Concept and Development of Intellectual Property Law in India
Concept and Development of Intellectual Property Law in India
1. Colonial Period: During British rule, India adopted IP laws through legislation
like the Indian Patents and Designs Act of 1911 and the Copyright Act of 1914.
These laws were largely based on British models and focused on protecting British
interests.
2. Post-Independence Era (1947-1970s):
India's IP laws underwent significant changes after gaining independence in
1947. The country aimed to strike a balance between protecting domestic
industries and promoting innovation.
The Patent Act of 1970 was a landmark development. It replaced the 1911
Act and introduced the concept of "process patents" to encourage domestic
innovation by allowing inventions related to processes to be patented even if
the end product was already known.
The Copyright Act of 1957 was enacted to consolidate and amend the law
relating to copyright in India. It granted protections to authors, composers,
and other creators, aligning with international copyright standards.
3. TRIPS Agreement and Globalization (1995 onwards):
India's accession to the World Trade Organization (WTO) in 1995 required
it to adhere to the Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights
(TRIPS) Agreement. TRIPS set minimum standards for IP protection, which
led to further amendments in Indian IP laws to comply with these standards.
The Patents (Amendment) Act of 2005 marked a significant shift in India's
patent regime. It reintroduced product patents for pharmaceuticals and
chemicals, aligning with TRIPS. However, it also included provisions to
prevent abuse of patent rights and ensure access to affordable medicines.
4. Modern Developments and Challenges (2000s-2020s):
India's IP landscape has continued to evolve with advancements in
technology and increased global trade.
The Copyright (Amendment) Act of 2012 brought changes to digital rights
management, broadcasting rights, and exceptions for disabled individuals.
The IP laws have faced challenges related to patent disputes, trademark
infringements, and questions about the balance between protecting IP rights
and ensuring public access to essential goods and services.
EBL Page 1
Page |2
Novelty: The invention must be new and not previously disclosed to the public.
Inventive Step: The invention should involve a non-obvious advancement over
existing technology.
Industrial Applicability: The invention must have a practical use and be applicable
in an industry.
EBL Page 2
Page |3
a. Filing an Application:
The inventor or the applicant files a patent application with the relevant patent
office. The application includes a detailed description of the invention, along with
any necessary drawings and claims that define the scope of the invention.
b. Examination:
The patent office examines the application to determine if it meets the patentability
criteria. This involves assessing the novelty, inventive step, and industrial
applicability of the invention.
c. Publication:
d. Opposition (Optional):
Some jurisdictions allow third parties to oppose the grant of a patent during a
specific period after the application is published. They can challenge the patent's
validity by presenting arguments against its patentability.
e. Grant or Rejection:
After examination, the patent office may grant the patent if the application meets
the patentability requirements. If the application is rejected, the applicant may
appeal or make amendments to address the examiner's concerns.
EBL Page 3
Page |4
patent infringement. The patent holder can take legal action against infringers to
protect their rights, which may involve filing a lawsuit for damages or seeking an
injunction to stop the infringing activities.
The law and procedure relating to trademarks involve the legal protection of
distinctive symbols, names, and identifiers used to distinguish goods and services
in commerce. In India, the governing legislation is the Trade Marks Act, 1999,
along with the Trade Marks Rules, 2017. Here is an overview of the process and
key aspects related to trademarks in India:
1. Trademark Application:
The process begins with filing a trademark application with the relevant authority,
which is the Office of the Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trademarks
(CGPDTM) in India.
The application can be filed online or in person and should include information
about the applicant, the trademark, and the goods/services for which protection is
sought.
2. Examination:
EBL Page 4
Page |5
4. Registration:
Trademark owners have the right to enforce their trademarks against unauthorized
use by others. This includes taking legal action against infringement,
counterfeiting, or passing off.
Remedies for infringement include injunctions, damages, and orders for the
destruction of infringing goods.
6. Well-Known Trademarks:
7. Renewal:
The Trade Marks Act also provides for the registration of collective marks and
certification marks. Collective marks indicate the common origin of goods/services
from members of an association, while certification marks signify that
goods/services meet certain standards.
