Summer Internship Project Report On "A Study On Comparative Analysis Between ULIPS and Mutual Funds"
Summer Internship Project Report On "A Study On Comparative Analysis Between ULIPS and Mutual Funds"
ISSN No:-2456-2165
Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Two Year Full Time PostGraduate Diploma in Management
CERTIFICATE OF ORIGINALITY
I hereby declare that this Summer Internship Project “THE STUDY ON COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS BETWEEN ULIPS
AND MUTUAL FUNDS” is my own work and that, to the best of my knowledge and belief, it reproduces no material previously
published or written thathas been accepted for the award of any other degree of diploma, except where due acknowledgement has
been made in the text.
(MUKUL RAJ)
Enrollment No. 2019084Date:
I would like to extend my deep gratitude towards my Faculty Mentor Prof. Jyotsana Vaid and myIndustry Mentor Mr. Aman
Savita, Corporate Sales Manager at Investosure Pvt. ltd who always motivated me and helped me during the internship and gave
his valuable time & guidance in every step of my project. He was like a mentor for me during 8 weeks of internship program
giving me valuable inputs & much need sales exposure. I would like to thank my colleagues whowere working with me during the
internship in
Investosure PVT LTD for their corporation & support during the entire training period.
Genesis of Study
Every investment is made with some objective or goal and there are various types of investments options available in the
market. ULIP (Unit Linked Investment Plans) and Mutual Funds are some of the investments options available in the market. This
study basically focuses on the comparative analysis between ULIP and Mutual Funds as what are the difference between them and
to understand the perspective of the investors for these two investment options available in the market.
Exact Scope
The scope behind this study depends on understanding the perspective of the consumers towardsULIP (Unit Linked
Insurance Plans) and Mutual Funds and doing the comparative analysis between these plans.
Research Methodology
This analytical research work is primarily focused to show the investors the right choice of investment for the best returns.
The researcher has observed the following in the design and the execution of this research study.
There is abundant information available to the public with respect to the mutual fund, but in the case of ULIP, the information
available to the public is very limited, particularly the charges arenot stated explicitly.
The research is based on the data made available on the funds of open ended equity funds, intermediate and short term funds of
Mutual Fund and ULIP.
The researcher will also focus on finding out which of the given investment options will be a fruitful choice for the investor in
context of getting better returns, flexibility, tax assistance, timeperiod etc.
The Cronbach‘s alpha was calculated for the seven statement questionnaire. Value of thecoefficient was found to be 0.906008
which indicates the reliability is higher than the value of 0.7. So, all the items in the questionnaire are highly reliable in nature.
The Financial regulator has allowed new entities such as payments banks to be created recently thereby doing it. However,
the financial sector in India is predominantly a banking sector with commercial banks has covering more than 64% of the total
stake covered by financial system. The Government of India has introduced several reforms to liberalize, regulate and enhance the
working of this industry.
There are many investors who are still not aware about the difference between the two options and where he has to invest his
savings for getting better returns according to his future goals. The various points on which these options will be assessed and to
find out which is the better option for investment. As we know the financial services are growing rapidly and the customers and
investors are also getting interested in investing their hard earned money in the capital make and such investments options
therefore, it is important for the society to understand the basic difference between the two options as the investor need to know
exactly where his money is invested and accordingly they are able to understand and make a wise choice as where actually they
have to invest. As a investor the reasons behind one is investing may vary investor to investor as for one investor security of his
funds matters the most while for the other maximum returns in minimum time will the case of concern. As for one investor will be
more interested in steady and slow returns while other person has the requirement of huge sum of money in some future time may
it will be for his daughter’s marriage or for his child’s higher education. Hence the requirement for this study is to clear out the
sense of confusion in the minds of the investor and he himself is able to make choice as actually where he has to invest for
fulfilling hisunderlying motive for his investment.
Literature Review
“A Comparative Study of ULIP and Mutual Funds investment of salaried person inUrban Area”
By Asst. Professor Deshpande Anuya Samruddha in March 2018 :- In this study ULIP and Mutual Fund investment are
compared on seven different parameters using questionnaire method of survey. Survey is conducted for the sample size of 100
salariedemployees from urban area of Nasik district. On the basis of literature review and conducted mutual fund investment is
proved to be better investment over ULIP.
Mutual Funds or ULIPS? – A Cost and Return Basis Analysis Dr. Kabirdoss Devi Assistant Professor (SG), Saveetha
Engineering College: - Investors always look for good investment opportunity, which would give good returns, safety and
security to their investment. The gaze of present financial distribution system and quality of advice available in the market, it
is strongly believed that Mutual Fund Investment would provide good returns with portfolio matching the risk attitude of its
investors. Mutual Fund is a mechanism of pooling resources from general public and investing collected funds in debt or
equity instruments in accordance with the objectives as disclosed in the offer document.
PROJECT REPORT ON COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF ULIP PLANS WITH MUTUAL FUNDS BY YOGITA: This
research paper also talks about a comparative analysis between different investment options and in this research it was also
proved thatMutual funds are far better option than ULIPS.
Comparative analysis of ULIPs V/s Mutual Funds By Satnam Singh Associate Professor (P.G Deptt of Commerce & Business
Management, S.S.M College, Dinanager) (2016) :- Some insurance advisers recommend ULIP based plans for meeting the
long term goals of the investors and some financial advisers recommend mutual fund with a term plan as a solution to meet
long term goals of the customers. Each one believes one is superior toother solution.
