Expectations of Industry From Technical Graduates
Expectations of Industry From Technical Graduates
net/publication/276842090
CITATIONS READS
17 1,748
2 authors:
Pk Tulsi Poonia M P
National Institute of Technical Teachers Training and Research Chandigarh Malaviya National Institute of Technology Jaipur
13 PUBLICATIONS 71 CITATIONS 19 PUBLICATIONS 237 CITATIONS
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Pk Tulsi on 25 April 2016.
Abstract- Industry is operating in an environment characterized creativity and adaptability. Industry is facing shortage of
by high performance work culture, intense competition, emphasis on competent trained manpower and need to spend time, money
quality, value addition, diversification of products and services, and and resources to train manpower to make them job ready. The
automation as a result of globalization. Industry requires job ready situation calls forth for a closer collaboration between the
graduates. It has been found that (a) the employability of technical technical institutes and industry. Though changes are required in
graduates is low, (b) the requirements of skill set vary from sector to
various sub- components of the technical education system, but
sector, (c) technical knowledge and skills are considered to be
important but soft skills (communication skills, self discipline, team two of the sub-components – curriculum and instructional
work, willingness to learn, flexibility, creativity etc.) are considered processes need urgent attention to produce job ready graduates.
to be more important for employability, (d) technical graduates lack
higher order cognitive skills such as ability to analyze, logical
reasoning, ability to evaluate and create, and ability to solve
problems, (e) knowledge of computers and mathematics are essential 2. TECHNICAL EDUCATION IN INDIA
for an engineer to succeed, and (f) teaching-learning processes must
focus on higher order thinking skills, problem solving and creativity The country has third largest system of education in place.
and evaluation processes must change accordingly. Technical
education needs total revamping and changes need to be introduced
Technical education in India comprises of 81 centrally
in the various sub-components of the system. The paper deals with funded institutions, 8562 degree level institutions and 3524
the strategies that can be used to improve the quality of curriculum diploma level approved institutions with an intake capacity of
and instructional processes, and collaboration with industry. 3.4 million [2]. Technical manpower, trained by the system, in
turn contributes to economic growth and development of a
Keywords—Technical graduates, Industry, Curriculum and country. During the last two decades, there has been
Instructional Processes tremendous increase in the number of technical institutions
but still there is a scope for expansion of technical
1. INTRODUCTION institutions as the Gross Enrolment Ratio (GER) at higher and
technical education level is only 22%. Govt. of India has set a
The acceptability of graduates from technical or engineering target of achieving 30% enrolment by the year 2020. The
education institutions is a cause of concern world over. quality of technical education is under severe criticism and is
According to the results of 2013 Talent Shortage survey [1], the of concern to all stakeholders namely policy makers,
most acute talent shortages are reported in Japan (85%) and administrators, teachers, students, industry and society. One of
Brazil (68%). The problem is widespread in Asia Pacific, with the parameters of measuring quality has been the
more than half the employers surveyed in India (61%), Hong employability of graduates from these technical institutions.
Kong (57%) and New Zealand (51%) saying that talent There are two views on employability-a narrow view and a
shortages prevent them from hiring people with needed skills. broader view. When viewed in narrow sense, it simply refers
Industry is operating in an environment characterized by high to as to how many students get employed on completion of the
performance work culture, intense competition, greater programme from the institution. But in broadest sense it refers
emphasis on quality or value addition, diversification of to how successfully a person is able to manage his career and
products and services, and automation as a result of lead a productive and meaningful life. Most of the surveys or
globalization. Industry requires job ready graduates who possess studies undertaken in the area have taken the narrow
the requisite competencies and can take up the assigned projects viewpoint of employability.
or tasks. The competencies expected of graduates include not
only technical knowledge and skills but also ability to work in 3. EMPLOYABILITY OF GRADUATES: REVIEW OF
teams, leadership, interpersonal skills, communication, RELEVANT LITERATURE
19
Journal of Engineering Education Transformations, Special Issue: Jan. 2015, eISSN 2394-1707
20
Journal of Engineering Education Transformations, Special Issue: Jan. 2015, eISSN 2394-1707
training programmes through integration of information and Both the review of relevant literature and the panel
communication technologies. Panel discussion on the theme discussions clearly point towards the skill gap that exist
‘Expectations of Industry from the Technical Graduates’ was between the requirements of the industry and the skill set
made an integral part of the Induction Training Programme being developed among the technical graduates. There is a
with the objectives (a) to identify the skill gaps that exist and need to develop curricula as per the requirement of industry
(b) seek suggestions from the industry personnel and academia and create a conducive environment in technical institutions
to bridge the gap by introducing needed changes in the for quality instruction (both theory and practical) to develop
technical education system. Forty-three panel discussions have the required competencies among technical graduates.
been organized till date. Panelists included the industry
personnel from a wide variety of industries such as 5. STRATEGIES FOR IMPROVING CURRICULUM AND
manufacturing, construction, pharmaceutical, electronics, INSTRUCTIONAL PROCESSES
automobile, infrastructure, bio- technology, service etc.
