(Occasional Papers) Gudrun Bühnemann - Buddhist Deities of Nepal - Iconography in Two Sketchbooks-Lumbini International Research Institute (2003) - 1
(Occasional Papers) Gudrun Bühnemann - Buddhist Deities of Nepal - Iconography in Two Sketchbooks-Lumbini International Research Institute (2003) - 1
---- -
- - f'- • J"'.
Buddhist Deities of Nepal:
Iconography in Two Sketchbooks
..
GUDRUN BUHNEMANN
~
Lumbini
2003
ISBN 99933-769-7-3
Published 2003
Printed in Nepal by Nepal Lithographing Co .
..
\
t ~- '\
I ;
'
l .. ' . '
' " I (•I
I
CONTENTS
1 Introduction 7
3b The Sketchbook LC 15
5 Acknowledgements 19
The Sketchbook LC 93
Index of Deities' Names in the BOC and LC 115
.. " ' ... :_; __ 1 c ... _ ,_........
I Introduction
those in 'Nepalese Sketchbook no. l' published by Lokesh Chandra(= LC) in 1984.
drawings of deities. More extensive documents such as these are rarely found. I
Kathmandu in 2001 I first obtained a microfilm of the BOC from the National
Archives and several weeks later a printed copy of the microfilm, on the basis of
which I prepared a preliminary list of the deities' names. Later I had an opportunity
to go over my reading of the names with Kasinath Tamo!, which led to several
iconographic source materials. I also began working on the LC. In an effort to obtain
additional material for comparison, and hoping to find the original manuscript from
which the BOC and LC were copied, I searched collections of sketchbooks in the
U.S. But I have been unable to find the original sketchbook or similar sketchbooks. I
also started correspondence with Dr. M. Blom, Utrecht, who kindly lent me several
older microfilms containing material she obtained from the National Archives in the
1980s. While going through her films I found negatives of the BOC whose quality is
therefore decided to use these negatives for reproduction of the sketchbook in this
book, and I express my thanks to Dr. Blom for placing them at my disposal.
7
2 Previous Research on Sketchbooks
A large number of painters' sketchbooks or model books from Nepal are preserved in
archives, museums and private collections in Nepal and the West. These sketchbooks
contain drawings of deities, m~<;talas, mudriis and related ritualistic objects for the
use of craftsmen and painters. Very few have been published and studied. The artistic
damaged, others do not label their drawings and are therefore difficult to interpret.
Blom 1985: 441 offers a brief classification of the extant types of sketchbooks. In her
book 'Depicted Deities' (1989) she presents for the first time a contextual study of
painters' model books and describes therein the characteristic features of these
materials, their practical use and the importance of their study. In this valuable work,
analyze two Nepalese manuscripts which illustrate the deities described in Chapter 6
book devoted to the metallurgical arts. A catalogue, titled 'The Circle of Bliss:
8
October 2003. This forthcoming publication will include a study of a sketchbook by
This book reproduces two similar sets of line drawings of Buddhist deities. The first
one, Bauddhadevatacitrasarµgraha (= BOC). is hitherto unpublished. It is referred to
in Blom 1989: 13-14, 84 and 1995: 140. 141. J.B. 145, 147 (with reproductions of
some drawings). The second sketchbook was published as 'Nepalese Sketchbook no.
1' by Lokesh Chandra(= LC) 1984: 1-19, but the drawings are rather dark and the
details hard to distinguish. They are reproduced in this book in somewhat better
quality and with a new list of deities' names. The BDC and LC appear to be copies of
another sketchbook which has not yet been discovered.
Kathmandu only in microfilm (reel no. E 1866/2, running no. E 35548). The
1980s Blom was apparently able to see the original (see her brief description in Blom
1989: 14). The original sketchbook is no longer traceable, since it was returned to its
9
manuscript (thyiisaphu) made of canvas and not - as usually is the case - paper. The
size of the sketchbook is recorded as 25.6 x 17 cm, but on the microfilm which I
obtained the drawings have been enlarged. Since the quality of the negatives obtained
by M. Blom in the 1980s is superior to that of the microfilm copy supplied by the
National Archives, the negatives were used for reproduction here. The sequence of
pages in the negatives and the microfilm is identical, but may not be the original
sequence of the drawings in the manuscript. It appears that some folios are out of
sequence. The arrangement of deities is not very systematic and may not follow a
particular text. The Lokesvaras and some forms of Mafijusli, for example, are found
in two different places. It is also possible that the sketchbook is incomplete. Since the
pages are unnumbered and the original unavailable, I did not have enough evidence
to justify rearranging the folios and have therefore retained the sequence in which the
drawings were photographed. This sequence is as follows (an asterisk indicates that a
Folios Deities
10
Folio 13 Deities 55--00
Among the deities that figure prominently are the Lokesvaras, forms of
Maiijusri and Tara. The manuscript also includes two ma1.1<;lalas, which are not found
in the LC. The first one is a mar:i<;lala of CakrasaqlVara, which corresponds for the
11
Most of the drawings are accompanied by the deities' names in Nevan
characters. The spellings of these names contain many errors. This is probably due to
carelessness on the part of the scribe as well as lack of knowledge of Sanskrit. One
also may note that in the orthography of Nevan manuscripts long and short vowels
are frequently interchanged, as are the letters llr, nlr,j/y, v/b, kh/~ and s/~/s. 1 In listing
the deities' names, I have standardized the orthography and corrected obvious scribal
mistakes, for example, when the inscriptions substitute single for double consonants
or dental for retroflex consonants. Thus I changed Marici to Manci,2 Mahavara to
Mahabala and Vajrasatva to Vajrasattva. But I did not correct Nevan variants of
Other names are hybrid formations with Sanskrit, Prfilqt and Nevan elements. In
such cases I have not attempted to make any changes either. The forms of names of
Buddhist deities which are recorded as standard forms in reference works and
dictionaries are often based on Bhattacharyya's edition of the Sadhanamfila and
rejected other local forms of names which are found in the manuscripts often enough
to be considered local Nevan variants. The names of the Lokesvaras, which are based
Manci (which seems to be the intended reading) can also be interpreted as (the
appear to be unusual and not attested elsewhere. Wherever a deity's name could not
be determined with certainty I have discussed possible readings of the text in the
footnotes. A final decision can only be made after comparing textual descriptions in
1
For peculiarities in the orthography of Nevari manuscripts, see Lienhard/Manandhar 1988:
XXVII-XXVIII.
