2016 Radiation Protection Studies
2016 Radiation Protection Studies
net/publication/310843718
CITATIONS READS
4 929
8 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Domiziano Mostacci on 19 January 2017.
INTRODUCTION
geometry set-ups. Moreover, these guidelines consider
Cyclotrons are widely established in research sites the problems ‘one at a time’, without a comprehensive
and in the biomedical field. In the latter, cyclotrons overview. In other cases, published results are general-
support both diagnostic and therapeutic applica- ised from meta-analysis on existing facilities, as
tions: in the diagnostic field, they are employed for reported by Tesch(3), or are based on general hypoth-
the production of radionuclides for clinical use, in esis on the source term(4, 5). Experimental measure-
particular tracers for Positron Emission Tomography ments of the neutron dose field around PET
(PET); while in hadron therapy cyclotrons are used cyclotrons(6) and the neutron energy spectrum(7–10)
to accelerate protons or heavy ions. can be useful sources of information, but inevitable
In the planning stage of a facility, the aspects differences in equipment, configuration and layout
related to radiation safety are key factors: an accurate should be carefully considered when planning new
‘a priori’ knowledge of the radiation field around the facilities, since generalisation of experimental results
accelerator is essential for the design of shielding (in is not straightforward.
particular as far as ‘bad geometry’ conditions are con- Given the complexity of the physical phenomena
cerned, like mazes, ducts and wall penetrations), the involved in the transport of radiations, the availabil-
selection of appropriate engineered controls and ity of Monte Carlo (MC) codes with accurate and
safety systems, the classification of areas and the pro- up-to-date libraries for radiation transport and inter-
tection of workers, the public and the environment (1). action of neutrons and charged particles at energies
Guidelines for site planning and installation, as well below 250 MeV, together with the continuously
as for radiation protection (RP) assessment, are given increasing power of modern computers, allows the
in a number of international documents; however, systematic use of simulations with realistic geom-
these well-established guides typically discuss analyt- etries. This provides the evaluation of the source
ical methods of calculation of both shielding and term specific for the site and the type of equipment,
materials activation(2), in approximate or idealised the assessment of shielding requirements, the
© The Author 2016. Published by Oxford University Press. All rights reserved. For Permissions, please email: [email protected]
A. INFANTINO ET AL.
perspective estimation of activation of the acceler- pressure transducers and liquid target fillers are
ator itself and the building materials and the assess- located at the Target Panel. The Target Panel is
ment of all the quantities relevant to RP at the same mounted in front of the cyclotron, close to the tar-
time(11). FLUKA(12, 13) is a general purpose code to gets and includes a slab of 5 cm thick lead and 10 cm
model particle transport and interaction with matter; thick polyethylene, both enclosed in a structure of
it covers an extended range of applications spanning iron. The cyclotron, not provided with self-shielding,
from proton and electron accelerators shielding to cal- is installed in a bunker with inner dimensions of
orimetry, dosimetry, detector design, radiotherapy and 650 cm by 535 cm and a height of 350 cm, while the
more. Even if the high-energy physics remains its main concrete walls are 200 cm thick. Data on dimensions
field of application, the number of publications in and features of the cyclotron, its main components
which FLUKA has been used in the medical field has and the bunker were taken from technical data sheets
recently increased, covering the production of medical of the manufacturer and the project drawings of the
radioisotopes(14–16), as well as proton and ion therapy site.
applications(17, 18) and radiation safety design(11, 19, 20)
at this low energy range. Given the main energy range
2
RP FLUKA STUDIES FOR MEDICAL CYCLOTRONS
Figure 1. (a) Section of the 3D FLUKA MC model of the PETtrace cyclotron and the cyclotron vault at S. Orsola-
3
A. INFANTINO ET AL.
Table 1. Comparison of neutron ambient dose equivalent and small differences in the modelling of the cycl-
H*(10) obtained from MC simulations and experimental otron components, FLUKA simulation provided an
measurements.
excellent agreement with the experimental measu-
rements and allowed an accurate estimation of the
Position Dose ± uncertainty (mSv μAh−1) neutron dose field.
