Towerco Digital Deply Solution
Towerco Digital Deply Solution
2 © 2020 Nokia
Tower Cos. Pain Points and Opportunity Analysis
Analysts identify operational complexity as the biggest hinderance to capture future growth opportunities
for Tower Cos.
Nokia Digital Real-time visibility and First time right Quality with Complexity management with Customized Digital Deploy
transparency on Network advanced automation and real- AI, ML and AR tools solutions for neutral hosting,
Deploy
operations & evolution time collaboration for asset/operation managem HetNet etc.
ent
3 © 2021 Nokia
TowerCo Business Models
Moving into Services
Digital Transformation is one of the pillar to deliver more revenue with less cost
Risk or opportunity for Nokia Deploy services?
TowerCo - Core Business TowerCo - Asset Diversifications TowerCo - Migration into Services
(Tower) (Fiber & Small Cell) (NetCo-IoT-Smart Cities)
4 © 2020 Nokia
Nokia Digital Deploy can help TowerCo in the transformation journey
How….
1 2 3 4
Digitalization for full Manage growing complexity Digitization as a catalyst to Nokia Digital Deploy Global
transparency and real- by changing the way of develop new business Delivery Center to support
time infrastructure working. models TowerCo evolution &
(Digital twin) transformation
5 © 2021 Nokia
Confidential
Nokia Deploy Solution for Tawal
Nokia can help Tawal to Digital Trasformation….
Tawal Business Model TowerCo - Asset Diversifications TowerCo - Migration into Services
(Fiber & Small Cell) (5G IoT Smart Cities)
Automatically evaluate
potential installation
defects
Provide immediate
response to field team on
pass/fail on specific
defects
Reduced time to complete the site survey reports Faster & accurate completion of the checklist, ML/AI HSS verification support better HSS
since equipment is automatically identified reduces amount of site visits assurance and zero tolerance approach
8 © 2021 Nokia
Cellnex Group and Digital Twin Vision
Cellnex Vision is to invest in the Digital
Twin technologies to:
Modelling modules: Create a Revit Site Model Modelling modules: comprehensive solution of
using inventory report and site inputs pre-defined Model sites + experience of GDC
provided by Customer. To be performed by a capabilities. Interest from Product Management
back-office service in a centralized way using to further develop and enhance this solution.
customer models
Field Service modules: whenever inventory Field Service modules: leveraging on partners
data are missing or inconsistent, site visit will and Nokia NDPd mobile App solution Nokia is able
be required to gather inventory and, where to fully satisfy customer requirements with best
required, static verification data in class speed and quality.
Onsite Survey
Data Gathering Via Drone modules: whenever
there is the need to gather data via drone (for
instance the sizes, azimuth and tilt of the Data Gathering Via Drone modules: long
antennas) experience with more than 5000 sites done in US
and Europe. Established collaboration with key
Maintain & Update module: process of innovators on the market.
updating and maintaining the 3D models
Maintain & Update module: leveraging on Global
Delivery Center capabilities and competence able
to fulfil customer requirements
10 © 2022 Nokia
Nokia Value added additional service proposal for Cellnex
• Services
• Site inventory checking and data mining
• Site design assessment and quality checks
• Site evolution, consolidation and standardization
• TowerCo designed solutions
• for combined energy system and power distribution, metering, battery storage and
pick hours optimization
• TowerCo antenna sharing
• Engineering consulting services
11 © 2022 Nokia
Conclusions and lessons after Spain and UK Cellnex RFQs
• Significant improvement reached for UK submission despite lower volumes and higher local cost
for data gathering due to higher local SPC and Static Verification requirement
• Better scope understanding gave possibility to optimize costs for UK submission from GDC point
of view. GDC is costing Inventory checking, while is under customer responsibility. Trial or POC of
the complete solution will be beneficial for better scope and cost tuning to be requested.
• Lack of TowerCo strategy delayed the Bid and no Bid decisions. Not clear why Nokia ?
• Nokia internal markup rules brought customer prices to no competitive level (far above market)
even for UK submission also after the feedback received from Spain where Nokia was 2 time more
expensive than the selected partner. To be verifies with Rafael who is the winner
• Nokia GDC Centralize Design solution can be a real competitive advance for TowerCo. Our
offering can be more optimize if extended to the Inventory checking, under customer
responsibility
• Global Site engineering portfolio will be enriched with this 3D site design. CoE is now looking how
to scale up their design capability using Photogrammetric combined with Autodesk Revit 3D
Modelling. C3 approval planned for P9 and available in Q1/23.