2
I adopt the spelling Manci recorded in the Monier-Williams 'Sanskrit-English Dictionary'
and in Edgerton's 'Buddhist Hybrid Sanskrit Dictionary.' The reading Marici is found in
some manuscripts (Goshima/Noguchi 1983: 22, no. 81 and Hodgson 1874 [1972): 19).
3
The form Vajradhate~vari is also used in Williamsffribe 2000: 21 l.
12
the siidhana collections related to Nepal with the drawings. At times I have found the
referring to an attribute, is found instead of the name Prajfiaparamita. In BOC 139 the
word dharmacakrasamiidhi, which refers to two mudras (i.e., dharmacakramudra
Paficarak~a goddesses. In another case (see below), a deity's name is derived from
the colophon of a siidhana text. It is impossible to say whether the deities' names
were added to the drawings by a later hand or not. Some drawings are not labelled at
all; perhaps they were inserted later. Two of these unlabelled drawings can be
identified as Loke~varas. Some deities may seem identical at first sight, but closer
examination shows that different colours are specified for them. Other deities, such
as the Paficarak~a goddesses. appear several times, each time following a different
iconographic tradition. The deities' attributes are rarely labelled; if they are, Nevan
later hand redrew pairs of arms with attributes separately. It also appears that on
some drawings the fingers of the hands of the deities have been redrawn.
number of arms and heads, postures and seats/mounts. In the table I have hyphenized
long compounded names to help the reader unfamiliar with Sanskrit. Words in angle
brackets indicate my additions. I have listed the number of heads of deities but not
their colours. The BDC frequently specifies colours, but it is often unclear whether a
colour refers to a deity's head or body. In the sketchbook the colours are indicated by
13
ku - for kunilkuvani (Nev.) - smoke-coloured, or for kurikuma - saffron
te - iveta - white
ha - harita - green
ra - rakta - red
pi - pfla - yellow
ni - nila - dark
I have only indicated the major postures: seated, standing, dancing and
flying. Since the names of the postures are usually not specified in the sketchbook, it
is not possible to distinguish, for example, between the standing postures alft!ha and
pratyalf<Jha, which are defined differently by authorities. The column 'Seat/Mount'
indicates the surface on which a deity is seated or standing. Such surfaces include
animals, subjugated deities, lotuses, etc. The seats sometimes have several tiers.
Among the subjugated deities on which a deity places a foot the group of four Maras
petalled, others have petals pointing upwards or downwards. I have not included
these details. The deities' attributes are not listed in the table, because many cannot
be recognized clearly. Additional information such as cross-references to the deities'
Kasinath Truno! places the BDC in the early 18th century based on linguistic
evidence. This date agrees with Blom 1989: 14 and 1995: 140, who assigns the
14
3b The Sketchbook LC
The second sketchbook contains 171 drawings by a single artist who is not identical
with the artist who prepared the line drawings in the BDC. It was first published by
Lokesh Chandra(= LC) 1984: 1-19 as 'Nepalese Sketchbook no. l' with very brief
introductory remarks (introduction, p. 4). In his book, several folios are reproduced
on a page with a single page number, and the deities' names are added at the bottom
of a page. These names were apparently deciphered from the dark microfilmed or
photographed copy of the drawings which is reproduced in the book and not from the
sketchbook were difficult to read: question marks were added to some names, while
other deities remained unidentified. As Blom 1995: 140 already noted, the LC is very
similar to the BDC. Comparing the LC with BDC enabled me to decipher some of
the previously unidentified names and correct some readings of the names. However,
some readings still remain tentative and can only be confirmed if the original
from Pa!an.
For the reproduction of the LC in this book I have used a set of photocopies
pages as followed in his book, but have assigned numbers to all the drawings (on the
margins, from left to right) for easy reference. Table 2 summarizes the iconographic
features of the deities following the same principles as in Table 1, but with cross
references to the BOC. To avoid repetition, the notes on the iconographic features in
Table 2 are less elaborate than those in Table 1. As Lokesh Chandra 1984: 4 already
noted, and Mevissen 1998: 347-349 confirmed after examining the Paiicar~a
folios only in so far as I have taken up the suggestion by Mevissen 1998: 349 that the
second set of Paiicarak~a images should precede the first set. This means that I have
15
moved page 14 to the beginning of the collection and prefixed it to page 1 in Lokesh
Chandra's 1984 edition. I did not have enough evidence to justify rearranging the
order of other pages and have therefore retained their sequence. This sequence is as
follows:
16
3c Comparison of the BDC and LC
About two thirds of the 186 drawings in the BDC are very similar to the drawings in
the LC. However, the last section of the drawings in the BDC (from 137 onwards)
has no parallel in the LC. The sketchbook LC also contains several drawings not
found in the BDC. In contrast to the BDC, the deities' attributes are frequently
labelled in the LC. There are occasionally differences in the orthography of proper
names between the two sketchbooks. In the drawing of one sketchbook the deity may
be seated on a lotus, while the lotus may be absent in the drawing of the same deity
erroneously shows Adibuddha-Mafijusri with nine arms, four on his right and five on
his left side. Similarly, LC 81 depicts Arnoghapasa-Lokesvara with seven arms. Both
numbers were added later in the BDC after comparing the drawings with those in
another document. The fact that the drawings in the BDC are not numbered in
consecutive order and some numbers are entirely missing supports this assumption.
The LC assigns numbers to only one of the two groups of Lokesvaras, that is, the
group of 32 Loke~varas. These same 32 Lokesvaras appear also in the BDC, but with
minor differences in the numbering. In the BDC the 32 Lokesvaras are part of a
other deities.