Some of the major issues that emerged included: The strategies that can be used to develop relevant
curriculum for various courses and improving quality of
Students instruction have been discussed in the following paragraphs.
21
Journal of Engineering Education Transformations, Special Issue: Jan. 2015, eISSN 2394-1707
Therapeutics, Quantified Self (predictive Analytics), and socially relevant projects or industrial projects are to be
Brain Computer Interfaces [11] should be included in the undertaken by students.
relevant disciplines. • Practical work should results in a useful product that is
• Soft skills such as communication, creativity, leadership, saleable in the market. For example, students of
working in teams, interpersonal skills, life long learning mechanical engineering in workshop may design furniture
must find a place in the curriculum of various courses which teaches them various types of joints, manufacturing
• There should also be provision for auditing of courses. techniques, selection of material, selection of tools,
• A variety of modes of offering the programmes such as economics etc.
regular contact mode, distance education, open learning • Students should have open access to laboratories and
etc. should be used to meet the diverse needs of the workshops for experimentation. This will instill confidence
clientele (regular students, working personnel, among students, develop research culture and may also
disadvantaged groups etc.) and increasing access of lead to new designs, techniques, processes etc.
technical education. • Faculty undertaking sponsored research and consultancy
• Curricula need to be revised and modified more projects should involve students in their projects. Students
frequently on the basis of systematic feedback from can thus be groomed for research.
students, teachers, pass-out students and industry/other • Competitions can be organized for students to motivate
work organizations them to take up novel and challenging projects and find
• Industry involvement needs to ensured in curriculum innovative solutions to the problems. Again, multi-
design process to make it relevant and appropriate to the disciplinary teams can be constituted to promote cross-
needs of the world of work and also to enhance fertilization of ideas and promote multi-disciplinary
employability of graduates. research.
• The laboratories and workshops need to be modernized as
per the latest trends in the various disciplines to provide
5.2 Implications for Instructional Processes industry like environment to students. Institutions in the
vicinity can think of establishing joint laboratories in order
Changes need to be introduced in the instructional processes to ensure optimum utilization of resources.
and evaluation processes to develop the necessary practical • Industry-Academia exchange programmes can help in
skills (hands on), higher order cognitive abilities (Minds on), providing required industrial exposure to faculty and also
and sensitizing the students to needs of society (hearts on,) help the students to get practical knowledge from the
and in turn to enhance the employability of technical graduates industry personnel. In addition, industry personnel can be
[12]. invited to interact with the faculty and students from time
to time and they can be involved in curriculum design
5.2.1 Strategies for Hands on process.
• Plan as to what is to be learnt by students, allow students 5.2.2 Strategies for Minds on
to explore, provide adequate practice to learners and then
allow them to perform (Plan-Explore-Practice –Perform) • Instructional methods such as Case studies, Problem-
[13]. solving, Problem based learning, Projects, Group
• Project work-both minor and major should be included to Discussion and Brainstorming should be introduced in
help students to apply the learnt knowledge and skills to order to involve students actively in classrooms. These
find solution to problems. instructional methods will help the students to develop
• Structured industrial training at least for six months in the analytical ability, ability to apply learnt concepts and
last semester or in a phased manner over a period of last principles in solving a problem and generate solutions to
two years should be provided to students. A workbook problems. This will also give them an opportunity to work
comprising of questions related to various aspects of in teams and generate interaction among the students.
industry-organizational structures, processes, products, • In theory classes, students should be encouraged to take up
technology, problems, application of learnt concepts, minor projects such as surveying the market, collecting
principles, procedures etc need to be designed. information about the technology, machines, products and
• An alternate strategy can be used for providing hands on materials, compare the gathered information on various
experience to students. During the first year, students parameters, share information with other students and
should be encouraged to look for appliances/gadgets make presentations in the class.
related to their disciplines available at home and get • Peer learning opportunities, where good students can teach
familiarized with those. In second year, students are to be other students, need to be provided to students. Students
encouraged to work under the supervision of teachers and may be paired or grouped in such a manner that a good
technicians in the laboratories. During third year, training student is able to help others in their learning. Peer
under the skilled person/master craftsman in the vicinity learning results in higher learning as students are able to
needs to be organized and during fourth year of training, freely exchange the information and clarify their doubts.