EBL Page 5
Page |6
Copyright is a legal concept that grants creators exclusive rights to their original
works of authorship. These rights include the right to reproduce, distribute,
perform, and display the work, as well as the right to create derivative works based
on the original. The law and procedures relating to copyright vary from country to
country, but I'll provide a general overview of the key aspects and procedures
typically associated with copyright protection:
EBL Page 6
Page |7
8. Digital Copyright Issues: The digital age has brought new challenges to
copyright, including issues related to online piracy, digital distribution, and
protection of digital rights management (DRM) technologies.
EBL Page 7
Page |8
goods that do not originate from the designated region. The protection applies to
both agricultural and manufactured goods.
1. Economic Benefits: GIs can enhance the market value of products and lead to
increased demand and premium pricing due to their unique qualities.
2. Preservation of Cultural Heritage: GIs help preserve traditional knowledge,
skills, and cultural practices associated with specific regions.
EBL Page 8
Page |9
1. Appeals: The primary function of the IPAB was to hear appeals against the
decisions of the Registrar of Trade Marks and the Controller of Patents, Designs,
and Geographical Indications. This provided a mechanism for parties dissatisfied
with decisions related to their intellectual property rights to seek redressal.
2. Dispute Resolution: Apart from appeals, the IPAB also had the authority to hear
and adjudicate disputes arising under various IP laws, including matters related to
patent revocations, trademark oppositions, copyright disputes, and geographical
indication-related issues.
3. Administrative Powers: The IPAB was vested with powers similar to those of a
civil court, including the authority to summon witnesses, require evidence, and
pass orders to enforce its decisions.
4. Cancellation of Registered Trademarks and Patents: The IPAB had the power
to cancel or revoke registered trademarks and patents based on certain grounds,
ensuring the accuracy and validity of registrations.
The IPAB was composed of technical and legal members with expertise in various
fields of intellectual property, including patents, trademarks, and copyrights. The
chairperson was typically a retired judge of the Supreme Court of India or a retired
Chief Justice of a High Court. The board's members were appointed by the central
EBL Page 9
P a g e | 10
government and were responsible for hearing and deciding cases based on their
expertise.
The Competition Act, 2002, is an important piece of legislation in India that aims
to promote and maintain fair competition in the market, prevent anti-competitive
practices, and protect consumer interests. The Act seeks to ensure that markets
remain competitive, leading to better consumer choices, innovation, and efficient
allocation of resources.
EBL Page 10
P a g e | 11
EBL Page 11
P a g e | 12
Tying and Bundling: The dominant firm forces customers to purchase one
product if they want another, leveraging its dominance in one market to gain
an advantage in another.
Discriminatory Pricing or Conditions: The dominant firm applies
different prices or terms to similar transactions, disadvantaging competitors
or customers.
Unfair Trading Conditions: The dominant firm imposes unfair or
unreasonable terms on trading partners, making it difficult for them to
compete.
Exclusive Dealing: The dominant firm requires customers to exclusively
buy from or deal with them, excluding competitors from the market.
3. Market Impact: Abuse of dominant position results in a significant negative
impact on competition, which can lead to reduced consumer choices, higher prices,
and hindered innovation.
4. Legal Implications: Many jurisdictions have laws that prohibit abuse of dominant
position. In India, the Competition Act, 2002, addresses abuse of dominance under
Section 4. The Competition Commission of India (CCI) is responsible for
investigating cases of abuse of dominant position and taking appropriate action to
protect competition and consumer interests.
5. Balancing Act: Not all conduct by dominant firms is considered abusive. Some
actions might be pro-competitive or based on legitimate business justifications.
The assessment often involves considering the effects on competition, consumer
welfare, and overall market dynamics.
6. Remedies: If abuse of dominant position is established, competition authorities
can impose remedies such as fines, cease-and-desist orders, or corrective actions to
restore fair competition in the market.
3-COMBINATION
EBL Page 12
P a g e | 13
4-REGULATION OF COMBINATION
EBL Page 13
P a g e | 14
1. Legal Framework:
2. Mandatory Notification:
In cases where a combination meets or exceeds the specified thresholds, the parties
involved are required to notify the competition authority before proceeding with
the transaction.
