Vestibular Testing.5
Vestibular Testing.5
Vestibular Testing
C O N T I N UU M A UD I O By Timothy C. Hain, MD; Marcello Cherchi, MD, PhD, FAAN
I NT E R V I E W A V AI L A B L E
ONLINE
VIDEO CONTENT
ABSTRACT
A VA I L A B L E O N L I N E PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Vestibular testing, both at the bedside and in the
laboratory, is often critical in diagnosing patients with symptoms of
vertigo, dizziness, unsteadiness, and oscillopsia. This article introduces
readers to core concepts, as well as recent advances, in bedside and
instrumented vestibular assessments.
INTRODUCTION
V
estibular testing is defined as the quantification of the function of
CITE AS:
CONTINUUM (MINNEAP MINN) the motion-sensing portions of the inner ear (semicircular canals
2021;27(2, NEURO-OTOLOGY): and otoliths). Vestibular testing is generally performed in the
330–347.
context of an evaluation of the symptom of dizziness, and such
Address correspondence to
evaluations often benefit from information about hearing.
Dr Marcello Cherchi, 645 N Accordingly, although this article mainly focuses on vestibular assessments, it also
Michigan Ave, Chicago, IL 60611, includes content about how hearing testing contributes to forming a diagnosis.
[email protected].
edu.
Vestibular testing has improved immensely over the past 30 years. Five
motion sensors are located in each inner ear: three semicircular canals and two
RELATIONSHIP DISCLOSURE: otolith organs (the utricle and saccule). Ideally, one should be able to quantify the
Dr Hain has served as an
associate editor for Audiology function of all five.
and Neurotology. Dr Cherchi In 1914, Robert Bárány was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physiology or
reports no disclosures.
Medicine for the development of a test of the lateral semicircular canal.1 Since
UNLABELED USE OF then, and especially in the past decade, new tests have come into clinical use that
PRODUCTS/INVESTIGATIONAL can quantify the remaining two canals (anterior/superior and posterior), as well
USE DISCLOSURE:
Drs Hain and Cherchi report
as both otolith organs.
no disclosures. The main goal of vestibular testing is to determine whether vestibular function
is normal or abnormal, testing in each sensor of the peripheral vestibular
© 2021 American Academy apparatus, which may identify when central vestibular and ocular motor
of Neurology. pathways exhibit dysfunction. For example, if examination identifies subtle
Balance Assessment
The goal of the assessment of balance is to quantify imbalance, look for
inconsistency, and to separate vestibular patterns of imbalance from other
neurologic problems, such as cerebellar ataxia, sensory loss in the feet,
movement disorders, and simulated unsteadiness.
GAIT OBSERVATION. The assessment of the balance of a patient with dizziness starts
when the patient is met in the waiting room and walked to the examination
room. Informal observations should be made concerning how the patients arise
from their chair, as well as how they lower themselves into the examination room
chair, their speed of locomotion, whether they swing their arms, and whether
they have a wide-based gait or use the wall or a caregiver’s arm to steady
themselves. To screen for a functional disorder, it is helpful to compare informal
observation and formal balance testing such as the Romberg test, which is
described in the following section. Most patients with acute vestibular problems
are unsteady, and most patients with chronic vestibular problems are not
unsteady. Inconsistencies should be noted.
EYES-CLOSED TANDEM ROMBERG TEST. The tandem Romberg test, also referred to as
sharpened Romberg, is quick and useful, albeit also nonspecific and somewhat
insensitive.4 It is a test for sensory ataxia. Borderline normal performance
consists of the ability to stand heel-to-toe, with eyes closed, for 6 to 30 seconds.
The test can be made easier and thus quantified to some extent by allowing the
eyes to be open or by allowing the feet to be in parallel but next to one another
(standard Romberg test) rather than in tandem. Variants of the test involve
standing on a foam pad, rather than in tandem, or on a narrow rail.5,6
High-normal performance, defined as the time before a step is required to
prevent a fall, is generally found in young adults, who can often perform the
eyes-closed tandem variant of the Romberg test for 30 seconds. Performance
declines greatly with age, especially in patients in their seventies and older.6
Many middle-aged patients with chronic inner ear disorders will have no
difficulty standing in tandem with their eyes open, but they may need to take a
step before 6 seconds passes with eyes closed.
