Peter Principle
Peter Principle
Or, have you promoted your star team players, only to find that they are
suddenly "out of their depth" and struggling to cope?
If either of these scenarios seems familiar, you may have unwittingly fallen
victim to the Peter Principle.
While the book is written in a lighthearted manner, there's more than a grain of
truth in its well-researched analysis of one of the main flaws in hierarchical
structures.
How can you guard against the Peter Principle, or mitigate its effects? Let’s
look at three scenarios where it can come into play, and explore strategies to
combat it
1. You are a hiring manager, and you want to be certain that you're
promoting the right candidate.
If you're promoting from within your team or organization, make sure that
you're choosing the person who's best suited for the role, rather than
rewarding someone for past successes. You don't want to lose your best
technician, only to gain a mediocre manager!
2. You have been offered a promotion, but you are not sure that you
have the necessary skills.
It's not easy to turn down a promotion! But before you accept one, think
carefully about what is most important to you. Is it salary and status, or doing
a job that you are good at and that you enjoy?
Research the role and find out what is involved. For example, talk to other
people in similar positions, and use your interview to find out what new skills
you'd need to do the job effectively. Consider carefully whether you are
really motivated to learn those skills. Also, are you prepared to manage
your former peers ?
If the role isn't right for you, there's no shame in turning it down. In fact, you
may be doing yourself and your organization a favor. Concentrate on your
strengths, and you will find more fulfilling ways to advance your career and
contribute to your company's success.
Key Points
The Peter Principle states that, if you perform well in your job, you will likely
be promoted to the next level of your organization's hierarchy. You will
continue to rise up the ladder until you reach the point where you can no
longer perform well.
This will likely leave you frustrated and unhappy, and it may impact morale
and productivity in your company.
You can mitigate the Peter Principle's effects in your organization with good
recruitment, support and training.
If you are in a position where you feel "out of your depth," take control as soon
as possible. Talk to your HR department, and seek feedback, training or
coaching.