One might wonder what practical purpose the sketchbooks served. Were their
line drawings actually meant to be models for paintings or sculptures? This may well
have been the case. From his study of the iconography of the Paficarak~a goddesses
Mevissen 1998: 354 concludes that the artist of the line drawings in the LC made an
effort to include iconographic types which were usually not depicted in Nepalese art
least one deity's name in the LC and BDC can be shown to have been derived from
17
the colophon of a sadhana text. The goddess in LC 166/BDC 99 is called 'Kixµcid-
4
vistara-Tara.' This name can be traced back to Sadhanamiila 98 whose colophon
ponds to the description in Sadhanamiila 98, but in the body of the sadhana text the
In his very brief introductory remarks to the LC (1984: 4), Lokesh Chandra traces the
of the BOC and LC, collections of sadhanas related to Nepal are clearly the kinds of
texts in which one should look for iconographic descriptions which correspond to the
drawings. Among the deities whose iconography should be studied in detail are the
become available in recent years, there is yet more scope for research.6
4
As I have explained in BUhnemann 1994: 1-23. Bhattacharyya's 'Sadhanamala' actually
consists of siidhanas which the edit01 compiled from several independent siidhana
collections.
s The Loke§varas should not be referred to as Avalokitesvaras. For the distinction between
the Loke§varas and Avalokite§vara, see Lokesh Chandra 1988: 29.
6
Below I list some material on the Loke§varas which has come to my attention and may be
useful to researchers. Deva 1984: 75-80 describes some forms of the Lokesvaras popular in
Nepal, and Blom 1995 discusses a number of problems related to the Nevar tradition. Lists
of names of the Loke§varas according to Nepalese traditions have been published by several
scholars. Bhattacharyya 1958: 394-431 provides descriptions and line drawings made of
statues of 108 forms which were located at that time in Kathmandu's Machhendra Biihii
(also spelt Machhandar Vahal or Machhandra Bahal), also known as Jana Biihii. He gives
this section the misleading caption '108 Forms of Avalokite§vara.' Locke 1980: 135-137
lists the names of the Lokesvaras written below the wood carvings on the struts supporting
the roof of the same temple. Lokesh Chandra 1981: 4 and 1984: 10-11 compares the names
of the Loke5varas published by Bhattacharyya with those on line drawings made by three
artists (Tantrikmuni Bajracharya, Ang Gelbu Sherpa and Gawang Tashi Sherpa, according
to Lokesh Chandra 1981: 3 and 1984: 10). The artists prepared the drawings under
Amoghabajra Bajracharya's supervision from paintings executed by Siddhimuni Sakya
which have replaced the statues in the Biiha. Lokesh Chandra also publ.ished a list of the
names on Siddhimuni Sakya's paintings (1981: 1~18, 1984: 12-14) and the line drawings
18
In this book I present only a preliminary study of the two sketchbooks on the
basis of the copies available to me. If the original sketchbooks or the original
document from which both were most likely copied comes to light, problems
regarding the reading of some of the deities' names and the sequence of drawings
should easily be resolved. I hope that this small book will contribute to our
knowledge of Nevar Buddhist iconography and will be useful to all who are
5 Acknowledgements
I thank Bishnu Kanta Sharma of the National Archives, Kathmandu, for permitting
me to reproduce the BDC and Dr. M. Blom for making her negatives of the
based on his paintings (1981 : 29-55, 1984: 341-367). In a special issue of the Journal
Mikkyo Zuzo 8: 1990, Tachikawa/Hattori provide some infonnation on the 108 Lokesvaras
in Jana Baba, followed by an essay on the painlings by Tuaoka (in Japanese). This volume
contains two sets of iconographic materials. The first set consists of contemporary line
drawings of the 108 Lokesvaras by Gautam Ratna Bajracharya, which were prepared on the
basis of the paintings in Jana Baba (pp. 25- 79). The second set consists of Takaoka's
photographs of the paintings of the 108 Lokesvaras in Jana Baba (pp. 81-135). It should be
stated that in addition to the paintings of the 108 Lokesvaras (which are preserved under
glass), Jana Baba now also houses representations of the Lokesvara group engraved on brass
sheets. Lokesh Chandra presents a discussion (1981: 12-14, 1984: 14-16) and complete list
of the names of the Lokesvaras as found in a manuscript acquired by Raghu Vira (1981: 18-
20, 1984: 11-12). In his detailed study of the thousand-armed Avalokitesvara, Lokesh
Chandra 1988: 38-42 lists the names of the Lokesvaras according to additional sources.
Gail specifies the names of 12 Lokesvaras from Kva Baba (1991: 40, plates XXXI-XXXIII)
and of 24 Lokesvaras from Caturbrahmamahavihara, Bhaktapur ( 1991: 48, plates XXXVI-
XXXVIII). Blom 1996: 145 notes that a group of 38 Lokesvaras is popular in Nepal and
lists their names according to a sketchbook (1995: 147-148). While going through the
manuscript collection of the National Archives, Kathmandu, I came across microfilm 5.267
(= Nepal Gennan Manuscript Preservation Project, reel no. B 108/2) labelled
'Lokesvaracitrabauddham~c;ialapratima.' This most likely incomplete document consists of
nine leaves with line drawings of the Loke§varas. The extant 27 Lokesvara drawings are
19
sketchbook available to me. Dr. Lokesq Chandra graciously granted me permission
identifying some of the deities' names. I also acknowledge Kasinath Tamofs help in
deciphering some of the names. I thank Dr. Charles E. Pain and Philip Pierce, M.A.,
for improving my English style. I owe thanks to the Lumbini International Research
Institute and the University of Wisconsin-Madison for support during the different
phases of my research. Finally I wish to thank Dr. Christoph Clippers and the
editorial board of the Lumbini International Research Institute for including this
20
Bibliography and Abbreviations
Blom, M.L.B. 1985. Painters' Sketch-Books in Nepal with Special Reference to the
Eight Mother-Goddesses in Bhaktapur. South Asian Archaeology: Papers
from the Eighth International Conference of South Asian Archaeologists in
Western Europe, held at Moesgaard Museum, Denmark, 1-5 July 1985.
Edited by K. Frifelt and P. Sorensen. London: Curzon Press: 441-448.
Blom, M.L.B. 1989. Depicted Deities: Painters' Model Books in Nepal. Groningen:
Egbert Forsten.
Blom, M. 1995. Lokesvaras in Nepal. A living tradition? In: Function and Meaning
in Buddhist Art. Proceedings of a seminar held at Leiden University 21-24
October 1991. Edited by K.R. van Kooij and H. van der Veere. Groningen:
Egbert Forsten: 139-148.
21
Das Gupta, R. 1968. Nepalese Miniatures. Varanasi: Bharatiya Vidya Prakashan.
