Farm No 1 Iowa Mens Reformatory NR
Farm No 1 Iowa Mens Reformatory NR
1024-0018
(8-86)
DISTRIBUTION:
National Register property file
Nominating Authority (without nomination attachment)
NFS Form 10-900 OMB No. 10024-0018
(Oct. 1990)
1. Name of Property
2. Location
street & number County Trunk Highway E28 D not for publication n/a
state Iowa code county Jones code 105 zip code 52205
As the designated authority under the National Historic Preservation Act, as amended, I hereby certify that this 13 nomination
D request for determination of eligibility meets the documentation standards for registering properties in the National Register of
Historic Places and meets the procedural and professional requirements set forth in 36 CFR Part 60. In my opinion, the property
TL! meets O does not meet the National Register criteria. I recommend that this property be considered significant
D nationally}._,_ statewide O locally. (D See continuation sheet for additional comments.)
^ T/T /
___-z^t^ c&-——. _____ /0 / z
I0J2.\
Signature of certifying official/Title Date
State Historical Society of Iowa
State of Federal agency and bureau
In my opinion, the property D meets D does not meet the National Register criteria. (D See continuation sheet for additional
comments.)
5. Classification
Ownership of Property Category of Property Number of Resources within Property
(Check as many boxes as apply) (Check only one box) (Do not include previously listed resources in the count.)
_na •
Miiniripfil Cnnnt'y f!nrr€''*t""f nn R none
roeries±1 in lotta.
$ Function or Use
Historic Functions Current Functions
(Enter categories from instructions) (Enter categories from instructions)
GOVERNMENT/correctional facility GOVERNMENT/correctional facility
AGRICULTURE/SUBSISTENCE/agricultural AGRICULTURE/STJBSISTENCE/a^ricultural
_____________________outbuilding ____________________outbuilding
7. Description
Architectural Classification Materials
(Enter categories from instructions) (Enter categories from instructions)
foundation.
walls ___ T.-fmARt-nnp
CONCRETE
roof
other
Narrative Description
(Describe the historic and current condition of the property on one or more continuation sheets.)
Farm No. 1, Iowa Men's Reformatory Jones Co. * IA
Name of Property County and State
8. Statement of Significance
Applicable National Register Criteria Areas of Significance
(Mark "x" in one or more boxes for the criteria qualifying the property (Enter categories from instructions)
for National Register listing.)
LAW
D F a commemorative property.
Acreage of Property
UTM References
(Place additional UTM references on a continuation sheet.)
Boundary Justification
(Explain why the boundaries were selected on a continuation sheet.)
Continuation Sheets
Maps
A Sketch map for historic districts and properties having large acreage or numerous resources.
Photographs
Additional items
(Check with the SHPO or FPO for any additional items)
Property Owner
(Complete this item at the request of SHPO or FPO.)
Paperwork Reduction Act Statement: This information is being collected for applications to the National Register of Historic Places to nominate
properties for listing or determine eligibility for listing, to list properties, and to amend existing listings. Response to this request is required to obtain
a benefit in accordance with the National Historic Preservation Act, as amended (16 U.S.C. 470 et seq.).
Estimated Burden Statement: Public reporting burden for this form is estimated to average 18.1 hours per response including time for reviewing
instructions, gathering and maintaining data, and completing and reviewing the form. Direct comments regarding this burden estimate or any aspect
of this form to the Chief, Administrative Services Division, National Park Service, P.O. Box 37127, Washington, DC 20013-7127; and the Office of
Management and Budget, Paperwork Reductions Projects (1024-0018), Washington, DC 20503.
NW Form 1MOO* 0MB Afpmn No. 10244011
7. Description
Located just west of the city limits of Anamosa and about 2000 feet west of the
Iowa Men's Reformatory, Farm No. 1 or the West Farm became the first penal farm
to operate at Anamosa. The approximately 84 acre farm lies in the south half of
the southwest quarter of section 3 in township 84 north, range 4 west. Its east
boundary runs along the west bank of Buffalo Creek, and the farm is placed west
of the Wapsipinicon River. A west extension of Cherry Street or County Trunk
Highway E28 forms its south and west boundaries while the north boundary runs
along the brow of the hill above the farmstead. Boundaries follow both man-made
and natural landmarks including a road, river bank, and brow of a hill. A long
gravel drive reaches the farmstead from CTH E28. The rural district focuses on
the farmstead and does not include all the lands originally associated with the
farm. These buildings are loosely clustered in an east-west linear direction
along the drive running along the base of the hillside and sit well away from the
prison farmer's dwelling and garage. The district encompasses three
noncontributing and seven contributing buildings including a dwelling, garage,
office, and seven agricultural outbuildings and the surrounding agricultural
lands.
