The Beginners Guide To Concrete Maturity Ebook
The Beginners Guide To Concrete Maturity Ebook
Concrete
Maturity
Copyright © 2021 Giatec Scientific Inc.
All rights reserved.
Global Headquarters
245 Menten Place, Suite 300
Ottawa, Ontario
Canada
K2H 9E8
[email protected]
www.giatec.ca
CONTENTS
Introduction to Maturity........................................................................................................................................5
So, How Exactly Does Maturity Work? And Why Is It Important? ............................................................. 6
Cylinders Vs. Maturity..................................................................................................................................................................... 8
Setting Up Maturity........................................................................................................................................................................... 9
Calibration Test Procedure......................................................................................................................................................... 9
What About Standards?................................................................................................................................................................ 9
Economic Benefits................................................................................................................................................. 10
Monitoring System.................................................................................................................................................13
Different Types of Concrete Temperature Sensors and Maturity Meters............................................. 14
Concrete Thermocouple............................................................................................................................................................ 15
Wired Concrete Temperature and Maturity Loggers...........................................................................................16
Wired Concrete Sensors with External Wireless Transmitter....................................................................... 17
Fully Embedded Wireless Concrete Sensors............................................................................................................18
Case Studies..............................................................................................................................................................26
Sundt Construction, Inc. San Diego, California ......................................................................................................27
PCL Construction, Edmonton, Alberta ..........................................................................................................................28
Graham Construction Calgary, Canada ........................................................................................................................29
S&F Concrete Contractors Hudson, Massachusetts ......................................................................................... 30
References..................................................................................................................................................................31
The Beginner’s Guide to Concrete Maturity
4 For the most part, the construction industry measures concrete strength the same way it has for the last
half a century, by pouring concrete into small cylinder (or cube) samples alongside its massive pours
(think the floor of an office building).
These cylinders filled with concrete are called field cured samples and they are supposed to mimic the
development of strength of the massive slab of concrete you just poured. So, throughout the first week
after you have poured your concrete, you would take your samples to a lab to test its strength.
If the tests say that the concrete of your cylinder has reached 75% of the concrete mix’s designed
strength, you are good to go to remove formwork and proceed with the next phase of the project. If not,
you continue waiting and testing more cylinders until that threshold has been reached.
The problem with these kinds of tests is that they are time consuming and, more importantly, not
necessarily accurate.
These field-cured concrete cylinders are often stored haphazardly, like under a tarp in the corner of a
jobsite. Concrete gains strength over time based on a number of factors like the weather conditions its
exposed to. The elements and variables that a massive slab of concrete endures is very different than
the small sample of concrete in your cylinder.
Just imagine we are on a jobsite and it’s snowing all over our newly poured apartment building floor
while our sample of concrete is warm and snug under a tarp next to a heater. This sample will not give
us an accurate idea of how strong our mass pour of concrete is, which could lead project engineers to
remove formwork and proceed onto the next stage of the project before it is safe to do so. Moving on to
the next phase of a project too soon can compromise the safety and durability of a structure.
There are, luckily, some alternative ways to measure how strong concrete is without having to use
cylinder samples. The Maturity method is one of the alternatives quickly gaining popularity due to its
ability to accurately measure in-place concrete strength, simplicity and variety of advanced technology
solutions in the market.
01
Introduction
to Maturity
The Beginner’s Guide to Concrete Maturity
INTRODUCTION TO MATURITY
The maturity method is one of the easiest and most straightforward ways to predict the early-age
strength of concrete because of the fact that concrete strength is directly related to the hydration
temperature of concrete’s cementitious paste.
Using the maturity method may address many of the challenges of the concrete industry, particularly
knowing when to remove formwork and to perform post-tensioning, this is especially important at low
temperatures where strength gain is slowed. It can also be used to create better mix designs and curing
conditions.
6 So, How Exactly Does Maturity Work? And Why Is It Important?
This approach takes into consideration that maturity is linearly dependent on temperature and can
simply be represented by the area below the temperature curve. In this approach, the area under
the temperature curve is taken as the difference between the average recorded temperature and the
datum temperature (Td). The datum temperature is defined as the temperature at which the hydration
of the cement stops, in other words, the temperature at which concrete stops developing strength.
