Business Environment Economic System
Business Environment Economic System
Merits of Capitalism:
i. Promote Economic Growth:
Many economist have argued that capitalism have great ability to
promote economic growth. It leads to a faster GDP growth and
better capacity utilization.
ii. High Living Standards and Hard Work:
Demerits of Capitalism:
i. Income Inequality:
It is not true that anyone can be rich if they work hard enough. In
fact, one will grow under capitalism at the cost of others only. It
means that along with every rich, a large army of poor will coexist.
In simple terms, there will be a growing income inequality in a
capitalistic setup.
In fact, it is this demerit of capitalism that has been amply
highlighted by the socialist thinkers including Karl Marx. It has
provided a basis for the evolution of socialist form of economic
system, as an alternative to capitalism.
ii. Economic Instability:
v. Exploitation:
It is not correct to say that a capitalist economy pays everyone as
per their contribution to the production process. The marginal
productivity theory of distribution, tells that every worker is paid a
sum equals to marginal productivity of last unit of labour and not
that of his own. The difference between the own marginal
productivity and that of the last unit is basically the profit of the
producer or exploitation of the worker.
Criticism:
It is not surprising therefore that the capitalism has been severely
criticized by a large number of social scientists including
economists and sociologist, for all the demerits inbuilt in it. So
much so that the capitalism have been completely discarded by the
socialist thinkers. They have propagated altogether a new form of
economic system which is based on equality and social justice. It is
known as socialism.
2. Socialism:
Emergence of socialism has been traced above in the criticisms of
capitalism, specifically the rising income inequality under it which
divides the society into have and have-nots. Further, the root cause
of income inequality in capitalism is the private ownership on
factors of production.
The socialist thinkers have, thus, proposed a socialist mode of
product as an alternative to capitalism or as a solution to all the
demerits of capitalism. To be precise, socialism proposes state
ownership on means of production and maximum social benefits as
profit motive in the production system. The system is looked upon
as need-based rather than profit-based.
Merits of Socialism:
There are many advantages in socialism.
They can be summarized as follow:
i. Efficient Resource Utilization:
In a socialist economy, production decisions are taken by a central
body on the basis of requirements of the economy. Depending upon
the availability of resources, it decides to produce the items most
needed and in just quantity ruling out any duplication of
production. Hence, there is neither any wastage of resources nor
unemployment. On this basis, one can argue that a socialist set up
ensures efficient resource utilization.
ii. Inequality of Income within Desirable Limits or
Distributive Justice:
Since factors of productions are owned by the government and the
factor payments are need based, there is no possibility of income
inequality beyond desirable limits. Moreover, it also offered social
security to everyone, at least with regard to basic needs. In nutshell,
it upholds the principles of distributive justice.
iii. No Class Struggle:
As the society does not divide into have and have-nots, there is no
possibility for social tension and, hence, no scope for class struggle.
iv. No Economic Instability:
Since market mechanism has no role to play, presence of business
cycles are not witnessed and hence no economic instability under
socialism. Each and every sector develops in a planned manner.
There is no excess demand or excess supply scenario. It implies that
resources are better allocated under socialist mode of production.
v. No Unemployment:
In socialist mode of economic system, production is planned as per
the availability of resources and, hence, there is no scope for unem-
ployment.
De-Merits of Socialism:
i. Efficiency and Factor Productivities are Low:
Being a need based system it ignores efficiency and factor produc-
tivity. No serious attention is given, especially at individual level, to
increase productivity since factor payments are no way linked to
their respective contributions in the production.
Moreover, high social security also discourages a person to work
hard as he knows that even if he does work, or does not work hard,
his future is secured at least for basic needs. Further, even if he
works harder, he will not gain much in terms of better life style. His
needs are pre-determined by the system. As such labour
productivity in socialism is always low.
At the other end, the production system is managed by state
officials who have no personal interest in it and hence, has no
incentives to perform.
For all these reasons, the socialism witness low labour productivity
which may even decline overtime. The efficiency level is also found
to be low in such a system.
ii. De-Motivating Hard Work:
An important weakness of socialism was that it adversely affected
the motivation to work hard as no personal gains and losses are
involved. This ultimately resulted in slower economic growth and
smaller income generation.
iii. Complex Administration:
Since every venture and each aspect is managed by bureaucrats, the
administrative process becomes very complex and the network
becomes multi-layered. The state officials used to consider produc-
tion system just as an extension of government departments. Thus,
often it used to take a long time to take a decision which has to be
approved at various levels. This not only increases the cost but often
cause considerable delay in decision-making.
iv. No Consumer Sovereignty:
A serious drawback of the socialist system is that it has no respect
for the consumer sovereignty. His preferences for the goods and
services to be consumed have just no place in the decision making.
He has to consume whatever decided for him by the State
authorities. This considerably lowers his motivation to work.
v. No Economic Freedom:
In this form of economic system, there is neither a freedom of
choice nor a freedom of enterprise, as observed in case of
capitalism. Hence, workers have no job satisfaction. They are asked
to perform a task and one has to do it whether he likes or dis-likes.
vi. Concentration of Power:
It has also been argued that the socialist system is also not free from
concentration of power. Under it, power gradually concentrates in
the hands of bureaucracy and the State machinery.
Criticism of Socialism:
Despite many merits and positive features of socialism, it has been
criticized for several reasons, which are amply elaborated under its
demerits. With the demise of socialism, it appears that its demerits
were more powerful and its merits did not exist in reality.