Insurance companies offering ULIP plans have several layers of costs and it is not easy to comprehend total cost of the plan.
But it is not difficult to read the expenses of a mutual fund. Even a novice investor can see the costs that he is paying in mutual
fund as fund expenses. I don’t understand why IRDA can’t impose a rule on all insurance companies to use one simple fixed
ratio as an expense.
The Study of Trends in Life Insurance Sector and Growth of ULIPs in India - Mrunal Chetan Joshi: - Life Insurance sector is
continuously growing sector and still in India large number of people are not insured and this sector has good potential to
grow. As continuous increasing contribution of service sector in GDP growth of Insurance Sector will play its crucial role in
future for the development of Indian economy. In insurance industry well defined guidelines about ULIPs and increasing
rationality decision making of investor increases the chances of development of ULIPs over traditional insurance plans. ULIP
serves all the benefits of MF, but at higher cost. But at the same time ULIP also serves one of the important purposes of an
investor i.e. Insurance – financial supportin future in case of casualty to investors’ life, which provides it an edge over MF.
Another crucial component of India’s financial industry is the insurance industry. The insurance industry has been expanding
at a fast rate. The total first year premium of life insurance premium has reached Rs. 2, 14,673 crore in FY 2019. Furthermore,
India’s leading Bombay stock exchange will set up a joint venture with EBIX incorporation to build a robust insurance
distribution in the country through a new distribution exchange platform.
Road Ahead
India is expected to become the fourth largest wealth market in the world by 2020.
India is today one of the most vibrant economies of the world, the back of robust bankingand insurance sector.
India’s mobile wallet industry is estimated to a compound growth rate of 150% to reach $4.4 billion by 2022.
Asset Management
The asset management industry of India is among the fastest growing industry in theworld.
As of FY 16, 42 asset management companies were operating in India.
In 2016, the country registered a record inflow of mutual funds at USD 29.74 billion per annum and in systematic investment
plans, investment crossed USD 594.97 million per annum.
Merchant Banking
Merchant bankers provide arranging support, knowledge and resources available to individual and organization for starting,
expanding and sustaining their business.
Leasing
Lease is an agreement whereby the lesser conveys to the lessee the right to use an asset for an agreed period of time in return
for a payment or series of payment with or without written down.
Securitization
Securitization is a process of pooling and packaging of homogenous illiquid financial assets into marketable securities that
can sold to investors.
Growing Demand
Rising incomes are driving the demand for financial services across income brackets
Financial inclusion drive for RBI has expanded the target market to semi urban & Ruralareas
Investment corpus in Indian insurance sector can rise to USD 1 Trillion by 2025.
Innovation
India benefits from a large cross utilization od channels to expand the reach of financialservices.
Maharashtra will be first state to launch its mobile wallet facility allowing transferringfunds from other mobile wallets.
Growing Penetration
Credit insurance and investment penetration is rising in rural areas.
HNWI participation is growing in the wealth management section.
Lower mutual funds penetration of 5-6% reflects latent growth opportunities.
SEBI allows digital wallet transactions of mutual funds worth USD 763.83
Policy Support
NRFIP is targeted for availing comprehensive financial services to remove rural households by2025.
Government has sanctioned new banking licenses and increased the FDI limit in the insurance sector.
In April 2017, SEBI allows instant credit into bank accounts, after redemption of mutual funds.
As they see this perspective as an opportunity for setting up a new venture in India and provide their services at affordable
cost. Their services includes wealth creation, portfolio managementservices etc.
Director’s Message
“ Our forefathers were used to save more money despite the income was less and the fact that there were bigger families and
expenses were higher as more number of people were there and earning members were less; we were able to save but our
upcoming generation would not able to do even half of the saving we were able to do in our lifetime so PMS services are one of
the essential needs and we want to make for not just High Network Individuals but also for common people as we want everyone
to have a better retirement and better life as they can achieve their financial goals with ease and they should be prepared for the
uncertain situation in life ahead , as life is full of uncertainties so we want common people to be able to sustain those uncertainties
with ease.”
Company’s mission is to gain the trust of their customers and become their family’s financial partners and providing them
affordable financial solutions during their entire career and even after their retirement
Core Values
Team Work
Innovation
Intregity
Saving Levels: - A saving culture is often associated with robust demand for financial services. According to ando and
Modigliani, the lifecycle hypothesis assumes that the prime earning years of an individual is often the period in which demand
for banking services if the highest.
Income Levels: - Income is defined as the payment received in exchange for labor or services pr from the sale of properties. In
cross sectional studies, income levels are often observed to be directly related to financial sectors. The volume and
sophisticationof the financial services demanded much higher in higher income individuals than in lower income.
Transaction Costs: - Both households and firms pay transaction cost and each and every time when they decide to buy or sell
or invest in financial assets. These cost consists service charges, commissions which affect decision making
Risk Factors: - There are various life stages of an individual according to which the risk taking capacity of an individual is
associated and it vary during his lifetime as in his early ages of life he can take risk by investing in financial services but in
later stages of life with increasing responsibilities his risk taking ability decreases.
Rules and Regulations Prevailing in the Country: - The various rules and regulations prevailing in the country also affect the
investing decision of the consumerregarding safety of his funds and return on investments.