Hodgson, B.H. 1874 (1972). Essays on the Languages. Literature and Religion of
Nepal and Tibet Together with Further Papers on the Geography, Ethnology
and Commerce of Those Countries. Corrected and Augmented Edition of
Two Earlier Collections of Essays ... With a Supplement of Additions and
Corrections From the Author's Copy. Edited by M.P. Saha And With Other
Additions, Omitted in the Former Edition. Amsterdam: Philo Press.
Huntington, J.C./D. Bangdel 2003. The Circle of Bliss: Buddhist Meditational Art.
Chicago: Arts Media Resources.
(This catalogue will accompany an exhibition at the Los Angeles County
Museum of Art in October 2003 and is currently in preparation.)
22
Kolver, B. 1996. Constructing Pagodas according to Traditional Nepalese Drawings.
Berlin: Akademie Verlag.
Kreijger, H.E. 1999. Kathmandu Valley Painting: The Jucker Collection. London:
Serindia Publications.
Locke, J.K. 1985. Buddhist Monasteries of Nepal: A Survey of the Ballas and Bahls
of the Kathmandu Valley. Kathmandu: Sahayogi Press Pvt. Ltd.
Lokesh Chandra 1981. The 108 Forms of Lokesvara in Hymns and Sculptures. New
Delhi: International Academy of Indian Culture.
Lokesh Chandra 1986. Buddhist Iconography of Tibet, begun by the late Prof. Raghu
Vira. 2 volumes. Kyoto: Rinsen Book Company.
Lowry, J. 1977. A Fifteenth Century Sketchbook (Preliminary Study). In: Essays sur
l'art du Tibet. <Edited by> A. Macdonald, Y. Imaeda et al. Paris: Maison-
neuve: 83-118.
Macdonald, A.W. and A.Vergati Stahl 1979. Newar Art: Nepalese Art during the
Malla Period. Warminster: Aris & Phillips Ltd.
23
Manandhar, T.L. 1986. Newari-English Dictionary: Modem Language of
Kathmandu Valley. By T.L. Manandhar, edited by A. Vergati. Delhi: Agam
Kala Prakashan.
Mikkyo Zuzo 1990. This abbreviation is used for two sets of iconographic materials
reproduced in the special issue of Mikkyo Zuzo (The Journal of Buddhist
Iconography) 8: The 108 Lokesvaras: Line Drawings by Gautam Ratna
Bajracharya (pp. 25-79); The 108 Lokesvaras at the Machhendra Nath
Temple: Photographs by Hidenobu Takaoka (pp. 81-135).
Nev. Nevari.
Pal, P. 1975. Nepal: Where the Gods are Young. New York: The Asia Society.
Pal, P. 1985. Art of Nepal. A Catalogue of the Los Angeles County Museum of Art
Collection. Berkeley: Los Angeles County Museum of Art in association with
University of California Press.
Pal, P. 1991. Art of the Himalayas: Treasures from Nepal and Tibet. New York:
Hudson Hills Press.
Pal, P. 1993. Indian Painting: A Catalogue of the Los Angeles County Museum of
Art Collection. Los Angeles: Los Angeles County Museum of Art.
24
Sadhanamala: A valokitesvara Section. Sanskrit and Tibetan. <Edited by> R.
Sakuma. Delhi: Adroit Publishers 2002.
Shakya, Min B. 2000. Sacred Art of Nepal: Nepalese Paubha Paintings: Past and
Present. Kathmandu: Handicraft Association of Nepal.
Slusser, M.S. 1982. Nepal Mandala: A Cultural Study of the Kathmandu Valley. 2
volumes. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
Tachikawa, M./S. Hattori 1990. The 108 Forms of Lokesvara at the Machhendra
Nath Temple. The Mikkyo Zuzo (The Journal of Buddhist Iconography) 8: fr.
18 (in Japanese).
Van Kooij, K.R. 1977. The Iconography of the Buddhist Wood-carvings in a Newar
Monastery in Kathmandu (Chu~ya-Baha). Journal of the Nepal Research
Centre I: 39-82.
25
Table l : The Iconographic Features of the Deities in the BDC
INo. l Nrune IArms IHeads IPosture lSeat/Mount IRemarks
1 Maiijusri 2 l seated lotus cf. also 46; LC 56
10 Unnruned 2 I standing - -
11 Harihari<hari>vahana- 6 l seated Hari riding LC73
rides a lion
rides a lion
which is on a
lotus
29
lNo. lName IArms IHeads IPosture ISeat/Mount IRemarks
15 Vi~Qulc:anta '7' 4 l seated Vi~QU riding LC23
Garuc;lawho
is on a lotus
lotus
lotus
s The name Vajrahuntika is found among the older representations of the 108 Lokdvaras in Jana Baba;
cf. Bhattacharyya 1958: 398, 409 (no. 35).
6
The inscription reads 'Sanvisi.' This Loke§vara is found among the 108 LokeSvaras in Jana Baba; cf.
Bhattacharyya 1958: 397, no. 32 ('Santiisi') and Amoghabajra Bajracarya 1979 and Mikkyo Zuro 1990
(no. 77): Sant~ri. The LC also reads 'Santasi.'
7
The inscription can be read as 'Sastrbudha' or 'SiistfYUdha.'
1
Bhattacharyya 1958: 397 reads 'Vi~vahana.'
9
The deity Sil!lhanatha differs from the iconographic type of Sil!lhanada (see also Gail 1991 : 47).
30
INo. !Name IArms IHeads IPosture ISeat/Mount IRemarks
30 Unnamed 2 1 standing snakes -
31 Sahasrabhuja10 8 11 standing - LC 38
Pi~9apatra '32'
11
37 4 1 seated lotus LC47
Prajfiaparamita:> '33'
thigh; LC 37
10
The numeral '23' was originally added to this drawing but later erased. This is an error, for '23'
belongs here and not to the following line drawing.
11
The inscription reads 'Pi1_1c;lapata.' This Lokesvara is found among the 108 Lokclvaras in Jana Baba; cf.
Bhattacharyya 1958: 419, 428 (no. 73), Amoghabajra Bajracarya 1979 and Mikkyo Zuro 1990 (no. 36),
who read Pi.l_lcµpatra.
12
The inscription reads 'Ti"ada.' The word trida~u!a seems to refer to the deity's attribute, not his name.
LC 48 adds Prajiiaparamita.
13
Halahala is a Nevan variant of Halahala.
