MANISHIMWE Adrien
MANISHIMWE Adrien
By:
Adrien MANISHIMWE
Registration Number: 218005090
Principal Supervisor: Pie NTAMPAKA (BVM, MVSc)
Academic Year 2022-2023
COMPONENT OF Research methodology
Lecturer: Dr.Richard Gashuru, PHD
CHAPTER.I. INTRODUCTION
I.1Background................................................................................. 1
I.2 .Problem statement and Justification............................................ 2
I.3. Aims and objectives........................................................................ 3
I.4.The specific objectives.....................................................................4
I.5. Research questions...........................................................................5
I.5. Hypothesis..........................................................................................6
CHAPTER II. MATERIALS AND METHODS
II. 1. The study area and population
II.2. Study design and targeted population
II.3. Sampling method and sample size determination
II.4. Data collection
II.5.Data Analysis
List of Figures
Figure 1. Map of Rwanda, Eastern province, Nyagatare district, and Nyagatare Sector
.............................................................................................................................................1
References
I.1. Background
Rabies is a viral disease that is preventable but it results in almost 100% of the case
fatality rate in humans and animals (WHO, 2016). Rabies is considered to be one of
the oldest infectious diseases affecting a vast host of mammals (Knobel et al, 2005)
and the mode of transmission in humans is usually via the bite of a rabid animal. All
warm-blooded mammals are susceptible hosts to rabies virus (Wilsmore et al, 2006).
Worldwide, rabies kills over 55,000 people per year in developing countries (CDC,
2022). Humane Dog Population Management (HDPM) is a versatile approach that
connects the different level of societies to break into silos and work together to
promote the wellbeing of stray dogs, solve the problems caused stray dogs at large is
facing, and take part in minimizing the size of free-roaming dogs and facilitate more
effective rabies control and prevention(Taylor et al, 2017).
Therefore, the significance of the expected results of the research study will involve
the establishment of a baseline assessment of the knowledge, skills needs, attitudes,
and practices on prevention, control, and eradication of rabies using the Humane Dog
Population Management (HDPM) concept in the Nyagatare sector. the study will
promote the welfare of stray dogs and will result in the establishment of effective
mass rabies vaccination campaign strategies for dogs in the Nyagatare Sector. This
will also help in assessing the level of understanding of the accomplishment regarding
Humane Dog Population management in eradicating and reducing animal welfare
matters faced by the dog and will improve knowledge of dog owners and professional
workers regarding rabies prevention, control and encourage veterinary students and
alumni to promote and raise the overall standard of the wellbeing of the dog owners
and free-roaming dogs by providing veterinary care services for dog health including
vaccination, humane treatment, castration, deworming and rehoming them, proper
feeding awareness. Therefore, the welfare of dogs will be taken into consideration in
the Nyagatare sector of Nyagatare District, Rwanda.
It will be very crucial to know the attitudes of the dog owners toward the welfare of
dogs to determine the contribution of Humane Dog Population Management in the
community as well as rabies eradication in the region. Finally, feed is scarce for dogs
as there is a large number of dog populations in the region with competition for
human food which has a direct or indirect negative impact on the health of humans
and the welfare of dogs. Most dog owners are unable to afford to spay, or castration
services due to poor financial ability which leads to many problems and rabies cases,
thus humane spaying and castration is a must to control dog population size, improve
the wellbeing of dogs and help us in rabies eradication and the Increase population
size will never be ended except to stop breeding in dog and through humane castration
and spaying will remove the barriers that prevent people from sterilizing their dogs
(Animal welfare violence) and promote animal welfare, for example, euthanasia has
to be performed in an ethically acceptable way and by veterinarians without suffering
for the animals thus, poisoning with strychnine will not be accepted and the use of
snares for the trapping of dogs will be replaced by life traps. Veterinary public health
practice has demonstrated that a reduction of canine rabies correlates with a
substantial decrease in human rabies cases. If rabies is eliminated from domestic
animals and wildlife, the incidence of rabies in mankind will also be controlled.
Animal rabies can be controlled by proper induction of herd immunity, humane
removal of stray animals, and promotion of responsible pet ownership via education
channels.
I.3. Research questions
1. What are the people's attitudes that can affect dog population management in the
Nyagatare sector?
2. What are the most welfare problems faced by stray dogs and home dogs in the
Nyagatare sector?
3. What is the current status of stray dogs and the sources of stray dogs in Nyagatare?
How is Humane Dog Population Management important in rabies control and
response to the welfare of stray dogs and home dogs?
4. What is the level of knowledge and practices of Humane Dog Population
Management as far as Rabies control in dogs among cattle farmers who keep dogs and
dog owners in the Nyagatare sector?
affect dog population management man attitudes that could
affect dog population management
To determine socio-culture barriers that prevent people from sterilizing their dogs
Humanely in society through skills, knowledge, and attitudes change of dog owners
in the Nyagatare sector
3. To understand practices regarding humane dog population management in rabies
control and prevention in the Nyagatare sector
I.6. Hypothesis
There is a low knowledge level among dog owners regarding Humane Dog
Population Management in rabies control in the Nyagatare sector.
