Unit 1 Workbook Evolution
Unit 1 Workbook Evolution
Unit 1 Workbook
How would biologists explain how the mice on the lava flow evolved black fur? Include all the elements
you think are needed for a full explanation.
Mice evolved black fur so as to camouflage with their surroundings. For mice that did not possess black fur, they
would typically be consumed by predators thus eliminating the traits found in these specific mice whereas those
that possessed the black fur phenotype would proliferate thus maintaining this specific phenotype among mice.
As more mice possess black fur and mate, it becomes the predominant fur color.
Would biologists say the mice changed because they wanted or needed to change? Why?
Biologists would say the mice changed because they needed to change. A desire for something would be similar
to the mice choosing preferential food whereas fur color is a survival adaption to continue living without being
preyed upon.
Inheritance The variation in the trait of interest is at Random mutation occurred in the MrC1 gene of
least partially inherited (passed from the rock pocket mouse causing a change in fur
parents to offspring). color which was then passed down to the
offspring of the mice that survived predation. After
The variation stems from random 1,000 years, almost 95% of all mice on the lava
mutations and the recombination that rocks had black fur.
accompanies sexual reproduction. The
genetic variation may have arisen many
generations in the past.
Differential More offspring are born than can survive. Within the population of pocket mice that
survival and Because of this, there is competition possessed black fur in the lava beds, there were
also those that did not maintain the gene that
reproduction among individuals within a population.
would promote black fur, thus maintaining a sand
Some individuals with a particular trait colored fur. For those specific mice, they were
are more likely to survive and / or have preyed upon. Via this natural selection, sand
relatively more offspring compared to colored mice reduced in population.
individuals that do not have that trait.
Selection depends on the specific context
of a species. Traits that are beneficial in
one environment may cause problems in
another environment.
Adaptation The frequency of the trait that helps Over the course of 1,000 years, the allele that
individuals survive or leave more expressed black fur in the rock pocket mice
increased in frequency until almost all mice
offspring will increase in the population
expressed the allele for black fur.
over time, as will the alleles that affect
the trait.
This process can take many generations
and extend over very long periods of
time.
CCSS.Math.Content.HSS.ID.A.1: Represent data with plots on the real number line (dot plots,
histograms, and box plots).
How could you emphasize these mathematical skills in your current science lessons?
Describe how the specific form of the trait found in a species is an adaptation to the species’ habitat.
Enter the values you calculated for the mean, standard deviation, standard error, and 95% CI for
relative hindlimb length.
Does hindlimb length vary among anoles from Iron Cay? Describe your evidence.
If long-legged lizards survived better than short-legged ones, how would you expect the mean leg
length of the population to change over time?
Which learning goals would be appropriate for your students for the mathematical analysis and
representation of the variation?
SUMMARIZING VARIATION
The Lesson Objectives stated that at the end of the lesson you will be able to
Describe the degree to which you achieved the objectives of this lesson. If there are still areas for you
to work on, what is your plan for getting more information or practice?
Below is one of those pedigrees. Look at the pedigree and then answer the questions below. (For a
refresher on pedigrees, refer to Appendix A on the last page of this workbook.)
I ? ? Family A
1 2
II ? ? ?
1 2 3 4 5 6
III
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
IV
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
V
1 2 3
Figure 2. Pedigree of Family A. (Adapted from a figure in Enattah, N. S., et al. 2002 Nature Genetics 30: 233-237.)
1. Based on the pedigree above, which of the following terms are appropriate for describing the
inheritance of the lactose-intolerance trait (filled-in symbols)? Check all that apply.
2. Which of the following terms are appropriate for describing the inheritance of the lactose-tolerance
trait (empty symbols)? Check all that apply.
3. Use the data in the pedigree and the terms listed in questions 1 and 2 to make a claim about how
lactose intolerance is inherited. Provide evidence to support your claim.
4. Study Individuals 5 and 6 of Generation III in Family A and their child. The two parents are lactose
tolerant, yet their son is lactose intolerant. Are these data consistent or inconsistent with the claim
you made in question 3? Explain your answer.
5. What other evidence would be valuable for understanding the extent to which lactase persistence is
inherited or not?
Tables 1 and 2 show DNA sequences from two short regions of DNA on chromosome 2. Because each
individual has two copies of chromosome 2 (one from each parent), each table includes two DNA sequences
per person. Individuals are identified by generation number and individual number. For example, Individual B
IV-4 is Individual 4, Generation IV in Family B.
*Sequence 1 is a nucleotide sequence corresponding to nucleotides 13923-13904 upstream from the start of the lactase gene.
