Evolution of Project Management
Evolution of Project Management
1962: United States Department of Defense Mandate the Work Breakdown Structure
(WBS) Approach
The United States Department of Defense (DOD) created the WBS concept as part of the Polaris
mobile submarine launched ballistic missile project. After completing the project, the DOD
published the work breakdown structure it used and mandated that this procedure be followed in
future projects of this scope and size. WBS is an exhaustive, hierarchical tree structure of
deliverables and tasks that need to be performed to complete a project. Later adopted by the
private sector, the WBS remains one of the most common and effective project management
tools.
1965: The International Project Management Association (IPMA) Founded
IPMA was the world's first project management association, started in Vienna by a group as a
forum for project managers to network and share information. Registered in Switzerland, the
association is a federation of about 50 national and internationally oriented project management
associations. Its vision is to promote project management and to lead development of the
profession. Since its birth in 1965, IPMA has grown and spread worldwide with over 120,000
members in 2012.
1969: Project Management Institute (PMI) Launched to Promote the Project Management
Profession Five volunteers founded PMI as a non-profit professional organisation dedicated to
advance the practice, science and profession of project management. The Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania issued Articles of Incorporation for PMI in 1969, which signified its official start.
During that same year, PMI held its first symposium in Atlanta, Georgia and had an attendance
of 83 people. Since then, the PMI has become best known as the publisher of, 'A Guide to the
Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK)' considered one of the most essential tools
in the project management profession today. The PMI offers two levels of project management
certification, Certified Associate in Project Management (CAPM) and Project Management
Professional (PMP).
1975: PROMPTII Method Created by Simpact Systems Limited
PROMPTII was developed in response to an outcry that computer projects were overrunning on
time estimated for completion and original budgets as set out in feasibility studies. It was not
unusual to experience factors of double, treble or even ten-times the original estimates.
PROMPTII was an attempt to set down guidelines for the stage flow of a computer project. In
1979 the UK Government's Central Computing and Telecommunications Agency (CCTA)
adopted the method for all information systems projects.
1984: Theory of Constraints (TOC) Introduced by Dr. Eliyahu M. Goldratt in his Novel
"The Goal"TOC is an overall management philosophy that is geared to help organisations
continually achieve their goal. The title comes from the view that any manageable system is
limited in achieving more of its goal by a small number of constraints, and there is always at
least one constraint. The TOC process seeks to identify the constraint and restructure the rest of
the organisation around it by using Five Focusing Steps. The methods and algorithms from TOC
went on to form the basis of Critical Chain Project Management.
1987: A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK Guide) Published
by PMIFirst published by the PMI as a white paper in 1987, the PMBOK Guide was an attempt
to document and standardise accepted project management information and practices. The first
edition was published in 1996, followed by a second in 2000, and a third in 2004. The guide is
one of the most essential tools in the project management profession today, and has become the
global standard for the industry.
1989: Earned Value Management (EVM) Leadership Elevated to Under-secretary of
Defense for Acquisition
Although the earned value concept has been around on factory floors since the early 1900s, it
only came to prominence as a project management technique in the late 1980s early 1990s. In
1989, EVM leadership was elevated to the Under-secretary of Defense for Acquisition, thus
making EVM an essential part of programme management and procurement. In 1991, Secretary
of Defense Dick Cheney cancelled the Navy A-12 Avenger II Programme because of
performance problems detected by EVM. The PMBOK Guide of 1987 has an outline of Earned
Value Management (EVM) subsequently expanded on in later editions.
1989: PRINCE Method Developed From PROMPTII
Published by the UK Government agency CCTA, Projects in Controlled Environments
(PRINCE) became the UK standard for all government information systems projects. A feature
in the original method, not seen in other methods, was the idea of 'assuring progress' from three
separate, but linked perspectives. However, the PRINCE method developed a reputation for
being too unwieldy, too rigid and applicable only to large projects, leading to a revision in 1996.
1997: Critical Chain Project Management (CCPM) Invented
Developed by Eliyahu M. Goldratt, Critical Chain Project Management is based on methods and
algorithms drawn from his Theory of Constraints (TOC) introduced in his 1984 novel titled, 'The
Goal'. A Critical Chain project network will keep the resources levelly loaded, but will need
them to be flexible in their start times and to switch quickly between tasks and task chains to
keep the whole project on schedule.
2006: "Total Cost Management Framework" Release by AACE International
Total cost management is the name given by AACE International to a process for applying the
skills and knowledge of cost engineering. It is also the first integrated process or method for
portfolio, programme and project management. AACE first introduced the idea in the 1990s and
published the full presentation of the process in the, 'Total Cost Management Framework'.