In other words, the key to understanding the maturity method is that the mix design of the poured
concrete has the same strength as its ‘maturity index.’ So, a concrete mix design may reach the same
strength after 7 days of curing at 50°F (10°C) as it would at 73°F (23°C) for 3 days.
While curing, concrete creates heat during the process of cement hydration which gets trapped in the
concrete. The high temperatures help it cure, or gain strength, faster. The maturity method uses the
differences in the temperature to estimate strength gain.
Without having accurate information, contractors will often wait too long to move onto the next phase
of the project which delays the project, or they move on too early which can result in cracking and
structural issues.
The Beginner’s Guide to Concrete Maturity
This is where field cured cylinders run into issues. They are smaller in surface area, so the heat leaves
them quickly which slows down how fast the concrete gains strength compared to the large slab of
concrete you just poured. This means that the strength of the field cylinders is often less than the slab. So,
while you’re waiting for a break test to tell you that you’re good to go, using maturity you might see that
you already made your strength target 8 hours earlier, for example, and could have already moved on
to stripping formwork.
7
While estimating the strength of concrete is great for a project’s
timeline and budget it can also reduce CO2 emissions by
optimizing concrete mix designs.
That’s why being able to accurately estimate your concrete strength can help you save time, money,
and the environment.
The Beginner’s Guide to Concrete Maturity
INTRODUCTION TO MATURITY
Cylinders Vs. Maturity
Still not sure if you want to ditch field-cured cylinders and make the switch to concrete maturity? Here
are some other ways cylinder testing compare to sensors that utilize maturity:
Test Procedure
• Information is gathered through the casting of • Information is gathered by embedded sensors
cylinders taken from the pour and crushed in a recording temperature and strength.
compression machine.
• Data is logged and/or retrieved by external
• Testing time could be too early or too late device in real-time.
Reliability
• Results may be affected by improperly prepared, • The data is logged without interruption, so the
handled, and/or tested cylinders. results are generally more consistent.
• Cylinders have small volumes but large surface • The maturity method predicts the actual in-place
areas so they retain less heat which results in low strength of concrete.
breaks.
• It can show local variation in strength for
• Temperature history for cylinders may differ due different structural locations.
to curing conditions causing a different rate of
strength gain which results in low or high breaks.
Speed
• Takes time to send samples to the lab and delay • Strength results are collected in real-time.
to receive results from the lab.
Cost
• Technician cost to cast, collect, deliver, test, and • Up to 50% direct test cost saving for determination
repeat the results. of in-place strength of concrete done by on-site
people.
• Additional labour costs due to uncertainty in
project scheduling resulted from delays in getting • Up to $10,000 labor saving as a result of more
the lab report. accurate job-site planning for each floor of a
high-rise building.
• Extra financing cost due to late completion time
in projects. • Significant financial saving as a result of early
completion of the project. The actual saving varies
depending on the size of the project.
These calculations and equations may sound complicated and to a degree they are. However, many of
the maturity tools and solutions on the market today like Giatec’s SmartRock™ sensor will do most of the
heavy lifting, so you don’t have to bust out your calculator to figure these out.
This calibration is done in a lab and can later be used to determine the field cured cylinders concrete
strength. For more details on the maturity calibration process, take a look at Giatec’s Concrete Maturity
eBook.
Time is money
11
While there is upfront cost in buying maturity sensors and doing the calibration, there are more long
term cost savings by using the maturity method. The table below shows a breakdown of the upfront
costs of using the maturity method and the possible cost savings on a project.
Note: prices and quantity of maturity sensors can vary so we use an average below. The cost of
cylinders and site operations can change based on location and the type of project.
The Beginner’s Guide to Concrete Maturity
ECONOMIC BENEFITS
12
The example above uses typical average values, and the cost
savings were rounded down. You should look at finding your
own ROI to see just how much the maturity method can save
you on your own project. In this example, if you were to save
one day – the maturity method already pays for itself.
03
Monitoring
System
The Beginner’s Guide to Concrete Maturity
MONITORING SYSTEM
So, the maturity method sounds like the solution to many problems and has a ton of advantages.
What different methods are available to monitor maturity?