It is helpful to develop a judgment of how much impairment of the Romberg
test is appropriate for a given degree of ear injury. Patients with bilateral
CONTINUUMJOURNAL.COM 331
vestibular loss have moderate ataxia; they rely heavily on their vision and are
unsteady when their eyes are closed when standing with a narrow base, whether
together in parallel or tandem. Most patients with substantial bilateral vestibular
loss cannot stand in the eyes-closed tandem Romberg test for 6 seconds. Patients
with bilateral vestibular deficits with an additional superimposed position sense
deficit, such as peripheral neuropathy, lose balance when standing with a
narrowed base even with eyes open. Patients with chronic unilateral vestibular
loss are only mildly ataxic, and they usually perform normally on the eyes-closed
tandem Romberg test. Patients with acute unilateral vestibular hypofunction
with nystagmus may be much more off balance but can adapt in weeks to a few
months to show fairly normal balance.
THE FUKUDA STEPPING TEST. The Fukuda stepping test (FIGURE 2-1) and assessment
for past-pointing are measurements of vestibulospinal function. They are rarely
used in contemporary clinical practice. In the Fukuda stepping test, the patient is
asked to march in place with eyes closed for approximately 30 seconds; and the
clinician then notes rotation and translation on a calibrated mat.7 The Fukuda
stepping test fell from popularity after it was shown that it has very wide
variability in subjects without balance problems. Honaker and Shepard8
concluded, “Overall, the [Fukuda stepping test] provides little benefit to
clinicians when used in the vestibular bedside examination.”
The past-pointing test is also called the Quix test.9 During the test, the patient
and examiner assume mirror-image postures with outstretched hands so that the
fingers almost touch, and the examiner assesses whether the patient’s fingers drift
after their eyes are closed. The Quix test has not undergone rigorous scrutiny in the
literature, and it is rarely used. Practically, much stronger tools are available to
detect vestibular imbalance based on nystagmus, ie, Frenzel goggle testing.
stethoscope. For more information about tinnitus, refer to the article, “Tinnitus,
Hyperacusis, Otalgia, and Hearing Loss” by Terry D. Fife, MD, FAAN, FANS,
and Roksolyana Tourkevich, MD,10 in this issue of Continuum.
Nystagmus Testing
Evaluation of nystagmus is very useful in a patient with dizziness. Optimally, this
requires the use of Frenzel goggles (FIGURE 2-2), which are worn by the patient to
reduce fixation, as well as to magnify the examiner’s view of the patient’s eyes.
Frenzel goggles are useful because most inner ear causes of dizziness produce
nystagmus that can be suppressed by fixation. To see nystagmus roughly 1 week
after onset of an acute vestibular syndrome such as vestibular neuritis, the
patient’s eyes must not be allowed to fixate when being viewed.
Of the two available variants of Frenzel goggles (optical and infrared video),
the infrared video goggles are far superior, but the optical goggles are more
affordable. Without a method of viewing the eyes without fixation, some types
of nystagmus may not be
observable. The ophthalmoscope
can be used for making
inferences about spontaneous
nystagmus if Frenzel goggles are
not available; this is discussed in
more detail in the following
sections.
CONTINUUMJOURNAL.COM 333
A 50-year-old man was born with congenital esotropia; as a child, he CASE 2-1
frequently squinted and eventually was able to describe that he was
experiencing double vision, so at age 5 years he underwent surgery to
correct the esotropia.
Videonystagmography recordings (with the camera placed over the
right eye while the patient had initially viewed out of the left eye)
documented a spontaneous left-beating nystagmus; however, caloric
tests were normal. Because he had spontaneous nystagmus but no caloric
weakness, the audiologist concluded that the patient had a central
vestibular disorder.
In the office, the patient had no depth perception (stereopsis) as
determined by the Titmus Fly test in which the patient wore polarized
glasses while looking at a specially formatted picture of a housefly that
should appear to pop out from the page if depth perception is intact. The
patient also had amblyopia in the right eye and weak left-beating
horizontal nystagmus in the light. When the left eye was covered, the
nystagmus reversed direction and became right beating. The nystagmus
stopped in complete darkness (with the use of video Frenzel goggles).
Close inspection of the videonystagmography pursuit traces showed that
the eye actually tracked faster than the target to the left, and backup
saccades were present.
This case illustrates some of the examination findings in a patient with a COMMENT
type of congenital nystagmus called latent nystagmus, which often results
from congenital esotropia, and points out how some of the findings taken
in isolation can lead to an incorrect diagnosis.
CONTINUUMJOURNAL.COM 335
NECK-VIBRATION TEST.
