Legal Research by B.K Das
Legal Research by B.K Das
Research Report
I f you would go up high, than use your own legs! Do not get yourself carried aloft; do not seat
yourself on other people's back and head"
Niet Zsche
The report gives some good,objective research to policy makers to help formulate strategies and
policies to encourage more students to stay and more graduates yo come back."
John Witherspoon.
Introduction:
The final stage of research work is report writing. Research work is not complete, unless report of
research is presented properly. The research problem, hypothesis, empirical findings may be superb
and brilliant, but they may be turn futile, if they are not well communicated or nicely presented to the
audience or readers. Research report, addresses to the reader, the entire findings of research in nutshell
A report may also be preseted to the experts in the field of legal studies, for his critical examination
and comments. It should be detailed description presented in a precise manner. A research report;
highlights the research findings for the dissipation of knowledge and dissemination ofrnew information
generalization Investigator. Prepares the report when he finalized all research exercises i.e.
broad
selecting problem forming hypothesis making empirical study, making analysis, data interpretation
and generalization. He never describes the vast planning and all preparation he has made for making
ne research study. He conveys important findings and how he has found them.
with the social attitude. Than he express them in a language, which can be well perceived
readers and evaluators. An expert may understand the technical terms, but common people ma
Thus the researcher prefer simple language, which may be well addressed to all i.e. laymen, scien
experts etc. tists,
Legal investigation require, specialized skill to address target audience. Target audience is th.
society in general, comprising experts and layman.therefore, it is highly essential to make farcef
expression in clear, unambiguious terms and soothing language.
According to Manroe and Engelhart-"The report of an investigation not only serves to record
and
communicate the procedure and the results but if fulfils an important function in the
process of
research. In the act of writing, if it is well done, the research worker refines his
detailed record facilities the critical testing of the work done. he is interested in
thinking and the
If
work to others, the report must be well written in order to fulfill that communicating his
purpose effectively"
It is well conceived that there is close nexus between well
organized though and effective style off
writing. 1f the researcher possessed effective skill in communication, and scientific character of
material analysis, he can present the research
report most effectively. In the matters of style and form,
research report differs considerably from institution to institution. There are some institutions,
departments and sponsoring agencies, who prescribe their own form and style. Such case researcher
has to present the research report
according to preserve from only. However in other cases, the
researcher has to communicate his ideas with his own
style and forms whatever may be the style and
form, the research report
must be purposive.
Purpose of research report:
The investigator should prepare research
report with some basic
Selltiz and other."The purpose of a report is not communication with purpose. According
to Claire
one sells but communication
with the audience. Audience may be different,
of law has to address the report for vast
particularly in the field of legal research. A researcher
audience, i.e. Sponsoring authority or the institutional
authority and experts, adjudicators, lawyers, Judges, administrators and public in general, whatever
may be the audience, the researcher should prepare the
report to serve the following purpose i.e. ()
What is the goal of the study (ii)What is the expectations of the audience (ii) Whether the report is
well presented (iv)whether the report contains new knowledge ? If above questions are well
the purpose of research have been answereu,
accomplished.
According to Prof B.N.Ghosh, "The purpose of a
report is dissipation of knowledge, broaa
casting of generalization and helping further research in the related field. A research report may oe
helpful to throw some new light which can make the building up of a new hypothesis and thus can
make possible new Theorizing. The
purpose of research is to express whole result of (research) stua
in sufficient detail in a organized manner. The main
goal of the researcher is to find truth and sp
the knowledge in the broader
spectrum to ensure their widest use. Research report should spell ou
finings to satisfy the expectations of the audience. Research report is skillfully prepared for
with an object to answer the presena
question posed in the hypothesis. It contains the basic findings o
outlined through data analysis and
generalization of research phenomena. It is to focus tne re
REsEARO REPT 1611
uestions
question that are not yet answered. Itis to raise new issues which need to
be answered through further
It is highly essential to unfold theoretical,
research.
3. It should be unambiguous:
The report must be unambiguous at all cost. Even, a report may be at times little
technical. hut s
should not be incomplete or ambiguous. It is advised that, the researcher to take
ho; ofa friendly critio
while finalizing the report. Thus Claire Selltiz and others rightly marked that
"Having at
least
colleague read the report just before the final revision is extremely helpful. Sentences that one
seem
crystal clear to the writer may prove quite confusing to other people, a connection that had seemed
self-evident may strike others non-sequitur. friendly
as a A critic, by pointing out passage that seem
unclear or illogical, and perhaps suggesting ways of remedying the difficulties, can be
an invaluable
aid in achieving the goal of adequate communication.