3. Review Process:
4. Competition Assessment:
The competition authority examines various factors to assess the impact of the
combination on competition, including market concentration, market shares of the
parties, potential for entry by new competitors, and impact on consumer choice and
prices.
5. Approval or Disapproval:
EBL Page 14
P a g e | 15
Many jurisdictions have specific timelines within which the competition authority
must complete its review. During this review period, the parties may be prohibited
from implementing the combination.
Parties aggrieved by the decision of the competition authority may have the right to
appeal to a higher authority or a court, depending on the jurisdiction's legal
framework.
1. Promoting Competition: The primary role of the CCI is to promote and sustain
fair competition in the market. It works to prevent practices that could limit
competition, distort markets, or harm consumer interests.
2. Enforcement of Competition Laws: The CCI enforces the provisions of the
Competition Act, 2002. It investigates anti-competitive behavior, reviews
combinations, and takes action against practices that may adversely affect
competition.
3. Investigations: The CCI can initiate investigations into anti-competitive
agreements, abuse of dominant position, and combinations that meet specified
thresholds. It has the power to gather information, summon witnesses, and
undertake detailed inquiries.
EBL Page 15
P a g e | 16
Structure:
1. Chairperson and Members: The CCI consists of a Chairperson and six Members.
These members are experienced in areas like economics, law, business, and public
administration.
2. Bench System: The CCI operates with multiple benches, each responsible for
handling specific cases and issues. This allows for efficient handling of cases and
inquiries.
3. Support Staff: The CCI is supported by a team of professionals, including
economists, lawyers, and experts in various fields, who assist in investigations and
case analysis.
Importance:
The Competition Commission of India plays a crucial role in ensuring that markets
operate in a competitive and fair manner. By preventing anti-competitive practices
and promoting competition, the CCI contributes to a level playing field for
businesses, encourages innovation, safeguards consumer interests, and supports the
growth of a healthy and vibrant economy.
EBL Page 16
P a g e | 17
Compliance with competition law is essential for businesses to operate in a fair and
competitive manner while adhering to legal requirements. Violating competition
law can lead to severe penalties, reputation damage, and legal consequences. Here
are some key aspects of ensuring compliance with competition law:
Familiarize yourself with the competition laws and regulations that apply in your
jurisdiction. These laws may include provisions related to anti-competitive
agreements, abuse of dominant position, and regulation of combinations.
2. Educate Employees:
Regularly assess your business practices to identify any practices that might raise
concerns under competition law. This could include reviewing contracts, pricing
strategies, distribution agreements, and more.
Do not engage in agreements with competitors that restrict competition, fix prices,
allocate markets, or rig bids. These practices are generally prohibited under
competition law.
If your business has significant market power, ensure that you do not abuse that
power by engaging in practices that stifle competition, harm consumers, or exclude
competitors.
6. Notify Combinations:
EBL Page 17
P a g e | 18
Some jurisdictions offer leniency programs that provide reduced penalties for
companies that self-report anti-competitive behavior. If applicable, consider using
these programs to rectify any violations.
If you are acquiring another business, conduct thorough due diligence to ensure
that the acquired business's practices do not violate competition laws.
EBL Page 18
P a g e | 19
Objectives:
1. Protection of Consumer Rights: The primary objective was to protect the rights
of consumers and provide them with effective mechanisms to seek redressal for
unfair trade practices and substandard goods and services.
2. Prevention of Unfair Trade Practices: The Act aimed to prevent deceptive
advertising, false labeling, and other unfair practices that could mislead consumers.
Consumer Rights:
1. Right to Safety: Consumers have the right to be protected against products and
services that are hazardous to their health and safety.
2. Right to Information: Consumers have the right to receive accurate and
transparent information about products and services, including their quality, price,
ingredients, and potential risks.
3. Right to Choose: Consumers have the right to choose from a variety of products
and services at competitive prices.
4. Right to be Heard: Consumers have the right to express their opinions and
concerns about products and services, and their interests should be taken into
consideration.
