Obligation and Contracts Part 4
Obligation and Contracts Part 4
5. Has the debtor the right to recover what he has paid to the creditor before the arrival of the
period agreed upon? Explain.
Yes. If the debtor has paid to the creditor before the arrival of the period agreed upon, he can still
recover it or he has the right to recover what he has paid. Since the period agreed hasn’t arrived yet and
the debtor has paid early and unexpectedly, he can still recover it but once the period has arrived he can
no longer recover it.
6. If an obligation does not state a period for its performance, has a party the right to ask a
court to fix a period or the duration thereof? Explain.
No. The court has nothing to do in fixing a period for the two parties. If an obligation does not
state a period for its performance, it means that the two parties haven’t settled a period of time for the
debtor to fulfill his obligation. The court has no right to make or decide a contract for the both parties.
7. Give the cases when the obligee can demand the performance of an obligation even before
the arrival of the period agreed upon.
When the debtor is insolvent – He cannot or unable to pay his debts as they mature.
When the debtor does not furnish guaranties or securities promised – He fails to deliver or give
what he promised in the agreement.
When guaranties or securities given have been impaired or have disappeared – If the guaranties
have been damaged and lost by the debtor, the obligation also becomes demandable.
When the debtor violates an undertaking – If he made an action contrary to the agreement or
contract.
When the debtor attempts to abscond – If the debtor run away or escape his obligation.
8. Mr. D borrowed P10,000 from Mr. C at 15% interest per annum payable on December 31,
2020. Can Mr. D (the debtor) require Mr. C (the creditor) to accept payment before
December 31, 2020? Explain your answer.
Yes, as long as that Mr. D pays the money together with interest, within the window that Mr. C
gave. Mr. C will not complain and will humbly accept the payment. Mr. D can give down payment or
pay the full debt even before the set period of time.
9. Mr. D binds himself to give P10,000 to Mr. C upon the death of the father of Mr. D. Is the
obligation of Mr. D conditional or one with a period? Explain your answer.
The obligation of Mr. D is conditional since the death of his father is unforeseeable. It is Mr. D’s
father’s obligation but unfortunately he died and the obligation was passed to his son.
10. Mr. D obtained a loan from Mr. C in the amount of P50,000, payable on September 15,
2020. As security for his debt, Mr. D mortgaged his car in favor of Mr. C. The car,
however, was substantially damaged without the fault of Mr. D. What rights, if any, does
Mr C have under the law? May Mr. C demand payment from Mr. D even before
September 15, 2020? Explain.
Mr. C must receive payment since Mr. D has obtained a loan from him. It is Mr. C’s right to
collect payment from Mr. D. Mr. C, as an obligee, can demand payment from Mr. D even before the
agreed period if the debtor has violated their agreement, tried to run away from him and if he’s insolvent.