Hubbard County Capital Improvement Plan 2023-2028
Hubbard County Capital Improvement Plan 2023-2028
A meeting of the Board of Commissioners will be held Tuesday, June 20, 2023 in the Hubbard County Board
Room commencing at 6:00 PM.
The Mission of Hubbard County is to provide high quality, cost effective public services.
All meetings of the Hubbard County Board of Commissioners are live streamed and archived to
promote public engagement and transparency.
Page
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
BOARD CHAIR CALL TO ORDER
1. PUBLIC HEARING - CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
1.A. Hubbard County Capital Improvement Plan 2 - 48
Hubbard County Capital Improvement Plan - Pdf
2. ADJOURN
Page 1 of 48
Board of Commissioners
AGENDA ITEM REPORT
BACKGROUND INFORMATION:
A county may adopt a capital improvement plan. The plan must cover at least the five-year period
beginning with the date of its adoption. The plan must set forth the estimated schedule, timing, and
details of specific capital improvements by year, together with the estimated cost, the need for the
improvement, and sources of revenues to pay for the improvement. In preparing the capital
improvement plan, the county board must consider for each project and for the overall plan:
1. the condition of the county's existing infrastructure, including the projected need for repair or
replacement;
2. the likely demand for the improvement;
3. the estimated cost of the improvement;
4. the available public resources;
5. the level of overlapping debt in the county;
6. the relative benefits and costs of alternative uses of the funds; (7) operating costs of the
proposed improvements; and
7. alternatives for providing services more efficiently through shared facilities with other counties
or local government units.
(b) The capital improvement plan and annual amendments to it are not effective until approved by the
county board after public hearing.
FINDINGS OF FACT:
A Capital Improvement Plan helps elected officials consider future needs when setting annual
operating budgets. The provide a process for considering the condition of current buildings and
infrastructure and a process for considering future facility needs. The Capital Improvement Plan has
been in the works for the past twelve months. It was first reviewed by the General Government
Committee. It was presented to the full board at a worksession on April 11, 2023. The scope of the
proposed jail renovation was reviewed with the board on May 9, 2023, and the date for the public
hearing was set by the board on May 16, 2023.
ATTACHED DOCUMENTS:
CIP Presentation 20230411
2023 Capital Plan
Hubbard Co Jail Planning
Page 2 of 48
Page 2 of 47 Page 3 of 48
•
Page 3 of 47 Page 4 of 48
•
•
Page 4 of 47 Page 5 of 48
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Page 5 of 47 Page 6 of 48
•
•
Page 6 of 47 Page 7 of 48
•
•
Page 7 of 47 Page 8 of 48
•
•
Page 8 of 47 Page 9 of 48
•
•
Page 9 of 47 Page 10 of 48
•
•
Page 10 of 47 Page 11 of 48
Page 11 of 47
Funding:
Enbridge Tax Capacity $ 1,100,000.00 $ 1,100,000.00 $ 1,600,000.00 $ 1,600,000.00 $ 1,600,000.00
Recorders Compliance Funds
Sheriff's Office Dedicated Funds
Historical Society Preservation Grant
GMRPT Funding $ 900,000.00 $ 2,000,000.00
Bonding $ 7,000,000.00 $ 10,000,000.00
Central Services
Courts/Public Safety Addition $ 12,894,000.00
Government Center Boilers $ 50,000.00
Renovation of Government Center ???
