Spectrum Effect Meeting With Digicel at MWC Feb 28 2022
Spectrum Effect Meeting With Digicel at MWC Feb 28 2022
Automated ML-Driven
Analysis of RF
Interference
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 2
Spectrum Effect®
Engineering Excellence and AI-Driven Automation
❖ Founded by wireless industry veterans
behind Eden-NET SON.
❖ Mission to solve the most challenging
problems in the wireless industry
through innovation and automation.
❖ Innovative technologies with roots in
spectrum sharing programs with the
United States DoD and ONR.
❖ R&D in Kirkland, WA USA and San
Pedro Garza García, Mexico.
❖ 27 issued patents.
$1T USD*
❖ Gartner Cool Vendor Award. VALUE OF SPECTRUM
❖ Cooperation with Nokia, Rohde & GLOBALLY
*Source: extrapolated from 2020 earnings reports from leading mobile operators
Schwarz, and PCTEL. *Will increase with additional purchases of 5G NR spectrum licenses.
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 3
Spectrum-NET®
Machine Intelligence Meets Spectrum™
✓ Automated analysis of RF interference for all RF bands seamlessly across multi-vendor NR, LTE & UMTS layers.
✓ Deep Machine Learning applied to RAN data incorporating learnings from networks across the globe.
✓ Prioritized, actionable events drive processes to rapidly solve RF interference.
✓ Dashboard view of network with breakdown of RF interference by band, source and KPI impact.
✓ Web-based, cloud-ready, containerized, horizontally scalable software solution with SON and TT system integration.
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 4
Spectrum-NET
RF Interference Demystified
Data Ingestion
❖ RAN CM, PM and topology data are ingested.
State-of-the-Art Analysis
❖ Per-ROP updates the spectral and temporal
characteristics of RF interference.
❖ Classifies, aggregates, locates, predicts and determines
the impact of RF interference.
❖ Determines if interference is carried during periods of
tropospheric ducting.
❖ Performs root cause analysis. Training of Deep CNN models for
new RF interference signatures
Off-Line Machine Learning to Create and Refine CNN Models
❖ Deep Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) models that are trained with labeled
measurement samples (interference signatures from known cases) from mobile
operator networks across the globe. The trained CNN models classify interference
types with measured accuracy of greater than 95%.
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 5
Spectrum-NET
APAC Customer Reviews
Discount
Spectrum-NET level of to
is expected greater than 65%
be deployed forfor
online Tigo from
over the Standard
4,000,000 License
NR & LTE Cost in 2022
cells globally
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 6
Spectrum-NET PoC Results
Executive Summary
Analysis Period
Digicel Network
Nov 01-Dec 03, 2021
Region Paramaribo
RAN Vendors
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 7
Spectrum-NET PoC Results
RF Interference Levels in Mobile Operator Networks
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 8
Spectrum-NET PoC Results
Executive Summary of External RF Interference
Cells are mostly affected by Broadband interference An increase of 1700% is
observed in the Packet
LTE Band 41 Data Access Failure
Rate and Packet Data
Drop Rate.
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 9
Spectrum-NET PoC Results
External Interference: Confirmed Narrowband Sources
LTE Band 28: 740.5 MHz
NB Tx at 742.5 MHz
NB Tx at 742.5 MHz
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 10
Spectrum-NET PoC Results
Cross-Border Interference Suriname – French Guiana
US
Suriname Band 41 TDD
French
Band 38
Guiana
Canada Band 7 UL Band 7 DL
TDD
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 11
Spectrum-NET PoC Results
Cross-Border Interference: Band 41 Examples
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 12
Spectrum-NET Roadmap
Cross-Border RF Interference Model (Q3 2022)
❖ Provides the probability of meeting an interference US / Canada 2.5GHz Frequency Allocations
threshold based on cross border interference
measurements, site distance to the border and site US Band 41 TDD
topology data.
❖ ML-based linear regression model is used to determine if
frequencies with cross border misalignments should be Canada Band 7 UL
Band 38
TDD
Band 7 DL
turned up at sites.
❖ Dynamic capture and analysis of cross border 2450 2500 2550 2600 2650 2700 2750
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 13
Spectrum-NET PoC Results
Passive Intermodulation (PIM) Interference
Spectrum-NET Automatic Capture of PIM Interference
✓ Automatically identifies the signature of PIM within PM data. A deep CNN model has been trained with PIM
interference signatures from known interference cases from many mobile networks.
