0% found this document useful (0 votes)
317 views15 pages

First Appeal RTI

1) The appellant is filing a first appeal against the Public Information Officer (PIO) and Deputy Commissioner of Circle No. 13, Karwan, GHMC for not providing full and correct information sought in an RTI application. 2) The information provided by the PIO contained incorrect details like a payment date of 1900. Key information sought for property and building permissions was also not provided. 3) The appellant is requesting the appellate authority to instruct the PIO to provide the full and correct information sought in the original RTI application in the interest of transparency and justice.

Uploaded by

Advocate
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
317 views15 pages

First Appeal RTI

1) The appellant is filing a first appeal against the Public Information Officer (PIO) and Deputy Commissioner of Circle No. 13, Karwan, GHMC for not providing full and correct information sought in an RTI application. 2) The information provided by the PIO contained incorrect details like a payment date of 1900. Key information sought for property and building permissions was also not provided. 3) The appellant is requesting the appellate authority to instruct the PIO to provide the full and correct information sought in the original RTI application in the interest of transparency and justice.

Uploaded by

Advocate
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 15

TO,

THE FIRST APPELLATE AUTHORITY,


PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER &
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER, CIRCLE NO.13,
KARWAN,HYDERABAD, GHMC .

AN FIRST APPEAL U/S 19 (1) OF THE RTI ACT 2005


(within 30 days )
Respected Sir/Madam

(I) Name and address of the appellant : Afzaluddin Faroqui,


H.No 12-2-417/B/3, Jaya Nagar,
Guddimalkapur, Mehdipatnam
Hyderabad-500028
Mobile No: 7799402420

(ii) Name and address of the : Public Information Officer


Public Information Officer & Deputy Commissioner,
against the decision of whom : Circle No.13, Karwan,
the appeal is preferred GHMC

(iii) Particulars of the order including : Lr.No./RTI/TC13/GHMC/2023


number if any, against which the : Dated: 17-3-2023
appeal is preferred; : This office has not provided the
full and correct information
Sought by the appellant under
RTI Act

(iv) Brief facts leading to the appeal:-

Aggrieved by the information furnished, which are not correct and quite
contrary to the physical features.

1) In fact the GHMC authorities has provided the GHMC PT online


database, the Assessment History copy enclosed along with the order copy
Dated 17-03-2023 which is showing the Tax Assessment date and with
effected Date as 01-JAN-1900 in the payment details table cheque date is
shown as 01-JAN-1900 which is suspicious due to incorrect year mention in
the table. The details provided by the GHMC are not clear and correct.
2

2) PIO & Deputy Commissioner has not answer the Sl.No 2 in which the
appellant request for date of allotment of H.No:13-6-27/A Kulsumpura,
karwan hyderabad but it is no where mentioned in the order.

3) PIO & Deputy Commissioner has not answer the Sl.No.3 and given the
reason as Manual record not traced. if the records are not maintained by the
GHMC authorities properly than who is responsible for this act. and it's not the
mere excuse to refuse the information sought by the appellant.

4) PIO & Deputy Commissioner has not answer the Sl.No.4 and not even
mention the reason of not providing the details of Building permission given to
H.No.13-6-27/A.

(v) Prayer or relief sought:


To provide the proper information sought by the appellant under RTI
Act. with full and proper details. it is suspected that GHMC has altered the
records due to the year of record is shown as 1900 request to take an
appropriate action against the authorities who has altered the data and instruct
to issue the records. kindly instruct the PIO & Deputy Comissioner of Circle
13, karwan, hyderabad GHMC to answer the Sl.No 2 to 4 along with the
sketch plan of the building permission given to the H.No.13-6-27/A in the
interest of justice. if information is provided no prejudice will cause to the
GHMC.

(vi) Grounds for the prayer or relief : Against the false information
furnished by the PIO quite
contrary to the real facts and
not answer the Sl.No.2 to 4
(vii) Verification by the appellant; and:

I verify that the above information are true and correct to the best of my
knowledge and belief. Hence verified.

Appellant.
(Afzaluddin Faroqui)
3

(viii) any other information which the Commission may deem necessary for
deciding the appeal.

The appellant has requested for the information related to H.No.13-6-


27/A, Kulsumpura, Karwan Dated 22-02-2023 but GHMC has not provided
the full details rather providing the information sought by the appellant.
GHMC has provided the GHMC PT online Database which is not clear and
correct. it shows the year of Payment of Cheque as 1900. The information
furnished are not true and correct. The appeal is filed within (30) days from
the date of order. The requisite fee by way of Court fee stamp of Rs.10/- is
enclosed.