Education Levels:- Education and knowledge levels of the investor also affects his investing decision as for deciding where to
invest he must attain the basic knowledgeof the financial system and financial services.
Rising Expectations and New Technologies: - The financial services industry is a cups of substantial change. Rapidly
advancing technologies, rising consumer expectations and disruptive innovations will reshape the structure of the industry
across country.
Growth in Foreign Investment: - Growth in India’s financial sector out 2035 will be driven by expected increase in FDI and
FDI partially into Indian infrastructure. This increases the trust of the consumers and they start to invest and enjoythe services
of financial sector.
B. Competitors Analysis
Deologic
Ranked No.1 MLA with 7.2% of market share in deologic global project finance leagueloans ranking 2014.
No.1 Financial advisor (28% of market share in the asia pacific Financial advisor rankings
No.1 India loans mandated arranger- Market share of 75.5% (Rs. 251 billion)
Services
Financial Assistance
Innovation
Debt syndication
Mergers & Acuiqisition
Investment Banking
Advisory
Avendus
Avendus is a leading provider of financial services in India and lays emphasis on creatingcustomized solutions in the areas of
asset management, credit solutions, investment banking and wealth management. They work along side with high performing
entrepreneurs, wealth creators and pioneer of the new age economy in their quest to outperform.
Services
Asset Management:- Delivering steady returns through variety of focused funds withdifferentiated strategies.
Credit Solutions: - Leveraging cross functional intellect to customize innovative flexiblecapital solutions.
Investment Banking:- Harvesting deep expertise to deliver high quality M&A and PEadvisory services.
Sunderam business services is also global outsourcing company with over 1000 employees and over 1000 clients across
three continents. There function is to provide efficiency in controlling costs and reducing costs, finding leveraging on their
experiences
Sunderam Business services provide back office services for SMSF administrations, accounting firms, wealth and portfolio
management companies and hospitality companies.
Services
Retirement Planning
Wealth Creation
Wealth Management
Portfolio Management
Mutual Funds
Strength
One of the strength which can provide benefit or which is currently providing benefit is their location and connections as a
place like Delhi NCR is full of HNWI(HIGH NET WORTH INDIVIDUALS) and youth who have keen interest in investment
services and their network is also growing very rapidly with their strong trust and other trusted business partners are coming up for
investing in these services.
Weakness
One of the greatest weaknesses of investosure Pvt Ltd company is lack of expansion plans and marketing strategies as for
now it is more than ten years old company in the market and only have 5 locations branch offices in Northern India only. I think
this is a case of concern for a company like investosure.
Opportunities
One of the opportunities available for investosure is the growing customer base who are interested to invest in financial
services as 2025 this sector has the capability to become one of the most rapidly growing sector of India.
Threats
There are various upcoming threats which might affect the company like investosure must overcome is the growing
competition in this sector as there are various business players who are currently beating them and giving them tough competition.
Objectives
One of the objective of the project is to understand the what is the difference betweenMutual funds and ULIPs
To make a comparative study between mutual funds and ULIPs
To make a comparative analysis between mutual funds and ULIPs on the basis of various factors namely Liquidity,
Flexibility, Taxability of income, Ease of choice, Returns on investment, Cost of investment, Safety of sum invested
A Mutual fund company can be considered as an investment company which gathers the funds of the investors having
common investment motive. The funds which are collected by the investors at one place having widespread objective are invested
in a portfolio which comprises of various investment options like equity, bond, money market instruments, real estate, gold, off
shore funds etc. The selection of these investment options is done by the professional financial managers who manage the
portfolio of a mutual fund scheme. Every mutual fund scheme launched by a mutual fund company has its own objective and total
investment in mutual funds is divided into various units. Each investor in mutual fund scheme is called a unit holder after
deducting the expenses involved in management o a portfolio. The regulating bodies clear out various guidelines related to fund
management and expenses involved in it In India all mutual fund schemes are formed under a trust. The securities exchange board
of India (MUTUAL FUNDS) regulation 1996 specifies various rules and regulations associated with the function of mutual funds
companies in India.
“Mutual Fund Is A Fund Eshtablshed In Form Of A Trust To Raise Money Through The Sale Of Units To The Public Or
Section Of The Public Under One Or Mor Schmes For Investing In Secirities, Inclusing Money Market Instruments” :- From A
Book On Financial Services By Renuka Sharma And Kiran Mehta
Similarly there are some other reasons of investment too. People may like to secure their old age and look for some regular
income source in form of pension. Others may be looking for regular income as a paid companies on their debt capital on high net
worth companies pay in form of regular pay equity dividend. In now a days a varied range of schemes are provided by mutual
fund industry which more or less fulsills the expectations of investors on a risk return time horizon scale.
Interval Scheme
As it is clear from the name itself, these types of funds have features of both the above discussed categories. These types of
schemes are basically close ended in nature, but these are kept open for buy and sell for a specific time period and necessasary
information related to this is already mentioned in the document.
Equity Funds
Equity funds generally in different equity shares of various companies. The equity shares how ever terms as the riskiest
financial instruments as compared to other financial instruments issued by a company in the form of debt and hybrid securities.
