450-R0 Mechanical Design of 65T RDH - Surge Shaft Gate
450-R0 Mechanical Design of 65T RDH - Surge Shaft Gate
DESIGNED BY:
OM INFRA LIMITED
NBCC PLAZA, TOWER- III,
4TH FLOOR, SECTOR-5, PUSHP VIHAR,
SAKET, NEW DELHI-110017
PROJECT:
KUNDAH PUMPED STORAGE H.E. PROJECT
CLIENT:
CONSULTANT:
WAPCOS LIMITED
Tamilnadu Generation and Distribution Corporation Ltd.
CHKD: RECM: APPVD:
WAPCOS Ltd.
1 Description
The Propsed electrically operated Rope Drum Hoist is designed of capacity 65 Tonnes
for the operation of HRT Surge Shaft Gates (size - 4.55m X 8.5m) as per the provision contained
in the IS:6938. The Gate shall be operated by proposed Hoist under balance water head condition
achieved by Filling Valve.
The Hoist shall be installed on the hoist bridge duly supported of fixed legs & girder on adequate
height so as to Bring out the gate out of the groove above Deck Level = 2235.0 m
3 Allowable Stress
A. Rope Drum IS:1030 Gr-280-520N
Compressive Stress Under Normal Condtion : 5300x0.2= 1060 Kg/cm²
Compressive Stress Under BDT Condtion : 2850X0.8= 2280 Kg/cm²
PAGE : 1 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
BDT Condition
i Bending & shear Stress Without Key Way : 3600x0.8= 2880 Kg/cm²
ii Bending & shear Stress With Key Way : 3600X0.8X0.75= 2160 Kg/cm²
iii Equ Bending & shear Stress Without Key Way : 2880X1.2= 3456 Kg/cm²
iv Equ Bending & shear Stress With Key Way : 2880X1.2X0.75= 2592 Kg/cm²
v Combined stress without keyway: 3600X0.8= 2880 Kg/cm²
vi Combined stress with keyway: 3600X0.8X0.75 2160 Kg/cm²
PAGE : 2 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
Normal Condition
i Bending Stress without Keyway : 6324x0.2= 1264.8 Kg/cm²
ii Bending Stress with Keyway : 6324x0.2x0.75= 948.6 Kg/cm²
iii Shear Stress without Keyway : 3264x0.3= 979.2 Kg/cm²
iv Shear Stress with Keyway : 3264x0.3x0.75= 734.4 Kg/cm²
v Equ.Bending Stress without Keyway : 1264.8x1.2= 1517.76 Kg/cm²
vi Equ.Bending Stress with Keyway : 1264.8x1.2x0.75= 1138.32 Kg/cm²
vii Equ .Shear Stress without Keyway : 979.2x1.2= 1175.04 Kg/cm²
viii Equ .Shear Stress with Keyway : 979.2x1.2x0.75= 881.28 Kg/cm²
ix Combined Stress without Keyway : 6324x0.24= 1517.76 Kg/cm²
x Combined Stress with Keyway : 6324x0.24x0.75= 1138.32 Kg/cm²
BDT Condition
i Bending & shear Stress without Keyway : 3264x0.8= 2611.2 Kg/cm²
ii Bending & shear Stress with Keyway : 3264x0.8x0.75= 1958.4 Kg/cm²
iii Equ Bending & shear Stress without Keyway : 2611.2x1.2= 3133.44 Kg/cm²
iv Equ Bending & shear Stress with Keyway : 2611.2x1.2x0.75= 2350.08 Kg/cm²
v Combined stress without keyway : 3264x0.8= 2611.2 Kg/cm²
vi Combined stress with keyway : 3264x0.8x0.75= 1958.4 Kg/cm²
4 Technical specification
i) Designed as per = IS:6938
ii) Lifting Capacity including wt. of wire rope = ( 65 + 2) = 67 T
iii) Deck Level = 2235.00 M
iv) Sill Level = 2157.45 M
v) Lift for Dogging Beam proposed = 0.50 M
vi) Min. Lift required = 2235-2157.45+0.5 = 78.05 M
vii) Lift Proposed = 78.50 M
vii) Hoist operating speed = 0.70 M/MIN
Efficiency
Components
Running Starting
Worm Gear Box 0.8135 0.44
Gate Sheave 0.98 0.95
Spur Gear-1 0.95 0.93
Spur Gear-2 0.95 0.93
Rope Drum 0.95 0.93
Total = 0.68 0.34
PAGE : 3 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
5.1 Motor
Motor K.W= (Wx V X S)/(6.12 x Er)
where,
W (Lifting capacity) V (Hoist Speed) Ser.Fact.(S)
67 T 0.7 M/MIN 1
Proposed :
a Type Dia (mm) Braking Torque Qty. Make
AC EM 300 45.7 Kg-m 1 Elektromag/Sterling Control
100% coil rating on 400/415V, 50cylce/sec.
a For EM Brake
Dia (mm) Size HP at 100RPM Pilot Bore Type Qty.