31
INo. IName IArms IHeads I Posture I Seat/Mount IRemarks
47 Sidclhaikavira-Mafijusri 2 1 seated lotus LC57
'41 '
Krodha-Lokesvara> 18
Lokesvara
14
The inscription reads Adyivalokite§vara.
is The drawing is unnamed. A similar Loke§vara is found among the 108 Loke§varas in Jana Bibi and is
identified as Kama1.up.lu-Loke§vara; cf. Bhattacharyya 1958: 395, 403 (no. 10), Amoghabajra Bajracarya
1979 and Mikkyo Zuzo 1990 (no. 99).
16
The inscription reads 'Nitenitha,' a Neviri variant of Sanskrit Nftyanatha. But the word nite/nitye also
corresponds to Sanskrit nitya (Manandhar 1986: 129). Blom 1995 uses the spelling 'Nityanatha,' which
is found in some manuscripts in her article.
17
The inscription reads: Lokanatha-Lalitik~epa-Loke§vara, i.e., Lokanatha-Loke§vara in the lalira
posture.
11
The drawing is unnamed. A similar Loke§vara is found among the 108 Loke§varas in Jana Biha and is
identified as Mayijiilakrama-Krodha-Loke§vara; cf. Bhattacharyya 1958: 395, 403 (no. 15), Amogha-
bajra Bajracarya 1979 and Mikkyo Zuzo 1990 (no. 94).
32
fNo. lName IArms l Heads l Posture l Seat/Mount l Remarks
Loke5vara LC80
thigh; LC 87
mouse/shrew
on a lotus
lotus
Vajratik~~a-Maiij usri
22
67 2 1 seated lotus LC97
19
Cf. LC 87 for the reading Padrnan(tyesvara; the inscription reads Paramanrtesvara. For the iconography
of this deity, see Slidhanamlilli 30. Bhattacharyya chooses the fonn Padrnanartesvara in his edition.
20
The posture is specified as the comfortable posture (sukhiisana).
21
Maitri is a variant of Maitreya in Nepal.
22
The inscription reads 'Vajrataki-Maiijusri.'
33
f No. IName I Arms I Heads I Posture I Seat/Mount IRemarks
Vajratik~Qa-Mafij usri
25
74 8 4 standing lotus LC 104
26
75 Vajrajvalanalarka 8 4 standing Nara<ya1:1a> LC 108
27 and
Lak~mi
horse's head; LC
110
Jayakara,
Siddhikara
and
30
Vasanta
23
The drawing shows four anns on the right side and (erroneously) five arms on the left side.
2
• The inscription reads 'Caturthavijayiisita-Arn{takuQ9alI.' This is the fourth (caturtha) Vajriirnfta named
Arn{takuQ9alI in a group of four; cf. the reference in Ni~pannayogavali p. 19, 11 with three other
Vajramrta deities in the Vajraffirtatantra.
25
The inscription reads 'Vajratrina-Mafijusri.'
26
The inscription reads 'Vajrajviilanarka.'
27
The LC reads Naray~a.
21
The inscription reads Hayagiri.
29
The deity is similar to Paramasva (Ni~pannayogavali, p. 60, 7-12 and Sadhanamiila 261).
30
The LC adds Madhukara to the list.
34
INo. !Name IArms IHeads IPosture ISeat/Mount IRemarks
79 Hayagriva 2 2 standing lotus top head is a
horse's head; LC
109
horse's head; LC
111
consort; LC 114
31
The inscription reads Vajrasiirakada.
32
The correct Sanskrit word is Vajradhatvisvari. The Nevari variant Vajradhate§vari is also found in
Williamsffribe 2000: 211 . For the interchangeability of the letters f and e in the orthography of Nevari
manuscripts, see Lienhard/Manandhar 1988: XXVII.
33
Probably for Mahattari-Tiirii, whose iconographic description is found in Sadhanamiila 90. The LC also
reads Mahattaripa-Tara.
35
INo. !Name IArms IHeads IPosture ISeat/Mount IRemarks
93 v arada-Tara 2 l seated lotus LC 159
LC 161
LC 157
va8yadhikara-Tara35
98 Vajratara 8 3 seated lotus LC 165
(i.e., Aryatara)
Grahamaq-ka
U~~i~avijayA
34
The inscription reads 'Ahaku-lara.' For the interchangeability of the letters o and va in the
orthography of Neviiri manuscripts, see Lienhard/Manandhar 1988: XXVII.
3
s I.e., V~yadhilcara-1ara in the bhadrasana posture (cf. Sadhanamala 92).
36
This name seems to be derived from the colophon of stidhana 98 in the SadhanamaJa, which specifies
the siidhana as ki,,.cidvistarQlfl liirastidhanam. The central goddess of the sadhana is Aryatara.
37
The goddess is described in Sadhanamala 114 with only two legs.
38
The LC specifies them as Brahma, Narayru:ia. Rudra and Indra. This group is known as the four Maras.
36
INo. !Name IArms IHeads IPosture ISeat/Mount IRemarks
106 Cunda Tara 4 1 seated - LC 136
Blq'ku~i Tara
39
113 4 l standing lotus LC 143
40
114 Sita<ta>patra 6 3 seated lotus LC 144
Dharmadhatu-Vagisvara41
39
The inscription reads 'Bhfku!i!i Tara.'
40
The inscription read 0 patra.
41
The inscription reads Dhannasailkhara-Dhannadhiitu-Viigisvara.
42
The addition niimasmrigftisa lhiiliii means 'mentioned in the Niimasarpgiti.'
43
The deity's name is most likely Vajradhatu. The word samiidhi may refer to the samiidhimudrii
displayed by two hands. Cf. 139 'Dharmacakrasarniidhi.'
44
The word dmriva means 'standing' in Neviiri.
37
INo. !Name IArms IHeads IPosture ISeat/Mount IRemarks
124 Pratisara 10 3 seated - LC2
consort; LC 1
<i.e.,
Mahamantranusarar:il>46
si'!'hiisana
45
In LC I this unidentified deity is much larger than the Paiicar~a goddesses. This may suggest that the
goddesses are considered subordinate to this deity.
46
The inscription refers to the goddess as 'Dharmacakrasamadhi,' since she displays the dhannacak.ra-
mudrii and samiidlzimudrii. The goddess can be identified as Mahamantranusar~i. For this iconographic
type, see Mevissen 1998: 334-335.
