Science, Technology and Society Reviewer
Science, Technology and Society Reviewer
▪ LG mobile app controlling LG Washer, LG ▪ Mid – 8th century – first wind powered automata
Dryer and LG TV were built in Baghdad
- LG’s HomeChat Brings Remote Control of Smart
Appliances to Your Smart Phone
▪ 827, Caliph Al- Ma’mun – silver and golden tree
▪ US Navy Close in Weapon Systems in his palace in Baghdad with metal birds that sang
- A close-in weapon system (CIWS), often automatically on the swinging branches.
pronounced "sea-whiz", is a point-defense weapon
system for detecting and destroying short-range ▪ 1495 – Leonardo da Vinci sketched complex
incoming missiles and enemy aircraft which have automaton that could, if built successfully, move its
penetrated the outer defenses, typically mounted arms, twist its head, and sit up.
shipboard in a naval capacity. Nearly all classes of
modern warships are equipped with some kind of
CIWS device. ▪ Writing automata
- They are considered to be among the remote
History of Artificial Intelligence ancestors of modern computers.
▪ AI discussions date from ancient Egypt
▪ Talking Heads – Middle Ages
▪ Astrolab – Early navigation instruments - “The earliest speaking machines were perceived as
the heretical works of magicians and thus as attempts
▪ 6th BC – Greek & Roman moving statues using
to defy God.
water
▪ Middle Ages –mechanical talking heads - 13th century Albertus Magnus created a head that
could talk, which was destroyed by St. Thomas
▪ Renaissance “automatons” that could write Aquinas, a former student of his, as an abomination.
▪ There are many examples of automata in Greek - Roger Bacon produced one as well.
mythology:
- 16th – 17th century – Miguel de Cervantes’s
- Hephaestus created automata for his described a head that spoke to Don Quixote – with
workshop; Talos was a giant automaton made the help of a tube that led to the floor below.
of bronze to protect Europa in Crete from pirates
and invaders.
- 18th century –science removed connection to magic,
and the problem of artificial speech was taken up by
inventors of a more mechanical bent.”
- Turochamp (1940) is a chess program and the
▪ Talking Heads – 19th cent first game developed for a computer.
- December 1845, Joseph Faber exhibited his - The Mancher Mark 1 (1948) – the first stored –
“Wonderful Talking Machine” at the Musical Fund program computer and described as “electronic
Hall in Philadelphia. brain”
- A bizarre – looking talking head that spoke in a - Artificial Intelligence (1950) – the possibility of
“weird, ghostly monotone” as Faber manipulated it creating a machine that can think.
with foot pedals and a keyboard.
The Turing Test
▪ Babbage ‘s Difference Engine ▪ 1950 – Turing in landmark paper
speculating about creating machines with
- 1823 – Charles Babbage true intelligence.
- Designed the first computer
- Although partially incomplete, his Difference Devised his famous Turing Test:
Engine worked. o “If a machine could carry on a
- Ada King, Countess of Lovelace and daughter of conversation (over a teletype) that was
Lord Byron, wrote programs for the Difference indistinguishable from a conversation
Engine, thus becoming the world’s first with a human being, then the machine
programmer. could be called “intelligent”.
- Programming language ADA was named after her.
o This allowed Turing to argue that a
“thinking machine” was plausible and
History of Artificial Intelligence answered objections
▪ 1941 – digital computer electronic computer o The Turing Test was the first serious
developed in 1941 proposal in the philosophy of artificial
intelligence.
▪ 1956 – term “Artificial intelligence” coined at the
Dartmouth conference ▪ “A computer would deserve to be called
intelligent if it could deceive a human into
believing that it was huma”
▪ Artificial Intelligence has expanded because of the - ALAN TURING
theories and principles developed by its dedicated
researchers.
Alan Turing
Negative Effects of STI on Human Flourishing - The MDGs served as a global framework for the
▪ Medical Science – atomic bomb needed action to be done to address the
- The atomic bombing of Hiroshima on August 6 challenges. For fifteen years, the framework had
helped induce significant progress across all
and Nagasaki on August 9, 1945 was one of the
goals and had improved millions of lives due to
darkest sides of the history of science, technology
coordinated efforts of individuals from local to
and innovations during the World War II. The
global levels. Much had been improved but much
effect of the bombs was so devastating that it
are also yet to improve. The result of the post-
killed over 200,000 innocent civilians and almost
2015 process paved way for a new global agenda
wipeout the two cities; however, the bombings
that would take the world on a more sustainable
ended the World War II (Praino, 2015).
pathway.
