Complication Intraoperative
Complication Intraoperative
·Clinical Research·
complications between residents and specialists. The secondary Table 1 Complexities during cataract surgeries
aim was to objectively assess the order of difficulty of phaco Complexity n (%)
surgery steps for residents. Earlier vitrectomy 156 (4.8)
High axial myopia 114 (3.5)
SUBJECTS AND METHODS
Corneal scar, dystrophy, or keratoconus 107 (3.3)
Ethical Approval The study was conducted at a tertiary
Narrow angles 74 (2.3)
eyecare center in Hungary. The study was approved by the Pseudoexfoliation or zonular fiber compromise 53 (1.6)
Regional and Institutional Committee of Science and Research Small-pupil intraoperative floppy-iris syndrome 50 (1.5)
Ethics of Semmelweis University, Hungary (No.121/2021). Special cataract (posterior polar, traumatic, or 30 (0.9)
hypermature)
The study was performed in accordance with the Declaration
Inadequate cooperation during surgery 28 (0.9)
of Helsinki Guidelines for Human Research. Written informed Earlier glaucoma filtration surgery 19 (0.6)
consent was obtained from the patients. Earlier keratoplasty 17 (0.5)
This retrospective review included 3272 consecutive patients Posterior synechiae 10 (0.3)
who underwent primary phaco surgery performed by residents Anatomical differences in the body habitus 2 (0.06)
and specialists over a period of 1y, from January 1, 2019, to Other complexities 6 (0.2)
587
IntraOP complications in phaco surgery in Hungary
visual impairment[16-17].
Table 3 Intraoperative complications during cataract surgery in
We analyzed the intraoperative complication rates for phaco
all simple cases and in simple cases for resident trainees and staff
surgery performed by specialists and residents and objectively
surgeons n (%)
determined the difficulty of each stage of the surgery at a tertiary
Simple cases Resident Staff surgeon
Complication
eyecare center in Hungary. To the best of our knowledge, this is (n=2675) trainee (n=217) (n=2458)
the first study to objectively report the order of difficulty in Posterior capsule tear 66 (2.47) 15 (6.91) 51 (2.07)
Without vitreous loss 26 (0.97) 5 (2.30) 21 (0.85)
phaco surgery steps for residents. This is also the first study to
With vitreous loss 40 (1.50) 10 (4.61) 30 (1.22)
report on intraoperative complication rates for primary phaco
With dropped nucleus 13 (0.49) 5 (2.30) 8 (0.33)
surgery, comparing specialists and residents in Hungary. Anterior capsule tear 37 (1.38) 12 (5.53) 25 (1.02)
The overall intraoperative complication rate was 5.4% and was Zonular fiber loss 26 (0.97) 6 (2.76) 20 (0.81)
higher than that reported by other studies in Sweden (0.9%), Intraocular lens dislocation 1 (0.04) 0 1 (0.04)
Canada (1.8%), Portugal (4.1%), and Australia (4.9%)[4-6,18].
Intraoperative complication rates for residents in this study and that of Oliveira-Ferreira et al[6] found significantly higher
was much higher (13.7%) compared to that reported by Low complication rates among residents during phaco surgery.
et al[5] in Canada (2.7%), Briszi et al[19] in Germany (3.8%), Differences may be explained by the different numbers of
Fong et al[4] in Australia (6.1%), Oliveira-Ferreira et al[6] phaco surgeries performed by residents during the residency
in Portugal (6.3%), and Ellis et al[20] in the USA (7.8%). program in different countries, because increased resident
Further, complication rates during phaco surgeries performed experience seems to decrease the incidence of intraoperative
by specialists alone in Hungary (4.8%) were slightly higher complications.
compared to that reported in Australia (2.7%)[4] and Portugal Phaco surgery is a cornerstone of the residency training
(3.3%)[6]. Comparisons of intraoperative complication rates worldwide[21]. While only 7.3% of all phaco surgeries involved
between residents and specialists showed different results in residents in Hungary, studies from other industrialized
different countries. While Low et al[5] and Fong et al[4] did not countries reported much higher resident involvement rates
find a significant difference between the two groups, our study (21%-64%)[1,4-5,22]. Our institution is the biggest and leading
588
Int J Ophthalmol, Vol. 15, No. 4, Apr.18, 2022 www.ijo.cn
Tel: 8629-82245172 8629-82210956 Email: [email protected]
ophthalmic center in Hungary, and about 4 new residents residents found phaco, capsulorhexis, and irrigation/aspiration
begin their residency training every year in the clinic. The to be the most challenging parts of the surgery[9-10]. Based
ophthalmology residency lasts for 5y and phaco surgery on the subjective and objective assessment of phaco surgery
training begins in the second year. During the entire residency difficulties and the incidence of different complication rates
training, every resident performs 50 to 150 phaco surgeries among residents, phaco and capsulorhexis may be considered
at our institution, and this number may be associated with the the most challenging steps in phaco surgery for residents.