Public Works
Transit Garage
Parks
Deep Lake Park Demo
Deep lake park engineering
Deep Lake Park Development $ 1,232,000.00 $ 2,492,000.00 $ 3,857,000.00
Page 13 of 48
Page 13 of 47
•
Page 14 of 47 Page 15 of 48
•
Page 15 of 47 Page 16 of 48
•
Page 16 of 47 Page 17 of 48
Page 17 of 47 Page 18 of 48
Page 18 of 47
GO Ref Rev 2020A HRAGO Rev Ref 2014 GO NH Rev 2014 GO HRA Cottage 2017
Refunded LEC & Courthouse Bonds HRA Bond Refunded 2014 Nurshing Home Renovations HRA Cottage refunded 2008
Interest Principal Total Interest Principal Total Interest Principal Total Interest Principal Total Total
2023 $ 123,100.00 $ 695,000.00 $ 818,100.00 $ 22,950.00 $ 140,000.00 $ 162,950.00 $ 358,307.50 $ 370,000.00 $ 728,307.50 $ 34,800.00 $ 85,000.00 $ 119,800.00 $ 1,829,157.50
2024 $ 94,700.00 $ 725,000.00 $ 819,700.00 $ 18,750.00 $ 150,000.00 $ 168,750.00 $ 347,577.50 $ 390,000.00 $ 737,577.50 $ 32,250.00 $ 85,000.00 $ 117,250.00 $ 1,843,277.50
2025 $ 65,000.00 $ 760,000.00 $ 825,000.00 $ 14,250.00 $ 160,000.00 $ 174,250.00 $ 335,877.50 $ 415,000.00 $ 750,877.50 $ 29,700.00 $ 85,000.00 $ 114,700.00 $ 1,864,827.50
2026 $ 46,000.00 $ 190,000.00 $ 236,000.00 $ 9,450.00 $ 155,000.00 $ 164,450.00 $ 322,390.00 $ 425,000.00 $ 747,390.00 $ 27,150.00 $ 90,000.00 $ 117,150.00 $ 1,264,990.00
2027 $ 38,300.00 $ 195,000.00 $ 233,300.00 $ 4,800.00 $ 160,000.00 $ 164,800.00 $ 307,515.00 $ 440,000.00 $ 747,515.00 $ 24,450.00 $ 95,000.00 $ 119,450.00 $ 1,265,065.00
2028 $ 30,400.00 $ 200,000.00 $ 230,400.00 $ 292,115.00 $ 455,000.00 $ 747,115.00 $ 21,600.00 $ 95,000.00 $ 116,600.00 $ 1,094,115.00
2029 $ 22,200.00 $ 210,000.00 $ 232,200.00 $ 274,825.00 $ 475,000.00 $ 749,825.00 $ 18,750.00 $ 95,000.00 $ 113,750.00 $ 1,095,775.00
2030 $ 13,600.00 $ 220,000.00 $ 233,600.00 $ 256,775.00 $ 495,000.00 $ 751,775.00 $ 15,900.00 $ 100,000.00 $ 115,900.00 $ 1,101,275.00
2031 $ 4,600.00 $ 230,000.00 $ 234,600.00 $ 236,975.00 $ 515,000.00 $ 751,975.00 $ 12,900.00 $ 100,000.00 $ 112,900.00 $ 1,099,475.00
2032 $ 216,375.00 $ 535,000.00 $ 751,375.00 $ 9,900.00 $ 105,000.00 $ 114,900.00 $ 866,275.00
2033 $ 193,905.00 $ 555,000.00 $ 748,905.00 $ 6,750.00 $ 110,000.00 $ 116,750.00 $ 865,655.00
2034 $ 170,595.00 $ 580,000.00 $ 750,595.00 $ 3,450.00 $ 115,000.00 $ 118,450.00 $ 869,045.00
2035 $ 146,235.00 $ 605,000.00 $ 751,235.00 $ 751,235.00
2036 $ 120,825.00 $ 630,000.00 $ 750,825.00 $ 750,825.00
2037 $ 92,475.00 $ 655,000.00 $ 747,475.00 $ 747,475.00
2038 $ 63,000.00 $ 685,000.00 $ 748,000.00 $ 748,000.00
2039 $ 32,175.00 $ 715,000.00 $ 747,175.00 $ 747,175.00
Page 20 of 48
Hubbard County
2023 Capital
Improvement Plan
with Five Year
Forecast
Page 20 of 47 Page 21 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
Executive Summary
This Capital Improvement plan is intended to provide context to the annual budgeting process and to
provide the Hubbard County Board of Commissioners with the information needed to effectively
maintain Hubbard County Infrastructure.
Projects evaluated within the Capital Improvement Plan are exclusive to projects scheduled within the
County’s Capital Projects fund. Projects that are not utilizing the County’s Capital Projects fund do not
need their criteria reevaluated within the context of this plan. Those items are assessed as part of the
County’s annual budget process within the corresponding fund’s department together with that
department’s specific levy impact, support from intergovernmental revenues, and local sources.
The forecast layout incorporates funding sources first, followed by scheduled projects by year, and the
projected ending fund balance for the Capital Projects fund.
The Future Years column includes items that are on the horizon for the County, but not specifically
scheduled to occur within the next five years. It also includes the cost for the replacement of items once
they reach the end of their estimated useful life. Each item that is not a one-time cost to the County will
disclose an estimated remaining life, with a replacement cost in the Future Years. This helps to ensure
that all major capital items of the County are being routinely assessed as to their condition.
