Canadian Coast Guard Welding Specification
Canadian Coast Guard Welding Specification
(CT-043-EQ-EG-001-E )
Welding Specification
Welding Specification
Published under the Authority of:
Integrated Technical Services Directorate
Fisheries and Oceans Canada
Canadian Coast Guard
Ottawa, Ontario
K1A 0E6
CT-043-eq-eg-001-E
Welding Specification EKME#3049715v3A
Disponible en français :Norme de soudage des métaux ferreux
FIRST EDITION – - MARCH 2014
Document Control
Record of Amendments
Approvals
Office of Primary Interest (OPI)
Tracey Clarke Approved:
2014-APRIL-10
Date:
Manager, Engineering and
Anne Marie
Maintenance Hull/ Mechanical/ Approved:
Sekerka 2014-APRIL-10
Electrical
Date:
Director,
Gary Ivany Approved:
Marine Engineering Services (ITS) 2014-APRIL-10
Date:
Director General,
Michel Cecire Approved:
Integrated Technical Services 2014-APRIL-11
Date:
W ELDING SPECIFICATION
Contents
FOREWORD ............................................................................................................................................................ IV
SECTION 1 SCOPE.................................................................................................................................................. 1
SECTION 2 DEFINITIONS & ABBREVIATIONS ....................................................................................................... 2
SECTION 3 APPLICABLE DOCUMENTS.................................................................................................................. 3
SECTION 4 ADMINISTRATION ............................................................................................................................... 4
SECTION 5 WELDING STRUCTURES...................................................................................................................... 5
5.1 CONTRACTOR REQUIREMENTS .................................................................................................................... 5
5.1.1 Steel Structures .................................................................................................................................... 5
5.1.2 Aluminum Structures .......................................................................................................................... 5
5.1.3 Welding Procedures ............................................................................................................................ 5
5.1.4 Welding Personnel .............................................................................................................................. 5
5.1.5 Performance and Qualification Testing ............................................................................................... 5
5.1.6 Limitations Prior to Commencing Welding Work .............................................................................. 5
5.1.7 Governing Standards for Welding ....................................................................................................... 5
5.2 WELD DESIGN ............................................................................................................................................. 5
5.3 SYMBOLS FOR WELDING ............................................................................................................................. 6
5.4 WELDING CONSUMABLES ........................................................................................................................... 6
5.4.1 Steel ..................................................................................................................................................... 6
5.4.1.1 Electrode and Consumable Selection ............................................................................................................ 6
5.4.1.2 Storage and Handling ................................................................................................................................... 6
5.4.1.3 Low or Controlled Hydrogen Electrode Requirements ................................................................................. 7
5.4.1.4 Shielded Metal Arc Welding (SMAW) ........................................................................................................... 7
5.4.1.5 Submerged Arc Welding (SAW) .................................................................................................................... 8
5.4.1.6 Flux Cored and Metal Cored Arc Welding (FCAW & MCAW) .................................................................... 8
5.4.1.7 Gas Metal Arc Welding (GMAW) ................................................................................................................. 9
5.4.1.8 Electrodes for Higher Strength Notch Tough Steels ..................................................................................... 9
5.4.1.9 Electrodes for Atmospheric Corrosion Resistant Steels .............................................................................. 10
5.4.1.10 Shell Butts & Seams – Ice Transiting Steel Ships........................................................................................ 10
5.4.2 Aluminum ......................................................................................................................................... 10
5.4.2.1 Electrode and Consumable Selection .......................................................................................................... 10
5.4.2.2 Storage and Handling ................................................................................................................................. 11
5.5 WORKMANSHIP ......................................................................................................................................... 11
5.5.1 Environment ...................................................................................................................................... 11
5.5.2 Preheat and Interpass Temperatures .................................................................................................. 11
5.5.3 Plate Forming .................................................................................................................................... 11
5.5.3.1 Personnel .................................................................................................................................................... 11
5.5.3.2 Materials ..................................................................................................................................................... 11
5.5.3.3 Procedures .................................................................................................................................................. 11
5.5.3.4 Controls ...................................................................................................................................................... 12
5.5.4 Weld Size and Dimensions................................................................................................................ 12
5.5.5 Adjacent Weld Spacing ..................................................................................................................... 12
5.5.6 Inserts and Doublers .......................................................................................................................... 12
5.5.7 Edge Preparation and Fitted Tolerances ............................................................................................ 12
5.5.8 Intercostals ........................................................................................................................................ 12
5.5.9 Dissimilar Plate Thickness ................................................................................................................ 13
5.5.10 Flush Tolerance ................................................................................................................................. 13
5.5.11 Smooth Tolerance ............................................................................................................................. 13
5.5.12 Preparation of Welds for the Application of Coatings or Paints ....................................................... 14
5.5.13 Distortion and Residual Stress .......................................................................................................... 14
5.5.13.1 Submission of Welding Sequence ................................................................................................................ 14
Foreword
This Specification has been prepared by Marine Engineering, Integrated Technical Services (ITS),
Canadian Coast Guard, Fisheries and Oceans Canada, Ottawa.
