Effect of Swelling Clay Dispersion Type On Fine Coal Flotation
Effect of Swelling Clay Dispersion Type On Fine Coal Flotation
ISSN 1643-1049
http://www.journalssystem.com/ppmp
© Wroclaw University of Science and Technology
Abstract: The influence of bentonite dispersion on fine coal flotation was examined to better understand
the role of swelling clay in the process of flotation. It was found that the coal flotation recovery was
lower with uncontrolled dispersion of bentonite than with controlled dispersion. The detrimental effect
was attributed to the increase in slime coating. In the uncontrolled dispersion, the dispersed bentonite
platelets formed an extensive card-house structure. The three-dimensional networks increased the
slurry viscosity, and caused significant coating of the coal particles, thereby inhibiting particle mobility
and bubble-particle attachment. In the controlled dispersion, the bentonite mineral appeared as separate
particles with low aspect ratios. The coal particles were partially coated, and the slurry viscosity was
lower, resulting in higher flotation recovery. The findings in this study suggested that a practical
solution to mitigate the negative impact of swelling clay on flotation would be to maintain high
electrolyte levels in the wash water to inhibit clay swelling and dispersion.
Keywords: fine coal flotation, swelling clay, controlled dispersion, CaCl2, slime coating
1. Introduction
Swelling clays such as bentonite have an innate capacity to hydrate and disperse into thin flakes in
suspension. Owing to this tendency, they cause several problems in mineral processing operations such
as high pumping energy, high water consumption, and difficulties in dewatering (De Kretser et al., 1997;
Lim et al., 2009). In the case of mineral flotation, previous studies have demonstrated that the presence
of even small amounts of bentonite can reduce both the mineral grade and recovery compared to that
of kaolinite, a type of non-swelling clay (Arnold and Aplan, 1986; Xu et al., 2003; Wang et al., 2015).
These studies correlated the negative impacts with a few characteristics of the bentonite mineral such
as coating of the valuable mineral surfaces by electrostatic attraction, increase in reagent consumption
due to clay-rich surfaces, increase in pulp viscosity, and variations in froth stability resulting from clay
aggregation (Arnold and Aplan, 1986; Polat et al., 2003; Wang and Peng, 2014). However, none of the
previous studies took into account another important feature of bentonite, i.e., swelling and dispersion.
Bentonite is a type of anisotropic phyllosilicate comprising silica tetrahedral (T) and octahedral (O)
sheets, which form hydrogen bonds in a 2:1 (T-O-T) fashion. In sedimentary form, dry bentonite exists
as stacks of this united structure aligned in a face- face orientation. On dispersion in a solution with
high electrolyte concentration, especially one containing certain cations such as calcium ions, the closely
packed structure can be maintained, and the swelling and dispersing behaviours are suppressed. This
is because some calcium cations exchange into the interlayer space and generate an additional attractive
force between the layers (Lim et al., 2009). The resultant suspension in this case would contain larger
clay particles, and the net number of interactions between the clay particles would be lower. This
approach has been termed as controlled dispersion by Tanihara and Nakagawa (1973), and Deason and
Onoda (1984), can significantly improve the dewaterability of coal tailings (De Kretser et al., 1997). On
the contrary, uncontrolled dispersion occurs when the aqueous ionic strength that initially wets the
swelling clay is insufficient to suppress its dispersion into individual platelets. In this case, numerous
DOI: 10.5277/ppmp18143
Physicochem. Probl. Miner. Process., 55(2), 2019, 380-388 381
platelets with sheet-like particle shapes, and high aspect ratios are randomly oriented and interact in
suspension, leading to high network strength and poor dewaterability. Investigations in soil science
have demonstrated that spontaneous rearrangement of these disordered clay platelets into an efficient
face-face orientation cannot occur without the application of significant external pressure (Pashley and
Quirk, 1984), therefore dewaterability of a suspension with dispersed clay platelets can only be
moderately improved by the subsequent addition of an electrolyte.
Rheology has been acknowledged as a useful index to characterize particulate suspension. In the
case of clay suspension, the rheology data can be used to understand the interaction between clay
particles. For example, the card-house structure resulting from the edge-face interaction is
predominantly characterized by non-Newtonian flow with development of yield stress. This type of
structure results in high viscosity. Face-face association leads to the formation of lamellar-structured
aggregates with low yield stress requirement. The presence of clay in ores can dramatically affect pulp
rheology. According to Farrokhpay et al. (2016), in the flotation of copper ore, montmorillonite
significantly changes the rheology and froth stability, causing both flotation grade and recovery to
decline. Other researchers indicated that the increase in yield stress and apparent viscosities reduces the
probability of collision between bubbles and particles. This is due to the poor dispersion of the bubbles
and the mobility of the particles in flotation cells, resulting in poor flotation performance (Bakker et al.,
2009; Shabalala et al., 2011).