Equipment replacement fund amounts are disclosed at the bottom of the forecast as reserved. The
Highway department actively utilizes their replacement fund. The Solid Waste department also has a
replacement fund with the goal to offset the cost of equipment, building and landfill needs.
Additionally, the draft master plan for the Deep Portage Park identifies the scope of work to be
completed and a phased approach to development and costs.
Page 21 of 47 Page 22 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
Table of Contents
Introduction
Facility Assessment 7
Executive Summary 7
Facility Assessment 7
Solutions 8
Financial Summaries
Appendices
Facility Listing 13
Facility Reports 14
Page 22 of 47 Page 23 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
Introduction
The Capital Improvement Plan (the “Plan”) aligns Hubbard County’s priorities with its long-range capital
needs for facilities and infrastructure that are scheduled to be funded with the County’s Capital Projects
fund. The Plan is intended to address the County’s immediate (five-year) and future capital needs. It is
a vital component of strategic planning to ensure the ability to provide public services currently and in
the future while maintaining sound, fiscally responsible, financial management practices. A sound and
reliable Plan is critical to maintaining financial health to provide a stable level of capital funding and
avoid dire consequences and disastrous financial impact by leaving capital needs unattended for long
periods of time.
The Plan is updated annually to incorporate changes in capital priorities, operating budget, or other
financial conditions.
The Plan provides the public and local elected officials with information and insight about the strategic
and financial direction of the County through the shared vision of the Hubbard County Board of
Commissioners, related to the future of public services and economic development.
1. The Plan emphasizes strategic priorities adopted by the Hubbard County Board of Commissioners:
2. The Plan prioritizes and evaluates each project using the following criteria and considerations:
Page 23 of 47 Page 24 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
MN Statute 373.40, Subd. 3. Capital improvement plan. (a) A county may adopt a capital improvement
plan. The plan must cover at least the five-year period beginning with the date of its adoption. The plan
must set forth the estimated schedule, timing, and details of specific capital improvements by year,
together with the estimated cost, the need for the improvement, and sources of revenues to pay for the
improvement. In preparing the capital improvement plan, the county board must consider for each
project and for the overall plan:
(1) the condition of the county's existing infrastructure, including the projected need for repair or
replacement;
(2) the likely demand for the improvement;
(3) the estimated cost of the improvement;
(4) the available public resources;
(5) the level of overlapping debt in the county;
(6) the relative benefits and costs of alternative uses of the funds;
(7) operating costs of the proposed improvements; and
(8) alternatives for providing services more efficiently through shared facilities with other counties
or local government units. (b) The capital improvement plan and annual amendments to it are
not effective until approved by the county board after public hearing.
• Hubbard County Department Heads shall submit new proposed capital projects for
consideration annually before March 31st.
• The Hubbard County Plan will be updated and adopted no later than June of each year, after
holding a public hearing. The resulting information regarding capital expenditures for the five-
year forecast will be incorporated into the preparation of the subsequent budget cycle for
consideration of a proposed capital levy.
• A priority of the Plan will be to identify and estimate the level of effort needed on a yearly basis
to maintain infrastructure. This will help avert unacceptable costs resulting from capital needs
that are postponed or overlooked for too long.
• A long-term approach will be used to evaluate projects considered for inclusion in the Plan by
using the criteria set forth herein, with an overriding goal to minimizing maintenance and
replacement costs while obtaining the best value for Hubbard County taxpayers.
• Prior to annual adoption of the Plan, cost estimates for major projects requiring bond issuance
will reflect actual architectural and engineering cost estimates based on approved building
plans. This ensures the Plan reflects the real maximum dollar amount needed for debt issuance
to adhere to statutory Plan requirements.
• Projects included in the Plan will be aligned with strategic goals of the Hubbard County Board of
Commissioners and other Hubbard County planning documents.
Page 24 of 47 Page 25 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
Items funded individually by County departments are proposed by the department and approved
through the County’s operating budget approval process. Typically, these departmental requests
do not meet the threshold for capitalization by the County (i.e., they are individually under $50,000
and do not provide an extended useful life) and are not part of the Plan forecast.
Incomplete departmental projects at the end of a year may, at the discretion of the County Board,
transfer unspent funding to the Capital Projects fund. This allows a project to roll into future years
with funding that has already been secured.
Plan projects are not undertaken unless and until they are approved by the Hubbard County Board of
Commissioners. All projects are subject to the County’s procurement policy, Board approval of
contract awards and terms, bond and insurance requirements, and budgetary project
management controls.