▪ Computers (Internet)
– internet, computers games, and the social media SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENTAL GOALS
have affected the social interactions among
young people. Internet helps to faster - The rising of inequalities within and among
communication. However, internet has brought countries, global health threats, and climate
many negative effects such as the promotion of change, together with other key challenges
pornography, human trafficking, and spread of prevents all countries to achieve sustainable
piracy, and computer addiction which can result development. Hence, the launching of the process
to violent behavior. called “Post-2015 Development Agenda” built
around the concept of sustainable development
▪ Environmental contamination and destruction and universally applicable SDGs to be achieved
- may come from resource extraction to produce by all countries.
the new technological products and toxic
byproducts from the process including castoff Goal 1. End poverty in all its forms everywhere
from obsolete technology were dump Goal 2. End hunger achieve food security and
indiscriminately in rivers, streams, oceans, and in improved nutrition and promote sustainable
land. . agriculture
Goal 3. Ensure healthy lives and promote well-
being for all at all ages
-
Goal 4. Ensure inclusive and equitable quality - The SDG index allows countries to benchmark
education and promote lifelong learning themselves with the use of a single holistic
opportunities for all measure that encompasses all SDGs as well as to
Goal 5. Achieve gender equality and empower all treat each of the goals equally.
women and girls
Goal 6. Ensure availability and sustainable STI IN TIMES OF CRISIS
management of water and sanitation for all
Goal 7. Ensure access to affordable, reliable, (Application of Science during a global pandemic)
sustainable and modern energy for all
Goal 8. Promote sustained, inclusive and ▪ COVID-19 Pandemic
sustainable economic growth, full and productive - This pandemic has exposed the crisis in global
employment and decent work for all health systems. And while it is severely
Goal 9. Build resilient infrastructure, promote undermining prospects for achieving SDG 3 by
inclusive and sustainable industrialization and 2030, it is also having far-reaching effects on all
foster innovation other SDGs.
Goal 10. Reduce inequality within and among
countries - Emerging evidence of the broader impact of the
Goal 11. Make cities and human settlements crisis on our quest to achieve the SDGs is
inclusive, safe, resilient and sustainable troubling. UNESCO estimates that some 1.25
Goal 12. Ensure sustainable consumption and billion students are affected, posing a serious
production patterns challenge to the attainment of SDGs Goal 4
Goal 13. Take urgent action to combat climate (Quality Education); and the International Labour
change and its impacts* Organisation (ILO) estimates some 25 million
Goal 14. Conserve and sustainably use the people could lose their jobs, with those in
oceans, seas and marine resources for sustainable informal employment suffering most from lack of
development social protection. Unfortunately, these are just the
Goal 15. Protect, restore and promote sustainable tip of the iceberg.
use of terrestrial ecosystems, sustainably manage
forests, combat desertification, and halt and
reverse land degradation and halt biodiversity - Crucially, in many parts of the world, the
loss pandemic and its effects are exacerbated by the
Goal 16. Promote peaceful and inclusive crisis in achieving clean water and sanitation
societies for sustainable development, provide targets (SDG 6), weak economic growth and the
access to justice for all and build effective, absence of decent work (SDG 8), pervasive
accountable and inclusive institutions at all levels inequalities (SDG 10), and above all, entrenched
Goal 17. Strengthen the means of poverty (SDG 1) and food insecurity (SDG 2).
implementation and revitalize the Global The World Bank estimates the crisis will push
Partnership for Sustainable Development some 11 million people into poverty.
STI in ACTION
SDG Progress Worldwide Rank
▪ Thai hospitals are deploying “ninja robots” to do
the temperature checking and ease the burden of
- From 2017-2019, the consistent top 20
those in the frontlines.
placeholders in achieving the goals are Sweden,
- The robots were created to monitor stroke
Denmark, Finland, Norway, Germany,
patients but were modified to help fight COVID-
Switzerland, France, Austria, Netherlands,
19 by allowing the doctors and nurses to
Iceland, United Kingdom, Belgium, Ireland,
communicate with the patients through the screen
Czech Republic, Slovenia, Japan, and Canada.
via video chatting.