*Sequence 2 is a nucleotide sequence corresponding to nucleotides 30192-30173 upstream of the start of the lactase gene.
1. Study the two tables above. Describe how the nucleotides differ between at least two sequences in
each table. Hint: Use the nucleotide numbers to help with your description.
2. Pretend that you are the researcher who discovered the variations and you are writing to a
colleague describing what you found.
a. How would you describe the variation(s) you found in Sequence 1?
3. Based on the sequence data you analyzed, which variation is associated with lactose tolerance
(lactase persistence)? Support your claim by providing using evidence.
4. Is the variation associated with lactose tolerance (lactase persistence) found on one chromosome or
both chromosomes in individuals with the trait? Explain your answer.
5. The mutation associated with lactose tolerance keeps the lactase gene turned on in adults. Based on
the sequence and pedigree data, what can you infer about the regulation of the lactase gene in
Individual A IV-3? Explain.
REFERENCES
Enattah, N. S., et al. 2002. Identification of a variant associated with adult-type hypolactasia. Nature Genetics 30:233-237.
Sahi, T. 2001. Genetics and epidemiology of adult-type hypolactasia with emphasis on the situation in Europe. Scandinavian
Journal of Nutrition 45:161-162.
Ingram C.J.E., et al. 2009. Lactose digestion and the evolutionary genetics of lactase persistence. Human Genetics 124: 579.
MUTATIONS IN ICEFISH
How would you characterize the relative size and type of mutation that initiated the evolution of the
antifreeze gene?
How would you characterize the relative size and type of mutations that caused icefish to lose their red
blood cells?
CAUSES OF MUTATIONS
Skin cancer is by far the most common type of cancer. Use what you learned to provide the scientific
reasoning that supports this observation.
Look back at the “Got Lactase?” section. Describe in as much detail as you can the type of mutation
that causes lactase persistence.
Why do you think discoveries of mutations in genetic regulatory regions are so common in studies of
the adaptation of species?
SHUFFLING ALLELES
Review the two learning objectives below. The first is from the Next Generation Science Standards for
high school life science. The second is from the AP Biology framework.
HS-LS3-2. Make and defend a claim based on evidence that inheritable genetic variations may result
from: (1) new genetic combinations through meiosis, (2) viable errors occurring during replication,
and/or (3) mutations caused by environmental factors. [Clarification Statement: Emphasis is on using
data to support arguments for the way variation occurs.]
Summarize how you can use the content you learned in this lesson and the resources you explored
from HHMI BioInteractive to help students achieve these learning goals.
In this activity, you will be testing the question, “What happens if all the offspring that are born
survive?”
1. Access HHMI BioInteractive’s Population Dynamics interactive available at
http://www.hhmi.org/biointeractive/population-dynamics. Read the introductory information and
then click on the Exponential Model. Again, read the introductory information and then
access the population simulator. Click on “How to Use” and review the aspects of the
model.
2. Explore the future of ducks known as mallards. Imagine that the world goes on a duck
hunting craze and there are only two mallards left in the world, one male and one female.
Mallards can have a clutch size of 10. The male and female breed and leave 10 offspring. To
keep our model simple, we will assume that the parents are not counted in the census of
the population. This results in a per capita population growth rate (r) = 1.6.
3. Input the beginning population No as 2 and r = 1.6. How many crows will there be in 4
years? In 10 years? In 20 years? (Note that you need to increase the maximum value for
Time (t) by selecting the “wheel icon.”)
4. Create your own scenario to further test the question “What happens if all the offspring
that are born survive?” and record your results.
5. Use evidence to support the claim that more offspring are born than can survive.
An important condition of evolution by natural selection is that more offspring are born than can
survive. Summarize the evidence you gathered from this activity that supports this claim.
Fitness is a measure of the relative ability of an individual to produce offspring that can themselves go
on to reproduce. This term causes many problems for students who confuse the meaning of fitness as
used by evolutionary biologists with the common meaning of fitness. Another common student idea
regarding fitness is that the fittest individuals are the fiercest, strongest, or biggest—but this is often
not the case. Fitness is about differential success in reproduction among individuals, and all kinds of
traits can increase fitness. How do you help students address these common ideas about fitness?
NGSS performance expectation MS-LS4-4 reads “Construct an explanation based on evidence that
describes how genetic variations of traits in a population increase some individuals’ probability of
surviving and reproducing in a specific environment.” Describe how you could use HHMI resources to
help students be successful with this expectation.
How would you design an experiment to support the hypothesis that elephant alarm calls increase
fitness for individuals that participate in the behavior?
