IV. Page 49
pengumuman/ pemberitahuan (to invite someone to do
(notice)
something, to give instruction and
Masing-masing diajarkan secara
terpisah to ask for permission)
Fungsi sosial
Tindakan dilaksanakan sesuai yang
diharapkan.
Struktur text
(gagasan utama dan informasi
rinci)
a. Menyebutkan tujuan dari pesan
singkat dengan atau tanpa
informasi rinci, sepertiSorry, I’m
in a meeting now. I’ll call you back
in 10 minutes.; Make sure you
lock the gate when you leave.
Unsur kebahasaan
31
(1) Kosa kata terkait dengan
kegiatan, kejadian, peristiwa,
dan hari penting bagi siswa dan
guru
(2) Tata bahasa: Kalimat imperatif
positif, kalimat imperatif negatif
(3) Penggunaan nominal singular
dan plural secara tepat, dengan
atau tanpa a, the, this, those,
my, their, dsb secara tepat
dalam frasa nominal
(4) Ucapan, tekanan kata, intonasi
(5) Ejaan dan tanda baca
(6) Tulisan tangan
Topik
Berbagai kegiatan, kejadian,
peristiwa, dan hari penting bagi
siswa dan guru, dengan memberikan
keteladanan tentang perilaku
santun, peduli, percaya diri,
kerjasama, dan bertanggung jawab.
Fungsi sosial
Memperoleh hiburan, menghibur
dan mengajarkan nilai-nilai luhur
melalui cerita dengan tokoh
binatang.
Struktur text
(gagasan utama dan informasi
rinci)
a. Memperkenalkan tokoh, tempat,
waktu, terjadinya cerita
(orientasi).
b. Memberikan penilaian (evaluasi)
tentang situasi dan kondisi
terjadinya cerita.
c. Memaparkan krisis yang terjadi
terhadap tokoh utama
(komplikasi)
d. Memaparkan akhir cerita, di mana
krisis berakhir (resolusi) dengan
bahagia atau sedih
32
e. Memberikan alasan atau
komentar umum (reorientasi),
opsional.
Unsur kebahasaan
(1) Tata bahasa: Simple Past tense,
Past Continuous Tense
(2) Kalimat langung dan tidak
langsung
(3) Kosa kata: tokoh binatang
dalam fabel, tempat dan benda-
benda terkait tokoh
(4) Adverbia penghubung waktu:
first, then, after that, before, at
last, finally, dsb.
(5) Adverbia dan frasa
preposisional penunjuk waktu:
a long time ago, one day, in the
morning, the next day,
immediately, dsb.
(6) Penggunaan nominal singular
dan plural secara tepat, dengan
atau tanpa a, the, this, those,
my, their, dsb secara tepat
dalam frasa nominal
(7) Ucapan, tekanan kata, intonasi
(8) Ejaan dan tanda baca
(9) Tulisan tangan
Topik
Cerita yang memberikan keteladanan
tentang perilaku jujur, disiplin,
percaya diri, kerjasama, dan
bertanggung jawab.
Fungsi sosial
Memahami pesan moral lagu dan
menghargai lagu sebagai karya seni
Unsur kebahasaan
(1) Kata, ungkapan, dan tata
bahasa dalam karya seni
berbentuk lagu.
(2) Penggunaan nominal singular
33
dan plural secara tepat, dengan
atau tanpa a, the, this, those,
my, their, dsb secara tepat
dalam frasa nominal
(3) Ucapan, tekanan kata, intonasi
(4) Ejaan dan tanda baca.
(5) Tulisan tangan
Topik
Hal-hal yang memberikan
keteladanan dan inspirasi untuk
berperilaku peduli dan cinta damai.
34
understand the text on the first
reading
Gunning Fog index: 7.52
Approximate representation of the
U.S. grade level needed to
comprehend the text:
Coleman Liau index: 3.96
Flesch Kincaid Grade level: 3.41
ARI (Automated Readability
2.05
Index):
SMOG: 8.07
Flesch Reading Ease: 90.19
We must not wear sandals, a t-shirt, or a casual wear at any place and at
the time during the school hours.
The girls must wear a black skirt, and the boys must wear a pair of black
pants.
From Monday to Thursday we must wear the batik shirt.