The purpose of this Specification is stated in Chapter 1.0, Scope.
When, this Specification is used other than as stated in the Scope, it shall remain the responsibility
of the user to judge its suitability for their particular purpose.
Section 1 SCOPE
This Specification establishes the requirements of Marine Engineering, Integrated Technical
Services, Canadian Coast Guard, Fisheries and Oceans Canada, Ottawa.
This Specification shall be followed whenever required by contract.
This Specification details the requirements for welding and non-destructive inspection of welds for
structural steel, aluminum and stainless steel and the wide variety of other materials used for
installation of pressure piping, pressure vessels and pressure containment systems and, shipboard
equipment.
This Specification is intended as an Owner's requirement. In addition to this Specification, the
Contractor shall meet all regulations and rules required by Transport Canada Marine Safety and
Security and, the governing Classification Society as applicable.
When the above mentioned rules exceed the requirements specified herein, the more stringent
requirement shall take precedence.
Section 4 ADMINISTRATION
This Specification shall be administered by the Director, Marine Engineering, Integrated Technical
Services, Canadian Coast Guard, Fisheries and Oceans Canada, Ottawa.
For the purpose of administration, the Director, Marine Engineering shall delegate representatives
that shall be responsible for measuring the Contractor's performance and ability to meet the
requirements specified herein.
The Contractor shall allow the Delegated Representatives access to the facilities, files and records
relative to the requirements of this Specification for the duration of the contract and warranty
period.
The documentation that is to be made available to the Delegated Representatives shall include, but
not necessarily be limited to, personnel qualification records, welding specifications and weld
procedure data sheets, certification records, visual and non-destructive inspection results, quality
control and quality assurance manuals and reports, and other associated documents.
A weld design schedule shall be submitted to the Delegated Representative in drawing form for
review prior to commencing any welding work.
5.4.1 Steel
5.4.1.1 Electrode and Consumable Selection
Electrodes and consumables for welding processes shall be selected on the basis of retained
hydrogen, mechanical properties (UTS, YS, elongation and toughness) and resistance to corrosion
in sea water.
Generally, the requirements of Tables 5.1- 5.5 inclusive shall apply involving use of steels having
a yield stress below 360 MPa (N/mm²) and charpy-v-notch toughness requirements at test
temperatures above -45°C.
For other materials or conditions, welding electrodes and consumables shall be selected in
accordance with the requirements of the following Sections of this Specification:
• Section 5.4.1.8 for higher strength notch tough steels;
• Section 5.4.1.9 for atmospheric corrosion resistant steels;
• Section 5.4.1.10 for Shell Butts & Seams – Ice Transiting Steel Ships
Welding electrodes and consumables for welding steel shall be certified by the CWB to the
requirements of CSA Standard W48 or the applicable AWS A5 series of standards.
When two different grades of material of the same tensile strength properties are being joined by
welding and corrosion resistance is not a consideration, electrodes and consumables for the lower
grade is generally acceptable. Similarly, when joining materials with differing tensile strength
properties, electrodes and consumables are to be suitable for the tensile strength of the component
on which the weld size (e.g. fillet weld) has been determined.
Care shall be taken not to overmatch weld metal mechanical properties.