✓ Determines whether internal or external PIM using branch imbalance (BI), correlations with other channels at the site
and analysis of antenna topology mapping.
✓ Analyzes site frequencies to generate PIM Spectrograph showing where the potential for PIM exists (IM2 - IM5).
✓ Measures the KPI impact from PIM and number of cells with PIM at each site for prioritization.
Example of PIM Interference in the Digicel Suriname Network:
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 14
Spectrum-NET PoC Results
Increase to PIM Potential with n78
• Currently, the utilization for the LTE cells is
much less than the UMTS Band 5 layers. As
the amount of LTE UEs increase, the DL
utilization increases. Higher DL utilization will
result in greater PIM.
• When NR n78 cells are added to provide
capacity in Digicel network, PIM potential will
increase significantly for UMTS Band 5 and
LTE Band 28.
Scenario UMTS Band 1 LTE Band 3 UMTS Band 5 LTE Band 28 LTE Band 41
2nd order: 0 2nd order: 8 2nd order: 1 2nd order: 0 2nd order: 4
3rd order: 7 3rd order: 5 3rd order: 5 3rd order: 1 3rd order: 76
Common Scenario
4th order: 50 4th order: 224 4th order: 52 4th order: 32 4th order: 90
5th order: 224 5th order: 181 5th order: 270 5th order: 87 5th order: 851
Impact of adding n78 channels 1.6 x more IM products 1.5 x more IM products 2.3 x more IM products 2.6 x more IM products N/A
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 15
Spectrum-NET PoC Results
PoC Team
Digicel Team Spectrum-NET Off-line RF Interference
Analysis of the Digicel Suriname Network
❖ Zarizi Bin Hamid: RAN Architect
❖ Vasisth Chotoe: RF Engineer
❖ Cherryl Daal: CTO
❖ Bryan Robinson: Head of Access Technology Strategy
❖ Isaias Ortiz Polanco: RF Engineer
Thank you to the Digicel Team for your excellent collaborative during this PoC!
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 16
Spectrum-NET
AWS Deployment for Digicel Group
State-of-the-Art Architecture
❖ Deployed as containerized micro-services running on
VM’s on AWS.
❖ Centralized access for all Digicel Opco’s.
❖ Kubernetes container orchestration.
❖ Horizontally scalable.
System Integrations
❖ Site topology and PM data securely transferred from
data mediation servers from each of the Opcos.
Scripts to be put in place to automate this process.
❖ Digicel staff provided with VPN access and accounts
for accessing Spectrum-NET.
❖ Additional integration possible with Digicel email
systems, TT systems, and SON tool.
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 17
Spectrum-NET
Annual Subscription License for Digicel Group
The Spectrum-NET annual subscription license includes:
✓ Installation & Commissioning of Spectrum-NET.
✓ AWS resources required for Spectrum-NET operation.
✓ Onboarding and training for each of the Digicel participating Opcos.
✓ All current Spectrum-NET features and capabilities.
✓ Continual analysis for all interference events for all cells (LTE, UMTS) from the participating Opcos.
✓ Each of the Spectrum-NET monthly software releases for ALL new features and updates.
✓ Support for all RAN and OSS upgrades: Huawei, Ericsson, and ZTE.
✓ Administration and support for Spectrum-NET including upgrades to new monthly releases.
✓ Warranty for Spectrum-NET during the term of the license.
✓ Help Desk support with trouble ticket response, workaround, and resolution times per the defined SLA’s as well as
tiered technical support of Spectrum-NET.
DiscountSimple
level of greater than
commercial 65% for
structure; Tigo from
excellent theforStandard
value License Cost
Digicel Group
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 18
Spectrum-NET
Digicel Deployment Timeline: Proposed
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 19
Spectrum-NET Roadmap
New Innovations Coming in 2022!
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 20
AI Meets Spectrum™
www.spectrumeffect.com
Spectrum-NET
External RF Interference
Spectrum-NET Automatic External Interference Detection
✓ Characterizes interference by time, frequency and intensity.
✓ Aggregates all cells impacted by the common interference signature.