35
Indication of the number of years
of formal education that a person
requires in order to easily
understand the text on the first
reading
Gunning Fog index: 7.70
Approximate representation of the
U.S. grade level needed to
comprehend the text:
Coleman Liau index: 3.97
Flesch Kincaid Grade level: 4.58
ARI (Automated Readability
2.80
Index):
SMOG: 7.90
Flesch Reading Ease: 85.76
36
of formal education that a person
requires in order to easily
understand the text on the first
reading
Gunning Fog index: 4.83
Approximate representation of the
U.S. grade level needed to
comprehend the text:
Coleman Liau index: 3.59
Flesch Kincaid Grade level: 2.74
ARI (Automated Readability
1.61
Index):
SMOG: 6.16
Flesch Reading Ease: 94.12
We must sweep the floor and dust the teacher’s desk and the shelf every
day.
We must not write or draw anything on the desks and on the walls.
37
Indication of the number of years
of formal education that a person
requires in order to easily
understand the text on the first
reading
Gunning Fog index: 4.19
Approximate representation of the
U.S. grade level needed to
comprehend the text:
Coleman Liau index: 2.66
Flesch Kincaid Grade level: 1.95
ARI (Automated Readability
0.47
Index):
SMOG: 5.07
Flesch Reading Ease: 96.87
Thanks for there through the tears, laughter and dirty diapers.
38
Indication of the number of years
of formal education that a person
requires in order to easily
understand the text on the first
reading
Gunning Fog index: 2.80
Approximate representation of the
U.S. grade level needed to
comprehend the text:
Coleman Liau index: 8.10
Flesch Kincaid Grade level: 4.00
ARI (Automated Readability
4.61
Index):
SMOG: 3.00
Flesch Reading Ease: 78.87
Thanks for there through the tears, laughter and dirty diapers.
Dear Mom,
Your, Son
Number of characters (without
90.00
spaces):
Number of words: 23.00
Number of sentences: 4.00
Average number of characters per
3.91
word:
Average number of syllables per
1.43
word:
Average number of words per 5.75
39
sentence:
Indication of the number of years
of formal education that a person
requires in order to easily
understand the text on the first
reading
Gunning Fog index: 4.04
Approximate representation of the
U.S. grade level needed to
comprehend the text:
Coleman Liau index: 2.03
Flesch Kincaid Grade level: 3.58
ARI (Automated Readability -
Index): 0.12
SMOG: 5.74
Flesch Reading Ease: 79.62
Dear Mom, I wish your days be blessed with smiles, love, and happiness.
Happy Mother’s Day!
My Dear Teacher,
Athan
Number of characters (without
122.00
spaces):
Number of words: 30.00
Number of sentences: 4.00
Average number of characters per
4.07
word:
Average number of syllables per 1.40
40
word:
Average number of words per
7.50
sentence:
Indication of the number of years
of formal education that a person
requires in order to easily
understand the text on the first
reading
Gunning Fog index: 4.33
Approximate representation of the
U.S. grade level needed to
comprehend the text:
Coleman Liau index: 4.15
Flesch Kincaid Grade level: 3.86
ARI (Automated Readability
1.47
Index):
SMOG: 5.74
Flesch Reading Ease: 80.78
Your nephew,
Kiki
Number of characters (without
89.00
spaces):
Number of words: 19.00
Number of sentences: 3.00
Average number of characters per 4.68
41
word:
Average number of syllables per
1.68
word:
Average number of words per
6.33
sentence:
Indication of the number of years
of formal education that a person
requires in order to easily
understand the text on the first
reading
Gunning Fog index: 4.64
Approximate representation of the
U.S. grade level needed to
comprehend the text:
Coleman Liau index: 7.05
Flesch Kincaid Grade level: 6.75
ARI (Automated Readability
3.80
Index):
SMOG: 6.16
Flesch Reading Ease: 57.92
It’s time to welcome the New Year with a fresh mind and clear
heart!
Adnan
Number of characters (without
118.00
spaces):
Number of words: 30.00
Number of sentences: 5.00
Average number of characters per 3.93
42
word:
Average number of syllables per
1.27
word:
Average number of words per
6.00
sentence:
Indication of the number of years
of formal education that a person
requires in order to easily
understand the text on the first
reading
Gunning Fog index: 2.40
Approximate representation of the
U.S. grade level needed to
comprehend the text:
Coleman Liau index: 2.37
Flesch Kincaid Grade level: 1.70
ARI (Automated Readability
0.10
Index):
SMOG: 3.00
Flesch Reading Ease: 93.59
It’s time to welcome the New Year with a fresh mind and clear heart!
May your dreams come true!