NOTE: (1) As required in Table 5.1; (2) Restricted use as detailed in Table 5.1
Wire electrodes approved by the yield strength and average impact values of 47 J, the “A” suffix
method, shall be submitted to the Delegated Representative for review and acceptance. Weld
procedure qualification testing is required.
5.4.1.8 Electrodes for Higher Strength Notch Tough Steels
Welding electrodes and consumables for joining normal and high strength shipbuilding grade
steels that have been manufactured using the thermo-mechanical controlled rolling practice
method shall be approved by a series of weld procedure qualification tests.
Welding electrodes and consumables for joining shipbuilding steel grades FH-XX and XX-40
through XX-69 inclusive shall also be approved by a series of weld procedure qualification tests.
As a minimum, welding electrodes and consumables shall match the base metal strength (UTS, YS
and elongation) and notch toughness properties at the base metal test temperature.
To qualify welding electrodes and consumables, a series of weld procedure qualification tests shall
be performed in each position of welding using joint configurations typical of that intended for
production. For each of the test conditions, two welds shall be made; one test each at the
minimum and maximum anticipated heat inputs (kj/mm) planned for production welding.
Assemblages, type of tests and specimens shall be in accordance with CSA Standard W47.1. Each
procedure qualification test shall be supplemented with 15 charpy-v-notch specimens; 5 specimens
with the "v" notch located at the centre of the joint, 5 specimens with the "v" notch intersecting the
line of fusion and 5 specimens with the "v" notch located 5 mm from the fusion line (HAZ). Charpy-v-
notch specimens shall be tested in accordance with the requirements of CSA Standard W47.1 at test
temperatures equivalent to that of the base metal classification (ie. E & EH @ -40°C, FH @ -60°C, etc).
The minimum acceptance requirements for each test method shall be those requirements of the test
specification under which the base metal was qualified.
5.4.1.9 Electrodes for Atmospheric Corrosion Resistant Steels
Welding electrodes and consumables for joining atmospheric corrosion resistant steels such as CSA
Standard G40.21 grades 350A, 350AT, 400A and 400AT including ASTM grades A242 and A588
steels shall be carefully selected to match the copper and nickel content of the base plate and the
ultimate and yield strength, elongation and toughness properties. Close attention shall be paid to
matching all of the chemical elements that prevent corrosion in sea water.
Butts and seams in the shell, weather decks and all welds in uncoated ballast tanks shall be performed
with welding electrodes and consumables that are proven to be resistant to weld zone (weld deposit and
HAZ) corrosion in accordance with the requirements of Section 5.4.1.10 herein. These requirements
also apply to weld repair of scars in shell plating caused by removal of temporary attachments and
permanent markings made by welding. There are no pre-approved corrosion resistant weld metal
deposits for welding atmospheric corrosion resistant steels. For welds in other locations of primary and
secondary structure, electrodes and consumables may be selected and matched in accordance with the
requirements of CSA Standard W59.
5.4.1.10 Shell Butts & Seams – Ice Transiting Steel Ships
The finishing layers of shell butts and seams located on the sea water side of ice-transiting ships shall
be performed with welding electrodes and consumables that are proven to be resistant to weld zone
(weld deposit and HAZ) corrosion in accordance with the requirements of this Section.
For shielded metal arc welding, E5518-C3 is approved for use without testing. There are no other pre-
approved corrosion resistant consumables for any welding process.
Once the Contractor has matched a welding electrode and consumable to the minimum base plate
mechanical property requirements of this Specification; coupons shall be prepared, welded and tested
for corrosion resistance in sea water by conducting anodic dissolution tests as outlined in Annex “B” of
this Specification. Two weld coupons shall be made for each weld metal/base metal combination; one
test each at the anticipated minimum and maximum heat inputs (kj/mm) planned for production
welding. Welding bead sequence for these tests must employ a stringer temper bead technique as
illustrated in Annex B of this Specification. No weaving is permitted.
The target acceptance criterion sought is near equivalent loss of the base plate, heat affected zone and
weld metal deposit. Since this may not always be accomplished for all grades of base metal, slight loss
of weld metal is desired over any loss in the heat affected zone. Anodic dissolution test results shall be
tabulated and submitted to the Delegated Representative for approval.