38
fNo. !Name IArms IHeads IPosture ISeat/Mount IRemarks
141 Vajrawa 8 4 seated lotus -
142 Bhuta<;tamarall;>amara47 4 1 standing divine -
being48
47
Both names are inscribed.
48
Aparajita would be expected but no name is specified.
49
Cf. Sadhanamila 135, whose colophon states: Kalpoktasitamancisadhana. One could also read the
inscription as 'Karapitra-Da!abhuja-Mirlci.'
39
No. Name Arms Heads Posture Seat/Mount Remarks
union with
Vajravarahi;
surrounded by
Khasliroha (=
KhaQ<;laroha),
Lama, J?ak.ini,
Riipi~i. Svanasya.
Y amadrup~!fl.
Uliikasya,
Y amamathani,
Kakasya,
Y amada<;lhini,
Siikarasya and
Yamaduu5 1
surrounded by the
ten Krodhas
50
Bhairava and Kalaratri are expected, as in Ni~pannayogavali, mai:i<;lala 12.
Cf. Ni~pannayogavali, mai:i<;lala 12 (Sarµvaramai:i<:fala) .
51
52
The deity is unnamed. A similar iconographic form of Maiiju§ri seems to be featured on the wooden
tora!Ul of the main gate to Rato Macchendranath, Katlunandu. A contemporary paubha from Pa~.
Nepal "usually displayed in the Hiranya Varna Mahavihara ("Golden Temple") during the Bahidyo
Boyegu ceremony in the month of August every year" (Shakya 2000: 77) represents a similar
iconographic type and is reproduced in Shakya 2000, plate 17. The paubha shows Maiiju§ri with three
heads and six arms. His two main hands display the dharmacakramudra while holding his vajra and bell.
In his other hands, the deity holds a sword and manuscript placed on a lotus, and a final pair of attributes,
the bow and arrow. The Maiiju§ri in the centre of our ma1_1<:fala displays the dharmacakramudra without
the vajra and bell. The other attributes are identical, except that the manuscript is missing (only a lotus is
shown).
40
No. Name Anns Heads Posture Seat/Mount Remarks
Nara<ya-
na>
. 53.
Mahadeva
and Indra
Mahadeva
and lndra56
<Vajrayogini> Bhairava
s3 For a Nepalese representation of Acala (with his consort Visvavajri), who places his feet on Brahma,
Siva, Vi~i;iu and Indra, see plate 19 in Kreijger 1999.
S4 In accordance with Sadhanamila 123; the inscription reads 'Vidyujjvilakaramukhaikaja!ltara.'
41
INo. !Name IArms IHeads IPosture ISeat/Mount IRemarks
169 Vajravarahi 2 2 dancing man pig's face on right
side of head
consort
consort
consort
<Guhya>samaja' consort
(samiijayti)s1
consort
consort
Vajrasattvass consort
57
The particle -yii denotes the genitive case in Nevliri, so that the fonn appearing here may mean 'of
Guhyasamaja.' It is also used as an adjectival suffix meaning 'related to.' It would then refer to a deity of
the Guhyasamaja such as Guhyasamaja-Ak~obhya or Guhyasamaja-Vajrasattva.
58
I.e., Vajrasattva as described in the Saippu~a(tantra)? The inscription reads 'Sakukta-Vajrasattva.' The
iconography of the deity is similar to that of Vajrasattva as described in Ni~pannayogavaH. p. 8, 17 - 22,
but according to the description in the Ni~pannayogivali the deity should have six arms. In that text the
mat)~a is referred to as the 'Srisal!lpu~tantroktavajrasattvamat)<;iala,' the 'Mat)~la of Vajrasattva as
described in the Saippu~tantra.' One could also interpret the inscription as ~~bhuja-Vajrasattva, 'Six-
armed Vajrasattva,' but the drawing shows (erroneously?) ten anns.
42
INo. !Name l Arms IHeads IPosture ISeat/Mount IRemarks
I
consort
standing <Mahi-
deva>60 and
Indra
consort
consort
consort
consort
consort
43
..
The S.ketchbook aoc
2 3
-·..:
. ....
.. ~
·"
....-
5
47
.. n-: .... :--1 &.,,..,..,,_,_
7 8
6 . ..... :;:=-:.· -:. ,.~~,:\::.. .. :·:,.-..\ ·
l·
I
. ~ -.
48
12 13
.,':..
-j
.::,
q·
' 'I.
..
w
I •
~~.-
..
•• ·--·-'·'
..
- -· ... c.
14
49
,....._;_; __ , __ _
~,
16 17
... 4 -t*'4f .•'*6·- - ~.,....
[ '
F
f.'
t:,
.. .
•·
50
r"\ ... : .... : ........ 1 & ... .-..._
~ . . ........
' I
i
I
'
J
' .
.,..'
' ~~~
·. :~
, {-
,
.. .:
I . .,• . ,,
• 1!.
23 24
51
.. r\..,;_; __ , &................
.. ..
... .. : :• . .
-;:·. .\:. :~,:: .. ..._,...
·..:.
~
n~ -- -~: . . .: •
.• .·.
:
E
-~
l
..j'
.
It
I .
r
. :. ..
• ' , ".. • J :
. :,I , ._!. -~ .. ·.. . : ~·· . ···:. ..
, · •··.~-J.
· ... ·'~·-· ~
); I.. 32 . ·-"'"""· -··~
!I .<Al .. J .)
53
... " ...:,...:--• &........ -
-
./
. . . ... ..'
•.._I ..• ·, =·~:· •. .
·. . • .
. '. l
... . .
"i;
,f.·
-
J.
t'
Ii&. ·
!:~
·. :
I.
••
f
.,
~.
.,
54
f"\-:.-:--1 '--.- .......
- .J
. ·'-~
.
. . ·..
. -v ~
•! . •
.. . ' ·•••..,r.,.o:
.,·_',·:::;;?0~~{~?'.~¥~·· .·.
40 41 42
55
r \ .. : .... :--1 .&...... -
;, .
i. .
..
-~
...
""......_ . '
:• '
·~
I
.
•
. ·..
I
•
t
• • •t
.I ....
.
J.
... ...
: :.·- .....
··r .
. .. ..
46
' :r .• -...,.,....
47
; •
.u ' ,
56
--:5::-'4.'_ _ _ __ ......._.
53
57
" - : - : ........ 1 c __ _
i
...
.. ~-~:r= .