- Sweden topped the ranking for the 2019 SDG
▪ Malaysian scientists have developed a
Index Report ranking (Figure 11.3), with 85.2%
“Medibot” created for health workers in treating
of the way to achieving its goals. Asia-Pacific
COVID-19 patients without risking infection.
countries Japan (78.9%) and South Korea
- Mounted with a camera and screen, the Medibot
(78.3%) secured spots in the Top 20 as well. The
can do the rounds and patients can communicate
Philippines ranked lower this time (97th) with an
remotely with the medics.
average achievement score of 64.9%, compared
to the 2017 and 2018 report, where it ranked 95th
(55.5%) and 85th (65.0%), respectively. The
purpose of this SDG index didn't intend to
compare countries since each country has
different development status.
▪ Developed by H-plus Yangji Hospital in the city's What is development?
Gwanak-gu District, this single-person booth was How can you say that a country is a
launched in Seoul, South Korea to test for developed one?
COVID-19. Does a country’s happiness measure by
- this single-person booth to test for COVID-19 is development?
700mm wide, 700mm long and 2,050mm high
and has a sound pressure facility and UV lamp. - We were raised to believe that life expectancy
and happiness are measured by how much
- Doctors safely swab a sample from the patient income one has – using a country’s growth
inside the booth using gloves equipped on the domestic product (GDP) to measure well-being.
booth and talk to the patient via intercom.
Growth Domestic Product (GDP)
- Many have believed in the idea that economic
How about in the Philippines? growth is synonymous with well-being; but a
disagreeing view were expressed by those who
▪ The GenAmplify™ COVID-19 rRT-PCR really recognize what GDP is among the most
detection kit, which is a low-cost counterpart, common indicators used to gauge the health of a
only Php 1, 320 per test. nation’s economic situation which includes
several different factors like consumption and
- Developed by 15 scientists from the Philippines investment
Genome Center and the UP Manila's National
Institutes of Health led by Dr. Raul V. Destura. ▪ “People are the real wealth of nations”, stated at
the first Human Development Report (HDR) in
▪ FEASIBILITY ANALYSIS OF SYNDROMIC 1990.
SURVEILLANCE USING SPATIO-
TEMPORAL EPIDEMIOLOGICAL MODELER ▪ Then-US Presidential candidate Robert
FOR EARLY DETECTION OF DISEASES Kennedy said it best as he addressed an election
rally in 1968 when he noted that GDP “measures
- FASSSTER aims to create a hub for different data everything in short, except that which makes life
sources (Disease records, environmental worthwhile.”
parameters, etc.), providing a rich layout of
integrated information that will facilitate in Human Development Index (HDI)
understanding the spread of diseases.
- This project is funded by the Philippine Council - an alternative single-number measure which
for Health Research and Development (DOST- captures the progress in health, education and
PCHRD). Currently, FASSSTER is being living standards – the three basic dimensions of
mobilized as a response to COVID-19 and is human development.
already a part of the Data Analytics Technical - HDI cannot replace the SDG targets and
Working Group of the Inter-agency Task Force indicators; however, the index can give
(IATF) for the Management of Emerging preliminary indication if nations are progressing
Infectious Diseases. against many of the SDGs.
- Moreover, DOST-ASTI is also supporting the - Pedro Conceição, Director of the Human
development of a non-contact temperature-taking Development Report Office at UNDP, said that it
device that uses a medical-grade sensor, which is is true that all nations have agreed to the
helpful for those working in the frontline. The importance of the SDGs; nevertheless, the
thermal scanning devices come in three types. A pursuance of the goals and even the formulation
small one that can be attached to smartphones of policies in relation to the goals lies within a
using wire interfaces; another one that can also be nation’s identified priorities.
attached to smartphones but with a Bluetooth
interface; and one that is a modified wood
moisture meter that was retrofitted with a thermal
sensor. (No photo released yet for this
innovation)
Summary and Conclusion
▪ Science, Technology and Innovation have
positive and negative effects on humanity and
the environment.
▪ In the attainment of the SDGs, STI has a great
role to play.
▪ Quality of life improvement are not captured by
merely measuring life expectancy or literacy
rates.
▪ We all have responsibilities to share to achieve a
more developed and sustained environment
Science and Technology and Nation Building
▪ The pre-colonial alpha-syllabic script Baybayin ▪ Medical and pharmaceutical schools were
was a native writing system from native inhabitants established.
of Luzon and Visayas.