The neck-vibration
FIGURE 2-4
Dix-Hallpike positional maneuver. To test (FIGURE 2-5) is very useful as a
precipitate the characteristic bedside test because it is a robust and
nystagmus of benign paroxysmal durable test for unilateral vestibular
positional vertigo, the patient is rapidly
brought from sitting (A) into a
weakness.14 In the neck-vibration test, the
head-hanging position (B and C) that patient’s eyes are observed in complete
makes the posterior canal vertical and darkness (ie, with video, not optical,
brings it through a large angular Frenzel goggles) while vibration
displacement.
(typically from a massaging device) is
applied to the sternocleidomastoid muscle
for 10 seconds. The vibration is applied first on one side and then on the other
(VIDEO 2-9). One looks for direction-fixed nystagmus (that is, it does not change
direction with changes in the direction of gaze) with fast-phase beating to the
side opposite the ear with vestibular hypofunction. The neck-vibration test
requires less expertise than the head impulse test (see the Head Impulse Test
section), requires almost no subjective judgment, and is not greatly affected by
CONTINUUMJOURNAL.COM 337
of the head rotation, which serves to stabilize the image of a viewed target on the
fovea during movement.
CASE 2-2 A 40-year-old man reported acute dizziness and unsteady gait and had
been vomiting for several hours. Although he was ambulatory, he was
unsteady and preferred to hold onto his wife’s shoulder as he was taken
from the waiting room to the examination room.
On examination, he could not stand with his eyes closed in a tandem
Romberg stance. He had a left-beating spontaneous nystagmus readily
seen in both eyes. The nystagmus increased on left gaze and stopped on
right gaze. His head impulse test was positive to the right and normal to
the left.
COMMENT This is the presentation of acute right-sided vestibular neuritis. This case
illustrates how a unilateral vestibular weakness presents with spontaneous
unidirectional horizontal nystagmus that obeys the Alexander law.
Ophthalmoscope Test
The ophthalmoscope test is used
to obtain objective corroboration
when a patient has a positive
dynamic illegible E test. The
examiner focuses on the optic
disk and then gently moves the
patient’s head as described for
the illegible E test. The vestibulo-
ocular reflex gain is abnormal if
the disk moves with the head, ie,
moves back and forth from the
examiner’s perspective.16 The
ophthalmoscope test is less
sensitive than the dynamic
FIGURE 2-6 illegible E test and should be
Dynamic illegible E test. This test of dynamic performed with the patient’s
visual acuity is performed with the examiner
spectacles on to avoid interaction
oscillating the patient’s head side to side about
the vertical axis at approximately 1 to 2 Hz; the with the effects of spectacles on
lowest line that can be read is ascertained. A vestibulo-ocular reflex gain.
decline in visual acuity before and during
movement of at least three lines is abnormal,
Hearing Testing
indicating bilateral vestibulopathy.
© 2007 Timothy C. Hain. TABLE 2-1 lists the indications for
common laboratory procedures
used for evaluating hearing in
patients with vertigo and dizziness. Not all of these tests are useful for every patient.
To be time- and cost-efficient, tests should be chosen according to each patient’s
specific set of symptoms (TABLE 2-2). For more information on hearing loss, refer to
Test Indications
Audiogram Hearing symptoms, dizziness, vertigo, Ménière disease suspected, superior canal
dehiscence suspected
CONTINUUMJOURNAL.COM 339
the article, “Tinnitus, Hyperacusis, Otalgia, and Hearing Loss” by Terry D. Fife,
MD, FAAN, FANS, and Roksolyana Tourkevich, MD,10 in this issue of Continuum.
When hearing symptoms are present or when a disorder such as Ménière
disease or vestibular schwannoma is reasonably suspected, then an audiogram is
the most useful initial test. An audiogram is recommended even for patients
who have few symptoms of hearing loss because some patterns of hearing loss
cannot be determined at the bedside (eg, low-frequency hearing loss) and may
not be readily noticed by the patient. TABLE 2-2 outlines four common hearing
patterns that may be documented on audiometry. FIGURE 2-7 shows the typical
low-tone hearing loss seen in early Ménière disease.
It is incumbent for the clinician seeing patients with dizziness to recognize
each of the abnormal patterns above because they should trigger important
actions on the part of the clinician.
ELECTROCOCHLEOGRAPHY.