For finishing layers of welds located on the external shell plating of ice transiting ships, a temper bead
approach shall be employed similar to what is illustrated in Figure 5.1.
Figure 5.1 Temper Bead Approach for Finishing Layers in Shell Plating
The first layer of corrosion resistance weld metal shall be deposited 5 mm below the plate surface.
5.4.2 Aluminum
5.4.2.1 Electrode and Consumable Selection
Welding electrodes, rods and consumables shall be matched to the base metal in accordance with
the requirements of CSA Standard W59.2. All welding electrodes, rods and consumables shall be
certified by the CWB to the requirements of AWS A5.10.
5.5 WORKMANSHIP
5.5.1 Environment
The work being welded shall be adequately protected against the direct effects of wind, rain and
snow throughout the welding operation.
Welding steel at ambient temperatures below -18°C requires approval in accordance with CSA
Standard W59. Aluminum welding shall not be carried out when the work surfaces are damp or
wet or at ambient temperatures below 0°C.
Welding with processes that utilize externally supplied shielding gas shall not be performed in a
draught or wind unless the weld zone is protected from loss of shielding gas as required by CSA
Standards W59 and W59.2 for steel and aluminum, respectively.
5.5.2 Preheat and Interpass Temperatures
Preheating and interpass temperatures for welding steel and aluminum shall follow the
requirements of CSA Standards W59 and W59.2, respectively.
For those materials not pre-approved, heat line bending procedures shall be submitted to the
Delegated Representative for consideration. The submission shall contain results of metallurgical,
physical and corrosion tests.
5.5.3.4 Controls
During plate forming, controls shall be in place to check maximum plate and water or air
quenching temperatures. On material grades having notch toughness properties, direct supervision
and monitoring is required.
5.5.8 Intercostals
The occasional misalignment of intercostals for steel structures shall not exceed the limitations
illustrated in Figure 5.2.
t3
t t2
t 1t
2
(X) = misalignment measured on the heel line; Where t 3 is less than t 1, then t 3 should be substituted for t 1
- When (X) ≤ t¹/3 Increase Fillet Leg Size Equal to Offset
For Strength Members:
- When (X) > t¹/3 Release and Re-Align
- When (X) ≤ t¹/2 Increase Fillet Leg Size Equal to Offset
For Other Members:
- When (X) > t¹/2 Release and Re-Align
Figure 5.2 Intercostals
Misalignment of intercostals is not permitted in aluminum structures.
5.5.9 Dissimilar Plate Thickness
Plates of different thicknesses that are groove welded require a transition as follows:
- Exterior Shell Plating of Ice Transiting Steel Ships, 1 in 4
- Other, 1 in 3
When the difference in thickness is less than
or equal to 5 mm and 3 mm for steel and
aluminum, respectively, the transition may be
created by welding as illustrated in Figure 5.3
TRANSITION BY SLOPING WELD SURFACE
Figure 5.3 Sloping Weld
(A)
(A) (D)
SEAM
SEAM
For Example: A Lifeboat 15 meters in length having a breadth of 4.5 meters and a moulded depth
of 2 meters will require: Method Number Length of Inspection
When access does not permit UT = 11 1000 mm – butts or seams
the use of 300 mm by 300 mm Inspections 500 mm x 500 mm – intersecting butts & seams
film size at intersecting butts MT or PT = 22 1000 mm
and seams, a series of films Inspections
shall be positioned to offer RT = 44 440 mm - butts or seams
examination of 150 mm of Inspections 300 mm x 300 mm – intersecting butts & seams
weld in all directions.
5.6.5.3 NDE Methods - Other
For work packages other than new construction, in addition to the requirements of Section 5.5.6.1
herein, the number of locations inspected by liquid penetrant, magnetic particle, radiographic and
ultrasonic test methods shall be in accordance with the requirements of Table 5.8 herein.