The diversification of equity can be done by investment in equity shares of companies under same industry or in equity shares of
companies from different industrial aspect. This type of decision is based on the style of fund managers and existing market
scenarios. For example AXIS long term equity fund dividend, UTI equity fund, Reliance equity funds etc. Further the equity funds
can be characterized as follows:-
Large Cap, Mid Cap and Small Caps Funds and Flexi Caps
The large cap funds make investments in equity shares of firms having a large size. These type of companies are of
comparatively high net worth and are considered safer than the others.
Likewise, the mid cap funds make investment in the funds of medium size and small cap funds generally investment in the
companies of small size. Here size means the size of the firms on thebasis of Market Capitalization.
The thematic funds generally have a broader base of classification of stocks but are lesser diversified in comparison to
diversified funds. For example, infrastructure, exports, and consumer goods can be a base of thematic funds.
For example, Baroda pioneers ELSS 66, EDELWISS ELSS FUNDS, IDFC TAX ADVANTAGE (ELSS) FUNDS-
GROWTH, and RELIANCE TAX SAVER (ELSS) FUNDSETC.
Advantage Schemes
An arbitrage scheme allocates its funds in opposite position of stock markets and derivativemarkets in order to neutralize the
price risk available in the equity stocks.
Debt Funds
Debt securities are less risky than equity stocks. The rate of interest on debt securities is generally pre-specified and fixed.
Moreover the payment of interest on the debt instrument is an obligation on the part of company raising debt funds; therefore
because of these features it is called a relatively safer or less risky financial instrument. A debt fund allocates to debt securities of
different companies. The credit rating of a debt instrument has significant impact on the selection of that debt instrument in the
portfolio of a debt fund scheme
Gilt Funds
Gilt funds invest in only such gilt securities offered by government. As gilt securities offered bythe government authorities
and that’s why the possibility of the counter party risk is almost negligible but the rate of interest in these types of securities is
very high.
These funds provide return better than debt and are of moderate risk level.
Gold Funds
These funds are generally characterized into Gold exchange traded funds and gold funds.These funds allocate their resources
into gold or gold related securities. The gold exchange traded fundsallocate their funds to various indices based on gold and gold
funds allocate their resources to theequity stocks of the companies which are relate to gold.
Commodity Funds
The allocation of funds of commodity exchange traded funds or in other funds related tocommodity sector.
Diversification
One of the benefits of investing in mutual funds is that the funds are invested in diversified portfolio. This depends upon the
type of mutual fund scheme investor has chosen and according to his objectives, this diversification is done on the basis of
financial instruments which includesequity, debt, hybrid securities and other derivative and off shore funds.
Professional Management
The portfolio of a mutual fund scheme is managed by professionals. These fund managers are experts and they know and
well aware of timing and selection of various types of investment avenues for the portfolio.
Liquidity
Mutual funds also provide liquidity option to the unit holders. Majority of mutual funds, weather an open ended fund or a close
ended fund are listed on the stock exchange, and investors can buyand sell units of mutual funds depending on the structure of the
scheme.
Divisibility
Divisibility is another benefit of mutual fund schemes. Small investors cannot invest in the stock and other securities of
companies with very large size, as the price per unit of these securities is very high. But many a times, these types of securities is
very high. But because a mutual fund scheme pools together the funds of a large chunk of common investors and amount, thus
collected fund is quite huge and the fund managers are capable to invest these funds in the stocks of large sized funds. Therefore,
just by buying some units of these mutual funds, the investors get the benefit of large cap stocks.
Economies of Scale
Economies of scale refer to getting benefit in doing bulk dealings. Mutual funds scheme invest in huge funds in buying and
selling the securities are bought and sold by individual investors, then it might cost very high in terms of doing transaction costs
and other chargers. Therefore, the investors also obtain the benefits of savings of such costs by simply buying units of a mutual
fund scheme rather than by investing themselves in large numbers of securities.
Tax Advantage
There are mutual fund schemes like ELSS on which investors can get tax benefit. There is double tax benefit by investing in
these schemes. On one hand, the taxable income of investors is reduced to the amount invested in these schemes considering the
maximum limit allowed for thisby tax regulations.
Convenient Administration
Various types of risks are involved in case of stock market products like risk of bad deliveries, delay in payments and other
documentations etc. But the investor is really relaxed if he is investing in mutual funds schemes and such kind of administration
becomes relatively easier forthe investors.
Administrative Costs
As we all know that the money collected in a mutual fund scheme is managed by professional managers popularly known as
Asset Management Companies (AMC) and a huge amount is paid to AMC for its expert services, these expenses are a fixed
charge on the total value of funddespite its performance. Similarly, a lot of payment is made to other service providers.
Over Diversification
It is good that mutual funds are focused towards a diversified portfolio. But many times over diversification leads to poor
performance of the fund. If majority of the securities included in theportfolio of the scheme are underperforming, then the benefit
of selection of a few securities is neutralized and the value of total assets of the fund reduced gradually. Therefore, over
diversification may result into distraction of investors towards mutual fund schemes.
No Insurance
The performance of mutual fund has been found to be blend a underperformance and over performance. Many a times,
mutual funds are underperforming than the other investment avenues. Under these conditions, there is way out to cover the risk or
get such insured. The investors invest in mutual fund to reduce the risk by diversified portfolios. But if the returns from mutual
fund scheme become risky, there is no tool provided by any bank or financial institution to cover such risk.