Therefore, it is prayed to take immediate action in the matter in the


interest of justice.

Dated: -0 -2023 Appellant.


Place: Hyderabad. Afzaluddin Faroqui
R/o H.No 12-2-417/B/3,
Jaya Nagar,Guddimalkapur,
Mehdipatnam, Hyderabad-500028
Mobile No: 7799402420

Copy enclosed
1. Order copy Dated 17-03-2023 Lr.No./RTI/TC13/GHMC/2023 from the
office of the PIO & Deputy comissioner Circle No.13, Karwan, GHMC,
Hyderabad.
2. RTI application Dated 22-02-2023 by Afzaluddin Faroqui
4

TO,
THE FIRST APPELLATE AUTHORITY,
PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER &
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER, CIRCLE NO.13,
KARWAN,HYDERABAD,
ZONAL COMMISSIONER, KHAIRTABAD,
HYDERABAD,GHMC .

AN FIRST APPEAL U/S 19 (1) OF THE RTI ACT 2005


(within 30 days )
Respected Sir/Madam

(I) Name and address of the appellant: Afzaluddin Faroqui,


H.No 12-2-417/B/3, Jaya Nagar,
Guddimalkapur, Mehdipatnam,
Hyderabad-500028
Mobile No: 7799402420

(ii) Name and address of the : Public Information Officer,


Public Information Officer : Deputy Commissioner,
against the decision of whom : Circle No.13, Karwan, &
the appeal is preferred Zonal Commissioner, Khairtabad,
Hyderabad, GHMC.

(iii) Particulars of the order including : Application Dated : 22-02-2023


number if any, against which the : This office has not provided the
appeal is preferred; information Sought by the appellant
under RTI Act related to complaint.
COMPT377 Dated 07-01-2023,
COMPT378 Dated 07-01-2023 &
Ref No. 660722 Dated 09-01-2023

(iv) Brief facts leading to the appeal:-

Aggrieved by the non furnishing of information. The appellant has no


other option except to approach the first Appellant authority. The officers of
GHMC are colluded with the encroachers and not taken action against the
5

encroachers who is having the support of politicians and on behest of the


political leaders they had encroach the Government land and Road which
creates the great difficulty to the local public. Though the GHMC officers
inspected the site but not taken any action against the encroachers. When the
appellant sought for the information under the RTI Act to take legal action
against the encroachers as per the law of land. The officers ignored the
application to avoid any legal action against the encroachers which is abuse of
law and power

(v) if the appeal is preferred against deemed : Public Information Officer,


refusal, the particulars of the application, : Deputy Commissioner
including number and date and name : Circle No.13, Karwan, &
and address of the Public Information officer : Zonal Commissioner,
to whom the application is made : Khairtabad, Hyderabad,
GHMC

(vi) Prayer or relief sought:

To provide the proper information sought by the appellant under RTI


Act. with full and proper details. it is suspected that GHMC has colluded with
the encroachers and not taken any action against the encroachers. when the
appellant requested for the report of GHMC the officers ignored the
application only to protect the encroachers. I request the GHMC Senior
officials to take a serious note and provide the information sought by the
appellant to approach the court of law against the encroachers for the interest
of justice.

(vii) Grounds for the prayer or relief: : Against the GHMC for non
providing the information
sought by the appellant under
RTI Act.

(viii) Verification by the appellant; and:

I verify that the above information are true and correct to the best of my
knowledge and belief. Hence verified.

Appellant.
(Afzaluddin Faroqui)
6

(ix) any other information which the Commission may deem necessary for
deciding the appeal.

The appellant has requested for the information related to the complaint
No COMPT377 & COMPT378 Dated 07-01-2023 and complaint refrence
No.660722 registered date 09-01-2023 against the illegal encroachment on
Government land and road. The application under RTI Act 2005 made on 22-
02-2023 to take an appropriate legal action against the encroachers and GHMC
officials. The GHMC has not furnish the detail only to protect the encroachers
and corrupt officials of GHMC. The appeal is filed within (30) days from the
date of completing the 30 days of Application. The requisite fee by way of
Court fee stamp of Rs.10/- is enclosed.

Therefore, it is prayed to take immediate action in the matter in the


interest of justice.

Dated: -0 -2023 Appellant.