5. Right to Redressal: Consumers have the right to seek compensation or redressal
for faulty products or deficient services.
6. Right to Consumer Education: Consumers have the right to be educated about
their rights and responsibilities to make informed decisions.
EBL Page 19
P a g e | 20
1. Unfair Trade Practices: The Act prohibits practices such as false representation,
misleading advertisements, and offering goods or services that are hazardous to life
and safety.
2. Misleading Advertisements: Advertisements must not contain false or misleading
information, and they should not exaggerate product qualities or services.
Product Liability:
1. Product Liability: Manufacturers, sellers, and service providers are liable for any
harm caused due to defects in their products or services.
2. Compensation: Consumers can seek compensation for injuries or damages caused
by defective products or deficient services.
The Right to Information Act, 2005, is an important legislation in India that grants
citizens the right to access information held by public authorities and government
bodies. The Act aims to promote transparency, accountability, and participation in
governance by empowering individuals to obtain information about government
decisions, actions, and policies. Here are the key features of the Right to
Information Act, 2005:
EBL Page 20
P a g e | 21
Objectives:
Salient Features:
Impact: The Right to Information Act, 2005, has had a significant impact on
promoting transparency in governance and empowering citizens to hold public
authorities accountable. It has helped in exposing corruption, improving
government services, and enabling informed decision-making by citizens.
EBL Page 21
P a g e | 22
The Act plays a pivotal role in ensuring that government activities are conducted in
a more open and accountable manner, fostering a culture of citizen engagement
and good governance.
OBLIGATION OF PUBLIC AUTHORITIES
Under the Right to Information (RTI) Act, 2005, public authorities in India have
specific obligations to ensure transparency and provide access to information to
citizens. These obligations are aimed at promoting openness, accountability, and
citizen empowerment. Here are the key obligations of public authorities under the
RTI Act:
Public authorities are required to designate Public Information Officers (PIOs) who
act as the main point of contact for receiving RTI applications and facilitating the
disclosure of requested information.
2. Providing Information:
Public authorities are obligated to respond to RTI requests from citizens within the
specified time frame, which is generally 30 days from the date of receiving the
request.
4. Providing Information:
Public authorities must provide the requested information to the applicant in the
format they prefer, whether in print, electronic form, or other accessible formats.
EBL Page 22
P a g e | 23
Public authorities can charge a fee for providing the requested information, but this
fee should be reasonable and not a barrier to accessing information. The fee
structure is defined by the government.
7. Assistance to Applicants:
9. Record Maintenance:
Public authorities must ensure that information is disclosed in a timely manner, and
any delay in providing information beyond the stipulated time frame should be
explained to the applicant.
Public authorities should conduct training and awareness programs for their staff
members, including PIOs, to ensure they are well-informed about their obligations
under the RTI Act.
Public authorities play a pivotal role in ensuring that the principles of transparency,
accountability, and citizen engagement are upheld through the effective
implementation of the RTI Act. By adhering to their obligations, public authorities
contribute to promoting good governance and empowering citizens with the right
to access information held by government bodies.
REQUEST IN RTI
EBL Page 23
P a g e | 24
In the context of the Right to Information (RTI) Act, a "request" refers to the
formal application submitted by an individual (referred to as the "applicant") to a
public authority seeking specific information that is held by the public authority.
Making a request under the RTI Act allows individuals to access government-
related information and promotes transparency and accountability in governance.
Here's how the process of making a request in RTI typically works:
Before submitting an RTI request, clearly identify the information you are seeking.
Be specific about the documents, records, or details you want to access.
Determine the public authority that is likely to hold the information you are
seeking. Different departments or bodies might be responsible for different types
of information.
Submit your RTI application to the PIO of the public authority. You can usually do
this through various methods, such as in person, by post, or online (if the public
authority offers an online application portal).
Some RTI applications require the payment of a nominal application fee. The fee
structure varies based on the state and central government rules. Payment can often
be made through various methods, including online modes.
EBL Page 24
P a g e | 25
Once you have submitted the application, you may receive an acknowledgment
from the public authority. Keep track of the reference number or acknowledgment
for future reference. If you don't receive a response within the stipulated time, you
can follow up with the public authority.