Additionally, clay minerals can cover the surface of valuable minerals and inhibit bubble-particle
attachment. In order to explain the slime coating phenomenon, the zeta potential of fine clays and
mineral particles has been measured in numerous investigations (Edwards et al., 1980; Basnayaka et al.,
2017). Xu et al. (2003) suggested a method based on zeta potential distribution, individually and
collectively, to characterize the slime coating of clay particles on coal. The results can be used to explain
the observed depression of coal flotation by montmorillonite.
The objective of this study was to explore the dissimilar effects of controlled and uncontrolled
dispersion of bentonite on fine coal flotation in identical solution chemical environments. Pulp rheology
and zeta potential distribution were examined to understand how they modified slurry properties and
particle interactions, and lead to different flotation behaviours. The results of the present research are
expected to outline an operating window for the flotation of clay-rich ores, an endeavour that has been
termed as “a mineral processing nightmare”.
report by Lim et al. (2009), the suspension was then stirred for complete dispersion. Subsequently, the
mixture was allowed to stand for 24 h prior to use.
According to the report by Lim et al. (2009), uncontrolled dispersion suspension was prepared by
dispersing 12 g of the bentonite sample in 0.8 dm3 of reverse osmosis-water and stirred as in the
controlled case. The suspension was left to stand for 12 h to fully hydrate and swell, after which it was
remixed for 5 min to well disperse. An amount of CaCl2, equal to that used for controlled dispersion,
was then added, and the mixing progressed for another 30 min. The resulting suspension was again left
to stand for 12 h to reach chemical equilibrium.
It is interesting to note that although the coal was floated in identical solution chemical
environments, the controlled and uncontrolled dispersion suspensions showed obviously different
flotation behaviours. Controlled suspension exhibited a faster flotation kinetics than uncontrolled
suspension. Under the current flotation condition, a flotation time of 5 min resulted in a 74% and 65%
combustible recoveries for the controlled and uncontrolled suspensions, respectively. The combustible
recovery was 93% at the completion of 8 min of flotation in the case of controlled suspension. However,
it decreased dramatically to 71% in the uncontrolled suspension. Ash recovery in both the cases,
however, stayed at nearly the same level i.e., 16%.
that bentonite particles moved independently under the stress applied. However, under conditions of
uncontrolled dispersion, the bentonite suspension exhibits non-Newtonian behaviour with pseudo
plastic characteristics. The viscosity of this flow type decreases with increase in shear rate. It appears
that bentonite forms aggregates in suspensions. Under shear force, the large clay aggregates are
separated into smaller units and, under very high shear forces, into individual particles. Such a process
rheologically manifests itself as shear-thinning behaviour (Cruz et al., 2015). Since the solid
concentration in the two suspensions is the same, the difference in flow type could be related to the
bentonite particle shape. Upon uncontrolled dispersion in solution, bentonite particles appear as thinner
sheets with high aspect ratio. It is known that thinner particles can produce a higher degree of texture
than can thicker compact particles of equivalent Stokes diameter, resulting in higher shear stress (He et
al., 2004).
Fig. 2. Shear stress of controlled and uncontrolled suspensions as a function of shear rate
Fig. 2 also exhibits the rheograms of the controlled and uncontrolled flotation slurries containing
coal and bentonite mineral. Compared to the Newtonian behaviour of the individual controlled
bentonite suspension, the controlled flotation slurry displays distinct pseudo plastic characteristics and
higher shear stress requirement. According to literature, the fluid change can be attributed to not only
the increase in solid concentration but also the interaction between the coal and clay particles, which is
examined below. Uncontrolled flotation pulps exhibit non-Newtonian behaviour like the individual
uncontrolled bentonite suspension does, and reveal higher viscosity. Although its solid concentration
is equal to that of the controlled flotation slurry, the uncontrolled flotation slurry produces significantly
higher shear stress. For instance, at a shear rate of 100/s, its shear stress is 1.73 Pa, which is 0.83 Pa
higher than that (0.90 Pa) of the controlled flotation slurry.