Table 5.8 Quantity of Inspections – Other
Item Method Number
Entire Plate Renewal – Butts & Seams (shell, decks, bulkheads, tanktop etc) RT 6 per plate
Entire Plate Renewal – Butts & Seams (secondary structure) RT 2 per plate
Partial Plate Renewal – Butts & Seams (primary & secondary structure) RT See inserts herein
Insert – Butt & Groove Welds (shell, decks, bulkheads, tanktop etc.) RT 4 per insert
Insert – Groove Welds (other primary structure) RT 2 per insert
Insert – Groove Welds (secondary structure) RT 1 per insert
Hull Penetration – Pipe or Plate to Shell Plate Opening (below waterline) UT Entire Weld Length
Pressure Pipe Girth Welds RT 1 of each 5 welds
Full Circumference
Each interpretation report shall contain a report number. The report number shall include the
Contractor's hull number (i.e. #1-218, etc.) and/or ship’s name.Each location listed on the report
shall be identified with an Inspection number (i.e., location #50 port is Inspection #3).
For radiographs, each film and its duplicate shall be submitted in a paper protective folder. The
identification to appear on each folder shall be Inspection #, Report # and Hull # as illustrated below.
Inspection # Report # Hull #
3 - 1 - 218
Each repaired location shall reference the original report of the rejected location, for example:
Location #50 - Port R1 - See 3-1-218
5.6.13.3 Inspection Arrangement Drawings
The Contractor shall prepare an adequate number of non-destructive inspection arrangement
drawings and sketches that accurately document the location of the inspections.
The inspection method, weld identification number and abbreviations for each inspection shall be
accurately recorded on a progressive basis (e.g. UT #75-R1, RT # 150 - adjacent - aft, etc). A legend
detailing the identification symbols used by the Contractor shall appear on each arrangement drawing.
The Contractor shall supply updated arrangement drawings to the Delegated Representative on a
regular basis throughout the contract period. Three copies of the final drawings shall be supplied
to the Delegated Representative at contract completion.
5.6.14 Overlapping Inspection
When a discontinuity extends to either or both ends of a location being inspected, additional overlapping
inspection shall be required. The overlapping inspection shall show a portion of the original end.
When an overlapping inspection displays unacceptable discontinuities at either or both ends, the
entire weld length shall be considered unacceptable unless proven otherwise by the Contractor.
Under this condition, welds shall be repaired to the extent required by the Delegated Representative.
All overlapping inspections shall be taken prior to repair of the originally rejected location. If
repair has occurred prior to overlapping inspections and the entire weld length has not been
repaired, the overlapping inspections shall be placed to overlap the start and finish of the repair.
The Contractor shall be responsible for all costs associated with performing overlapping inspections.
5.6.15 Rejected Weld or Part
When a portion of a weld contains discontinuities not meeting the acceptance criteria of this
Specification, corrective action may be taken providing the Delegated Representative has reviewed
the extent of unacceptable discontinuities and is in agreement with the repair procedure.
The repaired area shall be inspected by at least the same non-destructive inspection method used
for the original inspection. Care shall be taken to ensure that the inspection of the repaired area is
accurately located so that it measures the original location that was rejected.
For each failed location, one new location shall be examined. All new locations shall be selected
by the Delegated Representative. Each new location shall be considered in addition to the
requirements of this Section. All costs associated with performing the additional inspections shall
be at the Contractor's expense.
When an entire weld, base material, entire part or entire section contains unacceptable
discontinuities as specified herein, no corrective action shall be taken until the repair procedure
has been approved by the Delegated Representative and other interested parties.
6.3 CERTIFICATION
Contractors undertaking the welding of stainless steel within the scope of this Specification shall
be certified by the CWB to the requirements of CSA Standard W47.1 Division 1 or 2.
Welders, welding operators and welding procedures shall meet the requirements of CSA Standard
W47.1, and of AWS D1.6 as permitted by CSA Standard W47.1.
6.5 WORKMANSHIP
Welding shall meet the requirements of CSA Standard W47.1 and AWS D1.6, and of this
Specification.
6.6 INSPECTION
All examination and inspection of structural stainless steel shall comply with the requirements of
AWS D1.6
6.6.1 Personnel
All inspection personnel shall meet the requirements of Chapter 5.0, Section 5.6.8 of this
Specification.
6.6.2 Inspections
All welds shall be visually examined along 100% of their length for correct size, profile and the
presence of visible defects. Unacceptable conditions or defects shall be repaired to the satisfaction
of the Delegated Representative.