The penal farm belongs to The Prison Farm Subtype (Ic) of the Auburn Penitentiary
Property Type (1) and the Municipal, County, and State Corrections Properties in
Iowa multiple property listing. The state utilized the limestone from the state
quarry to construct the agricultural outbuildings between 1912 and 1939. The
seven massive and simply constructed, solid masonry outbuildings display the
limited influence of the Romanesque Revival employed at the Iowa Men's
Reformatory District. This influence includes the heavy massing, texture of the
stone, and the window, door, and corner treatments. The three other resources
are frame and concrete block. The farm has undergone change. Several of the
original buildings at the farm have been replaced by others which also date well
before 1942. Alterations have occurred around some windows and doors, and the
wing of one building was replaced. Although the property continues to function
as a farm, as farm methods and the manner of processing products alter, interior
functions are shifting. However, interior spaces remain intact. Despite this
loss of integrity of material, design, and workmanship, the visual image of the
farm's grouping of massive stone buildings in the simplified interpretation of
the Romanesque Revival design remains impressive. This farm is also the earliest
and most intact example of Iowa's penal farms.
1 Specific references to Farm No. 1 and prison farms occur in section E and
F on the following pages: 23, 25-26, 29-31, 58-61, 65, 76-77, 81-82, 86-91, 104,
107-110, and 128.
N* Form 1MOO* J034OOT*
1) Earner's Dwelling
This small, one and a half story balloon frame, rectangular dwelling sits on a
random rubble, limestone foundation. Its narrow clapboards are sided with
aluminum. Asphalt shingle covers the gable roof. The slightly off-set front
entrance is located in the gable end facing east toward the farmstead and
Anamosa. The double hung, 1/1 windows are irregularly placed along the facade
and elevations. Its steep cornice returns and bay along the south elevation
compose the only remaining decorative elements except the centered, hip roof
porch which crosses part of the facade. Its floor is now concrete. The interior
contains a living room along the east side, a dining room, kitchen in the
original rear ell, a bedroom in the north ell on the first floor, and two
bedrooms on the second floor.
The relatively extensive alterations include the addition of aluminum siding and
the north wing and the replacement of the original, square, wood porch posts and
porch floor. Pine paneling has been recently added to the interior walls. The
rear porch along the elevation of the kitchen wing was enclosed. The date of
this resource remains unclear. An early photograph (Iowa Men's Reformatory n.d.)
identifies the dwelling as a simple bungalow often constructed between 1910 and
1935, the era of the farm's construction. Because of these extensive
alterations, the building is classified as noncontributing.
2) Garage
The masonry walls of the squarish, one story, molded cement block garage sit on
a poured concrete footing. Asphalt shingle covers its clipped gable roof resting
on 2x4 wood framing. Its steel frame, awning type windows are symmetrically
placed along its elevations. Lintels and sills are concrete, and two overhead
doors close the front, east entrances. Vertical siding closes the front and rear
gables. The floor is concrete, wood paneling covers the ceiling, and the walls
remain unfinished. The construction date of the building remains unclear. The
state erected cinder block buildings at the Iowa Men's Reformatory by the mid-
1920s and their construction continued into the 1940s. Although it remains
unaltered, it is classified as noncontributing since it may date after 1942.
3) South Barn
The barn sits on the hillside facing north to the drive. The solid masonry,
rough- and smooth- faced, ashlar limestone walls rest on a random rubble
foundation. A steel, intersecting gable roof covers the building. The building
is cross-shaped in plan. A center, three level section with front-facing gable
is flanked by two side-facing wings containing two levels. While smooth-faced
ashlar composes the original west two sections, the east portion is built of
rough-faced ashlar. Attached to the east side of the south barn, a steel roof,
open-sided animal shelter rests on the former, uphill stone foundation of the
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National
^ _.