4. Report should not exaggerate facts:
In
socio-legal research, it is required to expose fact without exaggeration. The researcher should
carefully guard the tendency of exposing sentiments. This tendency may be born out of the spirit of
sensation mongering or out of literary fever. Dr. S.R.Bajpai remarks that,
"Literacy fever leads to too
much figurative language and therefore, some times the plain facts are over stated or
exaggerated. The
other weakness viz- lure of sensationalism is born out of feeling of self-importance. The work of a
research generally depends not on the work but on results produced. If the findings of any
investigation
are not novel or significantly different from the existing norm, they are not considered to be of much
worth and the labour of the investigation foes unrewarded. The fear of this insignificance, drives the
investor to exaggerate facts or say things in a novel way that my catch the attention of people" 6Similarly
one should not express his sentiments, arising out of social survey. Report should avert problem of
communication.
The expression of report should be faultless. The investigator should avoid basic problem of
communication. He should convey major idea through paragraphs. He should avoid faulty sentence
structure, poor punctuations, incorrect spelling and other variations of sentences. Introduction of quotations
and phrases may add to literary flavors, but all attempts should be made not to use them superfluously,
sometimes, literary flavor distort ideas and make sentence vague. Using too many quotations into an
authority-aden text, make the report irrelevant arnd inconsistent. The senternces should begrammaical
correct and well organized in terms of topical unity. It is remarked that, "spewing a disordered jumbie o
raw facts into a report not only fails to convey information to the reader, but also suggests that you have
not grasped the significance of your materials. Only through arduous intellectual effort one o
facts and convey precise ideas, that one may have in his mind"
6. The research should follow conventional rules:
It is essential on the part of the researcher to follow conventional rules in the use of abbreviation
commas inverted commas and use of capital letters.. Similarly footnotes should be used sparin
which enable researchers to substantiate sources of materials and to verify the authenticity ot mat
archer
relied. Sometimes, they are used to present explanatory statements. It is always advised to the rese
and
ue
that, he should
attach much importance to the clarity and expression, than to
ofthoughy
forms. The style, language, pagination, size,, spacing etc add colour to it.
RESEARCH RePORT 413
Essential Contents of Research Report:
A research report usually follow a standardized format of research report. In every research report we
three main sections.
may find following
1. Preliminary section.
ii. Aims
ii. Sources of information (including persons consulted and library material used)
iv. Scope of study.
B. Brief statement of the working hypothesis which guided the study.
C. Explicit definitions of units of study.
D. Brief statements of techniques used in the study.
i. Types of observations used and condition under which observations were made.
ii. Types of schedules formulated and conditions under which information was secured.
ii. Types of case history data secure, their sources, manner of presentation and preliminary analysis
made.
iv. Sampling procedures and conditions of selection and testing for appropriateness, representativeness
and errors,
v. Statistical procedures, sources of statistical data conditions under which they were obtained;
F. Major findings.
G. Major conclusions reached about findings.
H. Special remarks:
i. Problem encountered in gathering the data, classifying them, analyzing them
ii. Possible discrepancies in the data collected.
same topic in same contexts.
Suggestions to subsequent investigators on
ii.
i. Tables
ii. Graphs. Where figures of statistical data are presented.
ii. Maps
iv. Charts.
v. Diagrams
5. Conclusion and suggestions
a. Brief Restatement of problem.
b. Interpretation and generalization.
c. Major findings.
d. Recommendations or suggestions.
6. Reference section.
a. Bibliography
b. Appendix
c. Index.
d. Foot notes etc.
It is deemed necessary to explain the above outline sin detail for the guidance of research
scholars. Above outlines are prepared with the consideration of maintaining chronological order,
coherence and relevancy. Arrangement of ideas need systematic presentation. Therefore, the research
scholars are advised to take critical note, before venturing research report. They are to take assistance
from the experts or guide. It is not possible to take all help from the expet. They can make use of these
theoretical guidance, which may be immense use preparing the research report. An attempt is made to
guide the research scholar through the following presentation.