Full penetration welds shall be selectively sampled. Radiographic inspection shall be used for full
penetration groove welds in butt joints. Ultrasonic inspection shall be used for full penetration
groove welds in tee and corner joints.
Fillet welds shall be selectively sampled by liquid penetrant and/or magnetic particle inspection.
All of the requirements of Section 5.5 of this Specification shall be met unless otherwise specified
in this Chapter.
7.3 CERTIFICATION
Welders, welding operators and welding procedures shall meet the requirements of ASME Section
IX or other suitable standard(s) approved for use by the Designated Representative and the CWB.
All tests shall be fully witnessed and documented by the CWB.
7.5 WORKMANSHIP
Welding shall meet the requirements of CSA Standard W59, and of this Specification.
7.6 INSPECTION
7.6.1 Personnel
All inspection personnel shall meet the requirements of Chapter 5.0, Section 5.6.8 of this
Specification.
7.6.2 Inspections
All welds shall be visually examined along 100% of their length for correct size, profile and the
presence of visible defects. Unacceptable conditions or defects shall be repaired to the satisfaction
of the Delegated Representative.
Full penetration welds shall be selectively sampled. Radiographic inspection shall be used for full
penetration groove welds in butt joints. Ultrasonic inspection shall be used for full penetration
groove welds in tee and corner joints.
Fillet welds shall be selectively sampled by liquid penetrant and/or magnetic particle inspection.
All of the requirements of Section 5.5 of this Specification shall be met unless otherwise specified
in this Chapter.
8.6 WORKMANSHIP
All workmanship shall be in accordance with the requirements of ASME B31.1.
8.7 INSPECTION
All examination and inspection of pressure piping, pressure vessels and pressure containment
systems shall comply with the requirements of ASME B31.1.
8.7.1 Personnel
All inspection personnel shall meet the requirements of Chapter 5.0, Section 5.6.8 of this
Specification.
8.7.2 Inspections
All welds in pressure piping and pressure containment systems shall be visually examined along
100% of their length for correct size, profile and the presence of visible defects. Unacceptable
conditions or defects shall be repaired to the satisfaction of the Delegated Representative.
Full penetration groove welds shall be sampled by spot radiography at a frequency of one in every
five welds produced by each welder. Welders shall be assigned a unique identification number
that shall be stamped on each full penetration connection welded. If a radiograph reveals gross
defects, one additional joint shall be inspected by radiography. If the new radiograph reveals
gross defects, the remaining three welds shall be radiographed
Repair of defects shall be performed following procedures accepted by the Delegated
Representative. Second repair attempts shall not be permitted without due consideration of the
conditions and agreed to by the Delegated Representative.
CAN/ISO 14341:XX Welding consumables – Wire electrodes and deposits for gas
shielded metal arc welding of non-alloy and fine grain steels -
Classification
W48 Filler Metals and Allied Materials for Metal Arc Welding
6 mm
12.5 mm
Min.
DISCARD DISCARD 45 mm
ANODIC ANODIC
DISSOLUTION DISSOLUTION
MIN. HEAT INPUT 55 mm
MIN. HEAT INPUT
(KJ/mm) (KJ/mm)
250 mm
DISCARD DISCARD 50 mm
Min.
ANODIC ANODIC
DISSOLUTION DISSOLUTION
MAX. HEAT INPUT MAX. HEAT INPUT 55 mm
(KJ/mm) (KJ/mm)
DISCARD DISCARD
45 mm
150 mm Min.
Figure B1 Anodic Dissolution Test Plate Assembly
Welds shall be deposited following a stringer temper bead sequence at the lowest and highest heat
input (kj/mm) planned for production as illustrated in Fig. B2 herein. The centre 50 mm discard
portion of the test assembly shall be used as a transition between low and high heat input welds
(stop/starts).
For automatic welding using the submerged arc welding process, two test assemblies may be used;
one for high heat input and the other for low heat input welds. Bead and layer sequences shall be
adjusted to offer split layer finish to the weld.
600 to -560 mV vs. SCE which are potentials typical of unprotected steel in sea water. When the
potential is > -600 mV vs. SCE, daily stirring shall occur to avoid pH stratification of the anolyte.