Register
_. **m
of
.
Historic Places Fa™ ?°-*• Iow?
Men s Reformatory
Continuation Sheet Jones GO., u
7 4
Section number ___ Page ___
door flanked by two windows. The concrete silo attached to the building's
northwest corner no longer remains. Despite these alterations, the function,
basic shape, materials, and design remain recognizable.
4. North Barn
Placed along the base of the hillside, the main entrances of the two level,
rectangular barn open along the south elevation from the first level onto the
drive. The entrance to the second level is accessed directly off the hillside
along the north or rear elevation. Its rough-faced, coursed ashlar, limestone
walls rest on a random rubble foundation. A random rubble retaining walls runs
along the slope to the east and west of the barn. A galvanized metal, gable roof
covers the building. Openings are four light, hopper type windows. The wood
sliding doors were removed from the entrances. The entrance to the hay mow along
the east elevation was covered by a vertically sliding gate. Its track remains.
Lintels and sills are rough-faced, ashlar limestone while the quoins are smooth-
faced ashlar.
The second floor within the solid masonry barn is supported by sawn, square
timber posts, timber support members, and wood floor joists composed of multiple
2X8 lumber. Both floors remain open. The first level floor is concrete while
the second level floor is wood.
Construction of the north barn occurred about 1919 (Iowa Men's Reformatory n.d.
[photograph]; Osborne Association, Inc. 1938: 32). The barn originally served
as a dairy cattle barn with hay mow above. After the de-emphasis of dairy
farming at the reformatory in the 1970s, the first level became a machine shed.
Alterations include the replacement of stone with concrete lintels along the two
south entrances, removal of the doors, and alteration of the roofing material.
5. Barn Granary
Placed along the base of the hill south of the drive, the rectangular, masonry
barn faces north and uphill. Its single main entrance opens onto the drive from
the second level. The first level is directly accessed from the rear. The
barn's smooth-faced, coursed ashlar limestone walls stand on a random rubble
foundation. A steel, gable roof covers the building. Building details are
constructed of rough-faced ashlar stone. A single arched entrance composed of
heavy voussoirs is located in the center of the north facade while a row of four
smaller but similarly constructed entrances occur along the east end of the south
elevation. Additional square-headed doors and windows open the west elevation.
The small, sparsely placed windows emphasize the heavy massing of the building.
Doors and windows are emphasized with heavy stone lintels and sills, and their
sides are embellished by dentils. Entrances along the south and west are open
while a sliding wood door covers the main entrance. Quoins define the corners
of the building. The date block under the west gable indicates "1915" while the
name block along the south elevation states "FARM NO. 1."
NPCForm 1WOH
10344011
The farm has not undergone archaeological testing. The foundations east of the
hay barn mark the location of a granary and a barn. Photographs (Iowa Men's
Reformatory n.d.) also show a building west of the slaughter house, a concrete
silo adjacent to the south barn, and a barn on the hill north of the barn
granary. These areas remain relatively undisturbed. The cattle shed replaced
the west end of the barn east of the south barn. The north barn stands at the
position of a stone stable. However, these later remains have likely suffered
considerable disturbance. Thus, the district does likely contain several areas
with historical archaeological resources.
Primarily because of disturbance, all the buildings have undergone some degree
of change in design, materials, and workmanship. Some windows are closed and
some entrances, particularly the ones at the west end of the south barn, have
been reduced or expanded in size. While still separated from the farm and thus
an important spatial statement, the exterior and interior of the dwelling has
undergone considerable alteration. Aluminum siding now covers the building, it
has gained a north wing, and the interior underwent remodeling. The steel siding
of the east end of the south barn and the steel roof cattle shed to the east
represent a significant intrusion. The garage and office and tool shed post-date
the modern era and therefore non-contributing buildings. However, these low
buildings stand at opposite ends of the district, and their materials blend with
the other buildings. Perhaps the greatest threat to building integrity is
gradual building deterioration, their repair with modern materials, and their
alteration to storage functions which likely enhances deterioration. Despite
these changes, the simple design emphasizing heavy massing; the window, door, and
corner treatments; the original rough-faced, ashlar limestone materials; and the
workmanship by the prisoners remain. Despite the replacement and removal of
NPtForm OMB Appro** No. 10244)01*
Section number
buildings at Farm No. 1, tne overall setting ana visual image remains.Tne
dispersed, linear cluster of the farm's outbuildings along the drive near the
base of the hill survives. The agricultural fields immediately surrounding the
farm are uninterrupted by recent building activity.