2008: 4th Edition of PMBOK Guide Released
The fourth edition of the guide continues the PMI tradition of excellence in project management
with a standard that is easier to understand and implement, with improved consistency and
greater clarification. The updated version has two new processes not in the previous versions.
2009: Major PRINCE2 Revision by Office of Government Commerce (OGC)
A major revision has seen the method made simpler and more easily customizable, a common
request from users. The updated version has seven basic principles (not in the previous version)
that contribute to project success. Overall the updated method aims to give project managers a
better set of tools to deliver projects on time, within budget and to the right quality.
2012: ISO 21500:2012 Standard for Project Management Released
In September 2012, the International Organisation for Standardization published "ISO
21500:2012, Guidance on Project Management". It is the result of five year's work by experts
from more than 50 countries. The standard is designed for use by any organisation, including
public, private or community organisations, and for any project, regardless of complexity, size
and duration.
The PMBOK (2012) defines a project as a temporary Endeavour undertaken to create a unique
product or service. Temporary means that every project has a definite end. Unique means that
the product or service is different in some distinguishing way from all similar products or
services.
A project may also be defined as a means of moving from a problem to a solution via a series of
planned activities. It is a set of interrelated activities that has a definite starting and ending point
and results in the accomplishment of a unique often major outcome; or an identifiable goal and
an integrated system of complex but interdependent relationships.
NB; Projects differ from other organizational activities which involve repetitive processes e.g. a
steel plant orders raw materials, makes steel and ships finished products again in a recurring
cycle. Projects do not conform to common standards of operations; they do things differently
and often reveal new and better ways of doing things. The following are the distinctions
between process and projects
Process Projects
Repetitive Non repetitive
Several objectives One objective
People are homogenous People are more heterogeneous
Ongoing One shot- limited life
Well established systems in place to integrate efforts Systems must be created to integrate efforts
Greater certainty of performance, cost schedule Greater uncertainty of performance, cost schedule
Supports status quo Upsets status quo
TYPES OF PROJECTS
Construction and engineering projects eg construction of a building, abridge, a motor
way, a railway station, an airport, a power station, a sports stadium etc
IT and computer projects – includes both computer hardware and software projects such
as computerizing the medical records, designing of personal websites etc
Product development projects – includes the design and development of consumer
products eg designing, developing and testing of a washing machine or a mobile phone.
Advertising and marketing projects e.g a marketing promotion campaign
Bank projects such as implementing a new mortgage product.
Event management such as exhibitions, concerts, conventions and shows.
Human resource projects – performance appraisal process, preparing an annual report,
developing a new training curriculum.
The project management team, also called the core, executive, or leadership team, is responsible
for project planning, controlling, and closing and takes directives from the project team. Smaller
project responsibilities can be shared by the team or designated by the project manager. The
project management team and the project sponsor work together to secure funding, simplify
scope questions, and influencing team members.
Project human resource management processes include human resource planning, acquiring the
project team, developing the project team and managing the team. Processes are used multiple
times, usually occurring at least once in a project or several times in different phases if the
project is made up of many phases. In reality, processes intersect with each other and with other
phases and are not as definite and concrete as illustrated here.
Project human resource management planning may be required if more experienced members are
added to the team. The project management team should also prepare for risk management and
changes to project duration.
PROJECT PLANNING
Introduction
Failing to plan is planning to fail. There are two barriers to good planning. The first is prevailing
paradigms, and the second is the nature of human beings. A paradigm is a belief about what the
world is like. You can tell what people believe by watching what they do, because they always
behave consistently with their deeply held beliefs. Some managers don’t believe in planning.
The second reason that people don’t plan is that they find the activity painful. Some individuals,
especially engineers and programmers, are concerned that they will be held to estimates of
task durations that they have made using their best guesses as they have no historical data to
draw on. But they also know that such numbers are highly uncertain, and they are afraid that
failure to meet established targets will get them in trouble
PLANNING DEFINED
Planning is simply answering the questions “Who, What, When, Why and How?”. It is a process
of developing and maintaining a project plan that provides supporting details to the project
definition in terms of resources, time, scope and schedules. It is a tool of communication and
control that will indicate the project work breakdown structure, task relationships, estimated
work packages, resource schedules, assignment and leveling of resources and project budget.
Before a project team does any work, it should spend time ensuring that it has a shared
understanding of where it is going. The terms used to define that destination are mission,
vision, goals, and objectives. And it is at this very early stage that projects tend to fail, because
everyone takes for granted that “we all know what the mission is.”