Your nephew,
Shilmi
Number of characters (without
118.00
spaces):
Number of words: 30.00
43
Number of sentences: 5.00
Average number of characters per
3.93
word:
Average number of syllables per
1.27
word:
Average number of words per
6.00
sentence:
Indication of the number of years
of formal education that a person
requires in order to easily
understand the text on the first
reading
Gunning Fog index: 2.40
Approximate representation of the
U.S. grade level needed to
comprehend the text:
Coleman Liau index: 2.37
Flesch Kincaid Grade level: 1.70
ARI (Automated Readability
0.10
Index):
SMOG: 3.00
Flesch Reading Ease: 93.59
It’s time to welcome the New Year with a fresh mind and clear heart!
May your dreams come true!
To Meyriska,
Your friend,
Yayang
44
Number of sentences: 3.00
Average number of characters per
4.53
word:
Average number of syllables per
1.67
word:
Average number of words per
5.00
sentence:
Indication of the number of years
of formal education that a person
requires in order to easily
understand the text on the first
reading
Gunning Fog index: 7.33
Approximate representation of the
U.S. grade level needed to
comprehend the text:
Coleman Liau index: 4.90
Flesch Kincaid Grade level: 6.03
ARI (Automated Readability
2.42
Index):
SMOG: 7.47
Flesch Reading Ease: 60.76
To Ganjar,
Your friend,
Zifa
Number of characters (without
96.00
spaces):
Number of words: 22.00
Number of sentences: 3.00
45
Average number of characters per
4.36
word:
Average number of syllables per
1.55
word:
Average number of words per
7.33
sentence:
Indication of the number of years
of formal education that a person
requires in order to easily
understand the text on the first
reading
Gunning Fog index: 4.75
Approximate representation of the
U.S. grade level needed to
comprehend the text:
Coleman Liau index: 5.81
Flesch Kincaid Grade level: 5.51
ARI (Automated Readability
2.79
Index):
SMOG: 6.16
Flesch Reading Ease: 68.65
To Ganjar, Congratulation for being the first winner of the news reading
contest!
Your grandma was one of the nicest woman I’ve known. Best pray
for her.
Your friend
Number of characters (without
103.00
spaces):
Number of words: 29.00
46
Number of sentences: 4.00
Average number of characters per
3.55
word:
Average number of syllables per
1.28
word:
Average number of words per
7.25
sentence:
Indication of the number of years
of formal education that a person
requires in order to easily
understand the text on the first
reading
Gunning Fog index: 2.90
Approximate representation of the
U.S. grade level needed to
comprehend the text:
Coleman Liau index: 0.98
Flesch Kincaid Grade level: 2.29
ARI (Automated Readability -
Index): 1.08
SMOG: 3.00
Flesch Reading Ease: 91.54
To Anas,
I heard you lost a tooth. Don’t worry, you’ll get the new one soon.
Your sister,
Anis
Number of characters (without
69.00
spaces):
47
Number of words: 21.00
Number of sentences: 3.00
Average number of characters per
3.29
word:
Average number of syllables per
1.33
word:
Average number of words per
7.00
sentence:
Indication of the number of years
of formal education that a person
requires in order to easily
understand the text on the first
reading
Gunning Fog index: 2.80
Approximate representation of the
U.S. grade level needed to
comprehend the text:
-
Coleman Liau index:
0.73
Flesch Kincaid Grade level: 2.87
ARI (Automated Readability -
Index): 2.45
SMOG: 3.00
Flesch Reading Ease: 86.93
Number of Score
Formulation
Text (Result)
Text 1 90.19
Text 2 85.76
48
Text 3 94.12
Text 4 96.87
Text 5 78.87
Text 6 79.62
Text 7 80.78
Text 9 93.59
Text 10 93.59
Text 11 60.76
Text 12 68.65
Text 13 91.54
Text 14 89.93
CHAPTER III
CONCLUSION
Before we talk about the analysis result of the book (When english rings a
bell), we concluded that in teaching-learning process media is very needed by
teachers and also students. One of its medium in teaching learning process is
books. Because there are many publishers in the nearest area or in the world, it
49
made the book materials very varieties. But we could not receive easily with all of
the books material that we found. It means that not all the books have the good
quality for the students. Teacher must be selective with the book that will be used
by teacher in the teaching-learning process. Teacher can assess the book by
looking in the qualified book criteria by the expert, in order to get the best quality
of the textbook used in the class
The analysis result of this book (When english rings a bell) can be assumed
that each expert criteria point have different assessment. In general, both the
contents and the design of this book are interesting to learn. But, some cases point
it does not match with the criteria. Moreover, the result of Flesch Reading ease
also shows that the reading text in this book is suitable to students in junior high
school. However, between the syllabus and the topics entire in this book are not
match. So, wisely the teacher should consider also the additional content in order
the get the best result of studying process.
APPENDIX
50
2. Some Pictures/Figures in This Book
51
52
53