When it comes to the choice of concrete temperature or maturity measurement sensors and equipment,
14 contractors have many options to select from based on the cost, accuracy, and ease of use, and
of course how all these considerations would fit their project needs and budget. The measurement
systems available in the market are as follows:
• Thermocouples
Pros:
15
• Expensive (about $1/ft)
Cons:
• Wires need to be connected to external equipment at all times or data will be lost
• Measurement accuracy is low with a standard error limit of 4 degrees (ASTM C1064 requires an
accuracy of 1.0°F or 0.5°C)1
• Time-consuming to cut the wires, attach them to the plugs, and setup in the field
• Thin wires are prone to cuts and damages, resulting in lost data
MONITORING SYSTEM
Wired Concrete Temperature and Maturity Loggers
These loggers have an electronic circuit board that contains a coin-size battery with an onboard
thermistor for temperature measurement. The measurements are recorded and stored on this circuit
board at pre-defined intervals. The whole circuit board is completely sealed with a connector wire
coming out to download the measurements using an external device as needed.
16 Pros:
Cons:
Pros:
Cons:
• Remote jobsites with no cell network connection cannot use this system
MONITORING SYSTEM
Fully Embedded Wireless Concrete Sensors
These are self-contained wireless concrete
sensors and loggers that are fully embedded in
the concrete. The temperature measurements
are stored on the sensor. The recorded data
can then be download from the sensor through
18
various wireless communication protocols such as
Bluetooth LE, LoRa, Zigbee, or Wi-Fi onto a smart
device.
Pros:
Cons:
We’ll provide some pointers on where the best place is to position your sensors and the number of them
you may need. One thing to keep in mind is that sensor locations with cooler temperatures will have
decreased strength.
ACI 228 1R, Chapter 5 does give guidelines that one maturity meter is installed every 20 yd3 (15 m3) but
this may be overly conservative. With maturity meant to replace field-cured cylinders, we recommend
following the same minimum requirement of one maturity meter per 1/150yd3 (100 m3)3,4. Throughout
the industry we do see most applications use one maturity sensor per 1/100yd3 (75 m3), using two
sensors per pour. Depending on the volume of the pour you may need more sensors to measure it.
Main Applications
Different projects may require different placement locations for maturity sensors. Below are some of the
most common project types that have benefitted from using maturity sensors. For a comprehensive look
at optimal placement locations for these projects, check out Giatec’s Concrete Maturity eBook.
• 1-way/2-way Slabs
• Post Tensioning
• Mass Concrete
• Vertical Elements
• Pavement
• Precast
• Tilt-Up
• Shotcrete
Figure 8: Workers on a jobsite performing a tilt-up application
05
Frequently
Asked
Questions
The Beginner’s Guide to Concrete Maturity
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
What Can Affect the Maturity Calibration?
The maturity calibration is associated with a specific mix design and takes into consideration its
properties. As a rule of thumb, any changes in the mix design will have a direct impact on the
calibration; however, it is unrealistic to assume that all concrete batches will be equal to the one used for
the calibration. Therefore, it is commonly accepted that any changes in the concrete chemistry will have
a direct impact on the maturity calibration (i.e. accelerators, retarders, change in the type of cement,
supplementary cementing materials, etc.).
To check and analyze if a factor will affect the maturity calibration, one can ask: ‘Would this adjustment
23
in my mix change the strength data at given ages?’ or ‘Recently my producer made a small revision
to the mix, should I submit the mix for reapproval?’ and ‘Would this modification in my mix change the
temperature of my concrete?’. At any point where the temperature or the strength profile is affected, the
mix should be recalibrated.
Is the Calibration Still Valid if There Is Additional Water or Air Added to the
Mix?
A calibration is specific to the mixture design with specific properties. If you change the materials or
mixtures, you need to calculate a new calibration curve.
In real-world scenarios, additional water or air content can occur in mixtures so you can’t assume that
mix used for calibration is the exact same as the one on the jobsite. This is why you should use the
cylinders from the jobsite to produce your calibration. You can also build a calibration curve with a mix
with slightly higher w/cm and air content that still meeting the project specifications. This adds some
safety margins to the calibration.
24
the capability of retaining heat is smaller than a concrete structure.
Maturity helps to identify and measure critical locations in the real concrete structure. For example, due
to external factors, a slab can have different strength developments in different locations, which is also
affected by weather conditions. Also, the last-placed concrete is the last to start developing strength;
therefore, this location will generally have lower initial results if compared to the first concrete placed,
where the hydration process is further ahead.