▪ Manual de Medicinas Caseras. - written by Father
▪ Farming, shipbuilding and mining were already Fernando de Santa María, first published in 1763.
evident.
▪ In 1590, the Universidad de San Ignacio was
▪ The Banaue Rice Terraces carved into the founded in Manila by the Jesuits, initially as the
mountains of Ifugao, dubbed presently as the “8th Colegio-Seminario de San Ignacio.
wonder of the world” it is a sophisticated irrigation
system by indigenous Ifugaos. ▪ By the second half of the 17th century, the
university was incorporated as a mere College of
▪ Intricate irrigation systems, harvesting water from Medicine and Pharmacy into the University of
the forests of the mountain tops, and an elaborate Santo Tomás.
farming system, reflect a mastery of engineering.
▪ The Universidad de San Carlos was founded in
▪ The Balanghai or Balangay or Butuan Boat is a Cebú by the Jesuits on August 1, 1595, initially named
plank boat adjoined by a carved-out plank edged as the Colegio de San Ildefonso.
through pins and dowels. It was first mentioned in
▪ With the opening of Suez Canal in 1869 travel to
the 16th Century in the Chronicles of Pigafetta, and
Spain become quicker, easier and more affordable,
is known as the oldest pre-Hispanic watercraft found and many Filipinos took advantage of it to continue
in the Philippines higher education in Spain and Europe, mostly in
Madrid and Barcelona.
B. Spanish Era (1521–1898)
▪ During this era the Philippine culture were ▪ Educated Filipinos a new social class raised, that
came to be known as the Ilustrados.
influenced greatly with Western culture, particularly
Spanish, the Spanish language and the Catholic - Filipino educated class during the Spanish
faith. colonial period in the late 19th century. The
most prominent of the Ilustrados:
▪ Spanish Missionaries are the teachers in schools:
1. José Rizal
The Augustinians in Cebu (1565); 2. Graciano López Jaena
Franciscans (1577), The Jesuits (1581); 3. Marcelo H. del Pilar
Dominicans (1587). 4. Mariano Ponce or Antonio Luna.
✓ Scale of resource use and pollution • The rise of dynamic new industries based on
generation scientific breakthroughs:
“Prosumers”
Online Databases
SUMMING UP…
❖ Change in relationships
Egyptians Chinese
What is the Scientific Revolution? • Earth’s rotation accounts for the apparent
daily rotation of the stars.
-The Scientific Revolution develops as an
offshoot of the Renaissance. The same • The apparent annual cycle of movements of
questioning spirit that fueled the Renaissance the sun is caused by the earth orbiting it.
led scientists to question traditional beliefs and
• The apparent retrograde motion of the
the Church about the workings of the universe.
planets is caused by the motion of the Earth
It was a new way of thinking about the natural
from which one observes the planets.
world.
Johannes Kepler (1571 - 1630)
♦ Before 1500, the Bible and Aristotle were the
only authorities accepted as truth • proved Copernicus was right through
mathematics. To do this he needed to
♦ A geocentric model of the universe, in which gather a lot of information. He uses
the Earth is at the center was supported during night observations (over the span of
the Middle Ages years).
Technology that helped the Scientific • uses his information to make accurate
Revolution models of the heavens
• demonstrates that planets move in an
• Printing press spread new ideas elliptical orbit… not a circular orbit that
• Age of Exploration fueled a great deal of Copernicus had previously said.
scientific research because of • determined the cause of Earth’s tide –
technology needed for navigation moon.
• Translation of the works of Muslim • formulated the inverse square law of
scholars opened the minds of European light intensity
thinkers to new scientific knowledge
Galileo Galilei (1564 – 1642)
New Ideas About the Universe
• Considered the father of experimental
Nicholas Copernicus (1473-1543) science
-A mathematician who could read Greek and • Gravity accelerates all objects equally,
used Ptolemy’s data to plot the orbits. whatever their mass.
• Discovered the principle of inertia
-Declared “In the center of it all rests the Sun” • Was the first person to study the sky
– this overthrew the hierarchy of the ancient with a telescope.
and medieval cosmos
• Discovered Jupiter’s moon- Galilean
-Proposed the heliocentric theory. He took as Satellites
the basic starting points of his theory: • Discovered that Venus has phases like
the moon, ranging from a thin crescent
• The earth is not the center of the universe. to full.