What kinds of experiments or evidence could you use to help students develop the knowledge and
practice the skills to evaluate the role of behavior on survival and reproduction?
Which strategies will you use to have students interact with representations like the graph of the
changes in the percentages of mice of different fur colors?
100
black mice (%)
Frequency of
50
0
The Well
Christmas Pass
Lava (West)
Lava (Mid)
Lava (East)
O’Neil Pass
Rock pocket
mouse populations
Figure 2. The x-axis shows six different sites where rock pocket mice were collected. The locations on the lava
flow (west, mid, east) have dark soil. The other three locations (Christmas Pass, Tule Well, and O’Neill Pass) have
light soil. The y-axis shows the frequency of black mice. (Adapted from Hoekstra, Drumm, & Nachman, 2004.)
Calculate the percentage of tan mice in each population from the data in Table 1. Enter your
calculations in the last row below.
Table 1
Which populations show evidence for variation in fur color? Add the evidence to your Evolution by
Natural Selection Explanation Table as needed.
Describe how the evidence you collected relates to one or more of the major conditions for evolution
by natural selection.
20
Percent reflectance (%)
16
12
0
Two copies of One copy of Two copies of
allele 2 allele 1 allele 1
MC1R genotype
Figure 3. The relationship of genotype of rock pocket mice for the MC1R gene and fur color.
A higher value for reflectance means lighter fur. (Adapted from Hoekstra, Drumm, & Nachman, 2004.)
Make a claim about whether differences in fur color are inherited. Support your claim with evidence
from Figure 3. Add the evidence to your Evolution by Natural Selection Explanation Table as needed.
Also describe how the evidence relates to the major conditions for evolution by natural selection.
100
Frequency of MC1R
allele 2 (%)
50
0
The Well
Lava (West)
Lava (Mid)
Christmas Pass
Lava (East)
O’Neil Pass
Rock pocket
mouse populations
Figure 4. The genotype of rock pocket mice for the MC1R gene is different when the main background color of
the environment changes. (Adapted from Hoekstra, Drumm, & Nachman, 2004.)
Make a claim about whether the frequencies of alleles that affect fur color are different in populations
on light or dark backgrounds. Support your claim with evidence from Figure 4. Add the evidence to
your Evolution by Natural Selection Explanation Table as needed. Again, describe how the evidence
relates to the major conditions for evolution by natural selection.
Summary
Review your answer to the question in Unit 1, Lesson 1, “How would biologists explain how the mice
on the lava flow evolved black fur? Include all the elements you think are needed for a full
explanation.” Describe the number of conditions for natural selection you used in your initial answer.
Also describe the changes you would make to your answer based on what you’ve learned after
watching the video and analyzing additional evidence.
Write a short caption that would accompany the graph you made in the Lizard lab that includes the
means and standard deviation for the relative hindlimb length in anoles from the Iron Cay and
experimental islands. Optional. You may also want to include a screenshot of your graphs.
NGSS Performance expectation HS-LS4-2 reads “Construct an explanation based on evidence that the
process of evolution primarily results from four factors: (1) the potential for a species to increase in
number, (2) the heritable genetic variation of individuals in a species due to mutation and sexual
reproduction, (3) competition for limited resources, and (4) the proliferation of those organisms that
are better able to survive and reproduce in the environment.”
Describe how you could use the Lizard Virtual Lab as an assessment that includes science practices,
disciplinary core ideas, and crosscutting themes or the essential knowledge and science practices
outlined in the AP Biology Course Framework.
What types of data would you collect to determine whether the long horns on male dung beetle,
sometimes weighing up to 15% of the total weight of the animal, are the result of sexual selection?
GENETIC DRIFT
Explain why genetic drift is more prominent in small populations.
GENE FLOW
In tiger conservation, what are the problems of small population sizes?
What is the role of gene flow in Liz Hadly’s proposal to “merge” genetic diversity of tiger populations?
What effect might the proposed movement of genes have on local adaptation?
The NGSS Life Science standards and AP Biology Course Framework put a strong emphasis on natural
selection. Summarize what you have learned about supporting students in learning about natural
selection and HHMI BioInteractive resources available to support you and your students.
DECODING A PEDIGREE
SYMBOLS
Circles indicate females. Squares indicate males. A question mark indicates that
the person’s trait is unknown.
An unfilled symbol represents A filled symbol represents
someone without the trait someone who exhibits the trait A diagonal line indicates that
being studied. being studied. the person is deceased.
RELATIONSHIPS
I ?
1 2 A horizontal line
between two symbols
connects two parents.
II
Vertical lines connect
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
parents to children.
} Horizontal brackets
connect siblings.
III
1 2 3 4 5 6