12 © 2022 Nokia
Back up slides
13 © 2021 Nokia <Document ID: change ID in footer or remove> <Change information classification in footer>
Spain vs. UK Nokia response comparison
• Scope is the same except for Static verification requiring
Improvements in UK vs. Spain
in UK 2 certified riggers on site. In Spain we quote only 1
field engineer and 2nd was optional • PMS improvement – 27,4%
• 10k sites in Spain vs. 8,5k sites in UK
• PMS improvement volume wise – 14,6% (14
• UK RFQ documents much better prepared (more EUR per site), while UK SPC is higher then Spain
detailed explanation of scope, examples of input and
one
expected deliverables)
• Spain – leveraging on SubCo field activities (for 10% of • GDC TCO improvement volume wise – 38,88%
sites), while in UK – IRIS mode • GDC site base improvement – 28,09%
• PMS overhead: Spain – LDO, UK – IRIS. More lean (153EUR reduction in average per site)
organization in UK, since ROM provided by GDC
% Improvement UK vs. Spain Per site cost difference (improvement UK vs. Spain)
38,88% 37,16%
50,00% 27,43% 28,09% 26,08% € 640,32
14,62% 16,48% € 700,00
-11,94%
€ 600,00 € 544,40
0,00% € 473,35
PMS TCO PMS per GDC TCO GDC per Overall Overal Drone Field data Data € 500,00 € 391,45
site site case per site gathering Gathering € 400,00
-50,00%
+
Structural € 300,00 € 166,97
€ 152,95
-100,00% € 200,00 € 95,91
€ 81,89
€ 100,00 € 14,02
-150,00%
€ 0,00
-174,06% UK PMS Costs ES PMS Costs Absolute difference
-200,00%
PMS per site GDC per site Overal per site
14 © 2022 Nokia
Figures - costs
Absolute value cost improvement UK vs. Spain % Improvement UK vs. Spain
50,00% 27,43% 38,88% 37,16%
14,62% 16,48%
€ 6.403.165,04
€ 7.000.000,00 28,09% 26,08% -11,94%
€ 5.444.016,67 0,00%
€ 6.000.000,00
€ 5.000.000,00 € 4.023.442,22
-50,00%
€ 3.327.366,17
€ 4.000.000,00
€ 2.379.722,81
€ 3.000.000,00 € 2.116.650,50
-100,00%
€ 2.000.000,00 € 959.148,36
€ 696.076,05
€ 263.072,31
€ 1.000.000,00 -150,00%
€ 0,00
UK PMS Costs ES PMS Costs Absolute difference -174,06%
-200,00%
PMS TCO GDC TCO Overall case
€ 500,00 € 771,46
€ 901,80 2. UK – 2 rigging experts are
€ 95,91
€ 391,45 € 473,35 considered + higher daily SPC
€ 0,00 € 81,89
PMS per site GDC per site Overal per site Drone Field data gathering Data Gathering + rates.
Structural
UK Costs ES Costs
15 © 2022 Nokia
Figures - price
Total TCO UK vs. Spain Price Site base price UK vs. Spain
€ 10.514.953,20
€ 12.000.000,00 € 1.200,00 € 1.051,50
€ 8.916.372,60 € 891,64
€ 10.000.000,00 € 1.000,00
€ 823,81
€ 8.000.000,00 € 7.002.413,19 € 800,00 € 674,92
€ 5.736.820,37
€ 6.000.000,00 € 600,00
€ 0,00 € 0,00
PMS TCO GDC TCO Overall case PMS per site GDC per site Overal per site
30,00% 20,00%
25,00%
20,83%
15,00%
20,00%
15,00% 10,00%
6,86%
10,00%
5,00%
5,00%
0,00% 0,00%
16 © 2022 Nokia
PMS TCO GDC TCO Overall case PMS per site GDC per site Overal per site
Nokia strengths and opportunities
• Equipment Vendor
• Big player in the Telecommunication driving main standardization bodies
• Nokia Global delivery Center capability to support all the service solutions from the back office
• Service competence and capabilities and tools
• Radio and Transmission Network Planning
• Site Digitalization and site Modernization design
• Roll Out Management
• Supply chain and Material Management
• Quality Management
• Technical Support and Care operations
• Digitalization vision and tool automation , ML/AI use cases, API and Digimop capabilities
Nokia service solution for the TowerCo should be tailorized based on the TowerCo needs and maturity,
17 © 2022 Nokia <Document ID: change ID in footer or remove> <Change information classification in footer>
Digitalization : Rethink Network Reinvent Deployment
Sustainability is the heart of what we do
Less Person to Person contact via remote processes contributing to safe environment in
18 © 2020 Nokia
the current pandemic
Market trends CSPs and TowerCos
MNOs are under intense pressure to reduce costs, and this, combined with the rising
competition among towercos in many markets, is enabling them to make higher demands
on their infrastructure partners, not only for lower rental fees but higher SLA targets such
as guaranteed site uptime or power efficiency.
This will incentivise towercos to invest in the tools to predict and manage their sites,
power systems and fibre more intelligently
An example of such cooperation between Reliance Jio and Tower Vision in India. These
partners were assisted in setting up common data frameworks by being, in both cases,
new to the market, and therefore keen to use data intelligence to gain a competitive
edge, while also being unencumbered by legacy processes.
19 © 2022 Nokia <Document ID: change ID in footer or remove> <Change information classification in footer>
TowerCo cost areas and trends
• Site Renting fee and infrastructure Cost
• Site inventory management
• Site evolution and infrastructure adaptation
• Space optimization with
• consolidation
• more outdoor
• all in one cabinet,
• zero footprint
• Power supply consolidation and energy efficiency and CO2 targets
• Maintenance cost
• with standardization,
• site supervision,
• preventive maintenance
• optimize, minimize site visits
20 © 2022 Nokia <Document ID: change ID in footer or remove> <Change information classification in footer>
TowerCo go to market approach and investments
21 © 2022 Nokia <Document ID: change ID in footer or remove> <Change information classification in footer>