Reasonable estimates of the impact on the County’s Capital Projects fund are included with the
initial consideration of a Plan project. As a project nears, estimates are updated, and prioritization
may change if savings can be achieved.
The Plan forecast has been prepared with the following financial assumptions:
• Monitoring the County’s Capital Projects fund balance can help to minimize debt issuances. New
tax capacity will be used to start and maintain this Capital Projects Fund.
• The 2023 budget includes a levy for the Capital Projects fund in the amount of $1,100,000 with
an additional $500,000 identified for Economic Development. Annually, County Commissioners
will be charged with evaluating the needs for a levy effort through the annual budget and levy
adoption process. This forecast assumes a minimum levy effort of $1,600,000 for the years
2024-2028.
• Anticipated grant awards and contributions from other funds, that can offset project costs, have
been disclosed.
• The highway equipment and Capital Plans will continue to be approved separately but will be
included as appendices in this report.
As always, consideration of all current financial conditions and operating priorities, including the
financial indicators of debt level, annual levy, tax capacity rates, and fee-based revenues will be
benchmarked by comparison to neighboring counties, counties of similar size and population, and/or
other relevant Minnesota county group median measurements.
Page 25 of 47 Page 26 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
Facility Assessment
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
ICS Consulting engaged in an assessment and engagement process with Hubbard County as the first step
in developing a long-term Capital Improvement Plan. Information contained in this report is the result
of this work. The facilities assessment and staff engagement sessions were conducted to understand
current facility and department needs. These results are the drivers for prioritization and plan to
address solutions and provide the pathway to the Plan for approval by the County Commissioners and
execution by County Administration.
Goals for this process is to provide input data from the facilities assessments, engagement sessions and
strategic solutions to accomplish this work. The County will commit to developing a Capital
improvement Plan those accounts for immediate needs, needs in five to ten years and beyond as
required to accomplish the identified work.
FACILITY ASSESSMENT
ICS assessed the administration and courthouse facility, jail, public works and solid waste, surveying all
elements of the current facilities from exterior building envelope to interior finishes and building
systems. The existing conditions have been evaluated and specific facility elements are inventoried in
ICS’s proprietary CIP360 software to determine value and plan for long-term maintenance.
In all, the facilities in Hubbard County are modern, with very little deferred maintenance. Much of the
recommended work to upgrade departments is based on operational needs, not facility’s needs. Many
buildings and expansions have occurred within the last 20-25 years and critical building systems have
been upgraded in that timeline.
Refer to Exhibit A for facility reports. Access to CIP360 will be provided to the County to manage
elements of each facility and schedule required maintenance.
SOLUTIONS
Page 26 of 47 Page 27 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
The following are needs identified as a result of the facility assessments and staff engagement sessions
that should be addressed in the upcoming Capital Improvement Plan. The Plan should include future
budget considerations and a priority for addressing these needs:
• Renovate or add space to relocate the county attorney office to be adjacent to courts, probation
and the sheriff. Could this happen at the former jail location?
• Relocate the auditor/treasurer department to be co-located with their first-floor staff.
• Decommission/close the south (Park Rapids) demo landfill - ten-year plan. Expand and improve
the north (Laporte) landfill to accommodate future demolition waste and recycling needs.
• Expand jail to accommodate holding, booking and storage needs.
• Develop a plan to relocate transit from the Park Rapids Public Works facility to accommodate
growth of departments and equipment at Public Works.
• Develop a plan to replace the Nevis Public Works salt building.
Page 27 of 47 Page 28 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
Financial Summaries
Funding:
Enbridge Tax Capacity $ 1,100,000.00 $ 1,100,000.00 $ 1,100,000.00 $ 1,600,000.00 $ 1,600,000.00 $ 1,600,000.00
Recorders Compliance Funds $ 247,510.00
Sheriff's Office Dedicated Funds $ 155,000.00
Historical Society Preservation Grant $ 237,329.00
GMRPT Funding $ 900,000.00 $ 2,000,000.00
Bonding $ 7,000,000.00 $ 10,000,000.00
Public Safety
Radio Upgrades $ 150,000.00 $ 150,000.00 $ 150,000.00
Jail Planning $ 50,000.00 $ 50,000.00
Jail Remodel $ 7,233,600.00
Phoenix Software $ 250,000.00
Central Services
Historic Courthouse roof $ 275,000.00
Courts/Public Safety Addition $ 12,894,000.00
Government Center Boilers $ 50,000.00 $ 50,000.00
Renovation of Government Center ???