• The center of the universe is near the sun. • Discovered the rings of Saturn
• Discovered our moon has mountains.
• Discovered that the Milky Way is made • showed that the tides are caused by
up of stars gravitational interactions between the
• Known to discover planet Neptune but earth and the moon.
thought it’s a star.
Creationism VS Darwin
Rene Descartes (1596-1650)
Creationism
• Father of Modern Western Philosophy
• God is absolute creator of all
• Promoted science grounded in
• God is constantly involved in creation
observation and experiment
• 6 days of creation
• Created a mechanistic view of nature
• Coined the term “Molecule” Darwin
• Never accept anything as true until all
• World due to evolution
reasons for doubt can be ruled out.
• Organisms evolved from simpler forms
• Divide problems into as many parts as
possible and necessary to provide an • Survival of the fittest
adequate solution. Charles Darwin (1809-1882)
• Thoughts should be ordered, starting
with the simplest and easiest to know, • 1844 - Proposed the theory of evolution
ascending little by little, and, step by (Origin of the Species)
step, to more complex knowledge. • 1858 – Darwin’s friends arranged for
• Make enumerations so complete, and the simultaneous publication of Wallace
reviews so general, that nothing is and Darwin’s Natural Selection
omitted. • 1889 – Wallace published his book on
• Connected algebra and geometry natural selection which he called
Darwinism.
What does an apple have to do with gravity? • Evidence supporting evolution prior to
- Newton was sitting in the shade of an apple Darwin
tree when an apple fell nearby. Newton began • Fossils – replicas of living things
to wonder why apples always fall to the ground. • Geologic history
Why don’t the fall sideways or up? Newton • Species change by Lamarck
reasoned that the earth must have a power that Edwin Hubble (1889 – 1953)
draws objects to it. This was the beginning of
the law of gravity and motion. • 1925 discover galaxies through a
telescope and change the way we look
Isaac Newton (1643 - 1727) at our universe.
• Law of Universal Gravitation • Demonstrated that universe are
• Laws of Motion expanding (one of the most
• Corpuscular Theory cosmological discoveries ever made)
• Calculus – the mathematics of change • Hubble’s Law – galaxies are moving
• Wrote Philosophiae Naturalis Principia away from the Milky Way at a speed
Matimatica directly proportional to their distance
• built the world’s first working reflecting from it.
telescope.
Albert Einstein (1879 – 1955) James Watson and Francis Crick
• provided powerful evidence that atoms - interpreted the photos to figure out
and molecules actually exist that the DNA was a twisted double helix
• explained the photoelectric effect,
All 4 co-discovered the double-helix structure of
proposing that light came in bundles.
DNA - the basis of modern Biotechnology
Bundles of light (he called them quanta)
Watson, Wilkins and Crick received the Nobel
with the correct amount of energy can
Prize in Physiology in 1962.
eject electrons from metals.
• Proved that the measure of the speed
of light to be 300 million meters per
second in a vacuum. This led to the
strange new reality that time passes
more slowly for people traveling at very
high speeds compared with people
moving more slowly.
• E = mc2 - which showed that energy
and matter can be converted into one
another.
• rewrote the law of gravitation, which
had been unchallenged since Isaac
Newton published it in 1687. In his
General Theory of Relativity, Einstein:
Einstein’s wish
1. Science is a system of beliefs - FALSE • There is no doubt that scientists rely heavily
on their imagination in carrying out their work.
• Many students, teachers and the general
public believe that science is a system of beliefs • Creative imagination has always been
important part of science.
• What distinguishing science is its continuing
search for evidence in natural phenomena. • Scientists draw upon their imagination and
creativity to visualize how nature works, using
• Although we naturally look for evidence to
analogies, metaphors, and mathematics.
support ideas, scientific ideas are established
only after compelling evidence has accumulated • Scientists are often stereotyped as nerdy,
from observation of nature. serious – looking individuals in lab coats,
conducting laboratory experiments that require
• Scientists use reasoning and imagination,
superior intellect to be understood.
study the work of other scientist and
collaborate with others, always looking for • It is easy to forget that it requires imagination
evidence to support or disprove their ideas. to see the problem and possible solution.
• Rather than a belief system, science is based 4. Scientists are totally objective in their work -
on empirical evidence provided by observations FALSE
of the natural world.