Place: Hyderabad. Afzaluddin Faroqui
H.No 12-2-417/B/3, Jaya Nagar,
Guddimalkapur, Mehdipatnam,
Hyderabad-500028
Mobile No: 7799402420
Copy enclosed
1.Complaint copy of Complaint No COMPT377, COMPT378 Dated 07-01-
2023 and Refrence No.660722 Dated 09-01-2023
2. RTI application Dated 22-02-2023 by Afzaluddin Faroqui
7

TO,
THE FIRST APPELLATE AUTHORITY,
PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER &
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER, CIRCLE NO.13,
KARWAN,HYDERABAD,
ZONAL COMMISSIONER, KHAIRTABAD,
HYDERABAD,GHMC .

AN FIRST APPEAL U/S 19 (1) OF THE RTI ACT 2005


(within 30 days )
Respected Sir/Madam

(I) Name and address of the appellant: Afzaluddin Faroqui,


H.No 12-2-417/B/3, Jaya Nagar,
Guddimalkapur, Mehdipatnam,
Hyderabad-500028
Mobile No: 7799402420

(ii) Name and address of the : Public Information Officer,


Public Information Officer : Deputy Commissioner,
against the decision of whom : Circle No.13, Karwan, &
the appeal is preferred Zonal Commissioner, Khairtabad,
Hyderabad, GHMC.

(iii) Particulars of the order including : Application Dated : 22-02-2023


number if any, against which the : This office has not provided the
appeal is preferred; information Sought by the appellant
under RTI Act related to
H.No.13-6-27/1

(iv) Brief facts leading to the appeal:-

Aggrieved by the non furnishing of information. The appellant has no


other option except to approach the first Appellant authority. The officers of
GHMC has not provided the details of Building permission and Occupancy
certificate issued to H.No.13-6-27/1 kulsumpura village, karwan,Hyd (GHMC)

(v) if the appeal is preferred against deemed : Public Information Officer,


refusal, the particulars of the application, : Deputy Commissioner
including number and date and name : Circle No.13, Karwan, &
8

and address of the Public Information officer : Zonal Commissioner,


to whom the application is made : Khairtabad, Hyderabad,
GHMC

(vi) Prayer or relief sought:

To provide the proper information sought by the appellant under RTI


Act. with full and proper details of Building permission and Occupancy
certificate related to H.No.13-6-27/1 for the interest of justice.

(vii) Grounds for the prayer or relief: : Against the GHMC for non
providing the information
sought by the appellant under
RTI Act.

(viii) Verification by the appellant; and:

I verify that the above information are true and correct to the best of my
knowledge and belief. Hence verified.

Appellant.
(Afzaluddin Faroqui)

(ix) any other information which the Commission may deem necessary for
deciding the appeal.

The appellant has requested for the information related to of Building


permission and Occupancy certificate issued to H.No.13-6-27/1 kulsumpura
village karwan hyderabad. The appeal is filed within (30) days from the date of
completing the 30 days of Application. The requisite fee by way of Court fee
stamp of Rs.10/- is enclosed.

Therefore, it is prayed to take immediate action in the matter in the


interest of justice.

Dated: -0 -2023 Appellant.


Place: Hyderabad. ( Afzaluddin Faroqui)

Copy enclosed
1. RTI application Dated 22-02-2023 by Afzaluddin Faroqui related to
H.No.13-6-27/1, kulsumpura village, karwan, Hyderabad.
9

TO,
THE FIRST APPELLATE AUTHORITY,
PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER,
STATE PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICE,
TELANGANA STATE WAQF BOARD,
RAZZACK MANZIL, OPP: PUBLIC GARDENS,
HYDERABAD-500001

AN FIRST APPEAL U/S 19 (1) OF THE RTI ACT 2005


(within 30 days )
Respected Sir/Madam

(I) Name and address of the appellant: Afzaluddin Faroqui,


H.No 12-2-417/B/3, Jaya Nagar,
Guddimalkapur, Mehdipatnam,
Hyderabad-500028
Mobile No: 7799402420

(ii) Name and address of the : Public Information Officer,


Public Information Officer : state public information office,
against the decision of whom : telangana state waqf board,
the appeal is preferred Razzack manzil, opp: public gardens,
Hyderabad-500001.

(iii) Particulars of the order including : Application No.166/RTIA/HYD/2023


number if any, against which the : Dated : 22-02-2023
appeal is preferred; : This office has not provided the
information Sought by the appellant
under RTI Act related to complaint.

(iv) Brief facts leading to the appeal:-

Aggrieved by the non furnishing of information. The appellant has no


other option except to approach the first Appellant authority.