Preliminary Section:
i. Title page:
The first page of the report is called as cover page or title page. At the top, it contains the name of
the topic or title or research study. Immediately there under continuous the name ofthe degree for which
IS presented. Then appears the chest of the institution where research is carried out. Preceding to it the
and his Roll No. as well as
academic year is to be recorded. In the sequence, full name of the investigator
Than name of the guide with his academic qualification
unversty Registration number is mentioned. name of the institution and address is mentioned. These
and designation is mentioned. At the bottom of the is used. The
mentioned between the margins page and no terminal punctuation
nrormation are
other information is presented by capitalizing the
presented in the capital letters, whereas the
of the topic extends beyond one line. In such a case
nitial letters of principal words. Sometimes the title The investigator should indicate the purpose
aouble-spaced and placed in an inverted pyramid style. size papers are used in
which is precise and alluring. MostlyA4
O ne study. It is advised to chose a title, to make page attractive.
Penting research thesis. Now computer is used
416| LeGAL EDUCATION AND RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
ii. Preference
On this page the investigator ensures that the research work is his original work. It is not
duplicated or copied from any other similar work of any author or any institution. It is truthfu
statement made by the investigator to ensures accuracy or genuinity of the work. Sometimes, it
contains brief statement as to the scope and general character of the research.
v. Contents page:
It occupies a very important place in the investigators presentations. It gives an opportunity to the
readers to locate the important section or subject of his choice. It presents a scope to glance the subject
researcher prefers to describe
quickly. It includes chapter heading and sub-headings. Sometimes the
small letters and
topics within sub-headings. All titles and headings are typed in capital letters or with
is
initial letter Each content are followed
capitalized. the correct page citation. The investigator is
by
required to check the correct page numbers. This will be present after the main report is computerized
or typed.
vi. Table of cases:
of the
legal research, the investigator cites some case laws or the some relevant judgments
In the
reference.
High courts or supreme court. Those case laws are required to be presented for immediate ot
They should be with appropriate citation. The citations are consisting of name of journal, year
publication and page numbers. It is helpful for the reader for their further reference.
vii. List of Tables and figures.
If there are some tabular information, maps, graphs, diagrams, their lists are to be given o
separate page. That title of the table, corresponding numbers of the maps etc to be recorded a
appropriate page locations to be presented. Table, maps, diagrams, Graphs present data in the mo
efficient manner. It helps the reader to locate them easily for ready reference.
B. Main body of the Report or the texts:
i. Introduction:
lem
a. Introduction outlines fact about the research study. Introduction states the nature ot tne p
RESEARCH REPORT | 417
the
and develop lacts regarding the investigations. Generally it contains the reasons behind
choice or selection of the study. n introduction the researcher has to evaluate the study and
narrate the signilicance of the study. Ile has to reler the fact that, the study will be useful
and contribite significant towards the cause and concen of legal education.
b. Statement of the problem:
A statement of the problem is placed in a clear-cut terms and in logical sequence. It helps the
reader to get suficient materials and intlormation relating to researeh problem. The research problem
is finalized alter suflicient review of legal literature, consultations with experts and criticalappreciations
In the ficld of legal research, complex problem of law requires some explanation and elucidation. It
helps the reader to find clear insight into the study from the very beginning. The background of the
problem is well stated in the introduction. It illustrates the justification and significance of the study.
C. Purpose of the study.
A slatement as to the purposes of the study reflects the ideas. It answers the questions as to why
the study has been undertaken for research. The significance of the study is well addressed; it highlights
the points as to the objectives and reasons of the study. The purpose of the study signifies the goal of
the study and gives brief idea about the problem in nutshel.
d. Assumptions and delimitations.
Legal assumptions requires clear statement. It helps to understand the area of investigation. What
will be the area of operation is demarcated. The sources of information and their nature should be well
stated. The delimitation of the area should be justilied. It helps the reader to identify the subject and
it's jurisdiction of operation and scope of the study.
e. Definitions and concepts:
Some important and technical terms requires further explanations. In the field of law, the legislature
uses some words, those have separate meaning. They need little explanations. Similarly, legal concept
need clarification. It opens the eyes of the reader.lt helps the reader to understand the concept and the
importance of the study in the social context.
f. Description of hypothesis.