FHT-752 CR39 FLUKA
4
RP FLUKA STUDIES FOR MEDICAL CYCLOTRONS
A validated MC model is particularly useful, com- account a realistic workload of the accelerator. The
pared with analytical methods, in cases of ‘bad long-activation of the two local shielding is reported
geometry’ conditions. In Figure 3, the transmission in Figure 4. The radionuclidic inventory was assessed
of dose through the duct of the air exhaust is shown at the EOB and after 4 weeks to take into account a
as a representative example of these situations. representative waiting time before the beginning of
Alternative solutions were then studied and imple- the decommissioning of the site. The quantification
mented in the MC model: the position and the orien- of long half-life radionuclides is important not only
tation of the pipe through the wall were changed to for the RP of workers involved in the decommission-
satisfy planning and RP requirements. Figure 3 also ing, but also to assess the volume of radioactive wa-
shows the final configuration with no significant ste. According to the Italian legislation for RP, a
transmission through the duct. The case reported mixture of radionuclides has to be treated as radio-
here is a typical example of critical situations in active waste if the sum of the ratios between the
which analytical methods fail given the complexity activity concentration, expressed in Bq g−1, of a given
of the geometry and hypothesis made on the source radionuclide and the limit activity concentration is
term of radiation. Using a validated MC model, it is >1 or if radionuclides with a half-life >75 d are pre-
Figure 3. (a) First version of the planning of the TR19 cyclotron vault: a transmission of the dose through the pipe of the
out-coming ventilation was identified. (b) Optimisation of the position and the orientation of the pipe through the wall
allowed avoiding any significant transmission of dose.
5
A. INFANTINO ET AL.
sight of the need for a careful choice of the physics of RP and the study of feasibility and efficiency of
and transport parameters adopted, as well as an new radionuclides production methodologies.
accurate validation of the set-up simulated by com-
parison with experimental measurements.
In this work it is discussed the application of MC
simulation to the energy range of particle accelerators REFERENCES
of medical interest. This work shows that it is pos- 1. ICRP, 2007. The 2007 Recommendations of the
sible to accurately predict the quantities of radio- International Commission on Radiological Protection.
logical interest in the energy range of biomedical ICRP Publication 103. Ann. ICRP 2007; 37(2–4).
cyclotrons, in a unitary and comprehensive approach, 2. NCRP, 2003. Radiation Protection for Particle
more satisfactory compared with analytical methods. Accelerator Facilities: Recommendations of the National
The availability of an experimentally validated MC Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements.
model, in terms of physical and transport parameters NCRP report; no. 144, (Bethesda, MD).
3. Tesch, K. A simple estimation of the lateral shielding for
in the energy range of medical applications, makes it proton accelerators in the energy range 50 to 1000 MeV.
possible to revise the traditional approach to the Radiat. Prot. Dosimetry 11(3), 165–172 (1985).
assessment of RP problems. Currently, MC simula- 4. Birattari, C., Bonardi, M., Ferrari, A. and Silari, M.
tion can therefore be considered the ‘state of art’ in Neutron activation of air by a biomedical cyclotron and
the planning of new biomedical cyclotron installa- an assessment of dose to neighbourhood populations.
tions, being a powerful tool for both the optimisation Radiat. Prot. Dosim. 14(4), 311–319 (1985).
6
RP FLUKA STUDIES FOR MEDICAL CYCLOTRONS
5. Birattari, C., Ferrari, A., Parnell, C.J. and Silari, M. The 89Zr production using the Monte Carlo code FLUKA.
environmental release of radioactive gases produced by App. Radiat. Isot. 69, 1134–1137 (2011).
neutron activation of air with the new Hammersmith cyclo- 15. Infantino, A., Oehlke, E., Mostacci, D., Schaffer, P.,
tron. Radiat. Prot. Dosimetry 19(3), 183–186 (1987). Trinczek, M. and Hoehr, C. Assessment of the produc-
6. Gallerani, R., Cicoria, G., Fantuzzi, E., Marengo, M. tion of medical isotopes using the Monte Carlo code
and Mostacci, D. Neutron production in the operation FLUKA: simulations against experimental measure-
of a 16.5 MeV PETtrace cyclotron. Pro. Nucl. Energy ments. Nuclear instruments and methods in physics.
50, 939–943 (2008). Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. B. 366, 117–123
7. Silari, M., Agosteo, S., Beck, P., Bedogni, R., Cale, E., (2016).
Caresana, M., Domingo, C., Donadille, L., Dubourg, N., 16. Oranj, L.M., Kakavand, T., Sadeghi, M. and Rovias,
Esposito, A. et al. Intercomparison of radiation protection M.A. Monte Carlo FLUKA code simulation for study
devices in high-energy stray neutron field. Part III: of 68Ga production by direct proton-induced reaction.
Instrument response. Radiat. Meas. 44, 673–691 (2009). Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics. Nucl.
8. Guimarães, A.M., Lacerda, M.A.S., Santos, J.A.L., Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A 677, 22–24 (2012).
Maletta, P.G.M., Rodrigues, S.L.M., Andrade, R.S., 17. Battistoni, G., Cappucci, F., Bertolino, N., Brambilla,
Vilela, E.C. and da Silva, T.A. Use of a TLD-based M.G., Mainardi, H.S. and Torresin, A. FLUKA Monte