1) In fact the PIO has not provided the details and action taken report against
the complaint registered dated 22-10-2023 by Afzaluddin Faroqui. The waqf
land of Masjid E Kalan(Masjid E kulsumpura) is under encroachment by
unsocial elements by creating the forged registered documents. the notices has
10

been issued to the encroachers but no action has been taken against them by
seeing this opportunity some more land grabber has created the registered
documents by showing masjid e kalan land as their private land. complainant
requested the waqf board to take an action against them but till date no action
is taken against the encroacher.

2) The appellant request for Site map, Survey report , Extent and sketch
map of Masjid E Kalan ( Masjid E Kulsumpura). The PIO has not provided the
details of the same.

3) The appellant request for the details of allocation of development funds


and work related to mosque but the PIO has not provided the details of the
funds. The mosque is in dilapidated condition and it requires urgent repair and
renewals the month of ramzan is going on and next is rainy season. in the rainy
season the roof of the mosque is dripping.

4) The appellant request for the details of approval given for construction
under the land of mosque but the PIO has not provided the details of the same.
many construction works are underway in the land of mosque and many
tenants are demolishing the kamans of mosque and doing new construction
which reduces the beauty and charm of the mosque . it is an heritage of india
and telangana. it is an responsibility of the waqf board to protect such illegal
constructions on the land of mosque

(v) if the appeal is preferred against deemed : Public Information Officer,


refusal, the particulars of the application, : state public information office,
including number and date and name : telangana state waqf board and
address of the Public Information officer :Razzack manzil,
to whom the application is made : opp: public gardens, Hyderabad

(vi) Prayer or relief sought:

To provide the proper information sought by the appellant under RTI


Act. with full and proper details. The appellant requested the above
information for the protection of mosque land. The appellant is an native of
hyderabad and practicing muslim offer prayers in the masjid e kalan due to
non maintenance of proper record and lack of sketch map appellant is not able
to approach the court of law against the encroachers who are doing illegal
construction on the masjid land so i request to provide the above details of the
masjid e kalan (Masjid E Kulsumpura) for the interest of justice.
11

(vii) Grounds for the prayer or relief: : Against the Waqf Board for non
providing the information sought
by the appellant under RTI Act.

(viii) Verification by the appellant; and:

I verify that the above information are true and correct to the best of my
knowledge and belief. Hence verified.

Appellant.
(Afzaluddin Faroqui)

(ix) any other information which the Commission may deem necessary for
deciding the appeal.

The appellant has requested for the information related to the complaint
registered Dated 22-10-2022 by Afzaluddin Faroqui and Masjid e kalan Sketch
map, Extent, and other details such as allocation of funds for the development
of the mosque to protect the heritage monument from the encroachment and
any other demolition by the illegal occupants who occupied the land of Masjid.
The appeal is filed within (30) days from the date of completing the 30 days of
Application. The requisite fee by way of Court fee stamp of Rs.10/- is
enclosed.

Therefore, it is prayed to take immediate action in the matter in the


interest of justice.

Dated: -0 -2023 Appellant.


Place: Hyderabad. Afzaluddin Faroqui

Copy enclosed
1.Complaint copy of Complaint Dated 22-10-2022 by Afzaluddin faroqui.
2. RTI application Dated 22-02-2023 by Afzaluddin Faroqui
12

TO,
THE FIRST APPELLATE AUTHORITY,
THE PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER,
DEPARTMENT OF HERITAGE TELANGANA,
GUNFOUNDRY, HYDERABAD. .

AN FIRST APPEAL U/S 19 (1) OF THE RTI ACT 2005


(within 30 days )
Respected Sir/Madam

(I) Name and address of the appellant : Afzaluddin Faroqui,


H.No 12-2-417/B/3, Jaya Nagar,
Guddimalkapur, Mehdipatnam
Hyderabad-500028
Mobile No: 7799402420

(ii) Name and address of the : Public Information Officer


Public Information Officer Department of Heritage Telangana,
against the decision of whom : Gunfoundry, Hyderabad.,
the appeal is preferred

(iii) Particulars of the order including : Lr.Re.No. 82/247/2023


number if any, against which the : Dated: 17-3-2023
appeal is preferred; : This office has not provided the
full and correct information
Sought by the appellant under
RTI Act

(iv) Brief facts leading to the appeal:-

Aggrieved by the information furnished, which are not correct and quite
contrary to the physical features.