Public Works
Transit Garage
Parks
Deep Lake Park Demo $ 250,000.00
Deep lake park engineering $ 50,000.00
Deep Lake Park Development $ 1,232,000.00 $ 2,492,000.00 $ 3,857,000.00
Page 28 of 47 Page 29 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
10
Page 29 of 47 Page 30 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
11
Page 30 of 47 Page 31 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
September 9, 2022
• Use existing vehicle sally port space to increase/improve intake capacity and flexibility
• Extend building shell to provide new sally port space
• Include appropriate storage for equipment and vehicles displaced from demolition of existing
garage storage.
• Consider drive thru capacity. Receiving from the south and exit to the north.
New facility between LEC and Courts/Government Center two floors with basement? 10,000 sf per
floor
Facilities Listing
12
Page 31 of 47 Page 32 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
Total $ 59,791,467.00
Total without HLC facilities $ 44,301,687.00
13
Page 32 of 47 Page 33 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
Facility Reports
14
Page 33 of 47 Page 34 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
15
Page 34 of 47 Page 35 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
16
Page 35 of 47 Page 36 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
17
Page 36 of 47 Page 37 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
18
Page 37 of 47 Page 38 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
19
Page 38 of 47 Page 39 of 48
2023 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
(b) Before issuance of bonds qualifying under this section, the county must publish a notice of its
intention to issue the bonds and the date and time of a hearing to obtain public comment on the
matter. The notice must be published in the official newspaper of the county or in a newspaper of
general circulation in the county. The notice must be published at least 14, but not more than 28, days
before the date of the hearing.
(c) A county may issue the bonds only upon obtaining the approval of a majority of the voters
voting on the question of issuing the obligations, if a petition requesting a vote on the issuance is signed
by voters equal to five percent of the votes cast in the county in the last county general election and is
filed with the county auditor within 30 days after the public hearing. If the county elects not to submit
the question to the voters, the county shall not propose the issuance of bonds under this section for the
same purpose and in the same amount for a period of 365 days from the date of receipt of the petition.
If the question of issuing the bonds is submitted and not approved by the voters, the provisions of
section 475.58, subdivision 1a, shall apply.
Subd. 3. Capital improvement plan. (a) A county may adopt a capital improvement plan. The
plan must cover at least the five-year period beginning with the date of its adoption. The plan must set
forth the estimated schedule, timing, and details of specific capital improvements by year, together with
the estimated cost, the need for the improvement, and sources of revenues to pay for the
improvement. In preparing the capital improvement plan, the county board must consider for each
project and for the overall plan:
1) the condition of the county's existing infrastructure, including the projected need for repair or
replacement;
2) the likely demand for the improvement;
3) the estimated cost of the improvement;
4) the available public resources;
5) the level of overlapping debt in the county;
6) the relative benefits and costs of alternative uses of the funds; (7) operating costs of the
proposed improvements; and
7) alternatives for providing services more efficiently through shared facilities with other counties
or local government units.
(b) The capital improvement plan and annual amendments to it are not effective until approved
by the county board after public hearing.
20
Page 39 of 47 Page 40 of 48
Page 40 of 47
HUBBARD COUNTY
JAIL-PLANNING
Page 41 of 48
05/09/23
A. Staffing
o Increased Job Opportunity
o Improved working environment
Page 41 of 47
o Address Accessibility
o Better employee retention
B. Operations
o Improves operational efficiency
o Separations in housing units increase flexibility
o Better access to tactical vehicle
o Accommodates current and long-term needs
C. Security
o Improves staff security
o Improves facility security
o Accommodates pandemic separations
D. Budget Efficiency
o Cost savings for remodeling versus new construction
o Changes will not require increasing staffing
Page 42 of 48
4. Vehicle Sallyport – existing space needed for added cells for intake and pre-book area
a. Existing sallyport is a pull in back out configuration with limited space.
b. Existing space is not sized / large enough to accommodate transport vehicles and ambulances.
c. Kitchen access is currently through the garage, new layout will provide a separate and secured
access sallyport.
d. The new separate entrance to the kitchen will assist in limiting contraband
Page 45 of 48
5. LEC vehicle storage – need for adequate space with more accessible access
a. Current space does not accommodate all the public safety vehicles and apparatus.
b. Squads and tactical vehicles are currently stored at 3 separate locations.
c. The 3 locations do not provide the space needed for all of the response vehicles.
Page 45 of 47