300 N92PBD12 18 25.4 Brake Drum Type flexible 1
PAGE : 4 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
Proposed :
Dia (mm) Type Construction Breaking Load Wire Strength
40 Fibre core 6x36 1035 Kn 1960 N/MM2
Make : Usha Martin/Bharat Wire Rope
Effective Groove Required (considering 1st layer PCD)= (78.5x1000x2)/(3.14x1120) = 44.64 nos.
Effective Groove Required (considering 2nd layer PCD)= (78.5x1000x2)/(3.14x1200) = 41.67 nos.
PAGE : 5 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
Section Modulus ( Z )
D4 d 4
32 D
Where
D= 108 cm Min. Outside Diameter of rope drum
d= 95 cm Inside Diameter of rope drum
Z= (3.14(108^4-95^4)/32X108 = 49606.07 cm3
PAGE : 6 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
Module
Description Teeth PCD (mm) Pressure Angle Material
(mm)
W1 110 20 2200 20 IS:1030 Gr280-520N
P1 16 20 320 20 IS:2004 Gr-55c8
W2 116 10 1160 20 IS:1030 Gr280-520N
P2 19 10 190 20 IS:2004 Gr-55c8
Where,
P = Tooth Pressure F = Face Width
Q = Strength Factor M = Module
Case-1 When Gate is at Deck Level (full open) & Rope is on middle of drum
A B C D E
PAGE : 7 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
Horizontal Load at different location on the rope drum shaft from Gear (W1)
Hor. Load at "B" due to Gear W1 = = 9544.4xTan20 = 3473.88 kg
Hor. Load at "A" due to Gear W1 = =(3473.88X160.1/188 = 2958.34 Kg
Hor. Load at "D" due to Gear W1 = =(3473.88X27.9)/175.9 = 551 Kg
Hor. Load at "E" due to Gear W1 = =(3473.88-2958.34) = 515.54 Kg
Case-2 When Gate is at Sill beam (Full close) & Rope is on Gear side
A B C D E
Total vertical load at loaction D = (Self load of drum/2) +Load due to Rope Tension at C
= (2350+(16920X38)/148 = 6694.32 Kg
Vertical Load at A = (26670.08X160.1+6694.32X12.1)/188 = 23142.98 Kg
Vertical Load at E = 26670.08+6694.32-23142.98 = 10221.42 Kg
Horizontal Loads at different location on the rope drum shaft from Gear (W1)
Hor. Load at "B" due to Gear W1 = 9544.4XTAN20 = 3473.88 kg
Hor. Load at "A" due to Gear W1 = (3473.88X160.1/188 = 2958.34 Kg
Hor. Load at "D" due to Gear W1 = (3473.88X27.9)/175.9 = 551.00 Kg
Hor. Load at "E" due to Gear W1 = (3473.88-2958.34) = 515.54 Kg
PAGE : 8 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
A B C D E
Total vertical load at loaction D = (Self wt. of drum/2)+Load due to Rope Tension at C
= (2350+(16920X143.4)/148 = 18744.11 Kg
Vertical Load at A = (14620.29X160.1+18744.11X12.1)/188= 13656.98 Kg
Vertical Load at E = 14620.29+18744.11-13656.98 = 19707.42 Kg
Horizontal Load at different location on the rope drum shaft from Gear (W1)
Hor. Load at B due to Gear (W1) tooth load = 9544.4xTan20 = 3473.88 kg
Reaction at A due to Horizontal load =(3473.88X160.1/188 = 2958.34 Kg
Reaction at D due to Horizontal load =(3473.88X27.9)/175.9 = 551 Kg
Reaction at E due to Horizontal load =(3473.88-2958.34) = 515.54 Kg
PAGE : 9 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
Vertical Load
W2 P1
3404.38 Kg 10246.94 Kg
A1 C1 D1 B1
18 18 20
RVA1 56 RVB1
PAGE : 10 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
Horizontal Load W2 P1
1008.75 3473.88
A2 C2 D2 B2
18 18 20
RHA2 56 RHB2
PAGE : 11 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
A3 D3 B3
18 38
RVA2 56 RVB3
Horizontal Load
1008.75 Kg
A4 D4 B4
18 38
RHA4 56 RHB4