✓ Library of interference signatures. CNNs are trained to identify the signature of new types of external sources.
✓ Locates the interference source by analyzing interference magnitudes at each cell and applying weighted Bayesian inference. Applies
horizontal and vertical antenna radiation pattern and Topography data.
✓ The median distance from the location of the external source to the search area is < 50 m in urban/suburban environments.
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 22
Spectrum-NET Example Results
Validated External RF Interference
Time for Operator to
RF # of Cells
# Event Name Source PRB Signature Find the External
Frequency Affected
Source
❑ 1 source was
5 Event Name #5 712.5 MHz 4 Narrowband Not active
inactive at the time of
the in-field hunting. 6 Event Name #6 2510.0 MHz 1 WiMAX 15 mi
❑ Average time to find 784.5 MHz
the source was < 20 7 Event Name #7
712.5 MHz
2 Cable TV 20 min
minutes.
8 Event Name #8 1880.0 MHz 3 DECT 15 min
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 23
Spectrum-NET
Internal PIM Interference Example
❑ Internal PIM sources: high branch imbalance on
affected cells and signature do not appear on other
sectors at the same sites. Caused by nonlinearities
present along the RF signal’s path (cable, connector,
combiner or antenna). Steps to repair:
❑ Check cabling and connectors across the RF path. Make sure
that connectors are torqued to manufacturer’s recommendations.
❑ Check that the combiner has good isolation.
❑ Check that antenna ports are working properly. If the port is
faulty, change the cabling of the cell to an available port.
❑ If there are no available ports left and the cabling and combiner
are in good working condition, replace the antenna.
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 24
Spectrum-NET
External PIM Interference Example
❑ External PIM sources: low branch imbalance on
affected cells and signature appears on other sectors at
the same sites.
❑ External PIM sources include corroded or rusty mechanical
components, usually inside the near-field region of the antenna;
unintended reflection plates; and structural or mounting
hardware.
❑ Common sources of external PIM: cable trays, air handling units,
vent pipes, metal snap-in cable hangers, hose clamps, metal strut
fasteners, angle adapters.
❑ Solution include painting or shielding a corroded structure or
shielding, mitigate the impact of the interference by adjusting the
antenna or ISCO cancelation.
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 25
Spectrum-NET
Faulty Hardware
Uncorrelated High Wideband Interference Crossed Antenna Feeders
❖ Captures single cell cases with high wideband
interference and with no correlation to traffic and no
correlation to other cells at that site or nearby sites.
Defective RX Branch
❖ Mitigation steps can be performed in open loop or closed loop via SON
system.
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 27
Spectrum-NET
Interference via Tropospheric Ducting
❖ Under ducting weather conditions, the refractive index of the atmosphere increases and it causes signals to be
bent and propagate greater distances.
❖ Tropospheric ducting affects all frequencies and signals can travel more than 500 miles (800 km).
❖ For 5G NR and LTE TDD networks, TDD cells in neighboring deployment regions can cause interference to each
other (TDD Self-Interference) during ducting conditions.
❖ For FDD and TDD networks, ducting can lead to interference on the uplink of cells within a mobile network from
cross border transmissions.
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 28
Spectrum-NET
TDD Self-Interference During Tropospheric Ducting
Automatic Mitigation of TDD Self-Interference TDD Self-Interference
✓ Detects victim cells from TDD self-interference for
LTE and NR based on time and frequency
signatures.
✓ Determines the dominant aggressor cells based on
interference locating, topology analysis, traffic
correlation and reciprocity analysis.
✓ Detects the victim cells from cross-border
interference.
✓ Dynamic parameter reconfiguration to mitigate the
impact of ducting interference.
✓ Comprehensive integration with new RIM-RS RAN
capabilities in cooperation with a USA operator.
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 29
Spectrum-NET Roadmap
Integration with SON (Q3 2022)
Push & Revert
CM changes
SON
API
Cells for Interference Closed-loop
RF Optimizations changes to
CM, PM & Site Interference radio network
topology data Analysis SON
Module
Optimizations Status
✓ For ducting interference, Spectrum-NET will interface with the SON provisioning API to change the NR
OFDM Symbol Blanking.
✓ For RAN interference, Spectrum-NET will export list clusters to trigger optimizations by SON modules.