At the initial stage of research.study the investigator has to draw some inferences. He formulates
some ideas and put some important questions which need to be answered through some evidence.
Those important questions are main issues of hypothesis which require empirical investigations.
Hypotheses require some description for restricting various complex issued involved in the research
and
problem. Restrictions place on it, requires proper justification. It helps to attack main points
leaves the subsidiary points of research study. It makes the study meaningful, without diverting the
attention from the main issues of research problem. Therefore, at the introductory part of the study
is drawn to delimit the study. It time and energy of the investigator and highlights the
saves
hypothesis
important issues involved. It help the researcher in streamlining the data collection and concentrating
on meaningful issues of the problem.
2. Review of Legal literature:
previous research:
a. Analysis of historical incidence or
418 | LEGAL EDUCATION AND RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Description
of
tool and data gathering instrument:
He makes clear
theinvestigator briefly describe the data-gathering tools and instruments. the
were used. After describing the investigative instruments, he explains
vnlanation of how they
in gathering data. It may be stated that, complex, haphazard and unintelligible
ocedures employed
procedures employed
tabulation classification is a
data can be systematized through proper classification and
sS of
various items. These classified data
mass
are a arranged
comparative analysis easy.
and make the
4. Presentation and data Analysis:.
Report of (text)
facts
a.
of research report. Data Analysis and interpretation may be presented
This is a very important part size of
chapters. The arrangement of such chapter largely depends on the
in one or in separate made
one has developed during his research work. Analysis and interpretation of data is
information of research.
we will discuss the report of text or facts
the text and statistical figures. First
through
raw data. In the textual
and delightful stage to extract the meaning from the
It is most difficult the variables. One may
out important facts and the relationship between
discussion one has to point evidence form it and further
about the data, if he fine any dependable
make certain generalization observes the i.e.
qualification,
When one states the result of the study, he
explanation accordingly. valid. The main objective of an
situations or limits for which the findings are
precise conditions, are valid or not. If one
finds that
is to observe, whether hypothetical relationships
investigation that they need testing
is unpredictable, one may not his findings and suggests
hypothetical relationship how his findings are
studies. After interpretation of data one has to justify
through independent must be categorized and
inconsistent. Data which is significant to each hypothesis
consistent or Data
information to prove or disprove the hypothesis.
in the ways to reveal the pertinent
interpreted variables. This is
establish relationship between the independent and dependent
must be interpreted to
the relationship, the investigator
to confirm the hypothesis. If the result is contrary or affecting
required this way, one may justify his findings
and contribute
implications. In
has to discuss their possible
the advancement of knowledge.
b. Statistical data or Figures:
above. Apart from
of data in textual form has been discussed
The reporting and interpretation
statistical devices. The statistical data are
textual presentation, data critically reported through
are
to establish relationships
the following devices, those relatively simple
presented through figures by
between variables.
i. Tables: facts through
data in most effective way than presenting
Tables are popular device for presenting information most efficiently. If it is well
be drawn to convey
verbal disposition. A good table can and interpret the data significantly.
it is easy for the reader to grasp
complied and arranged properly, be presented through
through tables. Tables can
Statistical data can be systematically presented with textual
and columns. Table may be placed on a single page along
vertical and horizontal rows
with textual discussion: Tables
as close as possible along
materials. Tables are preferably presented
420 | LEGAL EDuCATION AND RESEARCH METHO0oLOGY
variables and vertical axis measure the characteristics. usually the independent
The figures formed by lines or curve Chapter-21 convey various aspect of graphs.
connecting the points. Graphs are useful to compare the variables.
Like table, graphs are useful to record the
a glance.
figures and it is very easy for the readers to grasp the data at
Graphs are presented along with textual discussion. Graphs are also numbered
and each
graphs contain the caption and the footnotes are placed just below the on
graphs.
ii. Maps:
Maps help the researcher to locate the geographic
made by use of dots., circles and the other representation of data. Investigation may be
symbols. The characteristics of area
shading and crosshatching. Map provides pictorial appearance of the data. It catchesrepresentation
the
by
reader. It makes the reading easy. sight of the
Maps are also numbered and appropriate description helps the
reader to get all information about
map. Maps are attractive and describes the data most
iv. Charts and
efficiently.