Project Design is a collaborative and systematic identification and prioritization of problems and
opportunities; followed by the planning of solutions; and preparing ways of assessing project
outcomes.
It is the process by which solutions to clearly identified problems are identified and structured in
a way that makes them implementable. It is a formalization, preferably set down in writing on
paper indicating how and why it is to be carried out. It includes any necessary details of timing,
budget, phasing and other choices about how and why it is to be completed.
Project design therefore involves the determination of the project goals, objectives, outputs,
activities and their relationships.
Importance of project design
Allows;
Accurate identification of the problem and it causes
Recognition of the organizations perceived need.
Involvement of stakeholders in design and implementation.
Timely monitoring and evaluation to show progress towards objectives and to allow
problems to be detected and corrected before they become irreversible.
Project management cycle is about dividing project into phases that simplifies the process and
enables leadership in the best possible direction. Five Project cycles includes
1. Project Initiation
Steps include:
1) Initiating Phase
3. Execution of the Project Feedback loop is activated
as part of the change
Steps include: The initiating processes management process
The initiating stage should include a plan that encompasses the following areas.
These areas can be recorded in a series of documents called Project Initiation documents.
Project Initiation documents are a series of planned documents used to create order for the
duration of the project. These tend to include: project proposal (idea behind project, overall
goal, duration)
2) Planning
3) Execution
The execution phase ensures that the project management plans and deliverables are executed
according to plan. This phase involves proper allocation, co-ordination and management of
human resources and any other resources such as material and budgets.
Monitoring and controlling consists of those processes performed to observe project execution so
that potential problems can be identified in a timely manner and corrective action can be taken,
when necessary, to control the execution of the project.
The key benefit is that project performance is observed and measured regularly to identify
variances from the project management plan.
In multi-phase projects, the monitoring and control process also provides feedback between
project phases, to implement corrective or preventive actions to bring the project into compliance
with the project management plan.
Relevance
Effectiveness
Efficiency
Impact
5) Closing
Closing includes the formal acceptance of the project and the ending thereof. Administrative
activities include the archiving of the files and documenting lessons learned.
In order to be successful in their practice, both beginning project managers and those who have
been in the trenches for years need to become proficient across all stages of a project’s life cycle.
There are a few different schools of thought regarding the phases of project management, but the
classification developed by the PMI is largely considered to be the authority and the most
complete approach.
Project Management Triangle is a model of the constraints inherent in managing a project. These
constraints are in threefold
Time
Scope Cost
Basically, the Triple Constraint states that the success of the budget is impacted by its budget is
impacted by its budget deadline and its features. As a manager of that project, you can trade
between these constraints however, changing the other two will suffer to some extent.
Enhance creativity- It provides a framework that everyone in the project can agree on. These
metrics drives the project forward while allowing for adjustments as needed when issues arises.
2. Defining of activities: identifying and documenting what actions must be done to produce
3. Sequence activities: Identifying and documenting the logical order of work to be most
efficient.
4. Estimate activity resources: What type and how many materials people, equipment,
5. Estimate activity durations: How long will it take to complete each activity with the
resources estimated.
6. Develop schedule: Analyze activity, duration, resources and timeline to develop a
schedule.
project is on track.
When managing a project some variables can change. The Triple Constraint gives you a firm
sense of what can and can’t be adjusted throughout the course of the project.
Cost
The financial commitment of the project is dependent on several variables. There are two
resources involved from the materials which include labor costs. There are other outside the
forces that can impact a project which must be considered in the cost of work. Cost resources
include cost estimating to figure out the needed financial commitment for all the necessary to
complete the job.
Scope
Deals with the specific requirements of tasks necessary to complete the project scope is
important to manager any project, whether agile software projects or well-planned waterfall
projects because if you cannot control the scope of the project, you are not likely it on time or
under the budget. When managing the scope of the project, it is critical that you prioritize your
tasks enabling you to plan and assign resources successfully.
Time
The schedule is the estimated of the time allocated to complete the project of producing the
deliverable. It is figured out by first noting all the tasks necessary to move from the start to the
end of the project.
By using a project management dashboard, a manager can keep sight of the project as it
progresses. Metrics such as schedule, cost and scope of the project are easy to track.
A process is defined as a set of activities that must be performed to achieve a goal. Project
Management Processes are overlapping activities that occur at varying levels of intensity
throughout each phase of the project.
There are nine management processes on a development project. These are designed to help
manage the different elements of a project. Different projects may have different needs from
each process; for example, a project that has identified that cost is a critical success factor will
spend more time and effort in developing a cost management plan. These processes are the key
knowledge areas a project manager must master.