✓ For minimizing the affects of other interference, Spectrum-NET will interface with the SON provisioning API
with coordination of SON modules potentially changing the same parameters.
✓ SON tools provide feedback on both successful and failed changes.
✓ CM parameter changes will be reverted once RF interference source is no longer present.
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 30
Spectrum-NET Roadmap
RAN Generated Interference (RGI) Root Cause Analysis (Q4 2022)
Source of RGI Spectrum-NET Root Cause Analysis Spectrum-NET Driven Resolution
• Identify cells with overlapping coverage via analysis of UE
Overlapping cell coverage due timing/distance counters and cell to cell handover counters. • Apply antenna tilt and/or azimuth adjustments antennas at cell with
to antenna pointing • Cells with overlapping coverage will be shown for RGI events in the RGI and cells with overlapping coverage.
UI and in reports.
• Modify cell reselection and handover parameters to move traffic to
High concentration of UEs on • Check traffic level counters on surrounding cells for high loading on other frequencies.
neighboring cells cells. Compare with loading other frequency layers. • Modify UL power control parameters to reduce Tx power from UEs in
areas of overlapping coverage (cell edge).
Poorly configured UL power • Audit UL power control parameter configuration of neighbor cells and • Fix poorly configured UL power control parameters for cells with
control parameters check for poorly configured values that may lead to RGI. overlapping coverage.
Cells missing from, or incorrect • Check for missing neighbor cells, and for closer cells with the same • Add missing neighbors/remove incorrect neighbors by running
neighbors on neighbor lists reuse code as cells already on the neighbor list. Automatic Neighbor Relations (ANR) SON feature
Reuse code (PCI, SC) • Change reuse codes at cells with reuse code collisions by running
• Check for same PCI or SC at cells within 5 neighbor tiers (hops).
confusion or collision. PCI or SC reuse optimization SON feature.
Excess overlapping coverage • Run Mobility Robustness Optimization SON function to optimize
• Check handover counters for evidence of early/late handovers or
due to non-optimal handover handover parameters to reduce early/late handovers and handovers
handovers to wrong cell.
parameter configuration to the wrong cell.
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 31
Spectrum-NET Roadmap
Regulator Portal (Q4 2022)
❖ Improves Operator-Regulator Cooperation.
❖ The Regulator Portal will address pain points in
the current process for managing external
interference events that require regulator support
to resolve.
❖ Key features proposed include:
✓ The ability for the operator to determine
which events the regulator can see in
Spectrum-NET.
✓ The ability for the operator and regulator to
track the status of each event.
✓ The ability for the operator and regulator to
provide commentary and attach files for each
event.
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 32
Spectrum-NET and 5G RIM-RS
Centralized Multi-Vendor Coordination of RIM-RS (Q1 2023)
★ RIM-RS: Remote Interference Management – Reference Signals
★ 3GPP Release 16 feature to assist with TDD self-interference mitigation during times of ducting
Spectrum-NET analyzes RIM-RS based PM data Spectrum-NET performs centralized optimization of the mitigation
from both aggressor and victim cells. actions to optimally respond to ducting interference.
RS-1 Transmission
NR
NR
• Measure and collect RIM-RS PM Aggressor • Measure and collect RIM-RS PM
counters.
Ducting Carried Interference Victim counters
Cells
Cells
RS-2 Transmission
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 33
Spectrum-NET PoC Results
Loss in Cell Coverage in the Digicel Suriname Network
❖ Table shows the reduction in uplink coverage
footprint for varying levels of uplink interference for LTE Avg Interference Relative Coverage
LTE cells. Interference per degradation Coverage Footprint
PRB (dBm) (dB) Footprint Size Reduction
▪ Pathloss exponent = 3.5 (typical urban/suburban
-120 0 100% 0%
environment pathloss)
-117 3 67% -33%
▪ 6dB interference degradation results in uplink -114 6 45% -55%
coverage footprint reduction of 55% -110 10 27% -73%
▪ 10dB interference degradation results in uplink -107 13 18% -82%
coverage footprint reduction of 73% -104 16 12% -88%
© Copyright 2022 Spectrum Effect. All Rights Reserved. www.spectrumeffect.com Confidential & Proprietary 34