Trading Blocks
Many times various trading blocks are imposed by stock exchanges to trade in mutual fund schemes which reduce the
attraction towards investment in mutual funds schemes. These trading blocs can be in the form restricted trading hours or in other
forms as well.
According to industry data, the numbers of investors in mutual funds in India is around 30 million, which represents less than
1.5-2% of the population. Interestingly, other related financial statistics (see below) demonstrate just where and why the potential
for the Indian market remains so positive.
AMFI’s Mutual Funds Sahi Hai campaign is aimed at making mutual funds less intimidating and part of everyday
conversation and bringing them into the consideration set of savers and investors, who have traditionally shown a preference for
bank deposits and physical assets.
Further, as part of the campaign, AMFI has a microsite, www.mutualfundssahi.com, available in English and Hindi, where
investors can find detailed information about mutual funds and also locate their nearest mutual fund office and mutual fund
distributors.
The campaign has hit the ground running. Increase in awareness has helped the industry add more than 5 million new
investors between March 2017 and June 2018.
Other data statistics too vouch for the campaign’s success. Compared with March 2017, the average AUM, as on June 2018,
was up 28%, while retail AUM was up 39%. The total number of folios saw a growth of 35%, while the monthly SIP contribution
jumped 74%.
Source: AMFI
Research
With the success of the mass media campaign, the focus has now turned to on-ground outreachprograms.
AMFI has tied up with a leading media house to launch ‘Jan Nivesh’. An initiative to educate, inspire and encourage Indians
to change their financial habits and create wealth smartly by investing regularly in mutual funds, Jan Nivesh aims to make every
citizen an equal participantin India’s economic growth story. Along with millions of TV viewers, the Jan Nivesh initiative will also
reach out to over 50,000 people on-ground through over 200 events in over 100 citiesand towns.
AMFI will also very soon launch the next leg of the mass media campaign. In the upcoming campaign, which continues
under the ‘Mutual Funds Sahi Hai’ banner, AMFI’s objective is to reach out to the savers who still prefer bank deposits and
introduce them to fixed income funds. The campaign will also communicate to the investor the nuances of mutual fund investing,
whileextolling the benefits of being invested for longer term, especially when markets are volatile.
There is a long way to go, considering only 1.5% of Indian population invests in mutual funds.
Fig 15
Source: - Crisil Digital Evolution Article August 2018
Fig 16 Assets Managed by the Indian Mutual Fund Industry have Decreased from Rs. 25.43 Trillion in May 2019 to Rs. 24.28
Trillion in May 2020. That Represents a 4.51% Decrease in Assets Over May 2019
Three-in-One Deal
Insurance:
Life insurance cover provided by ULIPs is one of the primary benefits. By investing in a ULIP one can protect their family
from uncertain events an ensure that the family is well taken care ofin the case of untimely death of the insured individual.
Financial Goals:
Another benefit that is provided by ULIP is its ability to generate wealth through investment in equity and debt assets.
Investors can choose to invest in ULIP to achieve their long term goals. They can choose from debt, equity or balance option
according to their risk profile, need and investment time horizon. There is a compulsory lock-in period of five years in ULIPs.
Tax Benefits:
Premium paid for an ULIP are eligible for tax deductions under section 80C ---------------------------- According to Income
tax act ‘1961., The maximum deduction that is allowed under this section is RS. 1,50,000. On maturity, the return from the policy
are exempted from income tax under section10(10D).
Flexibility is provided by ULIPs to choose either the sum assured or the premium based on your needs. Flexibility of
increasing your investment portfolio through top ups are also provided byULIPs.
Transparency:
Value of an investment , the charge structure and expected rate of returns, for the full tenure of policy are shared before you
purchase a product.It is always advised to know about the productbefore investing your money into it.
Spread of Risk:
ULIPs provides you the benefit of market-linked growth without any actual participation in thestock market. A fund manager
is provided to you who will track your investments and at the same time you have the flexibility to change your funds as you
progress with the plans.
Tax Benefits:
The premiums that are to be paid towards a policy are exempted from the tax under section 80C.
Insurance Cover:
Mortality cover is provided by ULIPs, they work in order to safeguard the funds of policy holder, if the policy holder dies
unexpectedly then the nominees can make a claim for the assured sum.
Top-Ups:
Excess money can be invested by the investors through a period of top ups that are provided bu the ULIPS, it is lead to tax
deductions as well as tax exemptions so that the premium does not exceed 10% of the assured sum.
Market Fluctuations:
A lower amount of returns are generally anticipated in the initial years due to the market fluctuations, therefore if you are
willing to invest into ULIPs for a short term then it will not bebeneficial for you.
Lock-in Period:
There is a lock-in period of five years during which the withdrawl of money cannot be done and it is also not sure that the
fund invested will increase, it is possible that a lower amount of money is received after the lock-in period.
Debt Funds:
Under these kind of funds, investors invest in debt instruments such as : Corporate bonds, debentures and government bonds.
Medium and slow risk is carried bythese instruments whilethe result associated with them are moderate.
Liquidity Funds:
Liquidity funds are for meeting short term financial goals.These types of ULIP planpark investors fund in highly liquid
money market instruments such as treasury bills, certificates ofdeposits
Balanced Funds:
In this, Balance is maintained between the debt and the equity market in terms of premium to minimise the risk for the
investors.
