● Powerful: will this goal, when reached, make a big difference in students’ lives? ● Easy: Is this goal simple, clear, and easy to understand? ● Emotionally Compelling: Does this goal really matter to the teacher? ● Reachable: Has the teacher identified a measurable outcome and strategy to meet the outcome? ● Student-Focused: Is this goal about student achievement, behavior, or attitude rather than the teacher or strategy? I then asked Mrs. Carzo a series of questions to hear her reflection on how her lesson observation went. Her answers are in red.
1. On a scale of 1-10, with 1 being the worst lesson
you’ve ever taught and 10 being the best, how would you rank that lesson? a. I felt as though the lesson was good; some of my kids could have had more engagement, but I do think, overall, it was good. I would rate it a 6 or 7, maybe. I also noticed that some of the same students were trying to answer every question/dominate the conversation. 2. What pleased you about this lesson? a. I like that the students were answering my questions and engaged, and I felt Students understood what was being taught. 3. What would you have to change to move the lesson closer to a 10? a. I think I would like to ensure all students are engaged because, you know, sometimes we have a few students who dominate the conversation. 4. What would your students be doing differently if your class was a 10? a. Everyone actively engaged and participating in the learning together. 5. Tell me more about what that would look like. a. I want my students to actively work together to answer questions during math discussions instead of asking a question and waiting for students to answer on their own. 6. Do you want that to be your goal? a. Yes, I would like to work on that as my goal. 7. If you could hit that goal, would it really matter to you? a. Yes because I know I have taken my classroom engagement and participation levels higher. 8. What teaching strategy can you use to hit your goal? a. We are going to learn about the Nominal Group Theory and implement that with the help of you, Ms. Knott! Thank you I’m excited to try something new out with my students. Sometimes when you’ve been teaching for a long time, you get comfortable with how you teach, but your students may benefit from shaking it up and trying something new! So again, I am excited about this! Session 2 - Learning and Prepping During this session, we discussed the Nominal Group Theory and I answered any questions Mrs. Carzo had. We also set up a time for her to observe me implementing the new teaching strategy. Her comments are written in red. 1. Let’s review this new teaching strategy, and please stop me at any time if you have questions or need more clarification. a. Ok great, thank you!
2. So, this technique allows the teacher to present a
problem or question, Students (on their own or in pairs) write down their ideas about how to respond to the question or problem. All ideas are recorded by the student discussion host. The teacher or student discussion host directs students’ attention to each idea and asks for comments. Students vote to identify the best ideas. Sometimes, students generate criteria for voting before they vote. The student discussion host shares ideas voted on to the teacher and the rest of the class. a. Oh I love this! This will really help support my goal of having everyone actively participate during our math talks. 3. We reviewed a video example of the NGT. Mrs. Carzo did not have questions regarding that. 4. Mrs. Carzo and I reviewed the Nominal Group Technique Checklist together. After review, We discussed what this would look like in her Kindergarten classroom. She wanted to incorporate the use of technology, so we decided to use Nearpod as a way for students to share answers. a. I think I will need to elect student leads and ensure they understand their role. I love the checklist - this allows me to ensure I am correctly implementing it! Thank you for this! I also am excited to use Nearpod, I remember we used it some when we were virtual, so I am interested to see how it works in this capacity.
Hacking Learning Centers in Grades 6-12: How to Design Small-Group Instruction to Foster Active Learning, Shared Leadership, and Student Accountability
Getting Started with Teacher Clarity: Ready-to-Use Research Based Strategies to Develop Learning Intentions, Foster Student Autonomy, and Engage Students