FIGURE 2-7
An audiogram showing right-sided low-frequency Electrocochleography is an
sensorineural hearing loss. Low-frequency evoked potential test in which the
sensorineural hearing loss on the right side is recording electrode is positioned
depicted, which is fairly specific for right-sided
on the eardrum to get a better
Ménière disease. Here, X depicts hearing
definition of the cochlear potential
thresholds for the left ear, and O and the triangle
indicate thresholds for the right ear. from the inner ear. An abnormal
electrocochleogram may suggest
Ménière disease in patients with a
clinical history that is consistent with Ménière disease. Electrocochleography is
technically difficult and relatively unrewarding in diagnostic power and should
not be considered a useful screening test in all patients with vertigo. For these
reasons, electrocochleography has fallen out of favor and is not widely available.
CONTINUUMJOURNAL.COM 341
Test Indication(s)
Videonystagmography (VENG) Vertigo
Rotary chair test (Rchair) Bilateral vestibular loss suspected, secondary test to confirm abnormal
caloric responses or video head impulse test suggesting unilateral or
bilateral vestibular loss
CONTINUUMJOURNAL.COM 343
ROTARY CHAIR. Rotary chair testing measures vestibular function of both inner ears
together. It is sensitive to bilateral loss of vestibular function and performs better
than VENG for this purpose.17 In unilateral vestibular loss, rotary chair testing is
sensitive but nonspecific because it is poor at identifying the side of the lesion.
TABLE 2-4 Common Vestibular and Auditory Tests and Their Corresponding CPT Codesa
Caloric vestibular test with recording, bilateral; bithermal (ie, one warm and 92537
one cool irrigation in each ear for a total of four irrigations)
Electrocochleography 92584
Video head impulse test None; bill as 92700 and have patient
sign an advanced beneficiary notice
a
Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) codes maintained by the American Medical Association and approved by the Centers for Medicare and
Medicaid Services in the United States as of January 1, 2021.
CPT © 2021 American Medical Association. All rights reserved. CPT is a registered trademark of the American Medical Association.
VIDEO HEAD IMPULSE TEST. This recently available vestibular test can quickly diagnose
both severe bilateral vestibular loss and complete unilateral vestibular loss, especially
when due to vestibular nerve injury. The video head impulse test is less sensitive
to vestibular damage due to hair cell disease, such as Ménière disease, whereas
VENG testing is more accurate. The video head impulse test is more resistant to
false-positive findings in patients with functional symptoms than tests of
nystagmus such as VENG and the rotary chair.
Variants of the video head impulse test purport to measure function of the
posterior and anterior semicircular canals, but they should not be relied on for
this because current commercially available eye-movement monitoring technology
is not able to quantify the entire three-dimensional vector of eye movement. As
a consequence, the results of video head impulse tests done for the anterior or
posterior canal planes are often puzzling. Despite the high utility of video head
impulse testing, many insurances do not currently cover it.
CONTINUUMJOURNAL.COM 345
CONCLUSION
For a clinician to diagnose a patient with dizziness, a careful history and an
examination that includes specific bedside vestibular tests are crucial. In some
instances, this may need to be supplemented with audiometric tests and with
instrumented vestibular testing, the latter of which has seen significant advances
in the past decade as it is now possible to evaluate the entire labyrinth (all
semicircular canals and otolith organs).
VIDEO LEGENDS
VIDEO 2-1 VIDEO 2-6
Weak jerk nystagmus in a patient with resolving Left-posterior canal benign paroxysmal positional
vestibular neuritis. The eyes are first in primary vertigo (BPPV). The patient is in the left Dix-Hallpike
position of gaze, and modest spontaneous position, and upbeat and left-torsional nystagmus is
left-beat nystagmus is present. When the patient present. This pattern is consistent with left-posterior
directs gaze rightward, no nystagmus is present. canal BPPV. The patient then sits up and is put in the
When the patient directs gaze leftward, left-beat right Dix-Hallpike position, and downbeat and right-
nystagmus is more pronounced than it had been on torsional nystagmus is present. This pattern is
primary position of gaze. This pattern is in accordance compatible with “unwinding” of left-posterior canal BPPV.
with the Alexander law for a right-sided vestibular
weakness. © 2021 American Academy of Neurology
1 Baloh RW. Robert Bárány and the controversy 14 Dumas G, Perrin P, Ouedraogo E, Schmerber S.
surrounding his discovery of the caloric reaction. How to perform the skull vibration-induced
Neurology 2002;58(7):1094-1099. doi:10.1212/ nystagmus test (SVINT). Eur Ann Otorhinolaryngol
wnl.58.7.1094 Head Neck Dis 2016;133(5):343-348. doi:10.1016/
j.anorl.2016.04.002
2 Hain T. Approach to the patient with dizziness
and vertigo. In: Biller J, editor. Practical 15 Halmagyi GM, Curthoys IS. A clinical sign of canal
neurology. 4th ed. Philadelphia, PA: Wolters paresis. Arch Neurol 1988;45(7):737-739.