Illustrated below we can find an example of time savings based on the strength obtained through
different methods, where the same concrete was exposed to different curing conditions.
I Have an Early Age Mix, How Should I Build My Maturity Calibration Curve?
A calibration is always specific to a mix design and choosing the break schedule that best reflects 25
the critical operations on-site is very important. ASTM C1074 states that, unless specified otherwise,
compression tests must be done at ages of 1, 3, 7, 14, and 28 days. However, since maturity is most
commonly used for early age strength prediction having more breaks at the initial stages of the strength
progression is fundamental. As a baseline to achieve good accuracy in the maturity curve, one can
assume 2 break points before the critical operation and 2 break points after, being the critical operation
the center data point.2
For instance, if the critical operation for stressing cables in a post-tensioned slab is 4,000 psi (27.5 MPa)
within 24 hours, it is important to develop the strength-maturity relationship in the first hours. In this
example, one could correlate the maturity with the strength at 12 hours, 18 h, 24 h, 3 days, and 7 days,
as the objective is to accurately estimate the initial strength. ASTM C1074 asks for a minimum of 5 data
points but, if desired, more data points at earlier or later ages can be included for higher accuracy.
On this project, both the short cables 12 in (30 cm) and long cables 10 ft (3 m) that Giatec’s SmartRock
offers were used in order to capture the highest temperature at the center of the concrete and the
27
lowest temperature near the surface of the concrete. The sensors allowed the team more flexibility in
terms of the installation location of where the temperature of the in-place concrete could be measured.
Overall, the consistent temperature monitoring made it possible to optimize the cooling requirements of
the concrete. This allowed for a 40% savings in cooling material on this project.
Some of the benefits expected for SmartRock to produce were to allow for savings on purchasing a
smaller amount of formwork. “SmartRock delivered! It saved time, ½ a day per cycle of pouring for
28 the four floors of the parkade. It also brought about savings from purchasing less formwork. Most
importantly, it provided confidence that the formwork can be stripped on a particular schedule, without
worries,” says Badry. When square footage per floor changed from 25,000 square feet to 14,000 and
concrete placement could be poured in 1 section, the team got each section down to a consistent 4-day
schedule. Why?
The switch to Giatec’s technology came about from a frustration with the inefficiencies of
thermocouples, such as wires which were prone to damage, and the need for expensive data loggers
to collect and read results which were time-consuming and labor-intensive. With the ability of the
SmartRock sensor to provide the most accurate in-situ concrete temperature and maturity data,
it consistently achieved a 90% accuracy in maturity-based strength estimation when compared to
standard concrete cylinder breaks. 29
“It was very easy and self-explanatory. No need even for
training. It took me 30 minutes to install 10 sensors. Anyone
on my jobsite could do it.”
Frank Hoffmann, Superintendent, Graham Construction
As a result, Hoffmann was able to cut costs due to the elimination of the need for a technician to visit
the jobsite every eight hours to plug into each and every thermocouple, record the temperatures, and
go back to the office to save and analyze the data. Furthermore, time was saved through the use of the
SmartRock app and its’ ability to share data automatically.
The Beginner’s Guide to Concrete Maturity
Project manager Steve Pirrello saw promise in Giatec’s SmartRock sensors and their ability to accurately
measure concrete maturity and strength, without the hassle of time-consuming lab testing and concrete
cylinder breaks.
Before any work started, the project engineers ran tests comparing the SmartRock sensor data to the
30 results of the cylinder breaks. Repeatedly, they found that the maturity meters provided similar, if not
more accurate results, than the lab break tests. As such, the engineers felt confident enough to eliminate
early break tests. The S&F team noted that they were more comfortable relying on the sensor readings,
rather than concrete cylinders, which they found had too many variables and inaccuracies. Relying
solely on SmartRock sensor data, the S&F team was able to schedule tensioning of slabs within an hour
of the concrete achieving the required strength, instead of waiting a minimum of 24 hours for break test
results.
CONNECT WITH US
[email protected]
Toll-Free: +1 (877) 497-6278
Giatec Scientific
Giatec
Giatec
Giatec Scientific
Giatec Scientific
Giatec