• Many believe that scientists are totally
2. Most scientists are men because males are objective in their work.
better at scientific thinking - FALSE
• Scientists like all other humans, are attached
• There is no evidence that men are inherently to their work.
better at science.
• They have been known to look for evidence to
• This idea is a remnant of historical prejudice support their favored or promising ideas,
and not true understanding of the history and sometimes overlooking and even rejecting that
nature of science. are contrary to their own beliefs.
• In many societies, this attitude often makes it • No indications that scientists actively practice
difficult or impossible for girls and women to programs to search for disconfirming evidence.
pursue science, to the point that a female (As Popper says Science can advance only
scientist like astronomer Caroline Hershel through a string of what he called conjectures
(1750-1848) had to disseminate her research and refutations)
through her brother William and John.
• theory-laden observation (a psychological
• Although women are still a minority in some notion)
fields, women like Marie Curie, Rosalind
• the allegiance to the paradigm.
Franklin and many others stand among the
giants of modern science.
5. The scientific method is the accepted guide • Not all of the supports from theories comes
for conducting research - FALSE from experiments.
• For many years scientists have tried to correct Examples: Big Bang Theory, Plate Tectonic
the idea that the scientific method is the only Theory, The Expanding Universe, Darwin’s
correct way to do science. Theory of Evolution, Heliocentric Theory were
developed through observation rather than
• This “a method of science” has a strong hold
experiments.
in science teaching but is not science.
• Science uses all types of investigative
• Posters are still hung in science classrooms
procedures and evidence gathering which are
listing the steps of the scientific method and are
all subject under the lens of scientific
still used to judged students’ procedures in
community.
science fair competitions.
8. A hypothesis is an educated guess - FALSE
• There is no logical or procedural method by
which the pattern is suggested because if there • A hypothesis is often called an educated guess
is then it goes against the creative nature and but it is rather rigorous than a mere guess.
element of science. (Here, we may argue that a mere “guess” is
elevated to a higher degree by the word
• Scientific papers seem to follow the scientific
educated.)
method but are reconstructed to account for
key elements of the study. • A guess is usually thought of as a judgment
with little information.
• The actual events for any investigations vary
considerably and may take many wrong turns • Scientist usually know a great deal of
and dead ends. information about a phenomenon before
forming a hypothesis to be subjected to test.
6. Experiments are carried out to prove cause
and-effect relationships - FALSE • “In the scientific world, the hypothesis
typically is formulated only after hours of
• At first, this statement seems correct, but,
observation, days of calculating and studying,
however, the statement is flawed.
and sometimes years of research into the
• In science, though nothing stands as proven or phenomena of interest” (Galus 2003).
completely true.
9. A theory becomes a law when it is
• Controlled experiments only provide evidence supported by a great deal of scientific evidence
that either supports or fails to add support to a - FALSE
hypothesis, not absolute proof. These
• Laws and theories are distinct types of
contribute to the cause and effect that can be
knowledge.
durable but tentative, always awaiting further
evidence. • Laws do not become theories nor do theories
become laws.
7. All scientific ideas are discovered and tested
by controlled experiments - FALSE • Laws describe a phenomenon or pattern in
nature. Laws hold true under most conditions,
• It is a myth that the most credible scientific
but can be modified or discredited.
theories are supported by controlled
experiments. • A theory is used to explain a phenomenon.
• Theories pertain to complex events and • Today science and technology are closely
combine many facts, concepts, and laws to form associated, whereby technology supports the
scientific understandings. advancement of science and science supports
the progress of technology.
• A good example of this is the law of
conservation of mass in chemistry and the 12. In time, science can solve most of society’s
atomic theory used to explain it. problems.
10. Scientific ideas are tentative and can be • Science has improved life considerably for
modified or disproved but never proved - TRUE many people on the planet but not everyone in
the world.
• This is the reverse of item #6 and is true.