2. There are negative attitudes of workers and dog owners towards the welfare of
dogs, especially stray dogs in the Nyagatare sector.
3. There are poor practices regarding key aspects of rabies control and prevention
measures among dog owners in the Nyagatare sector.
4. Attitudes towards animals correlate with attitudes to people and public health
workers– cruelty to animals is usually an indicator of societal problems.
Map of Nyagatare Sector showing cells where this study will be carried
out (represented by astar icon)
Source: https://rwandi24.blogspot.com/2020/11/rwanda-districts-map.html. Accessed
on 19/08/2022
II.2. Study design and targeted population
A cross-sectional survey will be used to assess knowledge, attitudes, and practices on
the prevention and control of dogs, and stray dogs using the HDPM concept. Open-
and closed-ended questionnaires will be used and face-to-face interviews with dog
owners or cattle farmers owning dogs at home be conducted. The study will involve
dog owners, cattle farmers who keep the dog on their farms, and stray dogs, in the
study area. The study will involve dog owners, cattle farmers who keep the dog on
their farms, and stray dogs, in the cells or villages of the Nyagatare sector. More than
One thousand(1000) people including dog owners and cattle farmers who keep dogs
will be interviewed. Our targeted population of dog owners or cattle farmers with
dogs at home in the whole Nine (9) cells of the Nyagatare Sector plus total straying
dogs occurring in the Nyagatare sector.
In 2021, the dog Population of Nyagatare district was estimated at 4080 dogs while
families owning dogs added up to 2812 families (Ndishimye Prudence, unpublished
data). Nyagatare sector is made up of 9 cells, all nine cells will be selected based on
the availability of dairy farms that keep or had kept guard dogs, dog owners, and stray
dogs. The Nyagatare sector report of December 2020 mentioned that the number of
cattle farmers was estimated to be 594 which equated to 594 dairy farms that kept or
had kept guard dogs. The respondents will be selected at random (simple random
sampling) from the population of Cattle farmers that kept or had kept guard dogs, and
dog owners in the study cells.
3.1. Sample size
According to the Nyagatare sector report of December 2020, the number of dogs in
the Nyagatare sector was estimated to be 594 which was equated to the number of
dairy farms that keep or had kept guard dogs. To determine the sample size, the
Yamane formula will be used: n=N/1+N (e) 2
Where:
N=594
n=594/1+594(0.1)2=86
N=Population
n= Sample size
e= Precision level: 10%
II.4.Data collection
Target participants will be dog owners and Cattle farmers or cattle farm workers that
kept or had kept guard dogs. A questionnaire for dog owners will be provided for
gathering data based, dog owners will be trained before to get accurate information
and answer the questions provided. and the questions will be translated into two
languages, both native language(Kinyarwanda) and foreign language (English ) to
remove language barriers for local people during data collection, however, the
application software used will be in English because this date will be needed in
scientific research and publication.
II.5.Data Analysis
The processed data will be analyzed using R software's latest version which is free. A
descriptive analysis will be done based on processed data. Quantitative variables will
account for average with its variance while the variables which are qualitative account
for absolute and (rf). where rf is relative frequency.
This study is planned to start from January toward the end of may 2023 if funded.
This will also help in assessing the level of understanding of the implementation of
humane dog population management in stopping and reducing problems caused by
stray dogs and will enhance best practices and skills required for dog owners and
change the poor mindset of the societies and socio-culture barriers to effective Animal
welfare especially stray dogs which are in dangers and encouraging veterinary
students to take a part by providing veterinary standards services to ward dog owners.
Humane spaying and castration is a must to control the dog population and help us in
rabies eradication and the barriers that prevent people from sterilizing their
dogs(Animal welfare violence) should be replaced by spaying to respect the welfare
of dogs, dogs need care like humans and other animals, therefore, must have right to
access to their five freedoms of animals. educating people who benefit from the
welfare of dogs will change their mindset because when the welfare of dogs is
respected well-being of humans will be improved.
Free dog castration services will help to improve community acceptance of dogs and
reduce cruelty toward dogs and enhance society participation to promote responsible
dog ownership and better veterinary care will be taken into consideration for caring
for dogs and dog vaccination coverage participation.
3.Education: Who benefits from the well-being of dogs (we people, God, animals
themselves)? Educating veterinary students about humane care for dogs and society
regarding bringing up their dogs will be a root for changing attitudes of dog owners
toward the welfare of dogs concerning the five freedoms of animals.
References :
Humane Dog Population Management Guidance, 2008. The International Companion
Animal Management Coalition (ICAM)
2.R. M. S. Pimburage, P. A. L. Harischandra, M. Gunatilake, D. N. Jayasinhe, A.
Balasuriya, R.