22
Journal of Engineering Education Transformations, Special Issue: Jan. 2015, eISSN 2394-1707
• Teachers need to provide experiences to students where by The following strategies can be used to enhance and ensure
they can observe a phenomenon or a process and then industry involvement in curriculum and instructional
questions related to why and how can be raised to develop processes [14]:
ability to observe, analyze and apply learnt knowledge. In
simple words, content need to be organized from 6.1 Industry participation in curriculum design
observation to reasoning.
• In order to develop creativity among students, students • Mandatory representation of industry on Board of Studies
should be encouraged to experiment with new ideas, for various Programmes: Curricula of various
techniques, models etc. Brainstorming, attribute listing programmes need to reflect the needs of industry and thus
analogies, and metaphors can be used in classroom Board of Studies(BOS) constituted for designing of
teaching. Problems that can have multiple right answers curricula of various programmes should have mandatory
need to be assigned to students to allow them think of representation of industry. The industry selected for the
alternate solutions to the problems. Open ended problems purpose must be one which is showing high performance,
when assigned; students may be encouraged to work in using modernized processes and technology and current
library to refer to various print resources to generate in its practices and processes .related to management,
alternate solutions to those problems. manufacturing etc. For example, reputed institutions such
• Teaching and research should go hand in hand. The as PSG College of Technology, Coimbtore and Walchand
research in the subject needs to be integrated into Institute of Technology, Solapur have adequate
classroom teaching either by asking students to locate representation of industry on its BOS [15]. Institute of
relevant literature in journals, read and analyze the Technical Education, Singapore, one of the leading
research findings or the teachers themselves may share institutions, has intensive involvement of industry such as
research findings. This will help the students to understand Association of Singapore Marine industries and other
the current status of research, know the various alternatives stakeholders in its curriculum development process.
available to solve a problem, and identify gaps, as well as • Manpower Spectrum Studies and Competence Profiles:
motivate them to undertake research. Industrial associations must take the lead in undertaking
• A system of continuous evaluation of students’ manpower spectrum studies and identify the competence
performance based upon a variety of techniques of profile of engineers at various levels and across the various
assessment should be designed and implemented to assess departments of the industry. Such studies can form the
student performance in technical knowledge and skills, soft basis of designing and developing the curricula for various
skills and managerial skills and generate seriousness programmes.
among students as well as to increase the validity and • Technology Forecasting Committees: Technology is fast
reliability of evaluation. changing and the curricula must keep pace with the
• In case of component design, structural design and system changing technology. This requires that technological
design, open book examination needs to be introduced. changes that are likely to take place in the coming four to
This will help the students in acquiring in-depth five years are forecasted and integrated into the curriculum
knowledge in the subject, minimize rote learning and also of various courses so as to ensure that students who
help them to apply the learnt knowledge. graduate after four years are proficient in handling the
current technology. Technology forecasting committees
5.2.3 Strategies for Hearts on comprising of technologists and academicians be
constituted for various disciplines.
• Subjects like Science and Humanism can be included to • Employer’s Feedback: A mechanism need to be instituted
sensitize the students towards the needs of society and the to obtain employer’s feedback regarding the performance
role science can play in meeting those needs. of passouts in order to introduce changes in curricum .
• During the summer vacations/winter vacations students • Alumni Feedback Mechanism: Feedback from the alumni
should be encouraged to take up surveys of the community working in industry can be of potential use in bringing
to identify the community related problems and the changes in the curriculum. Formal and informal feedback
community projects can be undertaken by group of from the alumni must be obtained to introduce changes in
students to improve the quality of life of people. The the processes.
students of technical institutions can organize
training/awareness camps for community. 6.2 Industry involvement in Instructional Processes
• Social service activities can also be undertaken under the
scheme of NSS/ NCC etc. • Industry-Academia Exchange Programmes: The exchange
programmes can help in providing needed industrial
6. STRATEGIES FOR ENHANCING INDUSTRY exposure to faculty and also help the students to get
PARTICIPATION IN CURRICULUM & practical knowledge from the industry personnel. Faculty
INSTRUCTIONAL PROCESSES may be encouraged to serve the industry for two to three
months every two years.
23
Journal of Engineering Education Transformations, Special Issue: Jan. 2015, eISSN 2394-1707
• Companies offering Electives to Students: Companies can 2. AICTE . ‘AICTE Approval Handbook’, New Delhi:All India
Council for Technical Education. 2013.
offer electives to students. For example, Infosys offers 3. Aspiring Minds Pvt. Ltd. ‘National Employability Study IT/ITeS
courses in Business Intelligence, Enterprise Resource Sector: Key findings and Intervention Indicators’, Aspiring Minds
Planning and Mobile Application Development in Sona Assessment Pvt. Ltd. 2010.