There are nine project management processes these are: group work
1. Scope Management
2. Schedule Management
3. Budget Management
4. Quality Management
5. Team Management
6. Stakeholder Management
7. Information Management
8. Risk management
9. Contract Management
1. Scope Management
This includes the processes involved in defining and controlling what is or is not included in the
project; required to complete the project successfully. Scope is the way to describe the
boundaries of the project. It defines what the project will deliver and what it will not deliver.
This process ensures that the project has identified the goals and objectives and those have been
documented and that each objective has a well-defined set of indicators to monitor their progress.
During this process a scope management plan is created to help manage any changes to the
projects. This is a critical process and one that will help project manager’s deal with scope creep,
which is when a project includes additional work after a project has started without considering
the impact on the resources or schedule of the project. Request for additional work may come
from many of the stakeholders. The project stakeholders can have a better understanding of the
project boundaries
2. Schedule Management
This process includes the actions required to ensure the timely completion of the project.
Schedule management is the development of a project schedule that contains all project
activities, the project schedule is a communication tool that informs project stakeholders the
status of the project and gives project team member’s information, in the form of graphs and
charts, as to when each activity must begin and end.
The project schedule is also used to assign project staff with their tasks. Monitoring the schedule
is an ongoing task, as each activity is performed the project manager must review the progress
made against the schedule baseline and determine what schedule variance have occurred, the
schedule management plan should include instructions on how to proceed when schedule
variances occur. Another element of schedule management is the procedure to control schedule
changes and define who can authorize changes to the schedule. It is not uncommon that at the
moment of planning the project some oversight occurred that did not plan for situations when the
beneficiaries are involved in other events, such as festivities or social events; this can also
include unpredictable events such as the weather or political events that can disrupt any project
schedule.
3. Budget Management
Budget management processes are required to ensure the project is completed within the
approved budget. This is the area that receives a lot of scrutiny during and after the project is
completed. The project’s ability to manage the financial resources obtained by the organization
will be a measure of the organizations probity, not only in compliance with donor’s requirements
but also a measure of its efficiency. Risks in this area have the highest impact to the project, the
organization and to the beneficiaries; inadequate budget management can lead to
misappropriations of funds, improper assignment of expenses and losses that the organization
may have to cover using its limited funds.
The main steps of budget management include; the definition of all resource requirements the
project will use, from consultants, material and equipment; development of a cost estimate of all
the resources including human resources, and the development of a budget baseline that will be
used to track and report budget expenditures
4. Quality Management
Quality management is the process to ensure that the project will satisfy the needs of the
beneficiaries. Quality is defined as a commitment to deliver the project outputs and meet the
expectations of the beneficiaries, which means that quality is ultimately defined by the
beneficiary. Quality is not about delivering the most expensive materials or services; is ensuring
the project outputs are relevant to the needs of the beneficiaries, that they are delivered in a
timely manner and are adequate to the conditions in which they have to be used. It is not
necessarily doing additional work if it does not add value or benefit to the beneficiaries, it’s
about delivering on the commitment the project made at its initiation, and it’s doing what the
project said it was going to do.
During the quality management process the project manager develops a quality management plan
which identifies the quality standards that are relevant to the project, some of these standards
may be initially set by the organization, the donor or are part of the technical competence area
the project is focusing, such as health or education. The second process in quality management
includes quality assurance, which implies the execution of the quality plan; this process includes
quality audits performed by the project team during every project deliverable and reevaluating
the quality standards and any assumptions made in the quality plan. Quality assurance focuses on
prevention measures during the project implementation phase and checks to see that project staff,
consultants or project partners are following the quality standards. In certain conditions meeting
quality standards could mean meeting legal and regulatory standards set by the local government
or the donor agency. The third process in quality management is quality control; this is where the
project measures the results of the deliverables or outputs and check to see if they meet the
quality standards. The final process is quality improvements is making changes to the quality
plan and identifying ways to improve quality an eliminate causes of unsatisfactory quality
discovered during quality control. Quality management outputs include a quality management
plan,quality audit reports, and quality improvement records. A such quality is also maintaining
the four project constraints in balance, implementing the project by delivering all that the
projects was designed to deliver in the time allotted and under the approved budget.