If your request is approved, the public authority will provide you with the
requested information within the prescribed time frame. The information can be
provided in the format you requested.
8. Appeal Mechanism:
If you are dissatisfied with the response or if your request is denied, you have the
right to file an appeal with the designated Appellate Authority within the public
authority or with the relevant Information Commission.
Under the Right to Information (RTI) Act, 2005, while the primary objective is to
promote transparency and accountability, certain categories of information are
exempt from disclosure to ensure the protection of various interests, including
national security, personal privacy, and commercial confidentiality. These
exemptions are intended to strike a balance between transparency and safeguarding
legitimate concerns. Here are the key categories of exemptions from disclosure of
information under the RTI Act:
1. National Security:
EBL Page 25
P a g e | 26
3. Public Order:
6. Personal Privacy:
9. Intellectual Property:
EBL Page 26
P a g e | 27
It's important to note that while these exemptions exist, there is a presumption in
favor of disclosure, and public authorities have the responsibility to justify any
denial of information under these exemptions. The Act also encourages a process
of severability, meaning that if some parts of the information can be disclosed
without harm, they should be provided while keeping exempt portions confidential.
Under the Right to Information (RTI) Act, 2005, there are grounds for disclosure
of information, as well as grounds for rejection of access to certain information.
The Act aims to strike a balance between promoting transparency and protecting
various legitimate interests. Here are the key grounds for disclosure of information
and grounds for rejection to access in certain cases:
1. Public Interest:
Information that is in the public interest, such as decisions, policies, and
actions of public authorities, should generally be disclosed to promote
transparency and accountability.
2. Promotion of Accountability:
Information that aids in holding public authorities accountable for their
actions, decisions, and use of public funds should be disclosed.
3. Transparency in Government Functioning:
Information that reveals the functioning of government bodies, decision-
making processes, and administration should be disclosed to maintain
transparency.
4. Protection of Fundamental Rights:
EBL Page 27
P a g e | 28
1. National Security:
Information that could compromise national security, defense, or
sovereignty might be rejected due to potential harm.
2. Personal Privacy:
Information that invades an individual's personal privacy, such as medical
records and personal correspondence, might be rejected to protect personal
rights.
3. Commercial Confidence and Trade Secrets:
Information that involves confidential business information or trade secrets
might be rejected to protect commercial interests.
4. Law Enforcement and Investigation:
Information related to ongoing investigations, legal proceedings, or
enforcement of law might be rejected to avoid interference.
5. Internal Deliberations:
Information that pertains to the internal deliberations and decision-making
processes of public authorities might be rejected to safeguard the decision-
making process.
6. Cabinet Papers and Records:
Information related to Cabinet discussions, decisions, and documents might
be rejected to maintain the confidentiality of government deliberations.
7. Third-Party Information:
Information provided by third parties in confidence might be rejected if its
disclosure could harm the interests of the third party.
8. Intellectual Property:
Information involving intellectual property rights, such as patents,
copyrights, and trademarks, might be rejected to protect those rights.
EBL Page 28
P a g e | 29
1. Appeals and Complaints: The CIC receives and adjudicates appeals and
complaints filed by individuals who are dissatisfied with the response received
from public authorities or who believe that their right to access information has
been violated.
2. Hearing Appeals: The CIC hears and decides on appeals against decisions made
by Public Information Officers (PIOs) and Appellate Authorities of various public
authorities regarding the disclosure of information.
3. Adjudication: The CIC has the authority to adjudicate disputes related to access to
information, including those arising from exemptions or rejections made by public
authorities.
4. Enforcement: The CIC ensures the implementation of its orders and decisions by
directing public authorities to disclose the requested information if found to be in
the public interest.
5. Promotion of RTI Principles: The CIC works to promote transparency,
accountability, and citizen engagement by raising awareness about the RTI Act and
its provisions.
6. Guidelines and Recommendations: The CIC issues guidelines,
recommendations, and advisory opinions to public authorities and government
departments to ensure compliance with the RTI Act.