Circles
Charts reflects the division of various units and it
of different variables. It shows
gives detail information as to the characteristics
simple percentile distribution of various figures i.e what is the delinquency
rate in different states and how
govt. is allocating it revenue to different states can be shown in the
charts. Different "components are
arranged in a clockwise direction and radius id drawn vertically.
The proportion of data is presented by the number of
degrees in each segment of the 360ú circle. Each
charts should be given numbers and
appropriate description should be provided.
v. Diagrams:
Diagrams presents pictorial views relating to, various complex and quantitative data for
conceptualizing cold figures in an attractive and lucrative manner. Diagrams represent homogeneous
data which are easily put to comparison. Their size
changes with the change in scales and style of
presentation. Diagrams helps us to visualize whole story of numerical figures at a single glance.
Diagrams are presented in many ways i.e. pictograms, Cartograms, Dimensional grams etc. Each
diagram should have title and foot note to indicate brief facts. Diagram should be numbered and
source of data should be indicated.
Diagrams are attractive and impressive to read the variables. They are easily intelligible, even to
an ordinary reader. It is helpful to draw a simple diagrams. It helps the researcher by way of analytical
thinking on critical investigations. It saves time and energy and stimulates interest of the reader.it has
been discussed well in a separate chapter.
5. Summary and conclusion
The summary is the most significant and most difficult portion of the research report. Summary
presents important points of the study. Readers scan the summary to have an overview of the research
problem and thereby determines the usefulness of the study. If the readers find that it hods some
rESEARCH REPORT| 421
aortinent points to serve their purpose, they examine the remaining parts of the study. While preparing
mary and conclusion following points to be taken for consideration.
Summ
C. REFERENCE SECTION:
It follow the main body of the report. The
Every research study contains reference materials.
researcher acknowledge the fact as to the referential study materials, which he has relied, while
for the reader for further study. This portion
pursuing research study. This portion is equally important
Is discussed on the following heads.
a. Bibliography:
c. Index;
Index follows the appendix. index OCgins with new page and page number continues. Index
contains important words, doctrines, proverbial reference and reference materials. It is placed with
anpropriate page numbers. IT tne word or aoctrines have appeared in several pages, the researcher
notes all page numbers. On the rignt side of the words or doctrines. It contains glossary of words,
which the reader can locate them easily by referring the index. Index should be arranged at the last and
Appendix,. ..320
Applied Research, .125
Bias, 35
Hypothesis, .. .....127-128
Interpretation of statues-..... ..137
Writing style of research Report,.... 246-252
Z test, . . . ....270,273,284 etc.
d. Footnotes:
Foot notes are place at the foot of the page. They are used as reference guide or short explanations
to the points under discussion. Footnotes enumerates authors names in natural order, followed the
nameofthe book, article, page Nos and publisher's name, edition and the year. Footnotes are used as
important devices and serve following purposes. Investigator substantiate his presentation by citing
other authorities, to attach credit to the sources of material quoted or paraphrased. Footnotes provide
specific sources to verify the authenticity and accuracy of materials used. Those serve as a explanatory
note of the text. Some institutions and department followed different procedure of inserting footnotes.
ACCordingly, they place all citations on a single page at the end of each chapter.
Conclusion:-
Above questions need proper consideration. The evolution of research project needs thorouph
reading. Analytical proceedings as suggested need proper examination. Critical evaluation of researcher's
report helps to develop efficiency. It helps them to be competent and skillful. It may be concluded that
report writing is an art one can master them by keen observation and practice.
Footnotes:-
1.
1 Claire Selltiz, Marie Jahoda, morton Deutsch and Stuard W. cook, research Methods in social Relations,
442(Ed. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New your, 1964
2.
2. ProfB.NGhose, Collection and Analysis of data, Ed. By S.K.Verma. and M.A. Wani, ILI, New Delhi
2006 reprint at P483.
3. Ibid at P. 485
4. Ibid-at p.486
5. Supra Note at P.454.
6. Methods of Social Survey and Research, kitab Ghar, 15th ed at 404
7. Scientific social survey and research, prentice Hall of pvt Itd, New Delhi. 1984
8. Best W. John and James V.Kahn-
Research in Education' 6th ed, 1992 at P. 337 Prentice-Hall of India PVt Ltd N.Delhi.