Fig. 3 shows the effect of bentonite dispersion type on froth stability and froth height as a function
of time since the introduction of air. In the same processes, the average half-life of the froth in controlled
and uncontrolled slurries was measured as 8.4 s and 9.3 s, respectively. These results are consistent with
Physicochem. Probl. Miner. Process., 55(2), 2019, 380-388 385
the findings of previous researchers that froth stability is related to slurry viscosity; the higher the slurry
viscosity, the more stable the froth is (Farrokhpay, 2012). However, the slight enhancement in froth
stability may have no significant impact on flotation behaviours.
Fig. 4. Zeta potential distribution of controlled and uncontrolled dispersions of bentonite alone and in mixture
with coal in the presence of 0.5 mmol/dm3 CaCl2 at pH 7.8
386 Physicochem. Probl. Miner. Process., 55(2), 2019, 380-388
a1 a2
Controlled
b1 b2
Uncontrolled
Fig. 5. SEM images of concentrates from controlled slurry flotation (a1, a2)
and uncontrolled slurry flotation (b1, b2)
In the controlled slurry, bentonite minerals appear as separated particles with a lower aspect ratio
i.e., ratio of particle diameter to thickness. These particles have an overall negatively charged surface.
Meanwhile, the coal surfaces also exhibit a negative charge. Theoretically, the electrostatic forces
between the coal and bentonite particles are repulsive, and hence slime coating was not expected to
Physicochem. Probl. Miner. Process., 55(2), 2019, 380-388 387
occur. However, the coating of bentonite particles on coal was evidently identified by the zeta potential
distribution measurements and cryo-SEM analysis. For the slime coating of clay on coal, Oats et al.
(2010) calculated the interaction force between coal and clay using the DLVO theory, and suggested that
van der Waals attraction, and not the double-layer force, was the driving force. In the uncontrolled
slurry, bentonite mineral had dispersed into numerous thin flakes, even into individual platelets with
higher aspect ratio and greater negative charge. These units interact in edge-face and edge-edge
manners and form voluminous, three-dimensional card-house structures. Obviously, the interaction
force between coal and clay cannot be calculated using the DLVO theory in this case. By integrating all
the information gathered in this study, we can deduce that the three-dimensional aggregates coated on
the coal surface are strong sufficiently to undergo flotation, and are subsequently recovered into the
concentrate. Obviously, the extent of coating on the surface of the coal particles by the three-dimensional
structure far exceeds that by the separated bentonite particles in the controlled slurry. This could
account for the lower combustible recovery in uncontrolled flotation. On the other hand, the three-
dimensional aggregates enhance the rheology of the flotation slurry. Patra et al. (2012) identified that
pulp rheology had a strong effect on the selective separation of Ni minerals from the fibrous minerals
entangled in the flotation slurry, leading to the formation of large networks with a simultaneous
increase in pulp viscosity and the subsequent poor flotation of Ni minerals. According to previous
investigations, the higher viscosity resulting from the three-dimensional structure of bentonite inhibited
the mobility of the coal particles and mineralized bubbles in the pulp phase, and also impeded particle-
bubble attachment, which subsequently caused combustible recovery to decline.
The practical application of controlled dispersion would entail high overall salinity levels and
calcium ions in the wash water. Through control of solution chemistry of the process water that swelling
clays first encounter whether in coal processing plant or the mine, the clay particles will remain closely
packed in a face-face association.
4 Conclusions
The current study found that dispersion type of swelling clay has a significant effect on fine coal
flotation. Uncontrolled dispersion of swelling clay results in significant reduction of combustible
recovery compared with controlled dispersion because the resultant high slurry viscosity can reduce
the mobility of bubbles and coal and, thereby, the frequency of bubble-coal collisions. Additionally, the
decrease in combustible recovery is also attributed to the severe slime coating of the extensive three-
dimensional clay structure on coal. The extent of coating far exceeds that by the separated bentonite
particles in the controlled slurry. The separated bentonite particles with low aspect ratios in controlled
dispersion lead to a lower slurry viscosity and partially slime coating, consequently a higher
combustible recovery.
Acknowledgments
This project received support from the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities
(2013RC17) supported by China University of Mining and Technology.
References
ARNOLD, B. J., APLAN, F. F., 1986. The effect of clay slimes on coal flotation, part I: The nature of the clay. Int. J. Miner.
Process. 17, 225-242.
BAKKER, C. W., MEYER, C. J., DEGLON, D. A., 2009. Numerical modelling of non-Newtonian slurry in a mechanical
flotation cell. Miner. Eng. 22, 944-950.