5. Team Management
During the definition of the project activities a list is created that identifies the skills needed by
the project. These range from highly technical to administrative and support functions. The
project team is after all the team responsible for the project and the project needs to be clear in
acquiring the skills it needs. Team management includes the processes required to make the most
effective use of the people involved in the project. The first step is identifying the roles,
responsibilities and reporting relationships. The second step is getting the people that will be
assigned to the project. These can come from within the organization or hired through the
Human Resource function of the organizational. This is where the project manager needs to be
heavily involved and participate in all interviews with possible candidates; the success of the
project will depend on the quality and commitment of the team. Once the team has been assigned
to the team the next step is to develop the team, most projects do not have the luxury of time to
fully develop a team, but the creation of a plan, that defines the development strategies and
goals, can help the project manager as the project gets implemented and the team starts to
produce. Team development includes hard and soft skills, hard skills like technical training to
learn new methodologies or practices, and soft skills such as time management, communications,
facilitating and negotiating skills
Organizations also include an induction process to new hires were the mission, norms and
culture of the organization are described and guidelines and other internal processes are fully
explained that will help new staff navigate through the organizations policies and procedures.
Part of team management also includes team evaluation; this should not be done once a year or at
the end of the project but on a continuous basis to provide feedback and opportunities for staff to
know about their performance and identify ways to improve it.
6.Stakeholder Management
Stakeholder management is one of the areas that receive the least amount of thought and
planning in development projects, this is due to the limited understanding and agreement on who
are the stakeholders and their role in the project. Stakeholders are all the people who have an
interest in the project and they are the most critical element for the success of the project. They
include donors, beneficiaries, local government, partner organizations and anyone who will be
impacted by the project. Each project has a different list of stakeholders, a range that can include
the local press, local organizations, institutions and even watchdog organizations. Stakeholder
management includes the processes of stakeholder analysis, planning, and communication.
Stakeholder Analysis is the technique used to identify who are the project stakeholders, the next
step is to identify their level of interest and influence in the project ,and identify their fears and
concerns about the project. The final step is to develop a good understanding of the most
important stakeholders and develop a communications strategy and a stakeholder map that
will help manage the relationships.
7. Information Management
Includes the processes required to ensure timely and appropriate generation, collection,
dissemination, storage, and ultimate disposition of project information. 80% of a project
managers’ time is spent communicating via reports, email, telephone, meetings and
presentations. The first step of the plan is to define the information’s needs of the stakeholders,
determine when they need it, how the information will be distributed and how to evaluate the
relevance and effectiveness of the information. Having a successful communications plan
depends to a large extend to the ability of the project to listen, communication is not just about
sending information, but learning to listen first and then define what information is missing. The
goal of communication is the acceptance of the project’s message by the receiving audience. If
the receiver understands the meaning of the message which asks for action, but fails to act, the
goal of communications is not achieved. But if the receiver responds to the message by taking
the appropriate action, the goal of the communication has been achieved.
8. Risk Management
Risk Management includes the processes concerned with identifying, analyzing, and responding
to project risk. Risk in projects is defined as something that may happen and if it does, will have
an adverse impact on the project. There are four stages to risk management planning, they are:
risk identification, risk analysis and quantification, risk response, risk monitoring and control.
Risk identification deals with finding all possible risks that may impact the project, it involves
identifying potential risks and documenting their characteristics. The project team members
identify the potential risks using their own knowledge of the project, its environment, similar
projects done in the past. Risk identification results in a deliverable project risk list. Risk
identification deals with finding all possible risks that may impact the project, it involves
identifying potential risks and documenting their characteristics. The next step is the quantitative
and qualitative analysis of the project risks. Qualitative risk analysis assesses the importance of
the identified risks and develops prioritized lists of these risks for further analysis or direct
mitigation. Quantitative risk analysis is a way of numerically estimating the probability that a
project will meet its cost and time objectives. Quantitative analysis is based on a simultaneous
evaluation of the impact of all identified and quantified risks
Risk monitoring and control keeps track of the identified risks, residual risks, and new risks. It
also ensures the execution of risk response plans, and evaluates their effectiveness.
9. Contract Management
Contract Management includes the processes required to acquire goods and services needed by
the project from third parties, for most projects the procurement process is usually managed by a
support or administrative function of the organizations. The role of the project is to supply, as
detailed as possible, all the procurement requirements including all the technical specifications,
quantity and the date when they will be needed; this is created in a project procurement plan.
Contract management consists of four steps; develop the resource plan, implement the plan,
review and update the plan. The resource plan identifies the what, when and how many of the
goods and services needed within the budgeted limits. It also identifies potential sources and the
strategies that the project will use to procure; this is done in conjunction with the organizations’
procurement function. Implementing the plan is the process of developing the procurement
documents such as the Request for Proposal (RFPs), developing the selection criteria and
contract terms; it also involves the process to solicit the goods and services, obtaining quotations,
bids, proposals or offers. Selecting the vendor or source involves choosing from the potential
suppliers, verifying their qualifications and capacity and negotiating and awarding the contract.