Construction
Map No. Historic Name/Use Dates Class Category
1 Dwelling unknown NC Building
2 Garage unknown NC Building
3 South barn 1912, 1926 C Building
4 North barn ca. 1919 C Building
5 Barn granary 1915 C Building
6 Seed house, dining hall, cold 1939 C Building
frame
7 Slaughter house 1921-22 C Building
8 Processing plant 1922 C Building
9 Root cellar 1919 C Building
10 Office and tool shed 1963 NC Building
Total buildings: 10
o
Class refers to the designation of contributing and noncontributing
properties.
NMiForm 10400* 102*00*1
Historical Background
Although the original property purchased with the reformatory in 1872 included
sixty-one acres of agricultural lands, farming did not become a significant
enterprise until the turn of the century. By 1878, inmates grew a 4.5 acre
vegetable garden inside the stockade and maintained sixty-five hogs. Production
remained near this level until the early 1900s (Iowa, State of [IA Docs.] 1857-
1931 [1878: 6-8]; Remley 1901: 67; Iowa Joint Committee to Visit the Additional
Penitentiary 1874-96 [1896]). The state purchased the land on which Farm No. 1
sits as an 80.31 acre parcel in 1904 and then added 3.66 acres to it in 1921
(Busman 1991). In 1904, the state constructed a hog house and stone barn which
no longer stand (Iowa, State of [IA Docs.] 1857-1931 [1904: 1010]). However,
despite the construction of additional buildings including the south barn and
barn granary by 1915, production remained relatively limited through 1916.
The Cosson report and the resulting 1913 legislation favored the development of
prison farms to retrain prisoners. In response, the Board of Control began to
purchase additional agricultural lands, and the reformatory and penitentiary
NW Fo»m 10*00* 0MB A**w* No. 1024001$
Statement of Significance
Law
Farm No. 1 gains significance in the area of law as part of the reformatory
program established at the Iowa Men's Reformatory. Prior to the turn of the
century, labor unions and private industries in Iowa and other states objected
to the competition of contract prison labor programs. As opposition from labor
rose in the nineteenth century even though prison labor produced only a fraction
of the manufactured goods in the country, the amount of labor performed under
contract declined slowly. In response to the pressure from labor and business,
federal and state laws slowly restricted the markets for and production of prison
products especially by the depression of the 1930s (Brookman 1934: 124; McKelvey
NPf FomKMOO*
National
^ __
Register
_. ^ ^.
of
.
Historic Places Fa™ ?°• *i Iow*
Men's Reformatory
Continuation Sheet Jones Co ., IA
8 12
Section number ___ Page ___
Briggs 1915: 212; Haynes 1956: 44-45, 79).
Architecture
Architectural Integrity
Although each building has some loss of integrity, the cluster of buildings
retains sufficient integrity to gain significance under criteria A and C, They
adequately represent a prison farm. The buildings retain integrity of location
and setting. Their loosely cluster, linear arrangement along the drive remains
despite the pre-1942 loss and replacement of several buildings. Although
altered, the farmer's dwelling and garage remain separate from the farm's
outbuildings in which the prisoners were engaged. The setting, the surrounding
agricultural landscape, remains intact and uninterrupted by recent intrusions.
Loss of design, materials, and workmanship has occurred through alteration of
windows and door; replacement of roof materials; the alteration of some
structural components including the replacement of steel for wood supports in two
instances; and the changing of wall the coverings along the east elevation of the
south barn. Although an intrusion into the district, the steel cattle shed sits
down low at the foundation level of the adjacent building. The post-1942,
noncontributing concrete office and tool shed and the garage are low, blend in
color with the other buildings, and sit at the extreme west and east ends of the
building cluster. Also noncontributing, the dwelling is a small building placed
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National
^ ..
Register
mm ***
of Historic Places Fa™ ?°-*• Iowa
Men s Reformatory
Continuation Sheet Jones Co ., IA
8 14
Section number ___ Page ___
away from the main building cluster. Its location contributes to the
understanding of the spatial layout of the farm, its system of operation with a
full-time supervising farmer, and the probably distant relationship between the
farmer and the prisoners.