BASNAYAKA, L., SUBASINGHE, N., ALBIJANIC, B., 2017. Influence of clays on the slurry rheology and flotation of a
pyritic gold ore. Appl. Clay Sci. 136, 230-238.
CRUZ, N., PENG, Y., WIGHTMAN, E., XU, N., 2015, The interaction of clay minerals with gypsum and its effects on
copper–gold flotation. Miner. Eng. 77, 121-130.
DE KRETSER, R., SCALES, P. J., BOGER, D. V., 1997. Improving clay-based tailings disposal: Case study on coal tailings.
Environ. Energy Eng. 43, 1894-1903.
DEASON, D. M., ONODA, G. Y., 1984. Controlled dispersion of clays and its effects on phosphate clay dewatering. Miner.
Metall. Process. 1, 149.
388 Physicochem. Probl. Miner. Process., 55(2), 2019, 380-388
EDWARDS, C. R., KIPKIE, W. B., AGAR, G. E., 1980. The effect of slime coatings of the serpentine minerals, chrysotile
and lizardite, on pentlandite flotation. Int. J. Miner. Process. 7, 33-42.
FARROKHPAY, S., 2012. The importance of rheology in mineral flotation: A review. Miner. Eng. 36–38, 272-278.
FARROKHPAY, S., NDLOVU, B., BRADSHAW, D., 2016. Behaviour of swelling clays versus non-swelling clays in
flotation. Miner. Eng. 96–97, 59-66.
HANG, P. T., BRINDLEY, G. W., 1970. Methylene blue absorption by clay minerals. Determination of surface areas and
cation exchange capacities (clay–organic studies XVIII). Clays Clay Miner. 18, 203-212.
HE, M., WANG, Y., FORSSBERG, E., 2004. Slurry rheology in wet ultrafine grinding of industrial minerals: a review.
Powder Technol. 147, 94-112.
LIM, J., DE KRETSER, R. G., SCALES, P. J., 2009. Investigating the influence of total electrolyte concentration and sodium–
calcium ion competition on controlled dispersion of swelling clays. Int. J. Miner. Process. 93, 95-102.
OATS, W. J., OZDEMIR, O., NGUYEN, A. V., 2010. Effect of mechanical and chemical clay removals by hydrocyclone and
dispersants on coal flotation. Miner. Eng. 23, 413-419.
PASHLEY, R. M., QUIRK, J. P., 1984. The effect of cation valency on DLVO and hydration forces between macroscopic
sheets of muscovite mica in relation to clay swelling. Colloids and Surf. 9, 1-17.
PATRA, P., BHAMBHANI, T., NAGARAJ, D. R., SOMASUNDARAN, P., 2012. Impact of pulp rheological behavior on
selective separation of Ni minerals from fibrous serpentine ores. Colloids and Surf., A: Physicochemical and
Engineering Aspects. 411, 24-26.
POLAT, M., POLAT, H., CHANDER, S., 2003. Physical and chemical interactions in coal flotation. Int. J. Miner. Process.
72, 199-213.
SHABALALA, N. Z. P., HARRIS, M., LEAL FILHO, L. S., DEGLON, D. A., 2011. Effect of slurry rheology on gas
dispersion in a pilot-scale mechanical flotation cell. Miner. Eng. 24, 1448-1453.
TANIHARA, K., NAKAGAWA, M., 1973. Flocculation treatment of waste-water containing montmorillonite. 2.
Flocculation of bentonite suspension of swelling with inorganic electrolyte. Nippon Kagakukai shi, Japan.
WANG, B., PENG, Y., 2013. The behaviour of mineral matter in fine coal flotation using saline water. Fuel. 109, 309-315.
WANG, B., PENG, Y., 2014. The interaction of clay minerals and saline water in coarse coal flotation. Fuel. 134, 326-332.
WANG, Y., PENG, Y., NICHOLSON, T., LAUTEN, R. A., 2015. The different effects of bentonite and kaolin on copper
flotation. Appl. Clay Sci. 114, 48-52.
XING, Y., GUI, X., CAO, Y., WANG, Y., XU, M., WANG, D., LI, C., 2017. Effect of compound collector and blending
frother on froth stability and flotation performance of oxidized coal. Powder Technol. 305, 166-173.
XU, Z., LIU, J., CHOUNG, J. W., ZHOU, Z., 2003. Electrokinetic study of clay interactions with coal in flotation. Int. J.
Miner. Process. 68, 183-196.