.:-s::·:itr·- ?Ji !
58 59 60
58
..
.
../\
......·. .
~ . .. ' 'r; . .
::'!"( .: ...... • _.......__,...,.. _. ~· ...
64 65 66
59
,....._;_; __ , __ _
~,
67 69 70
~t :·-: _~~f.'.'¥@?-JY:S?:: '~;if~j~~J.)!'--''"?2\ ·zo68·-::· a;~~k· 'a ~..~7~1:!'-·~.•~· •w 1:1·ftl1t '>:aarzr&pnz -- ,
·~. : ' -. "-'·
,.,. (:~
• '
71 72 73
60
..
61
f"\ .. i;oo; ....... 1 """ ..... """'
~ . ·'
85
62
.. f"\ .. i;oo; ....... 1 """ ..... """'
86 87 88 89
63
f"\ .. i;oo; ....... 1 """ ..... """'
94
f. -
1" ;.
·.
f~
:~ :
~-r-•
96 98 99
64
65
.... ("\.,.;,..;,..._, ...............
~
111 112
. . ..
~·
• I
'
. "; ·\· .:
. , .... .
,.: :. ·. . .' :
..
;.
. . · 1 .. .. ..
:- -·
1!'
-
••
_,.
...
.
d
·. ..
.... .~
');
F,
f.
.i...
~
t- .
66
66 ("\.,.j,...: ..... -1 ......... ~
11 6
119
- -.
' .,'
... . •,
',
.. . .
, ' ·· .:::. ·· - -"""!--t•-·...!:.:--- ..::-~:-:.-:4"_::~--- . ,.
121
122 123
67
125 126
.r
t
~
! .
£
-.
~
127
68
..
13 1 132 133
: . 1 · ;.. ~~
.. ,
~·
· ~
•·• ' • :: : • ~.. :.- • . ••: • ". l
. '-: ;· .... .. 1 ·
.. ..: .: .: .-~:-:;
..·.· . :-' .. ,· ·::. . : ·. ,.
.,,
.· . ' ...
.. ... . ·.··.
..
•
134 ...
135
136 ---=~'
69
·~ • • t!" ... \:.·~ · ·~: • 1. •
,-. ·}
. .. . :· ·
- ....;,' ' . .....
t
•
.. .
. : . .: . \• -~
•
•
•
70
..
144 145
143
. i.~~
. 'j ~.
. ~·
..:
'
148
71
149
,.
73
156
.·;. •• •• • 4J • I t "•
·~··.~.·(
•
.·..! ·~:"' ·
. . ::.
.· ~ ,,,.
_,
..,..... .
. "... .
• •:. , ·!. ~
.~· -, .. '·· ......
-
·:.' •'
. . . ..
~
.. .'.l\.
:. ·;11. •' :, •
\ -·
. ._ -·.~
'
•I
:.. -:·
.
. ..
./ ·
.-..
.
.
.
..
.. .•'·
.. . . ..· •', ..
. ·. ·• ':, !,..--
·...· ~c.: ·•··
'./
74
75
r\ ..: .... i .... -..1 ~...,.._
166 167 168
76
171
. .
."
....
: .
~
)
I
I •
......
174
77
.. /"'\ ..;,...; ........ 1 ".,,.,.,.........,
175
176 177
;. ' . .:
·'
.
l":;r';'-
: .-v.
~ -
!
•\ -"'.· ~
• "f I
-~
..._
..
180
78
. ' .
_:. . .. . .
''
~ l·..
....~ .... : ..:. •• •
··' '
79
...
Table 2: The Iconographic Features of the Deities in the LC
headed)
consort
'l'>
83
r \ ... : .... : ........ 1 .&. .... ,... .........
INo. IName I Arms I Heads IPosture I Seat/Mount I Remarks
GaruQa who
is on a lotus
lotus
lotus
thigh; BDC 42
1
Halahala is a Nevari variant of Halahala.
84
thigh
Maiijusri
4
47 Pir:i<;lapatra '32' 4 1 seated lotus BDC37
later; BDC 40
2
The list of names in Lokesh Chandra 1984 reads the name as Kamalarudra.
3
The reading is uncertain; the inscription can also be read as Lavaduvi (= Ravadevi?).
4
The inscription reads Pi1_1c;tapata.
85
thigh
peacock
Garuc;la who
rides a lion
s The inscription is hard to decipher. Namasarpgitisa lhana means ' mentioned in the Namasarpgiti;' cf.
no. 132, Maharatnasarpbhava niimasCllJlgftisa lhiiriii. Cf. Sadhanamlila 82 for Aryanamasarpgiti.
86
.. /"\,,...: .... : ......... 1-i...............
INo. !Name IAnns IHeads IPosture ISeat/Mount IRemarks
79 Sugatis~darfana- 6 1 standing lotus BDC54
Loke§vara
Loke§vara BOC56
rides a lion
and left
thigh; BOC 57
lotus
6
Four arms arc shown on the right and three on the left side. One ann was apparently added later on
the right side.
87
r \ ... : .... : ........ 1 .&. .... ,... .........
INo. !Name IArms IHeads IPosture ISeat/Mount IRemarks
96 Mahakala 2 1 standing lotus BDC66
Alllflaku1_14ali
9
107 Yarnasvavajra 8 4 standing Indra, top head is a
Jayakara,
Siddhikara,
Madhukara 10
and Vasanta
Lak~mi
8
I.e., the fourth (caturtha) Vajramrta named Amftakui;ii;tali in a group of four; cf. the reference in
Ni~pannayogavali p. 19, 11 with three other Vajrfunfta deities in the Vajrimftatantra.
The deity has similar characteristics to Paramasva; cf. the descriptions in Ni~pannayogavali, p. 60,
9
88
r \ ... : .... : ........ 1 .&. .... ,... .........
No. Name Arms Heads Posture Seat/Mount Remarks
79
76
80
consort; BOC 82
headed)
11
The list of deities' names in Lokesh Chandra 1984 reads VajracaJ_lc,iika. The inscription reads
VajracaJ11jika. The goddess Vajracarcika is described in Sadhanamala 193. For a similar line drawing.
see the Nepalese sketchbook M.84.171 . 3 a-g preserved in the Los Angeles County Museum of Art.
89
r \ ... : .... : ........ 1 .&. .... ,... .........