Despite these alterations in design, materials, and workmanship, the association
of these buildings with the former and current function as a prison farm remains
clear. Like the reformatory, the buildings make an impressive statement through
their massiveness. They too communicate a feeling of security from those working
within even without the walls. The buildings continue to communicate a feeling
of strength and direction of purpose to retrain honor prisoners in a respectable
livelihood.
In comparison with pre-1942 prison farms at the Iowa Men's Reformatory and the
Iowa State Penitentiary, Farm No. 1 remains the most intact and representative
of the prison farm. Clustered together north of the reformatory, Farms No. 2,
3, and 4 retain few pre-1942 buildings. While the main, 1930 tile dairy barn
remains at Farm No. 5, its calf barn, bull barn, and granary have undergone
considerable alteration. The dwelling no longer remains. Located east of the
reformatory, Farm No. 6 retains the dwelling which has undergone considerable
change, the tile hog house, and the limestone dining hall, but the remaining
outbuildings post-date 1942. Similarly, a majority of the buildings including
the dormitories at the two surviving prison farms associated with the Iowa State
Penitentiary at Fort Madison date after 1942. The third farm appears to have had
few associated outbuildings. The farms associated with the three other
corrections facilities, the Training School for Girls, the Women's Reformatory,
and the Training School for Boys have either completely lost their farms or the
remaining outbuildings generally post-date 1942. The outbuildings at the prison
farm at Clive, now Living History Farms, underwent significant alteration with
its adaption to a living history museum.
Thus, because Farm No. 1 retains integrity of location, setting, feeling, and
association; possesses sufficient integrity of design, workmanship, and materials
to represent its property subtype and its associated context; and remains the
most intact example of the farms at Iowa corrections facilities, the district
gains significance in the areas of law and architecture.
NP» Form NHOO*
National
^ .,
Register of
.•.!**•_ M.
Historic Places Farm "°- *• Iowa
Men s Reformatory
Continuation Sheet jones GO ., IA
9 16
Section number ___ Page ___
TA r>ru
National
_ Register
. -^. of Historic Places Fa™
Men *°s • Reformatory
*; Iowa
Continuation Sheet Jones co., IA
9 17
Section number ___ Page ___
_____McKelvev.
1977 American Prisons; A History of Good Intentions, Patterson Smith,
Montclalr, New Jersey.
Osborne Association, Inc.
1938 Handbook of American Penal Institutions and Reformatories (vol.1).
Osborne Association, Inc., National Society of Penal Information,
Inc., and the Welfare League Association, Inc., New York.
Remley, H.M.
1901 History of the Anamosa Penitentiary. Bulletin of Iowa Institutions.
3 (1).
Rothman, David J.
1981 Conscience and Convenience. Little, Brown and Company, Boston.
Zumbrunnen, Wanita
1978 The White Palace of the West. Palimpsest, 59 (3): 88-97.
NPTForm 1<WOO* QMB Aflpnw* No. 10244011
The boundary of the district begins at the west bank of Buffalo Creek where it
intersects with the north side of County Trunk Highway E28 and follows the west
bank of the creek north to the location at which the Anamosa city limits jog
east. The district boundary turns due west traveling to CTH E28. Here, it turns
south and follows the east and then the north sides of the road to the point of
beginning (see USGS map and farm plat).
Geographical Justification
The district includes the cluster of buildings of the farmstead of Farm No. 1 and
its adjacent setting. The boundaries follow easily defined natural and man-made
limits surrounding the farmstead.
NPS Form 10-900-a OM8 Approval No. 1024-0018
(8-86)
o
+j
03
T-t tri
««e <52
CO
C -<
o
o
>,u §2
as
c c «J a; to T3
I* C M f* C C
C ^325 QQ 0)
aj
•H Q) 09
i-H tjfl J3 O
^-4 « +J *•> 0 T3 9 O 4J -^
OJ t* 3 Li (M V 8) 0 O <«-t
> « Q O 8} OJ ^ t«
Q C3 9S CO QQ CO CU oa c
NM Form 10*»« o** Aflprav* No. 102+0019
^^•y