Moving to a Modern

API Gateway:
A Technology Comparison
 2

Table of Contents
3 Introduction

4 API Gateways: Essential Capabilities for Today’s Challenges

7 Comparing Today’s Most Prevalent API Gateway Solutions

12 Solo Gloo Edge: The Leading Next-Generation, Cloud-Native API Gateway

 3

Introduction
API gateways have been critical components of
applications for years, but legacy solutions are
showing their age.
As organizations increase their reliance on microservices and container-based architectures,
they’re finding that legacy API gateways fall short in regard to scalability, traffic management,
security, and observability. To support the evolving needs of modern enterprises, API gateways
need to evolve in areas such as Kubernetes support, microservices, multi-cloud deployments,
and cloud-native innovation.
This ebook explores the defining characteristics of a modern API gateway and uses that
framework to compare and contrast the current supporting technologies.
 4

API Gateways:
Essential Capabilities for Today’s Challenges
So, what are the defining features of a modern API gateway built for the rigors of today’s microservices journeys? At Solo.io, we’re trusted
experts in helping enterprises adopt, secure, and operate innovative cloud-native technologies. In working with our clients to deploy
future-ready API infrastructure from the edge to service mesh, we’ve seen that a truly modern API gateway has several key characteristics:

Built on Supports today’s architectures, Extensible across operating

Envoy Proxy future-proofed for innovation environments, customizable
with any language

Capable of zero-trust Built-in Internet scalability

security and advanced and high availability, with Integrates seamlessly into
threat prevention lower resource use DevOps/GitOps workflows

Let’s take a closer look at each of these areas.

 5

Modern Built on Envoy Proxy

Built to solve Internet-scale API challenges, Envoy Proxy is the foundation of next-generation
API gateway architectures. Leveraging an open-source community consisting of more than 300
contributing companies, Envoy has emerged as the de-facto data-plane standard for cloud-
native applications and APIs. Envoy abstracts the network, providing infrastructure-as-code
flexibility, while delivering traffic management, security, and observability in a platform-agnostic
manner. This foundation enables a modern API gateway that improves security, reliability, filtering,
transformations, and routing. A modern API gateway must also provide higher-level services such
as federation, high availability, load balancing, failover, zero-trust security, tracing, and metrics
gathering. Envoy Proxy delivers industry-leading capabilities in these areas as well.

Architecture Supports today’s architectures, future-proofed for innovation

Today’s API gateways have to support both traditional architectures (including monolithic applications
and VMs) as well as newer, cloud-native services and containers, and serverless workloads. In
addition, a modern API gateway has to accommodate the latest technologies, including RESTful APIs,
gRPC, and GraphQL. Many API gateways can support legacy architectures, but a modern solution will
have the flexibility to accommodate emerging innovations and standards.

Extensible across operating environments,

Flexibility customizable with any language
Modern API gateways allow organizations to “extend” the architecture with new capabilities in a
language-independent manner via WebAssembly—with the ability to decode, interpret, and filter wire
protocol formats. This helps to route traffic more efficiently and allows offloading of tasks from other
services. Modern API gateways can also easily add DLP and WAF capabilities (usually at no extra
cost), while incorporating external authentication servers, rate-limiting servers, and request/response
transformation and translation. Legacy API gateways simply can’t provide the same level of flexibility.
 6

Security Capable of zero-trust security and advanced threat prevention

A zero-trust security model differs from the traditional perimeter-trust approach by requiring
strict identity verification at “call-time” for every user and service request, as well as encryption
of traffic between services. Modern API gateways support a zero-trust model, including invoking
external authentications, applying network encryption (TLS/mTLS), and filtering requests with a
web application firewall (WAF)— as well as combining features to support Forrester’s ZTX and
Gartner’s CARTA strategies.

Scalability Built-in Internet scalability and high availability, with lower resource use
As the volume of API calls increases and infrastructure and microservice applications grow
more complex, it becomes harder to connect, secure, and observe network traffic. Legacy API
gateway architectures that use NGINX, Lua, Java, and other outdated technologies are too
resource intensive, lack the native distributed architecture, and don’t deliver the performance to
support medium- and large-scale applications. Also, legacy API gateways often rely on supporting
technologies (such as operational databases) that can become single points of failure and ultimately
drive up costs and complexity.