INo. lName l Arms l Heads l Posture l Seat/Mount l Remarks
Dharmadhatu-Vagisvara
Grahamaqka Tara
U~1,1i~avijaya Tara
12
The word daf!lva means 'standing' in Nevari.
"The inscription niimasClf!lgftisa lhiiriii means 'told in the Namasarpgiti.'
90
r \ ... : .... : ........ 1 .&. .... ,... .........
INo. !Name IArms IHeads IPosture ISeat/Mount IRemarks
145 Mahacinakrama-Tara 4 1 standing corpse -
146 Sita-Tara 2 1 seated lotus -
147 Sita-Tara 4 1 seated lotus -
148 Sita-$a"bhuja-Tara 6 3 seated lotus -
149 Janguli Tara 4 1 seated lotus -
150 Dhanada-Tara 4 1 seated lotus -
151 DurgottaraJ.li Tara 4 1 seated lotus -
152 Visvamata 2 1 seated elephant on a BDC 100
lotus
NarayaJ.la,
Rudra and
Indra
BDC95
14
The inscription reads Asvaka-Tara. The letters o and va are often interchanged m Nevari
manuscripts.
91
r \ ... : .... : ........ 1 .&. .... ,... .........
INo. lName l Anns l Heads l Posture l Seat/Mount l Remarks
v a5yadhikara-Tara 15
165 Vajra-Tara 8 3 seated lotus BDC98
Aryatara)
Vajradhate~vari
16
170 2 1 seated lotus BDC89
15
Cf. Sadhanamala 92 for this form of Tara, who is seated in the bhadriisana.
16
The inscription reads 'Vajradhlitatesvari_' The correct Sanskrit word would be Vajradhlitv!Svari; the
Nevliri variant Vajradhatesvari is also used in Williarnsffribe 2000: 211.
92
r \ ... : .... : ........ 1 .&. .... ,... .........
The Sketchbook LC
2 3
5 6
8 9
95
...
I0 II
13 I4
IS
96
16 17
18 19
20
22
24 25
26 27
28 29
30 31
98
32 33
34 35
36 37
38 39
99
... r'\ ...:,.. .......... 1 "' ... ,... ........
40 41
42 43
44 45
46 47
100
48 49
50 51
53 54
56
101
.. f"\ .. i;oo; ....... 1 """ ..... """'
58 59
60 61 62
63 64 65
66 67 68
102
.. ("'\.,.j,...: ....... 1 -F................
69 70 71
72 73 74
75 76 77
78 79
103
.... ("\.,.;,..;,..._, ...............
~
80 81
82 83 84
85 86 87
88 89
104
...
91
93 94
96 97
99 100
105
... n ...: .... : ..... -.1 ....,... ........
101 102
104 105
107 108
l 09 110
106
..
112
114
116 117
119
107
.,,
120 121 122
123 124
108
~ 125 126 127
128 129
130 131
132 133
109
134 135 136
140 141
143 144
110
A .. : ..... :-...,1 ;.,,,.....,.......,
145 146
I 14s 149
151 152
111
... r"\ ..:,...: .... -1 f ... -. .......
156 157
112
...
167 168 169
170 171
113
Aparajita LC 124
Brahmad~c;ta LC 42
117
.. /"\,,...: .... : ......... 1-i...............
I;>funara BOC 142
Dhanada-Tara LC 150
Dhvajagralcey\iri LC 156
Ekajata LC 162
Ekajata Tara BOC 159; BOC 160; BOC 161; BOC 164; BOC 165; see also Ekajata
Grahamatrka LC 134
Halahala-Lokesvara LC 66
118
..
Harihariharivahanodbhava-Loke§vara BDC 12/LC 82
Hayagriva BDC 76/LC 110; BDC 79/LC 109; BDC 80/LC 111
Praharai;iamat-H., ~a"bhuja-H.
Janguli LC 163
Kamalabhadra LC 43
Khasarpar:ia-Lokesvara LC 71
Kr~r:iacala LC 44
119
..
Krodha-L., Nilakru;itha-L., Pretasfil!ltarpita-L., $a<;lak~ari-L., S ugatisfil!ldarsana-L.,
Mahacinakrama-Tara LC 145
Mahasfil!lvara LC 15
Maiijusri BDC l/LC 56; BDC 46/LC 56; BOC 65/LC 95; BOC 156; LC 63; LC 105; see
120
r \ ... : .... : ........ 1 .&. .... ,... .........
Maiijuvajra BOC 176
(Mahamantranusfu'aQi)
U<:f<:fiyana-M.
Prajiiaparamita BOC 39/LC 51 ; BOC 40/LC 49; BOC 41/LC 52; BOC 44/LC 53;
BOC 45/LC 54; BOC 109/LC 139; BOC 110/LC 140; BOC 112/LC 142; LC
Pupala LC 46
Pupala-Maiijusri BOC 36
121
r \ ... : .... : ........ 1 .&. .... ,... .........
Ralctaryavalokitesvara LC 76
Ratna/Rava_(?) LC 45
~a<;falc~ari-Lokesvara LC 65
~a<:iak~ari-MaQidhara LC 70
Mahasahasraprrunardani
Sahasravajra BOC 32
SruppuJa-ukta-Vajrasattva BOC J 78
Sru'1khanatha BOC 14
Sankharanatha LC 21
Santasi LC 27
Santasri BOC 20
Sita-~a<;ibhuja-Tara LC 148
Sitavati LC 10
122
TrailokyavasarriJcara-Lokesvara LC 74
U~i:ti~avijaya LC 135
Vajracarcika LC 123
Vajradharma-Lokesvara LC 67
123
r \ ... : .... : ........ 1 .&. .... ,... .........
Vajragho1~a BOC 163
Vajraraga-Maiijusri LC 60
Vajravii:ia-Sarasvati LC 121
Vajrayogini BOC 168; see also Adiv., Ordhvapada-V., VajraghoQli, Vajravarahi, Vidyadhari
v.
Varada-Tara BOC 93/LC 159
Vasudhfu"a BOC 83/LC 115; BOC 84/LC 116; BOC 85/LC 127
124
r \ ... : .... : ........ 1 .&. .... ,... .........
YamadaQ4a BOC 18/LC 26
Yamasvavajra BOC 78/LC 107
Yogambara BOC 172; see also Sri-Yogambara
125
1111111111111111111111111111111111
3 9015 06910 9190