Kluwer, Lippincott, Williams & Wilkins 2017. doi:10.1001/archneur.1988.00520310043015
3 Fife TD. Approach to the history and evaluation 16 Kheradmand A, Zee DS. The bedside examination
of vertigo and dizziness. Continuum (Minneap of the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR): an update.
Minn) 2021;27(2, Neuro-otology):306-329. Rev Neurol (Paris) 2012;168(10):710-719.
doi:10.1016/j.neurol.2012.07.011
4 Longridge NS, Mallinson AI. Clinical Romberg
testing does not detect vestibular disease. Otol 17 Fife TD, Tusa RJ, Furman JM, et al. Assessment:
Neurotol 2010;31(5):803-806. doi:10.1097/ vestibular testing techniques in adults and
MAO.0b013e3181e3deb2 children: report of the Therapeutics and
Technology Assessment Subcommittee of the
5 Graybiel A, Fregly AR. A new quantitative ataxia
American Academy of Neurology. Neurology
test battery. Acta Otolaryngol 1966;61(4):292-312.
2000;55(10):1431-1441. doi:10.1212/wnl.55.10.1431
6 Agrawal Y, Carey JP, Hoffman HJ, et al. The
18 Fife TD, Colebatch JG, Kerber KA, et al. Practice
modified Romberg balance test: normative data
guideline: cervical and ocular vestibular evoked
in US adults. Otol Neurotol 2011;32(8):1309-1311.
myogenic potential testing: report of the
doi:10.1097/MAO.0b013e31822e5bee
Guideline Development, Dissemination, and
7 Fukuda T. The stepping test: two phases of the Implementation Subcommittee of the American
labyrinthine reflex. Acta Otolaryngol 1959;50(2): Academy of Neurology. Neurology 2017;89(22):
95-108. doi:10.3109/00016485909129172 2288-2296. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000004690
8 Honaker JA, Shepard NT. Performance of Fukuda 19 Klopp-Dutote N, Kolski C, Biet A, et al. A
stepping test as a function of the severity of caloric radiologic and anatomic study of the superior
weakness in chronic dizzy patients. J Am Acad semicircular canal. Eur Ann Otorhinolaryngol
Audiol 2012;23(8):616-622. doi:10.3766/jaaa.23.8.6 Head Neck Dis 2016;133(2):91-94. doi:10.1016/
j.anorl.2015.11.001
9 Hart CW. The Quix test. Laryngoscope 1983;93(9):
1160-1161. doi:10.1288/00005537-198309000-00010 20 Ishiyama G. Selected otologic disorders causing
dizziness. Continuum (Minneap Minn) 2021;
10 Fife TD, Tourkevich R. Tinnitus, hyperacusis,
27(2, Neuro-otology):468-490.
otalgia, and hearing loss. Continuum (Minneap
Minn) 2021;27(2, Neuro-otology):491-525. 21 Oh SY, Kim JS, Yang TH, et al. Cervical and ocular
vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials in
11 Robinson DA, Zee DS, Hain TC, et al. Alexander's
vestibular neuritis: comparison between air- and
law: its behavior and origin in the human
bone-conducted stimulation. J Neurol 2013;
vestibulo-ocular reflex. Ann Neurol 1984;16(6):
260(8):2102-2109. doi:10.1007/s00415-013-6953-8
714-722. doi:10.1002/ana.410160614
22 Cevette MJ, Puetz B, Marion MS, et al.
12 Kerber KA. Episodic positional dizziness.
Aphysiologic performance on dynamic
Continuum (Minneap Minn) 2021;27(2,
posturography. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg
Neuro-otology):348-368.
1995;112(6):676-688. doi:10.1016/s0194-5998(95)
13 Cherchi M, Hain T. Provocative maneuvers for 70175-3
vestibular disorders. In Eggers S, Zee DS, eds.
Vertigo and imbalance: clinical neurophysiology
of the vestibular system. Amsterdam,
Netherlands: Elsevier, 2010.
CONTINUUMJOURNAL.COM 347