lesser surgical experience compared to that in Canada, United In our curriculum, the number of phaco surgeries performed
Kingdom and Portugal where every resident performs 320 to by residents during the 5y of residency is lower compared to
400 phaco surgeries on average during the same period[5-6,23]. published data from other developed countries. This is because
To ensure patient safety, specialists are allowed to swap the our department places emphasis on theoretical knowledge
operating position with the resident during the surgery, in prior to surgical skill in the first part of the training, after which
case of intraoperative complication or before predictable the resident begins to perform a higher number of surgeries.
complication(s). This difference in the curriculum explains the disparity in the
In the present study, the order and incidence of the most number of surgeries performed by specialists and residents.
notable intraoperative complications were similar to findings The limitations of our study include its retrospective design, its
from other studies as follows: PCT (2.6%), ACT (1.53%), involvement of only a single center, and the non-randomization
zonular fiber loss (1.38%), and dropped nucleus (0.4%)[4-6]. The of patients.
incidence of PCT (2.3%) and that of dropped nucleus among In conclusion, intraoperative complication rates were higher in
specialists (0.3%) were also similar to data from Canada and residents than in specialists. Resident involvement into phaco
Portugal[5-6]. The incidence of ACT (5.81%) and PCT (6.22%) surgery should be increased in our department in Hungary, in
in residents was higher in our sample compared to that reported order to improve surgical confidence and acquire safe phaco
by Oliveira-Ferreira et al[6] from Portugal (ACT: 1.0%; PCT: techniques until the end of the residency. Objective assessment
3.4%), Corey and Olson[24] and Bhagat et al[25] from the USA of difficulty stages in phaco surgery was in line with the
(PCT: 2.0% and 6.7%), and Low et al[5] from Canada (PCT: subjective measurement of difficulty levels reported by other
0.8%). Dropped nucleus occurred also more frequently among surveys, with the most challenging parts of phaco surgery
residents in Hungary (2.0%) than in Germany (1.2%)[19], Portugal being phaco and capsulorhexis.
(0.6%)[6], and in the USA (0.6%)[26]. PCT and vitrectomy due to ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
dropped nucleus are considered as a benchmark intraoperative Authors’ contributions: Magyar M conducted the survey,
complication[27-28], because they are associated with a higher analyzed the data, and wrote the article. Sándor GL and
incidence of postoperative endophthalmitis (8×) and retinal Ujváry L conducted the survey and analyzed the data. Nagy
detachment (42×)[29]. ZZ planned the survey and reviewed the manuscript. Tóth G
The intraoperative complication rate also depends on case designed the survey, and edited and reviewed the manuscript.
complexity[18]. Al-Jindan et al[30] reported that the complication Conflicts of Interest: Magyar M, None; Sándor GL, None;
rate may be twofold in complex cases, compared to that in simplex Ujváry L, None; Nagy ZZ, None; Tóth G, None.
cases. To reduce the effect of complex cases on complication REFERENCES
rates, we also analyzed the intraoperative complication rates in 1 Pingree MF, Crandall AS, Olson RJ. Cataract surgery complications
simple cases. The incidence rates showed similar values across in 1 year at an academic institution. J Cataract Refract Surg
the entire sample and compared to other studies with one 1999;25(5):705-708.
exception, where the incidence of PCT among residents also 2 Randleman JB, Srivastava SK, Aaron MM. Phacoemulsification with
showed a higher value (6.9%) as in the whole sample. topical anesthesia performed by resident surgeons. J Cataract Refract
The most difficult steps of the phaco surgery, where the Surg 2004;30(1):149-154.
specialist took over the operation from the resident, were phaco 3 Ünal M, Yücel I, Sarıcı A, Artunay Ö, Devranoglu K, Akar Y, Altın M.
(60.0%), capsulorhexis (19.1%), irrigation/aspiration (11.8%), Phacoemulsification with topical anesthesia: Resident experience. J
and hydrodissection (8.2%). The difficulty of each stage of Cataract Refract Surg 2006;32(8):1361-1365.
phaco surgery is of great interest. Knowing which part of the 4 Fong CSU, Mitchell P, de Loryn T, Rochtchina E, Hong T, Cugati S,
surgery poses the greatest complexity for residents would be Wang JJ. Long-term outcomes of phacoemulsification cataract surgery
useful to design training methods alongside to enhance the performed by trainees and consultants in an Australian cohort. Clin Exp
practice of those critical steps. Several authors subjectively Ophthalmol 2012;40(6):597-603.
evaluated the difficulty of each stage of phaco surgery among 5 Low SAW, Braga-Mele R, Yan DB, El-Defrawy S. Intraoperative
residents. Based on their results and similar to our results, complication rates in cataract surgery performed by ophthalmology
589
IntraOP complications in phaco surgery in Hungary
590