M. S. K. Amunugama. "A cross-sectional survey on dog ecology and dog anti-rabies
vaccination coverage in selected areas in Sri Lanka", Sri Lanka Veterinary Journal,
2017
3. Louise H. Taylor, Ryan M. Wallace, Deepashree Balaram, Joann M. Lindenmayer
et al. "The Role of Dog Population Management in Rabies Elimination—A Review
of Current Approaches and Future Opportunities", Frontiers in Veterinary Science,
2017
4.Mouhamadou Faly Ba, Ndèye Mbacké Kane, Mamadou Kindi Korka Diallo, Oumar
Bassoum
et al. "Knowledge, Attitudes and Practices on Rabies among Human and Animal
Health Professionals in Senegal", Pathogens, 2021.
5.Pie Ntampaka, François Niragire, Vincent Nkurunziza, Gisele Uwizeyimana,
Anselme Shyaka. "Perceptions, attitudes and practices regarding canine zoonotic
helminthiases among dog owners in Nyagatare district, Rwanda", Veterinary
Medicine and Science, 2022
6.www.stud.epsilon.slu.se
7.www..mdpi-res.com
8.R. M. S. Pimburage, P. A. L. Harischandra, M. Gunatilake, D. N. Jayasinhe, A.
Balasuriya, R.
M. S. K. Amunugama. "A cross-sectional survey on dog ecology and dog anti-rabies
vaccination coverage in selected areas in Sri Lanka", Sri Lanka Veterinary Journal,
2017
9.David Moran, Danilo Alvarez, Loren Cadena, Julie Cleaton et al. "Heterogeneity in
dog
population characteristics contribute to chronic under-vaccination against rabies in
Guatemala", PLOS Neglected Tropical Diseases, 2022
Rabies in Man and Animals, 2014.
Dandan Li, Qiaoyan Liu, Fan Chen, Qingqing Jiang, Tiantian Wang, Xiaoxv Yin,
Zuxun Lu, Shiyi Cao. "Knowledge, attitudes and practices regarding rabies and its
prevention and control among bite victims by suspected rabid animals in China", One
Health, 2021
International Companion Animal Management Coalition. Humane Dog Population
ManagementGuidance.(2007).
Availablefrom:http://www.icamcoalition.org/downloads/Humane_Dog_Population_
Management_ Guidance_English.pdf
OIE. Stray dog population control. Terrestrial Animal Health Code. (Chap. 7.7), OIE
(2015). Availablefrom:http://www.oie.int/index.php?
id=169&L=0&htmfile=chapitre_aw_stray_dog.htm
World Animal Protection. Humane Dog Management: Better Lives for Dogs
(2015). Available from:http://www.worldanimalprotection.org/sites/default/
files/int_files/humane-dog-management.pdf
Totton SC, Wandeler AI, Zinsstag J, Bauch CT, Ribble CS, Rosette RC, et al. Stray
dog population demographics in Jodhpur, India following a population control/rabies
vaccination program. Prev Vet Med (2010) 97(1):51–7.
doi:10.1016/j.prevetmed.2010.07.009
18.Ntampaka, P., Nyaga, P. N., Niragire, F., Gathumbi, J. K., & Tukei, M. (2019).
Knowledge, attitudes, and practices regarding rabies and its control among dog
owners in Kigali city, Rwanda. PloS One, 14(8).
19. Rwanda Biomedical Center (2016). Press release: RBC Cautions Rwandans about
dog bites and Rabies. http://rbc.gov.rw/IMG/pdf/press_release_rabies_eng.pdf
P. Ntampaka, P. N. Nyaga, F. Nirangire, J.K. Gathumbi, M.Tukei (2009) Knowledge,
attitudes and practices regarding rabies and its control among dog owners in Kigali
city, Rwanda, PLoSOne,14(8),e02004https://journals.plos.org/plus one/article?
id=10.1371/journal.pone.02100-4
Nyagatare district. (2021). https://nyagatare.gov.rw/index.php?id=83
https://doi.org/10.1002/vms3.787
23. Hampson, K.; Dushoff, J.; Cleaveland, S.; Haydon, D.T.; Kaare, M.; Packer, C.;
Dobson, A.
Transmission Dynamics and Prospects for Elimination of Canine Rabies. PLoS Biol.
2009, 7,
e53.
24. Fooks, A.R. Rabies Remains a Neglected Disease. Euro Surveill. 2005, 10, 1-2.
25.Fekadu, M. Canine Rabies. Onderstepoort J. Vet. Res. 1993, 60, 421-427.
27. Rabies Elimination Progress. (2017). Global Alliance for Rabies Control.
https://rabiesalliance.org/country/rwanda
Fenelon, N.; Dely, P.; Katz, M.A.; Schaad, N.D.; Dismer, A.; Moran, D.; Laraque, F.;
Wallace, R.M. Knowledge, attitudes and practices regarding rabies risk in community
members and healthcare professionals: Pétionville, Haiti, 2013. Epidemiol. Infect.
2017, 145, 1624–1634. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Monje, F.; Erume, J.; Mwiine, F.N.; Kazoora, H.; Okech, S.G. Knowledge, attitude
and practices about rabies management among
human and animal health professionals in Mbale District, Uganda. One Health
Outlook 2020, 2, 24. [CrossRef]