Cloud-native Ops Integrates seamlessly into DevOps/GitOps workflows

Modern API gateways allow developers and operators to use declarative CRDs, usually as part of
a DevOps/GitOps process, to manage traffic, enforce security policy, and configure observability.
Dynamic updates without restarts, canary deployments, and federated configurations should be
native components of a cloud-ready solution. DevOps teams need to deploy and manage an API
gateway, often in concert with a service mesh, to programmatically manage application networking—
eliminating the need to separately access and manage individual resources and services.
 7

Comparing Today’s Most

Prevalent API Gateway
Solutions
Given these criteria for a modern, future-proofed API gateway
solution, how do the most commonly deployed technologies
stack up? What are their strengths and shortcomings in the
face of today’s networking challenges? Here’s a closer look.
 8

Hardware-based load HARDWARE-BASED LOAD BALANCERS

balancers Built on Envoy Proxy and

other current technologies No.
Examples: F5 BIG-IP, Citrix ADC
Hardware load balancers—or application delivery
controllers (ADCs)—are legacy data center Built to support today’s architectures No. No understanding of
technologies for traffic management at the microservices and Kubernetes.
perimeter. These legacy products are expensive,
don’t accommodate cloud-native architectures,
and can introduce single points of failure. In Extensible across different architectures
No.
addition, their configuration is typically managed
by a separate network team (in other words,
they aren’t DevOps-friendly). If you are migrating
Capable of zero-trust security
workloads to the cloud, you may want to transition No. Not designed for zero-trust architectures.
from this decades-old technology.

Built-In Internet scalability

No. Not scalable on-demand and
and High-Availability
introduces single points of failure.

DevOps and GitOps ready No. Configuration is typically managed by a

separate network team (not DevOps-friendly).
 9

Web server-based load WEB SERVER-BASED LOAD BALANCERS

balancers Built on Envoy Proxy and

other current technologies No.
Examples: NGINX
NGINX is the most commonly used technology
in this category. It acts as a load balancer and Built to support today’s architectures ?
Limited.
reverse proxy for HTTP and other protocols.
These technologies can be reliable for static
content and ingress and egress, but this is another ?
aging solution that isn’t built for highly dynamic Limited. NGINX alone isn’t a suitable API
Extensible across different architectures gateway and requires add-ons such as
environments (requiring hot restarts, periodically
NGINX+, NGINX Controller, NGINX App Protect,
dropping connections, and other issues). If you and NGINX Amplify to support core capabilities
are deploying a dynamic cloud infrastructure, for API management.
implementing a zero-trust security model, want
a declarative CRD-based configuration model,
or require advanced capabilities such as DLP ?
Capable of zero-trust security Limited. Not designed for zero-trust
and WAF as part of the core product (and not architectures.
an expensive add-on), web server-based load
balancers won’t meet your needs.
Built-In Internet scalability 
and High-Availability Yes.

DevOps and GitOps ready ?

Limited. Often requires additional products.
 10

NGINX-based API NGINX-BASED API GATEWAYS

gateways Built on Envoy Proxy and

other current technologies No. Built on NGINX.
Examples: Kong Gateway
While NGINX can provide the proxy foundation for
an API gateway, it requires significant additional
Built to support today’s ?
architectures Limited. Mostly supports older architectures.
functionality. Several API gateway providers have
taken this architectural approach. One example is
Kong Gateway, an API gateway that leverages NGINX, ?
Lua (LuaJIT and LuaEngine), and a persistent data Possible with plugins and modules, but with limitations.
Extensible across different Kong Gateway is a Lua application running in NGINX and
store. The primary issue with this approach is that it
architectures is distributed with OpenResty which is a module bundle
requires Lua expertise to implement and customize that extends the Lua-NGINX module. Lua and LuaJIT are
Kong Gateway. In addition, implementing API gateways outdated technologies, with the most recent release of
with outdated scripting languages has significant LuaJIT in May 2017.

drawbacks with tail latency, debugging, scaling, and

highly dynamic environments. Kong Gateway also
incorporates a persistent data store using PostgresSQL
?
Capable of zero-trust security Limited. Note: Kong Gateway and Kong Mesh (Kuma)
or Cassandra, which increases operational complexity utilize different architectures and data planes.
and expense. It can be run in a DB-less mode, but that
approach results in feature loss and degradation.
Built-In Internet scalability
!
Not without Complexity. As Kong scales, it scales the
and High-Availability ingress controller separately from the data plane. For each
new gateway, Kong also gets a new ingress controller.