PAGE : 12 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
5.14 Bearing
a For Shaft P1W2
Max load on plummer Block = 8096.12 Kg
Min. capacity of plummer block = 8096.12x1.5 = 12144.18 Kg
= 119134.41 N
Dia of shaft at support = 100 mm
Proposed ,
Plummer Block = SNL522 Adopt. Sleeve = H322
A.F. Bearing = 22222EK (Size: 110x200x53)
Dynamic Capacity = 572000 N
Static capacity = 640000 N (Both static & Dynamic capacity more than)
Make = SKF/FAG
b For Shaft P2
Max load on plummer Block = 1174.01 Kg
Max capacity of plummer block = 1.5x1174.01 = 1761.015 Kg
= 17275.56 N
Dia of shaft at support= 80 mm
Proposed,
Plummer Block = SNL518 Adopt. Sleeve = H318
A.F. Bearing = 22218EK (Size: 90x160x40)
Dynamic Capacity = 331000 N
Static capacity = 375000 N
Make = SKF/FAG
Max Horizontal Load on Plummer Block = 684.51 Kg
Max Vertical Load on Plummer Block = 2013.58 Kg
PAGE : 13 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
PAGE : 14 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
5.17 Coupling for connecting reducer & pinion (p2) shaft with floating shaft
Shaft Dia at coupling location = 7.5 cm
RPM of floating shaft = 15.58
Torque on motor shaft = 15.32 kg-m
Torque on reducer output/floating shaft = 15.32x60x0.8135/2 = 373.88 kg-m
150% Breaking Load Torque = 373.88x1.5 = 560.82 kg-m
HP on floating shaft = 2x3.14x15.58x373.88)/4500= 8.1
Coupling Rating (Normal Rating at 100 RPM) = (8.1X100)/15.58 = 52 HP
Proposed
Size Nos. req. Breaking torque HP/100RPM Type P. Bore Max. Bore
104 2 840 117 Half Rigid & Half Flexible 50mm 110mm
PAGE : 15 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
PAGE : 16 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
Case-1 When Gate is at Deck Level (full open) & Rope is on middle of drum
A B C D E
27.9 55.5 92.5 12.1
188
Horizontal Load at different location on the rope drum shaft from Gear (W1)
Hor. Load at "B" due to Gear W1 = = 19105.51XTAN20 = 6953.84 kg
Hor. Load at "A" due to Gear W1 = (6953.84X160.1/188 = 5921.86 Kg
Hor. Load at "D" due to Gear W1 = (6953.84X27.9)/175.9 = 1102.97 Kg
Hor. Load at "E" due to Gear W1 = (6953.84-5921.86) = 1031.98 Kg
Case-2 When Gate is at Sill beam (Full close) & Rope is on Gear side
A B C D E
27.9 38 110 12.1
188
PAGE : 17 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
Total vertical load at loaction D = Self load of drum/2+Load due to Rope Tension at C
= (2350+(33156.59X38)/148 = 10863.18 Kg
Vertical Load at A = (44425.64X160.1+10863.18X12.1)/188 = 38531.86 Kg
Vertical Load at E = 44425.64+10863.18-38531.86 = 16756.96 Kg
Horizontal Load at different location on the rope drum shaft from Gear (W1)
Hor. Load at "B" due to Gear W1 = = 19105.51XTAN20 = 6953.84 kg
Hor. Load at "A" due to Gear W1 = (6953.84X160.1/188 = 5921.86 Kg
Hor. Load at "D" due to Gear W1 = (6953.84X27.9)/175.9 = 1102.97 Kg
Hor. Load at "E" due to Gear W1 = (6953.84-5921.86) = 1031.98 Kg
A B C D E
Horizontal Load at different location on the rope drum shaft from Gear (W1)
Hor. Load at B due to Gear (W1) tooth load = 19105.51xTan20 = 6953.84 kg
Reaction at A due to Horizontal load =(6953.84X160.1/188 = 5921.86 Kg
Reaction at D due to Horizontal load =(6953.84X27.9)/175.9 = 1102.97 Kg
Reaction at E due to Horizontal load =(6953.84-5921.86) = 1031.98 Kg
PAGE : 18 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
