Chapter 12
Chapter 12
Explanations of aggression fall into two broad classes, the biological and the social, although
this distinction is not entirely rigid. A debate over which of the two explanations is superior is
an example of the nature–nurture controversy: is human action determined by our
biological inheritance or by our social environment?
an instinct is:
● goal-directed and terminates in a specific consequence (e.g. an attack);
● beneficial to the individual and to the species;
● adapted to a normal environment (although not to an abnormal one);
● shared by most members of the species (although its manifestation can vary from indi-
vidual to individual);
● developed in a clear way as the individual matures;
● unlearned on the basis of individual experience (although it can become manifest in rela-
tion to learnt aspects within a context).
Ethology
Approach that argues that animal behaviour should be studied in the species’ natural physical
and social environment. Behaviour is genetically determined and is controlled by natural
selection
Releasers
Specific stimuli in the environment thought by ethologists to trigger aggressive responses.
Fighting instinct
Innate impulse to aggress which ethologists claim is shared by humans with other animals.
Derived from Darwinian theory, the evolutionary argument is provocative: specific behav-
iour has evolved because it promotes the survival of genes that allow the individual to live
long enough to pass the same genes on to the next generation. Aggression is adaptive because
it must be linked to living long enough to procreate.
Biosocial theories
In the context of aggression, theories that emphasise an innate component, though not the
existence of a full- blown instinct.
Frustration–aggression hypothesis
Theory that all frustration leads to aggression, and all aggression comes from frustration.
Used to explain prejudice and intergroup aggression.
Dolf Zillmann’s excitation- transfer model. The expression of aggression (or any other
emotion) is a function of: (a) a learnt aggressive behaviour, (b) arousal or excitation from
another source and (c) the person’s interpretation of the arousal state, such that an aggressive
response seems appropriate.
Although Bandura acknowledged the role of biological factors in aggression, the theory’s
emphasis is on the role of experience, which can be direct or vicarious. Through socialisa-
tion, children learn to aggress because either they are directly rewarded or someone else
appears to be rewarded for aggression.
Early findings pointed to a clear modelling effect when the adult was seen acting
aggressively in a live setting. Even more disturbingly, this capacity to behave aggressively
was also found when children saw the adult model acting violently on television.
Research on age trends for murder and manslaughter in the United States shows that this
form of aggression quickly peaks among 15- to 25-year-olds and then declines systematically
Type A people are overactive and excessively competitive in their encounters with others,
and may be more aggressive towards those perceived to be competing with them on an
important task.
a correlation between levels of testosterone and aggression does not establish causality
Sociocultural theory
Psychological gender differences are determined by individuals’ adaptations to restrictions
based on their gender in their society. Also called social role theory.
1 Boys, like men, consistently show more physical aggression than girls.
2 Gender and nationality interact in the case of relational aggression–e.g.itoccursmore
frequently among Italian girls than Italian boys, but less frequently among Chinese girls than
Chinese boys.
Catharsis
A dramatic release of pent-up feelings: the idea that aggressive motivation is ‘drained’ by
acting against a frustrating object (or substitute), or by a vicarious experience.
Cathartic hypothesis
The notion that acting aggressively, or even just viewing aggressive material, reduces
feelings of anger and aggression.
Disinhibition
A breakdown in the learnt controls (social mores) against behaving impulsively or, in this
context, aggressively. For some people, alcohol has a disinhibiting effect.
Deindividuation
Process whereby people lose their sense of socialised individual identity and engage in
unsocialised, often antisocial, behaviours.
Dehumanisation
Stripping people of their dignity and humanity.
Collective aggression
Unified aggression by a group of individuals, who may not even know one another, against
another individual or group.