• Many problems in the world are political in
• Although Scientific theories are anchored on
nature, whereby individuals and governments
considerable number of evidences and are
promote or suppress economic and scientific
considered durable, they are considered
development in their country.
provisional and are subject to change and
rejection. • Science has provided us with the knowledge
of how to produce enough food to feed most of
• Theories are inferred explanations and science
the world’s hungry, but getting the food to their
is a way of knowing that does not represent
mouths is a problem that transcends science.
absolute truth. This way of thinking removes
science from being an all-knowing human 13. All Work in Science is Reviewed to Keep the
enterprise. Process Honest - FALSE
• “They may survive these tests; but they can • Scientists are constantly reviewing each
never be positively justified: They can neither other's experiments to check up on each other
be established as certainly true nor even as but unfortunately, while such a check and
‘probable’” (Popper 1963, vii). balance system would be useful, the number of
findings from one scientist checked by others is
• However, scientific theories as ideas built on
vanishingly small.
shaky facts and flimsy evidence such that
science have held up to considerable scrutiny • Most scientists are simply too busy
and have shown to be durable.
• Research funds too limited for this type of
11. Technology preceded science in the history review.
of civilization - TRUE
• The result of the lack of oversight has recently
• Technology preceded science in the history of put science itself under suspicion.
civilizations.
• The enormous amount of original scientific
• Tool making for survival began long before research published, and the pressure to
man understood how or why they worked. produce new information rather than
reproduce others' work dramatically increases
• Technology invents devices and systems to aid
the chance that errors will go unnoticed.
in human survival and to improve life.
• Scientists rarely report valid, but negative
• Science provides a better fundamental
results and the failure to report what did not
understanding of nature.
work is a problem.
STS Unit 1, Chapter 1 Research Knowledge
AN INTRODUCTION TO SCIENCE
Research Knowledge requires that:
• SCIENCE
• All observations be repeatable by more
• KNOWLEDGE AND ITS TYPE
than (and different) observers
• WHAT IS A GOOD SCIENCE
• All hypotheses (guesses) are falsifiable.
• SCIENTIFIC METHOD
• Involves natural phenomena.
• MYTHS IN SCIENCE
• Research knowledge does not claim
What is Science? FACT. It claims logical circumstantial
explanations in light of the
• Science: Latin Scientia
requirements of the mentioned
• To Know --- verb
requirements.
• Systematic enterprise
• Build & organize knowledge Research Knowledge
• Testable explanations and predictions
▪ Ancient times--- Where did life come
about the world
from?
• “Unveiling nature” ▪ RESULT – several false theorems
• Gain KNOWLEDGE ▪ BUT: they weren’t stupid, simply limited
Knowledge • Do not say “this is true”, rather
“this is the most likely explanation
• It is a statement about what you accept in light of existing knowledge”.
as sufficiently “real” to allow you to
take action upon and thereby live your Spontaneous generation
life. • living things came forth from non-living
• Examine this statement: “Dragons are things because the non-living material
real”. contained pneuma, or "vital heat“ –
• What does YOUR KNOWLEDGE tell you? Aristotle
Types of Knowledge • libraries be placed facing eastwards to
benefit from morning light, but not
Belief Knowledge towards the south or the west as those
winds generate bookworms. - Vitruvius,
• Knowledge about the world is inherent
a Roman architect
and unique in each human being.
• It is attained by individual revelation. John Needham - performed a series of
• Is it open to testing, observation or experiments on boiled broths,
quantification?
Francisco Redi – one of the pioneers who
Research Knowledge conducted experiment that disproved SP.
The spirit of the individual who believes. • collecting information to test new ideas
or to disprove old ones.
Research Knowledge
• discover new things
>the methodology of observation and testing • explains something problem previously
allows one to choose one “fact” over another. not explained,
• overturns some previously accepted
Belief VS Research Knowledge
idea.
• Research Knowledge • get pay checks or promotion
Even when you have tons of evidence, doubt Why does a society devote some of its
what you see resources to this business of developing new
knowledge about the natural world?
• Belief Knowledge
What has motivated these scientists to
Even without a single piece of evidence, believe devote their lives to developing this new
in what you can’t see. knowledge?
The Research Knowledge: Fact Why do Science? Societal Perspective
• A mini – hypothesis, subject to testing by • the desire to improve people's lives
repeated observations. • society's desires for economic
• Perception of facts varies > > > doesn’t get development
easily accepted. • humanity's increasing control over our
• Some facts become dominant but others planet and its environment.
are open to testing. • societies support science because of
A hypothesis simple curiosity and because of the
satisfaction and enlightenment that
An explanation for the pattern created by two come from knowledge of the world
or more facts. around us.
> Based on observations
How Research becomes Scientific Knowledge Hallmark of good science: DOUBT