7. Research and Reports: The CIC conducts research, compiles reports, and
generates data related to the implementation of the RTI Act, which helps in
evaluating its impact and identifying areas of improvement.
8. Public Hearings: The CIC may conduct public hearings or interactions to discuss
issues related to access to information and to receive feedback from stakeholders.
EBL Page 29
P a g e | 30
Importance:
In the Central Information Commission (CIC) of India, the terms of office for the
Chief Information Commissioner (CIC) and Information Commissioners (ICs) are
outlined in the Right to Information (Term of Office, Salaries, Allowances, and
Other Terms and Conditions of Service of Chief Information Commissioner,
Information Commissioners in the Central Information Commission) Rules, 2019.
These rules provide the framework for the appointment and terms of office for the
CIC and ICs. Here are the details:
EBL Page 30
P a g e | 31
In the context of the Central Information Commission (CIC) and the Right to
Information (RTI) Act, 2005, there are provisions related to filing appeals,
penalties for non-compliance, and other conditions. These provisions are designed
to ensure the effective functioning of the RTI Act and promote transparency and
accountability. Here are the key points regarding appeals, penalties, and other
conditions:
EBL Page 31
P a g e | 32
1. Appeal Process:
If an individual is not satisfied with the response or lack of response from a Public
Information Officer (PIO) or public authority regarding their RTI request, they
have the right to file an appeal with the relevant Appellate Authority within the
public authority.
2. First Appeal:
The first appeal is submitted to the officer senior to the PIO within the same public
authority. This officer is designated as the First Appellate Authority. The appeal
must be submitted within 30 days from the date of receipt of the PIO's response or
within 30 days from the date the response was expected.
If the individual is not satisfied with the decision of the First Appellate Authority
or if they do not receive a response within the stipulated time, they can file a
second appeal with the Central Information Commission (CIC) within 90 days
from the date of the First Appellate Authority's decision or the date the response
was due.
If a PIO or public authority fails to provide information within the specified time
or provides false, incomplete, or misleading information, penalties can be imposed
by the CIC. The CIC has the authority to impose a penalty of up to Rs. 25,000 on
the PIO for each violation.
Individuals can also file complaints directly with the CIC against non-compliance
with the provisions of the RTI Act. The CIC has the power to impose penalties on
public authorities for failure to implement the provisions of the Act.
The CIC has the authority to hear appeals, complaints, and disputes related to the
RTI Act. It can issue orders for the release of information, provide directions for
compliance, and impose penalties if necessary.
EBL Page 32
P a g e | 33
7. Representation of Parties:
Parties involved in an appeal or complaint before the CIC can represent themselves
or appoint legal representatives. They can also make oral or written submissions.
8. Enforcement of Orders:
The orders of the CIC are legally binding. Public authorities are required to comply
with the orders within the specified time frame.
EXIM POLICY
On march 31st 2002 government announced a new exim policy, sharply export
oriented rather than import liberalizing. The policy withdrew most of the earlier
export restriction and provide several incentives for newly created Special Export
Zones (SEZ).
OBJECTIVES
Gvernment control import of non essential items through the exim policy. At the
same time all out efforts are made to promote exports. The import policy which is
concerned with regulations and management, and the export policy concerned with
the exports not only promotion but also regulations.
1- To accelerate the economy from low level of economic activities to high
level of economic activity.
2- To stimulate sustained economic growth by providing access to essential
raw materials, intermediares, consumables, components etc..
3- To generate new employment, opportunities and encourage the attainment of
internationally accepted standards of quality.
4- To enhance the technological strength and efficiency of Indian sectors.
5- To provide quality consumer products at reasonable price.
GOVERNING BODY OF EXIM POLICY
The government of india notifies the exim policy for a period of 5 years
(1997-2002). Under sec-5 of the foreign trade development and regulation act
1992. The current export import policy covers the period 2002-2007 and is updated
every year on the 31st march. All type of changes or modifications related to exim
policy is normally announced by the union minister of commerce and industry.
FEATURES
1- Liberalization
EBL Page 33
P a g e | 34
EBL Page 34