Sl.N RTI Application Reply Through RTI Ground of Appeal


o
1. Please provide the It is to inform you The PIO has not attached
details and report that the Department the copy of the report
of Action taken staff have inspected along with the RTI. The
13

on the complaint the site and noticed staff has given the false
registered, that the construction information regarding the
Date:05-01-2023 of house has been distance of construction
by Afzaluddin carried out at a Hence the photos of
Farooqui. distance of 80 meters construction is attached
from Kulsum Begum
Mosque.
2. Please provide the See enclosed The sketch map attached
details of Kulsum documents (site map, along with the reply is
Begum Mosque extent of land) new one. Kindly provide
such as site map, the map of 1985 or the
Survey report, earlier one which is in the
Extent and sketch record of the Department
map
3. Please provide the The Department has Till date no development
details of allocated an amount work is done with the
allocation of of Rs. 3.00 Crores for amount of Heritage of
development the works at Kulsum telangana still mosque is
funds and works Begum Mosque such in depilated condition. if
related to Kulsum as (1) Restoration of any funds is released or
Begum Mosque Minars, (2) Water tender is called for the
tightening works to development work kindly
the roof, (3) Internal share the details of
and external lime contractor/Tender and
plastering works (4) amount release for the
Restoration of stucco work
works etc.
4. Please provide the The Department has There are lot of
details of approval not given permission construction done on the
given for for construction land of mosque by
construction under the land of demolishing the kamans
under the land of Kulsum Begum (Archs) of the masjid and
Kulsum Begum Mosque, Water well shown in the
Mosque. sketch map is fill with the
debris of kamans (Archs).
for refrence the site
photgraphs is attached
5. Please provide the No Remarks The staff has not taken
details and report any action on the illegal
if action is not constructions on the land
14

taken till date and of kulsumpura masjid nor


the reasons of non any notices is issued to the
action on tenants who are
complaints demolishing the Kamans
(Archs) and doing the
development work in the
shops of masjid

(v) Prayer or relief sought:

To provide the proper information sought by the appellant under RTI


Act. with full and proper details. it is suspected that Staff of Department of
Heritage of Telangana has colluded with the Tenants/Neighbours of
Kulsumpura masjid and submitted the false report to the department by
misguiding the department though the Kamans (Archs) of the masjid is
demolished and shop tenants has developed new shops by encroaching the
extra area allotted to them. still construction is going on in and around the
masjid the photograph of new construction and ongoing construction is
attached for the reference no action is taken on the illegal activities by the
department. The Water Well shown in the sketch map is fill with the debris of
Kamans (Archs) demolished by the tenants. kindly take the strict action against
the staff who has submitted the false report to the department and kindly serve
the details of the masjid to te appellant as soon as possible in the interest of
justice. if information is provided no prejudice will cause to the masjid.

(vi) Grounds for the prayer or relief : Against the false information
furnished by the PIO quite
contrary to the real facts
(vii) Verification by the appellant; and:

I verify that the above information are true and correct to the best of my
knowledge and belief. Hence verified.

Appellant.
(Afzaluddin Faroqui)

(viii) any other information which the Commission may deem necessary for
deciding the appeal.
15

The appellant has requested for the information related to Kulsumpura


Masjid (Masjid E Kalan), Kulsumpura, Karwan Dated 22-02-2023 but The
department has not shared the full and proper details. The answer for the first
questions is false and report is not shared with appellant. It shows that the staff
of Department of Heritage of Telangana is colluded with the encroachers and
not furnishing the correct details to the department as well as appellant. The
Kamans of Masjid which is an part an parcel of the old Heritage Mosque is
demolished and new shops been constructed without taking prior permission
from the Department of Heritage of Telangana. If any work would be done in
presence of Department of Heritage there is an possibilty that we can discover
many valuable items of the history. First of all demolishing of kamans has
effected the beauty of Masjid still if any development work required the
permission to be sought by the Waqf Board as well as Department of Heritage.
I request the First Appellate Authority to take strict action against the Staff and
the Tenants who are demolishing the kamans (Archs) of masjid as per the law
related to the Heritage. The appeal is filed within (30) days from the date of
order. The requisite fee by way of Court fee stamp of Rs.10/- is enclosed.

Therefore, it is prayed to take immediate action in the matter in the


interest of justice.

Dated: -0 -2023 Appellant.


Place: Hyderabad. Afzaluddin Faroqui
R/o H.No 12-2-417/B/3,
Jaya Nagar,Guddimalkapur,
Mehdipatnam, Hyderabad-500028
Mobile No: 7799402420

Copy enclosed
1. Order copy Dated 17-03-2023 Lr.No./RTI/TC13/GHMC/2023 from the
office of the PIO & Deputy comissioner Circle No.13, Karwan, GHMC,
Hyderabad.
2. RTI application Dated 22-02-2023 by Afzaluddin Faroqui

You might also like