Types of ULIPS
The charge of mortality in type 1 ULIP keeps reducing every year as the risk is reduced. The riskmis the difference between
the accumulated fund value and sum assured under a certain policy. It can also be said that the amount an insurance company pays
from its own pocket in thecase of death of the policy holder.
Mortality rate is also considered with every policy year because the risk of death increases with increasing age.
Flexibility:
ULIPs are very flexible for the policy holder. There is an option to switch between different funds to match the changing
needs of people, there is also a facility to partially withdraw thefunds but it is subject to some special charges and conditions.
Why to Invest in ULIP?
Transparency:
There is a positive point about the ULIP plans is that they are extremely transparent financial instrument. It is unlike the past
policies where the things were not told properly to the policy holder, there is no hidden charge levied, it is also easy to understand
ULIP NAV to historicalreturns.
Liquidity:
ULIPs are a liquid financial instrument, they also facilitates the partial withdrawals of the funds to meet the uncertain events
or emergencies. ULIP NAV of each fund is generally displayed on the website of the company; it helps to align the investment and
insurance cover with overall needs.
Reality is that the ULIPs have been significantly changed, the investors may not be aware of the fact that IRDAI in 2010 has
brought down the annual charges to 3% , for the first 10years of the holding period and extra 2.25% in the case of holding it for
more than 10 year. Mortality and morbidity charges are excluded from this, the fund management charges have also come down to
1.35%. This has made ULIPs affordable.
Funds are invested in equity market for those investors that have high appetite of bearing the risks; those who want the risk to
be low may invest in debt market based ULIPs. ULIP Plans also gives an option to switch from debt to equity market and vice
versa according to the riskappetite of the investors.
In the case of ULIPs , if the insured person dies during the policy term, ULIPs pay either the full amount of life cover or the
Additional cash requirements during some emergencies or uncertain situations can be taken care of by partial withdrawal of
the funds while there are some restrictions on clubbing the two riderstogether.
ULIPS came into existence from 1960 onwards and it is popular in many countries of theworld.
Unit Trust Of India offered the Unit Linked Insurance Plans(ULIP) in 1971. Out of the premiums paid by the investors some
amount is kept aside for the life cover and balanceinvested in units.
The guidelines for the ULIPs were notified by IRDA on 21st December, 2005 in India
ULIP is a fund that is market related where the premiums that are paid by the investor are invested in various fundsin debt
and equity market.According to the selected funds the returns may vary from person to person. The costs that are being invested
are purely transparent, the investment that is made by the company is known by the investor and therefore he can keep a drack by
the ULIP NAV although the company monitors the invested funds.
Flexibility that is provided is greater in ter,ms of premium paid that is to be invested, it means that the premium holiday is
also possible. The investor can invest the surplus money in the forms of top-ups which will increase his investment in either debt
or equity market.
ULIP policies provide various advantages such as life protection, capital gains, mortality rate, flexibility, life cover,
investment options, transparency etc.
UNIT LINKED INSURANCE PLANS(ULIP) is considered to be as life insurance solution that provides the investors with
risk protection and flexibility in investment. The instrument by which the investors can monitor the growth of their invested funds
are known to be as : NAV(Net AssetValue). The value of policy depends upon the assets that are underlying at that time.
Invested amount , that is paid as premium after deducting for all charges mrket.and premium forrisk under all the policies.
Mortality Charges-
Mortality charges are those charges to be insured against the life cover which depends upon various factors such as: amount
of coverage, age, state of health etc. These charges depend uponprimarily the age
Surrender Charges-
The charges that are deducted for the premature, partial or full encashment of units is known tobe as the surrender charges.
ULIP NAV is more understood on per unit basis in financial sense. It refers to the net value ofassets lying in the firm
It can also be said as:
Market value of funds current assets, value of current assets and any accrued income is includedin ULIP NAV.
The liabilities that are included in the ULIP NAV are: management charges, , current liabilities,provisions and service tax.
To reach at the value of a single unit of ULIP NAV. Whole funds are divided by the number ofunits existing on the date of
valuation.
Aviva I- Growth-
This is a non participating unit linked insurance plan that is participating savings life insurance plan that offers 3 investment
fund options and 3 policy terms. The total charge of the policy is as low as 1% and the insured person has an option to redirect
premium to different funds.
The age group of the respondents was taken between 20-30, 30-40, above 40.
63.2% of the respondents were of age group between 20-30 means most of the respondents are youngsters and they are very
much keen on investing in financialservices and also they are ready to take risk.
Another 20% of the respondents were between the age group of 30-40 and they are interested in taking medium level of risk
while investing in the financial services.
16.8% of the respondents were of age group above 40 and hence they are less interested in taking risks while investing in
financial services.
The time period during which the responses were collected between may and June 2020 during the situation of COVID-19
outbreak in the country.
Most of the respondents belong to two states basically New Delhi and Uttar Pradesh.
Fig 27 Gender
52.8% of the respondents were Male.
46.4% of the respondents were Female.
Rest were preferred not to say their gender.
Monthly salary of 44% of the respondents were earning less than INR10,000
23.2 % of the employees were earning between INR 20,000 TO INR 40,000
16% of the respondents were earning between INR 40,000 TO INR 60,000
Other 16.8% of the respondents were earning above INR 60,000 per month
Fig 29 Liquidity
While scaling the investments options available in the market the Respondents while investing in financial services almost 61
respondents (48.8%) give 4 out of 5 as givingimportance of liquidity while investing in financial services available.