College of Technology, Bengaluru [14]. This kind of 4. V K Gokuladas. ‘Predictors of employability of engineering
graduates in campus recruitment drives of Indian software services
arrangement will help students to acquire knowledge and companies’, International Journal of Selection & Assessment,
skills in specialized areas. 19(3) pp.313-319 2011.
• Inviting Persons Working at Shop floor for www.emeraldinsight.com/bibliographic_databases.htm?id=195274
Demonstrations: Persons working at the shop floor in the 2
5. V. K. Gokuladas. ‘Technical and non-technical education and the
industry can also be invited to give demonstrations on the employability of engineering graduates: an Indian case study’,
latest machinery and equipment to the students. This will International Journal of Training and Development, 14(2), pp.
help the faculty, technical staff and the students to learn 130–143, June 2010.
from and skilled persons and hone their skills. 6. Andreas Blom and Hiroshi Saeki. ‘Employability and Skill Set of
Newly Graduated Engineers in India’, The World Bank South Asia
• Joint Supervision and Evaluation of Project Work and Region Education Team. 2011.
Industrial Training: Students undertaking industrial 7. UK Commission for Employment and Skills – ‘Employability
problems as their project work need to be jointly Skills Project: Review of Evidence on Best Practice in Teaching
supervised and evaluated by the industry personnel and and Assessing Employability Skills’, Policy Research Institute.
2008
faculty. Likewise, industry personnel needs to be involved 8. Penn State University. Electrical Engineering Curriculum Changes
in evaluation of industrial training. for 2012.
• Collaborative Research Projects: Industry academia needs http://www.ee.psu.edu/Undergraduate/2012EEcurriculumchange.p
df , 2014.
to join hands for taking up joint research projects in order 9. K.C. Gonzalez. ‘Changes in UTSA engineering curriculum
to find solutions to the problems faced by industry or improve student retention, grades, graduation rate’, UTSA Today.
society and to promote transfer of knowledge among 2014. http://www.utsa.edu/today/2014/01/justintime.html
partners and strengthening inter-sectoral and 10. Ernest G. Frankel. Changes in Engineering Education, MIT
Faculty Newsletter , XX(5) , 2008.
interdisciplinary research. Collaborative research web.mit.edu/fnl/volume/205/frankel. Html
undertaken by the Solid and Structural Mechanical Group 11. Noubar Afeyan. ‘The top 10 Emerging Technologies for 2014’,
at University of Trento in collaboration with SACMI, The World Economic Forum Blog. forumblog.org/2014/02/top-
world leader industry for Ceramics and ENGINSOFT, a ten-emerging-technologies-2014.
12. P. K. Tulsi and M. P. Poonia. ‘Creating Enabling Environment in
medium enterprise specialized in Virtual prototyping for technical Institutions for Hands On , Minds On and Hearts On’,
improving the ceramic production process and developing Journal of Engineering and Technology Education, 6(2), 2012.
novel multi functional materials and structures lend 13. APEC. ‘Case study of an Institute of Technical Education (ITE)
support to the argument [16]. Singapore’, Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation(APEC). 2010.
14. P.K. Tulsi and M.P.Poonia. ‘Participation of Industry in
• Expert Lectures and Seminars by Industry Personnel: Curriculum Design and Instructional’, Unpublished Paper. 2013
Technical institutions must create a pool of expertise 15. ACCA. ‘AICTE- CII Survey of Industry-Linked Technical
available in the near by industry relevant to the Institutes’, 2013.
programmes being offered. The industry personnel may be https://www.mycii.in/KmResourceApplication/36287.AICTECIITI
Survey13F.pdf
invited frequently to interact with faculty and students on 16. F.Bosi, E. Mazzohcci, I. Jatro, F. Dal Corso, A. Piccolroaz, L.
the current practices. Desri, D. Bigoni, A. Cocquio, M. Cova, and S. Odorizzi. ‘A
Collaborative Project between Industry and Academia to Enhance
Engineering Education at Graduate and PhD Level in Ceramics’,
International Journal of Engineering Education, 27(6), pp1362-
The strategies suggested above if implemented in 1376. 2013.
technical education system can improve the quality of
curriculum and instructional processes and in turn will
enhance the employability of the graduates.
REFERENCES
1. Manpower Group. ‘2013 Talent Shortage Survey: research
Results’, 2013. www. Manpower.com
24