PAGE : 19 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
Vertical Load
C.L OF W2 C.L OF P1
6485.9 Kg 20421.66 Kg
A1 C1 D1 B1
18 18 20
RVA1 56 RVB1
Horizontal Load
2062.69 Kg 6953.84 Kg
A2 C2 D2 B2
18 18 20
RHA2 56 RHB2
PAGE : 20 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
Vertical Load
C.L OF P2
6048.9 Kg
A3 D3 B3
18 38
RVA2 56 RVB3
PAGE : 21 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
Horizontal Load
2062.69 Kg
A4 D4 B4
18 38
RHA4 56 RHB4
PAGE : 22 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
7 DESIGN OF KEYS
a For PINION -P1
Shaft Diameter (d)= 13 cm
Torque on P1-W2 shaft= 256891.04 Kg-cm
PAGE : 23 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
8 Sheaves
Min. PCD for Gate Sheave= 20x wire rope diameter = 800 mm
Min. PCD for Balancing Sheave= 12x wire rope diameter = 480 mm
C.L of Sheave
A B c
101 101
202 mm
Normal Condition :
Rope Tension = 16920 Kg
Total vertical load on sheave= 2x16920+100= 33940 Kg
Vertical Reaction at A or C = 16970 Kg
Bending Moment = 16970X10.1 = 171397 Kg-cm
BDT Condition :
Rope Tension = 33156.59 Kg
Total vertical load on sheave = 2x33156.59+100 = 66413.18 Kg
Vertical Reaction at A or C = 33206.59 Kg
Bending Moment = 33206.59X10.1 = 335386.56 Kg-cm
PAGE : 24 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
C.L of Sheave
A B c
87.5 87.5
175
mm
Normal Condition :
Rope Tension = 16920 Kg
Total vertical load on sheave= 16920x2 +75 = 33915 Kg
Reaction at A or C = 16957.5 Kg
Max. Bending Moment= 16957.5x8.75 = = 148378.13 Kg-cm
BDT Condition :
Rope Tension = 33156.59 Kg
Total vertical load on sheave= 33156.59x2 +75 = 66388.18 Kg
Reaction at A or C = 33194.09 Kg
Max. Bending Moment= 33194.09X8.75= = 290448.3 Kg-cm
Normal Condition :
Max. Load on bush = 33915 Kg
Bearing Pressure = 33915/(12.5x13)= 209 Kg/cm2 < 210 Kg/cm2 safe
BDT Condition :
Max Load on bush = 33194.09 Kg
Bearing Pressure = 33194.09/(12.5x13)= 204 Kg/cm2 < 252 Kg/cm2 safe
PAGE : 25 OF 26
OM INFRA LIMITED
Kundah Pumped Storage H.E. Project, (1x125MW), Package-II
65T Rope Drum Hoist for Surge SHaft Gates
Design of Hoisting Components"
250
155 mm
100
20
Proposed
Min. Width of Bracket= 250 mm= 25 cm
Thickness= 20 mm= 2 cm
Normal Condition :
Load on each sheave bracket= 16957.5 Kg
Shear stress= 16957.5/(2x10)= 847.88 Kg/cm2 < 960 Kg/cm2 safe
Tensile Strengh at minimun cross section= 16957.5/((25-12.5)x2) = 678.30 Kg/cm2
< 714 Kg/cm2 safe
Bearing stress= 16957.5/(12.5x2)= 678.30 Kg/cm2 < 1584 Kg/cm2 safe
BDT Condition :
Load on each sheave bracket= 33194.09 Kg
Shear stress= 33194.09/(2x10)= 1659.7 Kg/cm2 < 2080 Kg/cm2 safe
Tensile Strengh at minimun crossection= 33194.09/((25-12.5)x2) = 1327.76 Kg/cm2
< 2080 Kg/cm2 safe
Bearing stress= 33194.09/(12.5x2) = 1327.76 Kg/cm2 < 2080 Kg/cm2 safe
9 Other items:
i) Selection of Rotary Limit Switch & Its Components
To stop the Lifting & Lowering of hoist positively when its reach extreme end, Rotary type of
limit switch provided. Rotary Limit Switch is connected to P1W2 shaft with chain & sprockets.
Revolution of the Rope drum = 44.00 nos.
Revolution of the P1W2 shaft = (44x110)/16 = 302.50 nos.
Sprockets :
Simplex, Pilot bore, Type-B, steel/cast,
Teeth Pitch PCD
Sprocket-1 20 9.525 60.89
Sprocket-2 80 9.525 60.89
PAGE : 26 OF 26