While 34 of the total respondents (27.2) were given utmost important for liquidity while selecting a given investment options
available.
This data proves that for most of the respondents were giving preferences for liquidityaspect while investing.
As for sure liquidity is given a preference because the nature of most of the financial services are uncertain in nature as they
depend on numerous aspects an also a person whois investing can be in requirement of money at any point of time and for this
liquidity is given a preference.
Fig 30 Flexibility
In terms of flexibility aspect while selecting the investment criteria 71 of the total respondents (almost 57%) gives 4 out of 5
rating for this as they want flexibility featurein their investment option.
While 31 of the total respondents (almost 25%) gives total preference to flexibility aspectwhile selecting a investment criteria.
This clearly gives us the idea that most of the investors prefer being flexible in terms of investment options like their money
invested is flexible enough to adapt the changes pertaining in the market and it is less affected by this.
This data clearly proves that almost 80% of the respondents give preference to flexibility aspect while opting an investment
option.
Considering another aspect which is kept in mind by most of the investors, here almost 59 of the total respondents (47.2% )
gives 4 out of 5 importance to taxability of incomeaspect while selecting a investment criteria
While almost 39 of the total respondents gives 5 out of 5 importance to taxability aspect while selecting an investment criteria
In total almost 80% of the respondents gives importance to taxability aspect
As we can see that most of the investors now a day’s look forward to reduce their taxable income by taking the income tax
deduction under section 80 c and 10 (10) d.
As this is one of the greatest factor which lure the investors towards investing theirmoney in financial services.
In terms of Ease of choice aspect almost 50% of the respondents gives 4 out 5 to this as they don’t want to do so much of
paperwork and also they don’t have that much of freetime for completing these formalities.
Most of the work now a day is done on online mode so most of the respondents prefer to opt that investment option which
involves less paper work.
Almost 33% of the total respondents these 5 out of 5 to this aspect as this tells us that they gives very much importance to the
ease of choice factor.
Very less respondents ignore this aspect so we can conclude from the responses that Ease of choice is a great reason while the
investor chooses any investment option
Return on investment is one of the most important aspect as this one the sole reason whythe investor is interested to invest in
financial services.
Almost 87% of the total respondents give preference to return on investment criteria asinvestor gives sole importance to this.
But the problem with such options which gives higher rate of return on investment includes high level of risks involved in such
investment options.
As most of the respondents were in the age group between 20-30 years of age so in such age group one is interested in taking a
level risk for earning better level of investment.
While in the latter part of the age group which is above 40 is less interested in investing such options which carry high level of
risk with better return on investment but they want less level of risk with slow and steady level of return due to increase in the
level of responsibilities.
Cost of investment refers to the amount of money which is incurred in that particularinvestment options
As a investor one will surely look into this aspect, almost 45% of the respondents gives 4 out of 5 to this aspect of investment
that cost of investment matters to them.
Almost 32% of the total respondents gives complete 5 out of 5 importance to cost ofinvestment criteria.
As a investor one will surely have a fixed sum of money which he want to invest therefore the cost incurred for opting that
investment options.
Safety of the sum invested means the investor will surely want a safety of the amount of money invested by him as while
desiring for a level of return he wants at least he gets back the amount of money he has invested if in case his investment is not
able to providehim with handsome amount of return.
Almost 44% of the respondents gives 4 out of 5 importance to this aspect of investment
While 41% of the total respondents gives 5 out 5 importance to this criteria means they gives complete importance for the
safety of the sum invested by them in the financial services.
In total 84% of the respondents prefers to get safety of the sum insured by them which they have invested in the financial
services
If a respondent has to choose between two investment options namely mutual funds andULIP and the criteria will on the basis
of liquidity then most of the respondents are selecting to invest their money in mutual funds.
Reasons for this selection cab ne that both mutual funds an ULIPS are long term investments and the best part of mutual fund
is one can exit them whenever he or she wishes to and another important aspect of mutual fund is that investor also has the
optionto make partial withdrawals at any moment of time.
In ULIPS the investor has to pay all the premiums in due time but in case the investor stop making timely premiums that
ULIPS can prove to be a costlier deal and it even might lapse the policy and on the other hand investor can also lose all money.
Almost 86% of the respondents thinks that on the basis of cost of investment Mutual funds are a better option as compared to
ULIPs.
The reasons for such returns can be many, however according to the rules now the higher charges for ULIPs have been
removed in 2010 only and even some of the ULIP options are very much flexible and they even give a good level of
competition to the mutual fundschemes.
But another point of concern is that most of the ULIPS are being done omnline now a days as same as mutual funds schemes
are processed but this thing might not be in knowledge of the respondents and as compared to mutual fund companies , some
of theULIPs are way cheaper
On the other hand if a investor is wants to invest in equity oriented funds than the chargesincur by ULIPS are lesser as some of
the equity oriented mutual fund scheme a charges almost 2.5% while on the other hand ULIP charges up to 1.35%.
In this aspect of investment most of the respondents chooses mutual funds in place of ULIPs as almost 89% of the investors
selects mutual funds in the basis of ease of choice.
While investing in the mutual funds, investor is only required to fulfill the online requirements and formalities are done then a
investor is free with all such work but whileinvesting ULIPs it also provide life insurance cover so for that purpose even after
fulfilling all online formalities one has to complete some offline formalities also.