!
Not without Complexity. Not designed for DevOps/
GitOps. Requires a persistent data store (such as
DevOps and GitOps ready PostgresSQL or Cassandra) that increases operational
complexity and cost. New DB-less configuration is
available, but doesn’t support all features resulting in
feature loss and degradation.
 11

Full life-cycle API FULL LIFE-CYCLE API MANAGEMENT PRODUCTS

management products Built on Envoy Proxy and

other current technologies No. Gateway is built on NGINX with Java.
Examples: Apigee
Full life-cycle API management products such as
Apigee emerged as the need to share APIs across Built to support today’s architectures ?
Limited. Mostly supports older architectures.
organizations grew along with the need to better
manage, document, and monetize API traffic. Most
products in this category were developed during the ?
Extensible across different architectures
era of monolithic application architectures and VMs Very limited. Architected for public APIs. Other
scenarios complicated to support.
and have been slow to adapt to cloud architectures.
In addition, they tend to suffer from performance and
latency issues due to their reliance on Java-based
Capable of zero-trust security
architectures and other dated platform technologies. No.
Finally, they have limited ability to integrate into
DevOps/GitOps workflows and come with high
operational costs. !
Not without Complexity. Monolithic
Built-In Internet scalability application architecture with limited innovation
and High-Availability on core platform. Requires Cassandra for
persistent data store. Performance and
latency issues due to the use of outdated
technologies.

DevOps and GitOps ready

No.
Solo Gloo Edge
The Leading Next-Generation, Cloud-Native API Gateway
Solo Gloo Edge is a Kubernetes-native, next-generation API gateway built on Envoy Proxy to manage, secure, and
observe traffic at the edge. Gloo Edge configures the behavior of the Envoy Proxy data plane to ensure secure
application networking and policy-based traffic management, while gathering metrics to improve observability.

Representative Products Gloo Edge Apigee Kong Gateway NGINX+ F5

Modern Built on Envoy Proxy and other current technologies Envoy-Based NOT Envoy-based

Supports RESTful APIs, gRPC,

Architecture Built to support today’s architectures
and GraphQL
Limited to no support for RESTful APIs, gRPC, and GraphQL

Built in support for DLP and

WAF. Extend capabilities in Limited DLP and WAF. Can’t extend capabilities in language-independent
Flexibility Extensible across operating environments
language-independent manner manner via WebAssembly
via WebAssembly It’s just time to
move from this
Designed for zero-trust Not designed Not designed rigid, legacy
Security Capable of zero-trust security
architectures for zero-trust
Limited
for zero-trust technology
Does not scale ingress
Performance and
controller separately
latency issues due to
Scalability Built-In Internet scalability and High-Availability Highly Scalable
the use of outdated
from the data plane Highly Scalable
leading to resource
technologies
issues
Designed for DevOps and Not designed for DevOps/GitOps. Requires a Not designed for
Cloud-native Ops DevOps and GitOps ready
GitOps. Configured via CRDs persistent data store for fully functional product DevOps/GitOps

Not all API gateways are created equal.

Ideally, the API gateway sits in the data plane and manages “north-south” traffic through services such as security,
reliability, filtering, transformations, and routing. Working collectively, API gateways can provide higher-level services
such as high availability, load balancing, failover, zero-trust security, tracing, and metrics gathering.
Next-generation API gateways are also purpose-built for highly dynamic, ephemeral environments such as Kubernetes
and incorporate the design principles of declarative configuration, decentralized ownership, and self-service
collaboration. In addition, next-gen gateways use declarative CRDs, enabling seamless integration into GitOps workflow.

Ready to learn more about Solo Gloo Edge and why your next API Gateway needs to be Envoy-based?
Find more information and further analysis on the different API gateways www.solo.io.