Mutual funds also offer a wider choice to investors. Those looking for stable growth can go for large-cap funds and the more
adventurous investors can invest in mid-cap and small-cap schemes.
Insurers offer a wide bouquet of ULIP funds, but mostly the choice is between equity,debt and liquid funds.
In terms of flexibility factor, most of the respondents prefers mutual funds as compared to ULIPs as they thinks that mutual
funds provides them with higher level of flexibility ascompared to ULIPs.
He can easily shift from a non per-forming scheme to a better fund. He can exit anytime he wants or remain invested for the
long term. He can make partial withdrawals or make additional investments without any problem while in ULIPs it’s like
investing in a close ended scheme for a very long period of time and if the investor is not abet p payback the premium
installments then his policy might even lapse and his money is also lost.
On the other hand ULIPs also allows to invest some additional amount in the current plan and offers only some level of
flexibility as compared to mutual funds.
The investor ony has the option to switch from equity to debt scheme or equity to debt schemes and for this they don’t have to
face any additional tax liability.
In terms of return on investment respondents thins that mutual funds gives better rate of returns as compared to ULIPs and
only 24% of the respondents thinks in a different way.
The reasons for these can be that while investing in ULIPs not all 100% of the money is invested in some type of funds only
60-70% og the amount in invested in it while rest isfor insurance cover therefore the chances for better returns are less in it.
While investing in mutual funds almost 100% of the amount is invested so in that there are chances of getting a better rate of
returns as compared to ULIPs .
There is small gap in terms of return on investment in both option as mutual funds offers3-4% better returns than ULIPs so in
terms of investing in long runs mutual funds will always pay better.
Fig 41 What will you Prefer for Taxability of Income from Investment
In terms of taxability aspect most of the respondents thinks that mutual funds are betteroption than ULIPs.
The reasons for this can be that ost of the respondents are between the age group of 20-30means they are youngsters and their
monthly income of most of the respondents is between 10,000 – 30,000 and they investing a limited amount in mutual funds
while the nce who have responded that ULIP are better investment options in terms of taxability aspect is concerned and those
who are regular investors in mutual funds and ULIPs schemes know that when u are investing a handsome amount in mutual
funds then the returns on the mutual fund investments are charged heavily while the income from the ULIP schemes are
completely tax free.
Therefore, ULIPs will always prove to be better options for investment in terms of taxability aspect is concerned as compared
to mutual funds.
In terms safety of the sum invested the respondents thinks that mutual funds are better options than ULIPs as they feel that
their invested amount is more secured and safe while investing in mutual funds as compared to ULIPs.
The mutual fund companies generally provide a platform through which the investor can have a track on his portfolio through
which hey can monitor the performance of their funds, they have a complete information that where there fund is invested and
in what amount it is invested
ULIPs are also tracked abut they are not shown in very detailed manner and very few of the investors and managers know that
which of the ULIPs scheme is doing best currently in the market.
Fig 43 Time Horizon in which you have to Achieve your Financial Goal ? how long to Invest your Money?
In term of time horizon is concerned means up to how many years a investor want to invest his money in financial services,
most of the respondents feels that between 2-5 years of time frame they are ready to invest and will be sufficient for them to
achieve their financial goal.
33.6% of the respondents feels that while investing for a period of 6-10 years will a time horizon n which they feels
comfortable to invest and this will fulfill their financial goal expectation.
While very few of the respondents feels that they will be investing in such services more than 19 years time frame
In terms of most preferred form of investment most of the respondents feels mutual funds are far better option to invest as
compared to other available options like equity trading, fixed deposits, post office savings or bank savings.
As all other investment options available no one gives that much benefits and amount of returns in investment as given by
mutual funds in various aspects.
Findings
During my study for comparative analysis between Mutual funds and ULIPs on various aspects namely Liquidity, Flexibility,
Taxability of income, Ease of choice, Returns on investment, Cost of investment, Safety of sum invested and also understands
the perspective of the customers on various aspects and I got to know that out of 7 aspects of my study 6 factors proves to be
in favor of mutual funds that mutual funds proves to be a better option to invest.
Only on one aspect which was taxability of income that the income from ULIPs plans are completely tax free but the return on
investment in mutual funds are highly taxable by the government authorities.
One thing which I got to know is that on some other aspects ULIPs give tough competition mutual funds but most of the
investors are not aware of many facts and features of ULIPs as they know about mutual funds.
Recommendations
One of the recommendation which I want to give to the ULIPs companies and schemes that they need to create that much level
of awareness among the investors as the investors know about mutual funds as I felt there is high level of lack of awareness
among investors with regard to ULIPs schemes.
Government bodies should also promote such ULIPs schemes as the motive behind doing all the earnings through ULIPs are
completely tax free is to promote the investments in such schemes and for this government is also need to take the initiative.
Name
Age
Gender
Monthly salary
< 10000
20000 to 39999
40000 to 59999
60000 and above
Liquidity
Flexibility
Taxability of income
Ease of choice
Returns on investment
Cost of investment
Safety of sum invested
What will you prefer for liquidity?
Mutual fund
ULIP
Time Horizon in which you have to achieve your financial goal? How long do you Plan to invest your money?
Under 2 years
2-5 years
6-10 years
11-15 years
Over 15 years